NINGAPPA S/O ADIVEPPA SHIVANNI SINCE DEAD HIS LRS vs FAKIRAPPA S/O VEERABHADRAPPA MALANNAVAR SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD
TH
DATED THIS THE 16 DAY OF NOVEMBER 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI
WRIT PETITION NO.103804 OF 2024 (GM-CPC)
BETWEEN:
1.
NINGAPPA S/O. ADIVEPPA SHIVANNI
SINCE DEAD HIS LRs.
SMT. PARVATEWWA W/O. NINGAPPA SHIVANNI
AGE: 75 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. HEBBAL, TQ: NAVALAGUND,
DIST: DHARWAD-580001.
2. DEVAKKA W/O. TOPPANNA SHIVANNI
AGE: 55 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. BEDASUR, TQ: SAUNDATTI,
DIST: BELAGAVI-591126.
3. MANJUNATH S/O. NINGAPPA SHIVANNI
AGE: 53 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. HEBBAL, TQ: NAVALAGUND,
DIST: DHARWAD-580001.
4. HANAMANT S/O. ADIVEPPA SHIVANNI
AGE: 70 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
R/O. HEBBAL, TQ: NAVALAGUND,
DIST: DHARWAD-580001.
Digitally signed
by PRATIBHA
M PATIL
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
DHARWAD
BENCH
Date:
2026.11.17
14:29:48 +0530
…PETITIONERS
(BY SRI.K.ANAND KUMAR, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
FAKKIRAPPA S/O. VEERABHADRAPPA MALANNAVAR
SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRs.
SMT. NEELAWWA W/O. MUDEPPA KARIKATTI
AGE: 66 YEARS, OCC: HOUSEHOLD WORK,
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
R/O. HIREKUMBI, TQ: SAUNDATTI,
DIST: BELAGAVI-591126.
2. NINGAPPA S/O. FAKKIRAPPA MALANNAVAR
AGE: 55 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HEBBAL, TQ: NAVALAGUND,
DIST: DHARWAD-580001.
3. NIMBANNA S/O. FAKKIRAPPA MALANNAVAR
AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC: AGRICULTURE,
R/O. HEBBAL TQ: NAVALAGUND,
DIST: DHARWAD-580001.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.SANTOSH B.MALAGOUDAR, ADVOCATE)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT IN THE
NATURE OF CERTIORARI THEREBY QUASHING THE IMPUGNED
ORDER DATED 05-06-2024 PASSED BY THE PRL. CIVIL JUDGE AND
JMFC AT SAUNDATTI IN OS NO.179/2014 ON IA NO.16 FILED U/O 6
RULE 17 OF THE CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE, AS AT ANNEXURE F TO
THE WRIT PETITION, IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY
AND ETC.
THIS WRIT PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
ON 28.08.2026 COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDER THIS
DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM: HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE HEMA KULKARNI
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
CAV ORDER
The present writ petition is filed by the petitioners assailing
the order dated 05.06.2024 passed on I.A.No.16 under Order
VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1
1908 , in O.S.No.179/2014 by the Court of Principal Civil Judge
2
and JMFC, Saundatti , whereby the Trial Court allowed the said
application with costs.
2. For the sake of convenience and easy reference, the
parties will be referred to as per their respective rankings
before the Trial Court.
3. The brief facts, in a nutshell, leading to the filing of
the present petition are that the plaintiffs have filed a suit
seeking the relief of declaration against the defendants in
respect of the property bearing Bl.No.479/2A, measuring 04
acres 23 guntas, situated at Hanchinal Village, Saundatti
3
Taluk . It is the case of the plaintiffs that, on 31.07.1989,
defendant No.1 sold the suit property in favour of the plaintiffs
and executed a registered Sale Deed in their favour.
1
Hereinafter referred to as the ‘CPC’
2
Hereinafter referred to as the ‘Trial Court’
3
Hereinafter referred to as the ‘suit property’
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
Immediately after the registration of the Sale Deed, the
plaintiffs were put in possession of the suit property and have
been in peaceful possession and enjoyment thereof. However,
despite the execution and registration of the Sale Deed, the
concerned revenue authorities have not entered the name of
the plaintiffs in the revenue records, and the names of the
defendants continue to be reflected therein. The plaintiffs have
been regularly paying the taxes in respect of the suit property
without default. The defendants No.2 to 4 have illegally
attempted to interfere with and obstruct the plaintiffs’ peaceful
possession and enjoyment of the suit property. Hence, the
plaintiffs were constrained to file the suit against the
defendants seeking the relief of declaration and permanent
injunction in respect of the suit property. The defendant No.5
on service of summons has filed written statement refuting the
contentions raised in the plaint and defendants No.2 to 3 also
filed counter claim. That during the pendency of the suit
Sri. Fakkirappa Veerabhadrappa Malannavar (defendant No.1)
died on 24.11.2023 leaving behind defendant Nos.1(a), 2 and 3
as his legal heirs. After the death of the said Sri. Fakkirappa
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
Veerabhadrappa Malannavar, it has become difficult for
defendants No.2 to 4 for joint cultivation of the suit land and
hence have decided to effect partition in the suit property.
4. The defendant No.3, who is respondent No.3 herein,
filed I.A.No.16 under Order VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, seeking amendment of the
counter claim. The plaintiffs filed objections to the said
application. The said application reads as follows:
“APPLICATION UNDER ORDER VI RULE 17 R/W Sec. 151
OF CPC
Herein the application of the Advocate on behalf of the
Counter Claimant No.2 to 4 is as under.
That for the reason stated in the accompanying affidavit
of counter claimant No.4, the counter claimant No.2 to 4 may
kindly be permitted to make amendments of the pleading set
out in the counter claim. That the proposed amendments
prayed for the amendment of the pleadings of the counter
claim is as under.
That in the cause title of the counter claim Fakkirappa
Veerabhadrappa Malannavar is described as Counter claimant
No.1 and he is dead on 24.11.2023 leaving behind him
Counter claimant No.2 to 4 as his only class-I legal heirs.
Hence the name of above said Counter claimant No.1
Fakkirappa Veerabhadrappa
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
Malannavar may be allowed to be deleted from the cause title
of the counter claim.
That at Para No.5 of counter claim it be added as
under.
In front of the word be dismissed in the last line of Para
No.5 other sentences stated as under may be added.
"That counter claimant No.1 Fakkirappa Veerabhadrappa
Malannavar expired on 24.11.2023, leaving behind him
counter claimant No.2 to 4 as his legal class-I heirs. That after
the death of Counter claimant No.1 it has became difficult for
the joint cultivation of suit property amongst themselves due
to woman folk and dispute etc., counter claimants No.2 to 4
have decided effect partition in the suit property in respect of
rd
their 1/3 share each. Hence the cause of action to effect
partition has arosen, after the death of counter claimant No.1
and the same is continued till today" may be added as stated
above.
That in the cause title of the counter claim the amount of
Rs.1,000/- may be deleted and in that place an amount of
Rs.1096/- may be substituted and added. That in front of the
word and the word FOR BE ADDED AND in front of the word
JURISDICTION RS.4,50,000/- may be added.
That in Para No.9 of the plaint in Court Fee and
Jurisdiction column in front of the word SECTION 26(B) the
word "SECTION 7(2) AND SECTION 35(2)" be added and
in place of the figure Rs.1,000/- be deleted and in that place
Rs.1096/- be added and in front of the word AND the word
FOR BE ADDED and in front of the word Jurisdiction the figure
RS.4,50,000/- be added and in the same sentence the "Court
Fee of Rs.200/- is paid herewith" be added.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
That in the prayer column of the plaint below prayer
column A, another prayer may be added as under.
AA) It is humbly prayed that the counter claimant No.2 to 4
rd rd
are entitled for 1/3 share each and 3/3 share together in
the suit property bearing Bl.No.479/2A measuring 04 acre 28
Gs and the decree be passed by effecting partition by metes
and bounds and separate possession be handed over.
AB) That necessary direction be given to the concerned
authority for effecting partition in respect of suit property
under Sec. 54 of CPC.”
5. After hearing both sides, the Trial Court allowed
I.A.No.16 filed by the applicant, subject to payment of cost of
Rs.5,000/-. The relevant portion of the impugned order reads
as under:
“10. After going through the contents of affidavit of IA
and also after hearing the arguments of both sides on
IA, I have gone through the Order VI Rule 17 of
C.P.C., which reads as under :-
“ 17.Amendments of Pleadings: The Court
may at any stage of the proceedings allow either
party to alter or amend his pleadings in such
manner and on such terms as may be just, and all
such amendments shall be made as may be
necessary for the purpose of determining the real
questions in controversy between the parties:
Provided that no application for amendment
shall be allowed after the trial has commenced,
unless the Court comes to the conclusion that in
spite of due diligence, the party could not have
raised the matter before the commencement of
trial."
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
11. On careful scrutiny of the above said provisions of
law, it is crystal clear that the Court may, at any
stage of the proceedings, allow either of the parties to
alter or amend his pleadings provided such
amendment is just and necessary for the purpose of
determining the real questions in controversies
between the parties. Therefore, in the instant case,
the counter claim filed by the counter claimants for
the declaration, it is the specific contention of the
applicant that, the proposed amendment is necessary
for effective adjudication of the suit.
12. I have meticulously gone through the application
contents and the objections filed thereto. Ld., counsel
for the plaintiffs has relied upon the ratio held in the
following decisions:-
1. BASAVARAJ v. INDIRA AND OTHERS [SC - CIVIL
APPEAL NO.2886 OF 2012] , wherein it has been
held that,
"All what was pleaded was oversight. The
same cannot be accepted as a ground to allow any
amendment in the pleadings at the fag end of the
trial especially when admittedly the facts were in
knowledge of the respondents No.1 and
2/plaintiffs", the Bench held while also adding,
"Initially, the suit was filed for partition and
separate possession. By way of amendment, relief
of declaration of the compromise decree being null
and void was also sought. The same would
certainly change the nature of the suit, which may
be impermissible".
2. SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
KENCHEGOWDA (SINCE DECEASED) BY LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES – Appellant
V.
SIDDEGOWDA ALIAS MOTEGOWDA – Respondent
Civil Appeal No's.4347-48 of 1994
Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (CPC) - Order 6 Rule
17
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
"Civil Procedure Cod, 1908 (CPC) Order 6 Rule 17-
Partition of the suit property - Respondent filed two
suits bearing OS No.346 and 347 of 1974 before
the learned Munsiff at Mandy for declaration of his
title and permanent injunction - Plaintiff came to
file an application under order 6 Rule 17 CPC it
would not mean it could be allowed and a
preliminary decree for partition be passed -
Learned counsel for the respondent would submit
that once the property was held to be joint family
property the relationship between the parties
having been admitted there could be no
impediment in passing the preliminary decree for
partition – A suit for partial partition in the absence
of the inclusion of other joint family properties and
the impleadment of the other co-sharers was not
warranted in law. Court find no difficult in allowing
these appeals which are accordingly allowed".
3. SUPREME COURT OF INDIA DIVISION BENCH
REVAJEETU BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS -
Appellant
Vs.
NARAYANASWAMY AND SONS AND OTHERS –
Respondent
"The High Court in the impugned judgment
also held that any such amendment which changes
the entire character of the plaint cannot be
permitted and that too after a lapse of four years
after the institution of the suit. The High Court has
set aside the order of the trial court which allowed
the amendment under Order VI Rule 17 CPC.".
FACTORS TO BE TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION
WHILE DEALING WITH AMENDMENTS:
APPLICATIONS FOR AMENDMENTS:
67. On critically analyzing both the English and Indian
cases, some basic principles emerge which ought to be
taken into consideration while allowing or rejecting the
application for amendment.
(1) Whether the amendment sought is imperative for proper
and effective adjudication of the case?
(2) Whether the application for amendment is bona fide or
mala fide?
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
(3) The amendment should not cause such prejudice to the
other side which cannot be compensated adequately in
terms of money;
(4) Refusing amendment would in fact lead to injustice or lead
to multi-ple litigation;
(5) Whether the proposed amendment constitutionally or
fundamentally changes the nature and character of the
case? And
(6) As a general rule, the court should decline amendments if
a fresh suit on the amended claims would be barred by
limitation on the date of application.
68. These are some of the important factors which
may be kept in mind while dealing with application
filed under Order VI Rule 17. These are only
illustrative and not exhaustive.
69. The decision on an application made under Order
VI Rule 17 is a very serious judicial exercise and the
said exercise should never be undertaken in a casual
manner.
70. We can conclude our discussion by observing that
while deciding applications for amendments the courts
must not refuse bona fide, legitimate, honest and
necessary amendments and should never permit mala
fide, worthless and/or dishonest amendments.
13. On perusal of the first decision, it is evident that, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has spoken about
amendment sought after lapse of almost five years in a
suit for partition, despite specific contention of the
defendants in their written statement that, the suit was
not maintainable without seeking for the relief of
cancellation of compromise decree, wherein in the
Hon'ble court has held the proposed amendment would
change the nature of the suit and as such not
permissible in law. Hence, the context in which the ratio
was set out in the said case, is entirely different and
would not squarely fit in the facts circumstances of this
case.
14. Coming to the next decision relied upon, the Hon'ble
Supreme court of India, has clearly indicated that, a
decree for partition could not have been passed as
smaller relief on mere application for amendment, in a
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
suit for declaration and injunction, which are larger
reliefs. On going through the entire decision submitted
by the Ld., counsel, it is learnt that, the Hon'ble court
had arrived to such a decision observing that, Hon'ble
High Court of Karnataka was incorrect in allowing such a
amendment, when all the joint family properties were
not made the subject matter of the suit nor were all the
co-sharers impleaded in the suit. In this background, the
Hon'ble court had allowed the appeals filed by the
appellants, thereby holding that, the amendment for
partition in a suit for declaration and injunction,
permitted by Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka was
incorrect.
15. So far as the last decision relied upon by the
plaintiffs counsel is concerned, the Hon'ble Supreme
Court of India has laid down certain parameters to be
considered before passing orders on amendment
application. With due respect to the guidelines laid down
therein, I propose to hold that, this court has been
mindful of the principles as enunciated therein and the
same shall be critically analyzed before arriving at any
decision with respect to the instant application.
16. On perusal of the instant application, the
amendment sought for, in my opinion, does not change
the nature of suit, or introduce new cause of action or
either call for any inconvenience or hardship to the
opponents. It may be true that, at this belated stage,
the court shall not reopen the case for any proceedings,
but all circumstances should not be weighed on the
same scale, when the facts and circumstances of each
case are distinct from one another. It has been held by
Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka in Leela Devi & Ors
V/s Narayan & Ors at para No. 9-.
"The supreme court in K.K.Veluswamy,
has observed very clearly that convention of
not entertaining any application once the
case is reserved for Judgment is a sound
rule, but it is not a straight jacket formula
what the Supreme Court has held in this
content is extracted here:-
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
"13. The Ld., counsel for respondent
contended that once arguments are commenced,
there could be no re-opening of evidence of
recalling of any witness. This contention is raised
by extending the convention that once arguments
are concluded and the case is reserved for
judgment, the court will not entertain any
interlocutory application for any kind of relief. The
need for the court to act in a manner to achieve
the ends of justice (subject to the need to comply
with the law) does not end when arguments are
heard and judgment is reserved. If there is abuse
of the process of the court, or if interests of
justice require the court to do something or take
note of something, the discretion to do those
things does not disappear merely because the
arguments are heard, either fully or partly. The
convention that no application should be
entertained once the trial or hearing is concluded
and the case is reserved for judgment is a sound
rule, but not a straitjacket formula. There can
always be exceptions in exceptional or extra-
ordinary circumstances, to meet the ends of
justice and to prevent abuse of process of court,
subject to the limitation recognized with
reference to exercise of power under section 151
of the code".
17. Hence, in the background of the observations made
by Hon'ble Apex Court of India in K.K.Veluswamy's case
and Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka in Leela Devi's
case, this court has embraced the reasons putforth by
the applicants and we find no delay tactics on the part of
the applicant, so as to cause abuse of court process. The
interest of Justice requires this court to take note of the
proposed amendment requirement. The proposed
amendment with respect to new relief sought is
absolutely required to meet the ends of Justice, to
prevent the counter claim from being defeated due to
formal defect, which will jeopardize the rights of the
counter claimants available if any. Moreover, the
proposed amendment is well within time or not is a
mixed question of law and fact and already sufficient
evidence has been lead on the same and hence
absolutely there is no hurdle to allow the said application
for the aforestated reasons and the said question shall
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
be considered on merits at the time of giving final
adjudication.
18. It is also true that the proposed amendment is
necessary for proper adjudication of the suit and counter
claim, without which there are all probabilities of the
counter claim failing for defective and insufficient
pleadings. Mere amending prayer in the counter claim
would not entitle the counter claimants to the relief
unless the court is satisfied with cogent evidence on
record to grant relief in that respect as sought for. The
proposed amendment with regard to share is necessary
for proper entitlement and additional relief sought is also
necessary to be inserted to support the maintainability
of the counter claim in view of the requirement under
law as asserted in the application. In order to seek for
amendment at this fag end of this suit, the applicant has
to make out sufficient grounds that, despite exercising
due diligence the plaintiffs could not have brought the
proposed amendment as on the date of filing the suit. In
this case, the applicant has not at all whispered a single
word that, after exercising due diligence also the
plaintiffs could not have brought the proposed
amendment even prior to the commencement of
evidence, since the cause of action for seeking the relief
sought for has not arose as on the date of the death of
defendant No.1 and the same was existing during the
life time of defendant No.1 U/sec. 6 of Hindu Succession
Act, 1956, eventhough the cause of action for the relief
sought for U/sec.8 of Hindu Succession Act has arose as
averred by the counter claimants in the instant
application. But anyhow the proposed amendment is
necessary to be added in the counter claim for the
purpose of proper adjudication of the counter claim and
to mitigate the risk of counter claim being dismissed for
non maintainability, owing to failure to bring the
proposed amendment, when the pleadings in the
counter claim are in consonence with the freshly sought
relief, but due to some sort of inadvertance on the part
of the parties in seeking for the relief at the very intial
stage, it should not defeat the cause of the counter
claim. The delay caused in filing this application
definitely calls for imposing reasonable costs for having
failed to bring the necessary amendment well in
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
advance. But, merely because there has been delay in
filing the said application should not curtail the rights of
the counter claimants available if any, to seek for
necessary amendment, for proper adjudication of
counter claim. An application for amendment should be
considered liberally is the rule of law. Moreover the
proposed amendment would not change the basic
structure of the suit or introduce a new case of action,
so as to defy the case of the opponents as submitted by
the Ld., plaintiffs counsel. Hence, in my opinion, the said
application deserves attention of this court, in view
natural justice and equity and in order to mitigate the
risk of miscarriage of Justice. Therefore, I answer this
point in the affirmative.
19. Point No.2: In the light of the above
discussion, I proceed to pass the following:-
::ORDER::
IA No.16 filed by the applicant/counter
claimant No.4 Ulo VI Rule 17 R/w Sec.151
C.P.C., is hereby allowed with cost of Rs.5,000/-.
The applicant is hereby permitted to amend
the counter claim as prayed in IA No.16.
The applicant is also hereby directed to
carryout amendment in the counter claim and to
furnish the amended counter claim by 06-06-
2024.”
6. Being aggrieved by the said order, the
petitioners/plaintiffs have preferred the present writ petition.
7. Learned counsel Sri. K. Anandkumar appearing for the
petitioners/plaintiffs contended that there is a delay of nearly
nine years in filing the application seeking amendment of the
counter claim and, therefore, the same ought not to have been
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
permitted by the Trial Court. It is further contended that
counter claimant No.2 has no right to seek partition in respect
of the property which had already been allotted. It is also
further contended that the claim sought to be introduced by
counter claimants No.3 and 4 is barred by limitation.
8. Learned counsel for the petitioners further contended
that the amendment sought for is belated and would materially
alter the nature and character of the counter claim. According
to the petitioners, the proposed amendment seeks to introduce
a new claim and a fresh cause of action, which could not have
been permitted at this stage of the proceedings, despite
defendant No.3 not pleading and establishing due diligence as
said in plethora of Apex Court judgments of Co-ordinate
Benches. It was therefore submitted that the Trial Court has
committed an error in allowing I.A.No.16. Hence, learned
counsel for the petitioners prays to allow the petition and the
impugned order passed by the Trial Court be quashed.
9. Learned counsel for the petitioners places reliance on
the following judgments:
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
i) Basavanneappa Malleshappa Nandgad
vs. Smt. Sunanda Mahabaleshwar
4
Nandgad and Another ;
ii) Pandit Malhari Mahale vs. Monika
5
Pandit Mahale and Others .
10. Per contra, learned counsel Sri. Santosh B.
Malagoudar appearing for the respondents/counter claimants
supported the impugned order passed by the Trial Court. The
amendment is sought only for the purpose of bringing the
pleadings on record in their proper and complete form and for
effectively adjudicating the real controversy between the
parties. It is further contended that the questions relating to
limitation, entitlement to partition and the rights of the
respective parties are matters to be adjudicated on the basis of
the pleadings and evidence and cannot be conclusively
determined at the stage of considering an application under
Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC. Hence, learned counsel for the
respondents placing reliance on the judgment of
4
W.P.No.107506/2025, decided on 23.03.2026
5
Civil Appeal No.189/2020 [Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s).5888/2019
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
Mohammadrafi S/o. Mehabubsab and Another vs.
6
Bandenawaz and Others , seeks for dismissal of the petition.
11. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners and
learned counsel for the respondents. Perused the material
available on record.
12. The application for amendment of the counter claim
cannot be called belated, and the applicants/defendants cannot
be accused of lacking due diligence. Since the amendment
arose entirely from a development during the pendency of the
suit. Counter Claimant No.1, Sri Fakkirappa Veerabadrappa
Malannavar, died on 24.11.2023, leaving behind Counter
Claimant Nos.2 to 4 as his Class-I legal heirs. Before his death
there was no occasion for the defendants to seek the proposed
amendment. The need for it arose only on his death. The
proviso to Order VI Rule 17 CPC is therefore no bar. Despite
due diligence, the defendants could not have raised the matter
before trial commenced.
6
W.P.No.108512/2025, dated 16.12.2025
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
13. The pleadings in the counter claim are in consonance
with the relief sought by way of the proposed amendment. The
omission to seek the said relief at the initial stage appears to
have occurred due to inadvertence and, therefore, such
inadvertence ought not to defeat the substantive rights of the
defendants in the counter claim. The delay, if any, can be
compensated by imposing reasonable costs. The same has
been done by the Trial Court by imposing cost of Rs.5,000/-
payable by defendant No.3. Merely because there has been
some delay, the defendants' right to seek the relief by way of
counter claim cannot be curtailed.
14. Moreover, the proposed amendment neither alters the
basic structure of the suit nor introduces a new cause of action.
Therefore, allowing the application for amendment cannot be
said to be improper or erroneous.
15. The Trial Court, having considered all these aspects,
has allowed the application seeking amendment of the counter
claim. The Trial Court has passed a detailed and reasoned
order. Hence, there are no sufficient grounds warranting
interference with the order passed by the Trial Court.
- 19 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18744
WP No. 103804 of 2024
CNR: KAHC020112852024
16. Hence, I pass the following:
ORDER
a) The writ petition stands dismissed .
b) The order dated 05.06.2024 passed on
I.A.No.16 under Order VI Rule 17 read with
Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908, in O.S.No.179/2014 by the Court of
Principal Civil Judge and JMFC, Saundatti, is
confirmed.
In view of the dismissal of the petition,
pending IAs’, if any, stand dismissed.
Sd/-
(HEMA KULKARNI)
JUDGE
PMP
CT:VH
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 2