Kanhaiya Singh vs The State of Bihar
- Court
- Patna High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.3507 of 2023
======================================================
Kanhaiya Singh Son of Ram Ayodhya Singh Resident of Near Sahid Bhawan,
Mahavir Tola, P.S.- Arrah Nawada, District- Bhojpur.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1. The State of Bihar.
2. Principal Secretary, Health and family Welfare Department, Government of
Bihar, Patna.
3. Joint Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
4. Additional Secretary, Health Department, Grievance Redressal Cell,
Government of Bihar, Patna.
5. Under Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar, Patna.
6. District Magistrate, Madhubani.
7. Civil Surgeon Cum Chief Medical Officer, Madhubani.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Rajiv Kumar Singh, Adv.
For the Respondent/s : Mr. Gyan Shankar, SC33
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DR. ANSHUMAN
CAV JUDGMENT
Date : 20-11-2026
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and
learned counsel for the State.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the present writ application has been filed for setting aside the
order, dated 12.01.2023, passed by Joint Secretary, Health
Department, Government of Bihar (Annexure-16),
communicated through press regarding termination order from
the service of the petitioner along with others and the
petitioner’s name appeared at Serial No.33 during the pendency
of LPA No.1140 of 2019 without legal basis.
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
2/20
3. Further prayer has been inserted by virtue of
I.A. No.1 of 2023 by which the same order has been challenged
vide Memo No.105 dated 23.01.2023 issued under the signature
of Special Secretary, Health Department, Government of Bihar
(Annexure-P/19).
4. Counsel further submits that the petitioner had
joined his service as Medical Officer on 26.03.1988 at the PHC
Dhuraiya at Banka and since then, he had worked at different
places and presently, posted as Medical Officer at Sub-
divisional Hospital, Jhanjharpur, Madhubani and performing his
duty with quite satisfaction to the authorities. He further submits
that the petitioner has unblemished career and has never been
made any complaint against him. He further submits that due to
illness of his wife, he has filed an application/representation to
the authority dated 03.07.2010 requesting him to provide
Voluntary Retirement from Service (VRS). On that day, the
petitioner was more than 50 years of age and completed about
22 years of his service. The said representation has already been
recommended by the Civil Surgeon-cum- Chief Medical
Officer, Madhubani and sent to the Principal Secretary, Health
Department, Government of Bihar vide letter No.3152 dated
30.07.2010.
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
3/20
5. Counsel further submits that nothing has been
done on his representation dated 19.10.2010 and subsequently,
the Civil Surgeon has passed an order vide Memo No.3916
dated 19.11.2010 regarding handing over charge to the Deputy
Superintendent, Sub-divisional Hospital, Jhanjharpur,
Madhubani. He further submits that the petitioner has also
represented before the Grievance Redressal Cell, Government of
Bihar demanding VRS and thereafter, also sent representation to
the Principal Secretary, Health and Family Welfare, Government
of Bihar vide letter dated 01.08.2011. He further submits that
the relevant documents were demanded and the petitioner has
submitted his relevant documents on 29.03.2016 and again
submitted rest of the documents on 30.04.2016, but no decision
has been taken.
6. Counsel further submits that due to suffering of
his wife, the petitioner wanted to seek VRS and at the time of
filing the said the writ petition, the treatment of his wife was
going on at Neuro Pshyachiatri Centre at Chitpur, Varanasi
(U.P.). He further submits that by virtue of the charge-memo,
due to his absence, punishment order has been passed against
him against which the petitioner has preferred appeal, but the
same was rejected by the authority. Thereafter, the petitioner
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
4/20
challenged the said order through a writ petition, bearing CWJC
No. 12145 of 2017, which was allowed and the impugned orders
were quashed vide order dated 14.03.2018. Against the said
order, the State has not preferred LPA. On being dissatisfied
from non-disposal of representation of V.R.S., the petitioner
filed another Writ Petition, bearing C.W.J.C. No. 10660 of 2018
before this Hon’ble Court and the same was disposed of on
26.02.2018 with a direction to the Principal Secretary, Health
Department to dispose of the representation of the petitioner for
grant of VRS and pass a final order within a period of four
weeks from the date of the order. He further submits that since
the order dated 26.02.2018 was not complied with, the petitioner
filed contempt petition bearing MJC No. 1666 of 2018 which
was disposed of vide order dated 05.09.2018 granting liberty to
the petitioner to assail the aforesaid orders, dated 16.08.2018
and 04.09.2018.
7. Thereafter, the petitioner has challenged the said
orders in third writ petition bearing CWJC No.20149 of 2018
before this Hon’ble Court with grievance that he has filed an
application for VRS in terms of Rule 74(b) of the Bihar Service
Code, but respondents have not taken action rather they have
communicated through counter-affidavit about the pendency of
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
5/20
the departmental proceeding against him.
8. Counsel further submits that in the said writ
petition vide order dated 31.07.2019, the Hon’ble Single Judge
has pleased to direct the authority concerned to serve the copy
of this memo of charge, complete the proceeding in terms of
Rule 17 of the Bihar CCA Rules, 2005 and complete the entire
process within a period of six months from the date of receipt or
production of a copy of this order and if the petitioner is
exonerated, in such circumstance, the application for VRS will
be considered and take decision within one month. He further
submits that against the said order, the petitioner has preferred
appeal bearing LPA No.1140 of 2019 challenging the order
passed in CWJC No.20149 of 2018 dated 31.07.2019, but
during pendency of the LPA, the respondent authorities have
passed order of termination dated 12.01.2023 against the
petitioner, along with others, through press communique
without serving any notice/show cause to the petitioner
personally by the Joint Secretary, Health Department,
Government of Bihar (respondent No.3). The copy of said letter
under press note is annexure-16, which is order impugned.
Counsel further submits that by way of supplementary affidavit,
he has placed the order passed in LPA No.1140 of 2019 dated
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
6/20
15.03.2023 in which the direction was given to the authority
concerned to take decision on his representation. He further
submits that in the said LPA, the order contained in memo
No.624 dated 16.08.2018 has been declared bad and not
sustainable, hence, according to him, the decision of the
authorities on the VRS is still to be taken.
9. In this regard, counsel submits that the
petitioner has filed representation before the Principal Secretary
(Annexure-18) and submitted his entire facts that the decision
with regard to his VRS be taken in accordance with law.
10. In support of his argument, counsel relied on
judgment of Vijay Kumar Vs. The State of Bihar reported in
2015(2) PLJR 625 . Further on the judgment of Shamim
Ahmad Khan Vs. State of Bihar and Ors. reported in 2004(4)
PLJR 554 and the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
in case of Union of India & Anr. Vs. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal
reported in 2014 (2) 286 (SC) and submits that in the light of
the decision of LPA and further in the light of different
judgments, it becomes crystal clear that the decision of VRS has
to be passed in his favour as all the legal ingredients are in his
favour and the petitioner is entitled for the relief by virtue of
setting aside the order of termination dated 12.01.2023.
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
7/20
11. Learned counsel for the State, on the other
hand, opposes the prayer and submits that in the present facts
and circumstances, the petitioner has no case at all. Counsel
submits that the decision of L.P.A. No. 1140 of 2019 is not in
favour of the petitioner, rather, by virtue of decision of L.P.A,
No. 1140 of 2019, the order dated 31.07.2019 passed by the
Hon’ble Single Judge in CWJC No. 20149 of 2018 has been
approved. It has also been approved by this Hon’ble Court that
departmental proceeding second time may continue against him.
Counsel submits that the petitioner is aggrieved vide order dated
31.07.2019 passed by the Hon’ble Single Judge in C.W.J.C. No.
20149 of 2018. But, in the L.P.A., it is the categorical finding of
the Hon’ble Division Bench with regard to the petitioner is
concerned that filing of application for VRS does not ipso facto
vests the right to grant of relief of VRS, as it depends upon
several factors, as one of the factors whether he is facing
departmental proceeding. Counsel submits that in the light of
the observation made by the L.P.A. Court in para 20, the
petitioner is not entitled to get relief for which he has moved in
the present writ petition, due to the reason that departmental
proceeding was pending against him and the order passed by
Hon’ble Single Judge in C.W.J.C. No. 20149 of 2018 has
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
8/20
categorically held that second departmental proceeding may
continue. Counsel submits that it is true that by virtue of the
order passed by the Hon’ble Single Judge in C.W.J.C. No.
20149 of 2018, the petitioner has to participate in the
departmental proceeding, but instead of participating in the
departmental proceeding, he has opted to challenge the same in
the L.P.A. Court and during pendency of L.P.A., no stay was
granted in favour of the petitioner on the order passed by the
Hon’ble Single Judge and petitioner has not opted to participate
in the departmental proceeding. The officials have time and
again issued process, but when petitioner has not participated
thereafter, paper publication has been made and even after paper
publication, petitioner has not responded and then only, a
decision has been taken of termination from the service, which
has been communicated to him as well as to the press also. He
submits that initially, petitioner has challenged the press
communication dated 12.01.2023, but subsequently, the said
communication has been challenged by virtue of filing I.A. No.1
of 2023 in the present writ petition.
12. Learned counsel for the State further submits
that here in the present case, the department has followed the
observation made by the Hon’ble L.P.A. Court and due to
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
9/20
pendency of the departmental proceeding, which has been
approved by the Writ Court in C.W.J.C. No. 20149 of 2018 and
subsequently, when challenged in the L.P.A No. 1140 of 2019.
Court, the L.P.A. Court vide judgement dated 15.03.2023 has
also affirmed the order of writ Court. The department has
decided to take decision in the departmental proceeding and in
the departmental proceeding, the petitioner was terminated
therefore, there is no question of passing order on the VRS and,
hence, this writ petition is fit to be dismissed.
13. Upon hearing the parties and perusal of the
relevant documents, this Court deems it appropriate to quote the
judgments on which the counsel for the petitioner relied upon.
Firstly the judgment of this Hon’ble Court in case of Vijay
Kumar Vs. The State of Bihar (supra) whose relevant
paragraph 54- 59 reads as under:-
“ 54. The third case which has been
clubbed by this Court would require no longer
discussion and deliberation in view of the statuary
provision made in Rule 74 of the Bihar Service
Code, relevant portion whereof reads as follows:-
"74(a)... … ...
(b)(i) Notwithstanding anything
contained in the preceding sub-rule a Government
servant may, after giving at least three months
previous notice, in writing, to the appointing
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
10/20
authority concerned retire from service on the date
on which such a Government servant completes
thirty years qualifying service or attains fifty years
of age or on any date thereafter to be specified in
the notice:
Provided that no Government servant
under suspension shall retire from service except
with the specific approval of the State Government:
Provided further that in case of the
officers and servants of the Patna High Court
(including those of Circuit Bench at Ranchi) under
the rule making authority of the Chief Justice, no
such officer and servant under suspension shall
retire from service except with the specific
approval of the Chief Justice.
(ii) …. …. ….
(iii) ... ... ... ..."
55. Scope of Rule 74(b)(i) of the
Bihar Service Code has been decided by this Court
in C.W.J.C. No. 2900/2007 (Gauri Devi vs. the
State of Bihar & Ors.) as also in the case of Dr.
Shah Azad Siddiqui vs. the State of Bihar & Ors.,
reported in 2008(4) PLJR 194, wherein it has been
held that the option lies with the employee to
initiate the process of voluntary retirement and the
only right given to the Government is that if the
Officer is under suspension, such option of the
employee for voluntary retirement can be denied. It
has further been held that the Government could
also refuse voluntary retirement only during the
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
11/20
notice period of three months, otherwise it would
be a deemed retirement on expiry of three months
notice. This Court in fact had taken the aforesaid
view in the light of law laid down by the Apex
Court in the case of Union of India & Ors. vs.
Sayed Muzaffar Mir, reported in 1995 Supp. (1)
SCC 76, B.J. Shelat vs. State of Gujarat & Ors.,
reported in AIR 1978 SC 1109, State of Haryana &
Ors. vs. S.K. Singhal, reported in (1999)4, SCC
293, Tek Chand vs. Dile Ram, reported in (2001)3
SCC 290 and in the case of P. Lal vs. Union of
India & Ors., reported in (2003)3 SCC 393.
56. As would be apparent from
reading of the aforesaid judgments of Apex Court
and this Court as well as the clear provision of
Rule 74(b)(i) of the Bihar Service Code, there is no
option to the State Government to refuse voluntary
retirement on any ground except when the
Government servant has been placed under
suspension. In fact the concept of approval of the
State Government comes only where the
Government servant is under suspension.
57. Admittedly the petitioner of the
third case, namely, Dr. Lalit Kumar was never
placed under suspension till he had given a three
months notice by his application dated 21.6.2012
(Annexure-2) seeking his voluntary retirement with
effect from 1.10.2012 on the ground that he had
already completed 30 years of service and more
than 58 years of age. In such event his voluntary
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
12/20
retirement was automatic but the State Government
kept the matter lingering and initially did not
entertain his plea of voluntary retirement on the
ground that his application was not forwarded
through proper channel. Subsequently when he had
sent his application through proper channel the
same was rejected by an order dated 24.9.2013
which reads as follows:-
57 i=ad -17/ ववववध 2-06/12
वबहारसरकारसवासथयववभाग
izs’kd ,
डा०गगन , ववशेषकायरपदावधकारी।
सेवामे ,
डा०लवलतकुमार
,
रेवडयोलोजीववभाग
izk/;kid , ,
आयुववरजानसंसथानपावापुरी ,
o)~Zeku
नालनदा।
पटना
वदनांक 24/9/13
ववषयः सवैवचचकसेवावनवृवतकेसमबनधमे।
-
महाशय
,
वनदेशानुसारउपयुरकतववषयक izkpk;Z ,
आयुववरजानसंसथानपावापुरी , नालनदाके
o)~Zeku
संखया -36 वदनांक 1.2.2013 दारा
Kkikad vxzlkfjr
आपकेसवेचचासेवावनवृवतआवेदनके मेसूवचत
izlax
करनाहैवकराजयके वचवकतसामहाववदालयोमे
izk/;kid i= एवंवचवकतसकवशककोकाअभावहै।
अतएवलोकवहत मे आपके सवैवचचकसेवावनवृवत
आवेदन i= कोएतददाराअसवीकृतवकयाजाताहै।
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
13/20
ववषवासभाजन
ह० /-
( डा०गगन )
ववषेशकायरपदावधकारी
58. A question would, therefore, arise
whether such order passed by the Government is in
accordance with the provisions made in Rule 74 of
Bihar Service Code? There would be no difficulty
in holding that such rejection of the application of
the petitioner for his voluntary retirement was in
teeth of the provisions of Rule 74(b)(i) of the Bihar
Service Code. As a matter of fact from the circular
of the State Government dated 2.12.2013 on the
subject of voluntary retirement it would be also
found that such request of voluntary retirement
could be rejected only on the ground of pendency
of the departmental proceeding or any audit
objection or his not qualifying twenty years of
service. To that extent it would be relevant to quote
the Government circular dated 2.12.2013 which
reads as follows:-
वबहारसरकारसवासथयववभाग
आदेश
पटना , वदनांक 2.12.13
संखया -2/ कोटर -86/13-1408(2)
izk;% यहदेखाजाताहैवकववभागमे
ऐवचचकसेवावनवृवतकेमामलेकेवनषपादनमेकाफी
ववलमब हो जाता है फलसवरप माननीय उचच
,
नयायालयमेसरकारकोववषमपवरवसथवतकासामना
करनापडताहै।माननीयउचचनयायालयदाराऐसेकई
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
14/20
मामलोमेववभागदाराततपरतासेवनषपादनकरनेकी
आवशयकतापरबलवदयागयाहै।
2. वबहारसेवासंवहताकेवनयम -74 ( ख )
एवं ववत ववभागीय संखया वदनांक
ifji= -6190
27.4.1979 मेवनवहतअनुदेशोकेआलोकमे 20 वषरकी
अहरकसेवा करनेअथवा 50 वषरकोआयु कर
iwjh izkIr
लेनेकेउपरानतयवदकोईवचवकतसकवनयुवकत
izkf/kdkjh
कोकम - से - कमतीनमाहपहलेवलवखतसूचनादेकर
ऐवचचकसेवावनवृवतकाआवेदनदेतेहैतोआंतवरक
सवचचताएवंअंकेकणआपवतआवदकीसूचना
dze”k%
9 एवं 8 से करतीनमाहकेअनदर
iz”kk[kk iz”kk[kk izkIr
उसआवेदनकावनषपादनकरनाआवशयकहै।इसवलए
यहआवशयकहैवकऐवचचकसेवावनवृवतसेसंबंवधत
आवेदन होनेकेएकसपताहकेअनदरसंवचका
izkIr
उपसथावपतकर iz”kk[kk 9 एवं iz”kk[kk 8 सेआंतवरक
सवचचताएवंअंकेकणआपवतकीवसथवत izkIr करली
जाय। एवं तीनवदनोकेअनदरआंतवरक
iz”kk[kk - 9 8
सवचचतातथाअंकेकणआपवतकीवसथवतकोअंवकत
करसंबंवधत मेसंवचकालौटादेगे।
iz”kk[kk
3. संबंवधत के अवर
iz”kk[kkvksa izHkkjh
सवचवकोयहवयवकतगतवजममेदारीदीजातीहैवकहर
15 वदनपरवेअपनेअधीनसथ मे
iz”kk[kkvksa izkIr
सवैवचचकसेवा वनवृवतसे संबंवधतआवेदनो एवं
संवचकाओंकीवसथवतकीजानकारी करेऔरउसपर
izkIr
समय - सीमाकेअनदरतववरतकारवाईकरे।
4. संबंवधतसभी fu;a=h पदावधकारीको
भीयहवनदेशवदयाजाताहैवकऐवचचकसेवावनवृवतसे
संबंवधतसभीआवेदनोपरअपनेसपषटमंतवयकेसाथ
एकसपताहकेअनदरववभागको vxzlkfjr करदे।
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
15/20
5. यवदजाँचके मेयहपायाजाताहै
dze
वकऐवचचकसेवावनवृवत izkIr करनेवालेवचवकतसा
पदावधकारीपरकोईववभागीयकायरवाहीसंचावलतहै
याअंकेकणआपवत लंवबतहैयाउनकीअहरकसेवा
.
वनयमानुसार 20 वषोरंकीनहींहैवफरभीउनकेआवेदन
कोवनसतावरतकरतेहुएउनहेयहसूचनादेदीजायेगी
वकआपकेआवेदनकोइसकारणवनरसतकरवदयागया
है।
6. अगरऐवचचकसेवावनवृवतकेसंबंधमे
अभयावेदनोकेवनषपादनमेवकसीभीतरहका
izkIr
ृ
ववलमबद वषटगोचरहोताहै तोववलमबके वलए
वयवकतगतवजममेवारीवनधारवरतकरतेहुएवनयमानुसार
उनपरकारवाईकीजायेगी।
7. मे सवचव , सवासथयका
izLrko iz/kku
अनुमोदन izkIr है।
ह० /-
संजयकुमार
सरकारकेसंयुकतसवचव।
59. A question would arise that if the
petitioner's application dated 21.6.2012 was kept
pending for fifteen months before its being rejected
on 24.9.2013 who is responsible for such delay?
Secondly, the paucity of teachers in the
Government Medical College being not a ground
referable to the provisions of Rule 74(b)(i) of the
Bihar Service Code such rejection in fact wholly
uncalled for and per se illegal. In the considered
opinion of this Court Rule 74(b)(i) of the Bihar
Service Code does not brook of any two
interpretation and in fact this aspect of the matter
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
16/20
stands well settled in the line of catena of decision
of the Apex Court and of this Court as referred
above that the provision of voluntary retirement by
way of three months notice is automatic and the
incumbent cannot be refused the privilege of
voluntary retirement save and except when he has
been placed under suspension. In fact even
pendency of the departmental proceeding and/or
audit objection as per Circular of the department
quoted above cannot be made a ground in view of
the provisions made in Rule 74(b)(i) of the Bihar
Service Code.”
13.1 Further in the judgment of this Hon’ble Court
decided in case of Shamim Ahmad Khan Vs. State of Bihar
and Ors. (supra) whose relevant paragraph nos. 21 & 22 reads
as under:-
21. For examining the constitutional
validity of the rule, the court framed two questions,
the first/question was as follows:
"The first question for consideration,
therefore, is:
"Does it amount to removal of a
Government servant from service within the
meaning of Article 311 of the Constitution, where a
Government servant is continuously absent from
duty for 5 years, and as a consequence thereof is
treated no longer to be under Govern-ment
employment."
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
17/20
22. The court then proceeded to
consider two decisions of the Supreme Court, one
in Jai Shankar vs. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1996 SC
492 in which regulation 13 of Jodhpur Service
Regulations came up for consideration and the
other in Deokinandan Prasad vs. State, AIR 1971
SC 1409 [: 1971 PLJR 458 (SC)] in which the
court considered the import of the earlier decision
in Jai Shankar's case. On a consideration for the
Supreme Court decisions in Jai Shankar and in
Deoki-nandan Prasad this court came to hold "that
treating an employee to have ceased to be in
Government employ amounts to removal from
service" and further that removal from service
without giving an opportunity of being heard was
to go against Art. 311 Constitution. (emphasis
added)
and further in the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India decided in case of Union of India & Anr. Vs.
Ashok Kumar Aggarwal (supra) whose relevant Paragraph
25 reads as under :-
25. Placing reliance upon the earlier
judgments in Mulraj vs. Murti Raghunathji
Mahaaraj AIR 1967 SC 1386 Surjit Singh & Ors.
etc. etc., vs. Harbans Singh & Ors. etc. etc. AIR
1996 SC 135; Delhi Development Authority vs.
Skipper Construction Company (P) Ltd. & Anr.,
AIR 1996 SC 2005; and Gurunath Manohar
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
18/20
Pavaskar & Ors. VS. Nagesh Siddappa Navalgund
& Ors., AIR 2008 SC 901, this Court in Manohar
Lal (D) by LRs. vs. Ugrasen (D) by LRs. & Ors.,
AIR 2010 SC 2210 held that any order passed by
any authority in spite of the knowledge of order of
the court, is of no consequence as it remains a
nullity and any subsequent action thereof would
also be a nullity.
14. Upon consideration of the judgments referred
to hereinabove, this Court finds that, for the proper adjudication
of the matter, the observations made by the Hon’ble Division
Bench of this Court in LPA No. 1140 of 2019, decided on
15.03.2023, are of considerable relevance and are reproduced
hereinbelow:
“22. In view of the aforesaid
discussions, this Court does not find any reason to
interfere in the order under appeal. However, the
writ petitioner-appellant is at liberty to assail the
outcome of the departmental proceeding before the
competent authority/court and in case of quashment
of the resultant outcome or exoneration, the
application for voluntary retirement of the writ
petitioner – appellant shall be considered afresh in
accordance with law after taking into consideration
the fact that the unauthorized absence from
26.12.2005 to 18.05.2010 is no more in existence
on account of the order of this Court dated
14.03.2018 passed in C.W.J.C. No. 12145 of 2017
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
19/20
in the earlier round of litigation, hence order under
challenge in the writ petition as contained in Memo
No. 624 (3) dated 16.08.2018 has no leg to stand in
the law and accordingly held to be bad and not
sustainable.
23. In view thereof, the present
appeal does not require any interference and the
same stands disposed off with certain modification
observed hereinabove. ”
15. From the aforesaid observations made by the
Hon’ble Division Bench, it is evident that liberty was granted to
the appellant to challenge the outcome of the departmental
proceedings before the competent authority/court. It was further
observed that, in the event of the consequential order being
quashed or the appellant being exonerated, his application for
voluntary retirement would be considered afresh. The State was
also directed to take a decision in respect of the departmental
proceedings. It is a settled principle that a decision on an
application for voluntary retirement (VRS) cannot be taken
without taking into consideration the pendency and outcome of
the departmental proceedings. In the present case, this Court
finds that the departmental proceedings have culminated in the
imposition of a punishment upon the petitioner. Consequently,
in view of the aforesaid observations of the Hon’ble Division
Bench, the question of reconsideration of the petitioner's
Patna High Court CWJC No.3507 of 2023 dt.20-11-2026
20/20
application for voluntary retirement does not survive at this
stage.
16. For the aforesaid reasons, this Court finds no
legal infirmity in the impugned order warranting interference.
Accordingly, the present writ petition stands dismissed.
(Dr. Anshuman, J)
Prakashmani/-
AFR/NAFR NAFR
CAV DATE 22.09.2026
Uploading Date 20.11.2026
Transmission Date NA