Mohinder Pal vs Inderjit Singh Etc.
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 1 -
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
1. FAO-5091-2003
MOHINDER PAL & OTHERS ....Petitioners
Versus
INDERJIT SINGH & OTHERS ...Respondents
2. FAO-25-2004
MOHINDER PAL ....Petitioners
Versus
INDERJIT SINGH & OTHERS ...Respondents
1. Judgment reserved on 21.08.2026
2. Judgment pronounced on 18.11.2026
20.11.2026
3. Judgment uploaded on
4. Whether only operative part of the judgment is Full
pronounced or whether the full judgment is pronounced.
5. The delay, if any of the pronouncement of full judgment Nil
and reason thereof.
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR
Argued by : Mr. Arjun Bhardwaj, Advocate
for the appellants in both the cases.
Respondents No.1 and 2
proceeded ex parte before the Tribunal.
Mr. Neeraj Khanna, Advocate for
Mr. Ravinder Arora, Advocate
for respondents No.3 and 4.
YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR. J.(Oral)
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 2 -
1. This judgment shall dispose of above noted appeals, as the same have
emanated out of the same accident and Award.
2. The aforesaid two appeals have been instituted by the claimants for
enhancement of compensation against the Award dated 25.01.2003 passed by
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Jalandhar ( for short “Tribunal” ) in MACT
Case No.35 of 2001 and MACT Case No.36 of 2001 in the petitions under Section
166 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short “Act”) , vide which a sum of
Rs.1,49,000/- has been awarded as compensation to the claimants/appellants-
Mohinder Pal and Others on account of death of Asha Rani and a sum of
Rs.10,000/- has been awarded as compensation to the claimant/appellant-
Mohinder Pal on account of injuries suffered by him in a motor vehicular accident
due to rash and negligent driving on the part of respondent No.1, while driving the
offending car bearing No.PJR-7780 ( hereinafter referred to as offending
vehicle ), owned by respondent No.2 and insured with respondent No.3.
3. From the pleadings of parties, following issues were framed in
MACT Case No.35 of 2001:-
1. Whether due to rash and negligent driving of feat car No.PJR-
7780 by respondent No.1, resulted in death of Asha Rani on 16.09.01
2 Kms towards Amritsar from Kartarpur on the G.T. Road? OPA
2. Whether the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of scooter No.PB08-AD-2443 by Mohinder Pal claimant?
OPR
3. Whether the claim petition is bad for misjoinder and non-
joinder of necessary party?OPR
4. Whether respondent No.1 was not holding valid driving licence
at the time of accident?OPR
5. Whether the claimants are hairs of deceased Asha Rani and
are entitled to compensation, if so, to what extent and from whom?
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 3 -
OPP
6. Relief.
4. From the pleadings of parties, following issues were framed in
MACT Case No.36 of 2001:-
1. Whether due to rash and negligent driving of feat car No.PJR-
7780 by respondent No.1, resulted in injuries suffered by Mohinder
Pal claimant on 16.09.01, 2 Kms towards Amritsar from Kartarpur
on the G.T. Road? OPA
2. Whether the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of scooter No.PB08-AD-2443 by Mohinder Pal claimant?
OPR
3. Whether the claim petition is bad for misjoinder and non-
joinder of necessary party?OPR
4. Whether respondent No.1 was not holding valid driving licence
at the time of accident?OPR
5. Whether the claimant is entitled to compensation, if so, to what
extent and from whom? OPP
6. Relief.
5. Thereafter, the parties led evidence in support of their respective
cases.
6. Under issue No.1, Tribunal held that accident in question had taken
place due to rash and negligent driving on the part of respondent No.1 while
driving the offending vehicle and issue No.1 was decided in favour of claimants,
while issue No.2 was decided against respondents. Issue No.3 was also decided
against respondents holding that the petition is not bad for misjoinder of necessary
parties. Under issue No.4 it was held that the driving licence possessed by
respondent No.1 was a learner’s licence and at the most, insurance company is
entitled to recover the amount from the owner/driver in case there is a breach of
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 4 -
the terms and conditions of the insurance policy. Under issue No.5, claimants
were awarded a sum of Rs.1,49,000/- as compensation in MACT Case No.35 of
2001 and claimant Mohinder Pal was awarded a sum of Rs.10,000/- as
compensation in MACT Case No.36 of 2001, payable by respondents No.1 to 3
jointly and severally.
7. Feeling aggrieved, the appeals in hand have been preferred by
claimants. The material on file has been perused and parties have been heard.
8. Learned counsel for the claimants in FAO-5091-2003 argued that
impugned award vide which compensation has been awarded is based on
conjectures and surmises and is liable to be modified and enhanced amount of
compensation should be awarded. Learned counsel further contended that the
income of the deceased has been assessed on the lower side and future prospects
have also not been added to the monthly income of the deceased, contrary to the
settled provisions of law. Learned counsel next contended that no compensation
has been awarded under loss of consortium and loss of estate and he prayed that
compensation under these heads be suitably enhanced. In support of his
contentions, learned counsel has relied upon 2014 (1) RCR (Civil) 914 Sanjay
Verma Vs. Haryana Roadways, 2009(6) SCC 121 Sarla Verma and others Vs.
Delhi Transport Corporation and Another and 2017 (16) SCC 680 National
Insurance Co. Ltd Vs. Pranay Sethi and Others , 2018 (4) R.C.R. (Civil) 333
Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram &
Others and (2021) 11 SCC 780 United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Satinder
Kaur.
9. Learned counsel for the appellant in FAO-25-2004 argued that the
Tribunal has not appreciated the facts of the case and evidence on file in the
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 5 -
correct perspective while assessing the compensation which is grossly inadequate.
The claimant had suffered multiple injuries in the accident and he has been
awarded a total compensation of Rs.10,000/- for the expenses incurred on
treatment, pain and suffering and loss of income.
10. On the other hand, learned counsel for respondents No.3 and 4 argued
that the awards in question are well reasoned and justified. The material on files
has been appreciated in the correct perspective while assessing the compensation
and no interference in the same is thus called for.
ANALYSIS AND ASSESSMENT OF COMPENSATION IN ,
FAO-5091-2003
MOHINDER PAL AND OTHERS VS. INDERJIT SINGH @ RAJA AND ORS. -
11. Coming to the assessment of compensation, the term `just
compensation’ has been elaborated by Hon’ble Supreme Court in 2009(1) RCR
(Civil) 867 (SC), Syed Basheer Ahamed and Others Vs. Mohd. Jameel and
Another , and it has been held that while assessing compensation in a motor
accident claims case, the Tribunal should award compensation which appears to
be just. The expression “which appears to be just” vests a wide discretion in the
Tribunal in the matter of determination of compensation. Nevertheless, the wide
amplitude of such power does not empower the Tribunal to determine the
compensation arbitrarily, or to ignore settled principles relating to determination
of compensation. It has been further held that although the Act is a beneficial
legislation, it can neither be allowed to be used as a source of profit, nor as a
windfall to the persons affected nor should it be punitive to the persons liable to
pay compensation and that determination of compensation must be based on
certain data establishing reasonable nexus between the loss incurred by the victim
or dependents. It has been further held that misplaced sympathy, generosity and
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 6 -
benevolence cannot be the guiding factors for determining the compensation. As
such, compensation is required to be assessed by taking into consideration above-
said parameters.
12. In the present case, the accident had taken place on 16.09.2001,
wherein, Asha Rani died and the claim petition has been filed by her husband and
five children. As per their version, deceased was a home-maker and she used to do
tailoring and embroidery work and earn Rs.4,500/- per month. To prove this fact,
the claimants have examined PW3-Gain Chand, who deposed that he is running a
tailoring shop at Jalandhar, where he also does the work of embroidery. He knew
Asha Rani deceased, who used to do tailoring and embroidery work. She also had
an assistant in her tailoring shop. Normally, she used to stitch 6-7 suits in a week
and he used to pay Rs.40 per piece and an additional Rs.30/- used to be paid for
embroidery work. However, the Tribunal did not rely upon his testimony and
assessed the monthly income of deceased to be Rs.1,500/- per month, which in my
opinion is grossly inadequate. Hon'ble Supreme Court in (2022) 1 SCC 198,
Chandra alias Chander alias Chanda Ram and another Vs. Mukesh Kumar
Yadav , has held that merely because claimants are unable to produce documentary
evidence to show the monthly income of the deceased is not a ground to discard
the oral evidence and in such cases, the Court is required to ensure just
compensation based on preponderance of probabilities. Minimum wage
notification may serve as a yardstick but cannot be the sole basis for assessing the
income. Moreover, it is also well settled that where the victim/deceased belongs to
unorganized sector, strict proof of income is not mandatory and notional income
can be reasonably assessed based on the social status and facts and circumstances
of the case. As such, some amount of guess work has to be applied while assessing
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 7 -
the income of the deceased. In the present case, the accident had taken place on
16.09.2001 and it can be assumed that deceased must be earning atleast Rs.2,700/-
per month and accordingly, income of deceased is taken as Rs.2,700/- per month .
13. As per post-mortem report Ex.P2 she was 47 years of age and as
such, 25% amount has to be added to the monthly income of the deceased towards
future prospects in view of law laid down in Pranay Sethi’s case (supra), which
takes her income to Rs.3,375/- . However, this Court cannot lose sight of the fact
that deceased must have been rendering gratuitous services to the claimants being
a homemaker. Hon’ble Supreme Court in AIR 2021 (SC) 353, titled Kirti Vs.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., has held that the income of a home-maker should at
least be assessed by adopting the lowest minimum wages applicable for unskilled
workers. Future prospects too have to be applied, while assessing the monthly
income and amount incurred on personal expenses also has to be deducted. It has
been further held that in view of totality of circumstances and contribution of a
housewife towards household, 25% additional gratuitous income should be added
towards salary.
14. As such, 25% of the income of Rs.3,375/- per month has to be added
as income on account of gratuitous services being rendered by the deceased as a
home-maker, which comes to Rs.844/- per month and after adding the same the
income of deceased comes to Rs.4,219/- .
15. The present claim petition was instituted by the husband and five
children of deceased namely Asha Rani, who died in the accident in question.
Accordingly, it is held that deceased has left behind six dependents and as such,
1/4th of the income has to be deducted towards personal and living expenses in
view of law laid down in Sarla Verma’s case (supra). After deducting the same,
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 8 -
the monthly loss of dependency comes out to Rs.3,164/- and the annual loss of
dependency comes out to Rs.37,968/-, to which multiplier of 13 has to be applied
in view of the guidelines laid down in Sarla Verma’s case (supra) , and after
applying the same, the total loss of dependency comes out to Rs.4,93,584/-.
16. In addition to this, claimant No.1 (husband of the deceased) is held
entitled to a sum of Rs.70,000/- under conventional heads i.e. Rs.40,000/-
towards loss of consortium, Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate and Rs.15,000/- on
account of funeral expenses, as per law laid down in Pranay Sethi’s case (supra).
Likewise, claimants No.2 to 6 are also held entitled to a sum of Rs.40,000/- each
on account of loss of parental consortium, in view of law laid down in Nanu
Ram’s case (supra) and Satinder Kaur’s case (supra) , which takes the
compensation to Rs.7,63,584/-.
17. Accordingly, the compensation to be awarded to the claimants is
assessed as under:-
Sr. No. Heads Compensation awarded
1. Monthly income of the deceased Rs.2,700/-
2. Income after adding future prospects Rs.3,375/-
3. Gratuitous services as a homemaker @ Rs.844/-
25%
4. Total monthly income Rs.4,219/-
5. Deduction towards personal and living Rs.1,055/-
expenses (1/4th)
6. Monthly loss of dependency Rs.3,164/-
7. Annual loss of dependency Rs.37,968/-
8. Multiplier 13
9. Total loss of dependency Rs.4,93,584/-
10. Rs.70,000/-
Compensation under conventional
heads to claimant No.1 (husband)
11. Parental consortium to five children @ Rs.2,00,000/-
Rs.40,000/- each
12. Total compensation Rs.7,63,584/- (rounded off to
Rs.7,64,000/-)
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 9 -
18. Resultantly, claimants are held entitled to a sum of Rs.7,64,000/- as
compensation. The enhanced compensation thus comes out to Rs.6,15,000/- (
Rs.7,64,000/- - Rs.1,49,000/-).
ANALYSIS AND ASSESSMENT OF COMPENSATION IN FAO-25-2004,
MOHINDER PAL VS. INDERJIT SINGH @ RAJA AND ORS. -
19. Coming to the assessment of compensation, the law is well settled
that the compensation to be awarded for injuries suffered by claimant in a motor
vehicular accident should be just and equitable. Courts have consistently held that
while money cannot erase the pain, suffering, or trauma but it is the only legal
means to provide restitution and restore the victim to his previous position as far
as possible for which ‘just compensation’ has to be assessed. It is also well settled
that while it is impossible to fully compensate for the loss of limb, life, or quality
of life, the compensation must be ‘Just’, meaning thereby, that it should be fair,
reasonable, and equitable based on the evidence and not merely a ‘Windfall’ or a
‘Pittance’. The core objective is to put the injured/victim in the same position he
would have been if the accident had not taken place, to the extent money can do
so. This approach ensures that the law provides a realistic recompense for the
trauma endured, rather than just providing normal relief.
20. As per version of claimant, he had suffered multiple injuries and has
spent Rs.7,000/- on his treatment and he tendered his discharge slip Ex. P3 as well
as discharge certificate issued by Civil Hospital Ex. P4 and receipts vide which
medicines were purchased Ex. P5 to Ex. P25. However, Tribunal came to the
conclusion that from the bills produced on file, the claimant is proved to have
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 10 -
spent Rs.4,500/- approximately on his treatment. However, it is a matter of
common knowledge that patients or their attendants generally do not preserve all
the bills and some amount of guesswork has to be applied while assessing the
expenses incurred on treatment. Accordingly, he is held entitled to a sum of
Rs.7,500/- on account of expenses incurred on treatment.
21. Claimant has suffered simple injuries but the claimant has underwent
the trauma of accident and he is accordingly held entitled to a sum of Rs.5,000/-
on account of pain and sufferings as against Rs.2,000/- awarded by the Tribunal.
Likewise, claimant remained admitted in the hospital and has thus suffered loss of
income. During this period, he must have engaged an attendant, spent some
amount on transportation and on special diet and accordingly, he is entitled to a
sum of Rs.6,000/- under these heads as against Rs.3,500/- awarded by the
Tribunal.
22. Accordingly, the compensation to be awarded to the claimant is
assessed as under:-
Sr. No. Heads Compensation awarded
1. Expenses incurred on medical Rs.7,500/-
treatment
2. Pain and suffering Rs.5,000/-
3. Transportation, special diet and Rs.6,000/-
attendant charges
4. Total compensation Rs.18,500/- (rounded off to
Rs.19,000/-)
23. Resultantly, claimant is held entitled to a sum of Rs.19,000/- as
compensation. The enhanced compensation thus comes out to Rs.9,000/-
( Rs.19,000/- – Rs.10,000/-).
24. As a result of afore-said discussion, both the appeals are partly
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 11 -
accepted with costs.
25. So far as liability is concerned, it is well settled that the learner’s
licence is as good as a permanent driving licence and merely because the licence
possessed by respondent No.1 was a learner’s licence will not give the right to the
insurance company to file a suit for recovery of the amount from him as has been
observed by the learned Tribunal under issue No.4. In holding so, I have relied
upon the judgment dated 14.01.2026 passed by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court
in FAO-1242-2014 titled Virinder Singh & Anr. Vs. M/s IFFCO Tokio General
Insurance Company Ltd., in which it has been held that the insurance company
cannot be exonerated of its liability to indemnify the insured merely because the
driver of the offending vehicle was possessing a learner’s licence. Ín the present
case also, there is no evidence on file that there was any breach of terms and
conditions of the insurance policy or Rule 3 of Motor Vehicles Act i.e. whether
respondent No.1 was not accompanied by a duly licensed instructor at the time of
accident or not. Since insurance company has failed to prove any breach, it is
liable to indemnify the insured.
26. Resultantly, claimants in FAO-5091-2003 are held entitled to a sum
of Rs.6,15,000/- and claimant in FAO-25-2004 is held entitled to a sum of
Rs.9,000/- as enhanced compensation over and above the compensation awarded
by the Tribunal alongwith interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of
filing of claim petition i.e. 22.10.2001, till realization, payable by respondents
No.1 to 3 jointly and severally. Out of the enhanced compensation in FAO-5091-
2003 , a sum of Rs.60,000/- each along with proportionate interest be paid to
claimants No.2 to 6 while remaining amount be paid to claimant No.1 along with
proportionate interest.
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment
FAO-5091-2003 (O&M) &
FAO-25-2004 (O&M)
- 12 -
27. Registry is directed to email the authenticated copy of the award to
the respondent Insurance Company in terms of directions issued by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Writ Petition (Civil) No.534 of 2020 titled Bajaj Allianz
General Insurance Company Versus Union of India and others, decided on
16.03.2021 and Insurance Company shall comply with the directions as issued
under Clause (F) of the said judgment.
28. Pending misc. application (s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(YASHVIR SINGH RATHOR)
18.11.2026 JUDGE
amandeep
Whether speaking/reasoned. : Yes/No
Whether Reportable. : Yes/No
AMANDEEP GOSAIN
2026.11.20 18:09
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this
order/judgment