sanjiv Chaturvedi vs SH. R K SUDHANSU, IAS, PRINCIPAL SECRETARY FOREST GOVERNMENT OF UTTARAKHAND

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
CIRCUIT SITTING AT NAINITAL


C.P. No.813/2026
in
O.A. No.2276/2026

Reserved on: 17.11.2026
Pronounced on: 20.11.2026

(Through Video Conferencing)

Hon’ble Mr. Justice M. G. Sewlikar, Member (J)
Hon’ble Mr. Rajinder Kashyap, Member (A)

Sanjiv Chaturvedi, IFS,
Chief Conservator of Forest/Director (Forest Training
Academy), House No.D1, Forest Training Institute,
Rampur Road, Haldwani-263139.

…Applicant

(Applicant-in-person)

Versus


Shri R. K. Sudhansu, IAS,
Principal Secretary (Forest),
Government of Uttarakhand,
Uttarakhand Secretariat,
4-Subash Road, Dehradun,
Uttarakhand-248001.

…Respondent


(By Advocate: Ms. Ishita Bisht)
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

2

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

ORDER

Per: Justice M. G. Sewlikar, Member (J):

The original applicant in Original Application
(O.A.)No.2276/2026 has filed the present Contempt
Petition (C.P.). The facts leading to this C.P. are as under:
The applicant has filed the aforesaid O.A. alleging that
the reporting and the reviewing authority have awarded
grading of 9.74 to the applicant in the APAR for the period
st st
from 01 May 2024 to 31 March 2025. Respondent No.2,
i.e., the Principal Secretary (Forest), Government of
Uttarakhand, Uttarakhand Secretariat and respondent
no.3, who is impleaded in person, being the Principal
Secretary (Forest) Uttarakhand Secretariat downgraded it
to 9.30 though respondent no.3 had recorded complete
agreement with remarks made by Respondent No. 4, i.e.,
the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (HoFF),
Uttarakhand, Dehradun. The applicant has alleged malice
against respondent nos. 2 and 3 contending that the then
HoFF, Uttarakhand had sent two cases for initiation of
th
disciplinary proceedings against a junior officer on 18
October 2025 on the serious charges of use of
indecent/intemperate language against the applicant in
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

3

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

official communication for the purpose of character
assassination and humiliation and in the second matter on
the charges of pressurizing the field staff for making false
complaints against the applicant and for inciting them to
go on strike.
The applicant has further alleged that Respondent No.
2/3 deliberately kept both the above matters pending,
instead of sending the same to the Hon’ble Chief Minister
for approval for initiation of disciplinary proceedings and
thereby facilitated promotion of the said junior officer. He
has further alleged that the said junior officer was
st
promoted on 31 December 2025 thereby encouraging,
abetting and rewarding indiscipline and humiliation
against the applicant. The applicant in the O.A. has sought
the following reliefs:
“a. To pass appropriate order, expunging the grading of 9.3, as
recorded by Accepting Authority (R2/R3) into APAR of
Applicant, for the period 01.05.2024 to 31.03.2025 and to
declare the same as ab initio null and void (Annexure-13), in
view of being completely arbitrary, unreasoned and being
recorded by an officer of lower level of pay matrix, as compared
to Reviewing Authority and to declare grading of 9.74 recorded
by Reviewing Authority (and also by Reporting Authority), to be
final grading for APAR of Applicant, for the period 01.05.2024
to 31.03.2025, for all the intent and purposes;
b. To allow this O.A. with costs; and
c. To pass any other order as fit in fact and circumstances of
this case.”
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

4

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026


2. On 17th June, 2026, this Tribunal passed the
following order:
“The Registry is directed to allot an OA number to the present
matter. The office objection raised by the Registry stands
removed, being of a technical nature.
Heard the applicant, who is present in person.
The present OA has been filed for expunging the grading of
9.30 recorded by the Accepting Authority into the APAR of the
applicant for the period from 01.05.2024 to 31.03.2025. The
grievance of the applicant is that the Reporting Authority and
the Reviewing Authority had awarded a higher grading of 9.74
for the said period, which was subsequently downgraded by the
Accepting Authority.
It is submitted by the applicant that no reasons have been
assigned by the Accepting Authority for such downgrading of
the grading recorded by the Reporting Authority and the
Reviewing Authority. The applicant contends that in the
absence of any recorded reasons, the impugned downgrading is
arbitrary and unsustainable in law.
Issue notice to the respondents, returnable within six weeks.
The respondents shall file their counter reply within six weeks.
Rejoinder, if any, may be filed within two weeks thereafter.”

3. The applicant contends that the respondents have
filed the affidavit of Shri Himanshu Khurana, son of Shri
Shyam Sunder Khurana, presently posted as Additional
Secretary, Forest Department, Government of Uttarakhand,
Dehradun. He contends that in the Original Application,
the applicant has imputed personal mala fides, personal
bias, and personal knowledge to Respondent no. 3 Shri
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

5

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

R.K. Sudhansu, IAS. The applicant impleaded him eo
nomine as a respondent separately, in addition to the office
of Principal Secretary, Forest (Respondent No. 2).
4. He has further alleged in the Contempt Petition that
vide order dated 17th June, 2026, notice was issued to
each of the respondents, calling upon Respondent No. 3 to
answer the allegations of personal mala fides levelled
against him within six weeks, which expired on or about
29th July, 2026. He contends that in purported compliance
with the said order, a single common counter affidavit has
been filed on behalf of Respondent Nos. 1, 2, and 3 by the
said Shri Himanshu Khurana. Respondent No. 3 has not
filed any affidavit of his own and has not personally
answered the allegations made against him by name. This
conduct of the respondent constitutes wilful disobedience
of the order of this Tribunal dated 17th June, 2026, and
therefore action under Section 12 of the Contempt of
Courts Act, 1971 needs to be initiated against the
respondent.
5. When this Contempt Petition was listed for hearing on
21st September, 2026, the following order was passed by
this Tribunal:
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

6

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

“1. The applicant appears in person and submits that the
present C.P. has been filed alleging wilful defiance of the
directions of this Tribunal dated 17.06.2026 passed in O.A. No.
2276/2026. The relevant paragraphs of the order dated
17.06.2026 read as under:
“Issue notice to the respondents, returnable within six
weeks. The respondents shall file their counter reply
within six weeks. Rejoinder, if any, may be filed within
two weeks thereafter.”
2. The contention of the applicant is that four respondents
were originally impleaded in O.A. No. 2276/2026. However,
according to the applicant, he has not been supplied a copy of
the counter reply stated to have been filed by one Shri R.K.
Sudhansu. It is further contended that the said respondent is
bound by the order dated 17.06.2026.
3. No reply on behalf of the respondents/contemnors is found
on record.
4. Prima facie, there does not appear to be any wilful defiance
of the order dated 17.06.2026. The applicant appearing in
person has, however, argued the present C.P. for some time but
was not keen to explain as to what constitutes the alleged
wilful disobedience of the aforesaid order on the part of the
respondents. Instead, he has continued to refer to and argue
certain judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
5. It is made clear to the applicant appearing in person that he
has to argue the issue involved in the present CP and if there is
any requirement of placing reliance of the judgments of the
Hon'ble Constitutional Court that would follow. However, the
applicant remained adamant in pursuing the said submissions.
6. After hearing the matter for some time, Hon’ble Mr. Rajveer
Singh Verma, Member (J), is recusing himself from hearing this
matter.
7. The Registry is directed to list the matter before the
appropriate Bench and notify the same.”

6. We have heard the applicant, who has appeared in
person.
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

7

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

7. The applicant in person has submitted that vide order
dated 17th June, 2026, notice was issued to the
respondents calling upon them to file a counter reply
within six weeks. He has contended that the respondents
have filed a single common counter affidavit sworn by the
Additional Secretary, Forest Department, Government of
Uttarakhand. The respondent has not personally answered
a single allegation made against him by the applicant. He
submitted that the said affidavit has been filed beyond
three weeks of the period of six weeks fixed by this
Tribunal. He further contended that the verification of the
counter affidavit is not in tune with the rules, as it does not
mention which paragraphs are true to the knowledge of the
deponent and which paragraphs are based on legal advice.
The clause identifying the deponent, which is required to be
signed by an advocate, has been left blank. The document
bears no date beyond “August, 2026”. Therefore, this is not
an affidavit in the eye of law. He contended that non-filing
of reply amounts to contempt of the order of the Tribunal.
To buttress his submission, he has placed reliance on the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pratibha
Kashyap v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Others , 2026 SCC
OnLine SC 1105.
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

8

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

8. He invited our attention to paragraph 12 of the
Contempt Petition, in which observations made by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in S. Pratap Singh v. State of
Punjab, (1964) 4 SCR 733, have been cited. He invited our
attention to the following observations of the Supreme
Court in the case of S. Pratap Singh (supra):
“14….In these circumstances we do not think it would be
proper to brush aside the allegations made by the Applicant,
particularly in respect of those matters where they are
supported by some evidence of a documentary nature seeing
that there is no contradiction by those persons who alone could
have contradicted them. In making this observation we have in
mind the Chief Minister as well as Mrs. Kairon against whom
allegations have been made but who have not chosen to state
on oath the true facts according to them .”

9. Further, he has invited our attention to the following
observations made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in R. P.
Kapur and Others v. Sardar Pratap Singh Kairon and
Others , 1960 SCC OnLine SC 122:
“…..An affidavit from the Chief Minister would have cleared
much of the doubt which, in the absence of such an affidavit
arose in this case."

10. He has further invited our attention to observations of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of C.S. Rowjee v.
State of Andhra Pradesh , 1964 SCC OnLine SC 71, in
which it is observed thus:
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

9

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

“18…..There has been no denial by the Chief Minister nor an
affidavit by any person who claims or can claim to know
personally about the truth about these allegations. The
Secretary to the Home Department — one Mr S.A. Iyengar has
filed a counter affidavit in which the allegations we have set out
earlier have been formally denied. He says, "I have been
expressly instructed and authorised by the Hon'ble the Chief
Minister to state that the allegations suggesting personal
animus and giving mandate are false and mischievous and
have been deliberately made to create an atmosphere of
sympathy". The learned Advocate-General did not suggest that
the Court could act upon this second-hand denial by the Chief
Minister, as the statement by Shri S.A. Iyengar is merely
heresay. We are, therefore, constrained to hold that the
allegations that the Chief Minister was motivated by bias and
personal ill-will against the appellants, stands unrebutted.”

11. He has contended that in paragraph 11 of the counter
affidavit filed on behalf of Respondent Nos. 1, 2, and 3,
averments are made to the following effect:
“That in regard to the present matter, it is submitted that the
grading of 9.30 recorded by the Accepting Authority (R2/R3) is
neither arbitrary nor without basis and is squarely within the
scope of the powers vested in the Accepting Authority under
the AIS (PAR) Rules, 2007. The Applicant cannot claim any
vested or enforceable right to have the grading awarded by the
Reporting/Reviewing Authorities mechanically retained by the
Accepting Authority. The statutory scheme itself contemplates
assessment at different levels and permits the Accepting
Authority to make an independent assessment of the
performance of the officer.”

12. He submitted that Shri Himanshu Khurana cannot
make such averments and only the respondent himself can
make such averments. He therefore contended that notice
be issued to the respondent in the Contempt Petition.
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

10

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

13. He further submitted that upon recusal by one of the
Hon'ble Members, no other observations ought to have
been made, but those observations have nonetheless been
made.
14. We have given thoughtful consideration to the
submissions made by the applicant in person.
15. While passing the order dated 21st September, 2026,
this Tribunal observed in paragraph (3) that no reply on
behalf of the respondents/contemnors was found on
record. According to the applicant, the issuance of notice is
itself a command to the respondent Shri R K Sudhansu to
file an affidavit of his own, and he cannot delegate this
function to any other officer, especially when the said Shri
Himanshu Khurana is junior to the applicant.
16. It appears that the applicant has filed the affidavit in
original application which he received on his email ID
forwarded by the respondents. As indicated above, in
paragraph (3) of the order dated 21st September, 2026,
there is an observation that the reply is not on record,
which means that there was no reply in the original
st
application as on 21 Sept 2026.
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

11

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

17. The order dated 17th June, 2026 quoted hereinabove
shows that it was a usual order calling upon the
respondents to file a reply. Non-filing of reply will not
constitute contempt of court.
18. In Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971,
“contempt” is defined as under:
“civil contempt" means wilful disobedience to any judgment,
decree, direction, order, writ or other process of a court or
willful breach of an undertaking given to a court;

19. This shows that in order to constitute civil contempt,
there has to be wilful disobedience of the order passed by
the Tribunal. In the case at hand, the Tribunal had issued
notice to the respondents calling upon them to file a reply.
If any of the respondents chooses not to file a reply,
he/she/it will be doing so at his/her/its own peril. Non-
filing of reply will constitute contempt only when there is a
specific direction to any person/officer to file affidavit in the
administration of justice. Filing reply is an opportunity
accorded to the respondents to present his/their defence. If
he chooses not to use that opportunity, he loses his right to
rebut the claim of the petitioner/applicant to put up his
defence. Not exercising the right cannot be crossed into
contempt.
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

12

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

20. The applicant had placed heavy reliance on the case of
Pratibha Kashyap (supra) in support of his contention that
non-filing of a reply amounts to contempt. We do not agree
with his submissions. In the case of Pratibha Kashyap
(supra), the facts were totally different. In that case, a
specific direction was given to the impleaded party to
submit an explanation, and that order was violated. We
would like to reproduce the relevant portion of the order in
the case of Pratibha Kashyap (supra) as under:
“2. At the outset, we would note that by our earlier order dated
16.04.2026, the Director, All India Institute of Medical Sciences
(hereinafter referred to as "AIIMS") was impleaded as party
respondent no. 3. He was further directed to submit an
explanation and the matter was directed to be listed today.
3. We find that an affidavit has been filed by way of an
explanation and it is contended in the affidavit that it is in
compliance and in response to the order dated 16.04.2026. The
most objectionable part of the said affidavit is that one Nishant
Kumar, who claims to be working as Deputy Secretary, AIIMS,
New Delhi, is the person who has been authorised to file the
affidavit. We pause here to indicate that we had specifically
sought explanation to be furnished by Director, AIIMS and it is
not within the discretion of any person to submit his/her
explanation by authorising someone else to do the same.
4. In the present case, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent no. 3 submits that there is no permanent Director
in AIIMS, New Delhi as of now. On a query, as to when, the
previous Director demitted the office, the reply is that about
two-three weeks back. On a further query, as to why, the
person currently holding the charge of Director has not filed
the explanation, the answer is that he is only in temporary
capacity.
5. We are not only surprised but shocked at the said response.
Any person who is on a post, either in substantive capacity or
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

13

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

in acting capacity, has to take responsibility and perform the
duty of the post held by him/her in whatever capacity it may
be. We will not give benefit of doubt to the present
Director/Acting Director of any ignorance. Accordingly, in the
Court's tentative view, the present Acting Director, AIIMS, New
Delhi has committed contempt. Accordingly, Dr. Nikhil Tandon,
Acting Director, AIIMS, New Delhi is impleaded as party
respondent no. 4. Notice in contempt is issued against him.
Cause title be amended accordingly. He shall be personally
present along with his explanation on the next date of listing
i.e., 07.07.2026 at 12: Noon, treating it as part-heard.”

21. From these observations of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, it is clear that by the order dated 16th April, 2026,
the Director, All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS)
was impleaded as party Respondent No. 3 and was directed
to submit an explanation. We further find that an affidavit
had been filed by way of an explanation by one Nishant
Kumar, claiming to be the Deputy Secretary, AIIMS, New
Delhi, who was authorized to file the affidavit. The
observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court further indicate
that the Hon’ble Supreme Court had specifically sought an
explanation to be furnished by the Director, AIIMS, and it
was not within the discretion of any person to submit
his/her explanation by authorizing someone else to do the
same. In this background, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that there was contempt of its order. For this reason,
decision in Pratibha Kashyap case (supra) has no
application to the facts of this case.
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

14

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

22. In the case at hand, a usual order of notice was
passed calling upon all the respondents in the Original
Application, including the respondents in this Contempt
Petition. If Respondent No. 3 had been specifically directed
to file a reply and had violated the order of the Tribunal,
this could have constituted contempt. But this is not the
factual situation here. In these circumstances, we find that
there is no contempt. If the submissions of the applicant
are to be accepted, in that case, in every application in
which reply is not filed, contempt action will have to be
initiated. Contempt of court action can be initiated only
when there is willful disobedience. Non filing of reply
cannot be termed as disobedience, much less willful
disobedience.
23. The observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
mentioned in the Contempt Petition also show that non-
filing of an affidavit by the respondent against whom
allegations of malice are made would amount to non-
traversing of the allegations made in the application. The
applicant could not point out any observation in the cases
of R.P. Kapur , S. Pratap Singh , and C.S. Rowjee to the
effect that non-filing of reply is contempt of the order of the
Court. If no reply is filed, the consequence will be
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV

15

Item No.01 (C-1) C.P. No.813/2026

admission of allegations made in the application. Non filing
of reply in the facts and circumstances of the case at hand
cannot be transformed into contempt of order of this
Tribunal.
24. Hence, in our considered opinion, notice is also not
required to be issued as there is no contempt. The
contempt petition is, therefore, dismissed. No costs.


(Rajinder Kashyap) (Justice M. G. Sewlikar)
Member (A) Member (J)




/yy/
PRINCIPAL BENCH, OU=Central Administrative Tribunal PRINCIPAL
Bench, PostalCode=110001, L= Central Delhi, S=Delhi, STREET="
61/35, COPERNICUS MARG, NEW
DELHI 110001", Phone= 83adb11718fb7b39906534c3b0931
bebbe6cca1caf80f9d70a44adbceedf 0ddf, SERIALNUMBER=
875f17e46115f4929118cd40b8a596 d46b65e2cb74f3efe11079d869ece1
abc3, E=yakshyadav97@ gmail.com, CN=YAKSH YADAV
Reason: I am the author of this
YAKSH
YADAV