BIJAYALAXMI DAS vs STATE OF ODISHA
- Court
- Odisha High Court
CRLREV/299/2026
ODHC010292512026
2026:OHC:308
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
CRLREV NO.299 of 2026
CNR No. ODHC010292512026
(An application U/S.397 of CrPC r/w Sec.401 of CrPC
& Sec.438 of BNSS)
Smt. Bijayalaxmi Das Petitioner
….
-versus-
State of Odisha & Another Opposite Parties
….
For Petitioner : Mr. A. Mohanty, Sr. Advocate
along with Ms. S. Patnaik,
Advocate
For Opposite
Parties
: Mr. A. Pradhan, Addl. PP
Mr. J.K. Panda, Advocate (OP-2)
CORAM:
JUSTICE G. SATAPATHY
DATE OF HEARING: 22.09.2026
DATE OF JUDGMENT:19.11.2026
G. Satapathy, J.
1
. This is an application U/S.438 of BNSS r/w
Sec.442 of BNSS (397/401 of CrPC) by the petitioner-
accused seeking inter-alia to challenge the impugned
order dated 16.03.2026 passed by the learned JMFC-II,
(Cog. Taking), Cuttack in GR Case No.751 of 2023
refusing to discharge the accused-petitioner from this
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
1 16
Page of
case for commission of offence punishable U/Ss.294/323/
341/406 & 506 of IPC in an application U/S.262 of BNSS/
Sec.239 of CrPC.
2.
The short facts, bereft unnecessary details
are that the complainant-Suryamani Tripathy who was
working as a Sr. Grade Typist in the office of the
Directorate Technical Education & Training Odisha,
Buxibazar, Cuttack had cordial relationship with the
accused-petitioner-Bijayalaxmi Das, an Asst. Prof. of
Revenshaw University, but the complainant was arrested
in connection with EOW PS Case No.14 of 2021,
however, the present accused-petitioner met the
complainant in the Jail and gave false assurance to him
as well as his family members for getting him released
from custody by influencing the Judge. The accused-
petitioner had further impressed upon the complainant
by convincing him that the DSP, EOW is the husband of
one of her relations and she would approach the said DSP
to submit the charge-sheet by deleting the major
offences. Accordingly, the accused-petitioner asked for
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
2 16
Page of
Rs.11lakhs from the complainant for obtaining bail order
from the High Court. Believing the false representation of
the accused-petitioner, the wife of the complainant paid a
cash of Rs.11lakhs to the accused-petitioner on
18.11.2021 near Barabati Stadium and the accused-
petitioner had handed over a money receipt to the wife of
the complainant by executing it on a non-judicial stamp
paper.
2.1.
When the bail application of the complainant
in BLAPL No.10558 of 2021 was listed before the High
Court for hearing, the same was transferred to another
Bench, and thereby, the wife of the complainant asked
the accused-petitioner the reason for transfer of the bail
application, but the accused-petitioner got enraged and
abused her in slang language and the wife of the
complainant accordingly, demanded the accused-
petitioner to return the aforesaid amount of Rs.11lakhs.
When the accused-petitioner did not return the aforesaid
sum of Rs.11lakhs, the complainant after being released
from custody lodged a report on 26.05.2023 before the
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
3 16
Page of
IIC, Cantonment PS, who did not take any action against
the accused-petitioner and thereby, the complainant
approached the Court with a complaint which was sent to
the local Police Station U/S.156(3) of CrPC resulting in
registration of Cantonment PS Case No.117 of 2023 with
commencement of investigation which ultimately resulted
in submission of charge-sheet against the accused-
petitioner and thereafter, finding prima facie materials,
the learned JMFC-II (CT), Cuttack took cognizance of
offences and proceeded in the matter after rejecting the
discharge petition of the accused-petitioner by framing
charge against her for commission of offence
U/Ss.341/323/294/406/506 of IPC resulting in trial in the
present case with examination of one witness in the
meantime.
3.
Heard, Mr. Ashok Kumar Mohanty learned Sr.
counsel who is being assisted by Ms. Soma Patnaik,
learned counsel for the revision petitioner; Mr. Amitav
Pradhan, learned Addl. PP and Mr. Jugal Kishore Panda,
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
4 16
Page of
learned counsel for OP No.2 in the matter and perused
the record.
4.
On consideration of the settled position of law
governing the scope for dealing an application for
discharge U/S.262 of BNSS (239 of CrPC) vis-à-vis the
revisional jurisdiction of this Court U/S.438 read with
Section 442 of BNSS (397/401 of CrPC), undeniably at
the stage of considering an application for discharge, the
trial Court is not expected to conduct a mini-trial or
weigh the pros and cons of the prosecution materials as
if it were passing a final judgment of acquittal or
conviction, but at the same time, if, upon consideration
of police report and the documents submitted therewith
U/S.193 of BNSS, the learned Magistrate finds that there
is a strong suspicion as distinguished from mere
suspicion against the accused for presuming that the
accused has committed the offence(s), the Court would
be fully justified in refusing to discharge the accused by
framing charge against him/her. It is also well clarified by
the law that at this stage of framing of charge, the
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
5 16
Page of
learned Magistrate/court is not required to make a roving
inquiry with regard to material on record and examine
the genuineness of the documents filed by the
prosecuting agency. Further, at the stage of
consideration of charge, which obviously includes
discharge of accused, it is not permissible for a Court to
sift the entire evidence or materials forming part of the
charge-sheet with a view to find whether such
evidence/materials would result in conviction of accused
or not, and the Court would be perfectly justified to
frame charge, if the materials on record reveals a prima
facie case against the accused to proceed against him for
a trial or such materials are sufficient to sustain a trial
against the accused. Broadly speaking, framing of charge
against an accused in a given case is dependent upon the
following four factors: -
(i) Examination of materials and documents, if
any forming part of the charge-sheet to find out
prima-facie case;
(ii) Whether there exist sufficient grounds/
materials for proceeding against the accused in
the trial; but the same has to be done without
sifting the materials forming part of the charge-
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
6 16
Page of
sheet with a view to separate the grain from the
.
chaff
(iii) Whether the evidence/materials remain un-
rebutted do not disclose the ingredient of the
offences for which the accused has been
charge-sheeted.
(iv) Whether the materials/evidence produced
before the Court creates a grave suspicion
against the accused.
5.
On examining the materials on record against
the present accused on the parameters delineated above,
it is undisputed that the accused has been charge-
sheeted for the offences for which she has been charged
and there are allegation appearing against the accused
emanating from the statement of the informant and his
wife together with some documents. Besides, the case
diary contains the statements of witnesses corroborating
the allegation levelled against the petitioner, but the
contention raised on behalf of the revision-petitioner
regarding the opinion of handwriting expert on the
document supporting the revision-petitioner, the same is
essentially considered as matter of trial inasmuch as the
said opinion being a plea of defence cannot be accepted
at this stage as gospel truth to scuttle the prosecution
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
7 16
Page of
case against the revision-petitioner. It is equally well
settled that the revisional jurisdiction of this Court is
supervisory and limited in nature, but interference with
an order refusing to discharge is warranted only when
the order suffers from patent illegality, jurisdictional error
or results in a gross miscarriage of justice. Undeniably, it
is argued on behalf of the petitioner that after receipt of
forensic expert’s opinion, which is the opinion of
Government Examiner of Questioning Documents that
the disputed signatures stated to be put by the
petitioner-accused do not match with her admitted
signature, since there are unnatural hesitation and
structural indication of forgery and thereby, no offence of
forgery being prima facie established against the
petitioner, even to sustain an FIR and therefore, the
learned trial Court ought to have discharged the accused-
petitioner, but this Court in reply to this contention
reminds that at the stage of consideration of charge, it is
not permissible to sift the evidence/materials to find out
whether such evidence could result in conviction or
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
8 16
Page of
acquittal of the accused. This Court does not hesitate to
say that merely because the document does not
corroborate the allegation, the Court is not bound to
discharge the accused, more particularly when there are
other materials and statement of witnesses disclosing
allegation against the accused and when the law on
consideration of charge itself confers jurisdiction on the
Court to frame charge, if there appears grave suspicion
against the accused. It cannot be denied that the
probative value of the documents has to be considered in
a full-fledged trial, but it should not be accepted as a
conclusive proof to terminate the proceeding against the
accused at this stage of framing of charge. Besides, the
prosecution has opportunity to produce the additional
documents, which are collected during investigation after
submission of charge-sheet which is the principle that
has been laid down by the Apex Court in Central
Bureau of Investigation Vrs. R.S. Pai and another;
(2002) 5 SCC 82 ; wherein a three-judge Bench of the
Apex Court has held as under: -
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
9 16
Page of
“From the aforesaid sub-sections, it is
apparent that normally, the Investigating
Officer is required to produce all the relevant
documents at the time of submitting the
charge-sheet. At the same time, as there is
no specific prohibition, it cannot be held
that the additional documents cannot be
produced subsequently. If some mistake is
committed in not producing the relevant
documents at the time of submitting the
report or charge-sheet, it is always open to
the Investigating Officer to produce the same
with the permission of the Court. In our view,
considering the preliminary stage of
prosecution and the context in which Police
Officer is required to forward to the Magistrate
all the documents or the relevant extracts
thereof on which prosecution proposes to rely,
the word 'shall' used in sub-section (5) cannot
be interpreted as mandatory, but as directory.
Normally, the documents gathered during the
investigation upon which the prosecution
wants to rely are required to be forwarded to
the Magistrate, but if there is some
omission, it would not mean that the
remaining documents cannot be produced
subsequently . Analogous provision under
Section 173(4) the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1898 was considered by this Court
in Narayan Rao v. State of Andhra
Pradesh [(1958) SCR 283 at 293] and it
was held that the word “shall” occurring in
sub-section (4) of Section 173 and sub-section
(3) of Section 207A is not mandatory but only
directory. Further, the scheme of sub-section
(8) of Section 173 also makes it abundantly
clear that even after the charge-sheet is
submitted, further investigation, if called for,
is not precluded. If further investigation is not
precluded then there is no question of not
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
10 16
Page of
permitting the prosecution to produce
additional documents which were gathered
prior to or subsequent to investigation. In such
cases, there cannot be any prejudice to the
accused. Hence, the impugned order passed
by the Special Court cannot be sustained.”
6.
It is, therefore, very clear that the
prosecution can bring home the charge of forgery by
producing additional documents, but the same has to be
done in accordance with law. The provision of charge and
discharge requires the Court to consider “the record of
the case and the documents submitted therewith”, but it
would be improper for the Court to terminate the
prosecution case at the threshold of consideration of
charge by accepting a document which is in the nature of
opinion of the expert, more particularly when there are
other materials on record to sustain the charge for
commission of the offences. In the context of absence of
documents in support of allegation of forgery, this Court
considers it apposite to refer to the decision in Rama
Shankar Lal and others Vrs. State of UP; (1971) 3
SCC 905 , wherein at paragraph-7, the Apex Court has
observed as under: -
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
11 16
Page of
7. The document said to have been forged as
“
already pointed out has not been produced in
the case. According to the prosecution that
document was taken back by Rama Shankar
Lal; whereas according to the accused it was
Vishnu Pad Mathur (PW 1) who had received
back the original document from the office of
the Sub-Registrar. Both sides desired this
Court to draw an adverse inference against the
opposite party for the non-production of the
original sale deed. On the state of evidence on
this point, we are disinclined to express any
definite opinion on the question as to who had
received back the sale deed from the office of
the Sub-Registrar though it seems likely that
Rama Shankar Lal had taken back the sale
deed because the sale deed constituted proof
of the title of the vendee. In the circumstances
we refrain from raising any presumption from
the non-production of the sale deed. However,
the fact remains that we have not had the
benefit of looking at the document alleged to
have been forged, a circumstance which is
material and which must to a large extent go
against the prosecution. We do not mean to
say that in the absence of the document
alleged to be forged the court can in no
case hold the offence of forgery to be
established, but to claim such a finding in
the absence of the document said to be
forged, the evidence must in our view
exclude all possibility of a reasonable
doubt. This is in accord with the general
principle of our jurisprudence
.”
7.
The petitioner has of course relied upon the
decision in Rukmini Narvekar Vrs. Vijaya Satardekar
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
12 16
Page of
and others; (2008) 14 SCC 1 ; wherein the Apex Court
has held as under: -
22. Thus in our opinion, while it is true
“
that ordinarily defence material cannot be
looked into by the court while framing of
the charge in view of D.N. Padhi case, there
may be some very rare and exceptional
cases where some defence material when
shown to the trial court would convincingly
demonstrate that the prosecution version is
totally absurd or preposterous, and in
such very rare cases the defence material
can be looked into by the court at the
time of framing of the charges or taking
cognizance. In our opinion, therefore, it cannot
be said as an absolute proposition that under
no circumstances can the court look into the
material produced by the defence at the time
of framing of the charges, though this should
be done in very rare cases, i.e. where the
defence produces some material which
convincingly demonstrates that the whole
prosecution case is totally absurd or totally
concocted.”
8.
It cannot be held at the stage of consideration
of charge in the present case that the opinion of the
handwriting expert eclipse the allegation levelled against
the petitioner by the informant for misappropriation of
his money only on the ground that the signature on the
document does not match with her admitted signature,
but who knows the signature might have been put
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
13 16
Page of
deliberately to create a confusion to mislead its
examiner. The petitioner has of course relied upon the
decision in Chelloor Mankkal Narayan Ittiravi
Namboodiri Vrs. State of Travancore-Cochin;
(1952) 2 SCC 392 ; but the same judgment has been
rendered in an appeal against acquittal and the
materials/evidence on record has been totally considered
on merit therein, but in the present case, this Court is
confronted with a different situation to interfere with the
order rejecting the discharge application of the petitioner,
merely on the ground that the opinion of the handwriting
expert on the document is inconclusive, however, this
Court is conscious of the principle that at this stage of
framing charge, the probative value of prosecution
materials and the document(s) should not be minutely
assessed or scrutinized to find out guilt or innocence of
accused, unless the same are totally absurd and
preposterous to terminate the prosecution case against
the petitioner. Furthermore, it is an admitted position on
record that subsequent to the passing of the impugned
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
14 16
Page of
order dated 16.03.2026, the learned JMFC-II (Cog.
Taking), Cuttack has already framed charge against the
Petitioner, and the trial has effectively commenced with
the examination of one prosecution witness. Once the
trial is underway and evidence is being recorded, this
Court finds no compelling reason to exercise its revisional
jurisdiction under Section 438 read with Section 442 of
the BNSS to interdict the ongoing trial, especially when
the Petitioner has every opportunity to raise all her
factual and legal defences before the Trial Court at the
appropriate stage
9.
From a discussion made hereinabove and on
conspectus of materials & documents placed on record,
this Court does not find any patent illegality or perversity
in the impugned order, so as to warrant interference by
this Court nor is there any jurisdictional error in passing
the impugned order nor does it result in a gross
miscarriage of justice, and having not found any
illegality, irregularity or perversity in the reasons
assigned by the learned trial Court in rejecting the
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
15 16
Page of
discharge petition of the petitioner, this Court does not
consider it proper to interfere with the impugned order.
10.
In the result, the Criminal Revision being
devoid of merit stands dismissed.
It is, however, clarified that any observation
made in this judgment shall not be construed as an
opinion of this Court on merits in the case and the
learned trial Court is requested to dispose of the case
strictly in accordance with law applicable to it.
(G. Satapathy)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack,
th
Dated the 19 day of November, 2026/Jayakrushna
Signature Not Verified
Digitally Signed
Signed by: JAYAKRUSHNA DASH
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Kataka
Date: 19-Nov-2026 15:54:05
CRLREV No.299 of 2026
16 16
Page of