ZUHAID AHAMED KHAN @ ZUHAIB vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 11 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.PRAMOD
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 232 OF 2023 (C)
BETWEEN:
ZUHAID AHAMED KHAN @ ZUHAIB
S/O SYED AHAMED KHAN,
AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS,
TH
R/AT 4 CROSS,
VINOBHA NAGARA,
TUMAKURU TOWN,
TUMAKURU-572 101.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. MRC MANOHAR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY TILAK PARK POLICE STATION,
TUMAKURU,
BY STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
HIGH COURT BUILDING,
BENGALURU-560 001.
Digitally
signed by
LAKSHMI T
Location:
High Court
of Karnataka
…RESPONDENT
(BY SRI. VIJAYKUMAR MAJAGE, SPP-II ALONG WITH
SRI. SUDHINDRA B.S., HCGP)
THIS CRL.A. IS FILED U/S.374(2) CR.P.C., PRAYING TO
CALL FOR THE RECORDS AND SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
ORDER DATED 17.01.2023 PASSED BY THE PRINCIPAL
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, TUMAKURU IN
S.C.NO.113/2018 REGISTERED BY TILAK PARK POLICE
STATION, BENGALURU FOR THE OFFENCES PUNISHABLE
UNDER SECTION 302 OF INDIAN PENAL CODE AGAINST THE
APPELLANT AND ACQUIT THE APPELLANT.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FURTHER HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.PRAMOD
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
Accused has preferred this appeal, aggrieved by the
judgment and order of conviction and sentenced dated
17.01.2023, passed against him by the Court of the
Principal District and Sessions Judge, Tumkuru, in
Sessions Case No.113 of 2018, whereby he was convicted
for the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC and
sentenced to undergo rigorous life imprisonment and to
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
pay fine of Rs.50,000/-, in default of payment of fine, to
undergo S.I. for a further period of six months.
2. We have heard Sri. MRC. Manohar, learned
counsel for the appellant, Sri. Vijay Kumar Majage,
learned SPP-II for the State and perused the evidence and
material on record.
3. In a nutshell, the case of the prosecution is that
the accused and deceased were working in Honnasiri
Mahendra HD Motors Service Centre situated near
Ranichannamma Circle, Ring road Tumkur Town, Tumkur.
The deceased Vijay Kumar was working in a cordial
manner and he had gained a good reputation, which was
not liked by the accused and he was quarrelling with the
deceased. Hence, the complainant, the brother-in-law of
the deceased, who was also working as an electrician in
the service center had warned the accused not to quarrel
with the deceased. The accused had threatened the
complainant not to interfere in his personal affairs. On
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
30.04.2018 at about 04:30 p.m., when the deceased and
the accused were working in the washing section, the
accused inserted a compressed air nozzle to the anal part
of the deceased. Due to the air pressure, the deceased
sustained severe injuries. He was shifted by the
complainant and other co-workers to THS Hospital,
wherein he was provided first aid and on the advice of the
doctor, he was shifted for higher treatment to Siddaganga
Hospital, Tumakuru, wherein he died on account of the
injuries sustained by him, on 02.05.2018 at about 06:20
p.m.
4. The trial Court, based on the oral and
documentary evidence adduced by the prosecution,
particularly the evidence of PW3, an eyewitness to the
incident, and the medical evidence held that, because of
the injury to the anus i.e. multiple serosa injury on the
anus, perforation of large intestine, Vijaykumar
succumbed to those injuries, even though surgery was
conducted and he could not recover from the injury and
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
these facts clearly and categorically establish that only
with an intention to kill him, the accused had inserted air
compressor machine in the anus of the deceased. The trial
Court further held that the accused was a senior workman
in the service station and he knew the weight of the air
compressor machine and also the pressure of air which
comes out from its pipe and thus, he was definitely aware
that there will be every chance of death of the person.
Hence, holding that the prosecution has proved beyond
reasonable doubt that the accused had an intention to kill
the deceased, convicted him for the offence punishable
under Section 302 of IPC.
5. Assailing the impugned judgment, the learned
counsel for the appellant has vehemently contended that
the motive alleged by the prosecution is flimsy as no
person would venture to take away the life of another for
the said motive projected by the prosecution. He
contended that the evidence of PW3, the alleged
eyewitness is also not believable, as he has not given a
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
clear picture of the incident in question and other
witnesses are hearsay witnesses, who came to the spot
after the alleged incident and their evidence does not lend
any support to the evidence of PW3.
6. The learned counsel for the appellant further
contended that, PW5 has categorically admitted in his
cross-examination that the police had collected the CCTV
footages, however, the said CCTV footage has been
deliberately suppressed by the prosecution. If the footage
were to be produced, then it would have given a clear
picture of the incident.
7. The learned counsel further contended that even
accepting the case of the prosecution, death is not the
direct result of the injuries, on the other hand, the cause
of death is septicemia. He contended that on overall
appreciation of the material on record would clearly
establish that the accused had no intention to cause the
death and therefore, at any stretch of imagination, the
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
offence allegedly committed by the accused would not
attract the ingredients of Section 300 of IPC.
8. Per contra, the learned SPP-II contended that
PW3 is an eyewitness to the incident. He was also working
in the washing section along with the deceased. His
presence at the spot is natural and believable. His
evidence is corroborated by the evidence of PWs 1, 2, 4
and 5. There was no reason for the witnesses to falsely
implicate the accused. The medical evidence coupled with
the evidence of the above witnesses clearly establish that
the deceased died on account of the act committed by the
accused and the fact that the accused had inserted the air
compressor to the anal part of the deceased, itself shows
that he had the intention and knowledge that such act
would result in his death. Hence, sought to dismiss the
appeal.
9. The complainant, Sri. Shantakumar is the
brother-in-law of the deceased. He was working as an
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
electrician at Honnasiri Motors Service Centre, Tumkur. His
complaint at Ex.P1 reveals that about 2 months prior to
the date of incident, the deceased Vijaykumar started
working in the said service center. The accused was also
working in the service centre. The deceased was liked by
other co-workers, hence, the accused was indifferent
towards the deceased and used to quarrel with him. In the
complaint, it is stated that the accused had warned the
complainant that he would kill the deceased. On
30.04.2018 at about 09:00 a.m., the accused as well as
the deceased came to work in the service station. At about
04:30 p.m., on hearing the commotion, the complainant
rushed to the spot and by that time the accused had
pressed the air compressor nozzle to the anal part of the
deceased and the deceased was writhing in pain.
10. The deceased was initially taken to THS Hospital,
wherein, PW.7 provided him first aid treatment. In his
deposition, PW7, Dr.Prabhakar G.N., has deposed that at
around 05:30 p.m. on 30.04.2018, Vijaykumar was
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
brought to the hospital by the co-labourers with a history
of pain in abdomen and distension of abdomen. He was
semi-conscious and irritable. His vital parameters were
within the normal range. He suspected injury to the large
intestine and hence, after giving primary aid, referred him
to Siddaganga Hospital for further management.
11. PW7 has stated that, he sent MLC intimation to
the police, marked as Ex.P11 and also issued a letter
referring the patient for further management to higher
centre, marked as Ex.P12. He administered Roman IV fluid
to the patient with pain killers as a primary treatment prior
to referring him to higher Centre.
12. In Ex.P12, it is stated that Vijaykumar had come
to the hospital with alleged history of rectal puncture by
air compressor at his workplace. First aid was given and
then referred to higher/other centre for further treatment.
13. The prosecution has examined PW.8, Dr.
Chandrashekhar M., Medical Officer working in the Surgery
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
Department at Siddaganga Hospital and Research Centre,
Tumakuru. He has deposed that on 30.04.2018 at about
07:00 p.m., the injured by name Vijaykumar was referred
from THS Hospital, Tumakuru, for further management in
respect of injury said to have been caused by compressed
air nozzle insertion into anal part. When examined, he was
irritable and abdomen was grossly distended (enlarged).
As the patient was gasping, he was put on ventilators. The
CT scanning of the abdomen revealed that there was
perforation in the large intestine at rectosigmoid junction.
Immediately, he was taken to surgery at about 08:10 p.m.
and on opening the abdomen, there was around 200 ml of
blood traced in the abdominal cavity and there was
perforation at rectosigmoid junction with multiple serosa
injury on the rectum. He was given antibiotics and other
medical requirements and then shifted to medical ICU.
14. PW8 has further deposed that on 01.05.2018 the
BP of the patient was found fluctuating. He was put on
inotrops. On the second morning, the patient was found
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
not responding and mottling was seen on the abdominal
planks, the urine output was decreased. They gave
medication for all the problems. At about 05:30 p.m. in
the evening, the patient had a cardiac arrest and for 15-20
minutes, they tried to revive the patient, but they could
not succeed.
15. PW9 is the Doctor, who conducted the autopsy
over the dead body. He has furnished his final opinion
regarding the cause of death, stating that the death was
due to septicemia as a result of injury to bowel (small and
large intestine). The final opinion is marked as per Ex.P16.
PW9 has issued further opinion as per Ex.P17 with
reference to the letter issued by the Investigating Officer,
stating that possibilities of sustaining injuries and causing
death are there under the circumstances mentioned in the
letter. PW8 has also given his opinion as per Ex.P13
stating that the immediate cause of death is septic shock,
acute kidney injury and acidosis.
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
16. The deceased was not in a position to speak
when he was shifted to the hospital. This we can gather
from the evidence of PW5, working as Commercial Service
Manager in the service centre. In the cross-examination,
he has stated that when he rushed to the spot, he found
the deceased was struggling with pain and was not in a
position to speak. PW7-Dr.Prabhakar G.N., has stated in
the cross-examination that the patient was capable of
speaking being in semi-conscious state, but he was
irritable, not answering properly and talking irrelevant
things.
17. PW.10, the PSI who went to the THS Hospital at
about 06:45 p.m., on receiving the MLC, has stated that
he enquired with the doctor as to whether the injured
Vijaykumar was in a position to give any statement. The
doctor informed him that he was not in a position to give
any statement. The endorsement issued by the doctor is
marked as Ex.P18. None of the witnesses have stated that
the deceased was in a position to speak or revealed as to
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
how the incident took place. Hence, the case of the
prosecution rests on the oral testimony of PW1 to PW.6,
who were all working at Honnasiri Mahindra H.D. Motors.
18. PW1, the complainant is none other than the
brother-in-law of the deceased. He was working as an
electrician in the service centre. PW2 was working as a
driver, PW3 was working in the washing section, PW4 was
the Floor Manager and PW5 was working as a Commercial
Service Manager. PW2 is a witness to the spot mahazar-
Ex.P2. The evidence of PW1, PW4 and PW5 goes to show
that they are not the eyewitnesses, but came to the spot
after the incident. Hence, the case of the prosecution with
regard to the actual incident, depends on the evidence of
PW3, an eyewitness to the incident.
19. It is the contention of the learned counsel for the
appellant that, PW3 could not be an eyewitness, as he did
state the manner in which the incident had taken place
and he, being one of the co-workers, was also nurturing ill
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
will against the deceased and therefore, his evidence is
not believable.
20. We have perused the evidence of PW3. He has
deposed that on 30.04.2018 at about 04:30 p.m., the
deceased and himself were working in the washing section
and they had attended the duty at about 10:00 a.m. When
he was washing the back of the car, the accused took an
air pipe and inserted into the anal part of the deceased. As
a result of which, the deceased fell down and started
writhing in pain. Being scared, he called other workers
Shanthakumar (PW1) and others came and shifted the
deceased to the hospital.
21. It is not disputed that PW3 was also working in
the Honnasiri Service Centre and he was working in the
washing section, where the deceased was also working.
We find corroboration to the evidence of PW3 from the
evidence of PW4 and PW5. PW4, working as Floor Manager
in the service centre, has deposed that, on hearing the
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
screaming, he rushed to the spot and found the deceased
struggling. He has stated that Vinoda (PW3) and the
accused were present at the spot and when he enquired
with Vinoda (PW3), he informed him that the accused had
kept the air compressor pipe into the anal part of the
deceased. Thereafter, they shifted Vijaykumar to THS
Hospital, wherein he was provided first aid and the doctor
advised them to shift him to Siddaganga Hospital.
22. Similarly, PW5, working as Commercial Service
Manager in the service centre has also deposed that on
30.04.2018 at about 04:20 p.m., Vinod (PW3) came
running and informed him regarding the incident and
immediately they shifted the Vijayakumar to THS Hospital
and from there to Siddaganga Hospital, wherein he died
on 02.05.2018. PW5 has stated that, on enquiry with
Vinod PW3, he came to know that the accused had
inserted the air compressed air nozzle into the anal part of
the deceased.
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
23. The accused took a defense that the deceased
sustained injuries due to inhalation of nitrogen gas. The
said suggestion was denied by the witnesses. Except the
bald suggestion, no material was placed to justify said
defense raised by the accused. In fact the suggestion put
to PW.8, the doctor who treated the deceased at
Siddaganga Hospital that the injuries referred in Exs.P13
and 14 are possible if a person inhales nitrogen gas, has
been denied by him. Further, PW8 has denied that if a
person falls on a hard substance and if the abdomen
comes in contact with a hard object, such injuries are
possible and stated that, if a person falls by slip and
suffers any injury to his lower portion of back, possibility
of sustaining injury to intestine is ruled out.
24. It is the contention of the learned counsel for
the appellant that, there were CCTV cameras installed in
the service centre and PW5 has admitted that he had
handed over the footages to the Investigating Officer, but
the said footages were not produced and therefore, the
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
genesis of the incident has been suppressed. It is
contended by him that in view of suppression of the
material evidence, the benefit of doubt should go to the
accused.
25. PW5, the Commercial Service Manager, working
in the service centre has admitted in the cross-
examination that in every section of the service centre,
they had installed CCTV cameras. He has stated that the
police had collected the CCTV footages of the incident.
Admittedly, the CCTV footages are not produced. The
Investigating Officer examined as PW12, in his cross-
examination has also admitted that the CCTV cameras
were installed in Honnasiri Service Centre. However, he
has stated, he had made an attempt to collect the
footages and in-spite of issuance of notice, the CCTV
footages were not provided to him.
26. The evidence of PW12-Investigating Officer is
contrary to the evidence of PW5, who has categorically
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
stated in the cross-examination that the police had
collected the CCTV footage, whereas, PW12 has stated
that despite issuing notice, the CCTV footages were not
provided to him. However, that by itself is not a ground to
disbelieve the entire case of the prosecution, in view of the
evidence of PW3, an eyewitness to the incident. It is not
suggested to PW.3 that he was nurturing animosity
against the accused. There was no reason for PW3 to
depose against the accused. Hence, non-collection or
production of CCTV footage is not fatal to the prosecution.
27. The trial Court held the accused guilty of the
offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC, observing
that the accused was a senior workman in the service
centre and he knows the weight of the air compressor
machine and also the pressure of air which comes out
from its pipe and thus he definitely knew that if it is kept
in the anus, there will be every chance of death of the
person.
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
28. It is relevant to see that, the deceased as well as
the accused came to work in the service centre at about
08:29 a.m., as deposed by PW6, in his cross-examination.
PW3 has stated that normally the work would start in the
service centre at 09:00 a.m. and it will close at 06:00 p.m.
The deceased was working since two months prior to the
date of incident. According to the prosecution, the
deceased was liked by other co-workers and therefore, the
accused was jealous and used to quarrel with him. Even
though the prosecution tried to contend that the accused
had given a letter admitting his guilt, the said letter has
not been produced. However, PW4 has denied the
suggestion that the accused was not quarrelling with the
deceased. From the material on record, it can be gathered
that both the accused and the deceased came to the
service centre for work at about 08:29 a.m. on
30.04.2018. The incident took place at about 04:30 p.m.
None of the witnesses have stated as to what prompted
the accused to insert the compressed air nozzle to the anal
- 20 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
part of the deceased. This assumes importance, because if
the accused had any intention to take away the life of the
deceased, he would have done so, as soon as he had
arrived for work.
29. PW.3 has deposed in the chief-examination itself
that there used to be petty quarrels between the accused
and the deceased and the Floor Manager used to
reprimand and advise both of them. An oral appreciation
of the entire evidence on record goes to show that on the
date of incident there was a quarrel between the accused
and the deceased and without any premeditation or
intention, the accused inserted the compressed air nozzle
into the anal part of the deceased without knowing the
serious consequences. The evidence of PW1 shows that
when they rushed to the spot, the accused was present at
the spot. He was seen disturbed and frightened and
admitted the guilt. Hence, we are of the view that the
death caused by the accused was not premeditated. The
accused had no intention to cause the death of the
- 21 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
deceased. Hence, the instant case would fall under
Exception 4 to Section 300 of IPC. Though the accused
had no intention to cause the death, he had the intention
to cause such bodily injury as was likely to cause death.
Hence, the offence committed by the accused is
punishable under Section 304 Part I of IPC.
30. The accused was aged about 25 years at the
time of incident. It is submitted that he was in custody as
an under trial prisoner from 01.05.2018 to 03.07.2019 i.e.
for a period of 1 year 2 months and 2 days and from the
date of judgment i.e. from 17.01.2023 until 11.11.2026
i.e. for a period of 3 years 9 months 24 days. In all, he
has undergone imprisonment for a period of 4 years 11
months and 26 days. He has no bad antecedents.
31. In the facts and circumstances, the sentence of
seven years imprisonment with enhancement of the fine
amount would meet the ends of justice. Accordingly, we
pass the following:
- 22 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
ORDER
i. The appeal is allowed-in-part .
ii. The Judgment and Order of conviction and sentence
dated 17.01.2023 passed by the Court of the
Principal District and Sessions Judge, Tumakuru, in
S.C. No.113 of 2018, convicting and sentencing the
accused for the offence punishable under Section 302
of IPC, is set aside.
iii. The accused/appellant is convicted for the offence
punishable under Section 304 Part I of IPC.
iv. He is sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment
for a period of seven years and to pay a fine of
Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh only) and in default
of payment of fine, he shall undergo SI for a period
of one year.
v. If the fine amount is deposited/recovered, the same
shall be paid as compensation to the parents of the
- 23 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:62188-DB
CRL.A No. 232 of 2023
CNR: KAHC010067382023
deceased i.e. CW2-Lakshminarayanappa and CW3-
Yellamma, on proper identification.
vi. The order passed by the trial Court for referring the
matter to DLSA, Tumakuru, for payment of
compensation under the Victims' Compensation
Scheme shall be intact.
vii. The accused is entitled to the benefit of set-off for
the period of imprisonment already undergone by
him.
Sd/-
(MOHAMMAD NAWAZ)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(B.PRAMOD)
JUDGE
HB,MKM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 11