ANIL KUMAR AGARWAL vs HEALTH

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi

OA No.1437/2023 in
Dy. No.11921/2025 (MA)
MA No.265/2026
Along with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025


th
This the 27 day of October, 2026


Hon’ble Dr. Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A)
Hon’ble Sh. Rajveer Singh Verma, Member (J)


OA No.1437/2023

1. Shri Anil Kumar Agarwal
Age-67 Years
Group - "A"
(Retired as Finance & Accounts Officer from ICAR)
S/o. Shri Om Prakash Agarwal
R/o. 23, Park View Apartment,
Plot No. 16, Sector-12, Dwarka
New Delhi-110078
2. Shri Surendra Singh Bhoj
S/o Sh. Prem Singh Bhoj
H.NO. 46 A, Street No-3,
Raja Ji Enclave
Najafgarh -110043
3. Smt. Surinder Kaur
D/o Late. S. Jeet Singh
WZ-276/16, Flat No-7, Second Floor,
Inderpuri, New Delhi - 110012
4. Smt. Kuljit Kaur
D/o Sh. Isher Singh
WZ-105, Third Floor,
Ram Nagar, New Delhi-110018
5. Shri Om prakash
S/o Late. Sh. Hari Ram,
S-787, Mangol Puri,
New Delhi-110083

6. Shri R.S. Yadav
S/o Sh. Hari Singh
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

2 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

WZ-114 E, Todapur Main Road
New Delhi-110012
7. Poonam Singh
W/o Sh. Lal Singh
BH/4 Hahniman Enclave
Dwarka Sector-6
8. Radhamani
W/o Dr. B. Karunanand
3C, S-7, Pocket - 2,
DDA sfs Flats Dwarka, New Delhi - 110075
9. Poonam Suneja
D/o Sh. S.K. Suneja
7A, Nav Sera Apartment
West Enclave, Pitampura,
New Delhi-110034
10. Smt. Vijay Lakshmi Sharma
W/o Sh. Sushil Kumar Sharma
J-59/B, Phase-I, DDA Flats
Ashok Vihar, New Delhi - 110052
11. Smt. Bharti Sharma
C/o Sh. K.M. Sharma,
R-39, Model Town - III
New Delhi-110009
12. Sh. Roshan lal
S/o Sh. Ramkishan
B-339 Pandav Nagar
New Delhi-110008

13. Shri Harender Singh
S/o Late. Sh. Ramswarup
H. No. 1270, Second Floor,
Behind Apeejay School, Sec-21 D,
Faridabad-121012
14. Shri Charan Singh
S/o Sh. Raghubir Singh
Flat No. 137, Janhitkari Society,
Sector-6, Vasundhara Ghaziabad - UP
Pin Code-201012
15. Ruchira Pandey
W/o Jitendra Pandey
10 Vindhyachal Apartments
Inder Enclave, Pashim Vihar
New Delhi-110087
16. Anjula Pandey
W/o Ravinder Kumar
GH-1/25, Archana Apartment
Pashim Vihar, New Delhi-110063
17. Shri GangaNand
S/o Late. Shri Chand
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

3 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

H. No. K 4/3 D, Gali No-7
West Ghonda, New Delhi-110053
18. Shri D.D. Sharma
M-104, Hari Nagar,
Clock Tower, New Delhi-110064
Mob No. 9971415002
19. Shri Ramprasad Yadav
C-85, S.F. South City-II
Block C, Gurgaon - 122018
Mob No. 9899682607
20. Shri Shamsher Singh
S/o Late Sh. Jaga Singh
C-39, Inderpuri
New Delhi-110012
Mob No. 9999043542
21. Shri K.D. Joshi
S/o D.N. Joshi
RZ 153A/7 Gali No. 1, Dabri Extension
New Delhi-110045
22. Shri B.M. Singh
S/o Satnam Singh
A-18F, MIG Flat
Vatika Apartments
Mayapuri, New Delhi -110006
Mob No. 9818017110
23. Dr. J. L. Karihaloo
B1/15 Agrasen Apartment Plot-10
Sector -7, Dwarka, New Delhi - 110075
24. Shri D.K. Pokhriyal
S/o Late. Sh. G.R. Pokhriyal
H.No. 643, Sector-15
Vasundhara Ghaziabad (UP)- 201012
Mob No. 9953080684
25. Shri Rajiv Mathur
S/o Late. Sh. RBL Mathur
RZ-64 Hans Park, Sagarpur (West)
New Delhi-110046
26. Shri P.N. Gupta
S/o Sh. Anant Ram Gupta
F/A-166, Lajpat Nagar,
Sahibabad, Ghaziabad
27. Shri Jitendra Mohan
S/o C.M.L. Bhatnagar
153, Fourth Floor, Sector -51,
Near Ambedkar Chowk,
Gurugram-122001
28. Shri P.P. Khanna
S/o Sh. K.K. Khanna
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

4 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

E-95, G.K. Enclave I
New Delhi-110048
29. Vijay Laxmi Gulati
K-94 Bal Udhyan Road,
Uttam Nagar, New Delhi-110059
30. Shri Baleshwar Singh
226-A, Pocket J&K
Dilshad Garden, New Delhi – 110095.
....Applicants

(By Advocate: Mr. Nikhil Dhiman)

Versus


1. Union of India
Through its Secretary
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Room no. 348A, Wing Nirman Bhawan,
New Delhi-110011
2. Ministry of Agriculture
Through its Secretary
Krishi Bhavan, New Delhi-110001
3. Indian Council of Agricultural Research
Through its Secretary
Krishi Bhawan, Pusa Campus,
New Delhi-110012

4. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Through Director General
Department of Health and Family Welfare
Room No. 348A, Wing Nirman Bhawan,
New Delhi-110011
5. Central Government Health Scheme
Through Director
Sector-13, R.K. Puram,
Block-O, New Delhi-110066.
... Respondents

(By Advocate: Mr. Pradeep Kumar Sharma,
Mr. Rohit Sambher with Ms. Illashree,
Mr. Archit Upadhyay)

OA No.1444/2023


1. Ram Prashad Yadav
Age -66 Years
Group - "A"
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

5 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

(Retired as Head, ICAR-NBSSLUP Regional Centre)
S/o. Shri Sumer Singh Yadav
R/o. A-71, Kunj Vihar CGHS,
Plot No, 19, Near Hotel Radisson Blu,
Sector 12, DwarksSector-6,
New Delhi-110075
2. Dr. S.P. Singh
S/o Sh. Jaipal Singh
Sh. A-27, Sector 33, District Gautam Budh Nagar
Noida, U.P. 201301
3. Dr. Jagat Ram
s/o Sh. Pars Ram
R/o C-6/26 Yamuna Vihar, Delhi-110053

4. Dr. Ram Pal Dhankar
s/o Mehar Singh
RZ 143 Todarmal Colony
Near Golden Vallley School
Najafgarh, Delhi - 110043
5. Sh. Satish Kumar Arora
s/o Late Sh. F.C. Arora
R/o Flat No. F-403 Sector 23, Philips Tower
New Delhi-110077

6. Sh. Amar Jit Singh
S/o Late Jaswant Singh
R/o 19/78 A Tilak Nagar
New Delhi-110018
7. Sh. Bhola Mehto
s/o Late Sh. Sewak Mehto
R/o B 603, BhagwatpurBiradari Apartment, Sector - 6
Dwarka, New Delhi
8. Sh. Jai Mangal
S/o Late Sh. Mahindar Mehto
R/o R2F-27 Gali No. 23 B, Sadh Nagar II Palam Colony
New Delhi-110045
9. Sh. Deepak Adya
s/o Late Balkrishan Adya
R/o DB 108 A DDA Flats, Hari Nagar, New Delhi-64
10. Sh. Nanada Ballabh
s/o Sh Chander Mane Pandey
R/o C-101, Vikas Vihar
Kakrola, Sectro 15
Dwarka, New Delhi -110078
11. Sh. Vasdev
s/o Late Budhan Ram
R/o House No. 57 Ward No. 5
V&PO - Gouinchhi
Ballabgarh, Pin 121004, Haryana
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

6 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

12. Sh. Makan Singh
s/o Late Sh. Dayal Singh
R/o House No. 422 Gali No. 13, Amrit Vihar A Block, Burari
New Delhi-110084

13. Sh. Priya Shankar Chowdhary

S/o Late Sh. R.N. Chowdhary
R/o F-89/B Gali No. 15, Laxmi Nagar
Delhi 110092
14. Sh. Arvind Kumar
s/o Late Sh. M.M. Lal
R/o JB - 19 E, Hari Enclave, Hari Nagar
New Delhi-64

15. Sh. Mahinder Singh
S/o Late Sh. Lal Chand
R/o B-32 Gali No. 1 Sadh Nagar
Palam Colony, New Delhi-45
16. Sh. Chandrika Prasad
S/o Deoga Prasad
R/o B-78, Jwala Puri, Sunder Vihar
New Delhi-110084
17. Sh. Ram Singh Verma
S/o Late Khazan Singh
R/o R-Z-B 68, Jeevan Park, Uttam Nagar,
New Delhi-110059
18. Sh. Ravi Dutt Sharma
S/o Late Sh. Mahendra Pal Sharma
R/o WZ 276/C, First Floor, Inderpuri
New Delhi-110012
19. Dr. Nanak Singh
S/o Late Sita Singh
R/o WZ 245 G.F.
Inderpuri, New Delhi-110012
20. Sh. J.P. Verma
S/o Late Sh, Balmukhand
R/o House No. 560, Kalish Nagar
Ghaziabad (U.P.) PIN 201009
21. Sh. Nawab Khan
S/o Sh. Abdul Wahid
R/o F-61 Gali No.6, Bhagrithi Vihar, Brijpuri
Karawal Road, Delhi 110094
22. Sh. Krishan Murari Pal
S/o Late Sh. Ramkishan Pal
R/o 7 D Block R. Dilshad Garden, Delhi 110094
23. Sh. Rajeev Lochan Dubey
S/o Late Sh. Brindavan Dubey
R/o A-73 Sector X01, Grater Noida-201310
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

7 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

24. Sh. Anil Kumar
S/o LateSh. Karam Chand
R/o House No. 5912 A, Gali No. 8, Kabool Nagar
Shahdara, Delhi 110032

25. Sh. Ramesh Chand Kaim
S/o Late Sh. Behari Lal
R/o BG-3/28 B, Paschim Vihar, New Delhi-110063
26. Mrs. Nago Devi
W/o Late Sh. Ram Chandar
R/o A-1, Roop Vihar, MubarkpurDabas
North West Delhi-110081
27. Dr. Dharam Singh
S/o Sh. Samay Singh
R/o HIG Duplex II RH 34, Sector 2, Rajendar Nagar
Ghaziabad - U.P. 201005
28. Dr. Thakur Prasad Verma
S/o Late Sh. Gajodhar Lal Verma
R/o 332 FF MIG (Kautilya Apt),
Sector 14, Pocket B, Phase II,
Dwarka, New Delhi-110078
... Applicants
(By Advocate: Mr. Nikhil Dhiman)

Versus
1. Union of India
Through its Secretary
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Room no. 348A, Wing Nirman Bhawan,
New Delhi-110011
2. Ministry of Agriculture
Through its Secretary
Krishi Bhavan, New Delhi-110001
3. Indian Council of Agricultural Research
Through its Secretary
Krishi Bhawan, Pusa Campus,
New Delhi-110012

4. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Through Director General
Department of Health and Family Welfare
Room No. 348A, Wing Nirman Bhawan,
New Delhi-110011
5. Central Government Health Scheme
Through Its Director
Sector-13, R.K. Puram,
Block-O, New Delhi-110066.
... Respondents

(By Advocate: Mr. Pradeep Kumar Sharma,
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

8 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

Mr. Rohit Sambher with Ms. Illashree,
Mr. Archit Upadhyay)
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

9 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

OA No.4542/2025

1. Smt. Vijay Lakshmi Sharma
Age- 60 Years Group- “B”
Date of Retirement: 31/10/2019
W/o Sh. Shushil Kumar Sharma
R/o J-59 B, DDA Flats, Phase-I, Ashok Vihar,
Delhi-110052
2. Binay Bhushan Mandal
S/O Late Shri M. L. Mandal
R/o A2, Parijat Apartments, Dwarka, Sector 4,
Plot No.28 New Delhi- 110078
3. E. Roshini Nayar
D/o Late Sh. N.V. Nayar
R/o 41C, MIG, Sheikh Sarai
Phase-I, New Delhi-110017
4. Ravinder Singh Yadav
S/o Late Sh. Hari Singh
R/o WZ-114 E, Main Road,
Todapur, New Delhi-110012
5. Om Prakash
S/o Late Sh. Hari Ram
R/o S-787, Mangolpuri,
Delhi-110083
6. Vijay Laxmi Gulati
W/o Sh. G. D. Gulati
R/o K-94, Bal Udhan Road, Uttam Nagar,
New Delhi-110059
7. Madan Lal Malik
S/o Late Sh. I.D. Malik
R/o 865, Krishi Appartment, Vikaspuri,
New Delhi-110018
8. Balwant Singh
S/o Late Sh. Deep Chand
R/o E-24, Bhagwati Garden Extention,
Uttam Nagar, Delhi-110059

9. Dayanand
S/o Late Sh. Mange Ram
R/o Village Issapur,
Delhi-110073
10. Brham Prakash Dahiya
S/o late Shri Chander Bhan Dahiya
R/o - A-29 Rose Apartment, Sector-14 Ext Rohini,
Delhi -110085
11. Shashi Bhalla
W/o Late Sh. Ashwani Kumar Bhalla
R/o WZ-7, Partap Nagar, Hari Nagar,
New Delhi-110064
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

10 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

12. Bharti Sharma
W/o Sh. K.M. Sharma
R/o R-39, Model Town-3rd,
Delhi- 110009

13. Poonam Suneja
D/o Late Sh. S.K. Suneja
R/o - 7A Navsena Apartment,
West Enclave Pitampura, Delhi-110034
14. Kuljit Kaur
D/o Late Sh. Isher Singh
R/o WZ-105, 3rd floor Ram Nagar Near Adarsh Mandir,
Tilak Nagar, New Delhi 110018
15. Rajiv Mathur
S/o Late Sh. R.B.L. Mathur
R/o RZ-64, Hans Park, Sagarpur,
West Delhi, Delhi-110046
16. Girish Chandra Chandola
S/o Late Sh. C.M. Chandola
R/o D-102, Moti Residency,
Rajnagar Ext., Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh
17. R.S. Latha Devadas
W/o Sh. P. Devadasan
R/o CC-28F, DDA Flat, Hari Nagar,
Delhi-110064
18. Kalyani Srinivasan
D/o Late Sh. Veer Raghavan
R/o EG 61, Inderpuri, New Delhi-110012

19. Radhamani Jalli
D/o Late Sh. J.V.B. Chandrudu
R/o 3C, Sector-07, Pocket-02, Dwarka, Delhi-110075
20. Geetam Kumar
S/o Late Sh. Kishan Lal
R/o 1603, Block-C, Sushant Lok 1, Gurugram, Haryana-
122002
21. Birbal Singh
S/o Late Sh. Ram Chander
R/o - I-8 H.No.37 Sec-16, Rohini Delhi
22. Dr. Rai Singh Rana
S/o Shri Bakhtawar Singh Rana
R/o. Flat No. D43, Indraprastha Apts. Sector 14,
Plot no.1, Rohini, New Delhi- 110085
23. P.P. Khanna
S/o Late Sh. Kishen Chand Khanna
R/o E-95, Greater Kailash Enclave-I,
New Delhi-110048

24. R.K. Mahajan
S/o Sh. P.N. Mahajan
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

11 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

R/o Block E/2/3/37, Sector-15, Rohini,
New Delhi-110085
25. V.K. Srivastava
S/o Late Sh. B.D. Srivastava
R/o 18/36, Wellington Estate, DLF Phase-I,
Gurugram, Haryana
26. M.A. Kidwai
S/o Late Sh. A.S. Kidwai
R/o H. No. 5, Lane 2, Zakir Nagar,
New Delhi-110025
27. B.S. Dabas
S/o Dilip Singh
R/o EA-248, Maya Enclave,
New Delhi
28. Dinesh Kumar Pokhriyal
S/o Late Sh. Govind Ram Pokhriyal
R/o 643, Sector-15, Vasundhara,
Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh-201012
29. Deep Chand
S/o Late Sh. Jagdish
R/o RZ 3E/1, Indra Park, Palam Colony,
New Delhi-110045

30. Rekha Mahajan
W/o Late Dr. Vinay Mahajan
R/o 82D, Block R, Dilshad Garden,
Delhi-110095
31. Satyavir Singh Malik
S/o Late Sh. Hukam Singh Malik
R/o 24/602, East End Apartment,
Mayur Vihar-1, Delhi-110096
32. Abhay Sharma
S/o Late Sh. Bhanwar Lal Sharma
R/o 170, Pocket 6/3, Sector1A,
Dwarka, Delhi-110046
33. Rajendra Gupta
S/o Sh. Prakash Chandra Gupta
R/o B1/46, Paschim Vihar,
New Delhi-110063
34. Neeta Singh
W/o Sh. Vinod Kumar
R/o A-85, Inderpuri,
New Delhi-1100012
35. Surendra Singh Bhoj
S/o Late Sh. P.S. Bhoj
R/o 46A, Ranaji Enclave,
Najafgarh, Delhi-110043
36. Vinay Sharma
W/o Sh. Ashok Sharma
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

12 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

R/o C-803, Sea Show CGHS, Sector-19B,
Dwarka, Delhi-110075
37. Subhash Chandar Sharma
S/o Sh. Shankar Dass Sharma
R/o C-16, Gali No. 2, Prem Nagar Ext.,
Kirari Suleman Nagar, Delhi-110046
38. Yogendra Singh Rathi
S/o Sh. Mithan Singh
R/o H. No.4, Wazirpur Village, Sector-135,
Noida, Uttar Pradesh
39. Sushma
W/o Late Sh. Daya Shankar
R/o 855, Sector-A, Bhagwati Vihar,
New Delhi-110059
40. Bankey Lal
S/o Sh. Ram Prasad
R/o CA/88B, DDA Flats, Hari Nagar,
New Delhi-110064
41. Dr. Rishi Kumar Tyagi
S/o Late Sh. Om Tyagi
R/o B -2G Vijeta Vihar, Sector 13 Delhi Police Society,
Rohini, Delhi -110085

42. Dr. Ranbir Singh
S/o Late Sh. Narain Singh
R/o A-45 Narang Colony,
Janakpuri , New Delhi -110058
43. Prakash Chandra Agarwal
S/o Late Sh. G.L Agarwal
R/o G-4, Pusa Apartments,
Sec - 15, Rohini, Delhi–110089
44. Somlata
W/o late Sh. Davender Kr Nerwal
R/o F-61/34 Katwaria Sarai,
New Delhi -110016
45. Mrs Shyamawati Mishra
W/o late Dr S. K. Mishra
R/o - E-1403, Tower E French Apartments,
Sector 16 B, Greater Noida,
West Gautam Buddha Nagar,
Uttar Pradesh-201009
46. B.S. Phogat
S/o Sh. Umrao Singh Phogat
R/o A-19, Shree Balaji CGHS,
Plot No-37, Sector -6, Dwarka,
New Delhi-110075

47. Kalawati
W/o Late Sh. Lal Singh
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

13 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

R/o - H.No.182 Gali No. 16 Block- B,
Kaushik Enclave Burari New Delhi-110084
48. Dinesh Prasad
S/O Sh. Doma Prasad
R/o A-191, Gali no.6,
Mahavir Enclave part-2, New Delhi-110059
49. Savitri Devi
W/o Late Sh. Ram Kumar
R/o 233, IIB, Sector 02,
Ghaziabad, UP 201010
50. Dr. Beche Lal
S/o Shri Ram Lal
R/o Flat No-189, Pocket-4,
Sector-24, Rohini Delhi-110085
51. Smt. Sangeeta Gambhir
D/o Late Shri. D.R. Gambhir
R/o - H. No. D-120, Bathla Apartments Plot No. 43,
I.P. Extension Patparganj Delhi-110092
52. Smt. Yashoda Rani
D/o Late Sh. Govind Ram
R/o - WZ-1393, Rani Bagh Shakur Basti,
Delhi-110034

53. Arun Kumar Sharma
S/o Shri. Dev Dutt Sharma
R/o - C-30, IInd Floor Ram Puri Opp. Surya Nagar,
Ghaziabad-20101 (U.P)
54. Surender Kumar
S/o Late Sh. Heera Lal
R/o - D-7/3, Sector-6, Rohini,
Delhi-110085
55. Satyapal Singh
S/o Late Shri Prana Singh
R/o - BG-5/12A, Paschim Vihar,
New Delhi110063
56. Roshan Lal
S/o Late Sh. Ram Kishan
R/o - B-339, Pandav Nagar, J.J. Colony New Delhi-110008
57. Kasturi Devi
W/o Late Sh. Hukum Chand
R/o - M-161, Mangolpuri,
New Delhi-110083
58. Ram Nandan
S/o Late Sh. Bihari Shah
R/o - E-27, Khayala DDA Colony,
New Delhi-110018

59. Chandeshwar Rai
S/o Late Sh. Gambhira Rai
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

14 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

R/o - E-58, Khayala DDA Colony,
New Delhi-110018
60. Bindeshwar Thakur
S/o Ammilal
R/o - 153, Dabur Enclave Rawta More,
Gali No.14, New Delhi-110073
61. Dr. Pratibha Brahmi
D/o Late Shri. S.S. Vats
R/o - 166 C Block AC,
Shalimar Bagh, Delhi-110088
62. Ashok Kumar Maurya
S/o Shri Harsh Chand Maurya
R/o - Flat No. 2554, Landcraft Golf Link, NH-24,
Near Manipal Hospital, Ghaziabad
63. Dr. Veena Gupta
W/o Rajneesh Kumar Gupta
R/o - K D 1 B Phase-1, Ashok Vihar,
New Delhi-110052
64. Kanchan Khurana
W/o Shri Harish Chander Khurana
R/o - Flat No.82, Nuovo Apartment,
Plot No. 25, Sector-10, Near Golak Dham Temple,
Dwarka, New Delhi-110075
65. Anang Pal
S/o Late Sh. Vidhi Prakash
R/o - A/30A, Gali No. 14,
Sitapuri Part-1, New Dehi-110045

66. Ramesh Chandra
S/o Late Shri Chandi Prasad
R/o - WZ-105 2nd Floor Gali No.6, Shiv Vihar,
New Delhi-110058
67. Rita Gupta
W/o Dinesh Kumar
R/o - CB-13, First Floor, C-Block,
Hari Nagar Clock Tower, New Delhi-110064
68. Dr. Axma Dutt Sharma
S/o Sh. Surajbhan Sharma
R/o - D-14, Hanbhajan Enclave,
Opp. Todapur, New Delhi-110012
69. Dr. Bharat Lal Meena
S/o Late Shri Bihari Lal Meena
R/o - H.No. WZ-256, F/12 3rd Floor Front Side Portion,
Inderpuri, New Delhi-110012
70. Bhopal Singh Panwar
S/o Sh. Sukhbir Singh
R/o - C-61 A, Anoop Nagar Uttam Nagar,
New Delhi-110059
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

15 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

71. Yatish Chandra Chandola
S/o Late Chintamani Chandola
R/o - SH8/118, New Moti Nagar,
Near Milan Cinema, New Delhi-110015

72. Babu Ram Chaudhary
S/o Late Pardeshi Chaudhary
R/o EG 63, 3rd Floor Inderpuri,
New Delhi-110012
73. Wazir Singh
S/o Sh. Tek Ram
R/o - S-3/27, Swan Park Mundka,
West Delhi-110041
74. Saroj
W/o Late Dr. Arjun Lal
R/o - WZ-256, F-3, 3rd Floor,
Inderpuri, New Delhi-110012
75. Dr. Ranbir Singh Rathi
S/o Late Sh. Ramkala Singh Rathi
R/o - 6-B, New Gopal Nagar, Najafgarh,
New Delhi-110043
76. Dr. S.K. Malik
S/o Late Sh. R.P. Malik
R/o - 1/56, UGF, Sunder Vihar,
New Delhi-110087
77. Rohtas Singh
S/o Sh. Balwant Singh
R/o - House No. 781, Janil Kalan,
Sonipat, Haryana-131028
78. Gopi Chand
S/o Shri Amar Singh
R/o - Village Pochanpur,
Sector-23 Dwarka, New Delhi-110077
79. Poonam Singh
D/o Sh. Murli Dhar Singh
R/o B-4/4, Hahnemann Enclave Sector-06,
Dwarka, New Delhi-110076

80. Baleshwar Singh
S/o Late Sh. Risal Singh
R/o 226A, Pocket J&K Dilshad Garden,
New Delhi-110095.

…Applicants
(By Advocate: Mr. Nikhil Dhiman)

Versus

2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

16 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

1. Union of India
Through its Secretary
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Room no. 348A, Wing Nirman Bhawan,
New Delhi-110011
2. Ministry of Agriculture
Through its Secretary
Krishi Bhavan, New Delhi-110001
3. Indian Council of Agricultural Research
Through its Secretary
Krishi Bhawan, Pusa Campus,
New Delhi-110012
4. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
Through Director General
Department of Health and Family Welfare
Room No. 348A, Wing Nirman Bhawan,
New Delhi-110011
5. Central Government Health Scheme
Sector-13, R.K. Puram,
Block-O, New Delhi-110066

…. Respondents
(By Advocate: Mr. Pradeep Kumar Sharma,
Mr. Rohit Sambher with Ms. Illashree,
Mr. Archit Upadhyay)


ORDER (ORAL)

By Dr. Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A)


As common questions of law and facts are involved in
these three Original Applications, with the consent of learned
counsel for the parties, they are being disposed of through
this common order. However, for the sake of brevity, facts
from OA No.1437/2022 are extracted.

2. The instant Original Application has been filed by the
applicants under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals
Act, 1985, seeking the following relief:
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

17 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

“a. Restore the CGHS Facilities to the Pensioners who
had retired as their last posting at ICAR-NBPGR on
immediate basis;

b. Direct the employer of applicants ICAR to reimburse
to ICAR-NBPGR Pensioners the fixed monthly medical
allowance in lieu of OPD facilities withdrawn for the period
st
1 April 2022 till the date the CGHS facility is restored by
CGHS.

c. Till a final judgment is arrived at by Hon’ble
Tribunal on the present application, direct the employer of
applicants (ICAR) to allow the applicants to get
consultation from CGHS empanelled offices or Government
Hospitals and reimburse the cost of tests, medicines and
in patient treatment (if needed) at CGHS prescribed rates.

d. Pass any other further orders/directions which this
Hon’ble Tribunal may deem fit and proper, in the facts and
circumstances of the present matter.”


3. Factual Matrix

3.1 The present applicants are retired employees from
National Bureau of Plant Genetic Resources (NBPGR), New
Delhi, which is one of the Sub Offices/Units of Indian Council
of Agricultural Research (ICAR). The Ministry of Health &
Family Welfare vide their OM dated 20.10.1982 extended
CGHS facilities to the retired employees of ICAR. The
employees who were serving in NBPGR under ICAR were also
covered under the CGHS facilities. In the year 2022
respondent No.4 issued a letter dated 22.04.2022 to Assistant
Administrative Officer, NBPGR, New Delhi for payment of
advance provisional CGHS contribution in respect of
beneficiaries of ICAR employees at NBPGR for the year 2022-
23. Upon such direction mentioned in the aforesaid letter the
present applicants submitted their contribution for the year
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

18 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

2022-23. However, respondent No.5 informed respondent
No.3 that the employees of ICAR were covered under CGHS
but pensioners of NBPGR were not covered under CGHS.
Vide letter dated 26.07.2022 respondent No.4 issued letter
stating that NBPGR’s serving employees are covered under
CGHS in Delhi/NCR but the retired employees of the said
Institution were not extended CGHS facilities. The applicants
and similarly placed employees of NBPGR submitted a
representation dated nil to the respondents (Annexure A-12)
to respondent No.5. However, respondent No.5 has not
replied to the representation of the applicants. Being
aggrieved they have filed the instant OA, seeking the
aforementioned relief.
4. Pursuant to the notices issued, the respondents entered
appearance and filed their reply, to which the applicants have
filed their rejoinder.

5. Submissions by learned counsel for the applicants
5.1 Learned counsel for the applicants states that the ICAR
has more than 150 Research Units spread throughout the
country. In addition, the ICAR has its headquarters at New
Delhi under the control of Ministry of Agriculture and
Farmers’ Welfare. There are nine constituting Research
Institutes of ICAR located at Delhi including NBPGR. The
rules and bye-laws of ICAR, a Society registered under the
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

19 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

Societies Registration Act under the head definitions it is
specifically mentioned that “The Constituents Units of the
Society means the Indian Council of Agriculture Research
Headquarters, its Research Institutions, regional and sub-
stations, research laboratories etc. and Co-ordinate Project
managed and administrated by the Society” (Annexure A-2).
The definition of the constituting unit has been mentioned at
Rule-2 (k) of the said Rules which is reproduced below:
“2 (k) ‘The Constituents Units of the Society’ means the
Indian Council of Agriculture Research Headquarters, its
Research Institutions, regional and sub-stations,
research laboratories etc. and Co-ordinate Project
managed and administrated by the Society”


5.2 The Constituency of Research Units of ICAR draw their
employees from the general cadre of ICAR and they are inter-
changeably transferred from one Research Unit to another
Research Unit particularly the Scientists are recruited as
Agricultural Scientists through common examination
conducted by the Agricultural Research Scientists
Recruitment Board (ARSRB) located at New Delhi and they
are deployed to various Research Units and ICAR
headquarters. Similarly, the Technical Cadre are also
recruited by ARSRB centrally and also deployed to various
Research Units. Hence, the pay scales and other benefits of
all the employees working in various Research Units are the
same. In other words, the Scientists posted at ICAR
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

20 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

headquarters located at New Delhi has the similar pay scales
and the allowances as a Scientist posted in any of the
constituent research unit like NBPGR. Similarly,
administrative staff posted in the constituent research unit
gets similar pay scales and allowances as similar
administrative staff posted at ICAR headquarters at New
Delhi. Same is the case with the technical staff posted at
ICAR headquarters as well as the staff posted in constituent
research units. The respondent No.4, i.e., Ministry of Health
& Family Welfare vide their OM dated 20.10.1982 conveyed
the Government of India’s decision to extend the CGHS
facilities to both serving and retired employees of ICAR and its
constituent units at New Delhi. Since then retired employees
of NBPGR the constituent units of ICAR were getting CGHS
facility. However, arbitrarily respondent No.4 decided to
discontinue the CGHS facility to retired employees of NBPGR
whereas giving facilities of CGHS to serving employees of
NBPGR. In view of this, there is discrimination between the
retired employees of NBPGR vis-à-vis the retired employees of
ICAR headquarters on one hand and discrimination of the
retired employees of NBPGR viz-a-vis the serving employees of
NBPGR. There is no rationale or intelligible criteria of
according separate class of retired employees of NBPGR from
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

21 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

retired employees of ICAR as well as the serving employees of
NBPGR.

6. Submissions by the learned counsel for the
respondent Nos.1,4 & 5

6.1 Learned counsel for respondents 1,4 & 5 draws
attention to order dated 10.06.2014 issued by the Ministry of
Health & Family Welfare and stated that if any autonomous
or statutory body which are already covered under CGHS for
their serving employees and desirous to extend CGHS facility
to their retired employees may accept the conditions
mentioned in the said OM and forward their proposal with
approval/recommendation of IFD through their
administrative Ministry/Department to Ministry of Health &
Family Welfare for consideration.
7 Submissions by the learned counsel for the
respondent No.3

7.1 Learned counsel for respondent No.3 refers to the
counter-affidavit filed by them on 30.10.2023 and states that
respondent No.3 in response to the OM dated 10.06.2014
issued by Ministry of Health & Family Welfare has time and
again taken up the matter with respondent No.1, 4 & 5 for
restoration of CGHS facilities to the pensioners/retired
personnel of to Delhi Based research units, namely NBPGR
and regional centre located at New Delhi of National Bureau
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

22 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

of Soil Survey and Land Used Planning (NBSS&LUP). He
refers to Annexure R-3 containing the recommendations of
respondent No.3 dated 26.09.2022 and 27.01.2023. In both
the letters the respondent No.3 has recommended that the
constituent research units, namely, NBPGR, NBSS&LUP of
ICAR located at Delhi will adhere to the guidelines issued by
the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare vide their OM dated
10.06.2014 and they recommended that the retired
employees of these two constituents research units of ICAR
should also be granted CGHS facilities.

8. Analysis
8.1 Heard learned counsel for both the parties and perused
the materials placed on record.
8.2 The learned counsel for respondents No.1, 4 &5 has
referred to OM dated 10.06.2014 issued by the Ministry of
Health & Family Welfare, which is reproduced below:
“S 11011/15/2013-CGHS (P)
Government of India
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
CGHS (Policy)
Nirman Bhawan, New Delhi
Dated: the 10th June, 2014
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Sub: Extension of CGHS facilities to the retired
employees of Statutory/Autonomous bodies, whose
serving employees are already covered under CGHS -
reg.

The undersigned is directed to state that this
Ministry has been receiving requests from various
Statutory/Autonomous bodies and their Employees /
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

23 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

Pensioners Associations for extension of CGHS facilities
to the retired employees of such Statutory/Autonomous
bodies whose serving employees are already covered
under CGHS. The matter has also been raised before
different Courts of law.
2. The matter has been considered in the Ministry and
it has been decided to extend the CGHS facilities to the
retired employees also of such Statutory/Autonomous
bodies whose serving employees are already covered
under CGHS.
3. The CGHS facilities will be extended to the retired
employees of such Statutory/Autonomous bodies subject
to the following conditions:
a) CGHS facilities will be extended to the retired
employees of the Statutory/Autonomous bodies on cost-
to-cost basis. They will be entitled to OPD facilties and
medicine from CGHS Wellness Centres in Delhi/NCR only.

b) Medical expenses incurred on IPD/hospitalization
treatment of the pensioners beneficiary and their eligible
family members shall be borne by the
statutory/autonomous bodies concerned as per CGHS
approved rates and guidelines.

c) CGHS c ard(s) will be issued only on receipt of the
recommendation of Statutory/Autonomous bodies
concerned along with advance payment of requisite service
charges at prescribed rate (on cost-to-cost basis) on annual
basis. The CGHS cards will be renewed on annual basis
on receipt of annual service charge in advance from the
Statutory/Autonomous bodies concerned.

4. In this connection, it is to inform that the
Statutory/Autonomous bodies which are already covered
under CGHS for their serving employees and are desirous
to extend CGHS facilities to their retired employees also,
may accept the above conditions and forward their
proposal, with the approval / recommendation of IFD
through their Administrative Ministry / Department, to
this Ministry for consideration.


5. This issues with the approval of Competent Authority.

Sd/-
[V. P. Singh]
Director”

8.3 The issue involved in the present matter concerns the
extension of CGHS facilities to retired employees of the
National Bureau of Plant Genetic Resources (NBPGR). It is an
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

24 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

admitted position between the parties that CGHS facilities
have been extended to serving employees of NBPGR. However,
the same facilities have not been extended to retired
employees since 2022, pursuant to the distinction made by
the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. No rational or
reasonable justification for making such a distinction between
serving and retired employees has been brought to our notice.
Learned counsel for the respondents has referred to the Office
Memorandum dated 10.06.2014, wherein it has been
stipulated that the extension of CGHS facilities to retired
employees of autonomous organisations would be subject to
the conditions specified therein.
8.4 It prima facie appears that an artificial distinction has
been created between serving and retired employees of
NBPGR, as well as between retired employees of ICAR
institutions and autonomous organisations situated in Delhi
and those situated at other places. The aforesaid
communication dated 10.06.2014 indicates that the
concerned autonomous organisations may extend such
facilities to their retired employees, subject to acceptance of
the stipulated conditions. It has further been indicated that
the facilities would be extended on a cost-to-cost basis. The
matter, therefore, requires consideration and coordination
between the two concerned Ministries/Departments of the
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

25 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025

Government of India, namely, the Ministry of Health and
Family Welfare and the Department of Agricultural Research
and Education (DARE), Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers
Welfare.
8.5 Accordingly, the Secretaries of the two concerned
Ministries/Departments are directed to hold a joint meeting
and consider the issue of extending CGHS facilities to retired
employees of NBPGR and other ICAR institutions situated in
Delhi. They shall also examine whether similar facilities are
being extended to retired employees of ICAR institutions
situated in other towns and cities across the country and, if
so, the basis on which such facilities are being extended.
8.6 The concerned Secretaries shall endeavour to arrive at a
mutually acceptable and uniform policy, keeping in view the
applicable rules, the conditions stipulated in the aforesaid
Office Memorandum, and the principle of non-arbitrariness,
so that the issue may be resolved in a fair and consistent
manner.

9. Conclusion

9.1 The OA is disposed of in terms of the observations made
by us in paragraphs 8.3 to 8.6 above. The respondents shall
take a final decision as suggested above, within a period of 90
days from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'

26 OA No.1437/2023 with
OA No.1444/2023
OA No.4542/2025


10. No order as to costs.

11. Pending MAs, if any, shall also stand disposed of.

12. Registry is directed to place a copy of this order in the
case file of each case.


(Rajveer Singh Verma) (Dr. Chhabilendra Roul)
Member (J) Member (A)

‘SD’


2026.11.13
SUNITA DUTT
17:44:07+05'30'