Manoj Kumar Gautam vs Govt. Of Nctd

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1


Item No. 37 - Court 3

Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench
New Delhi

OA No. 2968/2017

th
This the 05 day of November, 2026

Hon’ble Mrs. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (J)
Hon’ble Dr. Sumeet Jerath, Member(A)

Manoj Kumar Gautam
Gr. C.
age. 40
S/o.Sh. Balbir Singh
R/O.G.B.S.S.S.
A-Block Nand Nagri, Delhi-110093

..Applicant(s)

(By Advocates: None)

Versus
1. Secretary GNCT of Delhi
GNCT Delhi, Delhi Sectt.
Players
ITO, New Delhi.

2. The Secretary
Education Department,
GNCT of Delhi, Old Sectt.
Delhi-110054

3. The Director of Education,
Education Department,
G.N.C.T. of Delhi, Old Sectt.
Delhi-110054

4. The Dy. Director of Education,
B-Block, Yamuna Vihar, Distt.
North-East, Delhi.

...Respondent(s)

(By Advocate: Ms. Deepika, Mr. Vikas)




SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA

2


Item No. 37 - Court 3

O R D E R(Oral)
Hon’ble Mrs. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member(J)
The applicant, serving on the post of PET in
Government Boys Senior Secondary School, A-Block,
Nand Nagri, Delhi. He was chargesheeted under Rule 14
of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, vide memorandum dated
18.05.2006. The article of charge levelled against the
applicant reads as under:
"That Sh. Manoj Kumar Gautam, while working on the post
of PET in GGSSS, Dilshad Garden, Delhi is reported to have
misbehaved filthy, abusive language unparliamentarily
words and gestures against Smt. Suman Lata, PET, SKY,
Block E, Nand Nagri, Delhi and other female colleagues who
have become a target of sexual harassment during Zonal
athletic meet held on 18.10.2005. It is a matter of serious
misconduct on the part of Sh. Manoj Kumar Gautam, PET.
He has violated the provisions as contained in GOI, DOPT,
OM No. 11013/10/97-Estt. (A) dated 13.02.98 para 2(a) (e)
stressed on para 3(d) of enclosure. Thus Sh. Manoj Kumar
Gautam, PET has failed to maintain absolute integrity and
devotion of duties and violated the stipulated provisions of
Sub Rule 3 (i) (iii) of CCS(Conduct), Rules, 1964.)"
2. The allegations against the applicant pertain to an
incident dated 18.10.2005 during an Athletic Meet,
wherein he was alleged to have used unparliamentary
language and committed sexual harassment.
3. Thereafter, an enquiry was conducted and the
Enquiry Officer submitted his report dated 09.12.2011. It
was concluded that the charges were partially proved,
since the charge of sexual harassment could not be
supported by any evidence. However, it was proved that
during the course of the meeting, the applicant had used
unparliamentary words.
4. The enquiry report was accepted by the Disciplinary
Authority and a penalty of reduction of pay by three
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA

3


Item No. 37 - Court 3

stages for a period of three years with immediate effect
was imposed upon the applicant. It was further directed
that the reduction would have the effect of postponing his
future increments of pay.
5. The applicant preferred an appeal against the order
of the Disciplinary Authority. However, the Appellate
Authority, vide order dated 16.11.2012, confirmed the
order of the Disciplinary Authority and rejected the
appeal.
6. Thereafter, the applicant made a representation to
the Secretary on 27.12.2016. Learned counsel for the
respondents would submit that the applicant had earlier
approached this Tribunal by filing OA No. 651/2017,
which was disposed of on 11.07.2017, granting liberty to
the applicant to file a better petition, since the order of
the Appellate Authority had not been challenged in the
said OA. Hence, the present OA, seeking the following
reliefs:
“a. Set-aside the order dated 16.11.2012 and direct the
respondent to grant increments as stopped by them.
b. Any other order, as may deem just and proper, may also
be passed in the facts and circumstances of the case.”
7. Learned counsel for the respondents would submit
that the only relief now being sought is setting aside the
order of the Appellate Authority, whereas the order of the
Disciplinary Authority and the charge-sheet have not
been challenged. He would also submit that the applicant
has not been pursuing the OA on a number of occasions.
8. We have heard the averments and the perused the
pleadings available on record.
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA

4


Item No. 37 - Court 3

9. At this stage, it is pertinent to mention that vide
order dated 13.05.2026, this Tribunal had granted a last
opportunity to the applicant to address arguments,
making it clear that in case the applicant failed to appear
on the next date of hearing, the matter would be liable to
be dismissed in default. However, today also, there is no
representation on behalf of the applicant.
10. On merits, learned counsel for the respondents
would submit that the Enquiry Officer, having gone
through the evidence which was on record, has passed a
reasoned report, giving his conclusion that the charges
were partly proved, although the charge of sexual
harassment could not be proved. The charge of using
unparliamentary language was confirmed, which is
evident from the enquiry report itself.
11. The said enquiry report has been considered by the
Disciplinary Authority as well as the Appellate Authority.
We have gone through both the orders and find that they
are well-reasoned and speaking orders.
12. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of B.C.
Chaturvedi v. Union of India & Ors. , (1995) 6 SCC
749 , has held that judicial review is not an appeal from a
decision but a review of the manner in which the decision
is made. The Court or Tribunal, while exercising the
power of judicial review, does not act as an appellate
authority to reappreciate the evidence and arrive at its
own independent findings. The interference is warranted
only in cases where the proceedings are inconsistent with
the rules of natural justice, in violation of statutory rules
or where the findings are based on no evidence. Similarly,
in the case of Union of India & Ors. v. P.
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA

5


Item No. 37 - Court 3

Gunasekaran , (2015) 2 SCC 610 , the Hon'ble Supreme
Court has reiterated the limited scope of judicial review in
disciplinary proceedings.
13. In view of the aforesaid settled position of law, we
are of the considered view that this Tribunal cannot sit as
an appellate authority over the findings recorded by the
Enquiry Officer. The fact that the charge of sexual
harassment could not be proved does not, by itself,
render the finding regarding use of unparliamentary
language unsustainable. The Enquiry Officer has
considered the evidence on record and has returned a
finding that the said charge stood proved. The same has
thereafter been considered by the Disciplinary Authority
and the Appellate Authority.
14. We do not find any ground made out for
interference with the orders passed by the Disciplinary
Authority and the Appellate Authority. The applicant has
also failed to demonstrate any ground warranting
interference within the limited scope of judicial review in
disciplinary matters.
15. In view of the foregoing discussion, the OA is devoid
of merit and is accordingly dismissed. Pending MAs, if
any are also dismissed. No costs.


(Dr. Sumeet Jerath) (Harvinder Kaur Oberoi)
Member(A) Member(J)
/ss/
SOURJYA
SOBHANIYA