TAMILNADU GOVERNMENT TRANSPORT vs THE GOVERNMENT OF TAMILNADU
- Court
- Madras High Court
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved On: 11.11.2026 Delivered On: 17.11.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE G. JAYACHANDRAN
and
THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE E. MANOHARAN
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
and
M.P.No.1 of 2008
Tamil Nadu Government Transport
Corporations Staff Federation,
Rep. By its General Secretary,
(Regd No.601/MDU)
TNSTC Head Office Complex,
Bye Pass Road, Madurai – 625 010. … Petitioner
vs.
1. The Government of Tamil Nadu,
Rep. By its Secretary,
Transport Department,
Fort St. George,
Chennai – 600 009.
2. The Tamil Nadu State Corporation,
(Madurai) Ltd.,
Rep. By its Managing Director,
Bye Pass Road,
Madurai – 625 010.
3. The Tamil Nadu State Corporation
(Kumbakonam) Ltd.,
Rep. By its Managing Director,
Railway Station Road,
Kumbakonam.
4. The Tamil Nadu State Corporation,
(Coimbatore) Ltd.,
_____________
Page Nos.1/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
Rep. By its Managing Director,
No.37, Mettupalayam Road,
Coimbatore. … Respondents
Prayer: Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, to
issue Writ of Declaration by declaring sub-rule 4(a)(b) of Part-C of Appendix II
read with Rule 59(b) of Common Services Rules as null and void and to forbear
the respondents from granting promotion to the graduate conductors on the basis
of the impugned sub-rule and to pass orders.
For Petitioner : Mr.V.Govardhanan,
for M/s.Row and Reddy
For Respondents : Mr.K.Rajesh,
Government Advocate, for R1
: Mr.C.Senapathi, for R3
: Mr.A.Sundaravadhanan, for R4
O R D E R
Dr. G. Jayachandran, J.
and
E.Manoharan, J.
The case of the petitioner federation, in short, is that it is a recognised
Union by virtue of an election held in the year 1998. Serial No.4(a) and (b) of
Part C of Appendix II, read with Rule 59(b) of the Common Service Rules,
which came into effect from 22.05.1987 insofar as prescribing quota of 25% for
graduates for promotion to the posts supervisory and above in the
Traffic/Administrative/Technical category, is void since under Clause 15 of the
12(3) settlement signed in the year 1977, it was agreed that there will be no
_____________
Page Nos.2/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
time-based review for filling the posts in supervisory group. The number of
supervisory posts will be fixed by the Corporation and vacancies to be filled by
promotion will be filled up from among the working group who have the
prescribed qualifications based on merit-cum-seniority. Therefore, when merit-
cum-seniority is the basic policy in operation for about 30 years, the impugned
Paragraph 4(a) and (b) in the Appendix, which deals with the method of
recruitment to the post of Checking Inspector, 25% is earmarked exclusively for
Conductors who possess graduate degree in Arts, Science or Commerce. The
remaining 75% to be filled on the basis of seniority. When the Corporation
tried to provide quota for graduates serving as Senior Assistants to Supervisory
post, dispute was raised by the aggrieved employees, which was subject matter
of I.D.No.18 of 1991. In the said dispute, an award was passed on 13.05.1997
holding that the settlement binds both the management and the employees.
When the settlement does not provide for any such quota, the same principle
should equally apply to the promotion for Special Grade Conductors to
Checking Inspectors.
2. The Learned Counsel, referring to the observations made in
Paragraph 12 of the award dated 13.06.1997 in the case of quota given to the
graduates in the Senior Assistant post, contended that the same analogy applies
_____________
Page Nos.3/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
to Senior Conductors. For better appreciation of the said submission, the
relevant portion of the award is extracted below:-
“ 12. The main question raised by the petitioner-
unions in the industrial dispute is one of discrimination
shown between technical and non-technical staff. While
they are promoted to the supervisory cadre and thereafter.
It seems the respondent Corporations have prescribed
certain qualifications for the senior posts like that of the
General Manager. Managing Director or Chairman-cum-
Managing Director. The petitioner-Union are very much
dissatisfied with the respondent Management for
promoting only the technically qualified staff members to
the higher post and not the non-technical persons. The
petitioner unions have clearly stated the guidelines
prescribed by the respondent for such higher post. The
respondent have also not stated that the managements
have prescribed any qualifications for the staff members to
reach the higher post in the transport Corporation.
However, from the claim statement and the counter
statement it is clear that only technically qualified staff
members alone reach the post like General Manager and
above and nontechnical persons are not promoted like to
the said position. From the hierarchy shown In the counter
statement one may feel that the non-technical staff
members belonging to the administrative set up may not
reach the higher positions because by the time when they
reach the eligibility for promotion to the higher posts
_____________
Page Nos.4/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
generally they retire. However, from the reading of the
claim statement it is clear that the managements select
only technical qualified persons to the higher positions
and not the non-technical staff members. No specific cases
have been shown as to how a non-technical staff member
was prevented from not reaching the higher positions.
Respondent No. 7 and some respondents have raised this
point in their counter statement and contended that the
claim statement is vague and non specific instances have
been shown to prove the discrimination attitude by the
management between technical and non-technical staff
members. In turn the petitioner Unions in their reply
statement have stated that there is one of the general
nature and therefore they need not show any specific cases
of discrimination to achieve their object. Whatever, it may
be, it will be better to show one or two specific instances
to prove the fact that the Corporations promote only
technical staff members to the post and not non-technicals.
While considering the reasons shown by both the parties
and also the documents marked on their sides, it is clear
that they have not come forward with specific instances.
The petitioner unions have also not shown how technically
qualified persons alone are preferred for the higher
positions.”
3. The respondents in the counter states that the writ petition is not
maintainable for two reasons:-
(i)Firstly, the writ petitioner filed by a Trade Union for the cause of a
_____________
Page Nos.5/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
group of employees as against another group of employees is not maintainable
especially, when the writ petitioner Union was unsuccessful in the election
conducted for recognition. After the process of election to identify the majority
union, the Management has entered into 12(3) Settlement with the Labour
Progressive Front which is the successful Union and other recognised unions on
08.01.2011. In the said settlement, the issue of promotion to the supervisory
post been decided and given effect.
(ii)Secondly, the writ petition has to be dismissed for not including
the necessary parties (the graduates in the post of Senior Conductors) who are
likely to be affected if in the event of their prayer is granted. Particularly, when
the graduates filed writ petition to implement 25% quota as per Paragraphs 4(a)
and (b) and same was dismissed as withdrawn after the management
undertaking to implement the same.
4. The Learned Counsel for the respondents further submitted that
State Transport Corporations which function under several divisions spread over
the State, periodically enter into settlements with the Unions and decide about
the issues including promotional aspect. Based on the conditions prevailing and
without causing any infringement to the Service Rules, the terms of the
settlements are finalised. Providing quota for graduates and non-graduates is
_____________
Page Nos.6/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
not violative of Articles 14 or 16 of the Constitution. In fact, by providing
quota for each distinct group, the promotional opportunities proportionate to
their strength are ensured.
5. The Hon’ble Supreme Court has consistently held that the fixation
of quota among graduates and non-graduates is permissible provided there is
fair and equitable distribution among them. The Common Service Rules (CSR)
are framed by the Transport Department for Transport Undertakings to adopt
and implement. Liberty is given to the respective Divisions to modify the rules
with the approval of the Board of Directors. The Settlements under Section
12(3) is arrived periodically, involving the Managing Directors of all the
Divisions and the Unions. Challenging provision of the CSR after 24 years of its
existence and effective implementation with certain variations which are
required and settled through the 12(3) settlement process, requires no
interference.
6. Heard the Learned Counsel for the petitioner and the Learned
Counsel for the respondents.
7. We are conscious of the fact that the writ petition is filed
_____________
Page Nos.7/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
challenging the vires of a Rule, which provides flexibility to modify. The
effectiveness of the impugned paragraphs in the Appendix well been examined
by the stakeholders during the settlement talks and appropriate decisions taken.
If there is a reasonable ground to provide quota for higher qualifications, the
same cannot be questioned on the ground of equality alone. The test of
intelligible differentia and reasonableness, san arbitrariness is to be applied
when the constitutional validity of a Rule is subjected to challenge.
8. In the case in hand, we find that in the Paragraphs 4(a) and (b),
quota is prescribed for the post of: a) Checking Inspector/Time Keeper and b)
Junior Checking Inspector/Time Keeper from among the feeder categories,
namely Direct Recruits and promotees, in the ratio of 3:1. Thus, the promotees
are given 75% and the direct recruits are given 25%. From among the quota
meant for promotees, 75% is distributed equally among:
(i)Selection Grade Conductors (III Level) in the working group for
the promotional post of Checking Inspector/Time Keeper (Second Level) in the
miscellaneous group, and
(ii)Selection Grade Conductors who possess MGEQ (Minimum
General Educational Qualification) or any other higher qualification.
_____________
Page Nos.8/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
9 . The remaining 25% is reserved for Senior Conductors (Second
Level) who possess a Degree in Arts, Science or Commerce only for the post of
Junior Checking Inspector and Junior Time Keeper (first level) in the
miscellaneous group, or by direct recruitment, to the post of Junior Checking
Inspector / Junior Time Keeper.
10. The rule under challenge explicitly makes out an intelligible
differentia for the posts as well the feeder category. It is not only educational
qualifications but also the level i.e., First level, Second level and third level in
the respective cadre based on the length of service and the group to which they
belong such as Working Group and Miscellaneous Group. Therefore, fusing in
one cadre but with differentia necessitates to fix quota for each distinct
group/grades.
11. In State of Mysore and another -vs- P.Narasinga Rao reported in
AIR 1968 SC 349 , in the newly formed State viz., State of Mysore when two
scales of Tracers who were doing the same kind of work challenged as ultra
vires to Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution, the Constitutional Bench of the
Apex Court held as below:-
“4. The relevant law on the subject is well settled. Under
Article 16 of the Constitution, there shall be equality of opportunity
_____________
Page Nos.9/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
for all citizens in matters relating to employment or appointment to
any office under the State or to promotion from one office to a
higher office thereunder. Article 16 of the Constitution is only an
incident of the application of the concept of equality enshrined in
Article 14 thereof. It gives effect to the doctrine of equality in the
matter of appointment and promotion. It follows that there can be a
reasonable classification of the employees for the purpose of
appointment or promotion. The concept of equality in the matter of
promotion can be predicated only when the promotees are drawn
from the same source. This Court in dealing with the extent of
protection of Article 16(1) observed in General Manager, Southern
Rly. v. Rangachari.
“Thus construed it would be clear that
matters relating to employment cannot be confined
only to the initial matters prior to the act of
employment. The narrow construction would confine
the application of Article 16(1) to the initial
employment and nothing else; but that clearly is
only one of the matters relating to employment. The
other matters relating to employment would
inevitably be the provision as to the salary and
periodical increments therein, terms as to leave, as
to gratuity, as to pension and as to the age of
superannuation. These are all matters relating to
employment and they are, and must be, deemed to be
included in the expression ‘matters relating to
employment’ in Article 16(1)…. This equality of
opportunity need not be confused with absolute
equality as such. What is guaranteed is the equality
of opportunity and nothing more. Article 16(1) or
(2) does not prohibit the prescription of reasonable
rules for selection to any employment or
appointment to any office. Any provision as to the
_____________
Page Nos.10/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
qualifications for the employment or the
appointment to office reasonably fixed (emphasis
added) and applicable to all citizens would certainly
be consistent with the doctrine of the equality of
opportunity; but in regard to employment, like other
terms and conditions associated with and incidental
to it, the promotion to a selection post is also
included in the matters relating to employment, and
even in regard to such a promotion to a selection
post all that Article 16(1) guarantees is equality of
opportunity to all citizens who enter service…. In
this connection it may be relevant to remember that
Article 16(1) and (2) really give effect to the equality
before law guaranteed by Article 14 and to the
prohibition of discrimination guaranteed by Article
15(1). The three provisions form part of the same
constitutional code of guarantees and supplement
each other. If that be so, there would be no difficulty
in holding that the matters relating to employment
must include all matters in relation to employment
both prior, and subsequent, to the employment
which are incidental to the employment and form
part of the terms and conditions of such
employment.”
12. Hence, we hold that for adequate opportunity for the graduates,
quotas have been prescribed, which is not an alien concept in Indian Service
Jurisprudence. It is neither violative of Article 14 or Article 16(1) of the
Constitution of India, which envisages equality of opportunity. When the feeder
category is composed of persons of different grades, levels and education
qualifications, earmarking reservations proportionate to their representation is
_____________
Page Nos.11/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
one of the methods to ensure equality to the possible extent.
13. As we have pointed out earlier, the Rule under challenge is not
rigid Rule but it is amenable to modification by way of a 12(3) settlement. This
has been demonstrated during the earlier settlement arrived between the
respective Managing Directors of the Transport Corporation Division and the
representatives of the Trade Unions. As a result, we hold, the Rules impugned is
neither arbitrary nor discriminative to declare it as void.
14. Accordingly, this Writ Petition is dismissed. No order as to
costs. Consequently, connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
(Dr. G.J. J,) & (E.M. J,)
17-11-2026
Index :Yes.
Internet :Yes.
bsm
To,
1. The Secretary,
Government of Tamil Nadu,
Transport Department,
Fort St. George, Chennai – 600 009.
2. The Managing Director,
_____________
Page Nos.12/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
Tamil Nadu State Corporation (Madurai) Ltd.,
Bye Pass Road, Madurai – 625 010.
3. The Managing Director,
Tamil Nadu State Corporation (Kumbakonam) Ltd.,
Railway Station Road,
Kumbakonam.
4. The Managing Director,
Tamil Nadu State Corporation (Coimbatore) Ltd.,
No.37, Mettupalayam Road,
Coimbatore.
_____________
Page Nos.13/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
Dr. G.JAYACHANDRAN, J.
&
E. MANOHARAN, J.
bsm
Pre-Delivery order made in
W.P.No.7401 of 2008
Judgment delivered on
17-11-2026
_____________
Page Nos.14/14
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 17/11/2026 05:48:48 pm )