Krishnan Narayana vs The State Of Andhra Pradesh

Court
Supreme Court

2026 INSC 748



NON-REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION


CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. OF 2026
[@ SLP(CRIMINAL) NOS. 19205-06 OF 2025]

KRISHNAN NARAYANA …APPELLANT(S)

VERSUS

STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AND ORS. ETC. …RESPONDENT(S)


J U D G M E N T

AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH, J.


1. Leave granted.
2. The present appeals challenge the common impugned
judgment and order dated 18.09.2025 passed by the High Court
of Andhra Pradesh at Amaravati wherein Crl. Petition
no.3712/2025 filed by the appellant herein was dismissed and
Signature Not Verified
Digitally signed by
NAVEEN D
Date: 2026.07.27
18:48:00 IST
Reason:
Crl. Petition No.7896/2025 filed by M/s Earth Stein Private
Limited (hereinafter “the respondent company”) was allowed. By
Page 1 of 17

the said order, interim custody of the subject vehicles, namely
one Bolero City Pick-up, 3 Excavators and one Ashok Leyland
Tipper was granted to the respondent company, pending the
resolution of the criminal cases between them.
3. The brief background is that the Appellant is the director
of one M/s Pure Minerals involved in quarrying of granite. He
was also a director of the respondent company with an 80%
shareholding. The subject vehicles were purchased in the name
of the company M/s Pure Minerals between 2014 to 2022.
4. It is the case of the appellant that on 31.05.2023, he visited
the house of one S.R Kumar, owner of M/s Parakrish Mineral
Enterprises Pvt. Ltd, a company from which certain amounts
were due to the appellant towards the supply of granite. On this
occasion, the respondents S.R Kumar, T. Arivudainambi and
G. Thirgunanam intimidated him and got his signatures on
blank papers, which were used to forge his resignation from the
respondent company on 16.06.2023.

5. Subsequently, on 31.08.2023, the Respondents committed
criminal trespass into the granite factory of M/s Pure Minerals
and forcefully took away the subject vehicles. An FIR bearing
Page 2 of 17

Crime No.353/2023 was registered in this regard on 17.09.2023
on the basis of the complaint filed by the appellant.
6. The Respondent’s version, however, is materially different,
₹
alleging that the appellant had misappropriated 1,73,11,894
from the respondent company and utilised the amounts to
purchase the subject vehicles in the name of his company M/s
Pure Minerals, with himself as the authorised owner. A counter-
FIR No.354/2023 came to be lodged in this regard. A
chargesheet was filed and the matter is pending before the trial
court.

7. On 20.11.2023, the appellant lodged another FIR bearing
Crime No.102/2024 regarding the allegations concerning the
amounts due from M/s Parakrish Mineral Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.
and the subsequent acts of intimidation and forgery as
described above.
8. Initially, FIR No.353/2023 was referred to as a ‘mistake of
fact’ and a closure report was filed on 14.08.2024. However, a
subsequent chargesheet came to be filed on 09.02.2025 after
the file was re-opened and further investigation was carried out.
During the course of this investigation, police seized the subject
Page 3 of 17

vehicles from the granite factory of the respondent company on
07.02.2025.
9. As regards Crime No.102/2024, this was also closed as a
‘mistake of fact’, and the protest petition against the same also
came to be dismissed, with the said dismissal being upheld by
the High Court. An SLP against the same is pending before a
coordinate bench of this Court.
10. Following the seizure of the vehicles, appellant filed a
Criminal Miscellaneous Petition bearing no.218/2025 before
the Trial Court seeking interim custody on 11.02.2025. This
came to be dismissed by order dated 26.03.2025, noting that a
Writ Petition filed by the Respondents was pending before the
High Court regarding the legality of the re-investigation and the
seizure, which would be rendered infructuous if the petition was
to be decided at that stage. Aggrieved, the petitioner approached
the High Court by way of Criminal Petition No.3712 of 2025
seeking quashing of order dated 26.03.2025.

11. Similarly, the Respondent company also preferred
Criminal Misc. Petition No.384/2025 before the Trial Court for
return of properties which came to be dismissed by order dated
Page 4 of 17

16.05.2025. Against this, Criminal Petition no.7896 of 2025
came to be filed before the High Court on 24.07.2025.
12. By way of the common impugned order, the High Court
granted interim custody of the vehicles to the Respondents. The
Court observed that it was alleged that the appellant being the
director, purchased certain machinery and other properties in
his own name using the funds of the respondent company , and
thereby committed misappropriation of Rs.1,73,11,894. Crime
no.354 of 2023 was registered in this regard u/s 406 IPC.
13. It was also noted that the material further disclosed that
on 16.06.2023 appellant submitted his resignation from the
respondent company which had been accepted by the Board of
Directors and Form DIR-12 filed with the Registrars of
Companies, Chennai. The appellant also executed an
undertaking agreeing to allow the company to continue the
operation of the subject vehicles until the settlement of the
entire accounts of the Company and handing over of all relevant
documents to the Company.
14. As mentioned above, appellant had earlier lodged a similar
complaint registered as Crime no.102/2024 wherein the police
Page 5 of 17

filed the chargesheet referring to the matter as a ‘Mistake of
fact’. The protest petition against the same was dismissed vide
order dated 17.04.2025 by the trial court which attained finality
upto the Supreme Court.
15. The High Court observed that in the present case, the
police referred the case as ‘false’ and filed a final report in RC
No.08/2024 which had attained finality. Despite this, and
during the pendency of the referred charge sheet, the Police,
without following due process, illegally seized the subject
vehicles. In such circumstances, the order rejecting the custody
of the subject vehicles to the respondent company was
erroneous and warranted interference. The petition of the
respondent company was allowed and the subject vehicles were
ordered to be released in its favour subject to undertaking
affidavit.
16. Aggrieved by the impugned order, the appellant has filed
the present appeals.

17. Learned Counsel for the appellant submits that the High
Court failed to follow the principle as laid down in Sunder Bhai
Page 6 of 17

1
Ambalal Desai Vs. State of Gujarat , wherein it is held by this
Court that under section 451 CrPC, the seized vehicles should
be released temporarily in favor of the ostensible owner as per
the registration certificate until the Court decides on the
disposal of the property after the trial.
18. It is submitted that the High Court has erred in holding
that the closure report had attained finality as further
investigation was carried out subsequent to the representations
made by the appellant, leading to the filing of a positive
chargesheet.

19. It is also submitted that the alleged resignation dated
16.06.2023 was fraudulently obtained. The undertaking has
also been forged. Separate proceedings are pending regarding
these disputes. The High Court has failed to correctly appreciate
these facts which has resulted in gross miscarriage of justice.
20. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents submits
that the appellant has suppressed the fact that the vehicles were
purchased by utilising the funds of the respondent company.

1
2002 (10) SCC 283
Page 7 of 17

21. It is submitted that the resignation letter dated 16.06.2023
was given voluntarily wherein he attended the Board meeting
dated 16.06.2023 held at the registered office of the company
and his resignation was accepted with immediate effect. A
cheque was handed to him as sale consideration for the share
transfer which was encashed by him. The fact that he encashed
the cheque clearly belies his claim that he was forced to sign the
share transfer forms.
22. He has also failed to disclose that he had voluntarily given
an undertaking to the effect that the machines in the name of
Pure Minerals will remain at the quarry of the respondent
company till he settles his accounts with the company, as the
payment for the loan taken from Shriram Finance Ltd. on the
machines was paid from the account of the respondent
company.
23. The learned counsel for the respondents also submits that
the seizure of the vehicles was illegal, as the Final
report/chargesheet dated 14.08.2024 referred the case as false
wherein it was noted that as per the company workers (LW2 to
LW6) the vehicles were brought to the respondent company with
Page 8 of 17

the consent of LW1 (appellant herein) and that no extortion was
committed. Thereafter, matter was referred to the Magistrate to
issue refer chargesheet proceedings vide RC No.8/2024 and
notice was issued to the complainant to be called on
05.12.2024. Pending the refer proceedings, the investigating
officer filed a memo stating permission to withdraw refer
proceedings and permit re-investigation but this was not
granted by the Magistrate. Therefore, RC No.8/2024 has
attained finality as noted by the High Court. The seizure
therefore was in contradiction of order dated 27.09.2024
registering the refer charge and amounts to unlawful
interference with the business of the Respondents herein.
24. Lastly, it is submitted that the appellant’s sole reliance on
registration certificates is legally misconceived. Registration
may be a relevant factor, but cannot override admitted
possession, undertaking, and settled use, particularly in
commercial arrangements where assets are purchased in
individual names using company funds. In the present case, the
vehicles were seized from the Respondent Company’s
Page 9 of 17

operational site and were under its use and control pursuant to
an express undertaking and the admitted course of dealings.
25. Having considered the submissions made by the learned
counsels for the parties and the material on record, we now
proceed to decide the issue before us. The short question that
arises for our consideration is:
As to who, between the parties, is entitled to interim
custody of the subject vehicles at this stage, in terms of
Sections 451 and 457 of the CrPC?
26. Section 451 and Section 457 CrPC read as hereunder:
“ Section 451 : Order for custody and disposal of property
pending trial in certain cases.
When any property is produced before any Criminal Court during
any inquiry or trial, the Court may make such order as it
thinks fit for the proper custody of such property pending the
conclusion of the inquiry or trial, and, if the property is subject to
speedy and natural decay, or if it is otherwise expedient so to do,
the Court may, after recording such evidence as it thinks
necessary, order it to be sold or otherwise disposed of.
Explanation.---For the purposes of this section, "property" includes-
-
(a) property of any kind or document which is produced before the
Court or which is in its custody;
(b) any property regarding which an offence appears to have been
committed or which appears to have been used for the commission
of any offence.

Section 457. Procedure by police upon seizure of property .

(1) Whenever the seizure of property by any police officer is
reported to a Magistrate under the provisions of this Code, and
such property is not produced before a Criminal Court during an
inquiry or trial, the Magistrate may make such order as he
thinks fit respecting the disposal of such property or the
Page 10 of 17

delivery of such property to the person entitled to the
possession thereof, or if such person cannot be ascertained,
respecting the custody and production of such property .
(2) If the person so entitled is known, the Magistrate may order the
property to be delivered to him on such conditions (if any) as the
Magistrate thinks fit and if such person is unknown, the Magistrate
may detain it and shall, in such case, issue a proclamation
specifying the articles of which such property consists, and
requiring any person who may have a claim thereto, to appear
before him and establish his claim within six months from the date
of such proclamation.”

27. The language used in these provisions makes it clear that
the Court is vested with the power to grant custody to
whomsoever it deems fit i.e. the Court has the discretion to
determine who is best entitled to possession of the property. The
use of the words ‘possession’ and ‘custody’ emphasize that the
Court does not adjudicate title but merely undertakes the
exercise of granting interim possession, with the object of
preventing decay and diminution in the value of the subject
property.
28. The said purport of these provisions has been discussed
2
by this Court in N. Madhavan v. State of Kerala . Paragraph 10
reads as hereunder:
“ 10. The words “may make such order as it thinks fit” in
the section, vest the court with a discretion to dispose of the
property in any of the three modes specified in the section.
But the exercise of such discretion is inherently a judicial
function. The choice of the mode or manner of disposal is not

2
(1979) 4 SCC 1
Page 11 of 17

to be made arbitrarily, but judicially in accordance with
sound principles founded on reason and justice, keeping in
view the class and nature of the property and the material
before it…”

29. This well-settled principle has also been reiterated in
Sunder Bhai Ambalal (Supra) wherein paragraph 7 reads as
hereunder:
“7. In our view, the powers under Section 451 CrPC should be
exercised expeditiously and judiciously. It would serve various
purposes, namely:
1. owner of the article would not suffer because of its
remaining unused or by its misappropriation;
2. court or the police would not be required to keep the
article in safe custody;
3. if the proper panchnama before handing over possession
of the article is prepared, that can be used in evidence
instead of its production before the court during the trial. If
necessary, evidence could also be recorded describing the
nature of the property in detail; and
4. this jurisdiction of the court to record evidence should be
exercised promptly so that there may not be further chance
of tampering with the articles.”

30. The thread of reasoning emerging from the above is that
the limited object of these provisions is to ensure that property
seized in the course of criminal proceedings does not suffer
waste, misuse, or deterioration, and that it remains available for
production before the Court as and when required. The exercise
of this power requires the Court to make only a prima facie
assessment of who is best entitled to possession, having regard
Page 12 of 17

to the nature of the property, the circumstances of seizure and
the material placed before it. It does not comprise an
adjudication of ownership, which falls generally within the
exclusive domain of a competent civil forum.
31. We may note we do not consider it necessary to enter into
the question of the reopening of investigation and the
consequent seizure of the subject vehicles as being without the
sanction of law in the present proceedings, as it is a matter that
would fall for consideration in appropriate proceedings
challenging the same and cannot by itself be determinative of
the question of interim custody with which we are presently
concerned. We accordingly proceed to decide the present
appeals on the independent and broader question of who, as
between the parties, is best entitled to interim possession of the
subject vehicles, having regard to the material on record.
32. Applying the above stated principles to the facts at hand,
we may now consider the circumstances relied upon by the
parties. The appellant's case rests almost entirely on the
registration certificates standing in the name of his company.
We are unable to accept that this circumstance, by itself, is
Page 13 of 17

determinative. Registration is a relevant factor, but it is
evidentiary and not conclusive of entitlement to interim
possession.

33. Furthermore, the appellant’s reliance on Sunder Bhai
Ambalal (supra) to contend that the subject vehicles must be
released in favour of the owner as per the registration certificate
is misconceived. The said judgment, as discussed above, does
not lay down an inflexible rule that custody must invariably
follow the registration certificate irrespective of all other
attending circumstances; it requires the Court to act
expeditiously and judiciously, having regard to the object of
preventing misuse and deterioration of property.
34. Several circumstances, taken cumulatively, weigh against
the appellant's claim to interim custody. Firstly, the registration
certificate stands considerably weakened given that criminal
proceedings remain pending against the appellant alleging
misappropriation of funds from the accounts of the respondent
company for the very purpose of acquiring the subject vehicles
in the name of his own company.
Page 14 of 17

35. Furthermore, it is not in dispute that the vehicles were
seized from the operational site of the respondent company,
where they had remained in continued use pursuant to a
written undertaking executed by the appellant himself. The
appellant does not dispute the existence of this undertaking,
albeit he has alleged that it has been forged. On this aspect, we
note that pertinently, the appellant has not offered any
explanation for having encashed the cheque issued to him in
connection with the transfer of his shareholding, a
circumstance that sits uneasily with his assertion that his
resignation and the accompanying undertaking were obtained
under coercion. Whether the resignation, the board resolution,
and the share transfer were validly executed or were, as alleged,
fabricated, is a matter requiring evidence and trial which cannot
be resolved at this interim stage, and is, in any event, the
subject of independent proceedings which remain pending. We
express no opinion on the merits of that dispute, and it shall be
open to the appellant to agitate all such contentions, including
the allegation of forgery, in the appropriate proceedings.
Page 15 of 17

36. Another circumstance weighing in the favour of the
respondent company is the undisputed fact that the
hypothecation instalments payable to Shriram Finance Ltd.
towards the loan availed for the subject vehicles have admittedly
been discharged from the account of the respondent company,
and not by the appellant in his individual capacity. If the
vehicles were, as claimed, the personal property of the
appellant, there is no explanation forthcoming as to why the
financial burden of servicing the loan secured over them was
borne by the respondent company. This circumstance, taken
with the appellant's own undertaking permitting the respondent
company to retain and operate the vehicles until settlement of
accounts, considerably weakens the appellant's claim of
exclusive individual entitlement and lends credence to the
respondents' case of continued beneficial use and control.
37. In view of the above, we agree with the findings of the High
Court. Based on a cumulative assessment, we find that the
circumstances favouring the respondent company, namely, the
continued possession, the undisputed factum of the payment of
the EMI instalments, and the undertaking on record, outweigh
Page 16 of 17

the circumstances in favour of the appellant, namely the
registration certificates.
38. The question as framed above therefore stands answered
in favour of the respondent company “M/s Earth Stein Private
Limited”, who has been rightly granted the interim possession.
39. The appeals being devoid of merit stand dismissed in light
of the above terms. It is, however, clarified that the observations
made herein are confined to the question of interim custody and
shall not be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits
of the rival claims of ownership, misappropriation, or the
validity of the resignation and share transfer, which shall be
independently determined in the pending appropriate
proceedings.
40. Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.

.……..………..……………………..J.
[ SANJAY KAROL ]



.……..………..……………………..J.
[ AUGUSTINE GEORGE MASIH ]

NEW DELHI;
JULY 27, 2026.
Page 17 of 17