Smt. Sunanda Bhattacharjee vs The State of Tripura and Ors.

Court
Tripura High Court

Page 1 of 8
2026:THC:1555-DB

TRHC010017202026


HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WP(C) NO.706 OF 2026

Smt. Sunanda Bhattacharjee, (Age-58 years)
(For and on behalf of convict Hiranmoy Ghosh,),
W/o- Hiranmoy Ghosh, R/O-Office Tila, Bishalgarh, P.O. &P.S. -
Bishalgarh, District -Sepahijala, Pin-799102.
…… Petitioner ( s )

Versus

1. The State of Tripura,
To be represented by the Secretary, Home Department, Government of
Tripura, New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban,
Agartala, Pin-799010.

2. The Deputy Secretary (Home), Jail Department, Government of Tripura,
New Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex, Kunjaban, Agartala, Pin-
799010

3. The Inspector General of Prison, Government of Tripura, Near old Central
Jail, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.

4. The Superintendent, Kailashar District Jail, Govt. of Tripura, Kailashahar,
Unakoti Tripura.

5. The DM & Collector, Government of Tripura, District- Sepahijala, O/o the
DM & Collector, Sepahijala,

....... Respondent ( s )


For the Petitioner(s) : Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
Ms. A. Debbarma, Advocate.
Mr. D. Paul, Advocate.
Mr. S. Ruhi Das, Advocate.

For the Respondent(s) : Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, G.A.

Page 2 of 8
Date of hearing : 18/11/2026

Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order : 21/11/2026

Whether fit for reporting : YES.


HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R
Dr. T. Amarnath Goud, J.

1. Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned Sr. counsel assisted by
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner as well
as Mr. Raju Datta, learned P.P., and Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, learned
G.A., appearing for the respondents.
2. The brief facts of the case are that the Petitioner filed WP(C)
No.-706 of 2026, before the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura for granting parole
for 30 days w.e.f. 15.11.2026 to 30.12.2026, of her husband namely convict
Hiranmoy Ghosh, on account of marriage ceremony of his niece-Srijita
Sengupta, which is scheduled to be held on 26.11.2026. In the aforesaid writ
petition, the Petitioner contended that for release of the convict Hiranmoy
Ghosh, husband of the Petitioner submitted representations before the
Respondents on 14.07.2026 and 13.08.2026. The respondent No.-5,
Superintendent, District Jail, Kailashahar, Unakoti, Tripura vide the impugned
letter dated 05.08.2026 rejected the claim of the convict for regular parole for a
period of 30 days, relying upon the bar prescribed under Rule 503(h) of the
Tripura Sansodhanagar Rules, 2021, and observed that the convict could avail
emergency parole for a period of up to 48 hours under Rule 501(b) of the said
Rules to attend the marriage ceremony of his niece.
3. Being aggrieved thereby, the petitioner has filed this present
petitioner seeking the following reliefs:-
“A. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or Order/direction shall not be

Page 3 of 8
issued whereby quashing and cancelling the impugned Order dated,
05.08.2026 issued by the Superintendent, District Jail, Kailashahar,
Unakoti, Tripura, whereby cancellingthe regular parole for 30 days in
favour of convict Hiranmoy Ghosh, husband of the Petitioner.
B. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or Order/direction shall not be
issued to declare and read down that Rule 503 (h) of Tripura
Sansodhanagar Rules, 2021 is unconstitutional and illegal insofar as it
relates to the release of the convict on regular parole is concerned.
C. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or Order/direction shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondents to read down Rule 503(h) of
Tripura Sansodhanagar Rules' 2021 to the effect, that, the bar
contemplated under that Rule is not applicable to the husband of the
Petitioner and notwithstanding that bar he is entitled to get regular parole.
D. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why Writ in the nature of mandamus and/or Order/direction shall not be
issued whereby directing the Respondents to grant parole for at least 30
days to convict Hiranmoy Ghosh, w.e.f. 15.11.2026 to 15.12.2026, to
perform Kanyadan Ceremony in the event of marriage scheduled to be held
on 24.11.2026 and other purposes.
E. Make the rules absolute.
F. Call for records.
Pass any further order/orders as this Hon'ble High
Court considers fit and proper.”


4. Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned Senior Counsel, assisted by
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that
the convict has already undergone the sentence of 7 (seven) years imposed
for the offence punishable under the Explosive Substances Act, 1908 read
with Section 149 of the Indian Penal Code, and has therefore served the
sentence awarded for that offence. Learned counsel submits that it is a well-
settled principle of law that a convicted prisoner does not lose all his
fundamental rights upon incarceration. The right to life under Article 21 of
the Constitution of India includes the right to live with dignity and to
maintain meaningful family relationships, subject to reasonable restrictions
imposed by law. Learned counsel further submits that the bar under Rules
501, 502 and 503 of the Tripura Sansodhanagar Rules, 2021 relates to the
sentence under the Explosive Substances Act, and that sentence is already

Page 4 of 8
over. Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel submits that the bar under Rule
503(h), relied upon in the impugned letter, no longer operates, and the
convict is entitled to regular parole. He adds that parole cannot be denied
even in cases of heinous crime. There is no apprehension that the convict
would abscond if released on parole, and there is no report of misconduct
against him in jail. The parole is sought for marriage of her niece and
Kanyadan, which is a family responsibility.
5. To substantiate his argument, learned counsel referred to
Paras 15 to 21 of the judgment reported in (2017) 15 SCC 55 titled as Asfaq
Vs. State of Rajasthan and ors ., titled as Civil Appeal No.10464 of 2017
th
decided on September 11 , 2017 . The same is produced here-in-under:-
“15) A convict, literally speaking, must remain in jail for
the period of sentence or for rest of his life in case he is a life convict.
It is in this context that his release from jail for a short period has to be
considered as an opportunity afforded to him not only to solve his
personal and family problems but also to maintain his links with society.
Convicts too must breathe fresh air for at least some time provided they
maintain good conduct consistently during incarceration and show a
tendency to reform themselves and become good citizens. Thus,
redemption and rehabilitation of such prisoners for good of societies
must receive due weightage while they are undergoing sentence of
imprisonment.
16) This Court, through various pronouncements,
has laid down the differences between parole and furlough, few of which
are as under:
(i) Both parole and furlough are conditional release.
(ii) Parole can be granted in case of short term imprisonment whereas in
furlough it is granted in case of long term imprisonment.
(iii) Duration of parole extends to one month whereas in the case of
furlough it extends to fourteen days maximum.
(iv) Parole is granted by Divisional Commissioner and furlough is
granted by the Deputy Inspector General of Prisons.
(v) For parole, specific reason is required, whereas furlough is meant for
breaking the monotony of imprisonment.
(vi) The term of imprisonment is not included in the computation of the
term of parole, whereas it is vice versa in furlough.
(vii) Parole can be granted number of times whereas there is limitation
in the case of furlough.
(viii) Since furlough is not granted for any particular reason, it can be
denied in the interest of the society.
{See State of Maharashtra and Another v. Suresh Pandurang
Darvakar1 ; and State of Haryana and Others v. Mohinder 1 (2006) 4
SCC 776 Singh2}.

Page 5 of 8
17) From the aforesaid discussion, it follows that amongst the various
grounds on which parole can be granted, the most important ground,
which stands out, is that a prisoner should be allowed to maintain family
and social ties. For this purpose, he has to come out for some time so
that he is able to maintain his family and social contact. This reason
finds justification in one of the objectives behind sentence and
punishment, namely, reformation of the convict. The theory of
criminology, which is largely accepted, underlines that the main
objectives which a State intends to achieve by punishing the culprit are:
deterrence, prevention, retribution and reformation. When we recognise
reformation as one of the objectives, it provides justification for letting of
even the life convicts for short periods, on parole, in order to afford
opportunities to such convicts not only to solve their personal and family
problems but also to maintain their links with the society. Another
objective which this theory underlines is that even such convicts have
right to breathe fresh air, al beit for periods. These gestures on the part
of the State, along with other measures, go a long way for redemption
and rehabilitation of such prisoners. They are ultimately aimed for the
good of the 2 (2000) 3 SCC 394 society and, therefore, are in public
interest.
18) The provisions of parole and furlough, thus, provide for a
humanistic approach towards those lodged in jails. Main purpose of
such provisions is to afford to them an opportunity to solve their
personal and family problems and to enable them to maintain their links
with society. Even citizens of this country have a vested interest in
preparing offenders for successful re-entry into society. Those who leave
prison without strong networks of support, without employment
prospects, without a fundamental knowledge of the communities to
which they will return, and without resources, stand a significantly
higher chance of failure. When offenders revert to criminal activity upon
release, they frequently do so because they lack hope of merging into
society as accepted citizens. Furloughs or parole can help prepare
offenders for success.
19) Having noted the aforesaid public purpose in granting parole or
furlough, ingrained in the reformation theory of sentencing, other
competing public interest has also to be kept in mind while deciding as to
whether in a particular case parole or furlough is to be granted or not.
This public interest also demands that those who are habitual offenders
and may have the tendency to commit the crime again after their release
on parole or have the tendency to become threat to the law and order of
the society, should not be released on parole. This aspect takes care of
other objectives of sentencing, namely, deterrence and prevention. This
side of the coin is the experience that great number of crimes are
committed by the offenders who have been put back in the street after
conviction. Therefore, while deciding as to whether a particular prisoner
deserves to be released on parole or not, the aforesaid aspects have also
to be kept in mind. To put it tersely, the authorities are supposed to
address the question as to whether the convict is such a person who has
the tendency to commit such a crime or he is showing tendency to reform
himself to become a good citizen.
20) Thus, not all people in prison are appropriate for grant of furlough
or parole. Obviously, society must isolate those who show patterns of
preying upon victims. Yet administrators ought to encourage those

Page 6 of 8
offenders who demonstrate a commitment to reconcile with society and
whose behaviour shows that aspire to live as law-abiding citizens. Thus,
parole program should be used as a tool to shape such adjustments.
21) To sum up, in introducing penal reforms, the State that runs the
administration on behalf of the society and for the benefit of the society
at large cannot be unmindful of safeguarding the legitimate rights of the
citizens in regard to their security in the matters of life and liberty. It is
for this reason that in introducing such reforms, the authorities cannot
be oblivious of the obligation to the society to render it immune from
those who are prone to criminal tendencies and have proved their
susceptibility to indulge in criminal activities by being found guilty (by a
Court) of having perpetrated a criminal act. One of the discernible
purposes of imposing the penalty of imprisonment is to render the society
immune from the criminal for a specified period. It is, therefore,
understandable that while meting out humane treatment to the convicts,
care has to be taken to ensure that kindness to the convicts does not
result in cruelty to the society. Naturally enough, the authorities would
be anxious to ensure that the convict who is released on furlough does
not seize the opportunity to commit another crime when he is at large for
the time-being under the furlough leave granted to him by way of a
measure of penal reform.”
6. On the other hand, learned Public Prosecutor submits that
where concurrent sentences are awarded, there is no scope for segregating
them. He submits that if the judgment does not mention whether the
sentences run concurrently or consecutively, then it must be treated as
consecutively and if the sentences run consequtively, it cannot be
determined which sentence runs first, the one under the Explosive
Substances Act or the one under Section 302 IPC (life imprisonment). The
offence is not limited to the Explosive Substances Act but also amounts to
murder. Likewise, if the petitioner's argument that the sentences run
consecutively were accepted, it would be unclear who decides which
sentence is to be undergone first.
7. Learned P.P. further submits that the convict may be
entitled only to emergency parole of 48 hours under the Rules. The
Petitioner has not challenged the Rules, and the Rules are not ultra vires . He
relies on Rule 502(iii) of the Tripura Sansodhanagar Rules, 2021, which
provides that release on parole is not an absolute right, though it is the legal
right of every prisoner subject to the conditions laid down. The Government,
the Head of the Sansodhanagar Department or the Competent Authority
reserves the right to debar or withdraw any prisoner or category of prisoners

Page 7 of 8
from the concession of parole if the prisoner becomes ineligible or violates
the prescribed conditions. Finally, he submits that the marriage is a one-day
event, not one of a month, and the convict is therefore not entitled to regular
parole.
8. We have heard and perused the evidence on record. The
convict was not convicted and sentenced only under the Explosive
Substances Act. He was also convicted for other offences, including Section
302 IPC, for which the sentence is imprisonment for life. The conviction and
sentence arise from the same judgment and must be read as a whole. The
learned P.P. rightly submits that the sentences cannot be bifurcated. If the
sentences are treated as running concurrently, as submitted by the learned
P.P., no sentence can be said to have been fully undergone while the others
remain. If they are treated as consecutively, as the petitioner's argument
would require, it would be unclear which sentence is to be undergone first.
There is no basis to assume that the sentence under the Explosive Substances
Act runs or that under other Sections including Section 302 of IPC. In either
case, the convict cannot be said to have completed his sentence. As such the
argument of the petitioner-counsel that his client has completed sentence of
7(seven) years under Section 3 of the Explosive Substances Act and the
impugned letter dated 05.08.2026 is bad in the eye of the law fails.
9. The learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on the
principle that a prisoner does not lose all his fundamental rights on
incarceration, and that Article 21 includes the right to live with dignity and
to maintain family relationships. That principle is not in dispute. It is,
however, subject to reasonable restrictions imposed by law. Parole is a
statutory concession regulated by the Rules, not an unfettered right. Rule
502(iii) of the Tripura Sansodhanagar Rules, 2021 itself provides that release
on parole is not an absolute right, though it is the legal right of every
prisoner on the conditions laid down. It also reserves to the competent
authority the power to debar any prisoner or category of prisoners from the
concession of parole. The submission that the convict has had good conduct
in jail and that there is no risk of his absconding is not enough to override

Page 8 of 8
the bar under Rule 503(h). The nature of the offence, which includes murder
and not only the offence under the Explosive Substances Act, has also to be
taken into account.
10. However, this Court is sympathetic to the petitioner's wish
to have her husband present at marriage of her niece on 26.11.2026. But, this
Court is also of the opinion the marriage ceremony is a one-day event on
26.11.2026 as per the wedding invitation and does not call for parole of 30
days. Further the Judgment as referred by the petitioner-counsel is not
relevant to the fact of this case.
11. For reasons as stated supra, the contention that the convict
has served his sentence under the Explosive Substances Act and is therefore
entitled to regular parole cannot be accepted. However, concerning the
sympathetic ground as stated above, the impugned letter dated 05.08.2026,
wherein even the emergency parole of 48 hours has not been allowed is set
side and emergency parole of up to 48(forty-eight) hours under Rule 501(b)
to attend the above mentioned marriage ceremony is granted. The petitioner
and the convict can choose the 48 hours and the dates of parole. The Jail
authorities to take all measures with the support of the concerned police
station officials.
12. With the above observation and direction, this present writ
petition stands dismissed. As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.


B. PALIT, J
DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD, J


Suhanjit
RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SINGHA
Digitally signed by RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SINGHA
Date: 2026.11.21 13:58:50 +05'30'