Neo Developers Private Limited vs Rahul Bhargava

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 875
Non-Reportable


IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

Civil Appeal Nos.10899-10904 of 2026
(Arising out of SLP (C) Nos.10086-10091 of 2026)


Neo Developers Private Limited ...Appellant (s)


Versus

Rahul Bhargava and Ors. ...Respondent (s)

O R D E R

Leave granted.
2. The appellant is the developer of a project titled ‘Neo
Square’, who entered into commercial agreements for sale of
undivided, un-demarcated commercial space with the
respondents who agreed to purchase such space in the
project situated at Sector 109, Dwarka Expressway,
1
Gurugram, Haryana. Separate Builder Buyer Agreement
2
and Memorandum of Understanding were entered into
regulating the construction, conveyance and use of the
Signature Not Verified
premises. As per the BBA, there was an assured return
Digitally signed by
VISHAL ANAND
Date: 2026.08.18
16:18:28 IST
Reason:

1
In short ‘BBA’
2
In short ‘MoU’
Page 1 of 11

payable to the purchasers, which initially was paid and then
defaulted. The project too got delayed and the respondents
herein approached the Haryana Real Estate Regulatory
3
Authority for enforcement of its rights under the BBA. The
HRERA passed an order which is produced as Annexure
P-13. It is seen from the impugned order that the respondents
had initiated execution proceedings in April 2025 for the
enforcement of the order dated 14.08.2024 before the
HRERA, which is pending.
3. In the meantime, the respondent is said to have issued
two communications dated 24.02.2025 and 11.03.2025,
informing that the property is proposed to be leased out.
Demands were also raised for development and fit out
charges. The respondents then approached the Commercial
Court under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
4
1996 , seeking interim measures against the alienation in any
manner including the leasing out of the premises. The
Commercial Court found that the respondents having first
approached the HRERA and obtained orders, cannot turn

3
In short ‘HRERA’
4
Hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act of 1996’)
Page 2 of 11

around and invoke the arbitration clause. An appeal filed
under Section 37 led to the impugned order, which
restrained the appellant herein from creating any third-party
interests or rights, including but not limited to that of leasing
out the property, till the commencement of the arbitration
proceedings. The respondent was further directed to
maintain status quo in relation to the respective units under
the BBA/MoU, again till the commencement of the arbitration
proceedings. The request for arbitration is pending before
the High Court.
4. The appellant is concerned with the interim orders
passed, especially in the case of the respondents herein;
when numerous persons have already taken conveyance and
permitted the leasing out of such premises, which if leased
out above the assured return, would inure to the benefit of
the purchasers in the proportion agreed to in the BBA. The
appellant is also concerned with the parallel proceedings
having been taken up by the respondents.
5. We heard Sri Amit Sibal, learned Senior Counsel on
behalf of the appellant and Sri Rajinder Singh, learned AoR
for the respondents.
Page 3 of 11

6. By the impugned order, the High Court found quite
distinction insofar as the prayers made before the HRERA and
before the Commercial Court under Section 9 of the Act of
1996. The impugned order held that the complaints instituted
by the respondents before the HRERA, were in exercise of
their statutory rights under the Real Estate (Regulation and
Development) Act, 2016, whereas under Section 9, they do
not seek adjudication of disputes on merits nor do they invite
the Commercial Court to sit in appeal or the order of the
HRERA, but only seeks interim measures to protect the
subject property from further alienation, and handing over of
possession to lessees, which would defeat their rights. We
are unable to concur with the said finding of the High Court.

7. Learned Counsel for the respondents argued with
reference to a Constitution Bench decision in In Re: Interplay
between Arbitration agreements under Arbitration and
5
Conciliation Act, 1996 and Stamps Act, 1899 , wherein it was
categorically held the scope of interference when an
arbitration clause is provided in the agreement between the

5
(2024) 6 SCC 1
Page 4 of 11

parties is very limited. At this stage, according to the
respondents, this Court can only look at whether there is an
arbitration clause and if there is one, the issue of
maintainability should be left to the arbitrator.

8. Be that as it may, we have to observe that despite the
arbitration clause, the respondents elected to go before the
HRERA. Before the HRERA, the reliefs sought, as extracted in
the impugned order, were a direction to the appellant to
comply with their statutory and contractual obligations,
ensuring completion of construction and handing over
possession of the allotted commercial units in accordance
with the agreed timelines, including appropriate directions
for compensation and/or interest. A prayer was also made for
payment of the assured monthly returns, which though
initially made, was later stopped by the appellants. There
was also a declaration sought that the demands made as
development and fit out charges were illegal, arbitrary and
contrary to the BBA. The relief claimed before the
Commercial Court was to pass an interim order of injunction
restraining leasing out of the property or creation of third
party interests till the commencement of the arbitration. It has
Page 5 of 11

to be emphasized that the interim measure was sought to
enable arbitration to enforce their rights under the BBA & the
MoU; which was the attempt before the HRERA, which also
attained fruition. The interim measures were sought when the
respondents had already initiated execution proceedings
before the HRERA.
9. We are not convinced that parallel proceedings of
arbitration and execution of HRERA orders can be carried out
and the former cannot be resorted to, for reason of the
respondents having elected first, to go before the HRERA.
The prayers made before both the authorities are
substantially the same and the respondents having elected
first to approach the HRERA, merely based on a
communication issued, proposing leasing out of the
properties and demanding development and fit out charges,
there cannot be a fresh cause of action plea, to be agitated in
arbitration. The application for arbitration in the facts of this
case is misplaced.
10. In fact, we have to specifically notice the reliefs as
granted by the HRERA coming out from Annexure P-13,
which has now become final since there is no appeal filed
Page 6 of 11

against the said order. The HRERA issued the following
directions: -
i) The cancellation dated 07.06.2021 is hereby set
aside and the respondent is directed to pay the
arrears of amount of assured return at the rate
i.e. Rs.22,500/- per month from the date i.e.
31.01.2015 till the commencement of the first
lease on the said unit as per the memorandum of
understanding, after deducting the amount
already paid by the respondent on account of
assured return to the complainants.
ii) The respondent is directed to pay arrears of
accrued assured return as per MOU dated
31.01.2015 till date at the agreed rate within 90
days from the date of this order after adjustment
of outstanding dues, if any, from the
complainants and failing which that amount
would be payable with interest @9% p.a. till the
date of actual realization.
iii) The respondent is directed to offer possession of
the unit within 2 months from the date of
obtaining occupation certificate from the
concerned authorities.
iv) The respondent is directed to execute
conveyance deed in favour of the complainants
within 3 months after obtaining the occupation
certificate.
v) The respondent shall not charge anything from
the complainant which is not the part of the
agreement of sale.

11. A reading of the above extract would indicate that the
HRERA intended that the assured return should be paid at the
rate provided in the BBA till the commencement of the first
lease of the said unit as per the MoU. Obviously, the HRERA
Page 7 of 11

reckoned the fact that on leasing out of the properties, there
could be an enhancement insofar as the returns are
concerned.
12. We need to look at the BBA for better understanding
of the directions issued by the HRERA. We looked at one of
the BBAs produced as Annexure 3, which relates to the retail
space in the area designated for the Food Court in the said
project and the specific assured plan scheme availed of by
the respondents herein, from the very many schemes floated
by the Developer.
13. Clause 3 entitles the respondents/allottee, a
preference to occupy the space equivalent to the area
purchased, which in the present case, for all the respondents,
rd
is on the 3 Floor, forming part of the area designated for the
Food Court in the said project. The assured return plan opted
by the party in Annexure 3, for which the sale consideration
is Rs.4,500/- per sq. ft., ensures a monthly assured return of
Rs.22,500/-. Clause 7 (a) speaks of the responsibility of the
developer to pay the assured return, which ceases on the
commencement of the first lease of the said unit and Clause 7
(b) further stipulates that on the allotted portion being leased
Page 8 of 11

out, if the monthly rental exceeds the assured return, the
allottee would be paid Rs.54.55 per sq. ft. for each rupee
increase in the monthly rental. On reduction of the monthly
rental, for each decreased rupee, Rs.109.10/- per sq. ft.
would be deducted.
14. The above clauses would indicate that there was no
handing over of possession contemplated in the agreement
but only a nominal ownership of the un-demarcated
undivided extent purchased by the allottee, which on lease
would generate a rental income in lieu of assured return,
which could either be in excess of the assured return or
lesser, depending on the commercial market conditions;
which govern the rental of any commercial space. These
terms along with Clause 8(a) to (e) puts it beyond any cavil
that the scheme of purchase of the respondents would only
give them the assured returns on the undivided portion
conveyed and not separate possession. Hence, the direction
of the High Court, not to lease out the properties would put
the spanner in the works and impede the project insofar as
the Food Court not being commenced. As we already
noticed, since the respondents had approached the HRERA
Page 9 of 11

and execution proceedings are pending before it, which was
first elected by the respondent, proceedings will have to be
continued there. There is no reason to now invoke the
arbitration clause since the respondents had elected to
approach the HRERA in the first instance. The proceedings
under Section 9 of the Act of 1996, as held by the Commercial
Court, cannot be continued.
15. We set aside the order of the High Court impugned in
the appeal and restore the order of the Commercial Court.
We make it clear that the respondents would be entitled to
approach the HRERA and agitate their cause regarding the
conveyance of the undivided area and with respect to the
development and fit out charges claimed by the developer-
appellant. The contentions of the developer-appellant would
be left open before the HRERA regarding the balance due as
per the BBA & MoU.
16. We make it clear that the findings rendered by us on
the assured return scheme, are based on the BBA and the
respondents cannot raise any contention in derogation of the
specific agreement entered into by both the parties. Clause
Page 10 of 11

(iii) in the contract of the operative portion of the HRERA
would stand modified to this extent.
17. With the above observation, the appeals are allowed
and the parties are relegated to the HRERA, which has ample
powers under Section 63 of the Real Estate (Regulation and
Development) Act of 2016 read with Rule 27 of the Real Estate
(Regulation and Development) Rules, 2017.
18. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.


.......…….……………………. J.
(J. B. PARDIWALA)


....……….……………………. J.
(K. VINOD CHANDRAN)

NEW DELHI;
AUGUST 11, 2026.
Page 11 of 11