Satya Narayan Meher vs State Of Odisha
- Court
- Supreme Court
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
2026 INSC 1013
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.3374 OF 2026
SATYA NARAYAN MEHER AND APPELLANTS
ANOTHER
VERSUS
STATE OF ODISHA RESPONDENT
J U D G M E N T
ATUL S. CHANDURKAR, J
1. In this criminal appeal, the appellants challenge their
conviction for the offence punishable under Section 325 read with
1
Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 . The appellants have
been sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year
and to pay a fine of ₹ 20,000/- each, in default, to further undergo
rigorous imprisonment for a period of six months each. The fine
amount has been directed to be disbursed to the widow of the
victim as compensation.
2. Facts giving rise to the present prosecution are that on
19.08.1994 at about 05.30 P.M, a written report was submitted by
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
IRAMNAZ
Date: 2026.09.18
17:47:27 IST
Reason:
1
For short, ‘the Penal Code’
Criminal Appeal No.3374 of 2026 Page 1 of 7
Urmila Meher-PW1, in which it was stated that her husband
Chintamani had been assaulted by the appellants along with one
another, who has since expired. Chintamani received various
injuries on his body and it was stated that he had been assaulted
by means of a spade as well as tangias . He was given first aid and
thereafter, admitted to hospital. He, however, succumbed to his
injuries on 22.08.1994. After completion of investigation, all the
three accused were charged for having committed the offence
punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Penal
Code.
3. Before the Sessions Court, the prosecution examined seven
witnesses while the defence examined two witnesses. The Sessions
Court found that despite enmity between the accused and the
deceased, there was no pre-meditation for causing death of
Chintamani. Out of the four injuries sustained by the victim, three
were simple while one injury was grievous in nature. The death
having occurred due to myocardial infraction, the Sessions Court
held the accused guilty under Section 304 Part II read with Section
34 of the Penal Code. They were, accordingly, sentenced to
rigorous imprisonment for a period of five years each.
Criminal Appeal No.3374 of 2026 Page 2 of 7
2
4. On appeal by the appellants before the High Court of Odisha ,
the learned Single Judge by his judgment dated 12.02.2026
recorded a finding that the death of Chintamani was not homicidal
in nature. The appellants were, therefore, convicted under Section
325 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code and sentenced to
undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of one year. They were
also ordered to pay a fine of ₹ 20,000/- each, which amount was to
be disbursed to the widow of Chintamani as compensation under
3
Section 357 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 . Being
aggrieved, the appellants have challenged their conviction. The
proceedings against accused No.3 abated during pendency of the
appeal before the High Court.
5. Ms. Renuka Sahu, learned counsel appearing for the
appellants assailed the conviction of the appellants by submitting
that the same was based on weak and hearsay evidence. It was
submitted that PW3 who was stated to be an eye-witness had
turned hostile. The other witnesses examined were family
members of the deceased and were, thus, interested witnesses. The
other evidence on record was not sufficient to sustain the
2
For short, ‘the High Court’
3
For short, ‘the Code’
Criminal Appeal No.3374 of 2026 Page 3 of 7
conviction of the appellants. Moreover, the death having occurred
due to myocardial infraction and there being no finding that the
injuries caused led to the death of Chintamani, the appellants
could not have been so convicted.
Without prejudice to the aforesaid, it was submitted that the
appellant No.1 is now aged sixty-nine years while the appellant
No.2 is aged fifty-nine years. The incident occurred on 19.08.1994
and a period of almost thirty-two years have since elapsed. The
appellants had already undergone incarceration for a period of six
months and hence, at this point of time, the appellants did not
deserve to be required to undergo the remaining sentence. Instead,
it was submitted that the fine amount could be enhanced so as to
further compensate the widow of Chintamani. It was, thus, prayed
that discretion under Article 136 of the Constitution of India be
accordingly exercised.
6. Per contra, Ms. Pracheta Kar, learned counsel appearing for
the respondent supported the conviction of the appellants. She
submitted that the evidence on record having been minutely
examined by the High Court and the conviction of the appellants
having been altered to one under Section 325 of the Penal Code,
no interference with the same was called for. Merely because some
Criminal Appeal No.3374 of 2026 Page 4 of 7
witnesses were related to the deceased, the same could not be a
reason to discard their testimonies. In fact, said witnesses
corroborated with each other and were, thus, reliable. It was, thus,
submitted that there was no merit in the appeal and it deserved
dismissal.
7. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties at length
and with their assistance, we have also gone through the records
of the case. Insofar as the conviction of the appellants under
Section 325 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code is concerned,
in our view, the same does not call for any interference. The
evidence on record, especially the depositions of PW1 and PW4 are
consistent and there is no reason to disbelieve them merely on the
ground that they were related to Chintamani. We find that the
appreciation of their evidence by the High Court is appropriate and
there is no reason, whatsoever, to take a different view of the
matter. Further, the conclusion that the death of Chintamani was
not homicidal, has not been challenged by the prosecution. We,
therefore, find that the High Court has assigned sufficient reasons
for altering the conviction of the appellants from Section 304 Part
II to Section 325 read with Section 34 of the Penal Code. The
conviction of the appellants, therefore, does not warrant
Criminal Appeal No.3374 of 2026 Page 5 of 7
interference.
8. The appellants have been sentenced to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for a period of one year. The sentence undergone by
them is six months. The offence under Section 325 of the Penal
Code is punishable with imprisonment up to seven years and fine.
There is no minimum sentence prescribed. The incident leading to
the prosecution occurred on 19.08.1994. Though the appellants
were convicted by the Sessions Court vide judgment dated
08.08.1995, their appeal before the High Court was pending for
almost thirty years. The appellant No.1 is now aged sixty-nine
years while appellant No.2 is aged fifty-nine years. In our view,
considering the aforesaid aspects and the backdrop in which the
unfortunate incident leading to the death of Chintamani occurred
coupled with the fact that the appellants and the family members
of Chintamani are distantly related, we are of the view that while
maintaining the conviction of the appellants under Section 325
read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, the sentence imposed can
be partly modified.
Accordingly, the sentence of imprisonment is reduced to the
period already undergone by them, which is six months. However,
the fine amount imposed is enhanced to ₹ 40,000/- each. The
Criminal Appeal No.3374 of 2026 Page 6 of 7
amount of fine shall be disbursed to the widow of Chintamani or
her legal representatives as compensation under Section 357 of
the Code. The amount of the fine shall be deposited by the
appellants before the Sessions Court, Balangir within a period of
four weeks from today. On such deposit, the said amount shall be
disbursed to the widow of Chintamani or her legal heirs with the
assistance of the District Legal Services Authority, Balangir.
Failure to deposit the amount of fine would require the appellants
to undergo the remaining sentence as ordered by the High Court.
The impugned judgment of the High Court in CRA No.253 of 1995
dated 12.02.2026 is modified to the aforesaid extent. The Criminal
Appeal is partly allowed in aforesaid terms. Pending interlocutory
application is also disposed of.
..………………………..J.
[ UJJAL BHUYAN ]
.…..………………………..J.
[ATUL S. CHANDURKAR]
NEW DELHI,
JULY 28, 2026.
Criminal Appeal No.3374 of 2026 Page 7 of 7