Gls Films Industries Private Limited vs Chemical Suppliers India Private Limited
- Court
- Supreme Court
<div> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b> </b> <b><i>Non-reportable </i></b><br /> 2026 INSC 344<br /> <b>IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA</b> <br /> <b>CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>Civil Appeal No. 4019 of 2025 </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>GLS Films Industries Private Limited </b> <b> </b> <b> … Appellant </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>versus </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>]</b><br /> <b>Chemical Suppliers India Private Limited … Respondent </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <br /> <b>J U D G M E N T </b><br /> <br /> <b>SANJAY KUMAR, J </b><br /> Initiation of corporate insolvency resolution process was denied by <br /> <b>1. </b><br /> the adjudicating authority but the appellate authority reversed that <br /> decision. Aggrieved thereby, the corporate debtor is in appeal. On <br /> 28.03.2025, this Court stayed the operation of the judgment under appeal. <br /> <b>2. </b> Company Petition (IB)-792(ND) of 2021 was filed before the <br /> National Company Law Tribunal, New Delhi Bench (Court II) ( <i>hereinafter</i> , <br /> ‘the NCLT’), by Chemical Suppliers India Private Limited, the respondent <br /> <b><i>1</i></b><br /> herein, under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 , <br /> Signature Not Verified<br /> Digitally signed by<br /> babita pandey<br /> Date: 2026.04.09<br /> 18:42:45 IST<br /> Reason:<br /> against GLS Films Industries Private Limited, the appellant. <br /> <br /> 1<br /> For short, ‘the Code’ <br /> 1 <br /> <br /><br /> <b>3. </b> The case of the respondent was that it had supplied chemicals to <br /> the appellant over a period of time and a sum of ₹2,92,93,223/- was due <br /> and payable to it as on 26.05.2021. Demand notice dated 11.11.2021 was <br /> issued by it under Section 8 of the Code. In response, the appellant <br /> addressed email dated 06.12.2021 disputing the claim. The respondent <br /> thereupon filed the subject application under Section 9 of the Code. The <br /> appellant contested the proceedings claiming that there was a pre-existing <br /> dispute between the parties prior to issuance of the demand notice. <br /> According to it, the respondent had supplied two consignments of solvent <br /> on 10.04.2021 and 11.04.2021 respectively at its factory premises at <br /> Gurugram but the same were found to be defective. This was brought to <br /> the notice of the respondent, which promised that it would do better. <br /> Basing on the said representation, the appellant claimed to have sourced <br /> some more solvent supplies from the respondent on 20.04.2021 and <br /> 23.04.2021. However, these supplies were also found to be defective. The <br /> respondent assured the appellant that it would compensate it for the <br /> losses suffered and supplied another batch of solvent on 21.06.2021. Yet <br /> again, upon checking, this batch was also found to be defective and was <br /> returned forthwith. <br /> <b>4. </b> According to the appellant the respondent was called upon time and <br /> again to come and settle accounts and compensate the appellant for the <br /> losses suffered by it. However, no steps were taken in that regard but the <br /> 2 <br /> <br /><br /> authorised representative of the respondent started applying arm-twisting <br /> tactics by threatening to commit suicide if payment was not made for the <br /> defective supplies. The appellant filed a police complaint in relation <br /> thereto. According to the appellant, in view of the losses suffered by it due <br /> to such defective supplies, it issued a debit note on 31.12.2021 for <br /> ₹2,42,11,648/-. After adjusting the account, <i>per</i> the appellant, the <br /> respondent was still due and liable to pay it a sum of ₹70,09,430/-. <br /> <b>5. </b> The NCLT took note of the letter dated 10.12.2020 written by the <br /> appellant to the respondent detailing the defective supplies made between <br /> 16.09.2020 and 24.10.2020, amounting to ₹1,66,89,770/-. The appellant <br /> had stated therein that its customer had debited its account by ₹6.50 crore <br /> but, owing to its long association with the respondent, the appellant was <br /> not planning to debit the said amount from its account. However, the <br /> appellant requested the respondent to take note of the debit note raised <br /> by it for ₹1.66 crore and arrange a credit note for that sum. <br /> The NCLT noted that the respondent replied to this letter dated <br /> <b>6. </b><br /> 10.12.2020 by way of email dated 14.07.2021. Therein, it denied that its <br /> supplies of solvent were defective and requested for payment to be made <br /> against overdue bills. In turn, by email dated 16.10.2021, the appellant <br /> reiterated that the material supplied to it was defective and called upon <br /> the respondent to reconcile the accounts and appropriate the losses <br /> caused to it due to defective supplies. The appellant asserted that it was <br /> 3 <br /> <br /><br /> only after repeated efforts on its part that the respondent incorporated a <br /> credit note for ₹1.66 crore but the original thereof and the tax paid note <br /> were never delivered to it. On the other hand, by email dated 10.09.2021, <br /> the respondent raised a demand for ₹4,60,05,397/-. The NCLT also noted <br /> that the appellant had lodged a police complaint on 27.09.2021, long prior <br /> to issuance of the demand notice, raising the issue of the defective quality <br /> of the supplies made by the respondent and its pressure tactics in seeking <br /> payment therefor under threat of suicide. Therein, the appellant had also <br /> referred to the fact that it called upon the respondent to come for <br /> reconciliation of accounts but to no avail. <br /> <b>7. </b> On a conspectus of these facts, the NCLT opined that there was a <br /> plausible dispute raised by the appellant, which was not disclosed by the <br /> respondent upfront in its application. The NCLT also took note of the <br /> counterclaim of the appellant that it was due and payable a sum of <br /> ₹70,09,430/-. The NCLT opined that the respondent had approached it to <br /> recover its alleged dues and that was not the objective of the process <br /> provided under the Code. The NCLT, accordingly, concluded that there <br /> existed a dispute between the parties prior to issuance of the demand <br /> notice which necessitated a detailed investigation of documents and <br /> adducing of evidence by all concerned, which was beyond the scope of <br /> its summary jurisdiction under the Code. The respondent’s application <br /> was accordingly dismissed by the NCLT, <i>vide</i> order dated 16.12.2022. <br /> 4 <br /> <br /><br /> <b>8. </b> Aggrieved thereby, the respondent filed Company Appeal (AT) (Ins) <br /> No. 157 of 2023 before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, <br /> Principal Bench, New Delhi ( <i>hereinafter</i> , ‘the NCLAT’). This appeal was <br /> allowed by the impugned judgment dated 11.02.2025. Therein, the NCLAT <br /> noted that the respondent had raised eight invoices between the dates <br /> 27.03.2021 and 26.07.2021, amounting to ₹1,72,04,137/-, for the material <br /> supplied by it to the appellant and as the appellant failed to make payment <br /> therefor within time, the respondent charged interest @24% per annum, <br /> as per the invoice terms, amounting to ₹1,20,89,086/-. As no payment was <br /> made even thereafter, the respondent was stated to have issued demand <br /> notice dated 11.11.2021 under Section 8 of the Code for ₹2,92,93,223/-, <br /> being the principal and the interest due, and then filed the application <br /> under Section 9 of the Code on 21.12.2021. <br /> <b>9. </b> The NCLAT observed that the appellant had addressed letter dated <br /> 10.12.2020 to the respondent, complaining about the poor quality of the <br /> material supplied by it in September, 2020 and October, 2020 and that this <br /> letter found reference in the appellant’s email dated 16.10.2021. The <br /> NCLAT, however, opined that the respondent had accepted its liability in <br /> that regard and issued a credit note to the appellant for ₹1.66 crore. The <br /> NCLAT also noted that the appellant had incorporated this credit note in <br /> its ledger account on 31.03.2021. According to the NCLAT, this credit note <br /> resolved the issue raised by the appellant in its letter dated 10.12.2020, <br /> 5 <br /> <br /><br /> which was again raked up in the email dated 16.10.2021. On this basis, <br /> the NCLAT concluded that it could not be treated as a pre-existing dispute. <br /> The NCLAT then referred to the appellant’s email dated 06.12.2021 in <br /> reply to the respondent’s demand notice dated 11.11.2021. Therein, the <br /> appellant had referred to the credit note dated 31.03.2021 for <br /> ₹1,66,89,770/-, the original of which was still awaited by it. The NCLAT <br /> opined that the amount covered by the demand notice did not take into <br /> account this sum of ₹1.66 crore which was in relation to the defective <br /> material supplied from September, 2020 to October, 2020. Further, the <br /> NCLAT was of the opinion that the issues raised by the appellant in its <br /> reply to the Section 9 application related to developments and events after <br /> receipt of the demand notice dated 11.11.2021 and could not be taken into <br /> consideration for the purpose of determining whether there was any <br /> pre-existing dispute. <br /> The NCLAT was also of the opinion that the failure of the appellant <br /> <b>10. </b><br /> to point out the defects in the supplies within seven days from the date of <br /> delivery was sufficient to hold that its contentions in that regard were <br /> nothing but a moonshine defence. The NCLAT rejected the contention <br /> urged by the appellant that levy of interest on the alleged delayed payment <br /> would be a disputed issue in itself. The NCLAT noted that the police <br /> complaint lodged by the appellant referred to the respondent’s demand <br /> for ₹4.60 crore as its outstanding dues but accepted the plea of the <br /> 6 <br /> <br /><br /> respondent that it had made a mistake in its email dated 10.09.2021 while <br /> making that demand and that it had clarified on 09.12.2021 that it had <br /> failed to adjust the sum of ₹1.66 crore. The NCLAT further noted that the <br /> respondent’s demand notice mentioned ₹2.92 crore as being due and <br /> payable to it and not ₹4.60 crore, which showed that adjustment of ₹1.66 <br /> crore had been taken care of. <br /> The NCLAT also rejected the plea of the appellant that its recovery <br /> <b>11. </b><br /> suit in Civil Suit No. 37 of 2022, filed in April, 2022, was an indication of <br /> the existing dispute between the parties, as the said suit was filed after <br /> the respondent’s Section 9 application. On that ground, the NCLAT <br /> refused to consider the proceedings in that suit which, according to the <br /> appellant, supported its plea that there was a pre-existing dispute. Holding <br /> so, the NCLAT set aside the order dated 16.12.2022 passed by the NCLT <br /> and directed admission of the respondent’s application under Section 9 of <br /> the Code after one month. During that period, the NCLAT left it open to <br /> the appellant to settle the issue with the respondent for discharge of the <br /> debt and, in the event of the same fructifying, the NCLAT left it open to the <br /> parties to bring it to the notice of the NCLT for passing appropriate orders. <br /> <b>12. </b> At this stage, we deem it apposite to set out the sequence of events. <br /> The appellant’s letter dated 10.12.2020, informing the respondent of the <br /> defective supplies made in September, 2020, and October, 2020, resulting <br /> in a loss of ₹6.50 crore and requesting a credit note for ₹1.66 crore was <br /> 7 <br /> <br /><br /> followed up by the respondent’s supplies made on 09.04.2021 and <br /> 10.04.2021. Notably, the tax invoices in that regard were signed only by <br /> the respondent’s authorised signatory. Further, it was only on 14.07.2021 <br /> that the respondent considered it appropriate to reply to the letter dated <br /> 10.12.2020, denying that the supplies made by it were of inferior quality. <br /> It was only after this date that the respondent started raising debit notes <br /> on account of interest @24% on the alleged delayed payments made from <br /> April, 2016 onwards. Debit notes dated 25.08.2021, five in number, and <br /> debit notes dated 15.09.2021, three in number, and the debit note dated <br /> 12.10.2021, bear out the fact that interest demands from April, 2016, to <br /> October, 2021, were raised only after the respondent’s reply email dated <br /> 14.07.2021. As to whether such interest could have been claimed in <br /> August, 2021, on the strength of unilaterally signed invoices quoting an <br /> interest rate of 24% per annum, in relation to alleged delayed payments <br /> dating back to 2016-17 and 2018 is itself a moot point. <br /> Further, the respondent’s ledger account from 01.03.2021 to <br /> <b>13. </b><br /> 13.11.2021, filed by the respondent with its counter, reflects that the credit <br /> entry of ₹1,66,89,770/- was made therein only on 31.07.2021 as a ‘sale <br /> discount’ without reference to the appellant’s letter dated 10.12.2020. The <br /> credit entry of ₹35,59,982/- marked ‘sale return’ was made on 01.07.2021 <br /> in relation to the supplies rejected by the appellant on 21.06.2021. The <br /> ledger account also discloses that debit notes were raised for interest on <br /> 8 <br /> <br /><br /> delayed payments only from 25.08.2021. The ledger account of the <br /> appellant for the FYs 2020-21 and 2021-22, which was also filed by the <br /> respondent along with said counter, disclose that the debit entry for <br /> ₹1,66,89,770/- was made on 31.03.2021, with the endorsement that the <br /> account had been debited due to ‘stringent smell and impurity in solvents’. <br /> The ledger account also discloses that a debit was raised on 21.06.2021 <br /> for ₹35,59,982/-, in relation to the material that was rejected and returned <br /> on that day. That apart, debit entries were made on 22.06.2020 and twice <br /> on 31.03.2021 due to ‘short quantity received’. The discrepancies <br /> between the ledger accounts are, therefore, quite patent. Further, the <br /> respondent’s eight invoices that were relied upon by the NCLAT added up <br /> to a sum of ₹1,72,13,065/- and not the sum of ₹1,72,04,137/-, which was <br /> mentioned in the demand notice. <br /> <b>14. </b> Significantly, had the respondent actually given effect to the credit <br /> entry of ₹1,66,89,770/- on 31.07.2021, there is no explanation forthcoming <br /> as to why it had sent the email dated 10.09.2021, raising a demand for <br /> ₹4,60,05,397/-, which admittedly included the sum of ₹1,66,89,770/- also. <br /> The belated email dated 09.12.2021 issued by it, professing to correct the <br /> mistake made in including ₹1,66,89,770/-, speaks for itself. <br /> <b>15. </b> Further, the irrefutable fact also remains that the appellant lodged a <br /> police complaint on 27.09.2021, long before the respondent’s demand <br /> notice dated 11.11.2021. The appellant mentioned therein that it had <br /> 9 <br /> <br /><br /> called upon the respondent to come for reconciliation of accounts, clearly <br /> indicating that there were issues to be settled between them. Even in its <br /> email dated 16.10.2021, issued prior to the respondent’s demand notice, <br /> the appellant had called upon the respondent to reconcile the accounts <br /> pursuant to the losses caused by supply of defective materials. <br /> The respondent’s debit notes raising exorbitant demands for interest <br /> <b>16. </b><br /> on delayed payments dating back to periods, in defiance of limitation, <br /> manifest that such claims are open to question. Further, though the <br /> NCLAT was not inclined to consider the proceedings in the appellant’s civil <br /> suit on the ground that the same were post-initiation of the corporate <br /> insolvency resolution process (CIRP), the same assume importance as <br /> what was stated therein by Ankur Aggarwal, the Director of the <br /> respondent, has relevance. In his cross examination in the said suit, <br /> speaking as PW1, he stated that he used to interact only telephonically <br /> with the appellant’s personnel and that there were no written <br /> correspondence or emails between them. He admitted that written/email <br /> correspondence started only when disputes arose regarding payment. He <br /> also admitted that there was no written protest of delayed payments by <br /> him from 2016-17 till 2021. He conceded that supply of material was made <br /> on 10.04.2021 and 11.04.2021 by the respondent from the stock at Delhi, <br /> which was kept in drums, and was supplied as it was, in drums, and not <br /> in tankers as it used to be in other transactions. He admitted that the <br /> 10 <br /> <br /><br /> drums had been purchased from vendors, other than the vendors of <br /> chemical products, locally from Delhi and there was no cleaning certificate <br /> for them. These admissions of the Director did not relate to post-CIRP <br /> events but had reference to pre-CIRP issues relevant to this case. The <br /> NCLAT, therefore, ought not to have eschewed them from consideration. <br /> Once the respondent admitted that written correspondence <br /> <b>17. </b><br /> commenced only after disputes arose, and the first such written <br /> correspondence dated back to 10.12.2020, long prior to issuance of the <br /> demand notice on 11.11.2021, this was sufficient in itself to show that <br /> there were pre-existing disputes between the parties. When the appellant <br /> sought reconciliation of accounts in that context and the respondent failed <br /> to oblige, its demand for a sum of money in excess of ₹1 crore would not <br /> be sufficient to meet the threshold for maintaining an application under <br /> Section 9 of the Code. More so, when the respondent had raised a <br /> demand for ₹4.60 crore just two months prior to issuance of the demand <br /> notice and clarified the same only on 09.12.2021, that is almost a month <br /> after issuance of the demand notice. This confusion and lack of clarity on <br /> the part of the respondent in deciding as to what was the amount allegedly <br /> due to it, clearly supports the case of the appellant that the accounts <br /> required reconciliation. <br /> <b>18. </b> Further, the delay on the part of the respondent in replying to the <br /> letter dated 10.12.2020 is another factor which strengthens the premise <br /> 11 <br /> <br /><br /> that the respondent’s belated reply followed by its multiple debit notes for <br /> interest in quick succession were just afterthoughts to build up a case so <br /> as to file an application under Section 9 of the Code. <br /> <b><i>19. </i></b> In this regard, useful reference may be made to <b><i>Mobilox </i></b><br /> <b><i>2</i></b><br /> , <br /> <b><i>Innovations Private Limited vs. Kirusa Software Private Limited</i></b><br /> wherein this Court had observed as under: -<br /> <b><i> </i></b><br /> ‘51. It is clear, therefore, that once the operational creditor has filed an <br /> application, which is otherwise complete, the adjudicating authority must <br /> reject the application under Section 9(5)(i)(d) if notice of dispute has been <br /> received by the operational creditor or there is a record of dispute in the <br /> information utility. It is clear that such notice must bring to the notice of <br /> the operational creditor the “existence” of a dispute or the fact that a suit <br /> or arbitration proceeding relating to a dispute is pending between the <br /> parties. Therefore, all that the adjudicating authority is to see at this stage <br /> is whether there is a plausible contention which requires further <br /> investigation and that the “dispute” is not a patently feeble legal argument <br /> or an assertion of fact unsupported by evidence. It is important to <br /> separate the grain from the chaff and to reject a spurious defence which <br /> is mere bluster. However, in doing so, the Court does not need to be <br /> satisfied that the defence is likely to succeed. The Court does not at this <br /> stage examine the merits of the dispute except to the extent indicated <br /> above. So long as a dispute truly exists in fact and is not spurious, <br /> hypothetical or illusory, the adjudicating authority has to reject the <br /> application.’ <br /> Thereafter, in <br /> <b><i>S.S. Engineers vs. Hindustan Petroleum </i></b><br /> <b><i>3</i></b><br /> , this Court noted that when examining <br /> <b><i>Corporation Limited and others</i></b> <b><i> </i></b><br /> an application under Section 9 of the Code, the adjudicating authority has <br /> to examine (i) whether there was an operational debt exceeding ₹1 lakh <br /> th<br /> (after 24 March, 2020, ₹1 crore); (ii) whether the evidence furnished with <br /> <br /> 2<br /> (2018) 1 SCC 353 <br /> 3<br /> (2022) 234 COMP CAS 95 <br /> 12 <br /> <br /><br /> the application showed that the debt was due and payable and had not till <br /> then been paid; and (iii) whether there was in existence any dispute <br /> between the parties or the record of pendency of a suit or arbitration <br /> proceedings filed before the receipt of demand notice in relation to such <br /> dispute and in the event, any of the aforestated conditions was not fulfilled, <br /> the application of the operational creditor would have to be rejected. <br /> <b><i>4</i></b><br /> In , this Court <br /> <b>20. </b> <b><i> Sabarmati Gas Limited vs. Shah Alloys Limited</i></b><br /> considered the scope of the word ‘reconciliation’ and applying the <br /> th<br /> definition in <i>Black’s Law Dictionary</i> , 10 edition, this Court opined that the <br /> apt meaning suitable to the situation in relation to accounting would mean <br /> an adjustment of amounts so that they agree, especially by allowing for <br /> outstanding items. This Court referred to the observations in <b><i>Mobilox</i></b> <br /> ( <i>supra</i> ) that it is not necessary that the Court should be satisfied that the <br /> defence of a pre-existing dispute is likely to succeed and it is enough if <br /> such a dispute exists between the parties. <i>Per</i> this Court, what is to be <br /> seen is whether there is a plausible contention requiring investigation for <br /> the purpose of adjudication for it to satisfy the requirement of a <br /> pre-existing dispute. <br /> <b>21. </b> Given the obtaining facts and the aforestated settled legal position, <br /> it was not for the NCLAT to delve into the appellant’s dispute to decide <br /> <br /> 4<br /> (2023) 3 SCC 229 <br /> 13 <br /> <br /><br /> whether it had actual merit. All that is required is for the adjudicating <br /> authority to satisfy itself as to the existence of a plausible pre-existing <br /> dispute, which was not spurious, hypothetical or illusory. Whether the <br /> party raising that dispute would succeed on the strength thereof is not <br /> within the ken of such inquiry. That being so, we are of the opinion that the <br /> NCLT was correct in concluding that the application filed by the <br /> respondent under Section 9 of the Code did not merit consideration, owing <br /> to pre-existing disputes. The NCLAT was not justified in reversing the said <br /> decision. There was clearly no consensus between the parties as to who <br /> was liable to pay to the other and the amount that was payable. <br /> <b>22. </b> The appeal is accordingly allowed, setting aside the judgement <br /> dated 11.02.2025 passed by the National Company Law Appellate <br /> Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi, in Company Appeal (AT) (Ins) No. <br /> 157 of 2023 and restoring the order dated 16.12.2022 passed by the <br /> National Company Law Tribunal, New Delhi Bench (Court II), in Company <br /> Petition (IB)-792(ND) of 2021. <br /> Parties shall bear their respective costs. <br /> <br /> <b>..............................., J. </b><br /> <b>SANJAY KUMAR </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b> </b><br /> <b>..............................., J. </b><br /> <b>R. MAHADEVAN </b><br /> <b>April 09, 2026 </b><br /> <b>New Delhi. </b> <br /> 14 <br /> </div>