KURIYODATH MUSABAH, vs ISRA ASKAR PARAPPAN

Court
Kerala High Court

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..1..
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE J. NISHA BANU
&
THE HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
TH
THURSDAY, THE 24 DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026 / 2ND ASWINA, 1948
OP (FC) NO. 375 OF 2026
OP NO.1211 OF 2025 OF FAMILY COURT, MALAPPURAM
PETITIONER/PETITIONER/RESPONDENT:
KURIYODATH MUSABAH,
AGED 28 YEARS
S/O KURIYODATH MUSTHAFA, KURIYODATH (H), PONMUNDAM
AMSOM, KURIKKOKIKUNN DESOM, TIRUR TALUK, MALAPPURAM
DISTRICT, REPRESENTED BY POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER,
MOHAMMED SHAHID P.P, S/O CHEKKU HAJI, PARAPARAMBIL(H),
PONMALA (PO), MELMURI, THIRURANGADI TALUK, MALAPPURAM
DISTRICT., PIN - 676528
BY ADVS.
SRI.JAMSHEED HAFIZ
SMT.T.S.SREEKUTTY
SMT.FATHIMA NASREEN S.
RESPONDENT/RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
ISRA ASKAR PARAPPAN,
AGED 25 YEARS
D/O ASKKAR ALI PARAPPAN, PARAPPAN (H), PADAPARAMB
AMSOM, KRUVA DESOM, PANG DESOM, PERINTALMANNA TALUK,
MALAPPURAM DISTRICT,, PIN - 679338

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..2..
BY ADVS.
SHRI.K.JAYESH MOHANKUMAR
SRI.PUSHPARAJAN KODOTH
SMT.VANDANA MENON
SRI.VIMAL VIJAY
THIS OP (FAMILY COURT) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON
07.09.2026, THE COURT ON 24.09.2026 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..3..
“CR”

JUDGMENT
Shoba Annamma Eapen, J.
This original petition has been filed by the respondent/husband
in OP No. 1211 of 2025 on the files of the Family Court, Malappuram,
challenging Exts.P9 to P11 orders passed in IA Nos. 2, 3 & 4 of 2026
respectively in OP No. 1211 of 2025.
2. For brevity, the parties are referred to as they are
arrayed before this Court.
3. The petitioner and the respondent herein were
husband and wife respectively. Their marriage was solemnized on
25.12.2023 by performing ‘nikah’ in accordance with the Islamic
religious rites in the presence of a Quazi of Khidmathul Islam Sangham
Padapparamba Juma Masjid Mahallu. The respondent filed OP No. 1211
of 2025 before the Family Court, Malappuram for declaration of ‘khula’.
The petitioner also filed OP No. 1252 of 2025 before the Family Court,
Tirur, for declaring that the ‘khula’ is void, for return of diamond
ornament and for compensation for mental agony.
4. The petitioner further filed IA No. 2 of 2026 in OP No.

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..4..
1211 of 2025, seeking to have the issue of ‘whether khula is legally
valid’ heard as a preliminary issue, IA No. 3 of 2026 seeking permission
to produce documents and examine witnesses, and IA No. 4 of 2026
seeking to keep OP No. 1211 of 2025 in abeyance. Objections were filed
by the respondent; and finally, the Family Court dismissed IA Nos. 2, 3
& 4 of 2026 by Exts.P9 to P11 orders. According to the petitioner, the
Family Court ought to have permitted the petitioner to lead evidence in
the case and ought to have held that the inquiry in a case filed seeking
declaration of ‘khula’ involves the question of evidence as to the return
of mahar and the attempt of mediations done by the parties, which,
allegedly, are the mandatory requirements for pronouncing ‘khula’.
Thus, the petitioner has come up before this Court challenging Exts.P9
to P11 orders.
5. The respondent filed a counter affidavit, relying on the
judgments of this Court in X and Others v. Y and Others [2021 (2)
KLT 967] and Asbi K. N. v. Hashim M. U. [2021 (6) KLT 292], and
contending that the inquiry stated therein is only summary in nature
treating it as an uncontested matter. It was further contended that all
conditions stipulated in X (supra) had been complied with by the
respondent and that there is no provision enabling the petitioner to
contest or seek a stay of the proceedings in OP No. 1211 of 2025.

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..5..
According to the respondent, an application seeking for declaration of
‘khula’ cannot be objected by the husband; and if there is any grievance
for the husband, his remedy is to contest the order declaring ‘khula’ in
an appropriate manner known under the law; and the Family Court is
not entitled to adjudicate upon such extra judicial divorce unless it is
called upon to decide its validity in an appropriate manner. It was
pointed out that in Asbi (supra), this Court specifically held that the
Family Court shall only peruse the recital of the ‘khula’ and ascertain
whether there was a valid pronouncement. The respondent further
contended that though she had filed a sworn statement and the case
was posted several times for the sworn statement of the
petitioner/husband, the petitioner purposefully sought adjournments
contending that he was not ready for inquiry. According to the
respondent, even if ‘khula’ is declared by the Family Court, the
petitioner has every right to challenge the effectiveness of ‘khula’ in an
appropriate manner known under law. Therefore, she prayed for a
dismissal of this original petition.
6. We have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner
as well as the respondent.
7. The learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..6..
Family Court failed to appreciate the dictums laid down in X (supra),
Shamim Ara v. State of U & Others [2002 (3) KLT 537] and Shayara
Bano v. Union of India & Others [2017 (4) KHC SN 19], and that any
form of ‘talaq/khula’ to be pronounced must be pleaded and proved, and
if he/she fails, the plea ought to have been treated as failed. It was also
argued that the apex court emphasizes fairness and hearing the other
side, before declaring any form of ‘talaq/khula’ and that the judgment in
Shamim Ara (supra) was later affirmed by the Constitutional Bench of
the apex court in Shayara Bano (supra), holding that ‘talaq-e-biddat’
was unconstitutional. The learned counsel further argued that the
Family Court ought to have found that the finding of the apex court that
this form of ‘talaq’ is manifestly arbitrary in the sense that the marital
tie can be broken capriciously and whimsically by a Muslim man without
any attempt at reconciliation so as to save it and that, this form of
‘talaq’ must, therefore, be held to be violative of fundamental right
contained under Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
8. It was the main argument of the learned counsel for
the petitioner that the Division Bench of this Court, in Asbi (supra),
totally misinterpreted the observations of this Court in paragraph No.76
of the judgment in X (supra), which reads as follows:

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..7..
“76. VII. JURISDICTION OF FAMILY COURT IN MATTERS RELATED
TO EXTRA JUDICIAL DIVORCE:
The Family Courts Act, 1984 provides for the establishment of the
Family Courts to exercise the jurisdiction excercisable by District
Courts or any subordinate Civil Courts under law in regard to the
matters specifically referred to in S.7 of the Family Courts Act.
Explanation (d) of S.7(d) of the Family Courts Act, confers the Family
Court with the jurisdiction to declare the matrimonial status of any
person. Therefore, there is no difficulty for the Family Court to
endorse an extra - judicial divorce to declare the matrimonial status
of a person. In the matter of talaq, khula, mubaraat, talaq - e - tafwiz,
the Family Courts shall entertain such applications moved by either
of the parties or both parties to declare the marital status of such
parties. In the matter of unilateral dissolution of marriage, invoking
khula and talaq, the scope of inquiry before the Family Courts is
limited. In such proceedings, the court shall record the khula or
talaq to declare the marital status of the parties after due notice to
other party. If any person want to contest the effectiveness of khula
or talaq, it is open for such aggrieved person to contest the same in
appropriate manner known under law. In the matter of mubaraat and
talaq - e - tafwiz, on being satisfied that the dissolution is being
effected on mutual consent, the Family Court without further inquiry
shall declare the marital status. We notice Family Courts are
overburdened with large number of cases. The Family Court
therefore, shall restrain from adjudicating upon such extra judicial
divorce unless it is called upon to decide its validity in appropriate
manner. The Family Court in such matters shall endeavour to
dispose the cases treating it as uncontested matter, without any
delay by passing a formal order declaring the marital status.”
The learned counsel for the petitioner further argued that the petitioner
ought to be given an opportunity to contest the matter on facts and to
ascertain whether the unilateral divorce is legally valid for want of
mandatory requirement of law, after adducing evidence in the case. It
was also submitted that no person should be judged without a fair
hearing, in which each party is given the opportunity to respond to the
evidence against them and that, in the extra judicial divorce pronounced
by the wife, the same is always subject to judicial review in a proceeding

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..8..
where the validity of the divorce is under challenge and that, there
cannot be any prima facie enquiry alone to declare the marital status
and that, the husband should be given a chance to contest the same on
merit. Hence, the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
finding in Asbi (supra) is contrary to the judgments of the apex court in
Shamim Ara (supra) and Shayara Bano (supra), wherein it was held
by this Court that the seal of the court is not necessary to the validity of
any of these modes of extra judicial divorce and is per incurium or
requires consideration by a Larger Bench.
9. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the
respondent, mainly relying on the judgments of this Court in X (supra)
and Asbi (supra), submitted that a detailed enquiry is neither essential
nor desirable in a proceeding initiated by either of the parties to get an
extrajudicial divorce endorsed and the marital status declared. It was
further argued that if the husband has any grievance, he has the right to
challenge the declaration of ‘khula’ in an appropriate manner known
under the law.
10. We have considered the rival contentions raised on
both sides. The challenge in this original petition is against Exts.P9 to
P11 orders, whereby the applications filed by the petitioner to hear the

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..9..
plea ‘khula is not legally valid’ as a preliminary issue, to permit the
petitioner to produce documents and to call witnesses, and to keep the
original petition filed by the respondent in abeyance, are dismissed. On
a perusal of the documents produced and the proceedings of the Family
Court, it is seen that the original petition was filed by the respondent for
declaration of ‘khula’ and a sworn statement was also filed by her as
directed by the Family Court. However, though a counter affidavit was
filed by the petitioner, he failed to file a sworn statement in spite of
giving several postings; and without filing the sworn statement, he filed
IA Nos. 2, 3 and 4 of 2026.
11. The issue to be decided in this original petition is
whether a detailed enquiry is required for declaration of ‘khula’ or the
petitioner should be given an opportunity to produce documents and to
call for witnesses. According to the petitioner, though the respondent
filed the petition for declaration of ‘khula’, the petitioner should be
given a proper opportunity to contest the same by adducing evidence.
Moreover, it is the petitioner’s case that he had filed another petition as
OP No. 1252 of 2025 before the Family Court, Tirur, for declaring that
the ‘khula’ is void, for return of diamond ornament and for
compensation for mental agony.

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..10..
12. The learned counsel for the petitioner mainly relied on
the judgments of the apex court in Shamim Ara (supra) and Shayara
Bano (supra). It is relevant to note that those two judgments are in
respect of instantaneous talaq/triple talaq and it is triple talaq that the
apex court found to be unconstitutional. Here, the issue pertains to the
pronouncement of 'khula' by the respondent, which stands on an
entirely different footing. The said issue was considered in detail by this
Court in X (supra), which was followed in Asbi (supra) as well.
According to the petitioner, Asbi (supra) is per incuriam as this Court
failed to consider the judgments in Shamim Ara (supra), Shayara
Bano (supra) and X (supra) while rendering the same. On a perusal of
Asbi (supra), it is seen that it was rendered by one among the judges
who rendered the judgment in X (supra). In X (supra) also, this Court,
finding that the detailed enquiry is not necessary in ‘khula’, held as
follows:
” 75. In the absence of any secular law governing khula, we hold that
khula would be valid if the following conditions are satisfied:
(i). A declaration of repudiation or termination of marriage by wife.
(ii). An offer to return dower or any other material gain received by
her during marital tie.
(iii). An effective attempt for reconciliation was preceded before the
declaration of khula. ”
It was also held in X (supra) that a ‘khula’ is also a unilateral dissolution

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..11..
of marriage and when ‘khula’ is invoked, the scope of inquiry before the
Family Court is limited. It was further held that in such proceedings, the
court shall record the ‘khula’ or ‘talaq’ to declare the marital status of
the parties after due notice to other party, and that if any person wants
to contest the effectiveness of ‘khula’ or ‘talaq’, it is open for such
aggrieved person to contest the same in appropriate manner known
under law. Thus, direction was given to the Family Court to restrain
from adjudicating upon such extra judicial divorce unless it is called
upon to decide its validity in appropriate manner. In Asbi (supra), this
Court referred to the judgment in X (supra) and held that unilateral
extrajudicial divorce under Muslim Personal Law is complete when
either of the spouse pronounce/declare ‘talaq’, ‘talaq-e-tafweez’ or
‘khula’, as the case may be, in accordance with Muslim Personal Law. It
was also held that the seal of the court is not necessary to the validity of
any of these modes of extrajudicial divorce. It was further held that the
Family Court has to simply ascertain whether a valid
pronouncement/declaration of ‘talaq’ or ‘khula’ was made and it was
preceded by effective attempt of conciliation and that, in the case of
‘khula’, it has to be further ascertained whether there was an offer by
the wife to return the ‘dower’. The judgment in Asbi (supra) is not
misinterpreted and cannot be said to be per incuriam. This Court has

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..12..
considered the judgment in X (supra) while rendering the judgment in
Asbi (supra). The very same judgment was followed by two different
Division Benches of this Court in Sudheer v. Surumiya [2024 KHC
OnLine 1269] and Muhammed Ashar K. v. Muhsina P.K. [2025 (7)
KHC 119]. In the afore judgments, this Court reiterated that scope of
inquiry before the Family Court is limited, and that the Family Court is
only required to record ‘khula’ to declare the marital status of the
parties after due notice to other party, and that if any person wants to
contest the effectiveness of ‘khula’ or ‘talaq’, it is open for such
aggrieved person to contest the same in appropriate manner known
under law. In Sudheer (supra), this Court held that the endorsement of
extrajudicial divorce and consequential declaration of the status of
parties by Family Court invoking Section 7(d) is contemplated only to
have a public record of extrajudicial divorce.
13. In Asbi (supra), the guidelines to endorse an
extrajudicial divorce under the Muslim Personal Law and to declare the
marital status of the parties to the marriage were formulated, which
read as follows:
“ (i) On receipt of the petition, the Family Court shall issue notice to
the respondent.
(ii) After service of summons or appearance of the respondent, as the
case may be, the Family Court shall formally record the statement of

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..13..
both parties. The parties shall also be directed to produce talaq
nama / khula nama (if pronouncement / declaration is in writing) /
mubaarat agreement.
(iii) The Family Court shall thereafter on perusal of the recitals in
talaq nama / khula nama / communication of talaq, khula or talaq - e
- tafweez (if available) and the statement of the parties, ascertain
whether there was valid pronouncement of talaq / khula / talaq - e -
tafweez. In the case of mubaarat, the Family Court shall ascertain
whether the parties have executed and signed mubaarat agreement.
(iv) On prima facie satisfaction that there was valid pronouncement
of talaq, khula, talaq - e - tafweez, as the case may be, or valid
execution of mubaarat agreement, the Family Court shall proceed to
pass order endorsing the extrajudicial divorce and declaring the
status of the parties without any further enquiry.
(v) The enquiry to be conducted by the Family Court shall be
summary in nature treating it as an uncontested matter.
(vi) The Family Court shall dispose of the petition within one month
of the appearance of the respondent. The period can be extended for
valid reasons.
(vii) If any of the parties is unable to appear at the Court personally,
the Family Court shall conduct enquiry using video conferencing
facility. ”
14. ‘Khula’ is the form of divorce conferred upon the wife
similar to ‘talaq’ conferred upon the husband. The recognition of ‘khula’
as a form of divorce is directly available from the Holy Quran. In
Chapter II Verses 228-229, Quran confers rights on both husband and
wife to unilaterally divorce the spouse. The husband cannot refuse to
accede to the request of the wife. The validity of ‘khula’ does not depend
upon the acceptance or consent of the husband; rather, it constitutes a
right available to the wife for dissolution of the marriage. The

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..14..
significance of invoking ‘khula’ is absolute. Hence, the Family Court
need only look into whether the ingredients mentioned in paragraph
No.75 of the judgment in X (supra) have been complied with.
15. In view of the observations as above, we are inclined to
follow the judgments in X (supra), Asbi (supra), Sudheer (supra) and
Muhammed Ashar K. (supra), and hold that a detailed inquiry is
neither essential nor desirable in a proceeding initiated by either of the
parties for endorsement of an extrajudicial divorce. The Family Court is
required only to consider whether the three ingredients stated in X
(supra) have been complied with. Accordingly, we hold that the
impugned Exts.P9 to P11 orders are in order and do not warrant any
interference by this Court.
Accordingly, the original petition is dismissed.
Sd/-
J. NISHA BANU
JUDGE
Sd/-
SHOBA ANNAMMA EAPEN
JUDGE
bka/-

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..15..
APPENDIX OF OP (FC) NO. 375 OF 2026
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1 TRUE COPY OF THE O.P. NO. 1211/2025 BEFORE
THE FAMILY COURT, MALAPPURAM DATED 19.09.2025
AND ITS ENGLISH TRANSLATION.
Exhibit P2 TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER IN O.P. NO.
1211/2025 BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT, MALAPPURAM
DATED 20.01.2026 AND ITS ENGLISH TRANSLATION
Exhibit P3 TRUE COPY OF THE I.A 2/2026 IN O.P. NO.
1211/2025 BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT, MALAPPURAM
DATED 20.01.2026 AND ITS ENGLISH TRANSLATION
Exhibit P4 TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER IN I.A 2/2026 IN
O.P. NO. 1211/2025 BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT,
MALAPPURAM DATED 06.02.2026 AND ITS ENGLISH
TRANSLATION.
Exhibit P5 TRUE COPY OF THE I.A 3/2026 IN O.P. NO.
1211/2025 BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT, MALAPPURAM
DATED 20.01.2026 AND ITS ENGLISH TRANSLATION.
Exhibit P6 TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER IN I.A 3/2026 IN
O.P. NO. 1211/2025 BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT,
MALAPPURAM DATED 06.02.2026 AND ITS ENGLISH
TRANSLATION.
Exhibit P7 TRUE COPY OF THE I.A 4/2026 IN O.P. NO.
1211/2025 BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT, MALAPPURAM
DATED 20.01.2026 AND ITS ENGLISH TRANSLATION.
Exhibit P8 TRUE COPY OF THE COUNTER IN I.A 4/2026 IN
O.P. NO. 1211/2025 BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT,
MALAPPURAM DATED 06.02.2026 AND ITS ENGLISH
TRANSLATION.
Exhibit P9 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN I.A 2/2026 IN O.P.
NO. 1211/2025 BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT,
MALAPPURAM DATED 16.03.2026
Exhibit P10 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN I.A 3/2026 IN O.P.
NO. 1211/2025 BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT,
MALAPPURAM DATED 16.03.2026
Exhibit P11 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN I.A 3/2026 IN O.P.
NO. 1211/2025 BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT,
MALAPPURAM DATED 16.03.2026
Exhibit P12 TRUE COPY OF THE POWER OF ATTORNEY DATED
08.10.2025

CNR : KLHC010386712026

2026:KER:72743
OP(FC) No.375/2026
..16..
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
EXHIBIT R1 (A) A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT 2021(2) KLT 967
PASSED BY THIS HON’BLE COURT DATED 09.04.2021
EXHIBIT R1 (C) A TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT 2021 (6) KLT 292
PASSED BY THIS HON’BLE COURT DATED 12.10.2021
EXHIBIT R1(B) A COPY OF THE KHULA NAMA DATED 08.08.2025
ALONG WITH ENGLISH TRANSLATION