Parveen Kumar vs Mahaveer Sangwan

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

RSA-2403 -2026 (O&M) -1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
149 RSA-2403-2026 (O&M)
Date of decision: 13.11.2026
Parveen Kumar
....Appellant
Vs.
Mahaveer Sangwan
....Respondent
CORAM : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER
Present: Mr. Sumit Sangwan, Advocate
for the appellant.
*
HARSH BUNGER J.
1. For convenience, the parties herein are being addressed as per
their status in the original suit.
2. This is the defendants' second appeal challenging the judgment
and decree dated 13.02.2026 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Charkhi Dadri, as well as the judgment and decree dated
26.05.2026 passed by the learned District Judge, Charkhi Dadri.
3. The plaintiff (Mahaveer Sangwan) filed a suit for recovery
against the defendant (Praveen Kumar), claiming Rs.5,44,000/- (principal
amount Rs.3,20,000/- + interest amount Rs.2,24,000/-) along with pendente
lite and future interest.
3.1 The aforesaid suit for recovery was filed by the plaintiff on the
plea that the defendant had borrowed Rs.3,20,000/- from the plaintiff on
12.10.2017 for domestic expenses at the rate of interest i.e. Rs. 2/- per
hundred per month. According to the plaintiff, the defendant agreed to repay
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2403 -2026 (O&M) -2-
the said amount in one year along with interest, and in this regard, the
defendant executed one bahi (tehrir) in favor of the plaintiff.
3.2 It is the pleaded case of the plaintiff that after admitting the
contents of the bahi , the defendant had signed thereon in Hindi after affixing
revenue ticket on the same. According to the plaintiff, he requested the
defendant many times to return the amount along with interest; however, the
defendant did not pay any amount, whereupon the plaintiff sent a legal
notice dated 11.08.2020 to the defendant through his Advocate. However,
even then, the defendant did not pay any amount. Accordingly, the suit was
filed.
4. Upon notice being issued in the suit, the defendant appeared
and opposed the claim of the plaintiff by filing his written statement,
wherein he denied that he had borrowed Rs. 3,20,000/- on 12.10.2017 at the
rate of Rs. 2/- per hundred per month from the plaintiff. The defendant
further denied executing any tehrir / bahi . The defendant claimed that the
bahi was forged and fabricated and that he was not bound by the same. The
other averments of the plaint were denied, and prayer for dismissal of the
suit was made.
5. The plaintiff filed his replication to the written statement filed
by the defendant.
6. From the pleading of the parties, following issues were framed
by the learned Trial Court:-
“1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to decree for recovery of Rs.
5,44,000/- along with interest, pendente lite and future
interest @ 12% per annum against the defendant? OPP
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2403 -2026 (O&M) -3-
2. Whether the plaintiff has no locus standi and cause of
action to file present suit? OPD
3. Whether present suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable in
present form? OPD
4. Whether the plaintiff is running business of money lending
without a valid license? OPD
5. Whether the plaintiff has not affixed proper Court fee?
OPD
6. Whether the plaintiff has not approached the Court with
clean hands and suppressed true and material facts? OPD
7. Relief?”
7. Thereafter, the parties led their respective evidence on the
aforesaid issues.
8. The learned Trial Court vide judgment and decree dated
13.02.2026, decreed the suit of the plaintiff by holding the plaintiff to be
legally entitled to recover Rs. 5,44,000/- from the defendant. The learned
Trial Court further granted pendente lite and future interest at the rate of 6%
per annum on the principal sum of Rs. 3,20,000/-.
9. Feeling aggrieved against the learned Trial Court’s judgment
and decree, the defendant preferred an appeal before the learned District
Judge, Charkhi Dadri, which has also been dismissed vide judgment and
decree dated 26.05.2026.
10. In the aforementioned circumstances, present regular second
appeal has been filed before this Court.
11. I have heard the learned counsel for the appellant and perused
the paperbook with his able assistance.
12. In the present case, the plaintiff filed a suit for recovery of
Rs.5,44,000/-, on the plea that the defendant had borrowed Rs.3,20,000/-
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2403 -2026 (O&M) -4-
from the plaintiff on 12.10.2017 at interest at the rate of Rs. 2/- per hundred
per month, and in this regard, the defendant had executed one bahi in favor
of the plaintiff, which was duly signed by the defendant in Hindi after
affixing revenue ticket thereon.
12.1 On the other hand, the defendant denied that he borrowed any
amount from the plaintiff. He further denied execution of any tehrir or bahi
by maintaining that the bahi was forged and fabricated.
13. The learned Trial Court, upon appreciation of the evidence on
record, under issue No. 1, held that the plaintiff has proved the due execution
of the bahi dated 12.10.2017 and also the borrowing of the amount of
Rs.3,20,000/- at the rate of interest of 2% per month. The relevant extract of
the findings reads as under:-
“20. In order to prove his case, the plaintiff has examined
PW1 Satyabir witness to the Bahi dated 12.10.2017 who
testified that defendant had borrowed Rs. 3,20,000/- from
the plaintiff on 12.10.2017 at the rate of Rs. 2 per
hundred per month from the plaintiff in front of him. He
also stated that in this regard one Bahi was executed on
which the defendant had signed in front of him. The
witness also identified his own signatures on the Bahi.
Further, the plaintiff has also examined himself as PW-2
wherein he reiterated the version of his plaint. The
plaintiff also proved the bahi dated 12.10.2017 and the
legal notice Ex. P2 and postal receipt Ex. P3.
21. Hence, with the abovementioned documentary and oral
evidence this court is of the view that the plaintiff had
proved that the defendant Parveen Kumar had borrowed
Rs. 3,20,000/- from the plaintiff on 12.10.2017, at the
rate of interest @2% per month and in this regard Bahi
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2403 -2026 (O&M) -5-
dated 12.10.2017 was executed on which the defendant
Parveen Kumar had signed in the presence of witness
Satyavir.
22. When once the plaintiff had proved that the defendant
had borrowed Rs. 3,20,000/- on 12.10.2017 and the Ex,
P1 Bahi/Tehrir was duly executed, the onus had shifted
on the defendant to prove that the said amount of Rs.
3,20,000/- was not borrowed and the tehrir dated
12.10.2017 to be false and fabricated. However, in order
to prove his case, the defendant has examined himself as
DW1 wherein he barely reiterated the version of his
written statement. There is nothing on record to
substantiate Ex. P1 bahi to be forged and fabricated.
23. Though he also tendered one sale deed no. 2494 dated
30.08.2013 however this court is of the view that the said
evidence tendered by the defendant is beyond his
pleadings as there was no mention of the payment to be
given with regard to any sale deed rather in the written
statement it has been averred by the defendant that the
Bahi to be forged and fabricated. The defendant hence
has led no cogent evidence oral or otherwise to prove
that the Bahi dated 12.10.2017 is a forged and fabricated
document.
24. In light of the above, this court is of the view that the
defendant has failed to prove the Bahi to be forged and
fabricated document and that no amount was borrowed
by the defendant from the plaintiff. The plaintiff on the
other hand proved the due execution of Bahi dated
12.10.2017 and the borrowing of the amount of Rs.
3,20,000/-at the rate of interest of Rs.2% per month. It
has been proved that the borrowed amount has been
outstanding from the defendant. Hence, the issue no.1
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2403 -2026 (O&M) -6-
same is decided in favour of the plaintiff and against the
defendant.”
13.1 The aforesaid findings returned by the learned Trial Court have
been further affirmed by the learned First Appellate Court.
14. Before this Court, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
has raised primarily only one submission that the findings returned by the
learned Court below on issue No. 4 is incorrect, as the plaintiff had failed to
prove that he had any license for carrying on the business of money lending.
15. I have considered the aforesaid contention raised on behalf of
the appellant. However, suffice it to say that a similar contention was raised
by the appellant before the learned First Appellate Court as well, and the
same has been duly considered and rejected by observing as under:
“19. So far as the contention of the appellant that the plaintiff
was not possessing any money lending license is concerned, the
same is devoid of merit. The evidence on record clearly
establishes that the transaction in question was a friendly loan
advanced for domestic needs and not a commercial money
lending transaction carried out in ordinary course of business.
Merely because there were 3-4 earlier entries in the Bahi would
not ipso facto prove that the plaintiff was carrying on the
business of money lending requiring licence under law. It has
been held by Hon'ble Punjab & Haryana High Court in
"Angrej Singh Versus Vijay Kumar" RSA No.1439 of 2018
(O&M), decided on 16.10.2018 , that "the mere fact that Vijay
Kumar had given money to 3-4 persons but without proving
terms and conditions of said transactions, it is difficult to
accept contention of the appellant that Vijay Kumar is doing the
business of money lending, thus, has incurred disability to
maintain a suit for recovery without possessing money lenders
licence. In this view of the matter, contention of the appellant
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2403 -2026 (O&M) -7-
that suit for recovery filed by Vijay Kumar is liable to be
dismissed for want of money lenders licence, is not tenable".
20. The appellant/defendant also sought to rely upon certain
photocopies of alleged Bahi entries marked as Mark-A1 to
Mark-A47. However, admittedly the said documents were
merely photocopies and were never proved in accordance with
law as it is a settled principle of law that photocopy of a
document cannot be read into evidence. In this regard this court
is guided by M/s Arati Bhargava Versus Kavi Kumar
Bhargava (Deceased) through LRs 1999 (3) Civil Court Cases
377 and Rashid Khan and another Versus State of Madhya
Pradesh and others 2011 (8) RCR (Civil) 417 . Further, it is
also worth mentioning that mere exhibiting a document does
not dispense with its proof. In this regard this court is guided by
Mohinder Singh Versus Krishan Lal and other 2009 (2) RCR
(Civil) 642 and Smt.Kashmir Kaur and other Versus Joginder
Singh and another 2010 (4) ICC 339 . As such, documents i.e.
Mark-A1 to Mark-A47 being photocopy cannot be read into
evidence. The learned trial Court rightly held that the same
cannot be read into evidence.”
16. Before this Court, learned counsel for the appellant could not
dispute the fact that in order to prove issue No. 4, he has only relied upon the
photocopies of the alleged bahi entries marked as Mark A-1 to Mark A-47.
17. In the attending circumstances, this Court has no reason to
differ with the findings returned by the learned First Appellate Court on
issue No. 4, as the appellant has failed to produce legally admissible
documents in support of such plea.
18. Learned counsel for the appellant has failed to show as to how
the findings returned by the learned courts below are either illegal or
perverse or based upon any misreading or misappreciation of material
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2403 -2026 (O&M) -8-
evidence. Apparently there are concurrent findings of fact returned by
learned Courts below.
19. Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Law Finder Doc Id #
2034559 - M/s Shivali Enterprises v. Godawari (Deceased) (SC); has held
as under:-
"14. This Court, in the case of (2019) 17 SCC 71- Randhir
Kaur v. Prithvi Pal Singh and Others , after considering the
scope of interference under the old section 100 of the Civil
Procedure Code, 1908 (for short "CPC") and Section 41 of the
Punjab Act, has observed thus:
"15. A perusal of the aforesaid judgments would show
that the jurisdiction in second appeal is not to interfere
with the findings of fact on the ground that findings are
erroneous, however, gross or inexcusable the error may
seem to be. The findings of fact will also include the
findings on the basis of documentary evidence. The
jurisdiction to interfere in the second appeal is only
where there is an error in law or procedure and not
merely an error on a question of fact."
15. It could thus be seen that this Court has held that, even
when a court exercises jurisdiction under Section 41 of the
Punjab Act, it cannot interfere with the findings of fact in
second appeal on the ground that the said findings are
erroneous, howsoever gross or inexcusable the error may seem
to be. It has been held that the findings of fact would also
include the findings on the basis of documentary evidence. The
jurisdiction under Section 41 of the Punjab Act would be
available only when there is a substantial error or defect in the
procedure provided by the CPC or by any other law for the time
being in force."
(Emphasis added)"
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh

RSA-2403 -2026 (O&M) -9-
20. In view of the discussion above, no ground is made out to
interfere in the impugned judgments and decrees passed by the learned Trial
Court and the learned First Appellate Court and the present Regular Second
Appeal is hereby dismissed .
21. All the pending application(s), if any, shall also stand closed.
(HARSH BUNGER)
13.11.2026 JUDGE
Ankit
Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No
ANKIT
2026.11.17 11:19
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Chandigarh