ABHISHEK BANERJEE vs UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
(Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Krishna Rao
W.P.A. No. 27989 of 2026
Abhishek Banerjee
Vs
The Union of India & Others
Mr. Shoaib Alam, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Gopal Shankar Narayan, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Ayan Bhattacharjee, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Nupun Saxena
Mr. Agnish Basu
Mr. Vipul Vedant
Mr. Aditya Roy
Mr. Shounak Mondal
Mr. Gourav Bose
Mr. B.D. Kundan Rao
....For the petitioners.
Mr. Billwadal Bhattacharyya, Ld. AAG
Mr. Srijib Chakraborty
Mr. Rivu Dutta
Mr. Anjan Chakraborty
….For the State.
2
Mr. Dhiraj Kumar Trivedi, Ld. ASGI
Mr. Sukanta Chakraborty
Mr. Heramba Narayan Dutta
Mr. Ronit Deyashi
….For the Union of India.
Hearing Concluded On : 12.11.2026
Judgment Delivered On : 17.11.2026
Judgment Uploaded On : 17.11.2026
Krishna Rao, J.:
1. The petitioner has filed the present writ petition challenging the
decision/ action of the respondent authorities wherein the “Z+”
Category Security of the petitioner reduced to “X” Category with effect
th
from 12 May, 2026. The petitioner is a sitting Member of Parliament
representing the Diamond Harbour Parliamentary Constituency, State
of West Bengal and is the General Secretary of the All India Trinamool
Congress.
2. The petitioner was elected to the Lok Sabha from the Diamond Harbour
Parliamentary Constituency in the year 2014 and has been successively
re-elected in the year 2019 and 2024. In the year 2013, the petitioner
was provided with “Y” category security and in the year 2014 the same
was upgraded to “Y+” category security. The security of the petitioner
was further upgraded to “Z” in the year 2015 and “Z+” category security
th
in the year 2016. Till 12 May, 2026, the petitioner was enjoying “Z+”
security.
3
3. Mr. Shoaib Alam, Learned Senior Advocate, representing the petitioner
submits that the decision of scaling down the security cover of the
petitioner is arbitrary, unreasonable, disproportionate and contrary to
the very basis upon which the petitioner has been accorded “Z+”
Category Security for more than a decade. He submits that there is
nothing on record to demonstrate that immediately prior to the abrupt
th
withdrawal of “Z+” security on 12 May, 2026, any fresh, independent,
objective and comprehensive threat perception assessment was
undertaken.
4. Mr. Alam submits that immediately after the withdrawal of the “Z+”
th
Category Security of the petitioner on 30 May, 2026, when the
petitioner visiting the family of the deceased, namely, Sanju Karmakar
at Sonarpur, the petitioner was attacked near Kamrabad More by a
mob of about 500 persons, who hurled eggs, stones, bricks, shoes and
with other obnoxious items, due to which the petitioner sustained
grievous injuries. He further submits that before visiting the house of
th
the deceased Sanju Karmakar on 30 May, 2026, the petitioner has
th
given prior intimation to the concerned authorities on 29 May, 2026,
but the authorities have not taken any steps either before or after the
incident.
th
5. Mr. Alam submits that on 19 June, 2026 when the petitioner and two
other Members of Parliament returned from Delhi at NSCBI Airport,
Kolkata, 25 to 30 persons led by one Uttam Das @ Tinka, armed with a
pistol came to the arrival gate and attacked upon the petitioner due to
4
which the petitioner has sustained injury. He submits that the matter
was reported to the concerned police station but no case has been
initiated on the complaint of the petitioner and no action is taken
against the culprits.
th th
6. Mr. Alam submits that on 18 July, 2026 to 19 July, 2026, during
the demolition time at the petitioner’s primary constituency MP Office,
a mob of BJP supporters led by Abhijit Das @ Bobby entered the office
and vandalized and looted the party records, furniture and electronic
th
articles. The matter was reported to the police authority on 19 July,
2026, but no action is taken by the authorities.
rd
7. Mr. Alam submits that on 3 September, 2026, 15 numbers of masked
persons trespassed into the office of the petitioner at Camac Street and
attacked with deadly weapons and the CCTV server was destroyed. The
matter was also reported to the concerned authority but no action has
th
been taken. He submits that on 26 September, 2026, the petitioner
has made representations of the said incidents and requested for
reinstatement of “Z+” Category Security instead of “X” Category
th
Security but no action has been taken and in the meantime, on 26
September, 2026, the police kiosks outside the residents of the
petitioner were removed.
th
8. Mr. Alam submits that during the pendency of the writ petition on 7
November, 2026, on the birthday of the petitioner, 30-40 BJP
supporters hurled stones, eggs and bricks at AITC workers of the
5
petitioner and other 40-50 persons attacked the workers of the
petitioner with sticks and bamboos fitted with nails. The matter was
reported to the police and a case has been initiated by the police
authority. He submits that time and again the petitioner has made
detailed representation to the respondent authorities for providing “Z+”
Category Security as time and again, the petitioner is facing attacked at
several areas but the respondents failed to consider the request made
by the petitioner. Mr. Alam submits that on receipt of the request of the
th
petitioner, the Ministry of the Home Affairs by a letter dated 5
October, 2026, requested the State Government to provide adequate
security to the petitioner based on local threat perception but inspite of
the request of the Ministry, the respondent authorities failed to provide
adequate security cover to the petitioner.
9. Mr. Alam in support of his submission has relied upon the judgment in
the case of Rajesh Ranjan vs. Union of India & Ors. reported in
2026 SCC OnLine Pat 2232 and submits that it is settled principle of
law that any order affecting rights of a person and particularly his
liberty must be with reasons and must reflect due application of mind.
He has further relied upon the judgment in the case of Naresh
Agarwal vs. State of U.P. through Prin. Secy. (Home) Lko. & Ors.
reported in 2012 SCC OnLine ALL 264 and submits that it is well
settled proposition of law that the Government must exercise its
discretion in a fair manner. The manner and hasty decision of
Government to withdraw security is itself indicative of arbitrary exercise
6
of discretionary power. He further relied upon the judgment in the case
of Sri Pankaj Kumar Gupta Vs. The State of West Bengal passed in
th
WPA No. 4521 of 2023 dated 10 April, 2023 and submits that the
Coordinate Bench of this Court has directed that the security which the
petitioner was enjoying before its withdrawal shall be restored back to
him immediately.
10. Mr. Alam has relied upon the judgment in the case of S.P. Kapoor (Dr.)
vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors. reported in (1981) 4 SCC 716
and submits that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the post-
haste manner in which these things have been done suggests that some
higher-up was interested in pushing through the matter hastily.
11. Per contra, Mr. Billwadal Bhattacharyya, Learned A.A.G. submits that
the petitioner has no right to claim “Z+” Category Security. He submits
that the authorities came to know that the petitioner is the sitting
Member of Parliament and is entitled to “X” Category Security but the
petitioner is enjoying “Z+” Category Security though there is no threat
perception and accordingly on receipt of the report from the Security
Cell of the State of West Bengal, the “Z+” Category Security was
th
reduced to “X” Category Security. He submits that on 12 May, 2026,
the Joint Commissioner of Police (Security), Kolkata after the
assessment of threat perception with respect to the petitioner and after
considering the report of the Special Branch, requested alteration of the
security cover of the petitioner from “Z+” Category Security to “X”
Category Security and accordingly on receipt of the proposal, the
7
Director, Security West Bengal, has passed a direction for re-
categorization of the security of the petitioner as “X” Category Security
th
instead of “Z+” Category Security with effect from 12 May, 2026.
th
12. Mr. Bhattacharyya has submitted report and submits that on 29 May,
2026, a Review Committee Meeting for security categorization of
protected persons in West Bengal was held and accordingly in the
meeting, it was held that the petitioner should be provided with “X”
Category Security. He submits that the Members of Parliament are
entitled to have “X” Category Security and accordingly, the same was
provided to the petitioner.
13. Mr. Bhattacharyya submits that immediately on receipt of
communication from the Ministry of Home Affairs, the same was
forwarded to the Kolkata Police authorities for necessary operational
review and field level threat assessment. After enquiry by the Kolkata
Police, it was found that no specific or actionable threat input was
received from Kolkata Police warranting an upward re-categorization of
the petitioner’s security from “X” Category to Z+ Category Security. He
submits that “X” Category Security cover was provided to the petitioner
strictly in compliance with the guidelines laid down in the Yellow Book.
14. Mr. Bhattacharyya has relied upon the judgment in the case of Shri
Ashwini Kumar Chopra vs. Union of India & Ors. reported in 2010
SCC OnLine Del 4470 and submits that the Hon’ble Division Bench of
the Delhi High Court held that security cover or its upgradation are
8
matters essentially in the domain of the concerned agencies and this is
not a matter in which the court would interfere.
15. Mr. Bhattacharyya has relied upon the judgment in the case of Ravi
Kumar Rai & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors. passed in W.P.(C) 8194
th
of 2021 dated 11 August, 2021 by the Delhi High Court and
submits that it is not for the Court to in the exercise of its power of
judicial review sit in appeal over such decision, whether there is a
perception of threat, has to be considered by the authorities.
16. Mr. Dhiraj Trivedi, Learned ASGI representing the Union of India,
submits that to provide the security to the Member of Parliament of the
concerned State is the duty of State Government. He submits that
though the petitioner was enjoying the “Z+” Category Security since the
year 2014 and when the authorities finds that “Z+” Category Security is
not required for the petitioner, accordingly, the State Government
reviewed the same and provided “X” Category Security to the petitioner.
He submits that on receipt of the representation of the petitioner, the
Ministry of Home Affairs requested the State Government to consider
the request of the petitioner but the Ministry has not recommend to
grant “Z+” Category Security to the petitioner. It is the duty of the State
Government to consider with regard to provide security and
accordingly, the State Government has convened a Review Meeting and
finds that there is no threat perception against the petitioner and was
granted “X” Category Security.
9
17. Heard the Learned Counsel for the respective parties, perused the
materials on record and the judgments relied by the parties. The
petitioner being the Member of the Parliament was enjoying “Z+”
th
Category Security. On 12 May, 2026, the Joint Commissioner of
Police, Security, Kolkata, informed the Director Security, Kolkata that
an assessment of threat with respect to the petitioner was made into
locally by the Special Branch and found that there is no input
indicating any specific threat to the subject from any outfit/
organization/ person against the petitioner and requested for alteration
of the security cover from “Z+” Category Security. On receipt of the said
proposal, the Director Security has re-categorized the security of the
petitioner as “X” Category Security with immediate effect as an interim
measure and requested the authorities to review the threat perception.
18. From the communication of the Joint Commissioner of Police, Security,
th
Kolkata dated 12 May, 2026 and the communication of Director
th
Security dated 12 May, 2026, it reveals that only on the basis of the
proposal of the Joint Commissioner of Police, Security, Kolkata, the
Director Security has re-categorized the security of the petitioner as “X”
Category Security in place of “Z+” Category Security. Admittedly, at the
time of the re-categorization of the security category of the petitioner
th
dated 12 May, 2026, no meeting of the Review Committee for security
re-categorization was held. Though the Learned AAG has submitted
report before this Court but in the report, there is no document
disclosed to show what are the reports considered by the Joint
10
Commissioner of Police, Security, Kolkata, for alteration of the security
cover of the petitioner from “Z+” Category Security to “X” Category
Security. The Director Security on the proposal of the Joint
Commissioner of Police, Security, has re-categorized the security
category of the petitioner from “Z+” Category Security to “X” Category
Security.
19. After the re-categorization of the security category of the petitioner from
“Z+” Category Security to “X” Category Security, several incidents were
th th
occurred since 30 May, 2026 till 7 November, 2026. The State
Authorities have not denied with regard to the said incident. The
Review Committee meeting was held for security categorization of
th
protected persons in the State of West Bengal on 29 May, 2026. By
that time, the Director-cum-Security has already altered the security
category of the petitioner from “Z+” Category Security to “X” Category
Security and in the meeting, the same was confirmed.
20. After the re-categorization of the security of the petitioner and after the
Review Committee meeting for security, several incidents were occurred
with the petitioner. The report submitted by the State Authority, reveals
that a high level Review Committee comprising representative from the
Special Branch (SB), the Subsidiary Intelligence Bureau (SIB), the
Home and Hill Affairs Department and the Police Administration are
mandated to undertake such evaluation at least once in every six (6)
months.
11
21. Whenever the incident was occurred to the petitioner, the same was
reported to the police authority. Out of six (6) incidents, in two (2)
incidents, the police has initiated a case and the cases are under
investigation. The report submitted by the State does not reveals that
after receipt of the complaint of the petitioner and the representation
made by the petitioner for upgradation of the security cover from “X”
Category Security to “Z+” Category Security, the authority has taken
any steps to consider the request of the petitioner.
22. It is settled position of law that it is not for the court to exercise of its
power of judicial review by sitting in appeal over the decision of the
authority, whether there is a perception of threat or not. In the present
th
case, re-categorization of the security of the petitioner was held on 12
May, 2026, which was confirmed by the Review Committee in its
th
meeting held that 29 May, 2026. The incident which was occurred to
th
petitioner after 29 May, 2026. The State Authorities have not
submitted any report with regard to the said incidents. The authorities
have also not denied about the said incidents.
23. Admittedly, the petitioner has informed all the incidents to the
concerned authorities and the petitioner was also requested for
enhancement of his security from “X” Category Security to “Z+”
Category Security. Thus, this Court is of the view that the authority
should conduct a Review Meeting for consideration of the request of the
petitioner whether the security cover of the petitioner is required to be
12
enhanced or not by taking into consideration of the incidents which the
petitioner has reported to the authorities.
24. In view of the above, the writ petition being WPA No. 27989 of 2026 is
disposed of by directing the Principal Secretary, Home and Hill Affairs
Department, Government of West Bengal, to convey the Review
Committee meeting for re-categorization of the security of the petitioner
within a period of two (2) weeks from the date of receipt of the order. It
is made clear that at the time of considering the re-categorization of the
security of the petitioner, the incidents which the petitioner has
th th
informed the authorities from 30 May, 2026 to 7 November, 2026
shall also be taken into consideration and to pass an appropriate order
in accordance with law.
25. WPA No. 27989 of 2026 is disposed of .
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of a server copy of the
Judgment placed on the official website of the Court.
Urgent Xerox certified photocopies of this judgment, if applied for,
be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
(Krishna Rao, J.)