Mehar Elahi & Ors vs Aman Ullah Khan
- Court
- Delhi High Court
$~
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Judgment reserved on: 25.09.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 19.11.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 19.11.2026
# CNR No. DLHC010735692012
+ CS(OS) 1452/2012
MAHER ELAHI & ORS. .....Plaintiffs
Through: Mr. Jagjit Singh, Senior
Advocate with Ms. Preet Singh
and Mr. Abhijeet Singh,
Advocates
versus
AMAN ULLAH KHAN .....Defendant
Through: Mr. Siddharth Khattar, Mr.
Divij Andley and Mr. Gaurav
Raj Sharma, Advocates
CORAM:
HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE SWARANA KANTA SHARMA
JUDGMENT
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
I.A. 5063/2026
1. By way of the present application filed under Section 151 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 [hereafter „ CPC ‟] read with Order
XVI Rule 1(2) of the CPC, the applicants/plaintiffs seek summoning
of the witnesses at serial nos. 7, 12, 13 and 14 of their list of
witnesses before the learned Local Commissioner appointed for
recording of evidence.
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 1 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29
2. The application was first listed before this Court on
24.02.2026, when notice was issued and the matter was referred to
the learned Joint Registrar (Judicial) for completion of pleadings. The
pleadings stood completed vide order dated 09.07.2026, whereafter
the matter was placed before this Court. During this period, no
further proceedings for recording of evidence took place before the
learned Local Commissioner.
3. The facts leading to the filing of the present application are that
the present suit seeks specific performance of the Agreement to Sell
dated 17.03.2008 [hereafter „ the Agreement ‟] in respect of property
bearing no. B-4, Nizamuddin West, New Delhi [hereafter „ suit
property ‟], or, in the alternative, damages. The total sale
consideration under the Agreement was Rs. 5.05 crores, out of which
the plaintiffs claim to have paid Rs. 3.35 crores till 23.08.2008, with
the balance amount payable by 31.08.2008. The plaintiffs contend
that they withheld the balance consideration upon learning that the
suit property had been mortgaged with Citibank. The defendants, on
the other hand, dispute the plaintiffs' claim of readiness and
willingness, as well as their financial capacity to pay the balance
consideration.
4. The issues were framed by this Court vide order dated
31.01.2014, which are as under:
“(i) Whether the plaintiff has been ready and willing to perform his
part of the agreement dated 17.3.2008? OPP
(ii) Whether the suit is barred by limitation? OPD
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 2 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29
(iii) Whether the suit is not maintainable due insufficient Court fees?
OPD
(iv) Whether the defendant was having free title of the suit property
as on 31.8.2008, the due date of final payment and whether the same
was lying mortgaged with Citi Bank, if so its effect? OPD
(v) Whether the plaintiff was aware of the financial arrangement
between the defendant and the Bank? OPD
(vi) Whether the defendant is entitled to forfeit the entire advance
money paid by the plaintiff to the defendant in terms of the
Agreement to Sell dated 17.3.2008 and/or due to damages suffered
by defendant? OPD
(vii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to relief of Specific performance
and/or in the alternative decree of damages? OPP
(viii) Relief.”
5. On 09.10.2018, the learned Joint Registrar (Judicial), while
deciding the plaintiffs‟ application under Order VII Rule 14 of the
CPC, being I.A. 5813/2018 , declined to take on record certain
additional documents, i.e. the UCO Bank passbook, the J&K Bank
statement and the Income Tax Return of plaintiff no. 1 for the
financial year 2014-15. These documents were sought to be placed on
record to demonstrate the plaintiffs‟ financial capacity to pay the
balance sale consideration. However, since the documents pertained
to the period after institution of the suit, the learned Joint Registrar
declined to take them on record, observing as follows:
“Present IA has been moved by plaintiff for placing on record
additional documents which are agreement dt.13.3.08, original pass
book of UCO Bank & original statement of J&K Bank and IT return
of plaintiff no.l for financial year 2014-15.
Learned counsel for both parties have argued on lines of their
application & reply.
In so far as UCO Bank passbook & statement of J&K Bank and ITR
are concerned, same admittedly reflect entry and figure post the
filing of the present suit. This is a suit for specific performance of the
contract.
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 3 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29
In my opinion the documents which can show the capability of
plaintiff to pay the balance consideration on or before institution of
the suit are only relevant. Pass book of UCO Bank and statement of
J&K Bank and copy of return sought to be placed on record are
related to the period after institution of the suit. These documents are
not relevant and cannot be taken on record…”
6. The aforesaid order was challenged by the plaintiffs by way of
a chamber appeal, being O.A. 157/2018 . However, the said appeal
was withdrawn on 09.01.2024 after some arguments were addressed.
Thereafter, the plaintiffs filed I.A. 8861/2024 seeking permission to
summon additional witnesses for the purpose of proving the very
same documents which had earlier been declined to be taken on
record vide order dated 09.10.2018. The plaintiffs sought to
distinguish the two applications by contending that the earlier
application was for placing additional documents on record, whereas
the present application was for summoning witnesses to prove those
documents. The learned Joint Registrar (Judicial), however, did not
accept this distinction and dismissed the said application vide order
dated 22.09.2025.
7. Vide order dated 24.11.2025, Sh. Brijesh Kumar Garg, District
& Sessions Judge (Retd.), was appointed as the learned Local
Commissioner for recording of evidence. After recording the
evidence of PW-1 and PW-2, the learned Local Commissioner fixed
28.02.2026 for recording the evidence of the remaining plaintiffs'
witnesses. Thereafter, the present application came to be filed by the
plaintiffs, seeking summoning of the witnesses at serial nos. 7, 12, 13
and 14 of their list of witnesses. The details of the said witnesses and
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 4 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29
the purpose for which they are sought to be summoned, as set out in
the present application, are extracted hereunder:
8. The learned senior counsel appearing for the plaintiffs submits
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 5 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29
that the witnesses mentioned in the list of witnesses are officials of
various departments and banks, whose attendance cannot be secured
without the process of the Court. It is further submitted that their
evidence is relevant and bears directly upon the issues framed in the
present suit.
9. On the other hand, the learned counsel appearing for the
defendant submits that there is no objection to summoning the
witnesses mentioned at serial nos. 7 and 14 of the list of witnesses.
However, he opposes the summoning of the witnesses at serial nos.
12 and 13, who are sought to be called for producing the bank
statements of Mrs. Nazma Noor (plaintiff no. 4) and Mr. Noor
Ahmad (plaintiff no. 3), for the period commencing from January
2007 onwards. It is contended that the said bank statements ought to
have been in the power and possession of the plaintiffs and could
have been filed along with the plaint, but the plaintiffs consciously
chose not to place them on record. It is further submitted that the
present suit pertains to the year 2012 and the contents of the
application clearly reveal an attempt on the part of the plaintiffs to
introduce the said documents indirectly through the summoned
witnesses. According to the learned counsel, what cannot be
permitted directly cannot be permitted indirectly by summoning
witnesses, and the plaintiffs ought to have sought permission to place
the said documents on record by filing an appropriate application
under Order VII Rule 14 of the CPC.
10. This Court has heard arguments addressed on behalf of both
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 6 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29
the parties and has perused the material available on record.
11. In the present case, it is undisputed that the witnesses at serial
nos. 7 and 14 are already named in the list of witnesses filed by the
plaintiffs. Their evidence relates to Issue Nos. (vii) and (iv),
respectively. Further, the defendant has no objection to their being
summoned. Accordingly, their summoning does not call for any
further consideration.
12. The controversy in the present application is, therefore,
confined to the summoning of witnesses at serial nos. 12 and 13.
13. Order XVI Rule 1 of the CPC provides as under:
“ 1. List of witnesses and summons to witnesses .—(1) On or before
such date as the Court may appoint, and not later than fifteen days
after the date on which the issues are settled, the parties shall present
in Court a list of witnesses whom they propose to call either to give
evidence or to produce documents and obtain summonses to such
persons for their attendance in Court.
(2) A party desirous of obtaining any summons for the attendance of
any person shall file in Court an application stating therein the
purpose for which the witness is proposed to be summoned.
(3) The Court may, for reasons to be recorded, permit a party to call,
whether by summoning through Court or otherwise, any witness,
other than those whose names appear in the list referred to in sub-
rule (1), if such party shows sufficient cause for the omission to
mention the name of such witness in the said list.
(4) Subject to the provisions of sub-rule (2), summonses referred to
in this rule may be obtained by the parties on an application to the
Court or to such officer as may be appointed by the Court in this
behalf within five days of presenting the list of witnesses under sub-
rule (1).”
14. Rule 7 of Chapter XI of the Delhi High Court (Original Side)
Rules, 2018 is also to similar effect. Further, Section 5 of the
Bankers‟ Books Evidence Act, 1891 makes a bank officer
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 7 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29
compellable to prove the entries in the bank's books “ by order of the
Court or a Judge made for special cause ”, while Section 6 empowers
the Court to direct production of certified copies of entries in bankers'
books.
15. Coming to the rival contentions, this Court is of the view that
the objection raised by the defendant does not merit acceptance. At
the outset, it is pertinent to note that the witnesses at serial nos. 12
and 13 are not new witnesses sought to be introduced by the plaintiffs
at this stage. They find mention at the very same serial numbers in
the list of witnesses dated 24.02.2016, wherein the purpose of
summoning them was specified as production of the records of the
respective bank accounts “ for the period Jan., 2007 to Sept., 2009 ”.
The said list has been on record for nearly a decade. Thus, the
defendant was aware, from the very beginning, that the plaintiffs
intended to summon the concerned bank officials and produce the
records of these accounts. There is, therefore, no question of any
surprise or introduction of an entirely new case at this stage.
16. Further, the bank accounts in question do not introduce any
new factual foundation into the suit. The documents filed along with
the plaint (Index-4, S. No. 2) include copies of cheque no. 367603
drawn on Oriental Bank of Commerce, Farrukhabad, and cheque no.
170923 drawn on Punjab National Bank, Farrukhabad, both dated
29.04.2008 and for an amount of Rs. 10,00,000/- each, which are
stated to have been issued towards payment to the defendant. Thus,
the transactions through the very same bank accounts already find
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 8 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29
mention in the documents filed with the plaint. The bank statements
are sought to be produced to substantiate the financial transactions
and the availability of funds in the said accounts during the relevant
period.
17. The evidence sought to be led through these witnesses is also
relevant to Issue No. (i), which concerns the readiness and
willingness of the plaintiffs to perform their part of the Agreement.
The financial capacity of the plaintiffs to pay the balance sale
consideration on or before 31.08.2008 is an important aspect of this
issue. In U.N. Krishnamurthy v. A.M. Krishnamurthy: Civil Appeal
No. 4703 of 2022, decided on 12.07.2022 , the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court held as under:
“25. To aver and prove readiness and willingness to perform an
obligation to pay money, in terms of a contract, the plaintiff would
have to make specific statements in the plaint and adduce evidence to
show availability of funds to make payment in terms of the contract
in time. In other words, the plaintiff would have to plead that the
plaintiff had sufficient funds or was in a position to raise funds in
time to discharge his obligation under the contract. If the plaintiff
does not have sufficient funds with him to discharge his obligations
in terms of a contract, which requires payment of money, the
plaintiff would have to specifically plead how the funds would be
available to him. To cite an example, the plaintiff may aver and
prove, by adducing evidence, an arrangement with a financier for
disbursement of adequate funds for timely compliance with the terms
and conditions of a contract involving payment of money.”
18. In the present case, the defendant has disputed the financial
capacity of the plaintiffs to pay the balance sale consideration and has
also cross-examined PW-1 on the source and availability of funds.
Once the financial capacity of the plaintiffs has been put in issue, the
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 9 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29
bank records which may have a bearing on the said question are
certainly relevant. The defendant cannot, on the one hand, dispute the
financial capacity of the plaintiffs and question the source of funds,
and, on the other hand, oppose the production of relevant bank
records which may assist the Court in determining that very issue.
19. The objection that the plaintiffs ought to have filed an
application under Order VII Rule 14 of the CPC also does not, by
itself, furnish a ground to decline the present request. Order VII Rule
14(1) and (3) of the CPC deal with documents upon which the
plaintiff sues or relies and which are in his possession or power, as
well as the consequences of non-production of such documents. Sub-
rule (2), on the other hand, contemplates a situation where such a
document is not in the possession or power of the plaintiff and
requires the plaintiff to state the person in whose possession or power
it is. In the present case, what is sought to be summoned is the
official record maintained by the concerned banks, through their
officials. In any event, the mere fact that the plaintiffs may have had
access to their passbooks or account statements would not, by itself,
disentitle them from seeking production of the banks‟ own records
through their officials. Thus, the question of admissibility and the
evidentiary value of the documents so produced can be considered at
the appropriate stage. The defendant shall also be at liberty to raise
all permissible objections in that regard.
20. However, this Court notes that the prayer in the present
application seeks production of the bank records “ for the period of
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 10 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29
Jan. 2007 onwards ”. This is wider than the period specifically
mentioned in the list of witnesses dated 24.02.2016, i.e., January
2007 to September 2009. No explanation has been furnished by the
plaintiffs for seeking the records beyond the said period. Further, the
earlier order dated 09.10.2018, which has attained finality, had
declined to take on record certain financial documents pertaining to
the period after institution of the suit, on the ground that such
documents were not relevant for determining the plaintiffs‟ financial
capacity at the relevant time. The present application cannot be thus
used to enlarge the scope of the evidence beyond what was originally
disclosed in the list of witnesses or to indirectly introduce financial
records pertaining to periods beyond the relevant transaction.
21. Accordingly, while the plaintiffs are entitled to summon the
bank officials at serial nos. 12 and 13, it is directed that their
evidence shall remain confined to the period from January 2007 to
September 2009, as originally specified in the list of witnesses dated
24.02.2016, since such period sufficiently covers the period
preceding the Agreement, its execution and the date fixed for
payment of the balance sale consideration, i.e. 31.08.2008. To this
extent, the objection of the defendant is sustained.
22. Accordingly, the present application is allowed and disposed of
with the following directions:
(i) Summons be issued to the witnesses at serial nos. 7, 12,
13 and 14 of the list of witnesses dated 24.02.2016, for the date
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 11 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29
to be fixed by the learned Local Commissioner.
(ii) Since Oriental Bank of Commerce stands amalgamated
with Punjab National Bank w.e.f. 01.04.2020, the witnesses at
serial nos. 12 and 13 shall be officials of Punjab National
Bank, Farrukhabad, who shall produce the records of the
respective accounts only for the period from January 2007 to
September 2009.
(iv) The learned Local Commissioner is requested to proceed
expeditiously with the recording of evidence.
23. The present application is disposed of in above terms.
24. Nothing herein shall nothing expressed herein above shall
tantamount to an expression of opinion on merits of the case .
CS(OS) 1452/2012
25. List on 08.04.2027.
26. The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
NOVEMBER 19, 2026/ns
CS(OS) 1452/2012 Page 12 of 12
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
Signing Date:19.11.2026
18:00:29