Union Of India & Ors. vs Mohammad Saquib
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$~133
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
# CNR No. DLHC010531272026
+ W.P.(C) 16308/2026 & CM APPL. 76410/2026, CM APPL.
76411/2026
UNION OF INDIA & ORS. .....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Achal Gupta, Adv.
versus
MOHAMMAD SAQUIB .....Respondent
Through:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
% 05.11.2026
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1. We express, at the very outset, our profound unhappiness at the
fact that the department has chosen to challenge the impugned
1
judgment, rendered by the Central Administrative Tribunal on 10
March 2006 in OA 2627/2024. The challenge, to our mind, militates
against the basic principles of reasonable accommodation of persons
with disabilities, which is an apically endorsed constitutional
imperative. Acceding to the prayer in this writ petition, to our mind,
would defeat the very purpose of the Rights of Persons with
2
Disabilities Act, 2016 .
1
“the Tribunal” hereinafter
2
“RPWD Act” hereinafter
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 1 of 14
2. We had expressed our prima-facie opinion in this regard to Mr.
Gupta, who appears for the petitioner, on 3 November 2026. He
sought time to convey the views of the Court to the respondent and
obtain instructions. Yesterday, Mr. Gupta was accompanied by an
Officer from the Department, who is, therefore, well aware of our
view in this matter. Mr. Gupta had, therefore, sought another day’s
time to enable him to confer with the department.
3. Today, no officer from the department has even deemed it
necessary to be present in Court. Mr. Gupta submits that he has
instructions to press the petition.
4. The expression “disability” has become anachronistic, with the
passage of time. Persons who were classically considered “disabled”
are now known to be as able as the rest of us; only differently,
resulting in the adoption of the more accurate description “differently
abled”. We have, in our own Court, sterling examples of Counsel
who, despite being blind from birth, manifest the highest degree of
legal competence, often overshadowing their “abled” peers, one of
whom has, deservingly, been conferred silk.
5. The concept of “reasonable accommodation” for the differently
abled has been explained, more than once, by the Supreme Court.
3
6. In Vikash Kumar v. UPSC , the Supreme Court held :
“43. There is a critical qualitative difference between the barriers
3
(2021) 5 SCC 370
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 2 of 14
faced by persons with disabilities and other marginalised groups. In
order to enable persons with disabilities to lead a life of equal
dignity and worth, it is not enough to mandate that discrimination
against them is impermissible. That is necessary, but not sufficient.
We must equally ensure, as a society, that we provide them the
additional support and facilities that are necessary for them to
offset the impact of their disability. This Court in its judgment in
4
Jeeja Ghosh v. Union of India , noted that a key component of
equality is the principle of reasonable differentiation and specific
measures must be undertaken, recognising the different needs of
persons with disabilities, to pave the way for substantive equality.
A.K. Sikri, J. stated in the above judgment :
“ 40 . In international human rights law, equality is
founded upon two complementary principles: non-
discrimination and reasonable differentiation. The principle
of non-discrimination seeks to ensure that all persons can
equally enjoy and exercise all their rights and freedoms.
Discrimination occurs due to arbitrary denial of
opportunities for equal participation. For example, when
public facilities and services are set on standards out of the
reach of persons with disabilities, it leads to exclusion and
denial of rights. Equality not only implies preventing
discrimination (example, the protection of individuals
against unfavourable treatment by introducing anti-
discrimination laws), but goes beyond in remedying
discrimination against groups suffering systematic
discrimination in society. In concrete terms, it means
embracing the notion of positive rights, affirmative action
and reasonable accommodation .”
(emphasis supplied)
44. The principle of reasonable accommodation captures the
positive obligation of the State and private parties to provide
additional support to persons with disabilities to facilitate their full
and effective participation in society. The concept of reasonable
accommodation is developed in section (H) below. For the present,
suffice it to say that, for a person with disability, the
constitutionally guaranteed fundamental rights to equality, the six
freedoms and the right to life under Article 21 will ring hollow if
they are not given this additional support that helps make these
rights real and meaningful for them. Reasonable accommodation is
the instrumentality – are an obligation as a society – to enable the
disabled to enjoy the constitutional guarantee of equality and non-
discrimination. In this context, it would be apposite to remember
R.M. Lodha, J's (as he then was) observation in Sunanda
4
(2016) 7 SCC 761
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 3 of 14
5
Bhandare Foundation v. Union of India , Disabled Rights Group
6
v. Union of India , where he stated :
“ 9 . … In the matters of providing relief to those who are
differently abled, the approach and attitude of the executive
must be liberal and relief oriented and not obstructive or
lethargic.”
7. That the principle of reasonable accommodation must also
inform the manner in which applicable Rules, Regulations or
executive instructions should be interpreted is underscored in the
following passage from Omkar Ramchandra Gond v. Union of
7
India :
“ 40. It is in matters like this that the principles of reasonable
accommodation should come into full play. Section 2(y) of the
RPwD Act, defines “reasonable accommodation” to mean
necessary and appropriate modification and adjustments, without
imposing a disproportionate or undue burden in a particular case,
to ensure to persons with disabilities the enjoyment or exercise of
rights equally with others. The concept of reasonable
accommodation would encompass within itself the deployment of a
purposive and meaningful construction of NMC Regulations of 13-
5-2019 read with Appendix H-1 guidelines in a manner as to
further the objectives of the RPwD Act .
41. The reasonable accommodation as defined in Section 2( y )
of the RPwD Act should not be understood narrowly to mean only
the provision of assisting devices and other tangible substances
which will aid persons with disabilities. If the mandate of the law
is to ensure a full and effective participation of persons with
disabilities in the society and if the whole idea was to exclude
conditions that prevent their full and effective participation as
equal members of society, a broad interpretation of the concept of
reasonable accommodation which will further the objective of the
RPwD Act and Article 41 of the directive principles of State policy
is mandated .”
(Emphasis supplied)
5
(2014) 14 SCC 383
6
(2018) 2 SCC 397
7
(2024) 14 SCC 158
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 4 of 14
8
8. In Anmol v. Union of India , the Supreme Court further
clarified that “flexibility in answering individual needs and
requirements is an essential component of reasonable accommodation.
There cannot be a “one size fits all” approach. The deleterious
consequences of denying, for one who is differently abled,
“reasonable accommodation” to enable her, or him, to rise to her, or
his, full potential, has further been thus emphasized, in Om Rathod v.
9
Directorate General of Health Services :
“ Reasonable accommodation is a fundamental right. It is a gateway right
for persons with disabilities to enjoy all the other rights enshrined in the
Constitution and the law. Without the gateway right of reasonable
accommodation, a person with disability is forced to navigate in a world
which excludes them by design. It strikes a fatal blow to their ability to
make life choices and pursue opportunities. From mundane tasks of daily
life to actions undertaken to realise personal and professional aspirations
- all are throttled when reasonable accommodations are denied.
Reasonable accommodation is a facet of substantive equality and its
failure constitutes discrimination.”
9. It must be understood that, when one talks of reasononable
accommodation , one does not accommodate the disability , but
accommodates the different ability of the candidate concerned, so that
the candidate is able to use his ability to the optimum extent. Ch.
10
Joseph v. Telangana SRTC , therefore, observes that the concept of
“reasonable accommodation … is now recognized as an aspect of
substantive equality under Articles 14 and 21”. In a competition, for
example, every candidate is entitled to perform at his optimum level,
and, for those who are differently abled, “reasonable accommodation”
is extended only so as to ensure that they are able to do so. The
8
2025 SCC OnLine SC 387
9
2024 SCC OnLine SC 387
10
2024 SCC OnLine SC 1592
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 5 of 14
11
following passages from Rajive Raturi v. Union of India views the
issue from another, though ideologically similar, perspective:
“38. As highlighted by the Committee on the Rights of Persons
with Disabilities in General Comment 6, reasonable
accommodation is integral to the principle of inclusive equality,
acting as a facilitator for substantive equality. [General Comment
on Accessibility, CRPD/C/GC/2, para 25.] The General Comment
articulated the relationship between reasonable accommodation
and accessibility as follows:
“23. The duty to provide reasonable accommodation is
an ex nunc duty, which means that it is enforceable from
the moment an individual with an impairment needs it in a
given situation (workplace, school, etc.) in order to enjoy
her or his rights on an equal basis in a particular context.
Here, accessibility standards can be an indicator, but may
not be taken as prescriptive. Reasonable accommodation
can be used as a means of ensuring accessibility for an
individual with a disability in a particular situation.
Reasonable accommodation seeks to achieve individual
justice in the sense that non-discrimination or equality is
assured, taking the dignity, autonomy and choices of the
individual into account. Thus, a person with a rare
impairment might ask for accommodation that falls outside
the scope of any accessibility standard. The decision to
provide it or not depends on whether it is reasonable and
whether it imposes a disproportionate or undue burden.””
(Emphasis contained in the original report)
Denial of reasonable accommodation was stated, in General Comment
No. 6 in the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, as
a facet of “intersectional discrimination”.
12
Ravinder Kumar Dhariwal v. Union of India holds that the
10.
“principle of reasonable accommodation is one of the means for
achieving substantive equality, pursuant to which disabled individuals
11
(2024) 16 SCC 654
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 6 of 14
must be reasonably accommodated based on their individual
capacities”.
11. “Reasonable accommodation” for the differently abled is,
therefore, clearly a constitutional imperative, and it is impermissible to
accord, to any instrument, statutory or executive, which is intended to
promote or ensure reasonable accommodation, an interpretation which
would defeat the purpose. The Court has to be expansive while
construing such instruments, always regarding Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution of India as a beacon to guide its approach.
12. Adverting, now, to the facts of the present case, the lis relates to
the entitlement of the respondent for exemption from undertaking the
skill test/typing test as part of the Combined Higher Secondary (10+2)
Level Examination, 2022, conducted by the Staff Selection
13
Commission , the petitioner before us.
13. The respondent is undisputedly a person suffering from 54%
Post Head Injury Right Hemiparesis, a “benchmark disability” within
the meaning of Section 2(r) of the RPWD Act, in respect of which the
petitioner has been issued a certificate by Dr. Vibha Sharma,
Professor, Department of Clinical Psychology, IHBAS, Delhi. The
SSC, too, does not dispute the nature and the extent of respondent’s
disability.
14. Among the tests which had to be undertaken by the candidates
appearing in the examination, were a written test and a skill test/typing
12
(2023) 2 SCC 209
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 7 of 14
test. Both these tests were held on 26 June 2023; the former in the
forenoon and the latter in the afternoon. At the time of appearing for
the written test in the morning of 26 June 2023, the respondent
submitted a certificate regarding his physical limitations, seeking the
assistance of a scribe to undertake the written test, as well as an
undertaking in the prescribed format seeking exemption from
appearing in the skill test/typing test along with the certificate in
Annexure (xiv) to the notice of examination, as required by the Clause
14.9.7.6.7 of the said Notice. For ready reference, we may reproduce
Clause 14.9.7.6.7 of the notice of examination, the Certificate
regarding the physical limitations for the purposes of seeking Scribe
assistance for the written examination and the undertaking provided
by the respondent seeking exemption from skill test/typing test, thus:
Clause 14.9.7.6.7 of the Notice of Examination
“14.9.7.6.7 Persons with Disabilities candidates who claim to
be permanently unfit to take the Typing Test because of a physical
disability may, with the prior approval of the Commission, be
exempted from the requirement of appearing and qualifying at
such test, provided such a candidate submits a Certificate in the
prescribed format (Annexure-XIV) to the Commission from the
competent Medical Authority, i.e., the Civil Surgeon of a
Government Health Care Institution declaring him to be
permanently unfit for the Typing Test because of a physical
disability. In addition, such candidates must substantiate their
claim by furnishing the relevant Medical Certificate in the
prescribed format as per Annexure-XI to Annexure-XIII of the
Notice of Examination, as applicable, at the time of Typing Test.
Otherwise their claim for seeking exemption from Typing Test will
not be entertained by the Commission.”
Certificate dated 13 March 2023 regarding physical limitation for
an examinee to write
“ Certificate regarding physical limitation for an examinee to
13
“SSC” hereinafter
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 8 of 14
write
This is to certify that, I have examined Mr. MOHAMMAD SAQIB
(name of the candidate with disability), a person with Post Head
Injury Right Hemiparesis 54% (Nature and percentage of disability
as mentioned in the certificate of disability), S/o Mohammad Rais a
141, Azad Apartments resident III I.P. Extension, Patpar Ganj
Delhi 110092 (Village/ District/ State) and to state that he/she has
physical limitation which hampers his/her writing capabilities
owning to his/her disability.
SD/-
Chief Medical Officer/ Civil Surgeon/ Medical
Superintendent of a
Government Health Care Institution
Name & Designation
Name of Government Hospital/ Health Care Centre with Seal
Dr. Uday K. Sinha
(Sea Affixed)”
Place: IHBAS, Delhi
Date: 13.03.2023
Note: Certificate should be given by a specialist of the relevant
stream/disability (e.g. Visual impairment- Ophthalmologist,
Locomotor disability-Orthopaedic Speicalist/PMR)”
Undertaking Dated 22 June 2023
“UNDERTAKING
“I Mohammed Saqib Roll No. 2201176903 am a candidate of
CHSL-2022 Examination and would like to avail exemption from
the requirement of appearing and qualifying in Skill Test, in
accordance with Para 14.9.7.6.7 of examination Notice, as I am
permanently unfit to take the typing test because of physical
disability. I am herewith attaching a copy of requisite certificate in
prescribed format (Annexure- XIV), issued by competent medical
authority Le. a civil surgeon of a Government health care
institution along with relevant medical certificate in prescribed
format. I also undertake that I will produce all these documents in
original at the time of document verification. If I fail to produce the
same, my candidature will be canceled and I will have no claim
against any posts.
SIGNATURE...M. Saqib
NAME OF CANDIDATE... Mohammad Saqib
ROLL NO.2201176903
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 9 of 14
DATE.. 22.06.2023”
15. The Tribunal, in para 6.8 of its judgment from which the
present writ petition emanates, that the respondent had further
produced documents relating to his medical condition and disability
status, including the certificate issued by the competent medical
authority indicating the extent of his disability.
16. Apparently because the respondent produced the aforesaid
documents in the morning of 26 June 2023, while appearing for the
written test, but had not again produced these documents on the
afternoon of 26 June 2023, seeking exemption from undertaking the
skill test/typing test, the respondent was marked absent in the typing
test and, therefore, was declared as unsuccessful in the selection.
17. Aggrieved thereby, the respondent approached the Tribunal by
way of OA 2627/2024, which stands allowed by judgment dated 10
March 2026, against which the SSC has approached this Court by
means of the present writ petition.
18. We have heard Mr. Gupta at length.
19. Before adverting to the submissions of Mr. Gupta and our view
in this matter, we deem it appropriate to reproduce the reasoning of
the Tribunal, as contained in the impugned judgment, following para
6.9, thus
“6.9 More importantly, it is also an admitted position that a
scribe was provided to the applicant during the morning session of
the examination. The provision of a scribe itself indicates that the
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 10 of 14
respondents were aware of the medical condition and physical
limitations of the applicant. The principal contention urged by
learned counsel for the respondents is that the instructions
contained in the scheme of examination and the general
instructions governing the conduct of the examination are
mandatory in nature, and therefore the applicant was required to
submit the requisite documents again at the time of the second shift
of the examination, i.e., the skill/typing test. However, in our
considered view, such a contention cannot be accepted. The
purpose behind granting exemption from the typing test is to
provide a concession so as to facilitate and improve accessibility
and participation in the examination process. This assumes greater
significance when the matter concerns a PwD candidate, in whose
case the principle of reasonable accommodation assumes
considerable importance. When a scribe had already been provided
to the applicant during the morning session and the relevant
documents relating to his disability had been accepted by the
authorities, it prima facie appears that the respondents were fully
aware of the applicant’s medical condition and the limitations
arising therefrom. In such circumstances, the submissions of the
applicant cannot be lightly doubted. It is also not in dispute that the
skill test/typing test was scheduled on the same day during the
afternoon session. Nothing has been placed on record by the
respondents to demonstrate that the applicant was mandatorily
required to submit again the same set of documents which had
already been submitted and accepted earlier on the same day. Such
a requirement is also not envisaged in the terms and conditions
stipulated in the examination brochure or the scheme of
examination, which undoubtedly have to be followed. At the same
time, such terms and conditions cannot be interpreted in a manner
that defeats the very purpose of providing reasonable
accommodation to candidates with disabilities. In the present case,
the applicant had already been accommodated during the morning
session and the respondents had accepted the documents submitted
by him regarding his disability. Therefore, the mere fact that the
applicant did not appear in the second shift of the examination,
after having submitted the requisite undertaking and certificate
seeking exemption from the typing test, cannot automatically lead
to the conclusion that the respondents were unaware of his medical
condition or that his claim for exemption was not substantiated.
Once the respondents had accepted the documents in the morning
session, there appeared to be no valid reason to disbelieve the
claim of the applicant regarding his disability or to disregard the
undertaking and certificate submitted by him in the prescribed
format.”
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 11 of 14
20. Mr. Gupta submits that, even if the respondent had, in the
morning of 26 June 2023, while appearing for the written test, also
submitted an undertaking seeking exemption from undertaking the
typing test along with a medical certificate in Annexure (xiv), as
required by Clause 14.9.7.6.7 of the notice of examination, he was
additionally required to submit a medical certificate in the format as
per Annexure (xi) to (xii) of the notice of examination, which he did
not submit.
21. There is nothing, with us, on record, to substantiate Mr. Gupta’s
submission that the respondent did not tender the requisite medical
certificate in Annexures (xi) to (xii).
22. That apart, even if it were to be assumed, for the sake of
argument, that the respondent did not submit the said medical
certificate, the fact of the matter remains that the respondent’s medical
condition was known to the SSC, and that the respondent had, in fact,
submitted an undertaking, as required by Clause 14.9.7.6.7 of the
notice of examination, seeking exemption from undertaking the typing
test, along with the requisite medical certificate in Annexure (xiv),
issued by the competent medical authority.
23. It is also not in dispute that the said certificate entitles the
respondent to exemption from taking the skill test/typing test. The
respondent’s only default appears to have been that he did not, once
again, produce the said medical certificate in Annexure (xiv) along
with certificate as envisaged by Clause 14.9.7.6.7 along with medical
certificates in Annexures (xi) to (xii) in the afternoon of 26 June 2023
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 12 of 14
for obtaining exemption from typing test.
24. The Tribunal has observed that such an approach would be
unjustifiably myopic in nature, and we entirely agree with the finding.
The approach of Courts and Tribunals, while dealing with a case of
persons who are differently abled, has to be qualitatively different
from that adopted while dealing with normally able-bodied persons.
25. The principle of reasonable accommodation has to permeate not
only executive, but also judicial decisions dealing with such persons.
The respondent had admittedly produced, on the morning of 26 June
2023, the requisite undertaking seeking exemption from participating
in the skill test/typing test along with the requisite medical certificate
in Annexure (xiv). The validity of the certificate is not in question.
The fact that the respondent would, on the basis of the said certificate,
be in fact entitled to exemption from undertaking skill test/typing test
is also not disputed by the SSC.
26. In that view of the matter, the mere default on the part of the
respondent – if it can be called one – in once again furnishing the
undertaking along with the requisite medical certificate in Annexures
(xi) to (xii) in the afternoon of 26 June 2023, cannot be treated as a
justifiable basis, to treat him absent in the typing test and disqualify
him on that basis.
27. We are of the firm opinion that the present writ petition ought
not to have been filed. The Tribunal’s view is eminently reasonable
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 13 of 14
and is in sync with the philosophy of granting reasonable
accommodation to the differently abled.
28. We were seriously inclined to award costs in this case.
However, as we are not entertaining the writ petition and dismissing it
in limine , we refrain from doing so.
29. We, however, direct that a copy of this judgment be forwarded
to the Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities as
well as the Ministry of Law, so that an informed decision may be
taken before challenging an order such as that passed by the Tribunal
in the present case, keeping in mind the philosophy of the RWPD Act.
30. The writ petition is dismissed in limine .
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA, J.
NOVEMBER 5, 2026/A
Signature Not Verified
Signed By:YOGESH
KUMAR
Signing Date:18.11.2026
12:39
W.P.(C) 16308/2026 Page 14 of 14