Sadhu Singh Now Deceased Through Lr And Others vs Raghbir Singh And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
116 RSA-2863-2023 (O&M)
Date of decision: 12.11.2026
Sadhu Singh (deceased) through his LR and others
....Appellants
Vs.
Raghbir Singh and others
....Respondents
CORAM : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER
Present: Mr. Anupam Singla, Advocate
for the appellants.
*
HARSH BUNGER J.
1. For convenience, the parties herein are being addressed as per
their status in the original suit.
2. This is the plaintiffs' second appeal challenging the judgment
and decree dated 21.04.2017 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Rajpura, as well as the judgment and decree dated 15.03.2023
passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Patiala.
3. Briefly, the plaintiffs filed a suit for declaration to the effect
that they are owners in possession of the site marked as ABCDEFGHIJ (as
shown in the site plan attached with the plaint), which is a part of Khasra
Nos. 798 and 423, and also for correction of entries in the revenue record of
consolidation for the year 1952-53 of Village Khanpur Baring, Tehsil
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -2-
Rajpura, District Patiala. Consequential relief of permanent injunction was
also sought.
3.1 The aforesaid suit was filed by the plaintiffs on the plea that
they are owners in possession of the suit property and their possession over
the site in question has been from the time of their forefathers. The plaintiffs
stated that they have their dung cakes and ruri over the site. It was averred
that there are also two kikar trees and two Sareen trees standing at the site in
dispute, whereas the remaining land is in the cultivating possession of the
plaintiffs. It is further pleaded that previously chari-chara was sown by the
plaintiffs and now the said site is lying vacant. The plaintiffs claimed their
possessory title over the site in dispute.
3.2 It is the pleaded case of the plaintiffs that previously the site in
dispute was comprised in Khasra Nos. 798 and 423, but the said entries were
deleted in the jamabandi for the year 1960-61, therefore, the same are liable
to be corrected as per the previous revenue record. The plaintiffs stated that
the defendants have no right, title or interest in the site in question, and they
want to dispossess the plaintiffs forcibly by encroaching upon the suit
property illegally and unlawfully, for which they have no right. Accordingly,
the suit was filed.
4. Upon issuance of notice, the defendants No. 1 to 4 appeared in
the suit and opposed the claim of the plaintiffs by filing their written
statement, inter alia, stating that the plaintiffs are not the original residents
of Village Khanpur Baring, whereas defendants No. 1 to 4 are the original
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -3-
residents of the village and are Ramdasia by caste. It is further stated that the
disputed property is also situated in the Ramdasia Basti, whereas the houses
of the plaintiffs are at a long distance from the site in dispute. It is also stated
that the plaintiffs are Jatt by caste and that they have produced a wrong site
plan. It is specifically stated that the plaintiffs have their separate houses and
Baras away from the suit property. It was averred that they had sold the
house to Sadhu Singh resident of Village Hulka, who further sold the same
to one Gulzar Singh, and that the plaintiffs and the other defendants in the
suit have got no concern with the site ABCD, and the trees standing in the
property belong to defendants No. 1 to 4. The site in question was stated to
be the ancestral property of defendants No. 1 to 4, which had fallen to their
share in the oral family settlement. The other averments in the plaint were
denied and prayer for dismissal of the suit was made.
4.1 On the other hand, defendants No. 5, 6 and 9 filed their separate
written statement stating that their houses are in existence in Khasra
Nos. 798 and 423, and that the plaintiffs have no concern with their houses.
The other submissions in the plaint were denied and prayer for dismissal of
the suit was made.
4.2 Defendant No. 7 also filed his separate written statement stating
that the plaintiffs' possession over the site in dispute has been continuing
since their forefathers and they have possessory title over the said site. It was
further stated that the site marked as ABCDEF (shown in the site plan
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -4-
produced by the defendants), is in his and defendant No.10 possession, to the
extent of 1/2 share each.
4.3 Defendant No. 10 filed her separate written statement stating
that near point F of the site plan produced by the plaintiffs, there is a vacant
plot of defendant No. 10 measuring 7’ x 77’ in length, where defendant
No. 10 has raised a boundary wall, and that the plaintiffs have got no right,
title or interest in the same.
4.4 Defendants No. 11 and 12 also filed their separate written
statement wherein they took a stand that the plaintiffs have produced a
wrong site plan, and that defendants No. 11 and 12 along with their brothers
are in possession of Khasra No. 425 measuring 2 bighas. They averred that
their brothers Gurnam Singh and Ram Singh had transferred their share in
favour of Baldev Kaur (wife of Inder Singh) and Naib Kaur (wife of
Balwinder Singh), vide registered sale deed dated 13.10.2010. Therefore,
Gurnam Singh and Ram Singh have no share in the aforesaid 2 bigha area,
and in lieu thereof, they (defendants No. 11 and 12) had left their shares in
favour of Gurnam Singh and Ram Singh, in the abadi deh . It was further
stated that there is no Khasra Nos. 798 and 423 at the spot. The other
averments of the plaint were denied and prayer for dismissal of the suit was
made.
4.5 Even defendants No. 16, 17, and 18 filed their separate written
statement claiming their ownership over the site marked with letters ABCD,
as shown in the site plan filed by the defendants. They stated that they have
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -5-
a pond for fish farming and they have planted safeda and neem trees in the
said site ABCD, over which they are in possession since the time of their
forefathers. The other averments in the plaint were denied and prayer for
dismissal of the suit was made.
4.6 It transpires that defendants No. 15, 19, 20, and 21 were
proceeded against ex parte vide order dated 31.05.2012.
5. From the pleading of the parties, following issues were framed
by the learned Trial Court:-
“1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to declaration as prayed
for?OPP
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to permanent injunction
as prayed for?OPP.
3. Whether the suit is not legally maintainable?OPD
4. Whether the plaintiffs have no locus standi to file the
present suit?OPD
5. Whether the plaintiffs have not come to the Court with
clean hands?OPD
6. Whether the suit is time barred?OPD.
7. Whether this Court has no jurisdiction to try and decide
the present suit?OPD
8. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary
parties?OPD
9. Relief.”
6. Thereafter, the parties led their respective evidence on the
aforesaid issues.
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -6-
7. The learned Trial Court, upon consideration of the matter,
dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs vide judgment and decree dated
21.04.2017.
8. Feeling dissatisfied, the plaintiffs preferred an appeal before the
learned Additional District Judge, Patiala, which was also dismissed vide
judgment and decree dated 15.03.2023.
9. In the aforementioned circumstances, present regular second
appeal has been filed before this Court.
10. I have heard the learned counsel for the appellants and perused
the paperbook with his able assistance.
11. At the outset, it would be gainful to refer to the judgment
rendered by a Division Bench of this Court in “Kashmir Singh v. Joint
Development Commissioner (IRD), Punjab, Chandigarh”, 2006(7) RCR
(Civil) 42 ; wherein this court explained the procedure during consolidation
operation in a village, as under:-
“17. In the case in hand the land in question of which
declaration has been sought by the petitioners, prior to
consolidation operations was part of Khewat No. 168/1.
Consolidation proceedings or operations in the Village were
carried out in the year 1962. These proceedings are done in
accordance with the provisions of the East Punjab Holdings
(Consolidation and Prevention of Fragmentation) Act, 1948
('Consolidation Act for short) and the East Punjab Holdings
(Consolidation and Prevention of Fragmentation) Rules, 1949
('Rules for short). Rule 4 of the Rules provides for preparation
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -7-
of scheme of consolidation. Rule 5 provides for the particulars
which such scheme of consolidation shall contain. Rule 6
provides that the scheme of consolidation is to be explained to
the persons affected thereby and Rule 7 provides for repartition.
Rule 7(iii) envisages the preparation of statement showing the
names of owners of holdings with particulars of field numbers,
shares, class of land, tenure, area, assessment and
encumbrances, if any, after getting the record-of rights upto
date. For the purpose of the present petition, it may be noticed
that Khatauni Ishtemal is amongst the first document which is
compiled which contains the existing khasra numbers of the
land, the area and its valuation. Further the Naqsha
Haqdarwar is prepared which indicates the rights of the right
holder and as to what would be its standard value. These are
pre-partition documents. Thereafter, re-partition is done and
the Consolidation Officer after obtaining the advice of the land
owners (Mushwarti Committee) of the estate concerned carries
out re-partition in accordance with the scheme of consolidation.
As a consequence of this repartition, the Khatauni Paimaish is
prepared which contains the statement showing the names of
owners of holdings, with particulars of field numbers, shares,
class of land, tenure, area, assessment and encumbrances, if
any, the name of owners with particulars of all different rights
possessed by each individually, the compensation payable by or
to an owner in order to adjust difference in the value of land
exchanged under Section 15 of the Consolidation Act. Besides,
a statement showing the names of occupants of holders to whom
the new consolidated holdings are allotted with particulars of
field number, share, class of land, tenure, area, assessment and
encumbrances and such other papers as may be considered
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -8-
expedient by the Settlement Officer (Consolidation). The first
Jamabandi (record of rights) that is prepared after
consolidation proceedings is the Misl Haqiat. The consolidation
proceedings also provide for the land which is to be kept for
common purpose of the village in terms of Section 18 of the
Consolidation Act. The management and control of the land of
common purposes are to vest in the Panchayat or the State
Government in terms of section 23-A of the Consolidation
Act…”
12. Coming to the case in hand, the plaintiffs filed a suit for
declaration in respect of the site marked as ABCDEFGHIJ in the site plan,
by stating that the same is a part of Khasra Nos. 798 and 423. However, in
the revenue record for the year 1960-61, the aforesaid khasra numbers have
been deleted, therefore, the said entries are liable to be corrected. The
aforesaid stand of the plaintiffs has been opposed by the defendants in the
suit.
13. The learned Trial Court, upon appraisal of the facts, pleadings,
as well as the evidence available on record, returned the following findings
under issues No. 1 and 2:-
“xxx xxx xxx
The argument addressed by the Counsel for the plaintiff
is devoid of any merit because as far as the area of abadi deh,
which is Khasra No.423 is concerned, as per the scheme of
consolidation during the consolidation of holdings in Punjab,
the abadi area which is also known as the area inside the lal
lakir was not disturbed. The entire proceedings relating to
consolidation were taken outside the lal lakir. The abadi inside
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -9-
the lal lakir was given a single Khasra Number in ownership of
abadi deh. Therefore, the claim of the plaintiff is unreasonable
with regard to Khasra No.423 when he states that though after
the consolidation, he continues to be in possession of the site in
dispute, but those khasra numbers have been deleted, as
admittedly Khasra No.423 constitutes the area of a abadi and
as discussed above, the area of a abadi were not disturbed
during the consolidation proceedings. As per the plaintiff, the
property in dispute constitutes of Khasra No.798 and 423.
Regarding Khasra No. 423, the claim of the plaintiff is not
maintainable as has been discussed above. Now regarding
claim of the plaintiff that part of the suit property which
constitutes Khasra No.798 was previously owned and possessed
by the plaintiff and for correction of the revenue record of
consolidation, as after consolidation, the relevant entries
relating to the rights of plaintiffs were not made by the official,
is concerned. The plaintiff should have produced in evidence
Khatoni Istemal i.e. for depicting the old khasra numbers and
thereafter connected it with Misl Haqiat to Naksha
Hakdar/Register Karwai and Khatoni Paimaish. The most
important document which would be the best evidence in the
case and could have easily proved the case of the plaintiff is
Khatoni Paimaish. The Khatoni Paimaish could have proved
the newly allotted Khasra numbers and also mentioned the old
Khasra numbers out of which the new numbers have been
carved out. The plaintiff has not produced the best evidence,
which could have substantiated his claim that he was in
possession of the suit property prior to the consolidation and it
is due to the fault of the revenue officials that Khasra numbers
have not been properly mentioned in the revenue record. As the
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -10-
best evidence has been withheld by the plaintiff therefore as a
necessary corollary an adverse inference drawn against the
plaintiff.
In view of the discussion made above, these issues are
decided against the plaintiffs and in favour of the defendants.”
13.1 On the basis of the findings on various issues, the learned Trial
Court dismissed the suit filed by plaintiffs, vide judgment and decree dated
21.04.2017.
14. The findings returned by the learned Trial Court have been
further affirmed by the learned First Appellate Court vide judgment and
decree dated 15.03.2023, the relevant extract thereof reads as under:-
“26. From the perusal of record and evidence of both the
parties, this Court has come to the conclusion that the
appellants have failed to prove their case and the learned
Lower Court has rightly dismissed the suit of the appellants.
The appellants have been claiming that they are the owners and
in possession of the site ABCDEFGHIJ as shown in the site
plan EX P1 and the said part of the suit property was part of the
Khasra numbers in question. The possession of the appellants
over the site in dispute is stated to be from the time of their
forefathers. It is also the case of the appellants that the property
in dispute is comprised in Khasra numbers in dispute. In the
jamabandi EX P2 of Khasra No.798 in the ownership column
the same is recorded as "shamlat patti jattan hasab hissa
paimana malqiyat". Further as per the jamabandi Ex P6 of the
Khasra No.423 in the ownership column the same is recorded
as "abadi deh". The argument of the learned counsel for the
appellants that the appellants have got possessory title over the
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -11-
suit property, but it has been deleted in the jamabandi for the
year 1960-61. It is further the case of the appellants that prior
to consolidation, the site in dispute was owned and possessed by
the appellants, but lateron the same became part of Khasra
numbers in question. After consolidation the relevant entries
were not made by the officials and as such, correctness of the
entries in the revenue record of consolidation in the year 1952-
53 was sought.
27. As per the East Punjab Holdings (Consolidation &
Fragmentation) Act, 1948, abadi area inside the Lal Lakir is
not disturbed and the entire proceedings relating to
consolidation are taken outside the Lal Lakir. The abadi inside
the Lal Lakir retains its single number in ownership of the
abadi deh and while taking up the consolidation of holdings in
the revenue estate, the last jamabandi of revenue estate is
updated by incorporating therein all the sanctioned mutations
and Fard Badar entries. The decision of pending mutations/fard
badar are also expedited. The rights in revenue estate are
brought up to date and updated rights are entered in "khatoni
Ishtemal" depicting the existing possession regarding the nature
of rights of various land holders in the revenue estate
immediately prior to the consolidation. After the preparation of
"khatoni ishtemal", the next document prepared is "naksha haq
darbar". The entitlement of each right holder in the revenue
estate is converted into standing absolute area by
proportionately reducing the area of land of lesser value. After
"naksha haq darbar" is prepared, the re-partition/re-allotment
is made in a book called "register karwai" and in this re-
allotted numbers are mentioned value of the land in lieu of
which numbers are re-allotted. After this proceeding in the
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -12-
register, the next document prepared is "khatoni paimaish". The
newly allotted Khasra numbers mentioned in the "register
karwai" are incorporated and it is also mentioned against each
new number old location Khasra numbers i.e. Khasra numbers
out of which new numbers have been carved out. The old
number given here are not the previous ownership numbers of
the record holder. After the “khatoni paimaish” the next
document, which is prepared, is called "misal haqiyat". There is
nothing on record of rights or the first jamabandi after
consolidation of holdings. It also contains the old location
number of newly allotted numbers during the re-partition. In
order to find out as to which Khasra numbers were held by the
record holder in the revenue estate prior to consolidation, in
lieu of which the Khasra numbers (mentioned in misal haqiyat)
were allotted and the "khatoni Ishtemal" and "Misal Haqiyat"
through "naksha haq darbar, register karwai and khatoni
paimaish" have to be connected.
28. Here in the present case, the appellants were required to
prove "khatoni ishtemal, naksha haq darbar, register karwai,
khatoni paimaish and misal haqiyat". Though, the appellants
have examined Lakhwinder Singh, Qanungo, PW7, to prove the
documents EX PW7/A to EX PW7/H. But he has stated in his
cross-examination that he does not know about the khatoni
paimaish and khatoni ishtemal and that Khasra No.798 was not
recorded in the documents EX PW7/A to EX PW7/E. Therefore,
when the appellants have failed to prove these documents and
withheld the best evidence available, therefore, adverse
inference is required to be drawn against them….
29. xxx
30. xxx
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -13-
31. The next argument of the learned counsel for the
appellants is that there is roorie and dung cakes of the
appellants lying over the property in dispute and trees of the
appellants are also standing there and they have got possessory
title over the same. In order to prove this fact, the appellant
Sadhu Singh himself stepped into witness box as PW2 and the
appellants also examined Chander Mahesh PW3, Hachand
Singh PW4, Harbilas Singh PW5 and Amar Singh PW6 and
they all have stated that the appellants are placing the roorie
over the property in dispute and they are in possession over the
same. Respondents No.1 to 4, as well as, 11 and 12, have
opposed the arguments of the learned counsel for the appellants
and have alleged that they have been in possession over the
same and they have constructed their houses. The appellants
have no concern with the suit property.
32. The question, which arises for consideration before the
Court is whether the appellants have been able to prove their
possession over the property in dispute or not?…..
xxx xxx xxx
33. From the above referred judgment, it is clear that mere
user, in the shape of throwing rubbish or placing dung cakes,
does not establish the possession of the appellants, who had
sought the relief of injunction. It is necessary for the litigants to
establish that they have been exercising their possession with
intention to retain it by excluding others over the property in
question.
34. Here in the present case, the appellants have failed to
prove this fact. Sadhu Singh PW2 has stated in his cross-
examination that he cannot tell the length and width of the
property in dispute. He also admitted the constructed houses of
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -14-
Inder Singh and Balbir Singh and boundary walls over the
same. He further stated that they have been using the barra
adjoining their houses for the last 35 years and mere acts of
user throwing rubbish does not prove the exclusive possession
of the appellants.
35. The grounds raised by the appellants before this Court in
appeal are found to be devoid of any merits and as such, the
appellants cannot be held entitled to the reliefs claimed by
them.”
15. When the findings returned by learned First Appellate Court are
tested on the touchstone of judgment rendered in case of Kashmir Singh
(supra), no fault can be found with the same.
16. Before this Court, learned counsel for the appellants has failed
to show as to how the findings returned by the learned Courts below are
either illegal or perverse or based upon any mis-reading or mis-appreciation
of any material evidence on record, so as to warrant any interference by this
Court. There are concurrent findings returned by learned Courts below.
17. In Jaichand v. Sahnulal, 2025(2) Apex Court Judgments (SC)
336 ; Hon'ble Apex Court observed as under:-
“24. In Navaneethammal v. Arjuna Chetty reported in AIR
1996 S.C. 3521 , it was held by this Court that the High Court
should not reappreciate the evidence to reach another possible
view in order to set aside the findings of fact arrived at by the
first appellate Court.
25. In Kshitisn Chandra Purkait v. Santhosh Kumar Purkait
reported in (1997) 5 S.C.C. 438) , this Court held that in the
Second Appeal, the High Court should be satisfied that the case
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -15-
involves a substantial question of law and not mere question of
law.
26. In Dnyanoba Bhaurao Shemade v. Maroti Bhaurao
Marnor reported in 1999 (2) S.C.C. 471 , this Court held:-
"Keeping in view the amendment made in 1976, the High Court
can exercise its jurisdiction under Section 100, C.P.C. only on
the basis of substantial questions of law which are to be framed
at the time of admission of the Second Appeal and the Second
Appeal has to be heard and decided only on the basis of such
duly framed substantial questions of law. A judgment rendered
by the High Court under Section 100 C.P.C. without following
the aforesaid procedure cannot be sustained."
27. This Court in Kondira Dagadu Kadam v. Savitribai
Sopan Gujar reported in AIR 1999 S.C. 2213 held:-
"The High Court cannot substitute its opinion for the
opinion of the first appellate Court unless it is found that
the conclusions drawn by the lower appellate Court were
erroneous being contrary to the mandatory provisions of
law applicable or its settled position on the basis of
pronouncements made by the Apex Court, or was based
upon inadmissible evidence or arrived at without
evidence."
28. It is thus clear that under Section 100, C.P.C., the High
Court cannot interfere with the findings of fact arrived at by the
first Appellate Court which is the final Court of facts except in
such cases where such findings were erroneous being contrary
to the mandatory provisions of law, or its settled position on the
basis of the pronouncement made by the Apex Court or based
upon inadmissible evidence or without evidence…”
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2863-2023 (O&M) -16-
18. Keeping in view the above, I see no merit in this appeal nor
there is any question of law, much less substantial question of law involved
in this regular second appeal.
19. Resultantly, the instant regular second appeal fails and the same
is accordingly, dismissed .
20. All the pending application(s), if any, shall also stand closed.
(HARSH BUNGER)
12.11.2026 JUDGE
Ankit
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh