Full Judgment Text
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS PETITION NO.9718 OF 2008
IN AND
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.884 OF 2009
(Arising out of S.L.P. (Crl.) No.3246 of 2009)
Lucknow Golf Club, Lucknow ...Appellant(s)
Versus
Prashant Chandra and Ors. ...Respondent(s)
O R D E R
Though the case was placed under the heading ‘Incomplete After Notice
Matters’, but both the parties stated that the matter be taken up and finally disposed
of.
Permission to file special leave petition is granted.
Leave granted.
th
By the impugned order passed on 19 May, 2008, the High Court issued
rule against Shri Amarjeet Verma, Civil Judge (Senior Division), Lucknow, to show
cause as to why contempt proceeding be not initiated against him for violation of
st
order dated 21 February, 2008 passed in First Appeal No.77 of 2007.
A perusal of the record shows that the first appeal preferred by the
th
respondent against judgment and decree dated 17 July, 2007 passed by Civil Judge
(Senior Division), Lucknow was allowed by the High Court and the case was
remanded to the trial Court with the direction to expedite the hearing of the case and
to conclude the same preferably within 3 months from the date of filing of certified
copy.
....2/-
- 2 -
It is not in dispute that certified copy of the judgment of the High Court
rd th
was produced before the trial Court on 23 February, 2008 and on 14 March, 2008,
th
notice was ordered to be issued to the defendant for 18 March, 2008. On the next
th
date, the case was adjourned to 29 March, 2008 because of the lawyers’ boycott of
nd
the courts. The case was then adjourned for 2 April, 2008 on which date no one
appeared for the parties. In the meanwhile, respondent filed an application under
Section 24 of the CPC for transfer of case from the court of Civil Judge (Senior
th
Division), Lucknow. That petition was dismissed by District Judge, Lucknow on 10
April, 2008. Due to pendency of the transfer application, no effective proceedings
could be conducted in the suit. After dismissal of the transfer application, the case
th th
was taken up on 17 April, 2008, on which date it had to be adjourned to 19 April,
2008 because counsel for the respondent No.1 herein stated that he would conduct the
th
case after coming from the High Court. On 19 April, 2008, the trial Court passed a
th
detailed order and adjourned the case to 29 April, 2008 by recording that in view of
th
the High Court’s order, issues will have to be framed. On 29 April, 2008, neither
party appeared till 1.10 p.m. and after lunch, counsel for the defendant did not
th
appear necessitating further adjournment. On 30 April, 2008, the case was
adjourned in the wake of resolution passed by the Bar Association. On the same day,
the respondent filed a petition under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, which
nd th
was dismissed by the High Court on 2 May, 2008 as not pressed. On 5 May, 2008,
the respondent filed transfer
....3/-
- 3 -
petition before the High Court. He also filed First Appeal No.502 of 2008 against
th th
order dated 19 April, 2008. On 17 May, 2008, the respondent filed second
contempt petition under Section 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act with the prayer
st
that the respondent be punished for his failure to comply with order dated 21
February, 2008.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record, we
are convinced that no case for contempt was at all made out and the direction
contained in the impugned order was not at all called for. The manner, in which
parties conducted the case before the Court, left respondent No.2 with no choice but
to adjourn the case on more than one occasion. This being the position, the High
Court was not justified in issuing notice to the respondent to show cause against the
proposed initiation of the proceedings on the ground of alleged violation of order
st
dated 21 February, 2008 passed in First Appeal No.77 of 2007.
Accordingly, the appeal is allowed, impugned order is set aside and the
contempt petition filed by the respondent No.1 is dismissed.
......................J.
[B.N. AGRAWAL]
......................J.
[G.S. SINGHVI]
New Delhi,
May 01, 2009.