Dr.V.Raja Gopal Reddy vs State of Telangana

Court
High Court for the State of Telangana

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA, HYDERABAD
*

CRIMINAL PETITION No. 8877 OF 2023
(CNR No. HBHC010459292023)

Between:

Dr. V. Raja Gopal Reddy, S/o. Late C.V. Subba Reddy,
Aged about 64 years, Occu: Retired Employee (Indian
Bank), R/o. Flat No. 308, A-Block, Sri Mahalakshmi
Meadows, Lakdikapool, Hyderabad.
… Petitioner/Accused No. 7.

AND

1. The State of Telangana, Represented by its Special Public
Prosecutor for CBI, High Court for the State of Telangana,
Hyderabad.

2. The Zonal Manager, Hyderabad Zone, Indian Bank,
th
Vigilance Cell, 4 Floor, Liberty Plaza, Himayathnagar,
Hyderabad – 500 029.

… Respondents.

ORDER PRONOUNCED ON: 17.09.2026
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N. TUKARAMJI

1. Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
may be allowed to see the Judgment? : Yes

2. Whether the copies of judgment may be
Marked to Law Reporters/Journals? : Yes

3. Whether His Lordship wishes to
see the fair copy of the Judgment? : Yes


________________
N. TUKARAMJI, J

2
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023



* THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE N. TUKARAMJI
+ CRIMINAL PETITION No. 8877 OF 2023
(CNR No. HBHC010459292023)
% 17.09.2026

# Between:
Dr. V. Raja Gopal Reddy, S/o. Late C.V. Subba Reddy,
Aged about 64 years, Occu: Retired Employee (Indian
Bank), R/o. Flat No. 308, A-Block, Sri Mahalakshmi
Meadows, Lakdikapool, Hyderabad.
… Petitioner/Accused No. 7.

AND

1. The State of Telangana, Represented by its Special Public
Prosecutor for CBI, High Court for the State of Telangana,
Hyderabad.

2. The Zonal Manager, Hyderabad Zone, Indian Bank,
th
Vigilance Cell, 4 Floor, Liberty Plaza, Himayathnagar,
Hyderabad – 500 029.

… Respondents.
! Counsel for the petitioner : Mr. Raja Sripathi Rao, learned
Senior Counsel, argued on behalf of
Mr. G. Aditya Goud, learned
counsel for the petitioner.

^Counsel for respondents : Mr. Srinivas Kapatia, learned
Special Public Prosecutor for Central
Bureau of Investigation (CBI),
representing respondent No.1-CBI

Mr. Hemanth Kumar Vemuri, learned
counsel, argued on behalf of Mr.
Srinivas Survi, learned counsel for
Respondent No.2-Indian Bank.
<GIST:
> HEAD NOTE:

3
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


? Cases referred
Susanta Kumar Dalei @ Susantha Kumar Dalai v. State of Odisha
(Vigilance), 2026 INSC 510;
Vijay Kumar Kela and another v. Central Bureau of Investigation and
another, 2026 INSC 588;
K. Bharathi Devi and another v. State of Telangana and another, (2024)
SCC 384;
CBI v. Sarvodaya Highways Ltd. , 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2598;
Anil Bhavarlal Jain v. State of Maharashtra , 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3823;

4
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.TUKARAMJI

CRIMINAL PETITION No. 8877 OF 2023
(CNR No. HBHC010459292023)
DATE: 17.09.2026

Between :

Dr. V. Raja Gopal Reddy
… Petitioner/Accused No. 7

AND
The State of Telangana, Represented by its Special Public
Prosecutor for CBI, High Court for the State of Telangana at
Hyderabad, and another.

… Respondents.
ORDER
This Criminal Petition is filed under Section 482 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 (Cr.P.C.), seeking quashment of the
proceedings against the petitioner in C.C. No. 16 of 2014, pending on the file
of the learned Principal Special Judge for CBI Cases, Hyderabad.

2. The petitioner is arrayed as Accused No. 7 in the aforesaid Calendar
Case, facing accusations for the offences punishable under Sections 120-B
read with Sections 420, 409, 467, 468, 471 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860,
420, 409 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), Sections 13(1)(d), 13(2) read
with Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act).

5
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


3. Heard Mr. Raja Sripathi Rao, learned Senior Counsel, argued on
behalf of Mr.G.Aditya Goud, learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr. Srinivas
Kapatia, learned Special Public Prosecutor for Central Bureau of
Investigation (CBI), representing respondent No.1-CBI and Mr. Hemanth
Kumar Vemuri, learned counsel, argued on behalf of Mr.Srinivas Survi,
learned counsel for respondent No.2-Indian Bank/de facto complainant.

Factual matrix:

4.1. The prosecution case, in brief, is that Accused No.1, K. Suresh
Kumar, the Proprietor of M/s. PDM Industries, in conspiracy with the other
accused, including the petitioner/Accused No.7, allegedly obtained various
credit facilities from Respondent No.2-Indian Bank, Osmangunj Branch,
Hyderabad, by submitting fake and forged title deeds, financial statements,
invoices, net-worth certificates and other documents. The accused allegedly
obtained an Overdraft Cash Credit/Open Cash Credit (OCC) facility for M/s.
PDM Industries up to a limit of Rs.4.50 Crores, a Housing Loan of Rs.40
Lakhs, an Industrial Mortgage/Term Loan of Rs.50 Lakhs, and Term Loans
in favour of M/s. P.S. Educational Society aggregating to Rs.2.25 Crores.
The investigation further revealed that the sanctioned amounts were
withdrawn and transferred to other accounts and were subsequently utilised
for purposes other than those for which the facilities had been sanctioned.
Certain non-existing firms were allegedly utilised for routing funds and
creating artificial business turnover.

6
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


4.2. It is further alleged that several title deeds offered as collateral
security were forged. Out of the 17 property documents examined during the
investigation, 11 were found to be fake/forged. The petitioner/Accused No.7
and Accused No.6, who were Bank officials, allegedly failed to properly verify
the title documents, business transactions, stock position, end-use of funds
and compliance with the conditions attached to the sanctions, thereby
facilitating the sanction and disbursement of the loan facilities in furtherance
of the alleged conspiracy. It is further alleged that the Housing Loan of Rs.40
Lakhs was released without proper site verification and without compliance
with the prescribed conditions, and that the funds were subsequently
diverted for other purposes. The accounts were thereafter classified as
Non-Performing Assets (NPAs) on 31.03.2010. Following
adjustment/recovery through SARFAESI proceedings, the total alleged
outstanding wrongful loss suffered by Indian Bank was calculated at
approximately Rs.7,17,96,555/-. On the basis of the investigation, the CBI
concluded that Accused Nos.1 to 8 had prima facie conspired to cheat
Indian Bank by resorting to forged documents, fraudulent loan transactions,
misuse/diversion of sanctioned funds and abuse of official position, thereby
causing an alleged wrongful loss of approximately Rs.7.18 Crores to the
Bank.

4.3. The prosecution specifically alleges that the petitioner/Accused No.7,
while serving as Branch Manager of Indian Bank, Osmangunj Branch,

7
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


Hyderabad, acted in conspiracy with the other accused and facilitated the
fraudulent loan transactions. According to the prosecution, the petitioner
failed to properly verify the title deeds, financial statements, statements of
assets and liabilities, invoices and other documents submitted by the
borrowers, notwithstanding that several documents offered as security were
subsequently found to be forged. It is further alleged that the petitioner failed
to ensure that the loan amounts were utilised for the purposes for which they
had been sanctioned. The prosecution, therefore, contends that the
petitioner failed to exercise the degree of diligence expected of a Bank
Official and that such acts and omissions enabled the alleged fraudulent
transactions and contributed to the wrongful loss caused to Indian Bank.

Pleadings of the Petitioner:
5.1. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that
the petitioner/Accused No.7 served as Branch Manager of Indian Bank,
Osmangunj Branch, Hyderabad, from 27.07.2001 to 16.07.2006. During his
tenure, credit facilities were extended to M/s. Sirish Traders/PDM Industries.
The petitioner personally sanctioned the initial OCC limit of Rs.15 Lakhs on
12.09.2001. Thereafter, the OCC limit was enhanced to Rs.40 Lakhs, Rs.70
Lakhs and Rs.150 Lakhs respectively by the Circle Office, Hyderabad, since
the enhanced limits were beyond the delegated powers of the petitioner. It
was submitted that the loan proposals were prepared by the Credit Officer
and were supported by legal opinions, valuation reports and other requisite

8
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


documents. According to the petitioner, his role was confined to forwarding
the proposals to the Circle Office for consideration and sanction, insofar as
the enhanced limits were concerned. It was further submitted that the
Housing Loan of Rs.40 Lakhs was sanctioned by the Circle Office and not by
the petitioner.

5.2. It is the further case of the petitioner that subsequent audits and
inspections conducted in relation to the concerned accounts did not disclose
any irregularity, diversion or siphoning of funds attributable to him. The Stock
Audit, Branch Inspections, statutory audits and Staff Accountability Studies
allegedly did not fasten any accountability upon the petitioner, and the staff
accountability was recorded as “Nil”. The petitioner was relieved from the
Branch in July, 2006. Even thereafter, the Circle Office continued to deal
with the accounts and the credit facilities and subsequently enhanced the
OCC limit to Rs.300 Lakhs in 2007 and to Rs.450 Lakhs in 2009. The
accounts ultimately became NPAs only in the year 2010, several years after
the petitioner had ceased to function as the Branch Manager of the said
Branch. It is further pleaded that the record indicates that the Bank’s Panel
Advocates had certified the genuineness of the title documents relating to
the securities offered. The petitioner also relies upon the fact that the Bank
subsequently recovered substantial amounts through One Time Settlement
(OTS), sale of properties and repayment of the loans. It is also stated that
proceedings against the co-accused, namely Accused Nos.6 and 8, were

9
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


quashed by this Court, while proceedings against Accused Nos.3 and 4
were quashed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.

5.3. The petitioner relies upon the aforesaid circumstances to contend that
the material on record does not disclose any specific act on his part, beyond
the sanction of the initial OCC facility of Rs.15 Lakhs within the scope of his
delegated authority and the forwarding of the subsequent proposals to the
competent Circle Office, which could establish his criminal culpability in
respect of the alleged transactions. According to the petitioner, the material
relied upon by the prosecution does not attribute to him any specific act of
forgery, fraudulent representation, diversion or siphoning of funds, or any
other overt act demonstrating his participation in the alleged conspiracy. His
contention is that his official role in processing or forwarding the loan
proposals, without more, cannot constitute sufficient material to establish
criminal culpability.

5.4. In support of his submissions, learned Senior Counsel placed reliance
upon Susanta Kumar Dalei @ Susantha Kumar Dalai v. State of Odisha
(Vigilance), 2026 INSC 510, to contend that general, vague and omnibus
allegations, without identification of a specific role or overt act attributable to
an individual accused, cannot, by themselves, justify the continuation of
criminal proceedings against such accused. It is submitted that, at the stage
of discharge or quashing, the Court is not required to undertake a detailed

10
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


appreciation of the evidence, so as to determine whether the prosecution will
ultimately succeed at trial. Rather, the Court is required to examine whether
the material on record discloses sufficient material or grave suspicion
connecting the particular accused with the alleged offences. Applying the
said principle, learned Senior Counsel contends that the petitioner’s mere
status as Branch Manager and his role in forwarding proposals cannot
constitute sufficient material establishing criminal culpability in the absence
of specific material demonstrating knowledge, dishonest intention, forgery or
participation in the alleged conspiracy.

Reliance is also placed upon Vijay Kumar Kela and another v. Central
Bureau of Investigation and another, 2026 INSC 588, to contend that, where
a banking transaction has been substantially completed or settled pursuant
to approved terms and the Bank has received the settlement amount, the
continuation of criminal proceedings may, in appropriate circumstances, be
examined from the perspective of abuse of the process of law, particularly
where the possibility of quashing the proceedings has otherwise become
remote. Learned Senior Counsel, therefore, submits that, since the amounts
were recovered by the Bank pursuant to the OTS, full satisfaction was
recorded before the DRT, and the basic ingredients of the alleged offences
are not made out against the petitioner, continuation of the criminal
proceedings against him would amount to an abuse of the process of law.

11
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


Learned Senior Counsel further placed reliance upon K. Bharathi Devi
and another v. State of Telangana and another, (2024) SCC 384, which
arose out of the very same Calendar Case, namely C.C. No.16 of 2014. It is
submitted that, in the said proceedings, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
considered the allegations against the concerned accused and ultimately
quashed the proceedings against Accused Nos.3 and 4, inter alia, on the
ground that the material on record did not attribute any specific and
independent culpable role to them.

According to the petitioner, the said decision assumes significance in
the present case because, similarly, no specific act of forgery, fraudulent
representation, diversion of funds or participation in the alleged conspiracy
has been attributed to the petitioner. His role, according to the petitioner, is
essentially stated to have been confined to processing and/or forwarding
proposals to the competent authority.

5.5. On the strength of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, learned
Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner contends that the prosecution
has failed to place any sustainable material connecting the petitioner
individually with the alleged offences. According to the petitioner, the
material on record, at its highest, demonstrates his official involvement in the
processing and forwarding of banking proposals, whereas the substantial
sanctions were made by the Circle Office and the supporting documents

12
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


were scrutinised by the concerned officers and professional experts. It is
further submitted that the subsequent audits and inspections did not attribute
any accountability to the petitioner and that the subsequent deterioration of
the accounts occurred several years after he had ceased to be the Branch
Manager of the concerned Branch. The petitioner, therefore, contends that,
in the absence of specific and legally sustainable material disclosing his
individual involvement, knowledge, dishonest intention or participation in the
alleged conspiracy, continuation of the criminal proceedings against him
would amount to an abuse of the process of law. Accordingly, learned
Senior Counsel seeks quashing of the proceedings against the petitioner in
the Calendar Case.

Pleadings of the Respondent No.1-CBI:
6.1. In contrast, learned Special Public Prosecutor appearing for
Respondent No.1-CBI opposed the petition and submitted that the petitioner
cannot be portrayed as a mere forwarding officer. According to the learned
Special Public Prosecutor, the material collected during the investigation,
coupled with the evidence already adduced before the trial Court, discloses
the petitioner’s active involvement in the processing, recommendation and
sanction of the credit facilities extended to M/s. Sirish Traders/PDM
Industries. It is submitted that, during the petitioner’s tenure as Branch
Manager of Indian Bank, Osmangunj Branch, Hyderabad, he was directly
involved in the processing of credit facilities aggregating to approximately

13
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


Rs.3.05 Crores, comprising the OCC facility of Rs.15 Lakhs sanctioned in
2001, the enhanced limit of Rs.40 Lakhs in 2002, Rs.70 Lakhs in 2004 and
Rs.1.50 Crores in 2005, as well as a Housing Loan of Rs.40 Lakhs
sanctioned in 2003. According to the CBI, merely because some of the
enhanced limits were ultimately sanctioned by the Circle Office, the
petitioner cannot thereby completely dissociate himself from the
transactions, particularly when his role in processing and recommending the
proposals is specifically alleged by the prosecution.

6.2. Learned Special Public Prosecutor further submitted that the loans
were processed and recommended on the strength of title deeds and other
documents, which were subsequently found, to a substantial extent, to be
vague, forged and unreliable. According to the prosecution, several title
documents furnished as collateral security were not genuine and some of the
documents were also found to have been deposited with other Banks. It is
contended that, being the Branch Manager, the petitioner was under an
obligation to exercise due diligence and to ensure verification of the
genuineness and validity of the securities offered before recommending the
credit facilities and their subsequent enhancements. The CBI submits that
the relevant question is not merely whether the petitioner possessed formal
authority to sanction a particular credit limit, but whether, notwithstanding the
limits of his delegated powers, he knowingly or negligently facilitated the
processing and recommendation of credit facilities on the basis of allegedly

14
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


forged and unreliable documents. It is further submitted that the petitioner
failed to independently verify the title deeds and did not ensure compliance
with the prescribed banking procedure relating to verification of the
securities. Particular emphasis is placed upon the manner in which the legal
opinions were allegedly obtained. According to the CBI, instead of the
Branch Manager forwarding the original title documents through the
prescribed procedure to the Bank’s Panel Advocate for independent
scrutiny, the borrower himself approached the Panel Advocate with
photocopies of the documents and obtained the legal opinion. The CBI
contends that such deviation from the prescribed procedure constitutes a
material circumstance, which requires consideration while examining the
petitioner’s conduct and the allegation that he failed to exercise the requisite
degree of care and diligence expected of a Branch Manager while dealing
with substantial public funds.

6.3. It is further contended that, while enhancing the OCC facility from
Rs.70 Lakhs to Rs.1.50 Crores, the petitioner allegedly recommended the
enhancement without disclosing or verifying that the properties offered as
security had already been mortgaged. According to Respondent No.1-CBI,
the alleged suppression of, or failure to verify, the existence of prior
mortgages, when considered cumulatively with the other circumstances
concerning the title documents and the manner in which the credit facilities
were processed, constitutes material which requires adjudication at trial and

15
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


cannot be brushed aside at the stage of exercising the inherent jurisdiction
of this Court. It is also contended that the petitioner failed to ensure
compliance with the conditions governing the sanction and disbursement of
the credit facilities. Such conditions allegedly included verification of the title
deeds by the approved Advocate, valuation of the secured properties by the
Panel Engineer, confirmation that the borrowers had not availed OCC
facilities from other Banks, and verification of the utilisation of the sanctioned
funds for the purposes for which the facilities had been granted. The CBI
submits that these safeguards were intended to protect the Bank against,
inter alia, the creation of multiple charges over the same properties and
misuse of the sanctioned funds. The alleged failure on the part of the
petitioner to ensure compliance with these conditions, according to the
prosecution, constitutes relevant material for assessing his role and conduct
in the transactions.

6.4. It is further submitted that the allegations are not confined to the
material contained in the charge sheet but are also supported by evidence,
which has already been recorded by the trial Court. Learned Special Public
Prosecutor submitted that PW-2 deposed that, out of the 14 documents
examined, 11 were fake and only three were genuine. According to the
prosecution, this evidence is corroborated by the testimony of PW-3 and
officials of the Registration Department. Learned Special Public Prosecutor
submits that the allegation concerning the forged title documents is,

16
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


therefore, not founded merely upon the assertions contained in the charge
sheet but is supported by oral and documentary evidence, which is presently
being tested before the trial Court. The prosecution accordingly contends
that the genuineness of the title deeds, the manner in which they were
produced and relied upon, compliance with the prescribed banking
procedures, and the petitioner’s conduct and knowledge are all matters
requiring appreciation of evidence and ought not to be conclusively
determined in proceedings seeking quashing of the criminal case.

6.5. It is further submitted that, when the acts and omissions attributed to
the petitioner are considered cumulatively, the conduct of the borrower and
the other accused, along with the surrounding circumstances, discloses
material suggesting his participation in the alleged criminal conspiracy.
According to the prosecution, the allegations raise questions as to whether
the petitioner possessed knowledge of the fraudulent nature of the
documents, whether he acted with dishonest intention, and whether his
conduct formed part of the concerted course of action allegedly undertaken
by the borrowers and the other accused. These questions, according to the
learned Special Public Prosecutor, are required to be assessed on the basis
of the entire evidence and cannot appropriately be determined at the present
stage. It is further submitted that the trial has already substantially
progressed. Out of 98 witnesses cited by the prosecution, 42 witnesses have
been examined and 387 documents have already been marked. According

17
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


to the learned Special Public Prosecutor, interference by this Court at such
an advanced stage would unnecessarily interrupt the trial. Any assessment
of the evidence for the purpose of determining the truth or otherwise of the
allegations, it is contended, would travel beyond the permissible scope of the
present proceedings and would amount to an exercise falling within the
domain of the trial Court.

6.6. Learned Special Public Prosecutor also opposed the petitioner’s
reliance upon the One Time Settlement (OTS), subsequent recoveries and
the alleged satisfaction of the Bank’s dues. It is submitted that settlement of
the Bank’s monetary claims or recovery of amounts due does not, by itself,
automatically extinguish criminal liability arising from allegations of
conspiracy, cheating, forgery, criminal breach of trust and criminal
misconduct. According to the learned Special Public Prosecutor, the Bank
received Rs.3.80 Crores under the OTS against alleged total dues of
approximately Rs.16.35 Crores, and the settlement consequently involved
an alleged loss of approximately Rs.12.56 Crores. It is, therefore, contended
that the OTS cannot be treated as wiping out the alleged criminality or as
converting the allegedly fraudulent transactions into a purely civil dispute.

6.7. In support of the aforesaid contentions, learned Special Public
Prosecutor placed reliance upon CBI v. Sarvodaya Highways Ltd. , 2025
SCC OnLine SC 2598, and submitted that, in cases involving serious

18
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


economic offences, fraudulent banking transactions and allegations
concerning forged or fabricated documents, mere settlement of the monetary
claims of the financial institution does not, by itself, extinguish the criminal
proceedings. It is contended that the present case does not relate merely to
recovery of a debt, but involves allegations of fraudulent conduct on the part
of the petitioner, misuse of the banking system and involvement of public
funds. Therefore, according to the prosecution, settlement of the financial
liability cannot constitute a ground, by itself, for quashing the criminal
proceedings.

Learned Special Public Prosecutor further placed reliance upon Anil
Bhavarlal Jain v. State of Maharashtra , 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3823,
wherein, according to the submission, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that
economic offences having a serious impact upon the public at large are
required to be considered independently of the settlement of financial
liability. It was further submitted that allegations involving corruption, abuse
of banking transactions, cheating and other criminal offences cannot
ordinarily be reduced to a dispute of a purely private nature merely because
the financial institution has accepted settlement of its monetary claims.

6.8. Further, referring to the order passed in Criminal Petition No.5778 of
2016 concerning Accused Nos.1 to 5 in the same C.C. No.16 of 2014,
learned Special Public Prosecutor submitted that those accused had also

19
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


sought quashing of the proceedings by relying upon the OTS and settlement
of the Bank’s dues, but the proceedings were not quashed. According to the
CBI, the said decision demonstrates that, in the context of the very same
prosecution, the existence of an OTS cannot, by itself, be regarded as
sufficient to terminate criminal proceedings where the allegations concern
fake or forged documents and other acts constituting alleged criminality. As
regards the relief granted to the co-accused and the plea of parity raised by
the petitioner, learned Special Public Prosecutor submitted that the petitioner
cannot claim parity as an automatic or absolute right. It is contended that the
orders relating to Accused Nos.3 and 4, and the proceedings concerning
Accused Nos.6 and 8, were based upon the specific records and material
applicable to those accused. According to the prosecution, the material in
the present case establishes that the petitioner had a definite role in the
processing and recommendation of the credit facilities. It is, therefore,
submitted that the petitioner cannot derive an automatic benefit from the
orders passed in favour of the other accused, particularly when the nature
and extent of the material and allegations against each accused have to be
examined independently.

6.9. Learned Special Public Prosecutor appearing for Respondent No.1
accordingly submits that the charge-sheet material collected during the
investigation, together with the evidence already recorded before the trial
Court, discloses sufficient material connecting the petitioner with the alleged

20
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


offences. It is, therefore, pleaded that the petitioner has failed to
demonstrate that the allegations against him are inherently improbable or
that the prosecution case is manifestly groundless, so as to warrant exercise
of the extraordinary/inherent jurisdiction of this Court. Learned Special Public
Prosecutor accordingly prayed for dismissal of the petition and for permitting
the trial Court to proceed with the trial in accordance with law.

Pleadings of the Respondent No.2-Indian Bank:
7.1. Learned counsel appearing for Respondent No.2-Indian Bank, while
opposing the petition, submitted that the petitioner was working as Branch
Manager during the relevant period and was involved in sanctioning and/or
recommending various credit facilities in favour of M/s. Sirish Traders/PDM
Industries, including OCC limits and a Housing Loan. The concerned loan
accounts were subsequently classified as Non-Performing Assets in the year
2010. It is further submitted that, during the course of recovery proceedings
initiated under the SARFAESI Act, the Bank discovered that eleven (11)
documents relating to five properties offered as security were allegedly fake
or fabricated and that third-party claims were found to exist in respect of the
said properties. According to Respondent No.2–Bank, the documents in
question had been deposited with the Bank during the tenure of the
petitioner and the petitioner had sanctioned and/or recommended credit
facilities relying upon the said documents. It is, therefore, contended that the
petitioner cannot now contend that his role was confined merely to

21
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


forwarding the proposals. According to the Bank, as Branch Manager, he
was responsible for exercising due diligence in relation to the borrowers,
verifying the title documents and securities offered, and ensuring the
genuineness and validity of the properties furnished as collateral security.

7.2. It is further submitted that, in respect of the initial OCC facility of Rs.15
Lakhs, the petitioner allegedly failed to obtain the Bank’s legal opinion in
accordance with the prescribed procedure. It is alleged that, in relation to the
title documents, the borrower himself approached the Panel Advocate with
photocopies of the documents and obtained the legal opinion. The Bank
contends that such a procedure was contrary to the applicable banking
procedure. With regard to the Housing Loan, the Bank further contends that
the petitioner allegedly recommended the facility against a property which
had already been mortgaged to the Bank.

7.3. It is further alleged that the petitioner failed to conduct the requisite
site verification and that the loan amount was released in four stages without
obtaining the necessary work-completion certificates. According to
Respondent No.2-Bank, these circumstances disclose deviations from the
prescribed procedure and are relevant to determining the petitioner’s role
and responsibility in the alleged transactions. It is further pleaded that, by
virtue of his position as Branch Manager, the petitioner had a direct
responsibility to verify and ascertain the credentials of the borrower, the

22
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


genuineness of the title documents, the authority and validity of the
sanctions, and the securities offered as collateral. It is, therefore, contended
that the petitioner cannot avoid such responsibility merely by asserting that
the authority to accord final sanction for the enhanced credit limits did not
vest in him. The Bank further submits that the petitioner’s conduct in
processing, scrutinising and recommending the proposals on the basis of the
documents and securities furnished by the borrowers is relevant for
assessing his role and responsibility in the alleged transactions.

7.4. It is also submitted that the record discloses allegations relating to the
loan documents and the alleged acceptance of fake and fabricated
documents as security, the alleged failure to follow the prescribed banking
procedure, the failure to obtain the requisite legal opinion, the failure to verify
the properties offered as security, and the failure to ascertain the existence
of any prior mortgage. According to Respondent No.2-Bank, the petitioner’s
criminal liability in respect of these allegations involves disputed questions of
fact and appreciation of evidence, which cannot appropriately be determined
in proceedings seeking quashing of the criminal proceedings, particularly
when charges have already been framed and the trial is substantially
underway.

7.5. Learned counsel for Respondent No.2-Bank also disputed the
contention that the subsequent OTS and recovery proceedings have the

23
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


effect of extinguishing the alleged criminal liability. It is submitted that the
settlement involved an alleged loss of approximately Rs.1,256 Lakhs and
that the settlement, by itself, does not nullify the allegations relating to
fraudulent abuse of the banking process or criminal conspiracy. On the
aforesaid grounds, Respondent No.2-Indian Bank prayed for dismissal of the
petition.

Analysis and Conclusion:
8. Having heard the rival submissions and upon consideration of the
material placed on record, the following points arise for consideration:
A. Whether the material placed on record prima facie discloses the
essential ingredients of the offences alleged against the petitioner?
B. Whether there is specific material connecting the petitioner with the
alleged criminal conspiracy?
C. Whether criminal liability can be fastened upon the petitioner merely
on account of his position as the Bank Officer, who authorised,
processed or forwarded the loan proposals?
D. Whether continuation of the criminal proceedings against the
petitioner would amount to an abuse of the process of law?

9. At the outset, it is necessary to bear in mind that the jurisdiction under
Section 482 Cr.P.C. is required to be exercised sparingly, cautiously and
with circumspection. At the same time, the inherent jurisdiction of this Court

24
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


is intended to prevent abuse of the process of law and to secure the ends of
justice. Ordinarily, while considering a petition seeking quashing of criminal
proceedings, this Court would not undertake a meticulous appreciation of
evidence or conduct a mini-trial. It is, however, equally well settled that
where the allegations and the material placed on record, even if taken at
their face value and accepted in their entirety, do not constitute the essential
ingredients of the alleged offences, or where the material does not disclose
the necessary nexus between the accused and the alleged criminality,
continuation of the proceedings cannot be permitted merely because a
charge sheet has been filed or the trial has commenced. The exercise of
inherent jurisdiction, therefore, necessarily requires the Court to examine
whether the prosecution material discloses the foundational ingredients of
the offences and whether there is sufficient material connecting the particular
accused with the alleged criminal acts.

10. In the instant case, the petitioner was admittedly working as Branch
Manager of Indian Bank, Osmangunj Branch, Hyderabad, from 2001 to
2006. The material placed before this Court indicates that the petitioner
initially sanctioned an OCC facility of Rs.15 Lakhs on 12.09.2001. The
subsequent enhancements to Rs.40 Lakhs, Rs.70 Lakhs and Rs.1.50
Crores were beyond the petitioner’s delegated powers and were sanctioned
by the Circle Office, Hyderabad. The proposals for the said facilities were
prepared by the Credit Officer/PW-4, and the petitioner’s case that he

25
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


forwarded the proposals to the competent authority finds support from the
material referred to before this Court. The Housing Loan of Rs.40 Lakhs was
also sanctioned by the Circle Office. In this context, the distinction between
an Officer who processes, scrutinises or forwards a proposal and the
competent authority empowered to accord the final sanction assumes
significance. The petitioner cannot be attributed criminal liability merely by
reason of the office held by him as Branch Manager. To sustain allegations
of conspiracy, cheating, criminal breach of trust, forgery, use of forged
documents or criminal misconduct, there must be material connecting the
petitioner with the essential elements of the respective offences. The mere
fact that the petitioner processed or forwarded proposals, which were
subsequently considered and sanctioned by the competent authority cannot,
in the absence of further material, by itself be construed as participation in
the alleged fraudulent transactions. The prosecution case substantially rests
upon the allegation that certain documents furnished as collateral security
were fake or forged. The mere fact that some documents were subsequently
found to be forged cannot, by itself, constitute a circumstance against every
person, who dealt with the transaction unless there is material to show that
such person fabricated the documents, intentionally used them as genuine,
or consciously relied upon them with knowledge of their alleged fraudulent
character.

26
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


11. The crucial question, therefore, in the case of the present petitioner is
whether there is any material to show that Accused No.7 either fabricated
the documents, participated in their preparation, deliberately facilitated their
use, or entered into an agreement with the other accused for obtaining the
loan facilities by fraudulent means. Upon examination of the material placed
before this Court, no specific nexus between the petitioner and the alleged
fraudulent acts has been demonstrated. There is no material pointed out to
show that the petitioner fabricated or caused the fabrication of any title
document. More importantly, there is no material on record demonstrating
that, at the relevant time, the petitioner was aware that the documents were
forged or that the securities allegedly offered to the Bank were based upon
fabricated documents. The mere fact that the securities were subsequently
found to be defective or fabricated cannot, by itself, establish that the
petitioner possessed knowledge of such forgery or acted with dishonest
intention at the time when the loan proposals were processed and forwarded
for consideration along with the legal opinion.

12. The prosecution alleges that the petitioner approached the Panel
Advocate with photocopies of the documents and obtained a legal opinion
without furnishing the original documents. The petitioner, however, points out
that the Circular relied upon by the prosecution was issued only in 2003 and,
therefore, could not have been retrospectively applied to the transactions in
question, so as to characterise the petitioner’s conduct as a deviation from

27
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


the banking procedure prescribed at the relevant time. Even assuming that
there was a deviation from the prescribed procedure, such deviation, in the
absence of material demonstrating that the petitioner consciously adopted
the procedure knowing that the documents were forged or with an intention
to facilitate cheating, would not, by itself, constitute the offences alleged
against him. A mere procedural lapse or deviation, without the requisite
criminal intent and without a demonstrable nexus with the alleged fraudulent
acts, cannot, by itself, be converted into an offence of cheating, forgery or
conspiracy.

13. In the instant Calendar Case, the statements of the witnesses referred
to above, at their highest, disclose a deviation from the prescribed
procedure. In the absence of any other material establishing a nexus
between such deviation and the alleged fraudulent acts, drawing an
inference of a deliberate design or criminal intent on the part of the petitioner
would not be justified. Similarly, the allegation concerning the enhancement
of the OCC facility beyond Rs.15 Lakhs, by itself, cannot establish the
existence of a criminal conspiracy on the part of the petitioner. The
enhanced facilities were admittedly beyond the petitioner’s delegated
powers and were sanctioned by the Circle Office. If the petitioner merely
forwarded the proposals to the competent authority, the subsequent decision
or action of the Circle Office cannot retrospectively be attributed to him in the
absence of material demonstrating that he deliberately participated in,

28
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


facilitated or was otherwise knowingly connected with the alleged fraudulent
activities.

14. The allegations concerning the genuineness of the documents also
require consideration. In this context, the prosecution relies upon the
depositions of PWs.2 and 3 and the officials of the Registration Department,
who stated that, out of fourteen (14) documents examined, eleven (11) were
fake and only three (3) were genuine. There can be no dispute that the
creation or fabrication of forged documents may give rise to criminal liability
on the part of the persons responsible for their creation or use, subject to the
ingredients of the relevant offences being established. However, the mere
fact that certain documents were subsequently found to be forged does not,
in the absence of further material, establish that every officer, who
processed or dealt with the loan transaction necessarily had knowledge of
the forgery or shared the dishonest intention behind it. Knowledge and
dishonest intention cannot be attributed generally or merely by virtue of an
official designation. They must be established, on the material available,
against the particular accused. Criminal liability cannot be imposed merely
by reason of a person’s designation, office or supervisory position.

15. The prosecution has also relied upon the responsibilities attached to
the petitioner’s position as Branch Manager. It is undoubtedly true that a
Branch Manager is required to exercise due care and diligence in

29
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


accordance with the applicable banking norms and procedures. However, a
mere lapse in the discharge of official duties, in the absence of material
establishing the requisite mens rea and the necessary nexus with the
alleged criminal acts, cannot, by itself, establish the ingredients of the
offences alleged against the petitioner. The distinction between negligence,
procedural irregularity and intentional participation in a criminal scheme
assumes particular importance in the present case. The existence of a duty
of care does not, by itself, establish that the petitioner possessed knowledge
of the alleged fraud or shared the dishonest intention of the principal
accused.

16. In particular, Section 471 of the IPC requires knowledge or reason to
believe that the document in question is forged. Section 420 of the IPC
requires the essential elements of deception and dishonest intention.
Section 120-B of the IPC requires an agreement between two or more
persons to commit an illegal act or to commit a lawful act by illegal means.
Similarly, Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, as
applicable to the relevant period, requires the obtaining or attempting to
obtain for oneself or for any other person any valuable thing or pecuniary
advantage by corrupt or illegal means or by abusing one’s position as a
public servant.

30
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


17. No specific material demonstrating the aforesaid requirements has
been brought to the notice of this Court insofar as the petitioner is
concerned. The subsequent conduct of the Bank also assumes some
relevance, though it cannot, by itself, determine the question of criminal
liability. The material placed before this Court indicates that Stock Audits,
Branch Inspections, Statutory Audits and Staff Accountability Studies did not
attribute any specific accountability to the petitioner, and the Staff
Accountability was recorded as “Nil”. It is further not in dispute that, after the
petitioner ceased to be the Branch Manager in July, 2006, the Circle Office
substantially enhanced the OCC limits in 2007 and 2009, and the accounts
were classified as Non-Performing Assets only in 2010. These
circumstances do not, by themselves, conclusively establish the petitioner’s
innocence. Nevertheless, they constitute relevant surrounding circumstances
when the Court examines whether there is sufficient material to demonstrate
that, during his tenure, the petitioner intentionally participated in the alleged
fraudulent scheme.

18. The petitioner’s reliance upon the legal opinions, valuation reports and
the institutional mechanism through which the credit proposals were
processed cannot also be completely disregarded. The credit proposals
were processed through a mechanism involving the Credit Officer, Panel
Advocates, valuation reports and the competent sanctioning authority. The
mere fact that the documents were subsequently found to be false does not

31
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


necessarily establish that every officer associated with the processing of the
proposals had knowledge of their falsity. In the absence of material
demonstrating that the petitioner had actual knowledge of the alleged fraud,
or that he deliberately ignored facts within his knowledge in furtherance of
the alleged conspiracy, the Court is required to distinguish between a mere
instance of negligence or procedural irregularity and conscious criminal
participation.

19. As regards the OTS and subsequent recovery, this Court is conscious
that settlement of a banking dispute does not invariably extinguish criminal
liability, particularly where serious offences such as forgery, cheating and
conspiracy are alleged. The OTS, therefore, cannot be treated as an
independent or automatic ground for quashing the criminal proceedings.
Nevertheless, the OTS, the substantial amounts recovered by the Bank and
the subsequent satisfaction recorded in the recovery proceedings constitute
surrounding circumstances, which may be taken into consideration along
with the absence of specific material connecting the petitioner with the
alleged criminal acts. The decisive factor in the present case is not the OTS
by itself. Rather, it is the absence of sufficient material establishing the
petitioner’s conscious participation in the alleged fraudulent transactions and
conspiracy.

32
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


20. The principle laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in K. Bharati
Devi (supra) assumes particular significance since the said proceedings
arose out of the same Calendar Case. While considering the role attributed
to the accused therein, the Hon’ble Supreme Court examined whether the
charge sheet disclosed a specific and independent culpable role against
them and ultimately quashed the proceedings. The said judgment cannot,
however, be understood as laying down that an OTS or settlement of the
Bank’s dues, by itself, is sufficient to quash criminal proceedings arising out
of the underlying transactions. Its relevance to the present case lies in the
principle that individual criminal culpability must be discernible from the
material available against the particular accused. Likewise, Susanta Kumar
Dalei (supra) is relevant to the extent that criminal proceedings cannot be
sustained on the basis of general, vague or omnibus allegations where the
material does not disclose the specific role of the accused or a sufficient
nexus between the accused and the alleged offences.

21. At this stage, this Court is not required to determine whether the
petitioner is ultimately innocent. The limited question is whether the
prosecution material is sufficient to justify the continuation of criminal
proceedings against him. The fact that the trial has progressed and several
witnesses have already been examined also deserves consideration.
Ordinarily, this Court would be slow to interfere with criminal proceedings at
an advanced stage of trial. However, mere progress of the trial cannot, by

33
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


itself, denude this Court of its jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C. Where
the foundational material against a particular accused does not disclose the
essential ingredients of the offences alleged, continuation of the proceedings
cannot be justified solely on the ground that evidence has already been
recorded. The inherent jurisdiction is intended, inter alia, to prevent the
criminal process from being permitted to continue in circumstances where its
continuation, in the facts of the particular case, would result in an abuse of
the process of law.

22. In the ultimate analysis, the material placed before this Court
establishes that the petitioner was the Branch Manager during the relevant
period and was associated with the processing of the loan proposals.
However, mere association with the banking transactions cannot, by itself,
be equated with participation in the alleged criminal conspiracy. The
enhanced credit facilities were beyond the petitioner’s delegated sanctioning
powers and were sanctioned by the Circle Office. The proposals were
prepared by the Credit Officer and were supported by legal opinions and
valuation reports, which formed part of the relevant records. No material has
been brought to the notice of this Court to establish that the petitioner
fabricated any title document, procured the forged documents, or had
knowledge that the documents were forged and nevertheless intentionally
used them as genuine. There is also no material demonstrating that the
petitioner deliberately suppressed the alleged prior mortgage in furtherance

34
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


of the conspiracy or entered into any agreement with the borrowers or the
other accused to cheat the Bank. Equally, there is no specific material
demonstrating that the petitioner possessed dishonest intention,
misappropriated any property, or forged any document entrusted to him, so
as to attract Section 409 of the IPC. Likewise, there is no material to show
that, by abusing his position as a public servant, the petitioner obtained or
attempted to obtain for himself or for any other person any valuable thing or
pecuniary advantage by corrupt or illegal means, so as to satisfy the
ingredients of the applicable provision of the Prevention of Corruption Act.
The material relied upon by the prosecution may, at the highest, give rise to
a question concerning the adequacy of the petitioner’s supervision or the
manner in which he discharged his official duties. However, criminal
prosecution cannot be sustained merely on the basis of such supervisory
lapses, particularly in the absence of material establishing the requisite
knowledge, dishonest intention or conscious participation in the alleged
conspiracy.

23. This Court is, therefore, of the considered view that, insofar as
Accused No.7 is concerned, the prosecution has failed to demonstrate
sufficient material establishing a specific nexus between the petitioner and
the alleged forged documents or the alleged conspiracy. The allegations and
the material, even when considered cumulatively, do not disclose the
essential ingredients of the offences alleged against the petitioner in the

35
NTR,J
Crl.P. No. 8877 of 2023


absence of material establishing his knowledge of the alleged forgery,
dishonest intention, conscious use of forged documents, or an agreement or
concert with the principal accused to commit the alleged offences. In such
circumstances, permitting the prosecution to continue against the petitioner
would amount to subjecting him to criminal proceedings without the
foundational material necessary to establish individual criminal culpability.
The petitioner is, therefore, entitled to invoke the inherent jurisdiction of this
Court under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to prevent abuse of the process of law and
to secure the ends of justice.

24. Accordingly, this Criminal Petition is allowed. Consequently, the
proceedings in C.C. No.16 of 2014, pending on the file of the learned
Principal Special Judge for CBI Cases, Hyderabad, insofar as they relate to
the petitioner/Accused No.7, are hereby quashed.
It is made clear that the observations made in this order are confined
exclusively to the case of the petitioner/Accused No.7 and shall not be
construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the case against the
other accused. The trial Court shall proceed against the other accused, if
any, in accordance with law and uninfluenced by any of the observations
made herein. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.


_______________
N.TUKARAMJI, J
Date: 17.09.2026
svl