PLUTUS RESEARCH PRIVATE LIMITED vs AASHAY HARLALKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 16 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD
CIVIL MISC. PETITION NO. 503 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
PLUTUS RESEARCH PRIVATE LIMITED
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICER AT
PARAGRAPH, KHAJANCHI BUSINESS CENTRE LLP
B-601 AND 611, MODEAL HEIGHTS
NR. NOVOTEL HOTEL
SG HIGHWAY, AHMEDABAD, GUJARAT-355
TH
ALSO AT 12 FLOOR, AWFIS, CRESCENT 3
PRESTIGE SHANTINIKETAN, WHITEFIELD
BENGALURU, KARNATAKA-560048.
REP. BY DIRECTOR MR. SAURABH BHOLA.
…PETITIONER
(BY SMT. ANANYA GHOSH, ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. ARJUN RAO., ADVOCATE)
AND:
AASHAY HARLALKA
4-G-50. NEW HOUSING BOARD
SHASTRI NAGAR, BHILWARA
RAJASTHAN-311001.
ALSO AT:
4114, SOBHA HABITECH APARTMENTS
CHANNASANDRA MAIN ROAD
NEAR HOPE FARM JUNCTION
WHITEFIELD, BANGALORE
KARNATAKA- 560066.
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. SURAJ S., ADVOCATE)
Digitally signed by
DHANALAKSHMI
MURTHY
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
THIS CMP IS FILED UNDER SECTION 11(6) OF
ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT, 1996, PRAYING TO
APPOINT DR. Y.P.C.DANGAY AS THE SOLE ARBITRATOR TO
RESOLVE AND ADJUDICATE THE DISPUTES ARISING OUT OF
THE EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT DATED:01.10.2018 IN TERMS
OF CLAUSE 16 OF THE SAID AGREEMENT (ANNEXURE A) AND
THE PARTIES THEREIN.
THIS PETITION, HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR ORDERS ON 04.11.2026, COMING ON FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT, THIS DAY, THE COURT, MADE THE
FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD
CAV JUDGMENT
This petition is filed under Section 11(6) of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short, ‘the Act’),
seeking for the appointment of a Sole Arbitrator to
adjudicate the disputes that have arisen between the
parties under the Employment Agreement dated
01.10.2018, particularly in terms of Clause 16 thereof,
produced at Annexure-A.
2. The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner
is a Private Limited Company incorporated on 17.08.2017
under the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013. The
petitioner-Company is engaged in quantitative trading,
employing advanced mathematical models, statistical
- 3 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
techniques and data-driven strategies for proprietary
trading algorithms in the Indian stock markets. The
respondent is one of the Directors and Shareholders of the
petitioner-Company. The petitioner entered into an
Employment Agreement dated 01.10.2018 with the
respondent. The said Agreement contains various terms
and conditions governing the employment, including
obligations relating to confidentiality, non-compete
restrictions and termination of employment. It is the case
of the petitioner that the respondent has violated the
terms and conditions of the Employment Agreement,
thereby giving rise to disputes between the parties.
3. In view of the disputes that arose between the
parties, the petitioner invoked the arbitration clause
contained in the Employment Agreement by issuing a
notice dated 07.04.2025 under Section 21 of the Act, as
per Annexure-E. Clause 16 of the Employment Agreement,
which provides for resolution of disputes through
arbitration, reads as under:
- 4 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
“16. DISPUTE SETTLEMENT
16.1. Where any dispute or controversy arises in
relation to the employment, whether or not relating
to the terms of appointment provided herein, it will
be settled by arbitration, in accordance with the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, as then
existing, to be heard and determined by a sole
arbitrator, appointed by the Company. The decision
of the arbitrator shall be final, conclusive and binding
on the parties.
16.2. All arbitration proceedings will be conducted in
English, at such place as the Company may decide.
Unless otherwise agreed in writing between the
Company and Employee, the arbitration shall be
conducted at Bengaluru, India.”
4. Despite service of the aforesaid notice, the
respondent has neither furnished any reply nor consented
to the appointment of an Arbitrator. Hence, the petitioner
has approached this Court by filing the present petition
seeking appointment of a Sole Arbitrator.
5. Learned counsel appearing for the respondent has
raised the following contentions:
- 5 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
(i) Firstly, the disputes sought to be referred to
arbitration are not arbitrable in nature, as they involve
allegations of serious fraud committed by the other two
Directors of the petitioner-Company, namely, Mr.
Shivakumar Reddy Chinthala and Mr. Saurabh Bhola. It is
submitted that the said Directors have been illegally
attempting to wrest control of the Company from the
respondent by misusing the legal process. It has an
implication in the public domain.
(ii) Secondly, the fraudulent acts committed by the
other two Directors are evident from the email
correspondence produced along with the statement of
objections and the accompanying memo of documents,
filed herein. It is submitted that, with a view to intimidate
the respondent, who had acted as a whistleblower, the
other two Directors initiated multiple legal proceedings
against him, including criminal proceedings resulting in
registration of an FIR. It is further submitted that, they
also illegally removed the respondent from the
Directorship of the Company. Aggrieved by the said action,
- 6 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
the respondent approached the National Company Law
Tribunal (for short, ‘the NCLT’), Ahmedabad, by filing a
petition under Sections 241 and 242 of the Companies Act,
2013, and obtained an interim order staying his removal
from the Directorship till the disposal of the petition. It is
therefore contended that the disputes involve serious
allegations of fraud relating to the affairs and management
of the Company, which fall within the exclusive statutory
jurisdiction of the NCLT. Such disputes cannot be referred
to arbitration. Consequently, the present petition filed
under Section 11(6) of the Act is not maintainable. In
support of his contentions, learned counsel has placed
reliance on the judgments of the Apex Court in A.
Ayyasamy v. A. Paramasivam , reported in (2016) 10
SCC 386; Rashid Raza v. Sadaf Akhtar , reported in
(2019) 8 SCC 710; Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading
,
Corporation reported in (2021) 2 SCC 1; and Sushma
Shivkumar Daga v. Madhurkumar Ramkrishnaji
Bajaj , reported in (2024) 12 SCC 253.
- 7 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
(iii) Thirdly, the petitioner had earlier filed an
application under Section 8 of the Act before the NCLT in
C.P.No.48/2025, seeking reference of the disputes arising
out of the Employment Agreement and other connected
disputes to arbitration. However, the petitioner
subsequently withdrew the said application without
seeking any liberty to initiate fresh proceedings. It is
contended that, by withdrawing the application under
Section 8 of the Act without reserving any liberty, the
petitioner has unequivocally abandoned its claim for
reference of the disputes to arbitration. Having abandoned
the said remedy, the petitioner cannot once again seek
appointment of an Arbitrator by filing a petition under
Section 11(6) of the Act, particularly when no fresh cause
of action has arisen subsequent to such withdrawal. It is
further contended that the petitioner is estopped from
seeking the very same relief through the present
proceedings. In support of this contention, learned
counsel has relied upon the judgments of the Apex Court
in Rajiv Gaddh v. Subodh Parkash , reported in 2026
- 8 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
SCC OnLine SC 507; M/s.HPCL Bio-Fuels Ltd. v.
Shahaji Bhanudas Bhad , reported in 2024 INSC 851;
and Anil v. Rajendra , reported in (2015) 2 SCC 583.
(iv) Fourthly, the petitioner has not approached this
Court with clean hands and has suppressed material facts.
It is submitted that, at the time of filing the present
petition under Section 11(6) of the Act, the application
filed by the petitioner under Section 8 of the Act was
already pending consideration before the NCLT. However,
the petitioner deliberately failed to disclose the pendency
of the said application before this Court. It is contended
that the petitioner was under an obligation to disclose all
material facts relating to the proceedings initiated between
the parties, particularly when the earlier application also
concerned reference of disputes to arbitration. The
deliberate suppression of such material facts disentitles
the petitioner from seeking discretionary relief from this
Court. Therefore, it is submitted that the petition is liable
to be dismissed on the ground of suppression of material
facts alone. In support of this contention, learned counsel
- 9 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
has placed reliance on the judgments of the Apex Court in
the case of Dalip Singh v. State of U.P. , reported in
(2010) 2 SCC 114; K.D. Sharma v. Steel Authority of
India Ltd. , reported in (2008) 12 SCC 481; Bhaskar
Laxman Jadhav v. Karamveer Kakasaheb Wagh
Education Society , reported in (2013) 11 SCC 531;
and Yashoda v. Sukhwinder Singh , reported in AIR
2022 SC 4623, as well as the judgment of the Division
Bench of this Court in Sujay Enterprises v. Airport
Authority of India , reported in ILR 2001 KAR 4634.
(v) Lastly, learned counsel contends that the
disputes pending adjudication before the NCLT and those
sought to be referred to arbitration are intrinsically
interconnected and arise out of the same set of
transactions and circumstances. Therefore, the disputes
cannot be artificially bifurcated by referring certain issues
in relation to a particular subject matter to arbitration
while retaining the remaining issues for adjudication
before the NCLT. It is submitted that such bifurcation
would result in parallel proceedings before different
- 10 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
forums, giving rise to the possibility of conflicting findings
and decisions. In support of this contention, learned
counsel has placed reliance on the judgment of the Apex
Court in the case of Sukanya Holdings (P) Ltd. v.
Jayesh H. Pandya , reported in (2003) 5 SCC 531.
On these grounds, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent seeks dismissal of the petition.
6. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner has raised the following contentions:
(i) Firstly, it is contended that the proceedings
pending before the NCLT relate exclusively to the affairs
and management of the Company, concerning the removal
of the respondent from its Directorship. The allegations
levelled by the respondent against the other two Directors,
namely, that they have committed fraud and illegally
attempted to take control of the Company, pertain to the
internal affairs and management of the Company. Those
issues are the subject matter of adjudication before the
NCLT. It is submitted that the disputes sought to be
- 11 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
referred to arbitration in the present petition stand on an
entirely different footing. They arise out of the alleged
violation of the terms and conditions of the Employment
Agreement dated 01.10.2018.
(ii) Secondly, as per the Memorandum of Association,
the respondent and the other two persons are Directors of
the Company, holding equal shares. Apart from their
status as Directors and Shareholders, the petitioner-
Company entered into a separate Employment Agreement
dated 01.10.2018 with the respondent, which is produced
at Annexure-A. The said Employment Agreement imposes
certain contractual duties and obligations upon the
respondent. It is the specific case of the petitioner that the
respondent has violated those obligations, thereby giving
rise to an independent contractual dispute. Since the
Employment Agreement contains a valid arbitration clause,
the petitioner is entitled to seek appointment of a Sole
Arbitrator for adjudication of the disputes arising
thereunder.
- 12 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
(iii) Thirdly, the allegations of serious fraud made by
the respondent against the other two Directors pertain to
the management and affairs of the Company and have no
direct bearing on the contractual disputes arising under
the Employment Agreement. Therefore, the contention of
the respondent that the disputes are non-arbitrable on
account of allegations of serious fraud is wholly untenable.
(iv) Fourthly, upon noticing the violations of the
terms and conditions of the Employment Agreement by
the respondent, the petitioner invoked the arbitration
clause by issuing a notice under Section 21 of the Act. It
is submitted that the petitioner had also filed an
application under Section 8 of the Act before the NCLT
seeking reference of the disputes to arbitration. However,
upon realising that the proceedings pending before the
NCLT concerned the affairs and management of the
Company, including the removal of the respondent from its
Directorship, and that the same did not directly concern
the alleged breach of the Employment Agreement, the
petitioner withdrew the said application. It is contended
- 13 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
that the withdrawal of the application under Section 8 of
the Act cannot be construed as abandonment of the
petitioner's substantive contractual right to invoke
arbitration under the Employment Agreement in respect of
disputes arising directly due to violation of the obligations
thereunder.
(v) Fifthly, the application filed under Section 8 of
the Act was dismissed as withdrawn without any
adjudication on merits. Therefore, the withdrawal of the
said application does not operate as a bar to the
maintainability of the present petition under Section 11(6)
of the Act. The learned counsel further relied upon the
case of Vijay Kumar Sharma V. Raghunandan Sharma
reported in (2010) 2 SCC 486 , to submit that the mere
pendency of an application under Section 8 of the Act
before the NCLT does not, by itself, preclude the petitioner
from invoking the jurisdiction of this Court under Section
11(6) of the Act, and particularly when the disputes
sought to be referred to arbitration arise out of an
independent contractual relationship. Learned counsel
- 14 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
submits that the proceedings before the NCLT and the
present petition arise out of distinct causes of action and
seek different reliefs. Therefore, the judgments relied
upon by learned counsel for the respondent have no
application to the facts and circumstances of the present
case.
(vi) Sixthly, learned counsel disputes the allegation
that the petitioner has suppressed material facts or
approached this Court without clean hands. It is
submitted that the petitioner had already invoked the
arbitration clause by issuing a notice under Section 21 of
the Act before initiating the proceedings under Section 8 of
the Act before the NCLT. It is further contended that the
proceedings pending before the NCLT relate to the affairs
and management of the Company, whereas the present
petition concerns the alleged breach of contractual
obligations arising under the Employment Agreement.
According to the learned counsel, the two proceedings are
distinct in nature and arise out of different causes of
action. Therefore, the non-disclosure of the pendency of
- 15 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
the application under Section 8 of the Act cannot be
treated as suppression of a material fact warranting
dismissal of the present petition. It is therefore submitted
that the judgments relied upon by learned counsel for the
respondent on the question of suppression of material
facts are distinguishable and have no application to the
facts of the present case.
(vii) Lastly, the learned counsel contended that the
scope of enquiry under Section 11(6) of the Act is limited.
At the stage of considering a petition for appointment of
an Arbitrator, this Court is primarily required to examine
the existence of a valid arbitration agreement between the
parties and whether the disputes sought to be referred
arise under the said agreement. It is submitted that the
Employment Agreement dated 01.10.2018 admittedly
contains an arbitration clause and that disputes have
arisen between the parties concerning the alleged breach
of the terms and conditions of the said Agreement.
Therefore, once the existence of the arbitration agreement
is established, all other contentious issues, including the
- 16 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
allegations of breach of contract, the nature of the
disputes, the defences raised by the respondent and the
merits of the respective claims, ought to be left open for
adjudication by the learned Arbitrator. In support of her
contentions, learned counsel has placed reliance on the
judgments of the Apex Court in Duro Felguera S.A. v.
Gangavaram Port Ltd. , reported in (2017) 9 SCC 729
and In Re: Interplay Between Arbitration
Agreements under the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 and the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 reported in
(2024) 6 SCC 1.
On these grounds, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner prays for allowing the petition by appointing a
Sole Arbitrator to adjudicate upon the disputes arising
between the parties.
7. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for
the parties and having perused the materials available on
record, the following question arises for consideration:
- 17 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
"Whether the disputes raised by the petitioner–
Company arising out of the Employment Agreement
dated 01.10.2018 are liable to be referred to arbitration,
notwithstanding the objections raised by the respondent
that the dispute is concerning allegations of fraud,
mismanagement of the affairs of the Company and
removal from directorship?"
8. It is not in dispute that the petitioner is a Private
Limited Company and that the respondent is one of its
Directors and Shareholders. It is also not in dispute that
the parties entered into an Employment Agreement dated
01.10.2018, which contains an arbitration clause under
Clause 16 thereof.
9. The principal contention of the learned counsel for
the respondent is that the disputes between the parties
essentially relate to the management and affairs of the
Company, including allegations of fraud, mismanagement
and removal of the respondent from directorship.
Therefore, it is contended that such disputes are not
arbitrable and cannot be referred to arbitration.
- 18 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
10. The said contention cannot be accepted in its
entirety. It is well settled that the scope of enquiry under
Section 11(6) of the Act is limited. At the stage of
appointment of an Arbitrator, this Court is primarily
required to examine the prima facie existence of a valid
arbitration agreement. The Court is not expected to
undertake a detailed examination of the rival claims,
defences or disputed questions of fact, which appropriately
fall within the jurisdiction of the Arbitral Tribunal.
11. The Apex Court, in the case of Vidya Drolia v.
Durga Trading Corporation , reported in (2021) 2 SCC
1 , has held that the question of arbitrability should
ordinarily be left to the Arbitral Tribunal, except where the
dispute is manifestly and ex facie non-arbitrable.
12. Similarly, in Duro Felguera S.A . (supra) , and
In Re: Interplay Between Arbitration Agreements
(supra) , the Apex Court has explained the limited nature
of judicial scrutiny at the stage of appointment of an
Arbitrator.
- 19 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
13. Further, in SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. v.
Krish Spinning , reported in 2024 INSC 532 , the Apex
Court has reiterated that the referral Court should confine
its enquiry to the prima facie existence of an arbitration
agreement and leave contentious issues relating to the
merits of the dispute to the Arbitral Tribunal.
14. In view of the aforesaid principles, this Court is
required to examine whether an arbitration agreement
exists between the parties and whether the disputes
sought to be referred arise out of the contractual
relationship governed by the said agreement.
15. On examination of the pleadings and the
materials available on record, it is evident that the parties
entered into an Employment Agreement dated
01.10.2018, containing an arbitration clause under Clause
16 thereof. The specific grievance of the petitioner–
Company is that the respondent has violated the
obligations imposed under Clauses 11, 12, 13, 14 and 15
of the Employment Agreement. It is on account of the
- 20 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
alleged breach of the said contractual obligations that the
petitioner has invoked the arbitration clause.
16. Thus, the dispute sought to be referred to
arbitration is founded upon the alleged breach of the
terms and conditions of the Employment Agreement.
Whether the respondent has, in fact, violated the said
contractual obligations and whether the petitioner is
entitled to any relief are matters which require
adjudication on the basis of evidence. Such questions
cannot be conclusively determined by this Court in
exercise of its limited jurisdiction under Section 11(6) of
the Act.
17. Insofar as the contention relating to allegations
of fraud and the pendency of criminal proceedings is
concerned, the mere existence of such allegations does
not, by itself, render a dispute non-arbitrable.
18. The Apex Court, in A.Ayyasamy (supra) ,
Rashid Raza (supra) , and Avitel Post Studioz Ltd. v.
HSBC PI Holdings (Mauritius) Ltd. , reported in (2021)
- 21 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
4 SCC 713 , has explained that allegations of fraud do not
automatically exclude the jurisdiction of an Arbitral
Tribunal. The relevant considerations include whether the
allegations impeach the arbitration agreement itself and
whether the dispute, by its very nature, falls within a
public law domain or otherwise involves rights which are
incapable of determination by private arbitration.
19. In the case on hand, the allegations concerning
fraud, mismanagement of the affairs of the Company and
removal of the respondent from directorship are stated to
be the subject matter of proceedings pending before the
NCLT. The present petition, however, concerns the alleged
violation of the contractual obligations arising under the
Employment Agreement dated 01.10.2018.
20. The distinction between these two proceedings
assumes significance. The proceedings before the NCLT
concern the statutory rights and obligations arising under
the Companies Act, 2013, whereas the dispute sought to
- 22 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
be referred to arbitration concerns the contractual rights
and obligations arising under the Employment Agreement.
21. Merely because the respondent happens to be a
Director and Shareholder of the petitioner–Company,
every dispute between the parties cannot be treated as a
dispute relating to the management and affairs of the
Company. The nature of the dispute must be determined
with reference to the cause of action and the relief sought.
22. In the present case, the cause of action for
invoking arbitration is the alleged breach of Clauses 11 to
15 of the Employment Agreement. Such a dispute is prima
facie contractual in nature. The mere fact that proceedings
concerning the affairs of the Company are pending before
the NCLT does not automatically deprive the Arbitral
Tribunal of jurisdiction to adjudicate an independent
contractual dispute.
23. Insofar as the contention regarding the filing and
subsequent withdrawal of the application under Section 8
of the Act is concerned, it is not in dispute that the
- 23 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
petitioner issued a notice invoking arbitration on
07.04.2025. Thereafter, an application under Section 8 of
the Act was filed before the NCLT. During the pendency of
the said application, the petitioner instituted the present
petition under Section 11(6) of the Act. Subsequently, the
application filed under Section 8 was withdrawn.
24. The question is whether such withdrawal would
constitute a legal impediment to the maintainability of the
present petition.
25. Section 8 of the Act enables a party to an
arbitration agreement to seek reference to arbitration
when an action is brought before a judicial authority in
respect of a matter which is the subject of an arbitration
agreement. Section 11, on the other hand, provides the
mechanism for appointment of an Arbitrator. The two
provisions operate in different spheres, although both seek
to give effect to the agreement between the parties to
resolve their disputes through arbitration.
- 24 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
26. Further, Section 8(3) of the Act expressly
provides that, notwithstanding the pendency of an
application under Section 8(1), arbitration may be
commenced or continued and an arbitral award may be
made. Therefore, the mere pendency of an application
under Section 8 cannot, by itself, constitute an absolute
bar to the initiation of proceedings under Section 11 of the
Act. Similarly, the withdrawal simpliciter of an application
under Section 8, without any adjudication on merits or an
unequivocal abandonment of the arbitration agreement,
cannot automatically be construed as a waiver of the
contractual right to seek appointment of an Arbitrator in
respect of all disputes arising out of that
contract/agreement.
27. In the present case, there is nothing on record,
prima facie, to establish that the petitioner has expressly
relinquished its right to invoke arbitration under Clause 16
of the Employment Agreement in respect of the
contractual obligations sought to be enforced through
arbitration herein. Consequently, the withdrawal of the
- 25 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
application under Section 8 does not, by itself, render the
present petition not maintainable.
28. The learned counsel for the respondent has also
contended that the petitioner has suppressed material
facts relating to the proceedings before the NCLT and the
filing of the application under Section 8 of the Act.
29. It is undoubtedly true that a party invoking the
discretionary jurisdiction of the Court is expected to
approach the Court with clean hands and disclose all
material facts. However, every omission or non-disclosure
does not necessarily warrant rejection of the proceedings.
The Court is required to examine whether the alleged
suppression is material to the relief sought and whether it
has resulted in an abuse of the process of law.
30. In the present case, the existence of the
Employment Agreement and the arbitration clause
contained therein are not disputed. The mere filing of an
application under Section 8 before the NCLT, followed by
its withdrawal during the pendency of Section 11
- 26 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
application, does not extinguish the arbitration agreement.
Therefore, even assuming that the pendency of the said
application was not specifically disclosed, such omission, in
the facts and circumstances of the case, would not, by
itself, justify rejection of the present petition, in the
absence of any demonstrated prejudice or abuse of
process.
31. The further contention of the learned counsel for
the respondent is that the dispute pending before the
NCLT and the dispute sought to be referred to arbitration
arise out of the same transaction and, therefore, cannot
be bifurcated for adjudication before two different forums.
In support of the said contention, reliance has been placed
on the judgment of the Apex Court in Sukanya Holdings
(P) Ltd. (supra). In Sukanya Holdings (P) Ltd.
(supra) , the Apex Court considered the question of
bifurcation of causes of action and parties in the context of
Section 8 of the Act as it then stood. However, the said
judgment cannot be applied mechanically to every case
where proceedings between the same parties are pending
- 27 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
before different forums. The material consideration is
whether the disputes sought to be adjudicated arise under
the same cause of action and whether the reliefs sought
are capable of determination by arbitration.
32. The Apex Court, in Cox and Kings Ltd. v. SAP
India (P) Ltd. , reported in (2024) 4 SCC 1, has also
emphasized upon the limited scope of enquiry at the
referral stage and the role of the Arbitral Tribunal in
determining jurisdictional questions, subject to the
statutory framework.
33. In the case on hand, the proceedings pending
before the NCLT concern allegations relating to the affairs
and management of the Company, including the removal
of the respondent from directorship. On the other hand,
the present petition seeks appointment of an Arbitrator for
adjudication of disputes arising from the alleged violation
of the Employment Agreement dated 01.10.2018.
Therefore, the two proceedings, though involving the same
parties and possibly certain overlapping facts, are founded
- 28 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
upon distinct legal rights and causes of action. The
determination of the respondent's statutory rights as a
Director or Shareholder is different from the determination
of his contractual obligations under the Employment
Agreement.
34. The mere existence of common factual
circumstances does not necessarily render the causes of
action identical. Nor does it follow that an independent
contractual dispute becomes non-arbitrable merely
because statutory proceedings concerning the affairs of
the Company are pending before the NCLT. It is also
pertinent to observe that the appointment of an Arbitrator
in the present proceedings would not amount to referring
the disputes pending before the NCLT to arbitration. The
Arbitral Tribunal would be competent to adjudicate only
such disputes as arise under the Employment Agreement
and fall within the scope of Clause 16 thereof.
35. Any challenge as to whether a particular claim
travels beyond the scope of the arbitration agreement or
- 29 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
falls within the exclusive jurisdiction of the NCLT may be
raised before the Arbitral Tribunal, which shall consider the
same in accordance with law. Thus, the contention of the
respondent that the present petition is liable to be rejected
on the ground of impermissibility of bifurcation of disputes
cannot be accepted.
36. Having regard to the existence of the
Employment Agreement dated 01.10.2018, the arbitration
clause contained in Clause 16 thereof, and the nature of
the disputes raised by the petitioner concerning the
alleged breach of contractual obligations, this Court is of
the considered opinion that a prima facie case is made out
for appointment of an Arbitrator. Hence, the following:
ORDER
a) Civil Miscellaneous Petition is allowed.
b) The Hon’ble Mr.Justice V.Jagannathan, Former
Judge, High Court of Karnataka, is appointed as
the Sole Arbitrator in the present case to
arbitrate the disputes between the parties at
the Arbitration and Conciliation Centre
- 30 -
CMP No. 503 of 2025
(Domestic & International), Bengaluru, as per
the Rules governing the said Arbitration Centre.
c) All the claims and contentions of the parties are
left open.
d) Registry is directed to communicate this order
via e-mail to the Arbitration and Conciliation
Centre (Domestic & International), Khanija
Bhavan, Bengaluru, and also to Hon’ble
Mr.Justice V.Jagannathan.
e) Registry is directed to return all the original
documents produced by any of the parties after
obtaining Photostat copies of the same.
f) Parties are directed to appear before the
Director, Arbitration and Conciliation Centre,
Bengaluru, on 18.12.2026 at 11:30 a.m.
Sd/-
(H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD)
JUDGE
Cm/-