KAMAKSHI KUMARAN vs VENKATRAMANI
- Court
- Madras High Court
OSA No. 69 of 2024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Reserved on : 16.11.2026
Pronounced on : 20.11.2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE N. SATHISH KUMAR
AND
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE GK.MUTHUKUMAAR
OSA No. 69 of 2024 and CMP.No.8821 of 2024
CNR: {HCMA010452012024}
1. Kamakshi Kumaran
2. M/s.Sree Builders
Represented by its proprietor V.Radhakrishna
(Deceased) No.15, I Avenue, Besant
Nagar,Chennai -90, Represented through its
Power Agent Mrs. Kamakshi Kumaran
3. R.Suchitra
4. V.R.Vighnesh
5. V.R.Vaishnave
(Plaintiffs 3 to 5 impleaded as per order dated
07.07.2021 in A.No.2298 of 2021)
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. Venkatramani
2. C.R.Chandrasekaran (Deceased)
3. C.R.Revathi alias Gowri Chandrasekaran
4. C.Kirupa Shankar
(The Defendants 2 to 4 impleaded as per order
dated 25.09.2014 in Appl.No.5361 of 2014)
5. Sowmiya Srikanthan
R5 brought on record as LRs of deceased R2
viz C.R.Chandrasekaran vide court order dt.
02.11.2026 made in CMP 29866 of 2026 in
OSA 69 of 2024 NSKJ and GKMJ
..Respondent(s)
__________
Page1 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
Original Side Appeal filed under Order XXXVI Rule 9 of OS Rules read with
Clause 15 of Letters Patent to set aside the judgement and decree dated
10.07.2023 in C.S.No. 82 of 2007.
For Appellant(s): Mr.R.Venkatraman
for M/s.Tatva Legal Chennai
For Respondent(s): Mr.R.Thiagarajan for R1
Vasudha Thiagarajan
Mr.Ashwin Shanbhag for R3 & R4
Ms.Jheertha for R5
JUDGMENT
N.Sathish Kumar, J.
Challenging the decree and judgment of the learned Single Judge
dismissing the suit for specific performance and decreeing the suit for granting
alternate relief of directing the first defendant to pay a sum of Rs.10 lakhs with
interest @ 7.5% per annum on Rs.2 lakhs from 07.12.2005 till the time amount
was deposited in the court, the present appeal has been filed.
2. The parties are arrayed to as per their own ranking before the Trial
Court
3. The following are the brief facts leading to filing this appeal:-
3.a. The first defendant being the owner of the suit property has agreed to
sell the property for a total sale consideration Rs.59 lakhs and received a sum of
Rs.10 lakhs on 21.07.2005 by way of cheque bearing No.093345 dated
21.07.2005 drawn on Indian Bank, Chennai. It was agreed that balance sale
consideration shall be paid within 90 days from the date of agreement, but the
__________
Page2 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
same is subject to fulfillment of certain conditions and obligations set out in the
st
agreement of sale. At the time of entering into agreement of sale, the 1
defendant did not produce the original title deeds with regard to the suit
schedule property and other parent documents, encumbrance certificates and
st
other papers for approving the title. While the same was demanded for, the 1
defendant informed the plaintiffs that the original title deed and other
documents are lying with Bank of India, Cathedral Road Branch, Chennai - 86
st
as security for the loans availed by the defendant. At the request of 1 defendant
to discharge the loan amount, the plaintiffs believed his representation and paid
st
a substantial advance of Rs.10 lakhs to enable the 1 defendant to discharge the
loan amount and to retrieve the title deeds from the said Bank. Inspite of taking
huge amount as advance amount, the first defendant has not discharged the loan
amount and retrieved and turned over the documents to the plaintiffs for the
purpose of approving the title and completion of sale transaction. Despite
frequent requests made by the plaintiffs for several months after the agreement,
the defendant has not produced the encumbrance certificate and handed over the
title deeds, therefore, the plaintiff has issued legal legal notice dated 26-02-2006
calling for the defendant to come forward and execute the sale deed after
discharging the mortgage from Bank of India, however, the first defendant
issued a reply notice making several allegations inter alia contending that
agreement itself was terminated due to non-performance of the terms of
conditions of the agreement. According to the plaintiffs, such allegations are
__________
Page3 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
totally false. The plaintiffs also came to know that the first defendant is not
willing to execute the sale deed in favour of the plaintiffs and negotiating with
third parties, therefore, the plaintiffs lodged complaint to the police for initiating
action against the first defendant; since the issue is civil in nature, the plaintiff
sent reply notice dated 09.11.2006 to the notice sent by the first defendant dated
01.11.2026 by not only returning the advance amount sent by the first
defendant, but also called upon him to perform his obligations.
3.b. The plaintiffs were having sufficient funds to pay the balance sale
consideration and they were always ready and willing to perform their
obligations so far as performance of sale transactions. It is the first defendant
who committed breach with regard to the terms and conditions, hence, the
plaintiffs are entitled to specific performance. The first defendant had sold the
property in favour of defendant Nos.2 & 3, by way of sale deed dated 08-12-
2008 and the defendant Nos.2 and 3, in turn, had settled their interest and
th
ownership on the suit property in favour of their son viz., the 4 defendant
through a settlement deed dated 08.06.2011 creating further encumbrance over
the suit property. Hence, the suit seeking specific performance.
3.c. According to the first defendant, the first plaintiff is the mother-in-
law of the second plaintiff. They are in the real-estate business. They entered
into a sale agreement with the first defendant for purchasing the suit property
with a view to develop it and to build few apartments. About a week prior to the
__________
Page4 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
sale agreement, on 13.07.2005, the second plaintiff addressed a letter to this
defendant and made the following offer which varied from the sale agreement
was that of the balance sale consideration of Rs.49.0 lakhs, Rs.10.0 lakhs would
be paid a week before the registration of the sale deed and that the balance
Rs.39.0 lakhs would be paid at the time of registration. Even before the
execution of the sale agreement, the first defendant had handed over the copies
of title deed and allied documents to the plaintiffs. Besides they were informed
that the property was outstanding on a mortgage with M/s Bank of India,
Cathedral Road branch since 22.06.2004, to secure a loan of Rs.8.0 lakhs, and
that the original title deed of the suit property had been deposited with it, and
that he was still due to pay the bank a sum of Rs.7.5 lakhs. The plaintiffs had
verified these facts with the bank pursuant to a written request made by this
defendant to his banker. Indeed, the letter dated 13.07.2005 referred to earlier
was given by the plaintiffs only after they had verified the facts. The first
defendant had agreed to obtain the documents only after receiving the balance
sale consideration of Rs.10.0 lakhs out of the balance sale consideration.
Though there was no express clause that the plaintiffs should pay Rs.10.0 lakhs
a week before the registration, there was a consensus on this aspect, as the intent
was to utilise this fund to discharge the debt dues to the bank and to redeem the
mortgage to render the property free of encumbrance.
__________
Page5 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
3.d. The three months time stipulated in the agreement is an essential
term of the contract. This is because the bank which is the mortgagee of the suit
property was preparing to initiate action to realise the loan dues, and the
intention to sell the property inter alia was for averting the coercive action by
the bank. That apart, the first defendant required funds for arranging marriage
alliance for his daughter. Due to the breach of contract by the plaintiff, that
alliance came to be dropped. That apart, trusting the promise of the plaintiffs
that they would perform their part of the contract, the defendant even vacated
the tenant of the suit property and paid him the rental advance of Rs.70,000/-
that the tenant had earlier left with him, and lost the rental income of Rs.7,000/-
p.m., plus the interest income on the advance amount left by the tenant. Apart
from this, the defendant had also booked an apartment then under construction
and paid an advance of Rs.10.0 lakhs to the builder on 23.07.2005, on the very
next day after the execution of the sale agreement. As the defendant intended to
make subsequent payment to his builder from and out of the sale proceeds, and
since due to the plaintiffs defaulted to perform their part of the contract, the first
defendant could not pay the builder, and consequently, the builder terminated
the contract, and had returned only Rs.7 lakhs as against a payment of Rs.10
lakhs paid by the first defendant. The plaintiffs were never ready and willing to
pay the balance sale consideration, despite several demands made by the first
defendant. The plaintiffs did not have requisite funds to perform their part of the
contract.
__________
Page6 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
3.e. Due to breach of contract by the plaintiffs, the first defendant could
not service his debt to the bank and redeem the suit property in time. He was
forced to pay Rs.8.80 lakhs towards the repayment of loan liability and redeem
the mortgage. The sale agreement dated 21.07.2005 stands automatically
terminated on 21.10.2005. The plaintiffs have waived and abandoned their
contractual right and cannot keep the contract alive. Under these circumstances,
the first defendant forfeited Rs.2.0 lakhs towards liquidated damages and
returned Rs.8.0 lakhs through a cheque along with his reply notice, but that was
refused. Again on 07.12.2005, he issued a demand draft for Rs.8.0 lakhs, drawn
in favour of the first plaintiff, and sent the same along with the reply notice
dated 02.03.2006. This demand draft was not accepted and was returned, but
the plaintiffs have concealed this fact in their plaint. The first defendant has
raised a counter claim of Rs.15.0 lakhs as damages.
3.f. The defendants 2 to 4 have filed their written statement in line with
the first defendant stating that on 05.02.2007, defendants 2 and 3 had entered
into a sale agreement with the first defendant for the purchase of the suit
property for a total consideration of Rs.96.0 lakhs and that under the agreement
they had paid Rs.4.0 lakhs as advance, and upon payment of the entire sale
consideration, the first defendant executed a sale deed on 08.12.2008 in favour
of defendants 2 and 3. Subsequently on 08.06.2011, these defendants had settled
the suit property in favour of the 4th defendant. These defendants had made
__________
Page7 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
substantial improvements to the property since the purchase. Now, the 4th
defendant is in occupation of the property. Since the defendants 2 and 3 have
paid the full consideration to the first defendant, the suit is not specifically
enforceable.
3.g. The plaintiffs filed their rejoinder cum written statement to the
counter claim of the first defendant pleading that the counter claim is badly
barred by limitation. In terms of the reply notice of the first defendant, the suit
sale agreement stood terminated even on or before 02.03.2006, and if the first
defendant has a right to claim damages, that should have been done within three
years at least from 02.03.2006. The counter claim however was raised only on
29.06.2016 and hence is barred by limitation. In terms of the sale agreement, the
first defendant is under an obligation to sell the property free of encumbrance,
but he had never redeemed the mortgage from his banker. He has not explained
why he did not utilise Rs.10.0 lakhs which he had received as advance amount
under the sale agreement for discharging the loan and for clearing the
encumbrance over the property. The plaintiffs’ readiness, or their turn to
perform their part of the contract would arise only after the first defendant had
cleared the encumbrance over the property. Time is not an essential of the
contract. The intention of the first defendant is to break the contract and to sell
the property for a higher consideration.
__________
Page8 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
3.h. Though various issues were originally framed, the learned Single
Judge re-casted the issue and the same are as follows:-
1.Whether time is the essence of the Agreement of Sale dated 21.07.2005,
entered between the plaintiffs and the 1st defendant, for sale of the schedule
property?
2.Were the plaintiffs ready and willing to perform their part of the
contract?
3.Who among the parties here to has committed breach of contract?
4.Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for the relief of specific performance
of the contract dated 21.07.2005? Or, to the alternate prayer for refund of
advance amount paid thereunder.
5.Who among the parties on either side is entitle to damages for breach of
contract, and if anyone is so entitled, what is the decree as to the quantum of
damages?
6.Whether the defendants 2 and 3 are bonafide purchaser for value
without notice of the contract between the plaintiffs and the first defendant?
And, will the doctrine of lis pendens affect their purchase
7.To what other reliefs are the parties entitled to ?
3.i. On the side of plaintiffs, power agent of the plaintiff was examined as
PW1 and Exs.P1 to P27 were marked. On the side of defendants, first defendant
__________
Page9 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
was examined as D.W.1 and third defendant was examined as D.W.2 and they
marked Exs.D1 to D31.
3.j. Based on the oral and documentary evidences, the learned Single
Judge dismissed the suit for specific performance, however, granted alternate
relief directing the first defendant to pay a sum of Rs.10 lakhs with interest @
7.5% per annum on Rs.2 lakhs from 07.12.2005 till the time amount was
deposited in the court. Challenging the same, the present appeal has been filed.
4. The learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the conduct of the
first defendant assumes significant. Having received an advance of Rs.10 lakhs
only in order to redeem the mortgage, he has not taken any steps to discharge
the mortgage from the bank, whereas, the defendant had invested that amount
for purchase of plot, that itself clearly shows that the first defendant’s intention
was only to defeat the contract. The readiness and willingness would arise only
on the performance of the contract by the first defendant on bringing of
encumbrance certificate and original documents, therefore, would submit that
the plaintiff has proved the readiness and willingness by sending legal notice
immediately and the suit is also filed within a period of 3 years and further,
there is no hardship caused on the defendant, the subsequent purchase and the
settlement is also during the pendency of the suit. Thus, the plaintiff is certainly
entitled to specific performance.
__________
Page10 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
5. It is his further contention that as per Section 13(c) of the Specific
Relief Act, where the property is mortgaged for an amount not exceeding the
purchase money, the purchaser may compel the vendor to redeem the mortgage
and obtain a valid discharge and where necessary also a conveyance from the
mortgagee. Therefore, it is the duty of the vendor to clear the mortgage. Having
received a sum of Rs.10 lakhs to clear the mortgage, the first defendant has not
redeemed the mortgage within the time stipulated in the contract, therefore,
according to the learned counsel, time is not an essence of contract. The
plaintiffs were always ready and willing to perform their contract, their
readiness and willingness will arise only on the performance of the first
defendant’s obligations. When the first defendant has not acted bonafidely and
invested the money for purchase of some other plot without clearing the
mortgage and made the title marketable, he cannot be shown any leniency. This
conduct has to be assessed by the Court and therefore, would submit that the
learned Single Judge though having held that time is not an essence of contract,
negatived the relief of specific performance.
6. It is his further contention that since the consideration is lower than
what was agreed in the contract, that itself shows that subsequent purchasers are
not bonafide purchaser; at any event, they purchased the property with the
notice of the earlier contract and therefore, would submit that the plaintiffs are
certainly entitled to specific performance. In support of his submissions, he
__________
Page11 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
relied upon decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Chandnee Widya Vati
Madden v. C.L. Katial and Ors. (MANU/SC/0257/1963) , contending that as far
as the parties to the contract are concerned, they are strictly bound by the terms
and conditions of the document executed by them.
7. The learned counsel for the first respondent submitted that the very
conduct of the plaintiffs indicate that they were not ready and willing to perform
the contract from the very inception; even at the time of contract, they were
informed about Rs.8 lakhs mortgage in the Bank of India. It is specifically
agreed between the parties that apart from the advance of Rs.10 lakhs, another
Rs.10 lakhs will be paid to clear the loan, however, the plaintiffs have not paid
the remaining Rs.10 lakhs to clear the loan despite requests being made by the
first defendant. The plaintiffs have also verified all the copies of the title deeds
even at the time of agreement which has been clearly admitted by PW1. It is the
further contention that the plaintiffs have never shown their readiness and
willingness, their bank savings accounts and postal savings account produced
before the Court clearly shows that at no point of time, they had substantial
amounts in their accounts to pay the remaining sale consideration within the
agreed period in the agreement. The agreement itselfs clearly indicate that the
first plaintiff agreed to purchase only 1/3rd undivided share of the suit property
nd
and the 2 plaintiff agreed to purchase 2/3rd of the undivided share of the suit
property, whereas, Exs.P20 and D8 clearly shows that the second plaintiff has
__________
Page12 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
never parted with any amount for the agreement. These documents indicate as if
he has nominated the first plaintiff and he has declared that no amounts
whatsoever was paid by him and further, he has declared that he had no right
over the property arising out of the agreement dated 21.07.2005. According to
the second plaintiff, he has virtually relinquished his right, these facts clearly
nd
show that 2 plaintiff has never parted with any amount, therefore, their
contention that they were always ready and willing to pay the remaining sale
consideration within a period of 90 days is highly improbable.
8. Further, it is contended that the first defendant had agreed to sell the
property due to pressing necessities to celebrate the marriage of his daughter,
that apart, also to purchase another plot. As the plaintiffs had failed to pay the
remaining sale consideration, the marriage of the daughter was also dropped,
therefore, according to him, undue hardship has been caused to him because of
the conduct of the plaintiffs. The first defendant has already taken a demand
draft for Rs.8 lakhs and sent to the plaintiff after deducting Rs.2 lakhs forfeiture
amount from the advance amount of Rs.10 lakhs, immediately during the
agreement period. Having sent a legal notice on 26.02.2026, the plaintiffs have
not taken any further steps to pay the remaining sale consideration, whereas, on
15.12.2006, they have lodged a police complaint; except that, they have not
done anything. Passbook of saving bank accounts and postal savings account
produced by the plaintiffs under Exs.A9 to A14 does not prove that the
__________
Page13 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
plaintiffs had substantial amounts to pay the sale consideration at any point of
time, therefore, the learned Single Judge has appreciated this aspect and found
that the plaintiffs were never ready and willing to perform the contract.
9. Furthermore, it is the contention of the first defendant that the plaintiffs
have never entered into the box, only the power agent of the plaintiffs was
examined as PW1. Though power agent is the son of first plaintiff, his evidence
indicate that the first plaintiff is only house-wife. PW1 evidence clearly indicate
that on 09.12.2005, the first defendant had returned Rs.8 lakhs by way of
cheque to the counsel of the plaintiff. The plaintiffs were also aware of the
mortgage of Rs.8 lakhs and the original documents are with the bank and they
had also verified the copies of the document at the time of agreement, therefore,
the contention that the first defendant has not produced the document is
introduced only for the first time in the suit and the suit has been filed belatedly.
Though the time is not an essence of contract, when the conduct of the parties
clearly shows that they are not entitled to specific performance, merely because
the property has been sold to third parties, that itself cannot be a ground to grant
the decree for specific performance. Hence, seeks for dismissal of the appeal.
10. In support of his submissions, the learned counsel for the first
respondent placed reliance on a series of judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court and sought for dismissal of this appeal. They are as follows:-
__________
Page14 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
a. Reliance was placed on I.S. Sikandar (D) by LRs v. K. Subramani ,
(2013) 15 SCC 27 , to emphasize that under the law of equity governing specific
performance of a real estate contract, the Court looks not merely at the letter but
at the substance of the agreement. It must be ascertained whether the parties
named a specific time intending strict compliance or whether performance
within a reasonable time was intended. An intention to make time the essence of
the contract must be expressed in clear and unequivocal language.
b. Reference was made to A. Kantamani v. Narseen Ahmed , (2017) 4
SCC 654 , wherein it was held that in a suit for specific performance, the
plaintiff is required to treat the contract as still subsisting and must prove
continuous readiness and willingness from the date of the contract up to the date
of hearing. Failure to prove such continuous readiness and willingness
inevitably leads to the dismissal of the suit.
c. Relying upon Rajesh Kumar v. Anand Kumar , (2024) 13 SCC 80 , it
was argued that a Power of Attorney holder cannot depose for the principal in
respect of matters within the exclusive personal knowledge of the principal.
Where the principal fails to step into the witness box to give evidence, an
adverse presumption arises against the case set up by them.
d. In respect of the bar of limitation, reliance was placed on Valliammai
v. K.P. Murali , (2024) 20 SCC 363 , highlighting that Article 54 of Part II of the
Schedule to the Limitation Act, 1963 prescribes a period of three years from the
__________
Page15 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
date fixed for performance, or where no such date is fixed, three years from the
date when the plaintiff has notice of refusal of performance.
e. Finally, the decision in R. Kandasamy v. T.R.K. Saraswathy , (2025) 3
SCC 513 , was cited to substantiate that the grant of specific performance is a
discretionary relief and Courts are not bound to grant it merely because it is
lawful to do so. The phrase “ready and willing” implies readiness to carry out
contractual obligations to their logical end. Continuous readiness and
willingness on the part of the plaintiff constitutes a mandatory condition
precedent for the grant of specific performance.
11. In light of the above, now the points that arise for consideration in this
appeals are:-
a. Whether the plaintiffs have proved the readiness and willingness
entailing them to seek the relief of specific performance?
b. Whether the first defendant had agreed to produce the original
documents immediately after the receipt of Rs.10 lakhs of the advance amount?
c. Is there any breach of contract on the part of the first defendant?
Points a to c
12. Ex.A2 is the agreement of sale entered into between the plaintiffs and
the first defendant. On perusal of the agreement dated 21.07.2005, the first
defendant had agreed to sell the property for a total sale consideration of Rs.59
__________
Page16 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
lakhs and had received Rs. 10 lakhs as advance. The agreement further reveals
that the first plaintiff has agreed to purchase the 1/3rd undivided share of the
rd
suit property. The remaining share of 2/3 undivided share was agreed to be
purchased by the second plaintiff. It was also agreed between the parties that the
balance sale consideration of Rs.49 lakhs shall be paid within 90 days from the
date of signing the agreement. It was also agreed between the parties if the
purchaser fails to comply with any terms of the condition set out, the vendor has
the right to forfeit a sum of Rs 2 lakhs from the advance amount of Rs 10 lakhs
and return the balance amount of Rs 8 lakhs to the purchaser. The sale
agreement makes it very clear that the first plaintiff has agreed to purchase only
1/3rd undivided share of the suit property and the remaining 2/3rd undivided
was agreed to be purchased by the second plaintiff. In the entire sale agreement,
there is no mention whatsoever with regard to the mortgage loan or its clearance
or handing over the title deeds so as to pay the remaining balance sale
consideration. What has been agreed between the parties is that the vendor has
to furnish the encumbrance certificate till the date of sale for the perusal and
record of the purchasers.
13. The suit proceeded as if on the date of agreement, the first defendant
did not produce the original title deeds and first defendant informed the plaintiff
that the title deeds are lying with the bank and requested to clear the bank loan,
hence, the first defendant received Rs.10 lakhs as advance amount. As per the
__________
Page17 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
plaint averments, they never verified the title deeds while entering into the
contract, therefore, according to them, even after receipt of rupees Rs.10 lakh as
advance, the same has not been paid to the bank to redeem the mortgage by the
first defendant. Whereas the contention of the first defendant is that, apart from
the advance amount, it was specifically agreed between the parties that another
Rs.10 lakhs would be paid by the plaintiffs so as to clear the mortgage.
According to the first defendant, copy of the title deed and the nature of the
mortgage with the Bank of India is known to the plaintiffs even at the time of
agreement. Though plaintiff is totally silent about this fact, the power agent,
who is none other than the son of the first plaintiff, in his cross examination
dated 22.11.2016 has categorically admitted that xerox copies were shown to
them at the time of agreement and they were also informed that the originals are
in the bank. Further, he has feigned ignorance to the question to the effect that
whether the first defendant informed the plaintiffs what was the amount due and
the balance payable by first defendant; for which PW1 has stated that he does
not remember or recollect at this juncture. He has also admitted that he has not
filed any document to prove the financial status and though certain documents
have been filed, he has clearly admitted that under Ex.P9/the savings accounts
balance as on 15.07.2005 in his mother's account was Rs.15,431/- and in
December 2005, his mother’s bank balance in savings account was Rs.1,804/-
and further, as per Ex.P12/Postal savings account, there was only Rs.40,000/-
available which was closed on 04.02.2011. Furthermore, as per Exs.P14 and
__________
Page18 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
P13, the highest balance in both the accounts in November and December, 2005
was Rs.5,63,960/- as on 25/10/2005.
14. He has also admitted he does not know the nature of business income
of his brother-in-law namely the second plaintiff. The plaintiff has specifically
agreed to pay the remaining amount of Rs.40 lakhs within a period of 90 days
from the date of signing the agreement. First thing that he should establish
before the court is that whether he had the capacity to mobilize the remaining
sale consideration at the relevant point of time. (see: His Holiness Acharya
Swami Ganesh Dassji v. Sita Ram Thapar , (1996) 4 SCC 526). Though much
emphasis has been made that since the mortgage has not been redeemed within
the agreed period, therefore they could not pay the amount, it is specific
contention of the first defendant that apart from the Rs.10 lakhs, the plaintiff has
also agreed to pay another Rs.10 lakhs to clear the mortgage. It is relevant to
note that within the agreed time as per the documents filed by the plaintiff
namely the savings account and postal account, it would clearly show that the
first plaintiff did not have any sufficient income in her accounts. The second
plaintiff under Exs.P8, P20 and D8 has declared that he is not claiming any right
over the property and he has also admitted that he has not parted with any
amount, whereas the agreement indicates that he has agreed to purchase 2/3rd of
undivided share in the suit property. According to the plaintiffs, the second
plaintiff has relinquished his right under Exs.P8, P20 and D8. It is relevant to
note that any interest in the agreement, though it is transferable, it should be by
__________
Page19 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
way of assignment. Therefore, merely some declaration in the name of some
letter, valid assignment cannot be presumed. Be that as it may. When the second
plaintiff is intended to purchase the larger share of the property, namely 2/3rd
has not even established the source of his payment for purchase. The evidence
of PW1 indicates that her mother was a housewife at the relevant point of time,
and his further evidence also indicates that the very agreement was entered into
by the second plaintiff. These fact clearly shows that the plaintiffs was never
ready and willing to perform the part of the contract.
15. Even assuming that it is the duty of the vendor to clear the mortgage,
the person intending to purchase the suit property and having known about the
mortgage and mortgage money is only Rs.8 lakh at the relevant point of time; if
really the purchasers were intended to purchase the property in time, the normal
conduct would be to pay the remaining Rs.10 lakhs within the agreed period and
could have compelled the first defendant to discharge the mortgage. The
plaintiffs agreeing to complete the sale within a period of 90 days, no attempt
whatsoever was made by them except to issue the legal notice only on
26.02.2006. The period of 90 days expired on 20.10.2005 itself. Within the
agreed period, no attempts whatsoever was made by the plaintiffs even to show
that they were ready to purchase the property or clear the mortgage by paying
the amounts. No doubt, there is a clause in the agreement that the vendor has to
furnish the encumbrance certificate for the perusal and record of the purchaser.
That clearly shows that plaintiff was aware that there was an existing mortgage
__________
Page20 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
with the bank for Rs.10 lakhs. Therefore, merely because the advance amount
has not been utilized by the first defendant, that will not absolve the plaintiffs
from paying the remaining balance sale consideration or compel the first
defendant to redeem the mortgage. The plaintiffs have not taken any steps.
Having sent the legal notice under Ex.A3 on 26.02.2006, plaintiffs have
remained silent, whereas the first defendant has sent a reply under the Ex.A4
indicating that the second plaintiff has agreed to pay another Rs.10 lakhs by
way of letter dated 13.07.2005 which is marked as Exhibit D1. Ex.D1 clearly
shows that it was agreed between the parties that another Rs.10 lakhs will be
paid before the registration. If really, the plaintiffs had sufficient means and
intention to complete the transaction, having known about the existing mortgage
the plaintiffs ought to have taken steps to clear mortgage loan of below Rs.10
lakhs and redeem the original document which has not been done so. PW1
evidence also indicates that they were also aware of the mortgage at the earlier
point of time. PW1 has clearly admitted that his father was taken to the bank by
the first defendant to inspect the original title deeds.
16. It is relevant to note that the evidence of PW1 clearly shows that the
first defendant has told them that he is looking for alliance for his daughter.
Therefore he needed funds. However, he has not said about the SARFAESI Act
proceedings or about the auction. In this regard, Ex.D4/letter addressed by the
Bank of India 27.12.2025 is marked. When Ex.D4 carefully seen, it would
indicate that the bank has addressed the letter requesting the first respondent to
__________
Page21 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
make the payments immediately without any further delay, otherwise, they will
classify the accounts as NPA and action will be initiated under SARFAESI Act
for recovery of their dues. Though the first defendant has also entered
agreement for purchase of plot, it is the main contention of the first defendant
that he could not purchase the property since the sale consideration has not been
paid. Further, the marriage proposal of his daughter was also dropped. The first
defendant only in order to avoid the distress sale, he had to enter into sale with
some other third party. At any event, the documents relied upon by the plaintiffs
clearly show that the plaintiffs did not have any sufficient fund during the
agreement period to pay the remaining sale consideration. Though the second
plaintiff has also entered into agreement to purchase the 2/3rd undivided share
of the suit property without paying any amount as per the Ex.P20, according to
him, he is said to have nominated the first plaintiff and has given up his right in
the agreement and the evidence of PW1 clearly shows that he is not aware of
the nature of the transaction. Though the suit has been filed by the plaintiffs 1
and 2, none of them had entered into the box. When a person seeking equitable
relief, it is for them to come before the court and explain as to what has actually
transpired between them and the vendor. Whereas PW1/power agent of the
plaintiffs who has no direct knowledge about what has transpired between the
plaintiffs and the defendant, he is not the best person to substitute the evidence
of principal. (see: Janki Vashdeo Bhojwani v. IndusInd Bank Ltd. , (2005) 2
SCC 217; Man Kaur v. Hartar Singh Sangha , (2010) 10 SCC 512) .
__________
Page22 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
17. The above aspects clearly indicate that the plaintiff never intended to
purchase the property. The readiness and willingness have to sail together.
Readiness is the capacity to mobilize the fund and willingness is the mental
attitude. (see: Kalawati (D) through Lrs and Others vs. Rakesh Kumar and
Others (2018) 3 SCC 658; U.N. Krishnamurthy v. A.M. Krishnamurthy ,
2022 SCC OnLine SC 840). Only when both sail together, a person succeeds in
proving the readiness and willingness. When the ingredients has not been
established, the specific performance being an equitable remedy cannot be
granted to the plaintiffs.
18. It is further to be noted that the first defendant has shown that
hardship that has caused on him due to the non-payment of the remaining sale
consideration by the plaintiffs within a period of 90 days. As far as the
immovable property is concerned, though time is not an essence of contract,
(see: Chand Rani v. Kamal Rani , (1993) 1 SCC 519; K.S. Vidyanadam v.
Vairavan , (1997) 3 SCC 1) , but specific time agreed between the parties cannot
be ignored altogether. Further, forfeiture clause to forfeit Rs.2 lakhs of amount
as damages makes it very clear that, in fact, the parties have intended to make
the time as an essence of contract. Therefore, once the plaintiffs had agreed to
complete the sale within a period of 90 days by paying the entire balance sale
consideration and without performing their obligations as per the contract, now
the plaintiffs cannot contend that merely because mortgage is not redeemed,
they can seek specific performance. If only the plaintiffs had intended to
__________
Page23 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
purchase the property, they ought to have paid the remaining sale consideration
and get the original document. The evidence of PW1 itself clearly shows that
they were aware of the existing mortgage and they had also verified the
document in the bank. Even assuming that the initial advance amount has not
been paid and the mortgage has not been redeemed by the first defendant, the
plaintiffs ought to have paid the remaining Rs.10 lakhs within the period and
discharged the mortgage loan, however, the same has not been done so.
19. All these facts clearly shows that the plaintiff has not proved the
readiness and willingness. Though the defendant Nos.2 and 3 are the pendente
lite purchasers, such sale is not void, it is always subject to the result of the suit.
(see: Thomson Press (India) Ltd. v. Nanak Builders & Investors P. Ltd. ,
(2013) 5 SCC 397) . Merely because the purchase is made later during the
pendency of the suit, the plaintiffs as a matter of right cannot claim specific
performance without establishing the readiness and willingness. The defendants
evidence clearly establishes that due to the non-performance by the plaintiffs of
the contract, he has suffered hardship of his daughter marriage issues, further,
he could not purchase the plot, though he was intending to perform his part of
the contract. That apart, under Ex.D24, the bank has also taken coercive steps.
These facts clearly show that in fact only to avoid hardship, the first defendant
has entered into a further contract and, In fact, he has also tried to make
payment of rupees Rs.8 lakh after forfeiting Rs.2 lakh as damages. Such
payment is also refused by the plaintiff. PW1 has also admitted in his evidence
__________
Page24 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
that the payment of Rs.8 lakhs was returned on 09.12.2005 and the same was
refused by the mother/first plaintiff. Later, payment is also made by way of Pay
Order and that was also refused. All these facts clearly show the defendant in
fact was not taking any advantage of the amount. In fact, the first defendant
wanted to pay that amount to the plaintiffs.
20. The plaintiff has not proved readiness and willingness and never
entered into box. Neither the first plaintiff nor the second plaintiff have entered
into the box to confront this documents and they have conveniently remained
outside the court. All these facts clearly show that the plaintiffs are not entitled
to any relief of specific performance. Accordingly, these points are answered.
21. In view of the above, we are of the view that the learned Single Judge
has rightly dismissed the suit for specific performance and granted alternate
relief. Accordingly, the judgment and decree of the learned Single Judge dated
10.07.2023 stands confirmed and this original side appeal stands dismissed. No
costs. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition stands closed.
(N.S.K.,J.) (G.K.M.,J.)
20-11-2026
dhk
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Neutral Citation: Yes/No
__________
Page25 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )
OSA No. 69 of 2024
N.SATHISH KUMAR, J.
AND
GK.MUTHUKUMAAR, J.
dhk
OSA No. 69 of 2024
20-11-2026
__________
Page26 of 26
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis ( Uploaded on: 20/11/2026 03:59:22 pm )