Bull Agro Implements vs Ashlyn Antony

Court
Madras High Court

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on:26.10.2026 Pronounced on: 13.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE P.B. BALAJI
OP (PT) No.4 of 2024
1.M/s.Bull Agro Implements,
Represented by its Partner
Mr.R.Chandramohan, 200/IB6, Trichy Road,
Kannampalayam Post, RavathurPirivu,
Coimbatore 641 402, Tamil Nadu.
2.Mr.R.Chandramohan,
Partner, M/s.Bull Agro Implements,
200/IB6, Trichy Road, Kannampalyam Post,
RavathurPirivu,
Coimbatore 641 402, Tamil Nadu.
3. Mrs.C.Nivashini,
Partner, M/s.Bull Agro Implements,
200/IB6, Trichy Road,
Kannampalyam Post,
RavathurPirivu,
Coimbatore 641 402, Tamil Nadu.
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1.Ashlyn Antony
Having its office at
Redlands Ashlyn Motors PLC,
2/575, Madukkarai Road,
Malumichampatti, Coimbatore - 641 050.
(Amended as per order fated 03.12.2024 made
in (PT) A No.8 of 2024 in OP (PT) No.4 of 2024)
2. The Deputy Controller of Patents & Designs,
The Patent Office Intellectual Property Building,
GST Road, Guindy, Chennai 600 032.
..Respondent(s)
__________
Page1 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
PRAYER: This Original Petition is filed under the Patents Act, 1970, to revoke
st nd
the patent of the 1 respondent, which was granted by the 2 respondent,
bearing Patent No.458805.
For Appellant(s): Mr.Sruya Senthil
and Shubham Mathew George
for M/s.Surana & Surana
For Respondent(s): Mr.Dinesh Jothwani for R1
Mr.P.G.Santhosh Kumar,
Senior Panel Counsel for R2
ORDER
The petitioners have filed the instant original petition to revoke the patent
st nd
of the 1 respondent which was granted by the 2 respondent in Patent No.
458805.
Brief summary of the petition for revocation filed under Section 64 of the
patents Act, 1970 are as follows:
2. The impugned patent application titled “Baler for tying round blade
using twine” was favourably considered and granted on 12.10.2023 in Patent
st
No. 458805. The 1 respondent, pursuant to the said grant had issued a cease-
and-desist notice dated 22.01.2024 calling upon the petitioners to stop
st
infringing the registered patent granted to the 1 respondent. The petitioners
sent a reply dated 15.02.2024 (since the cease and desist notice itself was sent
on 22.01.2024, it cannot be 15.02.2023, as mentioned in the reply) contending
__________
Page2 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
st
that the 1 respondent’s patent is devoid of any novelty and that there are prior
arts and that it is used commonly in industry for over a decade, even before
st
filing the patent of the impugned patent. The 1 respondent claims monopoly
based on a non-existing invention. The mechanism for tying bales has been
st
prevalent long before the 1 respondent had even applied for patent and the
same is evident from patent and non-patent literature, as well as prior arts in
st
existence, prior to the alleged invention of the 1 respondent.
3. The petitioners have been engaged in agricultural mechanical
implements field for more than 25 years and have even made a technically
advanced strong straw baler. Petitioners have been manufacturing baler
machines for over 8 years and in fact, in 2017, the petitioner, on considerable
research and development has invented a technically advanced baler machine
and has applied for patent registration. It took the petitioners 4 years to come up
with a safer baler machine which protected the farmers from physical injury or
harm to their hands, while operating the baler machine. The petitioner’s
conceptualisation has also been fruitful with a sale of over 1000 machines and
st
the same also being put to commercialisation successfully. The 1 respondent
has obtained patent with no intention to commercialise the impugned patent and
st
the 1 respondent has not even produced a single machine, though has obtained
st
grant of impugned patent. The 1 respondent is attempting to monopolise the
mechanism and hinder the market with ulterior motives of depriving the
__________
Page3 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
petitioners and the like from getting their inventions registered. Contending that
the petitioner is an interested person under Section 2(t) of the Patents Act, 1970,
the original petition has been filed seeking revocation of the patent granted to
st
the 1 respondent.
st
Summary of the counter of the 1 respondent:
st
4. The patent granted to the 1 respondent is an integrated combination of a
chain drive on a link plate, a side backstop clutch that holds the twine at one end
for the next cycle, and a blade mounted beneath that clutch which cuts at a set
bale density and stops the twine. The said patent was granted by the Controller
after a thorough examination was made. The present original petition has been
st
filed only as a counter blast after the 1 respondent had issued a cease-and-
desist notice to the petitioner alleging infringement of the patent granted in
st
favour of the 1 respondent. Though the petitioners claim to have been in the
market for 25 years and have made balers for 8 years, the petitioners have
chosen to challenge the patent only after they were called upon to stop the
infringement by way of cease-and-desist notice dated 22.01.2024. Petitioners
have not come to Court with clean hands. All the prior arts that have been cited
and relied upon by the petitioners do not disclose the features put together
namely, a side backstop clutch that holds the twine at one end for the next cycle,
with a blade mounted beneath it that cuts it at a set density and stops the twine.
Therefore, none of the prior arts can come in the way of the patent being
__________
Page4 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
st
granted, rightly, by the Controller, to the 1 respondent. The prior arts also do
st
not come in the way of the combination invented by the 1 respondent being
obvious in view of the unknown technical effects that have been brought about
st
by the 1 respondent in the granted patent.
st
5. The allegations of the petitioner that the 1 respondent is attempting to
monopolise the basic mechanism for tying bales is hit by Section 64(1)(d) and it
not amounting to an invention is also denied, contending that, in the baler
st
machine invented by the 1 respondent, the advancing new features are capable
of industrial application and therefore would clearly amount to an invention
under Section 2(1)(j) of the Act and certainly involves an inventive step. It was
further contended that petition offers no expert, experiment or attempt showing
st
that a skilled person tried to build a baler and failed. The 1 respondent
therefore prays for dismissal of the revocation petition with costs.
6. This Hon’ble Court, by order dated 17.06.2025, framed the following
issues:
i. Whether the impugned patent is liable to be revoked on the ground
that the invention was publicly known before the priority date of the
claim?
ii. Whether the impugned patent is liable to be revoked on the ground of
lack of novelty?
__________
Page5 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
iii. Whether the impugned patent is liable to be revoked on the ground of
lack of inventive step?
iv. Whether the impugned patent is liable to be revoked on the ground
that the complete specification does not sufficiently and fairly describe
the invention?
v. Whether the petitioners are entitled to the relief claimed?
vi. Whether the parties are entitled to any other relief?
7. Both parties chose to not lead any oral evidence, excepting for filing
their respective affidavits of admission and denial with regard to the documents
st
that have been relied on by the petitioner and 1 respondent.
8. Heard Mr. Surya Senthil, learned counsel for petitioners and
st
Mr.Dinesh Jothwani, learned counsel for the 1 respondent and Mr.
P.G.Santhosh Kumar, learned Senior Panel Counsel, Central Government, for
nd
the 2 respondent.
Submissions of Mr. Surya Senthil are summarised as hereunder:
st
9. The 1 respondent’s claim is not new and there is nothing inventive
about it. The very same objectives have been sufficiently addressed by earlier
prior arts which have been prevailing in the agricultural industry for several
__________
Page6 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
st
decades together, before even the 1 respondent’s application for the impugned
patent. 12 prior arts have been cited to show that there is no invention or
st
inventive step in the claim of the 1 respondent. The mechanism employed in
st
the patent granted to the 1 respondent has been adopted with same features,
including blade sprocket movement of twine in prior art 11 and there is nothing
st
novel in the claim for grant of patent made by the 1 respondent and it was only
an obvious existing mechanism that was adopted. Even the claim of stopping
mechanism in the impugned patent is not new, but has been anticipated in the
prior arts as well.
10. Further there is insufficient disclosure and the complete specification
does not fairly describe the invention in the impugned patent specification.
Therefore, even applying Section 64(1)(h) of the Patents Act, 1970, the claim of
invention cannot be sustained. For being obvious, the claim of the complete
specification is also hit by Section 64(1)(f) as well, since the mechanism has
st
been publicly known and published even prior to the claim made by the 1
respondent. Further, the claim of the complete specification is not even based on
the disclosed material in these specifications and even under Section 64(1)(i),
the patent is liable to be revoked. Relying on Section 64(1)(d), Mr. Surya
st
Senthil states that the 1 respondent, by obtaining the patent, is attempting to
only monopolise a basic mechanism of tying bales which has been in common
practice and within public knowledge and therefore, even on this ground,
__________
Page7 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
according to Mr. Surya Senthil, the patent cannot be sustained.
Submissions of Mr. Dinesh Jothwani are summarised as hereunder:
11. The petition itself has been filed only as a counter blast after receipt of
st
the cease-and-desist notice issued by the 1 respondent. If the petitioners have
really been in the field as claimed, for 2 decades and have been manufacturing
baler machines from 2017 onwards, there was no reason why the petitioners
remained quiet all along and chose to lay their first challenge only after the
st
cease-and-desist notice was issued by the 1 respondent. In fact, the petitioners
nd
cannot even claim lack of knowledge since the 2 petitioner’s application for
st
patent has already been opposed by the 1 respondent and the notice and reply
notice have already been exchanged prior to the verification of the present
original petition. It is therefore contended that the petitioners have suppressed
material facts and have approached this court with unclean hands.
12. He would further state that though as many as 12 prior arts have been
st
cited against the claimed patent invented by the 1 respondent, none of such
prior arts disclosed new features and advancements found in the impugned
patent. He would take me through each of the prior arts to contend that the
st st
patent granted in favour of the 1 respondent was only invented by the 1
__________
Page8 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
respondent, with new and advance features. Therefore, none of the prior arts can
st
be cited against the 1 respondent. As far as the objections under Section 64(1)
st
(f), the 1 respondent has shown that the combination is not obvious, since the
st
claimed combination in the patent granted by 1 respondent produces a
technical effect which none of the prior arts addressed. The learned counsel
further brought to my notice that the following 3 features which stand out in the
combination and invention claimed, namely:
i. twine held at one end for the next cycle
ii. winding initiated from the centre
iii. the density-triggered cut that stops twine movement
13. He would further state, with regard to the objections under Section
64(1)(d) that the patent granted is not an invention, claim 1 is only for an
st
apparatus and not for a process claim and the said machine invented by the 1
respondent, is certainly capable of industrial application and would clearly fall
within the definition of invention under Section 2(1)(j) of the Patent Act, 1970
containing new and inventive steps.
14. As regards insufficient disclosure in the specifications and objections
st
raised under Section 64(1)(h), the learned counsel for the 1 respondent states
__________
Page9 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
that the specifications sufficiently describe the structure and operations and
even the averments in the original petition make out a case that the petitioners
have understood the specifications in the right perspective. He would further
state that the test is to only see whether the complete specification sufficiently
and fairly describes the invention and the methods by which it is to be
performed to the extent that a person in India, of average skill and knowledge in
the art, can work it and that the specifications disclose the best method known
to the applicant, for which the protection is claimed. In this regard, he would
state that every new feature has been described in claims 1 to 7 in the complete
specification and therefore the allegation of insufficient disclosure under
Section 64(1)(h) is without any merit.
15. As regards the objection raised under Section 64(1)(i) that the claim is
not clear and not fairly based on any specification, the learned counsel Mr.
Dinesh Jothwani, contends that excepting for a pleading that there is no
particular or material disclosed to expand the one sentence plea as to how claim
1 is unclear or as to which feature lacks support. In any event, it is his
contention that claim 1 defines each component clearly and there is nothing
unclear about it. He would also state that all features of claim 1 to 7 appear in
the description as well.
st
16. As regards the objection that the 1 respondent has not marketed the
__________
Page10 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
invention, the learned counsel relies on Section 146(2) of the Patents Act, 1970
read with Rule 131 of the Patents Rules, 2003. Section 146(2) and Rule 131
have been extracted below for convenience.
Section 146(2):
“ (2) Without prejudice to the provisions of sub-section (1), every patentee and
every licensee (whether exclusive or otherwise) shall furnish in such manner
and form and at such intervals (not being less than six months) as may be
prescribed statements as to the extent to which the patented invention has been
worked on a commercial scale in India.”
Rule 131:
Form and manner in which statements required under section 146(2) to be
furnished
(1) The statements shall be furnished by every patentee and every licensee
under sub-section (2) of section 146 in Form 27 which shall be duly verified by
the patentee or the licencee or his authorised agent.
(2) The statements referred to in sub-rule (1) shall be furnished once in respect
of every period of three financial years starting from the financial year
commencing immediately after the financial year in which the patent was
granted, and shall be furnished within six months from the expiry of such
period. Provided that the Controller may condone the delay or extend the time
in filing of such statement for a period up to three months upon a request made
in Form 4.
(3) The Controller may publish the information received by him under sub-
section (1) or sub-section (2) of section 146.
17. He would therefore state that when the patent was granted only on
12.10.2023, the statement is due only by 30.09.2027 and therefore the allegation
regarding non-working and seeking to revoke the patent on this ground is
__________
Page11 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
premature. It is his further submission that non-working is not even a ground for
revocation under Section 64(1) and it is only addressed under compulsory
licensing provisions contained under Section 85(1) of the Patents Act, 1970.
18. Lastly, he would submit that none of the cited prior arts are similar to
st
the patent of the 1 respondent and the learned Controller of the Patents has
thoroughly examined the said prior arts and came to a definite conclusion that
there is no similarity with any of the earlier disclosed prior arts and therefore the
st
1 respondent was entitled to the grant of patent. The learned counsel would
therefore, pray for the original petition being dismissed.
19. I have carefully considered the submissions advanced by the learned
counsel on either side. I have also gone through the pleadings, the documents
filed on either side and as well as the written submission, supplemented by oral
arguments advanced before me.
20. In the backdrop of the issues already framed by this Court it would
suffice to decide issue numbers 1- 4. For the sake of convenience, issues 1 to 3
are taken up together and issue 4 is dealt with separately.
ISSUES 1 – 3:
__________
Page12 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
21. The primordial submissions of Mr. Surya Senthil, learned counsel for
st
the petitioner, is that the patent that has been granted to 1 respondent is based
on an alleged invention which was already publicly known and was in place
st
even before the date of application for patent was made by the 1 respondent. It
is also contended that there is no novelty or inventive step in the impugned
patent.
22. For deciding these issues together, I have to first understand the actual
st
claim for invention in respect of which patent has been granted to the 1
st
respondent. According to the 1 respondent, the patent involves an integrated
combination of a chain drive on a link plate, a side backstop clutch that holds
the twine at one end for the next cycle, and a blade mounted beneath that clutch
which cuts at a set bale density and stops the twine. It is the specific argument
st
for the learned counsel for the 1 respondent that none of the prior arts that are
st
now being cited against the 1 respondent’s invention, have adopted or even
st
disclosed the combination that has been invented by the 1 respondent.
Therefore, I have to test the 12 prior arts and see whether there is any new
st st
inventive step or novelty claimed by the 1 respondent, thereby entitling the 1
respondent to grant of a patent. I have to also see whether there is any teaching
in place that would lead a skilled person to merely assemble it, thereby
st
depriving the 1 respondent from claiming the patent. Lastly, I have to see
whether any of the grounds for revocation have been made out under Section
__________
Page13 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
64(1) of the Patents Act, 1970.
23. In this backdrop, I also have to keep in mind, the conduct of the
st
parties. The patent has been granted to the 1 respondent on 12.10.2023,
st
subsequent to which the 1 respondent has alleged infringement of its patent and
issued a cease-and-desist notice to the petitioners. Admittedly, the above
original petition has been filed only after receipt of the cease-and-desist notice.
nd
It is also relevant to keep in mind that in the interregnum period, the 2
st
petitioner’s patent application has been opposed by the 1 respondent as well.
Though this aspect may not be really significant in deciding the revocation
petition, at best it may be an additional factor that this Court may weigh, while
arriving at the final conclusion.
st
24. Having discussed the invention and novelty claimed by 1 respondent,
I will see whether the 12 prior arts have adopted the same mechanism or
combination earlier. If I am able to come to a conclusion that the combination
that has been invented by the petitioner is not relatable to any of the prior arts
and that additionally, there is no literature available to a skilled person to arrive
st
at this combination, then the 1 respondent is entitled to retain its patent.
25. Coming to the 12 prior arts, in prior art 1, in US41332584A dated
09.01.1979, it is a device invented for helically winding twine around a bale
__________
Page14 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
with a movably mounted twine guide assembly, a cutter operated by movement
of the guide assembly, and a guide support moving in a straight path parallel to
the bale axis. This prior art does not disclose a backstop clutch holding the
twine for the next cycle and in this prior art, there is no blade beneath the clutch
leave alone a density triggered cut. Coming to prior art 2 in US4563854A dated
14.01.1986, it is a round baler with a binding tape supply, a pivotable blade
holder, tape advancing rollers, a hydraulic piston-cylinder and a drive chain
over deflection rollers. However, even in this prior art, there is no side backstop
st
clutch and no blade beneath one. which is new feature invented by 1
respondent.
26. In prior arts 3 (US4956968A dated 18.09.1990) and 4 (US5036642A
dated 06.08.1991) also, there are balers with a sledge assembly carrying
dispensing means for sheet material wrapped around the bale. However, the
mechanism of twine winding or chain drive on a link plate and clutch holding
the twine are absent as in the case of the granted patent. Coming to prior art 5 in
US5054387A dated 08.10.1991, it is a twine based wrapping apparatus with a
feed roller, a knife, actuator means, a twine arm on the tongue, and two links
with a crank lever where the twine is fed by driven roller and cut by a knife
st
operated through links. The 1 respondent’s claim however has an additional
chain drive on a link plate with no side backstop clutch and no blade beneath.
__________
Page15 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
27. Prior art 6 in US5479766A dated 02.01.1996, is a baling apparatus
with a bale chamber loaded from beneath, periodic compression means and
retractable supporting means. The said prior art does not involve any twine at
all. In prior arts 7 in US5581973A dated 10.12.1996, it is a round baler with a
web-material dispensing assembly, pivoting insertion means and grasping tips.
Prior art 8 in US5581976A dated 10.12.1996 is a method that dispenses a web
and also twine, cut by the same transverse cutting means. These prior arts do not
disclose any chain drive on link plate or a clutch holding the twine or blade
st
beneath it as in the case of the granted patent to the 1 respondent.
28. Prior art 9 in US5941166A dated 24.08.1999 is a twine wrapping
arrangement with a longitudinally moving twine guide, a twine outlet, a cutting
knife, and a groove shaper that cuts a circumferential groove in the bale to
receive the final wrap. This prior art 10 in US6021622A dated 08.02.2000 also
does not involve any clutch and blade beneath it as in the case of the invention
st
of the 1 respondent. Prior art 10 is a baler where wrapping material is
dispensed through a slot between two transverse tolls with a feed-assist element.
Admittedly, wrapping material, not twine tied by any chain drive. Further, there
st
is no clutch or blade beneath as in the invention of the 1 respondent.
29. In prior art 11 in US20020005097A1 dated 17.01.2002, it is an
apparatus for severing the twine from a finished bale held by a tractor’s grapple
__________
Page16 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
arms: a slide bar, a blade riding on it, and a motor coupled to the blade.
However, as rightly contended by Mr. Dinesh Jothwani, learned counsel for the
st
1 respondent, I find that prior art 11 is only a post-baling twine severing device
and it cannot be compared to a baler’s tying mechanism, which is the subject
st
matter of the patent granted to the 1 respondent. In any event, prior art 11 also
does not have any side backstop clutch or holding of the twine at one end or the
next cycle or a cut triggered by blade density also stopping of the twine
movement. It is also driven by the blade side from the motor and not a chain
drive on a link plate carries the twine to the centre of the bale as in the case of
st
the 1 respondent’s invention.
30. In so far as last prior art 12, in EP1882409B1 dated 30.01.2008, it is a
clamping device for a round baler, a duck bill assembly with a pair of plates
gripping wrapping material and moving between an advanced and a retracted
position, a cutting device located between the retracted duck bill position and
the bale-forming position, and a clamping device urging the plates together
between wrapping cycles. It is the contention of Mr. Surya Senthil that the duck
st
bill is nothing but the backstop clutch that is claimed to be invented by the 1
respondent. However, as rightly pointed by Mr. Dinesh Jothwani, prior art 12 is
entirely different in the sense that it has no chain drive on a link plate and also
does not stop a twine movement during cutting. Further, even the cutter
employed in prior art 12 is a separate cutting device whereas in claim 1 in the
__________
Page17 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
granted patent, the blade is mounted beneath the clutch and cuts at a set bale
density.
31. As regards duck bill grips, it grips web material between plates urged
together by a clamping device. However, in the invention of the patent granted
st
to the 1 respondent, the clutch is a catcher body and there is a lock plate bolted
by spring-loaded pins, opened by a lever at the pre-determined bale density and
closed again at the end of the link plate to catch and hold the twine. Therefore,
in view of the above discussion, certainly there are new and innovative features.
Though they may be a combination of some features already existing in the
field and known publicly, when the particular combination that has been
invented is certainly novel and capable of industrial application, I do not see
st
why the 1 respondent should be declined the grant of patent. I find that there
are new technical advancements and novelties over the prior arts put against the
st
1 respondent.
32. I have also carefully gone through the Controller’s decision to grant
st
patent to the 1 respondent. The order is a well-considered and comprehensive
order, discussing all relevant aspects. Therefore, I am unable to see any grounds
st
arising to revoke the patent grant to the 1 respondent under Sections 64 (1)(f)
and (d).
__________
Page18 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
I SSUE 4:
33. Now coming to the aspect of whether there has been insufficient
disclosure and the claims are not clear and fairly based on the specifications as
required under law, I am unable to countenance the arguments of Mr. Surya
Senthil on two grounds. Firstly, as rightly pointed out by Mr. Dinesh Jothwani,
st
the structure and operation of 1 respondent’s patent, as described in his
specifications has been rightly understood by the petitioners themselves, which
can be made out from their own original petition averments and allegations. In
such view of the matter, I do not see any insufficient or incomplete disclosure in
the specifications. Secondly, in claims 1 to 7, which have been set out in the
complete specification, every feature claimed has been disclosed, with its
numbered element and operation. As rightly pointed out by Mr. Dinesh
Jothwani, there is also no evidence adduced or material produced on the side of
the petitioners to show that any skill person has already attempted to experiment
st
with the combination reached by the 1 respondent in building a baler and has
failed in such attempt. Therefore, I am unable to see any merit in the
submissions of the learned counsel for the petitioners that under Section 64(1)
st
(h) and 64(1)(i), also the 1 respondent’s patent is to be revoked
34. As regards the non-workability of the patent, though no issue has
st
been framed, it was vehemently contended by Mr. Surya Senthil that the 1
respondent has not even sold a single machine to the general public till date
__________
Page19 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
despite grant on patent on 12.10.2023. However, as rightly pointed by Mr.
st
Dinesh Jothwani, learned counsel for the 1 respondent, under Section 146 (2)
of the Patents Act, 1970 read with Rule 131 of the Patents Rules, 2003 (as
amended in 2024), a patentee has 3 financial years’ time to file a statement of
working in Form 27. Considering that the patent was granted only on
st
12.10.2023, the 1 respondent can file his statement on or before 30.07.2027.
Therefore, today, it is not open to the petitioner to contend that there is a default
st
in disclosure of the working of the patent and therefore the 1 respondent is only
attempting to monopolise the market by taking an advantage of the patent
granted to. Further, as rightly pointed out, under Section 64, non-working or
non-marketing of the patent is not even a ground for revocation. In such view,
even this argument of the petitioners falls to the grounds. Issues are answered
accordingly.
35. For all the above reasons, I do not see any merit in the petition. In
fine, the OP is dismissed. No order as to costs.
13-11-2026
Index: Yes
Speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes
RKP
To
The Deputy Controller of Patents & Designs,
__________
Page20 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
The Patent Office Intellectual Property Building,
GST Road, Guindy, Chennai 600 032.
__________
Page21 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )

2026:MHC:4560
CMA (TM) No.13 of 2026
P.B.BALAJI J.
RKP
Pre-delivery Order in
OP (PT) No.4 of 2024
13-11-2026
__________
Page22 of 22
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 13/11/2026 07:52:32 pm )