ZAHIDA MUSHTAQ vs UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K TH.SECRETARY TO GAD AND ORS

Court
Jammu and Kashmir High Court

HIGH COURT OF JAMMU &KASHMIR AND LADAKH AT
SRINAGAR
Reserved on: 05.11.2026
Pronounced on: 20.11.2026
Uploaded on: 21.11.2026
Whether the operative part or full
judgment is pronounced: Full
WP(C) No.2376/2025
ZAHIDA MUSHTAQ
...PETITIONER(S)
Through: - Mr. M. Y. Bhat, Sr. Advocate, with
Mr. Shabir Ahmad, Advocate,
Mr. Sajid Ahmad, Advocate.
Vs.

UT OF J&K AND ORS. …RESPONDENT(S)
Through: - None for R1 to R3.
Mr. Shuja-ul-Haq, Advocate-for R4 & R5
Mr. N. A. Beigh, Sr. Advocate, with
Mr. Sofi Manzoor, Advocate-for R12
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY DHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
1) The petitioner, through the medium of present petition,
has challenged communication dated 28.07.2025 issued by
respondent No. 5, whereby Chief Manager, Retail Sales, of
M/S Indian Oil Corporation Limited has been directed to
deposit penalty amount of Rs.2,50,000/- in view of
energizing of fuel station located at Ch.270+040 (LHS)
without obtaining final NOC from the Highway
Administration. A further direction for de-energization of the
operations of the aforesaid retail outlet till grant of final NOC
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 1 of 17

has also been issued vide the said communication. Besides
this, the petitioner has also sought a direction upon
respondent Nos.4 and 5 to grant final NOC for access
permission with a further direction to all the respondents for
removal of unauthorized occupation/encroachment of
National Highway land by implementation of Control of
National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002.
2) As per case of the petitioner, she has established a fuel
outlet of M/S Indian Oil Corporation under the name and
style of ‘M/S Fatima Filling Station’ after obtaining necessary
clearances from the competent authority as required under
the Petroleum Act, 1934, and the Petroleum Rules, 2002.
Thereafter, the petitioner obtained access permission from
National Highway Authority through Indian Oil Corporation
for establishing the fuel outlet on Khasra Nos. 7489, 7190,
7492 and 7493 of Village Letpora, Tehsil Pampore, after
obtaining necessary permissions including explicit access
rights from National Highway Authority of India vide
reference permission letter No.NHAI/RO-Jammu/2013/
11051/NOC/395 dated 25.02.2021. In terms of the said
communication, the petitioner was granted right to use an
approach road carved out of land owned and maintained by
NHAI connecting the fuel outlet directly to the National
Highway for seamless vehicular access.
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 2 of 17

3) It has been submitted that National Highway Authority
has issued various notices to the District Administration for
removal of encroachment on National Highway land by some
shopkeepers and locals who have encroached upon the
National Highway land adjacent to the petitioner's fuel
outlet. It has been submitted that these persons, without
having any legal claim or authority over the land of the
National Highway Authority, are creating law and order
problem for highway authorities who are trying to remove the
encroachments. The petitioner has placed on record
communications addressed by her as well as by the Indian
Oil Corporation to National Highway Authority seeking
removal of encroachment on the access road from National
Highway land to the fuel outlet established by the petitioner.
4) It has been submitted that the Supreme Court in the
Gyan Prakash vs. Union of India
case of (WP(C) No.1272 of
2019) has issued general directions on 20.02.2024 for
removal of encroachment of National Highways and in this
regard, a communication has been issued to all the Chief
Secretaries for compliance of the order passed by the
Supreme Court. It has further been submitted that National
Highway Authority has framed guidelines and norms for
grant of permission for construction of access to fuel
stations, wayside amenities, connecting roads from other
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 3 of 17

properties, rest area complexes and such other facilities
through circular dated 26.06.2020 and as per para 2.11 of
the said circular, penalty has been stipulated for operating a
fuel station without obtaining the prior permission for grant
of access and under this circular, the impugned
communication has been issued by the National Highway
Authority.
5) The petitioner has challenged the impugned action of
the respondents on the grounds that the final access
permission to her could not be granted because of the illegal
encroachments on the National Highway land, which the
respondents have been unable to remove, therefore, no
penalty could have been imposed upon the petitioner, who
has otherwise been subjected to harassment and loss. It has
been submitted that the petitioner has invested her time,
money and labour for operation of the petrol pump, but the
respondents, without any justification, are delaying to
consider her request for removal of encroachment and grant
of final NOC for access permission, which is in clear violation
of her constitutional rights.
6) During the pendency of the writ petition, an application
was made by one Zaffar Ahmad Lone seeking his
impleadment as a party to the writ petition. The said
application was allowed by this Court and Zaffar Ahmad
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 4 of 17

Lone was impleaded as respondent No.12 to the present writ
petition and he was permitted to file his reply to the writ
petition.
7) In his reply to the writ petition, respondent No. 12 has
raised a preliminary objection to the maintainability of the
writ petition on the ground that the said respondent had filed
a writ petition bearing WP(C) No.1919 of 2025, in which the
petitioner was impleaded as a respondent, and vide the said
writ petition, respondent No.12 had challenged the
installation of petroleum retail outlet by the petitioner on
various grounds, including the ground that the outlet has
been installed in violation of the rules and guidelines. It has
been submitted that the said writ petition came to be
disposed of by this Court in terms of order dated 12.08.2025,
whereby the official respondents, particularly the District
Magistrate, Pulwama, was directed to examine all the
requisite NOCs and in case it was found that the petitioner
has got all the requisite NOCs, only then she should be
allowed to operate the retail outlet, otherwise she should not
be allowed to operate the same. It has been submitted that
this material fact has been suppressed by the petitioner,
hence the present writ petition deserves to be dismissed on
this ground alone.
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 5 of 17

8) On merits, it has been submitted that till date the
petitioner has not got all the requisite NOCs, including the
final NOC from National Highway Authority, as such, she
cannot operate the petrol pump. It has been submitted that
pursuant to order dated 12.08.2025 passed in WP(C)
No.1919/2025, the District Magistrate, Pulwama, has held
a detailed enquiry, whereafter the said authority has
observed that the petitioner is operating the petrol pump in
violation of the rules and guidelines, but because of interim
order passed by this Court on 26.09.2025, the District
Magistrate has expressed his inability to proceed further in
the matter. It has been further submitted that the petrol
pump of the petitioner is situated in close proximity of
residential house of respondent No. 12, which is less than
50 meters away from the petrol pump, therefore, the
permission to operate the petrol pump cannot be granted in
her favour. It has also been submitted that the license in
respect of the petitioner's retail outlet has expired on
31.12.2025 and the same has not been renewed. According
to respondent No.12, there are a number of residential
houses and shops existing in close proximity of the petrol
pump set up by the petitioner, and these residential and
commercial structures cannot be demolished in order to
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 6 of 17

permit the petitioner to operate the petroleum retail outlet,
which is located in the vicinity of the water body.
9) Respondent National Highway Authority has also filed
its reply to the writ petition, wherein it has been submitted
that the penalty imposed upon Indian Oil Corporation
Limited vide the impugned communication is strictly in
accordance with the applicable policy framework,
particularly para No. 2.11(v) of MoRTH circular No. RW-NH-
33032/01/2017/S&R(R) dated 26.06.2020. It has been
submitted that the said action was necessitated on account
of the fuel station having been energized and commercial
operations having been commenced without obtaining the
final NOC from the Highway Administration. It has been
submitted that the petitioner has, admittedly, deposited the
penalty amount on 31.07.2025, hence she is debarred from
challenging the impugned communication.
10) It has been submitted that on account of inaction of the
authorities of District Administration in removing the
encroachment on the National Highway land, which has
been caused by third party interference, the final access
permission to the petitioner could not be granted. It has been
submitted that respondent Nos.4 and 5 have consistently
taken up the matter with regard to removal of
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 7 of 17

encroachments on National Highway land with District
Administration and the police authorities, but the said
authorities have failed to take necessary action for removal
of the encroachments. Respondent Nos.4 and 5 have referred
to various communications addressed to District Magistrate
and other authorities for removal of encroachment on the
National Highway land.
11) In any case, the petitioner or Indian Oil Corporation
could not have energized the petrol pump without obtaining
final access permission from National Highway Authority. It
has been submitted that the permission, which was granted
in favour of Indian Oil Corporation, was provisional in nature
and it was subject to compliances within the prescribed
conditions and completion of approved access/service layer.
It has been submitted that on the basis of provisional
permission, the petrol pump could not have been energized.
12) I have heard learned counsel for the parties and
considered the material on record.
13) As already stated, respondent No.12 has raised a
preliminary objection with regard to maintainability of the
writ petition on the ground that the petitioner has
suppressed order dated 12.08.2025 passed by this Court in
WP(C) No.1919/2025. To support this contention, learned
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 8 of 17

Senior Counsel appearing for respondent No.12 has placed
heavy reliance upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in
the case of K. D. Sharma vs. Steel Authority of India
Limited and others , (2008) 12 SCC 481.
14) It is an admitted fact that respondent No.12 had filed a
writ petition against the petitioner and official respondents
before this Court, challenging the installation of petrol pump
by the petitioner on the ground that she has been permitted
to operate the petrol pump without obtaining all requisite no
objection certificates from concerned departments and
without adhering to the rules and guidelines on the subject.
The said writ petition came to be disposed of by this Court
on 12.08.2025 with the following directions:
04. Therefore, this writ petition is disposed of at its very
inception stage with a direction to the District Magistrate,
Pulwama to examine all the requisite NOCs of the
respondent No. 11 and if found complete valid and
effective for enabling him to commence and carry on with
the business of Retail Petrol Pump then to allow the same
by passing an order bearing reasons and if not then also
to pass an order bearing reasons.
05. Petitioner shall also be entitled to place his
objections with respect to the NOCs as has come to be
procured and presented by the respondent No. 11 to
show that all the requisite NOCs are not at the disposal
of respondent No. 11 with respect to the Petrol Pump.
06. Needful to be done within a period of one month.
07. One month period to commence from the date a copy
of this order gets delivered by the respondent No. 11 to
the District Magistrate, Pulwama.
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 9 of 17

15) From a perusal of the aforesaid order, it is clear that
District Magistrate, Pulwama, was mandated to examine all
the requisite NOCs of the petitioner herein, and if the same
were found to be complete and valid, she was to be allowed
to operate the petrol pump, or else a reasoned order was to
be passed in either case.

16) It is true that the aforesaid order has not been brought
to the notice of this Court by the petitioner while filing the
present writ petition. However, the question that arises for
determination is as to whether it was necessary for the
petitioner to bring the aforesaid order to the notice of this
Court by making its mention in the writ petition. As already
stated, the present writ petition has been filed to seek
quashment of communication dated 28.07.2025 issued by
National Highway Authority, whereby penalty of Rs.2.50
lakhs has been imposed upon Indian Oil Corporation, on
whose behalf the petitioner is operating the retail outlet. The
petitioner is also seeking removal of encroachment from the
National Highway land so that she is able to construct access
from the National Highway up to the petrol pump installed
by her. Having regard to the nature of reliefs that are being
sought by the petitioner in the present writ petition, it was
not necessary for the petitioner to make any mention about
the earlier writ petition filed by respondent No.12 against her
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 10 of 17

and other official respondents. Imposition of penalty upon
the petitioner is an unrelated development. Therefore, non-
disclosure of filing of earlier writ petition by respondent
No.12 against the petitioner and other official respondents is
not a material fact, the concealment of which would non-suit
the petitioner.

17) However, it would have been prudent for the petitioner
to bring to the notice of this Court order dated 12.08.2025
passed in WP(C) No.1919/2025 at least at the time of
obtaining interim order dated 26.09.2025, whereby it was
directed that the petitioner's running of petrol pump at the
sanctioned place shall not be disturbed. By not bringing the
earlier order to the notice of this Court, two apparently
conflicting orders came into existence, which has put the
District Magistrate, Pulwama, in quandary, inasmuch as,
despite having noticed certain deficiencies in the
compliances made by the petitioner, he was unable to stop
the operation of the petrol pump in view of interim order
dated 26.09.2025. This situation could have been avoided if
the petitioner would have at least brought to the notice of
the Court at the time of passing of order dated 26.09.2025
the order passed in the earlier writ petition, whereby the
District Magistrate was obliged to first enquire into the
compliances made by the petitioner and thereafter allow her
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 11 of 17

to operate the petrol pump. The later order dated 26.09.2025
passed in this writ petition is a blanket direction permitting
the petitioner to operate the petrol pump at the sanctioned
place. In any case, order dated 10.12.2025 passed by the
Deputy Commissioner, Pulwama on the basis of interim
order dated 26.09.2025 has been put on hold by this Court
in terms of order dated 30.09.2026. Therefore, the situation
stands remedied.
18) That takes us to the merits of the case. In this behalf
the relevant guidelines are required to be noted. As per
guidelines for grant of permission for construction of access
to Fuel Stations, etc. issued by the Government of India,
Ministry of Road Transport and Highways vide
communication dated 26.06.2020, particularly para 2.3
thereof, the persons requiring and applying for access to
National Highway have to submit a self-certified proposal for
obtaining access permission to the concerned authority to
whom such highway is entrusted. It further provides that in
case the execution of access is not carried out as per the
prescribed norms, the fuel station shall be de-energized and
access of fuel station/property shall also be disconnected.
Para 2.5.2 of the said guidelines provides that the Highway
Administration shall issue provisional permission or reject
the application within 15 days after receipt of comments
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 12 of 17

from field officers. It further provides that the fuel station
shall not be energized during the intervening period of
provisional permission and grant of regular access
permission. Para 2.6 of the guidelines provides that Regional
Officer of the Ministry may grant one year extension to the
validity of provisional permission for access based on
justifications for delay submitted by the applicant. As per
para 2.11(v), penalty of Rs. 2,50,000/- has been provided for
operating energized fuel station without obtaining prior
permission for grant of access from the Highway
Administration.
19) From the aforesaid guidelines, which are mandatory in
nature, it is clear that on the basis of a provisional access
permission, a fuel station cannot be energized and it is only
after grant of regular access permission that a fuel station
can be energized. It is also clear that in case a fuel station is
energized without obtaining final permission for grant of
access from Highway Administration, the defaulter has to
pay a penalty of Rs.2,50,000/-.
20) In the present case, the petitioner has, admittedly, not
obtained the final access permission and without obtaining
the said permission, the Indian Oil Corporation has
energized the petrol pump being operated by the petitioner.
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 13 of 17

Therefore, respondent National Highway Authority is legally
justified in imposing penalty upon the Indian Oil
Corporation by way of the impugned communication. It is
true that the petitioner has not been able to construct access
to her petrol pump because of reasons not attributable to
her, but because of the fact that neither National Highway
Authority nor the District Administration has been able to
remove encroachment on the National Highway land.
However, the petitioner cannot proceed to operate her petrol
pump without waiting for removal of encroachment and
without construction of access to the petrol pump. Doing so
would be violative of the guidelines issued by the Ministry of
Road Transport and Highways. The fact that the petitioner
has been unable to construct access to her petrol pump for
the reasons not attributable to her may offer a justification
for her to seek extension of provisional access permission
and to pray for further time to construct the access to the
petrol pump until the encroachment is removed, but without
constructing the access to the petrol pump, the same cannot
be energized in any circumstances whatsoever.
21) So far as the grievance of respondent No.12 is
concerned, the District Magistrate is already seized of the
matter and after passing of interim direction by this Court
on 30.09.2026, whereby earlier order dated 10.12.2025
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 14 of 17

passed by the Deputy Commissioner, Pulwama, has been
kept in abeyance, it would be open to the said officer to hold
an enquiry into the compliances made by the petitioner for
installation of the petrol pump and if it is found that she has
complied with the necessary requirements, she has to be
allowed to operate the petrol pump and in case there is any
deficiency, she has to be given an opportunity to make good
those deficiencies. If she fails to do so, then the petrol pump
installed by her has to be shut down.
22) This Court would not like to go into the merits of the
rival contentions on the issue as to whether necessary
compliances have been made by the petitioner for
installation of the petrol pump, as the same is a subject
matter which has to be gone into by the District
Magistrate/Deputy Commissioner, Pulwama, while
proceeding in the matter in terms of order dated 12.08.2025
passed in WP(C) No.1919 of 2025.
23) Yet another aspect that is required to be deliberated
upon is with regard to the alleged encroachments on the
National Highway land. There are a series of
communications addressed by National Highway Authority
and Indian Oil Corporation to the District Administration
seeking removal of encroachment on the National Highway
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 15 of 17

land. Whether the said encroachment has been made by
respondent No.12 or any other person, the same has to be
removed in accordance with law by following the mandate
prescribed in Control of National Highways (Land and
Traffic) Act, 2002, particularly the provisions contained in
Chapter IV of the said Act. Needless to mention here that the
District Magistrate is the authority vested with powers under
Sections 26, 27, 36 and 43 of the aforesaid Act to facilitate
swift removal of the encroachments on National Highway
land. Therefore, in terms of the directions passed by the
Supreme Court in the case of Gyan Prakash vs. Union of
India and the instructions issued to the States pursuant
thereto, the District Magistrate, Pulwama, is duty bound to
ensure that all the encroachments existing on the land of the
National Highway which prevent construction of access to
the petrol pump of the petitioner have to be removed.
24) For what has been discussed hereinabove, the writ
petition is disposed of in the following terms:
(I) The imposition of penalty upon Indian Oil Corporation
in terms of the impugned communication dated
28.07.2025 is upheld.

(II) The District Magistrate/Deputy Commissioner,
Pulwama, is directed to hold an enquiry into the issue
as to whether the petitioner has installed the petrol
WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 16 of 17

pump at the sanctioned location in accordance with
the relevant rules and guidelines after having
obtained the requisite NOCs from the concerned
departments.

(III) If, upon holding the enquiry, the District
Magistrate/Deputy Commissioner, Pulwama, comes
to the conclusion that the petitioner has complied
with all the requirements, she shall be allowed to
operate the petrol pump at the sanctioned location,
and if there is any encroachment on the National
Highway land, which prevents construction of access
to the petrol pump of the petitioner, the same shall be
removed by the District Magistrate/Deputy
Commissioner after taking recourse to law.

(IV) Upon construction of access to the petrol pump, the
respondent National Highway Authority shall grant
necessary final access permission to the petitioner
and permit her to energize the petrol pump.
(V) In case, after enquiry, it is found that the petitioner
has not complied with all the requirements, she shall
be given time to make up the deficiencies, and if she
is unable to make up the deficiencies, the petrol
pump installed by her shall be closed down/sealed.
(Sanjay Dhar)
Judge
SRINAGAR
20.11.2026
“Bhat Altaf-Secretary”
Whether the judgment is reportable: YES/NO

WP(C) No.2376/2025 Page 17 of 17