The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. vs Smt. Rina Debbarma and Ors.

Court
Tripura High Court

Page 1 of 5 2026:THC:1560
TRHC010018822026



HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA


CRP No.91 of 2026


The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., A Company registered under the
Companies Act, 1956, being represented by the Assistant Manager/Officer in
Legal Hub/Authorized signatory, Agartala Business Office H.G.B. Road, near at
Sarkar Nursing Home, P.S.-Agartala, West Tripura.
……. Petitioner(s).


V E R S U S

1. Smt. Rina Debbarma, Mother of late Falguna Debbarma, Presently residing at
Village-Puskarbari, P.O. & P.S.-Bishramganj, District-Sepahijala, Tripura.

2. Smt. Sangita Debbarma, Daughter of late Falguna Debbarma, Presently
residing at Village-Puskarbari, P.O. & P.S.-Bishramganj, District-Sepahijala,
Tripura.

3. Smt. Sayantika Debbarma, Daughter of late Falguna Debbarma, Presently
residing at Village-Puskarbari, P.O. & P.S.-Bishramganj, District-Sepahijala,
Tripura.
The Claimants-Respondents nos.2 and 3 being minor, represented by their
mother and natural guardian, Smt. Rina Debbarma, being the Respondent no. 2.

4. Sri Hari Bhusan Paul, Son of Ramesh Chandra Paul, resident of village East
Laxmibil, P.O. Bishalgarh, P.S. Bishalgarh, District:-Sepahijala, Tripura.
[Owner of vehicle bearing no.TR-01-N-1794 (TATA ACE)].
……….. Respondents(s).

For Petitioner(s) : Mr. Biswanath Majumder, Advocate.

For Respondent(s) : None.



HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO

CAV reserved on : 13.11.2026 .

Judgment delivered on : 21.11.2026 .

Whether fit for reporting : YES .

JUDGMENT & ORDER




This Revision is filed by the petitioner-Oriental Insurance
Company Ltd challenging the order dt.10.8.2026 of the Member, MAC
Tribunal No.4, West Tripura, Agartala.

Page 2 of 5 2026:THC:1560
TRHC010018822026



2. The respondents had filed on 2.1.2012, a claim petition vide. TS
(MAC) No.01 of 2012 seeking compensation under the Motor Vehicle
Act,1988 before the said Tribunal against the petitioner seeking compensation
for death of one Falguna Debbarma in a motor accident on 1.12.2021.
3. The said Tribunal allowed the same on 20.7.2013 awarding
compensation of Rs.26,05,240/- along with interest @ 7% p.a. from the date
of filing of the said claim petition i.e., 2.1.2012 within 2 months and if it is not
paid, interest @9 % p.a. from that date till date of payment.
4. The petitioner filed MAC (Appeal) No.38 of 2014 before this
Court. At the time of filing of the said Appeal, the petitioner deposited
Rs.25,000/- vide chq.no.008821 dt.27.2.2014 and as per an order of this Court
deposited Rs.34,61,610/- vide chq.00816 dt.15.10.2015 with the High Court.
5. On 21.9.2016, the High Court partly allowed the said appeal
enhancing the compensation to Rs.28,72,670/-. It directed payment of interest
@9 % p.a. from 2.1.2012 till payment. In the last para of its order this court
observed:
“ Since the appellant has already deposited a sum of
Rs.34,71,924/- , the difference that might accrue for granting the
enhanced sum for the loss of consortium and the loss of love and
affection shall be deposited by the appellant-insurance company
within a period of 2 (two months) in the Tribunal. The Registry
shall disburse the amount in terms of this order and after
releasing the said amount create new fixed deposits in favour of
respondents no.3 and 4 in the manner as stated above. If it is
found that the appellant is entitled to refund any sum, that shall
be refunded as per procedure .” (emphasis supplied)

Page 3 of 5 2026:THC:1560
TRHC010018822026



6. Thus there was a clear and specific direction to deposit the
difference before the Tribunal i.e., MAC Tribunal No.4, West Tripura,
Agartala.
7. But, the petitioner allegedly deposited the difference amount of
Rs.4,48,577/- vide chq.no.1100 dt.9.2.2018 before the Registrar General of
this Court. No proof of such deposit has been filed by petitioner in this Court.
8. The respondents filed Civil.Misc.No.33 of 2017 before the
Tribunal for recovery of this amount i.e. Rs.4,98,194/- with interest @ 9% p.a.
from 16.10.2015 till payment.
9. For the last 9 years, the petitioner has been dodging the payment
of the same by claiming that it had made the deposit in the High Court and the
respondents should get it from the High Court.
10. They also contend that the Tribunal should dismiss the Execution
Petition filed by respondents.
11. The petitioner also filed an application No.1065 dt.25.5.2026 in
MAC (App) No.38 of 2014 before the Registry of the High Court for
obtaining the CC of the order/note dt.17.9.2018 and 19.9.2018 wherein
allegedly it was found that it had deposited the said amount. The Registry on
15.6.2026 however declined to give copies saying they are „office notes‟.
12. On 10.8.2026, the Tribunal noted that the petitioner failed to
place on record any material to show total satisfaction of the award; and
without an order for recovery of the amount through process of Court, no
fruitful purpose will be served. It directed issuance of notice to the Collector
of the District for realisation of the balance amount with interest as on that
date.

Page 4 of 5 2026:THC:1560
TRHC010018822026



13. Assailing the same, this CRP is filed.
14. Counsel for petitioner reiterated that petitioner had made the
deposit in this Court and the respondents be directed to approach this Court
and take the amount deposited.
15. I am unable to accept the said plea.
16. Firstly, when this Court in its order dt.21.9.2016 in MAC App
No.38 of 2014 directed deposit of the difference amount by petitioner
specifically in the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, the petitioner, a Public
Sector Insurance Company, having a Law officer and several panel counsel,
should explain why it made the deposit before this Court allegedly. It was duty
bound to deposit the said sum before the Tribunal only. Deposit before this
Court cannot amount to „full satisfaction‟ of decretal debt of respondents.
17. Secondly, no proof of such deposit in this Court is filed by
petitioner in this Court either.
18. Thirdly, the petitioner had sufficient assets to make the deposit of
the amount claimed by respondents all these 7 years and could have fully
satisfied the decretal debt long back. It could have also approached this Court
to take back what it had allegedly deposited in 2018 in the meantime by
producing proof of such deposit.
19. For the last 9 years, realisation of this amount by respondents was
thwarted by petitioner by taking this unreasonable stand.
20. I therefore find that the conduct of petitioner is not bonafide and
that its intention was only to harass the respondents by depriving them of this
amount all along.

Page 5 of 5 2026:THC:1560
TRHC010018822026



21. Accordingly, this CRP is dismissed with costs of Rs.10,000/- to
be paid to the respondents in 4 weeks.
All pending Miscellaneous Applications stand disposed of.


(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO), CJ





PULAK BANIK
Digitally signed by PULAK BANIK
Date: 2026.11.21 17:07:41 +05'30'