BHARATBHAI HIRJIBHAI SHANKAR vs STATE OF GUJARAT
- Court
- Gujarat High Court
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL MISC. APPLICATION (FOR QUASHING & SET
ASIDE FIR/ORDER) NO. 854 of 2018
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. M. RAVAL
================================================
Approved for Reporting Yes No
√
================================================
BHARATBHAI HIRJIBHAI SHANKAR
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR.
================================================
Appearance:
MR RAJESH K KANANI(2157) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
MR NK MAJMUDAR(430) for the Respondent(s) No. 2
MR KM ANTANI, APP for the Respondent(s) No. 1
================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. M. RAVAL
Date : 07/10/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
1. This application under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure
Code, 1973 (the Code) is filed by the applicant praying to quash
and set aside the FIR being C.R. No. II-1169 of 2017, dated
21.12.2017, registered with Salabatpura Police Station, District:
Surat for the offence punishable under Sections 295A r/w. 114 of
Page 1 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC).
2. Facts of the case are that the de facto complainant was serving
as the President of the Samast Yuva Ambedkar Samaj. About two
to three days prior to lodging of the FIR in question, Akash Ashok
Gaikwad, Prakash Naval Baviskar, and Sunil Madhu Rupvante,
members of his Ambedkar Community, visited the office of the de
facto complainant and informed that Sarees and Textile material
bearing printed images of Lord Gautam Buddha, were being
offered for sale at several premises in the Textile Market and other
shops. Being community representatives, they inspected the said
shops and verified that Sarees and other Textile fabrics bearing
printed impressions of Lord Gautam Buddha were indeed being
sold. The said images of Lord Gautam Buddha were positioned
such that they fall toward the lower portion of the garment (the
feet/border/pallu area). The said act calculated to degrade the
deity and intentionally wounded the religious feelings and
sentiments of their community. Thus, on the said facts, FIR in
question came to be registered.
3. Heard, learned advocates for the respective parties.
3.1 The learned advocate for the applicant would submit that no
prima facie case is made out even if the FIR in question it taken at
face value. It is submitted that false and baseless allegations with
ulterior motive with false implication of the present applicant have
Page 2 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
been made in the FIR.
3.2 The learned advocate for the applicant would further submit
that the applicant is not involved, directly or indirectly, in the
crime in question and no ingredients of the offence alleged i.e.
295A IPC are satisfied so far as the present applicant is concerned.
3.3 It is further submitted that incident in question is dated
19.12.2017 whereas, the FIR in question is lodged on 21.12.2017 i.e.
almost two days after, for which, no plausible explanation is
forthcoming on record and it creates serious doubts about the
credibility of the FIR.
3.4 The learned advocate submitted that present FIR is nothing
but a case of suppression of true and correct facts. He submitted
that the applicant is a reputed businessman of Surat and dealing in
Sarees and dress material under the name of Shivam Textiles. The
applicant procures goods from some manufacturers as per the
latest designs in trend and sells it in market as per requirement.
There was no objectionable prints/material was being sold by the
applicant and that, the prints were not of the God as alleged by the
complainant.
3.5 The learned advocate for the applicant moreover, submitted
that there was no intention on the part of the applicant to hurt the
religious feelings of any class of people and there was no
Page 3 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
deliberate attempt on the part of the applicant to do so and
outrage the religious feelings of any class of people by insulting
religious belief or feelings nor any direct or indirect malicious act
committed by the present applicant so as to attract the provisions
of Section 295A IPC. It is submitted that in fact the de facto
complainant is into the same business and therefore out of
business rivalry and competition, with a view to exert pressure
false FIR has been filed and accordingly, it is urged that this
application may be allowed.
4. Conversely , the learned advocate for the de facto complainant
as well as the learned Additional Public Prosecutor would submit
that from the photographs annexed with the application
themselves it is evident that the allegations levelled in the
impugned FIR are correct and a strong prima facie case is made out
against the present applicant.
4.1 It is submitted that at the stage of quashing application, this
Court may not conduct a mini trial. The learned advocate for the
respondent No. 2 as well as the learned Additional Public
Prosecutor for the respondent – State submitted that as per the
settled law, inherent powers under Section 482 of the Code should
be used sparingly and with a view to curb the abuse of process of
law. It is submitted that in the case on hand, a prima facie case is
made out against the applicant and hence, they requested that it is
ultimately a matter of trial after which, the truth could be churned
Page 4 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
out and hence, it is requested not to entertain this application.
5. Heard, learned advocates for the respective parties and
perused the papers available on record.
6. Prior to assessing the factual matrix on the touchstone of
criminal jurisprudence, it is apposite to reinforce the settled legal
position governing the scope, ambit, and limits of the inherent
jurisdiction vested under Section 482 of the Code. The
jurisprudential parameters regulating the exercise of this
extraordinary power have been authoritatively catalogued by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in a long line of precedents, chief among
them being the authoritative in the case of State of Haryana v.
Bhajan Lal [AIR 1992 SC 604] . Therein, Hon’ble Supreme Court
crystallized seven distinct, illustrative categories of cases where
judicial intervention under Section 482 of the Code or Article 226
of the Constitution is necessitated to secure the ends of justice and
clip any abuse of the process of Court. The relevant portion of
Paragraph 102 of the said judgment is extracted below:
“ 102. In the backdrop of the interpretation of the various relevant
provisions of the Code under Chapter XIV and of the principles of
law enunciated by this Court in a series of decisions relating to the
exercise of the extraordinary power under Article 226 or the
inherent powers under Section 482 of the Code which we have
extracted and reproduced above, we have given the following
categories of cases by way of illustration wherein such power could
be exercised either to prevent abuse of the process of any court or
otherwise to secure the ends of justice, though it may not be
Page 5 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
possible to lay down any precise, clearly defined and sufficiently
channelised and inflexible guidelines or rigid formulae and to give
an exhaustive list of myriad kinds of cases wherein such power
should be exercised.
(1) Where the allegations made in the first information
report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face
value and accepted in their entirety do not prima facie
constitute any offence or make out a case against the
accused.
(2) Where the allegations in the first information report
and other materials, if any, accompanying the FIR do not
disclose a cognizable offence, justifying an investigation by
police officers under Section 156(1) of the Code except under
an order of a Magistrate within the purview of Section
155(2) of the Code.
(3) Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the FIR
or complaint and the evidence collected in support of the
same do not disclose the commission of any offence and make
out a case against the accused.
(4) Where, the allegations in the FIR do not constitute a
cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable
offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer
without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under
Section 155(2) of the Code.
(5) Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint
are so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of
which no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion
that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the
accused.
(6) Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of
the provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which
a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and
continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is a
Page 6 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
specific provision in the Code or the concerned Act,
providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the
aggrieved party.
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended
with mala fide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously
instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on
the accused and with a view to spite him due to private and
personal grudge.”
6.1 Evaluating the present application on the anvil of the
principles enunciated in Bhajan Lal (supra) , this Court has to
determine whether the allegations in the FIR, even when accepted
at face value, satisfy the essential statutory ingredients of Section
295A of the IPC. This Court must ensure that criminal machinery
is not permitted to degenerate into an engine of harassment where
liability under criminal law is completely absent.
6.2 At the outset, it is apt to refer to a decision of the Apex Court
in Mahendra Singh Dhoni v. Yerraguntla Shyamsundar, (2017) 7
SCC 760 = 2017 (0) AIJEL-SC 60295 , wherein, reference was made
to a decision in Ramji Lal Modi v. State of U.P., AIR 1957 SC 620 ,
and observed:
“6. Be it noted, the constitutional validity of Section 295A was
assailed before this Court in Ramji Lal Modi v. State of U.P., AIR
1957 SC 620 which was eventually decided by a Constitution
Bench. The Constitution Bench, adverting to the multiple aspects
and various facets of Section 295A IPC held as follows :-
“8. It is pointed out that section 295A has been included
Page 7 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
in chapter XV of the Indian Penal Code which deals with
offences against the public tranquility and from this
circumstance it is faintly sought to be urged, therefore, that
offences relating to religion have no bearing on the
maintenance of public order, or tranquility and,
consequently, a law creating an offence relating to religion
and imposing restrictions on the right to freedom of speech
and expression cannot claim the protection of clause (2) of
Article 19. A reference to Articles 25 and 26 of the
Constitution, which guarantee the right to freedom of
religion, will show that the argument is utterly untenable.
The right to freedom of religion assured by those Articles is
expressly made subject to public order, morality and health.
Therefore, it cannot be predicated that freedom of religion
can have no bearing whatever on the maintenance of public
order or that a law creating an offence relating to religion
cannot under any circumstances be said to have been enacted
in the interests of public order. These two Articles in terms
contemplate that restrictions may be imposed on the rights
guaranteed by them in the interests of public order.”
6.3 Tested on the anvil of the afore-stated principles, if the facts
of the case on hand are considered, it is amply clear that Section
295A IPC does not contemplate each and every act to be penalised
and every act of insult to or attempt to insult the religion or the
religious beliefs of a class of citizens but it penalises only those acts
of insults to or those varieties of attempts to insult the religion or
the religious beliefs of a class of citizens, which are perpetrated
with the deliberate and malicious intention of outraging the
religious feelings of that class. Insults to religion offered carelessly
or without any deliberate or malicious intention of outraging the
religious feelings of that class do not come within the section.
Thus, when an insult to a religion without any deliberate or
Page 8 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
malicious intention of outraging the religion feelings does not fall
within the purview of that section. However, as held by the
Constitutional Bench in the decision in Ramji Lal Modi (supra) ,
the said provision only punishes the aggravated form of insult to
religion when it is perpetrated with the deliberate and malicious
intention of outraging the religious feelings of that class. What is
emphasized is the calculated tendency of this aggravated form of
insult is clearly to disrupt the public order would invite the
penalty under the provisions of Section 295A IPC.
6.4 From a perusal of the photographs on record which are even
not disputed by the learned advocate for the respondent No. 2 and
from a Report of the Police Inspector Salabatpura Police Station,
Surat dated 07.08.2024, placed on record by the learned Additional
Public Prosecutor, it appears that the applicant, allegedly, got
printed the Saree and other cloth (material) with image of God and
Gautam Buddha face, which covers the lower portion of the
garment (the feet/border/pallu area) and thus, committed the
offence as alleged. However, it appears from the said Report that
such material was also sold by some other persons in the city of
Surat. Be that as it may, from a perusal of the photographs
produced on record, in the considered opinion of the Court, there
appears nothing so as to suggest insult or attempts to insult the
religion or the religious beliefs of a particular class, that too,
deliberate and malicious, intending to outrage religious feelings of
any class by insulting its religion or religious beliefs, so as to
Page 9 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
attract the provisions of Section 295A IPC.
7. The High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh, in
Misc. No. M-31988 of 2012 (O&M) , in the case of Maninder Singh
and Another v. State of Punjab and Another held as follows:
“The word "deliberate" has the following meanings : Carefully
weighed or considered; intentional (New Websters Dictionary of
the English Language, Delux Encyclopaedic Edition Page 264). To
weigh, ponder, discuss (Blacks Law Dictionary). The word
"intend" means to decide, resolve, purpose (Blacks Law
Dictionary). "Intended" means intentional or designed; as to
produce the intended effect (New Websters' Dictionary).
While interpreting the words "deliberate and malicious intention"
occurring in Section 295A of the Penal code, the Allahabad High
Court in Kali Charan Sharma v. King Emperor AIR 1927
Allahabad 649 (SB) held that:
"This matter must be judged primarily by the language of
the book itself though it is permissible to receive and consider
external evidence either to prove or to rebut the meaning
ascribed to it in the order of forfeiture.
If the language is of a nature calculated to produce or to
promote feelings of enmity or hatred the writer must be
presumed to intend that which his act was likely to
produce....
I have sought, therefore, to judge the intention of the writer
from his own declarations in the book, from the nature of the
language he has used and from the circumstances in which
the book was published and I cannot entertain any doubt, in
spite of the author's protestation to the contrary, that the
book was conceived and written with the deliberate intention
not only of exciting odium against the founder of the
Page 10 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
Mahomedan religion, but of promoting in Hindus feelings of
hatred or enmity against their Muslim fellow-subjects. I pay
no attention to the plea that the statements contained in the
book are supported by authority; in cases like these the truth
of the language can neither be pleaded nor proved; it is
immaterial......"
It may be observed that the word "malicious" does not occur
in the definition of the words "objectionable performance" in
the Act.”
……………………..
While examining the validity of the order passed by the Uttar
Pradesh Government forfeiting a book which was a compilation of
speeches made by the late Dr. Ambedkar, exhorting the scheduled
castes to throw off the shackles of caste tyranny by repudiating the
Hindu religion and adopting Buddhism instead, a Full Bench of
the Allahabad High Court in Lalai Singh v. State of U.P. 1971 Cri
LJ 1773 observed as follows :
“Rational criticism of religious tenets, couched in restrained
language, cannot amount to an offence either under Section
153-A or under Section 195-A of the Penal Code. And
criticism of the Hindu religion for its inculcation of the
doctrine of untouchability and for the sanction which it has
given to reprehensible treatment meted out to the lower
castes has of recent years been considered perfectly
legitimate, having been sponsored by no less a person than
Mahatma Gandhi himself".
The Supreme Court while confirming the said judgement in State
of Uttar Pradesh v. Lalai Singh Yadav (1976) 4 SCC 213: (AIR
1977 SC 202) quoted with approval the following observation of
Holmes, J. in Schenck v. U.S. (1918) 249 US 47: 63 Law Ed 470:
"We admit that in many places and in ordinary times the
defendants, in saying all that was said in the circular, would
have been within their constitutional rights. But the
Page 11 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
character of every act depends upon the circumstances in
which it is done.......... The law's stringent protection of free
speech, would not protect a man in falsely shouting 'fire' in
a theatre, and causing panic. It does not even protect a man
from an injunction against uttering words that may have all
the effect of force...... The question in every case is whether
the words used are used in such circumstances and are of
such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that
they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has
a right to prevent. It is a question of proximity and degree."
The Supreme Court finally held as follows:
"Government has the power and responsibility to preserve
societal peace and to forfeit publications which endanger it.
But what is thereby prevented is freedom of expression, that
promoter of the permanent interests of human progress.
Therefore, the law (S. 99A) fixes the mind of the
Administration to the obligation to reflect on the need to
restrict and to state the grounds which ignite its action. To
fail here is to fault the order. That is about all."
In State of Mysore v. Henry Rodrigues 1962 (2) Cri LJ 564 a
Division Bench of the Mysore High Court considered the scope of
Section 295-A of the Penal Code. The 1st accused was the editor
and publisher of a monthly magazine and the 2nd accused was the
printer of the said magazine. The complaint was to the effect that in
certain issues of the magazine there were articles which were
insulting to the religion and religious beliefs of the Roman
Catholics and that the accused acted with a malicious intention in
publishing and printing the same and therefore they committed
offence publishable under Section 295A of the Indian Penal Code
The 1st accused claimed to have made a deep study of the Holy
Bible and became convinced that the Bible does not sanction the
worship of Virgin Mary. So also it was stated that the Institution
of Papacy was not the one sanctioned by the Bible. The Court held
as follows:
"Having regard to the purpose for which Section 295-A of
Page 12 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
the Indian Penal Code has been enacted, we find ourselves
unable to accept the view that a statement which would
otherwise fall within the mischief of Section 295-A, can be
taken out of it merely because it happens to be a true
statement, As contended by the learned Advocate-General, if
the language used transgresses the limit of decency and is
designed to vex, annoy and outrage the religious feelings of
others, then, the malicious intention of the writer can be
inferred from the language employed by him".
8. Applying the settled legal principles enunciated by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court and the High Court of Punjab and
Haryana in Maninder Singh, (supra) to the facts of the present case,
it becomes abundantly clear that the foundational ingredients of
Section 295A of the IPC—specifically, a "deliberate and malicious
intention" to outrage religious feelings—are completely absent.
The applicant is a commercial merchant engaged in the routine
business of trading Sarees and dress materials based on prevailing
market trends and designs. Mere printing or selling of textile
materials containing artistic depictions of a deity or revered icon,
even if appearing on portions of a garment near the lower border
or Pallu , cannot automatically be presumed to be an act driven by
deliberate malice or calculated to disrupt public order.
Commercial activity involving religious motifs, undertaken
without any overt act, inflammatory rhetoric, or demonstrable
intent to denigrate a religious belief, does not cross the threshold
into a criminally punishable insult under Section 295A. To hold
otherwise would expand the criminal statute beyond its intended
constitutional parameters and penalize commercial practices
Page 13 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026
R/CR.MA/854/2018 JUDGMENT DATED: 07/10/2026
(GJHC240098432018)
absent any criminal mens rea . Thus, the uncontroverted facts set
out in the FIR, even when taken at face value, fail to establish a
prima facie case of an aggravated insult to religion against the
present applicant.
9. On a careful consideration of the FIR and the material on
record vis-a-vis the argument of both the sides, this Court finds
that continuing the criminal prosecution against the applicant
would constitute a clear abuse of the process of law. The present
case falls within parameters (1), (3), (5), and (7) laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Bhajan Lal’s case.
10. In fine , this application succeeds and is accordingly, allowed.
The First Information Report registered against the applicant,
referred in Paragraph 1 above, with all consequential criminal
proceedings emanating therefrom, are hereby quashed and set
aside qua the applicant.
10.1 Rule is made absolute, accordingly. Direct service is
permitted.
[ P. M. Raval, J. ]
hiren/20tss71026
Page 14 of 14
Uploaded by HIREN MER(HC00351) on Wed Oct 07 2026 Downloaded on : Wed Oct 07 18:46:11 IST 2026