ASHIK MIRZA vs UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Arjun Ray Mukherjee
(Samarpita)
WPA/16926/2024
ASHIK MIRZA
VS
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
For the petitioner : Rabindra Kumar Jaiswal
For the Respondents : Ms. Sayani Roy Chowdhury,
Ms. Biswadeepa Mandal
th
Heard on : 19 November, 2026
th
Judgment on : 19 November, 2026
th
Uploaded on : 19 November, 2026
Arjun Ray Mukherjee, J.
1. The petitioner is an employee of the Central Reserve Police Force.
2. A criminal case was initiated against the petitioner and he was arrested in
connection with the said criminal case by the Dibrugarh Police Station.
3. Subsequently, a disciplinary proceeding was also initiated against the petitioner
under Section 11(1) of the Central Reserve Police Force Act, 1949 (hereinafter
referred to as “the CRPF Act” for short).
th
4. By an order dated 24 December, 2008, the disciplinary authority/the
Commandant, 171 Battalion, CRPF, removed the petitioner from service.
2
th
5. Being aggrieved by the order dated 24 December, 2008, the petitioner preferred
an appeal before the Deputy Inspector General of Police, Siliguri Range.
nd
6. The appellate authority, by an order dated 2 January, 2010, upheld the order
passed by the disciplinary authority and rejected the appeal preferred by the
petitioner.
7. The petitioner thereafter filed a revisional application under Rule 29 of the CRPF
rd
Rules, 1955. The Inspector General of Police, CRPF, by an order dated 3 July,
2010 rejected the revisional application.
th
8. On 30 January, 2017 the learned Court of Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate,
Dibrugarh, by a judgment and order, found the petitioner “not guilty” in
connection with GR Case No. 1118 of 2008.
9. The petitioner filed a writ petition before this Court being WP No. 11726(W) of
2017 challenging the orders passed in connection with the disciplinary
proceeding.
nd
10. A coordinate Bench of this Court, by an order dated 22 June, 2017, dismissed
the said writ petition.
nd
11. Being aggrieved by the order dated 22 June, 2017, the petitioner preferred an
appeal being MAT no. 69 of 2018, which was subsequently renumbered as FMA
350 of 2019.
12. The said appeal was taken up for consideration by a Division Bench of this Court
st
and by a judgment and order dated 31 August, 2023 the Division Bench set aside
the order passed by the learned Single Judge, and remanded the matter back to
the revisional authority for fresh consideration of the issue.
3
st
13. Pursuant to the order dated 31 August, 2023 the Inspector General, CRPF took
th
up the issue and by an order dated 8 November, 2023, found the petitioner
guilty of misconduct. However, the Inspector General, CRPF, having considered
the submissions of the petitioner and the materials on record, also found that the
punishment imposed upon the petitioner was harsh and disproportionate. The
Inspector General, CRPF, inter alia, passed the following order.
“Now Therefore, keeping in view of all aspects of
the case and judgement of SDJM(S), Dibrugarh,
Criminal Court dated 30/01/2017, Hon'ble High
Court of Calcutta order dated 31/08/2023 and
direction of DIG (Law) Dte signal No. J.II-
384/2017-LWP-9 dated 19/09/2023, considering
gravity of offence, socio economic condition, I take
a lenient view and pass following orders to meet
the ends of natural justice....
1) The punishment order dated 24/12/2008 of
"Removal from Service" passed by the disciplinary
authority i.e. Commandant -171 Bn is set aside.
Besides, orders dated 02/01/2010 and 03/07/2010
passed by Appellate authority and Revisioning
authority are hereby set aside.
2) No. 045260757 Ex-Water Carrier Ashik Mirza
of 171 Bn is hereby "re-instated into service" and
awarded punishment of "Stoppage of Annual
Increment for 01 year effective from date of
reporting which will not have the effect of
postponing his future increments of pay” as per Sl.
No. 07 of table, under Rule 27 of CRPF Act & Rule,
1955.
3) The intervening period between the date of
Removal from service i.e, from 24/12/2008 (AN)
and date of his actual joining on re-instatement
shall be treated as “not spent on duty" on the
principle of "No work No pay” in terms of FR 54(5)
However, the break in service for above period is
hereby condoned for the purpose of pension in
terms of Rule 25 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.
4
4) Suspension period wef. 06/07/2008 to
03/10/2008 is hereby treated "AS SUCH".
Suspension period beyond 90 days i.e.
04/10/2008 to 24/12/2008 was to be reviewed by
the disciplinary authority which has not been
done. Therefore, the petitioner is deemed to be
revoked immediately after completion of 90 days
suspension period le. wef. 04/10/2008 to
24/12/2008 in terms of provision of Rule 10 of
CCS(CCA) Rule. Hence, the period from wef.
04/10/2008 to 24/12/2008 shall be treated as
duty.
5) On his reinstatement he is posted to 228 Bn,
CRPF. No. 045260757 Ex-CT/WC Ashik Mirza will
report for duty at 228 Bn within 15 days from the
date of receipt of this order.”
14. The petitioner, by filing this writ petition, has, inter alia, sought for the following
reliefs:
“ (a) A writ in the Mandamus do issue upon the
state respondents to treat his intervening period
between the date of Removal from service i.e. from
24/12/2008 (ΑΝ)and date of his actual joining on
re-instatement as on duty and regulate his pay
and allowances and make payment of full back
wages to the petitioner;
(b) nature A writ in the Certiorari directing the of
state respondents to certify, transmit and to
produce the relevant records of the case before this
Hon'ble Court at the time of hearing, SO that
conscionable justice may be done;”
15. Learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner refers to FR 54(2) of the
Fundamental Rules. He also refers to FR 54 (4) and FR 54(5), which are set out
herein-below:
“(2) Where the authority competent to order
reinstatement is of opinion that the Government
Servant who had been dismissed, removed or
compulsorily retired has been fully exonerated, the
5
Government Servant shall, subject to the
provisions of sub-rule(6), be paid the full pay and
allowances to which he would have been entitled,
had he not been dismissed, removed or
compulsorily retired r suspended prior to such
dismissal, removed or compulsory retirement, as
the case may be…
(4) In cases other than those covered by sub-
rule (2) (including cases where the order of
dismissal, removal or compulsory retirement from
service is set aside by the appellate or reviewing
authority solely on the ground of non-compliance
with the requirements of clause (1) or clause (2) of
Article 311 of the Constitution and no further
inquiry is proposed to be held held the
Government Servant shall, subject to the
provisions of sub-rules (6) and (7), be paid such
amount (not being the whole) of the pay and
allowances to which he would have been entitled,
had he not been dismissed, removed or
compulsorily retired or suspended prior to such
dismissal, removal or compulsory retirement, as
the case may be, as the competent authority may
determine, after giving notice to the Government
Servant of the quantum proposed and after
considering the representation, if any, submitted
by him in that connection within such period
(which in no case shall exceed sixty days from the
date on which the notice has been served) as may
be specified, in the notice.
(5) In a case falling under sub-rule (4), the period
of absence from duty including the period of
suspension preceding his dismissal, removal or
compulsory retirement, as the case may be, shall
not be treated as a period spent on duty, unless the
competent authority specifically directs that it
shall be treated so for any specified purpose:
Provided that if the Government servant so desires
such authority may direct that the period of
absence from duty including the period of
suspension preceding his dismissal, removal of
compulsory retirement, as the case may be, shall
be converted into leave of any kind due and
admissible to the Government servant.”
6
16. Learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner, in support of his contention, also
refers to Rule 16(4) of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964.
17. He relies upon a judgment passed in Appeal No. 4411 of 2011 [ Mithilesh
Kumar Pathak vs. Union of India &Ors. Civil] by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court and submits that the petitioner is entitled to receive back wages from the
th
date of his removal till the date of his joining pursuant to the order dated 8
November, 2023.
18. Per contra , learned Counsel appearing for the respondents submits that the
petitioner is not entitled to receive any back wages in view of FR 54(4). She
th
further submits that there is no procedural infirmity in the order dated 8
November, 2023. In view of the above, she submits that the writ petition is liable
to be dismissed.
19. Heard the parties.
20. FR 54(2) provides that a government servant is entitled to receive full pay and
allowances if he has been fully exonerated. That is the precondition which is
required to be fulfilled for getting such benefit under FR 54(2), whereas, those
cases which are not covered under FR 54(2) are required to be considered by the
competent authority under FGR 54(4), which says that a delinquent employee be
paid such amount (not being the whole) of the pay and allowances to which he
would have been entitled had he not been dismissed, removed or compulsorily
7
retired or suspended prior to such dismissal, removal, or compulsory retirement,
as the case may be, as the competent authority may determine.
21. In the instant case the respondent authority/the Inspector General of CRPF
found the petitioner guilty of misconduct. Therefore, it is not the case of the
petitioner that he has been fully exonerated. Such imposition of punishment has
not been challenged by the petitioner and the same has attained finality. In view
th
of the above, the order dated 8 November, 2023, having not been challenged by
the petitioner, is binding upon him.
22. Moreover, the proviso in Rule 16(4) of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964, is not
applicable to the petitioner’s case at this stage, since the petitioner has not
th
challenged the order dated 8 November, 2023, this Court cannot reopen this
issue on merits.
23. It has not been alleged by the petitioner that there was any procedural
impropriety in the decision-making process. The respondent authority exercised
its discretion in terms of FR 54(4) and FR 54(5) and the same cannot be termed
perverse.
24. The judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for petitioner passed in
Mithilesh Kumar Pathak [supra] is not applicable to the facts and
circumstances of the present case.
8
25. In view of the above, the writ petition being WPA 16926 of 2024 stands
dismissed. There will be no order as to costs.
26. Parties shall act on the server copy of this order.
(Arjun Ray Mukherjee, J.)