Hemant Ankush Balwadkar vs The State Of Maharashtra Throu. Its Ministry Of Home Affair And Anr

Court
Bombay High Court

CNR No : HCBM010037432026

WP.2180. 2026.doc
Ajay

IN IN THE THE HIGH HIGH COURT COURT OF OF JUDICATURE JUDICATURE AT AT BOMBAY BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 2180 OF 2026
Hemant Ankush Balwadkar .. Petitioner
Versus
State of Maharashtra and Anr. .. Respondents
....................

Ms. Kalyani Mangave, Advocate for Petitioner.

Mrs. Mamta S. Srivastava, AGP for Respondent – State.
......…...........
CORAM : MILIND N. JADHAV, J.
DATE : NOVEMBER 18, 2026.
JUDGEMENT:
1.
Heard Ms. Mangave, learned Advocate for Applicants and
Ms. Srivastava, learned AGP for Respondent – State.
2. Petitioner is a citizen of India and permanent resident of
Pune. He is a renowned sportsperson and due to his exemplary
performance and record in Clay Pigeon Trap Shooting National
Championship for men. He is certified as a renowned shooter by the
National Rifle Association, India in 2 disciplines. Petitioner has
participated in numerous National and International level shooting
competitions and achieved/confirmed various awards. His credentials
are appended to the petition. There is no dispute or ambiguity about
the facts. Presently, Petitioner holds four arms, bearing license no.
PNG/69/2014 for his sport. Petitioner desired to up-skill and upgrade
his performance, and his rifle shooting for which he desired to possess
1 of 9
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 20:46:26

WP.2180. 2026.doc
6 other weapons for practice.
3. As per Gazette Notification dated 12.02.2020, issued by the
Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, Petitioner is eligible to
possess maximum 12 weapons/arms (10 in exempted category + 2 for
personal use under sub-section 2 of Section 3 of the Arms Act).
Petitioner therefore filed application no. 194/2024 before the
Respondent no. 2, Commissioner of Police, Pune seeking permission of
6 additional weapons viz. 3 non-prohibited bore revolver/pistols, and 3
rifles for the purpose of his sport in the exempted category.
4. By virtue of the impugned order dated 24.01.2025, the
Respondent No. 2 rejected the application on the ground that
petitioner sought additional arms for personal use/safety. Been
aggrieved, Petitioner immediately filed statutory appeal on 24.02.2025
within the statutory limitation period, before Respondent No. 1, State,
along with application seeking urgent hearing since petitioner desired
to acquire additional weapons for his practice and preparations for
national and international competitions. The appeal is rejected.
Petitioner filed present writ petition on 09.02.0206. Hence the present
petition is pressed by the Petitioner.
5.
Ms. Mangave, learned Advocate appearing for the Petitioner
at the outset would submit that as per Schedule 5 of the Arms Rules,
2016 the Statutory Appeal is required to be disposed of within 60 days,
2 of 9
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 20:46:26

WP.2180. 2026.doc
but it was rejected after almost one year. She would submit that the
impugned order dated 22.01.2025 passed by the Commissioner
rejecting the Petitioner’s application is a non-speaking unreasoned
order. She would submit that since the statutory appeal was not
disposed of within the statutory time limit, Petitioner filed Contempt
Petition in this court against the State, during the pendency of which,
the statutory appeal of the Petitioner was rejected vide order dated
14.12.2025, copy of which is appended at Exhibit E, Page No. 57. She
would submit that Petitioner’s case has been unfairly rejected on the
ground of registration of FIR against him under Sections 34, 406, 504
and 506 of IPC, copy of which is appended at Exhibit F, Page 61
wherein no role whatsoever is attributed to the Petitioner. Neither does
the FIR state that Petitioner has misused his weapons.
6. She would submit that merely because a criminal case is
pending, Petitioner cannot be dis-entitled to the benefit of possessing
additional weapons required for his practice purposes relating to his
sports career and more so because his existing weapons having become
old and obsolete due to wear and tear which affects his shooting
accuracy and skill-set. She would submit that the Petition be allowed
along-with further directions for endorsement to be done on the arms
license by the Respondent No. 2, Commissioner in a time bound
manner so as to enable the Petitioner to procure the desired weapons
at the earliest for his sport purposes.
3 of 9
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 20:46:26

WP.2180. 2026.doc
7. PER CONTRA, Mr. Patil, learned AGP appearing on behalf of
the Respondents would oppose the Petition and draw my attention to
Affidavit-in-Reply dated 21.10.2026, copy of which is appended at
page No.70 of the Petition.
8.
Respondent No.2 in her Affidavit-in-Reply has stated that the
Petitioner is charged with offenses under the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
She submitted that upon perusal of the material on record, the
Petitioner did not sufficiently justify the grant of permission for
additional firearms over and above firearms already permitted, and
that the denial of the request was not arbitrary. She has come to this
conclusion after considering the relevant Police Report and the above-
mentioned criminal case, which is pending.
9. Reliance is placed by Ms. Mangave on the decision of this
Court in the case of Ajay Jayawant Bhosale Vs. Commissioner of Police,
Pune City and Ors in support of Petitioner’s case. Paragraph Nos. 13 to
15 of the said judgment are read and are relevant which are
reproduced hereinbelow for ease of reference :-
“13. The right to life and liberty are guaranteed under Article 21
of the Constitution of India. Arms licence is granted for personal
safety and security after due enquiry by the authorities in
accordance with provisions contained in the Arms Act, 1959.
The provisions of Arms Act with regard to suspension or
cancellation of Arms licence cannot be invoked lightly in an
arbitrary manner. The provisions of the Arms Act particularly
Section 13 to 17 indicate that once a licence is granted under
the Act, the same shall be renewed from time to time unless
there exist a ground of refusal as enumerated under Section 14
of the Act. Protection to life, property of citizen is responsibility
4 of 9
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 20:46:26

WP.2180. 2026.doc
of the State. It is only when person apprehends that machinery
of State would not come to his help for protection, he/she
applies for licence under the Act. The provisions of Section 17A
of the Arms Act indicate that arms licence can be cancelled or
suspended if the licensing authority finds it necessary for the
security of public peace or public safety. Merely because a
criminal case is pending, the provisions of Section 17 of the
Arms Act would not be attracted. Such provisions would be
attracted in case the licensing authority finds that continuance
of licence is detrimental to public peace or public security and
safety. But the authority concerned will have to record a finding
that how and under what circumstances and in what manner
possession of arms licence could be contrary to the provisions of
Section 17B of the Arms Act. Each case is required to be
considered on its own merits.
14. Nothing was placed before us by the respondents to indicate
that the petitioner had misused the licenced weapon at any
point of time in past. The order of revocation of license refers to
two criminal cases registered against the petitioner. In the facts
we find that mere registration of criminal case/cases could not
be a ground to revoke the license. The order shall indicate
clearly that continuance of licence would be against public
peace, safety and security.
15. Learned Counsel appearing for petitioner submits that in
fact petitioner and his driver were attacked in the year 2009
regarding which he had filed a complaint. Considering the
business activities, political and social work of the petitioner, it
was submitted that to protect petitioner's life and property,
arms licence was applied for and it was granted. The petitioner
still requires the same. The licensing authority has not given any
opinion as to whether the petitioner requires licence to protect
his life and property. The subjective satisfaction of the authority,
therefore, plays a vital role while assessing merits of a case
before passing orders under the provisions of Section 13, 14 or
17(b). Each case needs to be assessed, tested on its own merits.
Therefore, it is imperative that before arriving at a conclusion of
invoking powers under the provisions of Section 17(b), the
licensing authority ought to have considered the entire material,
threat perception of the licencee and pass appropriate orders.”
10. In response to the Petitioner’s contention that the Gazette
Notification dated 12.02.2020 permitted him to hold additional
firearms, the Respondent states it does not create an automatic or
absolute right in favor of the Petitioner. She also states that the
5 of 9
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 20:46:26

WP.2180. 2026.doc
Petitioner’s contention that only one offense is registered against him
attempts to imply that having a single offense is inconsequential, which
is not the case as the offenses are of grievous nature, which cannot be
overlooked. Citing these reasons, the Respondent No. 2 has invoked
Sections 13 and 14 of the Arms Act to decide the Petitioner’s
Application. Hence she would submit that the Petition be rejected.
11.
I have heard the submissions made by the learned Advocates
and perused the records of the case. At the outset it is seen that the
first impugned order dated 24.01.2025 is an unreasoned non-speaking
order passed without application of mind altogether. I am of the
opinion that no purpose will be served in remanding the matter back
since it will lead to further delay specially when substantial time has
been lost which is prima facie seen from the record of the case.
12. It is seen that Petitioner is a renowned sportsman and his
requisition is for acquiring the arms for his day to day practice to
upgrade his skill and performance since he participates in national and
international competitions. Petitioner is 38 years old and has a
substantial future in the chosen sport of shooting where he has
excelled at the highest stage. Petitioner’s application is within the
parameters and purview of the Gazette Notification dated 12.02.2020
issued by Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India. It is seen that
it is not Respondent’s case that Petitioner has misused his arms already
6 of 9
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 20:46:26

WP.2180. 2026.doc
possessed by him so as to reject his Application. From the record, it
emanates that Petitioner’s four subsisting arms have become old and
obsolete, he requires to upgrade himself with new modern technology
and sophisticated arms to enhance his skill set so as to achieve the
highest standards in national and international competitions. It is seen
that Petitioner’s subsisting arms are in use by him for the past several
years and he requires additional weapons/arms purely for sporting
purposes. Respondents have not placed on record any incriminating
material of misuse of the arms possessed by Petitioner under the
license presently possessed by him neither there is any threat to public
safety and public security.
13. It is seen that rejection of permission in such circumstances is
therefore highly arbitrary, high handed and a curb on Petitioner’s
fundamental right of denying him participation in the sport of his
choice in which he has been recognized as a renowned sportsperson.
Insofar as the objection and reason for rejecting Petitioner’s application
is concerned qua the pending criminal case, it is seen that no role is
attributed to Petitioner in the FIR neither there is any incidence of
violence mentioned in the FIR. Further, invocation of Section 17 of the
Arms Act cannot be attracted against Petitioner due to pendency of the
aforesaid criminal case. Petitioner has already lost substantial, rather
humongous amount of time in prosecuting the present Petition and
proceedings. Persons like Petitioner are required to practice their skill
7 of 9
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 20:46:26

WP.2180. 2026.doc
set virtually on a daily basis in order to compete and participate at the
highest level. Despite being eligible, Petitioner is forced to continue his
practice with his old weapons/arms due to the regressive mindset of
the prosecution in rejecting his application on completely untenable
and innocuous grounds which cannot be allowed and countenanced by
this Court.
14.
On overall consideration of the Petitioner’s case and
observations and findings, Petition deserves to be allowed and both the
twin impugned orders dated 18.12.2025 and 24.01.2025 passed by
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 are required to be quashed and set aside.
Petition stands allowed in terms of prayer clauses ‘b’ and ‘c’ of the
Petition. Hence, Petitioner’s Application dated 19.01.2024 filed for
acquiring 6 additional arms for sporting purposes as per his
specifications falling within the exempted category is allowed by this
Court.
15. In that view of the matter, Additional Commissioner of
Police, Pune is directed to endorse the 6 additional arms on Petitioner’s
license within a period of 7 days from receipt of Petitioner’s
Application for endorsement of additional weapons which is the
prescribed period in Schedule V of the Arms Rules, 2016. Under no
circumstances concerned Additional Commissioner, Pune or concerned
competent authority for endorsement shall delay endorsement once
8 of 9
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 20:46:26

WP.2180. 2026.doc
the license is submitted with all necessary details for endorsement and
along with a copy of this order downloaded from the official website of
the Bombay High Court.
16. Writ Petition is allowed and disposed in the present terms.
[ MILIND N. JADHAV, J. ]
Ajay
Digitally signed
by AJAY
TRAMBAK
UGALMUGALE
Date:
2026.11.19
20:30:48
+0530
AJAY
TRAMBAK
UGALMUGALE
9 of 9
Uploaded on - 19/11/2026 Downloaded on - 19/11/2026 20:46:26
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)