ANNETTE CHACKO vs TOM MERVIN GUILD
- Court
- Kerala High Court
CNR : KLHC010783492026
1
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
“C.R”
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.S.DIAS
TH
WEDNESDAY, THE 11 DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026 / 20TH KARTHIKA, 1948
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
AGAINST THE ORDER/JUDGMENT DATED IN OP NO.875 OF 2026 OF FAMILY
COURT, ALUVA
PETITIONER/RESPONDENT:
ANNETTE CHACKO
AGED 37 YEARS
OOLAKKADEN HOUSE, SION VILLAS, IRINJALAKUDA VILLAGE,
MUKUNDAPURAM TALUK, THRISSUR DISTRICT, PIN - 680121
BY ADVS.
SRI.RAHUL SUNIL
SRI.D.ARUN BOSE
SHRI.AROMAL SASI
RESPONDENT/PETITIONER:
TOM MERVIN GUILD
AGED 43 YEARS
XIV/305, VAZHAKKAPURATH VATTAPARUTHA, PUTHUSSERY MUGAL
ROAD, KANGARAPPADY, THRIKKAKARA WEST P.O., THRIKKAKARA
NORTH VILLAGE, KANAYANNUR TALUK, ERNAKULAM., PIN -
682021
BY ADV SMT.SIKHA G.NAIR
THIS TRANSFER PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR FINAL
HEARING ON 11.11.2026, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
CNR : KLHC010783492026
2
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
“C.R”
th
Dated this the 11 day of November, 2026
O R D E R
This transfer petition is filed under Section 24 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (‘CPC’, for brevity),
seeking transfer of O.P. No. 875/2026 from the Family
Court, Aluva, to the Family Court, Irinjalakuda.
2. The petitioner is the estranged wife of the
respondent. A child is born to them in their wedlock. The
petitioner has instituted O.P. No. 1235/2026 (‘Annexure
A’) before the Family Court, Irinjalakuda, seeking
permanent custody of the minor child. Thereafter, the
respondent has instituted O.P. No. 875/2026 (‘Annexure
B’) before the Family Court, Aluva, seeking substantially
the same relief. According to the petitioner, she and the
child are permanent residents of Irinjalakuda, and the
child ordinarily resides with her. She states that no one
is there to chaperone her on the journey from
Irinjalakuda to Aluva to prosecute the Annexure B
CNR : KLHC010783492026
3
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
petition. She further points out that, as the proceedings
concern the custody of a child, who is aged only three
and a half years, the child may also have to travel with
her to Aluva on every posting date to facilitate the
interim custody to the respondent. This, according to
her, would cause considerable hardship and
inconvenience to the child and her. On these grounds,
she seeks transfer of Annexure B petition to the Family
Court, Irinjalakuda.
3. The respondent has opposed the transfer
petition by filing a counter affidavit. His case is that, on
16.02.2026, the petitioner left for her parental home
with the child. He contends that the child had expressed
a desire to accompany him. According to the respondent,
the child was admitted to pre-KG in a school in Aluva and
ordinarily resided there. He submits that the petitioner
has forcibly and unlawfully taken the child away from his
residence in Aluva and has since denied him access. He
CNR : KLHC010783492026
4
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
has approached the Child Welfare Committee,
Ernakulam, seeking its intervention. It is at this juncture,
to scuttle the proceedings before the CWC, the petitioner
filed the Annexure A petition. The respondent specifically
contends that the Family Court, Aluva, is the court of
competent territorial jurisdiction to entertain the custody
petition. Therefore, the transfer petition may be
dismissed.
4. I have heard Sri. Rahul Sunil, the learned
counsel for the petitioner, and Smt. Sikha G. Nair, the
learned counsel for the respondent.
5. The petitioner has instituted Annexure A
petition before the Family Court, Irinjalakuda, and the
respondent has instituted Annexure B petition before the
Family Court, Aluva. Both petitions are filed seeking the
custody of the parties’ only child.
6. It is also undisputed that Annexure A petition
was instituted on 31.08.2026 before the Family Court,
CNR : KLHC010783492026
5
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
Irinjalakuda, whereas Annexure B petition was instituted
on 17.09.2026 before the Family Court, Aluva.
7. The pendency of parallel proceedings
concerning the guardianship and custody of the a minor
calls for consideration of the relevant provisions of the
Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 (for short, ‘Act’), and the
power of transfer of this Court under Section 24 of the
CPC.
8. Section 14 of the Act deals with simultaneous
proceedings in different Courts. It reads as follows:
" Section 14- Simultaneous proceedings in different
Courts.-
(1) If proceedings for the appointment or declaration of a
guardian of a minor are taken in more Courts than one, each of
those Courts shall, on being apprised of the proceedings in the
other Court or Courts, stay the proceedings before itself.
(2) If the Courts are both or all subordinate to the same High
Court, they shall report the case to the High Court, and the High
Court shall determine in which of the Courts the proceedings
with respect to the appointment or declaration of a guardian of
the minor shall be had.
(3) In any other case in which proceedings are stayed under sub-
section (1), the Courts shall report the case to and be guided by
such orders as they may receive from their respective State
Governments.”
9. Section 14 of the Act contemplates the
CNR : KLHC010783492026
6
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
institution of proceedings for the appointment or
declaration of a guardian of a minor in more than one
Court. In the above exigency, and if the two Courts are
subordinate to the same High Court, the proceedings are
to be stayed, and the matter is to be reported to the High
Court, which in turn is to decide the court of competent
jurisdiction.
10. In addition to the above provision, Section 24 of
the CPC confers power on this Court to transfer a
proceeding. In the case of the above nature, the above
two provisions are to be applied harmoniously,
particularly where the parties advance rival claims as to
the child’s place of ordinary residence and one party
alleges that the child was forcibly and unlawfully
removed from the place where the child had been
residing.
11. The petitioner asserts that she and the child are
ordinarily residing at Irinjalakuda. The respondent, on
CNR : KLHC010783492026
7
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
the other hand, maintains that the child was ordinarily
residing at Aluva and was taken forcibly away from there
by the petitioner without his consent. Thus, the parties
have raised a dispute regarding the child’s place of
ordinary residence, which is essentially a disputed
question of fact, which cannot be resolved merely by
accepting one version over the other based on the
pleadings in this transfer petition.
12. Section 9 of the Act confers jurisdiction to
entertain an application under the Act on the Court
within whose jurisdiction the minor ordinarily resides.
The expression ‘ordinary residence’ is again a question
of fact which, in the circumstances of this case, cannot
be conclusively determined in a proceeding under
Section 24 of the CPC. It is important to distinguish
between the convenience-based exercise of the power of
transfer and an adjudication on the territorial
jurisdiction of the Court before which the proceeding is
CNR : KLHC010783492026
8
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
to be tried. An order under Section 24 of the CPC
regulates the forum in which a proceeding is to be tried;
it does not, by itself, confer territorial or subject-matter
jurisdiction on the transferee Court. The Family Court,
Irinjalakuda, has to decide the objection to its
jurisdiction in accordance with law.
13. The principles governing the transfer of
matrimonial proceedings are well settled. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in Sumita Singh v. Kumar Sanjay and
another [2002 KHC 1889], Vaishali Shridhar Jagtap v.
Shridhar Vishwanath Jagtap [2016 KHC 6489],
Santhini v. Vijaya Venketesh [2017 (5) KHC 48] and
N.C.V. Aishwarya v. A.S. Saravana Karthik Sha [2022
(5) KHC 185], has consistently recognised that the
convenience of the wife and the children is a relevant
consideration in deciding a transfer petition. The Court
must, however, consider the circumstances as a whole
and balance the competing conveniences and
CNR : KLHC010783492026
9
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
inconveniences. The convenience of either party cannot
be treated as an inflexible or conclusive rule.
14. In the present case, the petitioner is a woman,
and the child is only three and a half years old. They are
presently residing at Irinjalakuda. Requiring the
petitioner to travel from Irinjalakuda to Aluva to contest
the proceedings, with a child of such tender age, would
cause severe inconvenience and hardship to both of
them. The respondent’s contentions—that the child was
ordinarily residing at Aluva and that his access to the
child has been denied—are not being rejected. They raise
issues which must be examined by the Family Court on
the basis of the pleadings and materials on record. At
this stage, however, those disputed contentions do not
outweigh the practical hardship that would be caused to
the petitioner and the child if proceedings of the same
child continue before two different Courts. Bringing the
proceedings before one Court would also facilitate their
CNR : KLHC010783492026
10
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
joint consideration, avoid multiplicity of proceedings,
save judicial time, and eliminate the possibility of
conflicting orders. The respondent will, of course, remain
entitled to contest the proceedings and to seek
appropriate orders for access to the child.
15. On an overall consideration of the
circumstances, I am satisfied that the balance of
convenience and the interests of justice warrant the
transfer of O.P. No. 875/2026 to the Family Court,
Irinjalakuda, where O.P. No. 1235/2026 is already
pending. The fact that Annexure A was instituted first,
the common subject matter of the two proceedings and
the hardship likely to be caused to the petitioner and the
young child if they are required to attend proceedings at
Aluva are relevant considerations supporting the
transfer. I make it clear, however, that this conclusion is
confined to the choice of Court for the present. It shall
not be understood as a finding that the child ordinarily
CNR : KLHC010783492026
11
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
resides within the territorial jurisdiction of the Family
Court, Irinjalakuda, or that the said Court necessarily
has jurisdiction under Section 9 of the Act. That question
is left open to be decided by the Family Court,
Irinjalakuda, on the basis of the pleadings and evidence,
untrammelled by any observation in this order.
In the result, the transfer petition is allowed on the
following terms:
(i) O.P. No. 875/2026 pending before the Family
Court, Aluva, shall stand transferred to the Family
Court, Irinjalakuda.
(ii) The Registry shall forward a copy of this order to
the Family Court, Aluva. The said Court shall
forthwith transmit the records in O.P. No.
875/2026 to the Family Court, Irinjalakuda.
(iii) On receipt of the records, the Family Court,
Irinjalakuda, shall post O.P. No. 875/2026 along
with O.P. No. 1235/2026 and consider the two
proceedings together.
(iv) The Family Court, Irinjalakuda, shall consider the
objection to its territorial jurisdiction, with
CNR : KLHC010783492026
12
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
reference to Section 9 of the Act, as a preliminary
issue. The parties shall be afforded an opportunity
to adduce such evidence as may be necessary for
the determination of that issue.
(v) It is clarified that the transfer of the proceedings
by this order shall not be treated as a
determination of the question of territorial
jurisdiction. If the Family Court, Irinjalakuda, finds
that it lacks territorial jurisdiction to entertain the
petitions, it shall pass appropriate consequential
orders in accordance with law.
Sd/-
C.S.DIAS, JUDGE
mtk/dkr
CNR : KLHC010783492026
13
TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
2026:KER:86278
APPENDIX OF TR.P(C) NO. 678 OF 2026
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE A A COPY OF THE ORIGINAL PETITION FILED BY
THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT,
IRINJALAKUDA AS O.P. NO. 1235 OF 2026
DATED 02.09.2026.
ANNEXURE B A TRUE COPY OF THE ORIGINAL PETITION
ALONG WITH THE NOTICE FILED BY THE
RESPONDENT SEEKING PERMANENT CUSTODY OF
THE MINOR CHILD AS O.P. NO. 875 OF 2026
DATED 17.09.2026 BEFORE THE FAMILY COURT,
ALUVA.
RESPONDENT ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE-R1 TRUE COPY OF THE BONAFIDE CERTIFICATE
FROM HOLLY CROSS CONVENT PRE PRIMARY
SCHOOL-KANGARAPPADY
ANNEXURE-R1(A) TRUE COPY OF SCHOOL TRANSFER CERTIFICATE
FROM BACKYARD ACADEMY,KANGARAPPADY
ANNEXURE-R1(B) TRUE COPY OF I.A.3/2026 IN O.P.1235/2026
DATED OCTOBER 2026 FAMILY COURT,
IRINJALAKKUDA.