RAMESH G SHAH (DIRECTOR) vs RBL BANK LTD AND ORS

Court
Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal

1

TELECOM DISPUTES SETTLEMENT & APPELLATE TRIBUNAL
NEW DELHI
th
Dated 20 November 2026
Cyber Appeal No. 5 of 2021

Ramesh G. Shah (Director)
(Gujarat) …Petitioner
Vs.
RBL Bank Ltd., and Ors. …Respondent(s)

BEFORE:

HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAM KRISHNA GAUTAM, MEMBER

For Petitioner : Mr. Harsh N Gokhale, Advocate
Mr. Partha Deka, Advocate
For Respondent : Mr Anand Shankar Jha, Advocate & Ms Nandika
Kaushik Advocate for R-1
Mr Rony John, Advocate for R-2
Ms Vasudha Arora, Advocate for R-3
Mr Vivek Ojha, Advocate for R-4
Mr. Gopal Jain, Sr. Advocate,
Mr Kunal Singh, Mr Nitin Kala, Mr. Tanmay Jain
Advocates for R-6 & R-7
Ms Pratima N Lakra & Mr Shailendra Kumar
Mishra, Advocates for R-9


2

JUDGMENT

1. This Appeal, under Section 57, of the Information Technology Act, 2000,
read with Section 14(c) of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
Act, 1997, has been filed by Ramesh G. Shah, Director, against RBL Bank
Limited and Others, against Impugned Order, dated 31.03.2021, passed
by the Learned Adjudicating Officer, under Information and Technology
Act, 2000, in Special Civil Complaint No. 8/2019, wherein the Learned
Adjudicating Officer has levied a penalty only of Rs. 2,00,000/- (Rupees
Two Lakhs Only) on Vodafone Idea Limited, Respondent No. 6 herein,
and had written "I still cannot ignore the fact that concerned franchisee
working under the trust of M/s Vodafone Idea Ltd., issued duplicate SIM
to unauthorised person which resulted in all these unauthorised
transactions causing loss after recovery of remaining amount. If the
franchisee of M/s Vodafone Idea Ltd., has been more diligent in
verifying identity of the person seeking the duplicate SIM, this loss could
have been avoided. I also consider the fact that this negligent on the
part of franchisee of M/s Vodafone Idea Ltd., has resulted in
compromise of the OTP based authentication." The loss suffered by
Complainant was about Rs. 82,00,000/- (Rupees Eighty Two Lakhs
Only), and after this complaint, as well as a complaint at Police

3

regarding the Cyber Crime, a recovery of some part was made, and the
remaining loss was of about Rs. 43,00,000/-(Rupees Forty Three Lakhs
Only). But, the penalty imposed, and was directed to be paid by
Telecom Service Provider(TSP), was of only Rs. 2,00,000/-. Nothing was
there, for remaining about Rs. 41,00,000/- (Rupees Forty One Lakhs
Only), and for this enhancement of above awarded
compensation/penalty, this appeal has been filed by Complainant
victim - Appellant. No appeal by Telecom Service Provider got filed.
Rather, Rs. 2,00,000/- got deposited and no appeal by Banks. The initial
Bank, in which account of Complainant was there, as well as
subsequent Banks, through whom the amount was withdrawn, by way
of siphoning by fraudsters, were not held liable in the Judgment. Hence,
in the present appeal, the Banks have been arrayed as Respondents.
This Appellate Forum, vide its Order, dated 04.08.2026, had specifically
narrowed the sphere of this appeal, that this appeal is with regard to
prayer for enhancement of compensation and is to be heard as such.
This appeal may be either allowed, and compensation may be
enhanced, or it may be dismissed. Hence, the appeal is to be heard on
merits.

4

2. From the very perusal of the Impugned Judgment, it is apparent that
the same is with no finding, or reason for coming to conclusion for
awarding Rs. 2,00,000/-, against Telecom Service Provider(TSP), and
keeping mum for the rest of huge amount of Rs. 30,00,000/- (Rupees
Thirty Lakhs Only), which was suffered by Complainant Company, and
for enhancement of which, this appeal has been filed by Complainant.
Hence, apparently the Order had been assailed by Complainant -
Appellant, and the same is being assailed by the Telecom Service
Provider too.

3. The facts pleaded before Learned Adjudicating Officer, and the
evidences led there at, had not been discussed, in this Impugned
Judgment. The relief was claimed against the Respondents, with
narration of facts and the damages claimed was Rs. 1,64,000,00/-
(Rupees One Crore Sixty Four Lakhs Only). The reply filed before
Learned Adjudicating Officer by the Respondents there at, were with
specific facts written in them. The points for determination by Learned
Adjudicating Officer, was to be framed and evidences led there at, was
to be considered and written in the judgment, as a reason for coming
to above conclusion by Learned Adjudicating Officer. But, apparently
there is no reason in the Impugned Judgment. Merely, a conclusion is

5

there, that too, in a cryptic way, by way of awarding Rs. 2,00,000/- and
keeping mum for remaining siphoned money. The liability of RBL Bank,
which was having the account of the Complainant, and from which
money was siphoned. The guidelines and directions issued by Reserve
Bank of India (RBI), with regard to expected practices and procedure for
securing the confidential personal data of the account holder, and all
endeavour with regard to perjury, fraud, illegal siphoning of money, by
way of a Cyber crime, was to be considered, but, no such discussion is
there in the Impugned Judgment. Neither, above Bank was held liable,
nor was exonerated from its liability by a cogent and reasoned order.
The alleged negligence of complainant, written in a line at the end of
Judgment, is also with no finding and evidences with a discussion in this
regard. Hence, the Impugned Judgment is to be set aside and file is to
be remanded back to Learned Adjudicating Officer, Gandhi Nagar,
Gujarat, for making afresh adjudication, and passing Order with a
detailed reason, analysis of the facts pleaded, and evidences led there
at, with a specific finding, regarding the liability of Banks, liability of
Telecom Service Provider(TSP), and liability of Complainant itself.

4. Hence, the Appellant - Complainant is suffering since 2021, wherein the
Complaint was filed in 2019, and this agony could not be redressed

6

adequately. Hence, a direction to Learned Adjudicating Officer, Gandhi
Nagar, Gujarat, for making earliest disposal of this Complaint,
preferably within a period of six months, from the date of receipt of this
Order, will be mandatory. The Learned Adjudicating Officer will not be
with any bias, because of this Judgment, of this Appellate Court, which
is being passed not on the merits of the case.

5. With above direction, this appeal is being allowed. Impugned Judgment
is being set aside. File is being remanded back to Learned Adjudicating
Officer, Gandhi Nagar, Gujarat, for making adjudication and disposal in
accordance with the time frame, and observations given above. Parties
to appear before Learned Adjudicating Officer on 07.01.2027.


….......………………
(Justice Ram Krishna Gautam)
Member
20.11.2026
/NC/