Shantilal Gurjar vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh
- Court
- Madhya Pradesh High Court
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91615
1 CRA-5169-2017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE AMIT LAHOTI
th
ON THE 18 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5169 of 2017
CNR No.: MPHC010581712017
SHANTILAL GURJAR
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
Appearance:
Shri Prasanna Namdeo - Advocate for the appellant.
Shri Ajay Shukla- Government Advocate for respondent/State.
ORDER
Per: Justice Vivek Rusia
Despite hearing on the application for suspension of jail sentence and
grant of bail (I.A. No.23946/2026) with the consent of parties, this appeal is
heard finally.
02. The present Criminal Appeal has been filed under Section 374 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, being aggrieved by the judgment of
conviction and sentence dated 31.10.2017 passed by the Sessions Judge,
District-Khandwa, in Sessions Trial No.8/2017, whereby the present
appellant has been convicted for commission of offence punishable under
Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to undergo Life
Imprisonment along with a fine of Rs.1,000/- with default stipulations.
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TARUN KUMAR
SALUNKE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
17:51:24
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91615
2 CRA-5169-2017
3. As per the prosecution story, on 06.10.2016 the complainant
Narendra, S/o of Girdhari Sen, lodged a report that when he was returning
from the Durga temple, he noticed White Magic was parked in front of the
house of her mother Nirmala Bai, and this appellant was having a
conversation with her; thereafter, the appellant took out an axe from the
White Magic and gave blows to the head of his mother. One other person
was also sitting on the driver's seat, and after committing the above crime,
both ran away from the crime scene. According to the prosecution, before
such an incident, one Kadwa (who is the brother-in-law of the complainant
and son of the deceased) fled away with the wife of this appellant. The
appellant had been searching and enquiring about his wife. In continuation of
such search, he went to the house of Kadwa, and he had some altercation
with his mother and killed her. After registering an FII, the police completed
the investigation and filed a charge-sheet against the appellant and one
Mukesh, S/o Sukhram.
4. The appellant denied the charges and pleaded for trial. The
prosecution was called upon to lead evidence against the appellant and one
other. However, based on the evidence of the witnesses, it has been
established that the present appellant caused the injuries by means of an axe,
due to which she died. Along with the present appellant, one Mukesh, S/o
Sukhram was also made an accused, but he has been acquitted by the trial
court. The criminal appeal has been filed against the judgment of conviction
and sentence dated 31.10.2017 passed by the Sessions Judge, District-
Khandwa, in Sessions Trial No.8/2017. The appellant has not been granted
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TARUN KUMAR
SALUNKE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
17:51:24
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91615
3 CRA-5169-2017
the benefits of suspension of sentence; hence, he has been in jail since the
date of arrest.
4. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that even if the
prosecution story is accepted, it is a case which will fall under Exception IV
of section 300 of IPC because he had no intention to kill the mother of the
Kadwa who took his wife, as he had a grudge against Kadwa. He had been
searching for his wife for the last 1-2 months and, in continuation, he went to
the house of Kadwa, where he did not find his wife and no proper answer
was given about her; hence, he caused injury in the heat of passion after an
altercation with mother of Kadwa; therefore, the learned trial court has
committed an error while convicting the present appellant under section 302
of IPC instead of section 304 Part-II.
5. Learned Government Advocate opposed the aforesaid submission
by submitting that the appellant was carrying an axe in his white magic
vehicle and had an intention to commit murder; therefore, he gave three
repeated blows to a vital part, because of which she died on the spot.
Therefore, he prayed that this appeal be dismissed.
6. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
7. Narendra Sen (PW-1) is the complainant who deposed that while
returning from Durga temple, he saw a White Tata magic standing in front of
his house and the appellant was talking to his mother, Nirmala Bai.
Thereafter, he took an axe from Tata Magic and gave 3-4 blows and ran
away from the spot with the co-accused. In his cross-examination, he admits
that Kadwa is his brother-in-law who ran away with the wife of the
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TARUN KUMAR
SALUNKE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
17:51:24
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91615
4 CRA-5169-2017
appellant. Kadwa came to the house about one month and 15 days ago along
with wife of the present appellant, but he was not permitted to reside in the
house. About 15 days ago, the appellant came to his hair-cutting shop
enquiring about his wife and said that he would kill Kadwa. The statement of
PW-1 establishes that the appellant had no intention to kill the deceased, i.e
the mother of Kadwa. He went to the house of Kadwa in search of his wife;
when he did not find his wife, there was some altercation between the
present appellant and his mother and in sudden heat of passion, he took out
the axe and gave a blow. It cannot be said to be a pre-planned murder, and
the appellant assaulted the deceased in a sudden fight without premeditation,
out of anger and ran away from the spot. Therefore, in our considered
opinion, the offence will not travel beyond Section 304 Part I of the IPC, and
the appellant is entitled to get the benefit of Exception - IV of Section 300 of
the IPC. Apart from that, the appellant has completed 12 years of sentence,
and there is no criminal record of the appellant. He is not a habitual
offender.
8. The Apex Court in the case of Gurpal Singh v/s The State of Punjab
reported in AIR 2017 SC 471 has held as under:-
“However, in the singular facts of the case and noticing in particular, the progression
of events culminating in the tragic incident, we are inclined to reduce the sentence
awarded to him. Incidentally, the occurrence is of the year 2004 and meanwhile
twelve years have elapsed. Further, having regard to the root cause of the incident
and the events that sequentially unfolded thereafter, we are of the comprehension
that the appellant was overpowered by an uncontrollable fit of anger so much so that
he was deprived of his power of self-control and being drawn in a web of action
reflexes, fired at the deceased and the injured, who were within his sight. The facts
do not commend to conclude that the appellant had the intention of eliminating any
one of those fired at, though he had the knowledge of the likely fatal consequences
thereof. Be that as it may, on an overall consideration of the fact situation and also
the time lag in between, we are of the view that the conviction of the appellant ought
to be moderated to one under Sections 304 Part 1 IPC and 307 IPC. Further,
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TARUN KUMAR
SALUNKE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
17:51:24
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91615
5 CRA-5169-2017
considering the facts of the case in particular, according to us, it would meet the
ends of justice, if the sentence for the offences is reduced to the period already
undergone. We order accordingly.”
9. The Apex Court in the case of Arjun & Another, The State of
Chhattisgarh reported in AIR 2017 SC 1150 held as under:-
“20. To invoke this exception (4), the requirements that are to be fulfilled have been
laid down by this Court in Surinder Kumar v. Union Territory of Chandigarh (1989)
2 SCC 217 : (AIR 1989 SC 1094, Para 6), it has been explained as under: "7. To
invoke this exception four requirements must be satisfied, namely, (i) it was a
sudden fight; (ii) there was no premeditation; (iii) the act was done in a heat of
passion; and (iv) the assailant had not taken any undue advantage or acted in a cruel
manner. The cause of the quarrel is not relevant nor is it relevant who offered the
provocation or started the assault. The number of wounds caused during the
occurrence is not a decisive factor but what is important is that the occurrence must
have been sudden and unpremeditated and the offender must have acted in a fit of
anger. Of course, the offender must not have taken any undue advantage or acted in
a cruel manner. Where, on a sudden quarrel, a person in the heat of the moment
picks up a weapon which is handy and causes injuries, one of which proves fatal, he
would be entitled to the benefit of this exception provided he has not acted
cruelly.............."
10. Further in the case of Arumugam v. State, Represented by
Inspector of Police, Tamil Nadu, (2008) 15 SCC 590 : (AIR 2009 SC 331,
Para 15), in support of the proposition of law that under what circumstances
exception (4) to Section 300 IPC can be invoked if death is caused, it has
been explained as under:
"9. .......
"18. The help of Exception 4 can be invoked if death is caused (a) without
premeditation; (b) in a sudden fight; (c) without the offender's having taken undue
advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner; and (d) the fight must have been
with the person killed. To bring a case within Exception 4 all the ingredients
mentioned in it must be found. It is to be noted that the 'fight' occurring in Exception
4 to Section 300 IPC is not defined in the Penal Code, 1860. It takes two to make a
fight. Heat of passion requires that there must be no time for the passions to cool
down and in this case, the parties had worked themselves into a fury on account of
the verbal altercation in the beginning. A fight is a combat between two and more
persons whether with or without weapons. It is not possible to enunciate any general
rule as to what shall be deemed to be a sudden quarrel. It is a question of fact and
whether a quarrel is sudden or not must necessarily depend upon the proved facts of
each case. For the application of Exception 4, it is not sufficient to show that there
was a sudden quarrel and there was no premeditation. It must further be shown that
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TARUN KUMAR
SALUNKE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
17:51:24
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91615
6 CRA-5169-2017
the offender has not taken undue advantage or acted in cruel or unusual manner. The
expression 'undue advantage' as used in the provision means 'unfair advantage'."
11. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Prabhakar Vithal
Gholve v/s State of Maharashtra reported in AIR 2016 SC 2292 has laid
down that if the assault on the deceased could be said to be on account of the
sudden fight without premeditation, in heat of passion and upon a sudden
quarrel, Conviction of the appellant cannot be sustained under S. 302 and
altered to one under Section 304 Part-I of IPC. In Sikandar Ali v/s State of
Maharashtra reported in AIR 2017 SC 2614, the Court altered the
conviction u/s 302 IPC to one u/s 304 part-2 IPC in the following
circumstances:
“We have no doubt about the complicity of all the accused in the homicide of
Sarfraj. A-1 attacked the deceased with the knife and caused injury on his neck
which resulted in his death. The other accused assisted him in committing the crime
by holding the hands of the deceased. However, the only question that falls for our
consideration is whether the accused are liable to be punished for an offence under
Section 302 IPC. After considering the submissions made by the counsel for the
Appellants and scrutinising the material on record, we are of the opinion that the
accused are not liable to be convicted under Section 302 IPC. We are convinced that
there was neither prior concert nor common intention to commit a murder. During
the course of their business activity the accused reached the dhaba where the
deceased was
present. An altercation took place during the discussion they were having behind the
dhaba. That led to a sudden fight during which A-1 attacked the deceased with a
knife. Exception 4 to Section 300 is applicable to the facts of this case. As we are
convinced that the accused are responsible for the death of Sarfraj, we are of the
opinion that they are liable for conviction under Section 304 Part II of the IPC. We
are informed that A-1 has undergone a sentence of seven years and that A-2 to A-4
have undergone four years of imprisonment. We modify the judgment of the High
Court converting the conviction of the accused from Section 302 to Section 304 part
II of the IPC sentencing them to the period already undergone. They shall be
released forthwith.”
12. The Apex Court in the case Madhavan & Others State of Tamil
Nadu reported in AIR 2017 SC 3847 has held as under:-
“8. Notably, the High Court has not considered the issue of quantum of sentence at
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TARUN KUMAR
SALUNKE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
17:51:24
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91615
7 CRA-5169-2017
all, but mechanically proceeded to affirm the sentence awarded by the Trial Court.
From the factual position, which has emerged from the record, it is noticed that there
was a preexisting property dispute between the two families. The incident in
question happened all of a sudden without any premeditation after PW1 questioned
the appellants about their behaviour. It was a free fight between the two family
members. Both sides suffered injuries during the altercation. The fatal injury caused
to Periyasamy was by the use of thadi (wooden log) which was easily available on
the spot. The appellants, on their own, immediately reported the matter to the local
police alleging that the complainant party was the aggressor. No antecedent or
involvement in any other criminal case has been reported against the appellants.
Taking oral view of the matter, therefore, we find force in the argument of the
appellants that the quantum of sentence is excessive.”
13. In the case of Ankush Shivaji Gaikwad v/s State of Maharashtra
reported in (2013) 6 SCC 770 the Supreme Court of India has held as under:-
“10. On behalf of the appellant it was contended that the appellant's case fell within
Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC which reads as under: Exception 4. Culpable
homicide is not murder if it is committed without premeditation in a sudden fight in
the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel and without the offender's having taken
undue advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner.
11. It was argued that the incident in question took place on a sudden fight without
any premeditation and the act of the appellant hitting the deceased was committed in
the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel without the appellant having taken undue
advantage or acting in a cruel or unusual manner. There is, in our opinion,
considerable merit in that contention. We say so for three distinct reasons:
11.1. Firstly, because even according to the prosecution version, there was no
premeditation in the commission of the crime. There is not even a suggestion that
the appellant had any enmity or motive to commit any offence against the deceased,
leave alone a serious offence like murder. The prosecution case, as seen earlier, is
that the deceased and his wife were guarding their jaggery crop in their field at
around 10 p.m. when their dog started barking at the appellant and his two
companions who were walking along a mud path by the side of the field nearby. It
was the barking of the dog that provoked the appellant to beat the dog with the rod
that he was carrying apparently to protect himself against being harmed by any stray
dog or animal. The deceased took objection to the beating of the dog without in the
least anticipating that the same would escalate into a serious incident in the heat of
the moment. The exchange of hot words in the quarrel over the barking of the dog
led to a sudden fight which in turn culminated in the deceased being hit with the rod
unfortunately on a vital part like the head.
11.2. Secondly, because the weapon used was not lethal nor was the deceased given
a second blow once he had collapsed to the ground. The prosecution case is that no
sooner the deceased fell to the ground on account of the blow on the head, the
appellant and his companions took to their heels a circumstance that shows that the
appellant had not acted in an unusual or cruel manner in the prevailing situation so
as to deprive him of the benefit of Exception 4.
11.3. Thirdly, because during the exchange of hot words between the deceased and
the appellant all that was said by the appellant was that if the deceased did not keep
quiet even he would be beaten like a dog. The use of these words also clearly shows
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TARUN KUMAR
SALUNKE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
17:51:24
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91615
8 CRA-5169-2017
that the intention of the appellant and his companions was at best to be labour him
and not to kill him as such. The cumulative effect of all these circumstances, in our
opinion, should entitle the appellant to the benefit of Exception 4 to Section 300
IPC.”
14. In view of the aforesaid judicial pronouncement by the Apex Court
as well as this Court, the present Criminal Appeal is partly allowed. So far as
the culpability of the appellant is concerned, the same is maintained, but the
conviction is altered to Section 304 Part I of the IPC instead of Section 302
of the IPC and accordingly, the sentence is reduced from Life Imprisonment
to the period already undergone and the fine amount is hereby maintained.
The appellant be released from jail after depositing the fine amount, if he is
not required to be kept in jail in any other case.
15. Record of the trial Court be sent back along with a copy of this
judgment.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
(AMIT LAHOTI)
JUDGE
JUDGE
tarun
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: TARUN KUMAR
SALUNKE
Signing time: 19-11-2026
17:51:24