Greater Mohali Area Development Authority (Gmada), vs The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission,
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
1
CWP-35650-2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
107
CWP-35650 of 2026 (O&M)
Reserved on: 31.10.2026
Pronounced on: 18.11.2026
Uploaded on 20.11.2026
Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or the full judgment is pronouned: Full judgment
GREATER MOHALI AREA DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
(GMADA)
…..Appellant
V/S
THE NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL
COMMISSION, NEW DELHI AND ANOTHER.
… Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUVIR SEHGAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH GAUR
Present: Mr. Pradeep Sharma, Advocate for the petitioner.
RAJESH GAUR, J.
1. The petitioner has invoked the jurisdiction of this Court under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, challenging the order dated
26.03.2024 (Annexure P-5) passed by the National Consumer Disputes
Redressal Commission, New Delhi (hereinafter referred to as ‘National
Commission’), the order dated 22.09.2016 (Annexure P-4) passed by the State
Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Punjab (hereinafter referred to as
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.20 11:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2
CWP-35650-2026
‘State Commission’) and the order dated 01.08.2014 (Annexure P-3) passed by
the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Mohali, whereby the
complaint preferred by respondent No.2-Harwinder Kaur Gill before the
District Forum, was allowed and the appeal and revision preferred by the
petitioner-GMADA before the State Commission and National Commission
were dismissed.
2. The facts necessary for deciding the controversy are that
Harwinder Kaur Gill-respondent No.2, applied for allotment of freehold
residential plot measuring 400 square yards and deposited a sum of
Rs.1,50,000/- towards registration. She was declared successful in the draw of
lots held on 30.03.2001. The letter of intent issued on the same date fixed the
tentative price of the plot at Rs.15,00,000/-, calculated at the rate of Rs.3,750/-
per square yards. Respondent No.2 was required to deposit 15% of the
tentative price, amounting to Rs.2,25,000/-, which was deposited on
24.05.2001.
3. Thereafter, fresh allotment proceedings took place on 16.05.2008,
pursuant to which respondent No.2 was issued an allotment letter dated
25.09.2008, allotting plot No.1086 (Corner), Sector 77, Mohali. Thereafter,
vide letter dated 02.02.2009, the tentative price of the plot was revised to
Rs.18,45,937/- on account of an additional area measuring 47.50 square yards.
An additional amount of approximately Rs.86,485/- was deposited by the
allottee, while the remaining sale consideration was payable in accordance
with the prescribed instalment schedule.
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.20 11:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
3
CWP-35650-2026
4. Clause 11 of the allotment letter required the allottee to take
possession of the allotted site within 60 days from the issuance of the
allotment letter. GMADA has relied upon the aforesaid provision to contend
that possession was liable to be treated as deemed to have been delivered.
5. However, the aforesaid clause cannot be read in isolation. A
stipulation requiring an allottee to take possession necessarily presupposes that
the authority is itself in a position to deliver possession of an identifiable,
demarcated and legally available plot. A contractual provision relating to
deemed possession cannot be invoked to create a fiction contrary to the actual
state of affairs, particularly where the authority itself was unable to hand over
possession on account of litigation affecting the land.
6. The record shows that respondent No.2 submitted a written
request dated 17.02.2009, seeking delivery of possession of the allotted plot.
However, there is nothing on record to establish that GMADA, in response to
the aforesaid request, issued any communication fixing a date for delivery of
physical possession or requiring the allottee to appear for taking possession of
a duly demarcated and available site.
7. On the contrary, the material considered by the State Commission
reveals that the land falling in Sectors 76 to 80, Mohali, was affected by
litigation and an order of stay was passed by this Court. The development
work in the area was also not completed. The reports relied upon by GMADA
itself refer to the position regarding feasibility of the plots, sewerage facilities,
storm-water drainage and the necessity of verification of the stay order passed
by this Court.
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.20 11:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
4
CWP-35650-2026
8. It is in this background that the subsequent conduct of GMADA
assumes significance. Vide communication dated 04.04.2012, GMADA
demanded Rs.2,58,429/- towards instalment and Rs.9,346/- towards penal
interest, making a total of Rs.2,67,775/-. The said amount was deposited by
respondent No.2 on 30.04.2012. No demand towards non-construction charges
was reflected in that communication.
9. Thereafter, respondent No.2 applied for issuance of a ‘No Dues
Certificate’ in August 2012. However, vide communication dated 21.09.2012,
GMADA raised a demand of Rs.2,25,222/- towards non-construction charges,
besides Rs.213/- towards interest. The property ledger dated 10.10.2012 also
reflected a balance of amount of Rs.213/-. Notwithstanding the same, a further
demand of Rs.2,70,266/- towards non-construction charges was raised on
06.11.2012. The allottee submitted a representation dated 20.11.2012,
requesting withdrawal of the aforesaid charges. The demand was nevertheless
enhanced and, vide communication dated 14.03.2013, GMADA demanded
Rs.4,16,726/- towards non-construction charges and declined to issue the ‘No
Dues Certificate’.
10. It is not in dispute that actual physical possession of the
demarcated plot was delivered to respondent No.2 only on 02.04.2013. The
demand of Rs.4,16,726/- had already been demanded before that date. The
record further reveals that respondent No.2 deposited the aforesaid amount on
19.03.2013 in connection with obtaining approval of the building plan.
Permission for occupation/use of one living unit on the ground floor was
subsequently issued on 30.05.2013.
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.20 11:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
5
CWP-35650-2026
11. The aforesaid facts are material. Respondent No.2 had sought
possession on 17.02.2009, whereas actual physical possession was delivered
only on 02.04.2013, i.e. after a lapse of more than four years. During this
intervening period, the allottee was being required to discharge her financial
obligations, while GMADA had not fulfilled the corresponding obligation of
delivering physical possession of the allotted plot.
12. Learned counsel for the petitioner has contended that the allottee
was required to raise construction within three years from the date of issuance
of the allotment letter under clause 13 and that non-construction charges, were,
therefore, recoverable. He has further submitted that the plot was feasible, that
respondent No.2 failed to take possession within the prescribed period and the
Consumer Fora could not have interfered with the charges imposed under the
terms and conditions of allotment.
13. We have heard learned counsel for the petitioner and have
perused the record with his able assistance.
14. The precise question that arises for consideration is whether
GMADA can legitimately penalize the allottee by levying non-construction
charges for failure to raise construction on the allotted plot, when GMADA
itself had failed to deliver physical possession of the plot within the stipulated
period, thereby depriving the allottee of an opportunity to raise construction.
15. To examine the aforesaid issue, it would be necessary to advert to
the relevant facts and the terms and conditions of allotment. Respondent No.2
was allotted plot No.1086 (Corner), Sector 77, Mohali, vide allotment letter
dated 25.09.2008, followed by revised allotment letter dated 02.02.2009. As
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.20 11:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
6
CWP-35650-2026
per the terms and conditions stipulated in the allotment letter, the allottee was
required to take possession of the allotted plot within a period of 60 days and
complete construction thereon within three years.
It is borne out from the record that respondent No.2, vide
communication dated 17.02.2009, requested GMADA to deliver physical
possession of the allotted plot. However, despite the aforesaid request,
physical possession of the plot was handed over to respondent No.2 only on
02.04.2013, i.e. after a lapse of more than four years from the date of
allotment.
16. At this stage, it is pertinent to notice the stand taken by GMADA
itself. The authority has referred to the stay granted by this Court concerning
the land falling in Sectors 76 to 80, Mohali, and incomplete development
works in Sector 77, Mohali. At the same time, GMADA contends that
respondent No.2 failed to raise construction within the period prescribed under
the allotment letter.
17. These two stands require examination together. If the
development of the area was affected by pending litigation and the plot could
not be handed over to the allottee, it remains unexplained how the allottee
could have been expected to commence construction during that very period.
18. The reliance placed by GMADA upon the deemed possession
clause also requires consideration. The stipulation requiring the allottee to take
possession within a period of 60 days cannot, by itself, establish that
possession was actually offered or that the plot was available for construction.
Respondent No.2 had specifically sought possession on 17.02.2009. No
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.20 11:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
7
CWP-35650-2026
communication has been shown, whereby GMADA informed her that the plot
was ready for delivery and called upon her to take possession thereof. The
subsequent delivery of physical possession of 02.04.2013 assumes significance
in this regard.
19. The State Commission, while examining the matter in appeal,
also considered the reports relating to the feasibility and development of the
plot, as well as the factum of pending litigation. It noticed that the allottee had
sought possession, but the authority had failed to establish that possession was
offered to her. The National Commission, while exercising revisional
jurisdiction, found no ground to interfere with the findings recorded by the
Fora below.
20. In these circumstances, the obligation to raise construction cannot
be considered independently of the delivery of possession. An allottee could
be held responsible for non-construction only if the plot had been made
available to her and she had failed to raise construction despite having a
reasonable opportunity to do so. Where delivery of possession itself remains
undelivered, the mere expiry of construction period stipulated in the allotment
letter would not, by itself, establish a default attributable to the allottee.
21. Viewed in this light, the demand of Rs.4,16,726/- raised vide
communication dated 14.03.2013, prior to the delivery of physical possession
on 02.04.2013, cannot be justified on the ground of failure to raise
construction. GMADA cannot attribute to respondent No.2 a default arising
from circumstances which prevented her from undertaking construction in the
first place.
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.20 11:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
8
CWP-35650-2026
22. Consequently, the writ petition is dismissed. The directions issued
by the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Mohali, as upheld by the
State Commission and the National Commission, shall remain operative and
enforceable in accordance with their terms.
23. All pending civil miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also
stand disposed of.
(SUVIR SEHGAL) (RAJESH GAUR)
JUDGE JUDGE
18.11.2026
Kamal Gandhi
Whether speaking Yes
Whether reportable Yes
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.20 11:02
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document