K. G. Seshadri vs The Trustees Of State Bank Of India

Court
Supreme Court
<div> 2026 INSC 333<br /> <b>REPORTABLE </b><br /> <br /> <b>IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA </b><br /> <b>CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION </b><br /> <br /> <b>CIVIL APPEAL NO. 4279 OF 2026 </b> <br /> <b>(ARISING OUT OF S.L.P. (CIVIL) NO.12462 OF 2022) </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>K.G. SESHADRI </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> … APPELLANT(S) </b><br /> <b>VERSUS </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>THE TRUSTEES OF STATE BANK OF INDIA </b><br /> <b>AND ANOTHER </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> ... RESPONDENT(S)</b><br /> <b> </b> <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b> </b> <b> </b><br /> <b>J U D G M E N T </b><br /> <br /> <b>PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA, J. </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>1.</b> <b> </b> Leave granted. <br /> <b>2.</b> <b> </b> This Appeal is directed against the impugned judgment and order dated <br /> 27.04.2022 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Madras in W.A No.1065 <br /> of 2022, whereby the Division Bench of the High Court dismissed the appeal filed <br /> by the appellant and upheld the order passed by the learned Single Judge of the <br /> High Court. <br /> <br /> <b>FACTUAL MATRIX </b><br /> Signature Not Verified<br /> Digitally signed by<br /> NISHA KHULBEY<br /> Date: 2026.04.08<br /> 17:03:43 IST<br /> Reason:<br /> <b>3.</b> <b> </b> The appellant was appointed as a Clerk in the respondent-Bank and the <br /> same was confirmed after the probation period of six months i.e., from <br /> Civil Appeal @ SLP (Civil) No.12462/2022 Page <b>1</b> of <b>11</b> <br /> <br /><br /> 17.02.1979 till 12.12.1998. The appellant ceased to be in the job and left for <br /> abroad in the year 1989. After returning in the year 2004, he gave a letter to re-<br /> join the service. However, the respondent-Bank turned down the said request <br /> and, <i>vide</i> letter dated 21.07.2008, the respondent-Bank declared that the <br /> appellant has been voluntarily retired. <br /> <b>4.</b> <b> </b> Aggrieved by the aforesaid letter dated 21.07.2008, the appellant filed a <br /> writ petition being W.P. No.19002 of 2008 before the High Court of Judicature <br /> at Madras. On 21.04.2009, the High Court orally directed the appellant to <br /> withdraw the case and approach the Labour Court. <br /> <b>5.</b> <b> </b> Pursuant to the direction of the High Court, the appellant approached the <br /> 1<br /> Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court , Chennai, by filing <br /> a claim petition being CP No.5 of 2010 under Section 33C(2) of the Industrial <br /> 2<br /> Disputes Act, 1947 and prayed the Labour Court to compute the appellant’s <br /> pension benefits @ Rs.8,11,770/- along with interest. The Labour Court <i>vide </i><br /> order dated 24.09.2010 dismissed the claim petition by observing that it had no <br /> jurisdiction and competence to decide the case, since the present case was not <br /> relating to any pre-existing right under pension rules, and, hence, it could not <br /> adjudicate the issue raised therein as per ID Act or under the SBI Pension Rules. <br /> <b>6.</b> <b> </b> The appellant once again approached the High Court by way of a writ <br /> petition being W.P No.25597 of 2010. The learned Single Judge <i>vide </i> order dated <br /> 05.11.2019 concluded that the appellant could not establish any pre-existing <br /> right with reference to the eligibility conditions prescribed under the pension <br /> <br /> 1<br /> For short, “Labour Court” <br /> 2<br /> For short, “the ID Act” <br /> Civil Appeal @ SLP (Civil) No.12462/2022 Page <b>2</b> of <b>11</b> <br /> <br /><br /> scheme and confirmed the findings of the Labour Court <i>inter alia</i> holding that <br /> since the eligibility and other terms and conditions for grant of pension are all <br /> disputed facts, the claim petition filed by the appellant could not have been <br /> entertained by the Labour Court. <br /> <b>7.</b> <b> </b> Aggrieved by the aforesaid order dated 05.11.2019 of the learned Single <br /> Judge, the appellant filed W.A. No.1065 of 2022 before the Division Bench of the <br /> High Court. The Division Bench <i>vide</i> its impugned judgment and order dated <br /> 27.04.2022 dismissed the writ appeal and upheld the order of the learned Single <br /> Judge taking into consideration the limited jurisdiction of the Labour Court <br /> under Section 33C(2) of the ID Act and that the claim of pensionary benefits was <br /> disputed by the respondent(s) by a reasoned order and the challenge to it by the <br /> writ petition was not pressed by the appellant and was rather withdrawn. <br /> <br /> <b>SUBMISSIONS</b> <br /> <b>8.</b> <b> </b> Learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant would submit that <br /> appellant has completed 20 years and 3 months and 25 days of service from date <br /> of appointment/date of confirmation and, hence, he was entitled to pension as <br /> per the Pension Fund Rules, more specifically under Rule 22(i)(c) of the State <br /> 3<br /> Bank of India Employees’ Pension Fund Rules, 1955 . <b> </b><br /> <b>9.</b> <b> </b><br /> Additionally, it was argued that the respondent-Bank denied the <br /> legitimate pension by deliberate misinterpretation of Pension Fund Rules by not <br /> applying Rule 22(i)(c) of the Pension Fund Rules, which states completion of 20 <br /> years’ service, irrespective of age, the respondent-Bank is said to have <br /> <br /> 3<br /> For short, “Pension Fund Rules” <br /> Civil Appeal @ SLP (Civil) No.12462/2022 Page <b>3</b> of <b>11</b> <br /> <br /><br /> approbated and reprobated in their counter affidavit that the appellant has been <br /> declared under Voluntary Cessation, but deny legitimate pension, by erroneously <br /> applying the incorrect Rule 22(i)(a), instead of 22(i)(c) of the Pension Fund Rules. <b> </b><br /> <b>10.</b> <b> </b> It was submitted that the respondent-Bank, even though a premier bank <br /> of Government of India, failed to notice that a normal Voluntary Retirement <br /> 4<br /> Scheme was introduced in the Bank on 20.09.1986, after obtaining approval <br /> from Government of India, Reserve Bank of India and Board of Directors of the <br /> Bank. The VRS was open to any employee at all point in time. So, the statement <br /> of the respondent-Bank that there was no VRS in existence when the appellant <br /> applied for the same is totally false and mischievous. <b> </b><br /> <b>11.</b> <b> </b> The appellant has relied on the decisions in <b><i>Assistant General Manager, </i></b><br /> <b><i>5</i></b><br /> <b><i>State Bank of India &amp; Ors.</i></b> <i> </i> <b><i>vs. Radhey Shyam Pandey</i></b> <b><i> </i></b> and <b><i>Rugmini </i></b><br /> <b><i>Ganesh w/o Ganesh Raman Iyer vs. State Bank of India Rep. By its </i></b><br /> <b><i>6</i></b><br /> <b><i>Chairperson</i></b> <b><i> </i></b> to bolster his submissions. <b> </b><br /> <b>12.</b> <b> </b> <i>Per contra,</i> learned ASG appearing for the respondent-Bank would argue <br /> that the appellant is not eligible for pension as per the applicable Pension Fund <br /> Rules since he has not completed 20 years of qualifying service and neither he <br /> has completed 50 years of age. Thus, making him non-entitled for pension under <br /> Rule 22(i)(a) of the Pension Fund Rules. <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>13.</b> Additionally, the learned ASG argued that the claim petition filed by the <br /> appellant under Section 33C(2) of the ID Act was not maintainable since such a <br /> <br /> 4<br /> For short, “VRS” <br /> 5<br /> 2020 (6) SCC 438 <br /> 6<br /> 2018 SCC OnLine Bom 3884 <br /> Civil Appeal @ SLP (Civil) No.12462/2022 Page <b>4</b> of <b>11</b> <br /> <br /><br /> petition can only be entertained by the Labour Court when there is a pre-existing <br /> right. <b> </b><br /> <b>14.</b> <b> </b> The respondent-Bank also denies the contention of the appellant regarding <br /> obtaining VRS, since there was no VRS in operation during that relevant time. <br /> Instead, it is argued that the appellant from 24.01.1998 to 11.12.1998 without <br /> informing and without availing leave started remaining unauthorizedly absent <br /> for a long period. During this period, the respondent-Bank, following the <br /> provisions of the Bipartite Settlement, issued notices dated 01.06.1998 and <br /> 12.11.1998 calling upon the appellant to report for work and explain his <br /> unauthorized absence. As the appellant failed to report for duty, he was declared <br /> to have voluntarily abandoned his services from 12.12.1998. During this time, <br /> it is argued on behalf of the respondent(s) that the appellant had been in <br /> employment abroad and was residing there. Thus, this was not a case of <br /> voluntary retirement, but of voluntary abandonment of services on part of the <br /> appellant. <b> </b><br /> <b>15.</b> <b> </b> To bolster the submissions, the respondent-Bank has relied on the <br /> <b><i>7</i></b><br /> decision in <b><i>Municipal Corporation of Delhi vs. Ganesh Razak &amp; Anr.</i></b> <b><i> </i></b> and <br /> <b><i>Arikaravula Sanyasi Raju vs. Branch Manager, State Bank of India, </i></b><br /> <b><i>8</i></b><br /> <b><i>Visakhapatnam (A.P) and Ors.</i></b> <b> </b><br /> <i>.</i><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>16.</b> The rival submissions now fall for our consideration. <b><i> </i></b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <br /> 7<br /> (1995) 1 SCC 235 <br /> 8<br /> (1997) 1 SCC 256 <br /> Civil Appeal @ SLP (Civil) No.12462/2022 Page <b>5</b> of <b>11</b> <br /> <br /><br /> <b>ANALYSIS</b> <b><i> </i></b><br /> <b>17.</b> <b> </b> At the outset, we make it clear that though the Labour Court and the High <br /> Court have dismissed the case of the appellant on the technical ground of non- <br /> maintainability of the petition under Section 33C(2) of the ID Act, primarily since <br /> the proceedings under Section 33C(2) of the ID Act are in the nature of execution <br /> proceedings and, since in the present case, the issue of the grant of the pension <br /> to the appellant cannot be held to be a pre-existing right, as the same was <br /> disputed by the respondent-Bank, both, the Labour Court and High Court, <br /> decided to dismiss the case of the appellant at the threshold. However, we have <br /> decided to proceed with the case on its merits. <b> </b><br /> <b>18.</b> <b> </b> The primary question that arises for our adjudication is that whether the <br /> appellant is entitled for pensionary benefits keeping in view the Pension Fund <br /> Rules. <b> </b><br /> <b>19.</b> <b> </b> Employee’s pension rights are crystallized under Rule 22 of the Pension <br /> Fund Rules. The said rule reads as under: <br /> <b>&quot;22. Minimum service for pension</b> - (i) A member shall be entitled to <br /> a pension under these rules on retiring from the Bank&#x27;s service- <br /> <br /> a) <b>After having completed twenty years’ pensionable service </b><br /> <b>provided that he has attained the age of fifty years</b> or if he is in the <br /> service of the Bank on or after the 1.11.1993, after having completed <br /> ten years pensionable service provided that he has attained the age of <br /> fifty eight years or if he is in the service of the Bank on or after <br /> 22.05.1998, after having completed ten years pensionable service <br /> provided that he has attained the age of sixty years; <br /> <br /> (b) <b>After having completed twenty years&#x27; pensionable service</b> , <br /> irrespective of the age he shall have attained, if he shall satisfy the <br /> authority competent to sanction his <b>retirement by approved medical </b><br /> <b>certificate</b> or otherwise that he is incapacitated for further active <br /> service; <br /> <br /> (c) after having completed twenty years pensionable service, <br /> irrespective of the age he shall have attained at <b>his request in writing. </b><br /> <br /> Civil Appeal @ SLP (Civil) No.12462/2022 Page <b>6</b> of <b>11</b> <br /> <br /><br /> (d) <b>after twenty five years&#x27; pensionable service.</b> ” <br /> <b> </b><br /> (emphasis supplied) <br /> <br /> <b>20.</b> <b> </b> The reckoning of pensionable service has to be determined in accordance <br /> with Rule 20 read with Rule 7 of the Pension Fund Rules which read as follows: <br /> <b>&quot;20. </b> Save as provided in rule 21, with effect from 1.11.93, <b>service </b><br /> <b>rendered by an employee/member from the date of his admission </b><br /> <b>to the fund</b> upto the date of retirement in terms of rule 22 infra from <br /> the Bank&#x27;s service shall be reckoned as service for pension. <br /> <br /> Rule 7 of the Rules <br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>7. </b> Save as provided in rule 8, <b>every permanent employee </b> (including <br /> a permanent part-time employee who is required by the Bank to work <br /> for more than six hours a week) <b> in the service of the Bank</b> , who is <br /> entitled to pension benefits under the terms and conditions of his <br /> service <b>shall become a member of the Fund from- </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>(a) the date from which he is confirmed in the service of the </b><br /> <b>Bank</b> , or <br /> <br /> (b) the date from which he may be required to become a member of <br /> the Fund under the terms and conditions of his service.” <br /> <br /> (emphasis supplied) <br /> <br /> <b>21.</b> <b> </b> The appellant has primarily placed reliance upon Rule 22(i)(c) of the <br /> Pension Fund Rules to claim entitlement to pensionary benefits, whereas the <br /> respondent(s) has contended, by placing reliance on Rule 22(i)(a), that the <br /> appellant does not fulfil the conditions prescribed therein and is, therefore, not <br /> entitled to pension. In view of the rival submissions, it becomes necessary for <br /> this Court to examine the scope and applicability of Rule 22(i)(c) and Rule 22(i)(a) <br /> of the Pension Fund Rules. <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>ELIGIBILITY CONDITIONS FOR PENSION UNDER RULE 22(i)(c) OF THE </b><br /> <b>PENSION FUND RULES </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>22.</b> <b> </b> Primarily in order for the appellant to be eligible for the pension under <br /> Rule 22(i)(c) following two conditions are required to be satisfied: <i>The employee </i><br /> Civil Appeal @ SLP (Civil) No.12462/2022 Page <b>7</b> of <b>11</b> <br /> <br /><br /> <i>should have completed twenty years of pensionable service, irrespective of the </i><br /> <i>age, he shall have attained at his request in writing. </i> <b> </b><br /> <b>23.</b> <b> </b> It is the case of the appellant that he completed 20 years, 3 months and <br /> 25 days, as on 12.12.1998, i.e. from the date of appointment being 17.08.1978, <br /> to the date of deemed voluntary retirement being 12.12.1998. However, the <br /> record of the case clearly shows that the appointment of the appellant was <br /> confirmed on 17.02.1979 and he was declared to have voluntarily abandoned <br /> his services from 12.12.1998. <b> </b><br /> <b>24.</b> <b> </b> Additionally, a reading of Rule 20 along with Rule 7 of the Pension Fund <br /> Rules would make it clear that service for the purpose of pension is to be <br /> reckoned from the date of the employee’s admission to the fund wherein the <br /> employee shall become the member of the fund from the date on which he was <br /> confirmed in the service of the Bank. Thus, if we calculate the total period of the <br /> service rendered by the appellant, after completion of probation, it would come <br /> down to less than 20 years i.e., 19 years, 09 months and 25 days. Thus, the first <br /> condition of the appellant having completed 20 years in service is not-fulfilled. <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>VOLUNTARY </b> <b>RETIREMENT </b> <b>OR </b> <b>VOLUNTARY </b> <b>ABANDONMENT </b> <b>OF </b><br /> <b>SERVICES? </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>25.</b> <b> </b> The second condition that needs to be fulfilled is that the appellant must <br /> have obtained voluntary retirement from services of the respondent-Bank. <br /> However, looking at the record of the case, we have noticed that the present case <br /> is not of voluntary retirement, rather of voluntary abandonment of the services, <br /> wherein from 24.01.1998 to 11.12.1998, the appellant, without informing and <br /> availing leave, started remaining absent for a long time after which the <br /> Civil Appeal @ SLP (Civil) No.12462/2022 Page <b>8</b> of <b>11</b> <br /> <br /><br /> respondent-Bank issued notices dated 01.06.1998 and 12.11.1998 calling upon <br /> the appellant to explain his absence. <b> </b><br /> <b>26.</b> <b> </b> After receiving a non-satisfactory reply, services of the appellant were <br /> declared to have been voluntarily abandoned. Hence, the reliance placed by the <br /> appellant on Rule 22(i)(c) of the Pension Fund Rules is completely misplaced. <b> </b><br /> <b>27.</b> <b> </b> The appellant has relied on <b><i>Radhey Shyam Pandey</i></b> (supra) to contend <br /> that since pension is a pre-existing right under the Pension Fund Rules, <br /> voluntary cessation of service should be treated at par with voluntary retirement. <br /> This submission, however, in our view, seems to be completely misplaced as in <br /> <b><i>Radhey Shyam Pandey</i></b> (supra), <i> </i> this Court was concerned with employees who <br /> had undisputedly retired under a recognized Voluntary Retirement Scheme, and <br /> the controversy was limited to the interpretation of pension rules and the extent <br /> of qualifying service. The entitlement to pension itself was not in dispute, and, <br /> therefore, the Court proceeded to interpret the scheme in favour of granting <br /> benefits. <b> </b><br /> <b>28.</b> <b> </b> In contrast, in the present case, the very foundation of the appellant’s <br /> claim, namely, his entitlement to pension, is seriously disputed by the <br /> respondent-Bank, particularly with respect to the fact that his case is not of <br /> voluntary retirement, rather of voluntary abandonment of service on part of the <br /> appellant. <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>ELIGIBILITY CONDITIONS FOR PENSION UNDER RULE 22(i)(a) OF THE </b><br /> <b>PENSION FUND RULES </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>29.</b> <b> </b> Since the respondent-Bank has submitted that the appropriate rule under <br /> which the appellant’s case falls is Rule 22(i)(a) and not Rule 22(i)(c), we shall now <br /> Civil Appeal @ SLP (Civil) No.12462/2022 Page <b>9</b> of <b>11</b> <br /> <br /><br /> examine whether the appellant is entitled to pension under Rule 22(i)(a) of the <br /> Pension Fund Rules. <br /> <b>30.</b> <b> </b> The two conditions that are required to be fulfilled are that <i> the appellant </i><br /> <i>must have completed twenty years of pensionable service provided that he </i><br /> <i>attained the age of fifty years during the relevant time.</i> Since we have already held <br /> that the total service years of the appellant is less than 20 years, the first <br /> condition remains unfulfilled. That apart, it is an admitted position on record <br /> that the appellant had not attained the age of 50 years as on the date of cessation <br /> of service. Therefore, the mandatory condition relating to attainment of the <br /> prescribed age under Rule 22(i)(a) also remains unfulfilled. In view of the non-<br /> satisfaction of both the essential conditions, namely, completion of 20 years of <br /> qualifying service and attainment of 50 years of age, the appellant is clearly not <br /> entitled to claim pension under Rule 22(i)(a) of the Pension Fund Rules. <br /> <b>31.</b> <b> </b> The appellant has relied on the decision in <b><i>Rugmini Ganesh </i></b> (supra) <b><i> </i></b> to <br /> submit that the probation period during the appellant’s service should also be <br /> counted for calculating his pensionable service. It is important to note that <br /> <b><i>Rugmini Ganesh</i></b> (supra) dealt with the limited question of computation of <br /> qualifying service, including whether pre-confirmation service could be counted, <br /> in a situation where the employee’s entitlement to pension was already <br /> recognized. It did not address a case where entitlement itself was in issue. Also, <br /> in <b><i>Rugmini Ganesh</i></b> <i> </i> (supra) <i>, </i> the employee’s service record was not <br /> fundamentally disputed and the issue was confined only to the interpretation of <br /> the service rules. In the present case, even if we for argument’s sake agree to <br /> the submission of the appellant and include the probation period to calculate <br /> Civil Appeal @ SLP (Civil) No.12462/2022 Page <b>10</b> of <b>11</b> <br /> <br /><br /> the pensionable service, he would still not be eligible as he had not attained the <br /> requisite 50 years of age at the relevant time. Hence, making the appellant <br /> ineligible under Rule 22(i)(a) of the Pension Fund Rules. <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>CONCLUSION </b><br /> <b>32.</b> <b> </b> In view of the above discussion, we are of the opinion that the appellant <br /> cannot be said to be eligible for pension under the Pension Fund Rules <br /> considering that he has not completed 20 years of service nor had attained the <br /> age of 50 years, hence, making him ineligible under Rule 22(i)(a). Also, the <br /> appellant’s case cannot be said to fall under Rule 22(i)(c) since the appellant was <br /> never granted VRS, instead his services were declared to have been voluntary <br /> abandoned. Keeping in view that the case of the appellant does not fall in either <br /> of the above-stated Rules, this Appeal deserves to be dismissed. The same is, <br /> accordingly, dismissed. <br /> <b>………………………………………J. </b><br /> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> (PRASHANT KUMAR MISHRA) </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>………………………………………J. </b><br /> <b> (N.V. ANJARIA) </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>NEW DELHI; </b><br /> <b>APRIL 08, 2026.</b> <br /> Civil Appeal @ SLP (Civil) No.12462/2022 Page <b>11</b> of <b>11</b> <br /> </div>