Brijesh Chand vs AIIMS

Court
Central Administrative Tribunal

1
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench: New Delhi
(Nainital Bench)

O.A. No. 600/2024 with O.A. No. 3406/2025 & O.A.
No. 3672/2025

th
This the 17 day of November, 2026

Hon’ble Mr. Justice M. G. Sewlikar, Member (J)
Hon’ble Mr. Rajinder Kashyap, Member (A)


OA/600/2024

1. Ranbir Singh Rawat, S/o Late Shri Manbar Singh Rawat,
R/o Shivalik Enclave Lane 2 Kargi Grant Banjarawala Near
Sandal Wood School Dehradun - 248121. Group C
Employee Working as Office Assistant (N.S.)

2. Champal Rana, S/o Shoorveer Singh Rana, R/o Rana
Bhawan, Near Kusum Bharti Public School, 14-Bigha Muni
Ki Reti, Dhalwala, Tehri Garhwal- 249201. Group C
Employee Working as Office Assistant (N.S.)

3. Rajesh Bhatt, S/o Roshan Lala Bhatt, R/o Lane No- 9 20
Bigha, Virbhadra, Rishikesh, Dehradun - 249203. Group C
Employee Working as Office Assistant (N.S.)

4. Lokendra Singh Bisht, S/o Late Shri Jagdish Singh
Bisht, R/o Lane 03, Amit Gram, Gumaniwala, Near Mohan
motors, Rishikesh, P.O-Satyanarayan Mandir, Dehradun -
249204. Group C Employee Working as Office Assistant
(N.S.)

5. Pawan Kumar, S/o Ramashray Dubey, R/o 12/69
Railway Road, Rishikesh. 249201. Working as Office
Assistant (N.S.) Group C Employee

6. Manbir Singh Rawat, S/o Late Sh. Surbir Singh Rawat,
R/o Gali No. 10, Visthapit Colony, Rishikesh, Dehradun -
249202. Group C Employee Working as Office Assistant
(N.S.)

7. Digamber Prasad, S/o Late Shri Jay Datt Devrari, R/o
Gali No. 12 A, Shivaji Nagar, Bapugrm, Rishikesh, UK.
249203. Group C Employee Working as Office Assistant
(N.S.)
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

2
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch


8. Danish Mansoor, S/o Late Sh. Abul Faiz Sawney, R/o
A/1153 IDPL Colony Virbhadra, Rishikesh Dehradun -
249202. Group C Employee Working as Office Assistant
(N.S.)

9. Mahendra Singh, S/o Guru dev Singh, R/o 94/1.Tilak
bazar Road, Subhash Nagar, Clement Town,Dehradun
248002. Group C Employee Working as Office Assistant
(N.S.)

10. Awdhesh Sharma, S/o K.L. Sharma, R/o 136/8, New
Colony, Smithnagar, PO, Premnagar, Dehradun - 248007.
Group C Employee Working as Office Assistant (N.S.)

…Applicants

(By Advocate: Mr. Abhijay Negi)


Versus

1. Union of India through Secretary, Government of India,
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Room No. 348; 'A'
Wing, Nirman Bhavan, New Delhi-110011.

2. AIIMS Rishikesh through Director, All India Institute of
Medical Sciences, Virbhadra Road, Rishikesh, Uttarakhand-
249203, India.

…Respondents


(By Advocate: Mr. Devi Shankar Shukla, Mr. T C Aggarwal)

OA/3406/2025

1. Ranbir Singh Rawat, Aged About 43, Male, S/o Late Shri
Manbar Singh Rawat, R/o Shivalik Enclave Lane 2 Kargi
Grant Banjarawala Near Sandalwood School Dehradun -
248121.

2. Champal Rana, Aged about 44, Male, S/o Shoorveer
Singh Rana, R/o Rana Bhawan, Near Kusum Bharti Public
school, 14-Bigha Muni Ki Reti, Dhalwala, Tehri Garhwal-
249201.

RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

3
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

3. Rajesh Bhatt, Aged about 43, Male, S/o Roshan Lala
Bhatt, R/o Lane No- 9 20 Bigha, Virbhadra, Rishikesh,
Dehradun - 249203.

4. Lokendra Singh Bisht, Aged about 44, Male, S/o Late
Shri Jagdish Singh Bisht, R/o Lane 03, Amit Gram,
Gumaniwala, Near Mohan motors, Rishikesh,
Р.ОSatyanarayan Mandir, Dehradun -249204.

5. Pawan Kumar, Aged about 41, Male, S/o Ramashray
Dubey, R/o 12/69, Railway Road, Rishikesh, 249201.

6. Manbir Singh Rawat, Aged about 42, Male, S/o Late
Sh. Surbir Singh Rawat, R/o Gali No. 10, Visthapit Colony,
Rishikesh, Dehradun-249202.

7. Digambar Prasad, Aged about 42, Male, S/o Late Shri
Jay Datt Devrari, R/o Gali No. 12 A, Shivaji Nagar,
Bapugrm, Rishikesh, UK. 249203.

8. Danish Mansoor, Aged about 45, Male, S/o Late Sh.
Abul Faiz Sawney, R/o A/1153 IDPL Colony Virbhadra,
Rishikesh Dehradun - 249202.

9. Mahendra Singh, Aged about 43, Male, S/o Guru dev
Singh, R/o 94/1 Tilak bazar Road, Subhash Nagar,
Clement Town, Dehradun 248002.

10. Awdhesh Sharma, Aged about 46, Male, S/o K.L.
Sharma, R/o 136/8, New Colony, Smithnagar, РО,
Premnagar, Dehradun - 248007.

…Applicants

(By Advocate: Mr. Abhijay Negi)


Versus

1. Union of India through Secretary, Government of India,
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Room No. 348; 'A'
Wing, Nirman Bhavan, New Delhi-110011.

2. AIIMS New Delhi through Director Sri Aurobindo Marg,
Ansari Nagar, Ansari Nagar East, New Delhi, Delhi 110029

3. AIIMS Rishikesh through Director, All India Institute of
Medical Sciences, Virbhadra Road, Rishikesh, Uttarakhand-
249203, India.
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

4
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch


…Respondents


(By Advocate: Mr. Devi Shankar Shukla, Mr. T C Aggarwal)

OA/3672/2025

1. Brijesh Chand,(Male) Aged About 45, S/o Shanker
Chand, R/o AIIMS Rishikesh, Biochemistry Department,
Pashulok, Rishikesh, Dehradun, Uttarakhand-249201.

2. Ram Ratan (Male) Aged 50 years S/o Pyare Lal R/o
A2575, IDPL, Veerbhadra Rishikesh, Dehradun,
Uttarakhand – 249202

3. Pankaj Kothiyal (Male) Aged 42 years S/o Ramanand
Kothiyal R/o Gali no-3, near primary school, Suman
viharbapugram, Rishikesh, Dehradun, Uttarakhand -
249202

4. Dinesh Chandra Mishra (Male) aged 50 years, S/o Bal
Mukund Mishra R/o 65, Nehru marg, Ashutosh Nagar,
Rishikesh, Dehradun, Rishikesh, Uttarakhand – 249201

5. Kasim Ansari (Male) Aged 39 years, S/o Sahadat Ansari
R/o Virbhadra Road, Department of Anatomy, AIIMS
Rishikesh, Rishikesh, Dehradun, Pashulok, Uttarakhand,
249203

6. Rajesh Singh (Male) Aged 34 years, S/o Vijay Ram R/o
132 Nirmal Block A bhag 2 Pashulok, Near Shiv Chowk,
Rishikesh, Rishikesh, Dehradun, Virbhadra, Uttarakhand,
249202

7. Sunil Kumar (Male) Aged 48 years, S/o Prem Singh, 82,
Itharna, Gadul, Dehradun, Itharna, Uttarakhand, 248143

8. Sanjay Kumar (Male) Aged 45 years, S/o Ratan Mani
Bhatt, R/o Shivaji nagar, near primary school,
pashulokbairaj, Rishikesh, Dehradun, Rishikesh,
Uttarakhand, 249201

9. RamkrishanPokhriyal(Male) Aged 44 years, S/o Satya
Singh Pokhriyal, R/o Plot no.-83, Nirmal block – A,
Virbhadra, Vishtapit Chetra, Rishikesh, Dehradun,
Virbhadra, Uttarakhand, 249202

RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

5
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

10.Lokendra Singh (Male) Aged 34 years, S/o Chhancher
Singh R/o Pashulok Colony, Rishikesh, Dehradun,
Pashulok, Uttarakhand, 249203

11.Shobhan Singh (Male) Aged 53 C/o Har Singh Bisht,
R/o Near panchayat ghar, vilaspurkandli, VTC: Bilas
purKandli, PO: Ghangora, Sub District: Chakrata, District:
Dehradun, State: Uttarakhand – 248141

12.Satendra bhatt(Male) Aged 39 years S/o Devendra Dutt
Bhatt R/o House no. 43, Gali no. – 5, Laxminagar Metro
station, Shakarpur, East Dehli, Dehli – 110092

13.Arjun Singh (Male) Aged 40 years S/o Jagat Singh R/o
Jagat Singh, Mohsanpur, Bijnor, Nagina, Uttar Pradesh
246762

14.Jai Prakash Yadav (Male) Aged 42 years S/o
Marakandey R/o Manifold Rooms, AIIMS, Rishikesh,
Dehradun, Uttarakhand – 249203

15.Krishna Prasad Sharma (Male) Aged 52 years C/o
Chandra Kant Sharma, Gali no. – 4 Haridwar Road Near
Hanuman Mandir Veerbhadra, post Rishikesh, Rishikesh,
Rishikesh Dehradun Uttarakhand – 249201

…Applicants

(By Advocate: Mr. Abhijay Negi)


Versus

1. Union of India through Secretary, Government of India,
Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, Room No. 348; 'A'
Wing, Nirman Bhavan, New Delhi 110011.

2. AIIMS Rishikesh through Director, All India Institute of
Medical Sciences, Virbhadra Road, Rishikesh, Uttarakhand-
249 203, India.
…Respondents


(By Advocate: Mr. Devi Shankar Shukla, Mr. T C Aggarwal)



RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

6
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch


ORDER (ORAL)
Hon’ble Mr. Justice M. G. Sewlikar, Member (J)

All these three O.As. are being decided by a common order, as
the issues involved therein are identical.
2. The facts of O.A. No. 600/2024 are being taken as the lead
case.
3. The ten applicants in O.A. No. 600/2024 have filed the
present O.A. alleging that the respondents had issued an
advertisement for filling up various Group ‘B’ and Group ‘C’ posts
on a contractual basis. One of the posts advertised was that of
Office Assistant (N.S.), for which the essential qualifications
prescribed were a degree from a recognised University, proficiency
in computer applications, and a Data Entry Speed Test (DEST) at
the speed of 8,000 key depressions per hour on a computer. The
advertisement also prescribed five years’ experience in the relevant
field in a reputed organization.
4. Since all the applicants fulfilled the prescribed qualifications,
they applied for the said post of Office Assistant (NS). Respondent
No. 2, All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), Rishikesh,
conducted the written examination, pursuant to which the
applicants were appointed as Office Assistants (NS) vide the orders
referred to in Para 4.4 of the O.A. It is alleged that, after their
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

7
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

appointment, the applicants were outsourced, as detailed in
Column 3 of Para 4.4 of the O.A. Thereafter, they were reinstated in
service, as indicated in Para 4.4 of the O.A. It is further alleged that
when the applicants were outsourced, they approached the Hon’ble
High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital, which directed their
reinstatement on various dates, as detailed in Para 4.4 of the O.A.
The applicants have been rendering continuous service since 2015
and were appointed against sanctioned posts. The respondents
have now issued an advertisement for recruitment to the posts on a
regular basis, giving rise to the cause of action for the applicants to
approach this Tribunal seeking regularisation of their services. The
applicants have sought the following reliefs:
“i. To issue order or direction to respondent no.2 toact on the direction
dated 28th August 2018 and 3rd November 2021 as given by the
Government of India to the AIIMS Rishikesh to consider the services of
the applicants to be regularized.
ii. To issue order or direction to respondent no.2 not discontinue the
applicants from the service.
iii. To issue order or direction to respondent no.2 to grant the
applicants equal pay for equal work and pay them salaries as per the
new Recruitment Rules of Non-Faculty Posts for new AIIMS, 2015 at
Pay Band-2: 9300-34800+ Grade Pay of Rs 4200 and also pay
arrears that are due to them. (Annexure 12)
iv. To grant compensation for violation of the applicants' fundamental
rights, more particularly Article 14, 16 & 21 of the Constitution of
India.
v. To give any other relief that this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and
proper in the circumstances of the case.
vi. To give cost of the petition to the Applicants.”

5. The respondents have filed their reply, wherein they contend
that the applicants were appointed on a contractual basis. The
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

8
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

appointment orders themselves stipulate that the appointment
would not confer any right upon the applicants to claim
regularisation. The applicants accepted their appointment subject
to the aforesaid condition and, therefore, they cannot now claim
regularisation. It is further contended that vide O.M. dated
07.10.2020, the claim of the applicants for regularisation of their
services was rejected. It is also submitted that vide O.M. dated
03.11.2023, issued by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, it
was clarified that regularisation cannot be treated as a mode of
recruitment by any State within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution of India. The respondents, therefore, contend that
they cannot regularise the services of the applicants and have
accordingly prayed for dismissal of the present O.A.
6. In O.A. No. 3406/2025 and O.A. No. 3672/2025, the facts are
identical, with the only difference being that, in O.A. No.
3406/2025, the applicants have also sought quashing of the
recruitment process in respect of the 12 posts of Office Assistant
(N.S.) and/or Junior Administrative Officer, pursuant to the
advertisement dated 11.07.2025, against which the applicants are
presently working. In these two O.As., the applicants were
appointed to the posts of Technical Assistant, Technical Officer,
Driver Grade-II, Manifold Room Attendant, Dark Room Assistant,
Junior Engineer, Assistant Engineer, Store Keeper-cum-Clerk and
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

9
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

Upper Division Clerk. The applicants in these O.As. are also seeking
regularisation of their services.
7. The respondents have filed their replies to these O.As. and
have raised contentions similar to those raised in O.A. No.
600/2024.
8. We have heard Mr. Abhijay Negi, learned counsel for the
applicants, and Mr. D.S. Shukla, learned counsel for the
respondents.
9. Mr. Abhijay Negi, learned counsel for the applicants, submits
that AIIMS, Delhi, and AIIMS, Raipur, have issued notifications for
regularisation of the services of employees working on contractual
basis against the posts of Office Assistant, Technical Assistant,
Technical Officer, Driver Grade-II, Manifold Room Attendant, Dark
Room Assistant, Junior Engineer, Assistant Engineer, Store
Keeper-cum-Clerk and Upper Division Clerk, who were appointed
pursuant to the advertisement dated 05.03.2014. He further
submits that in the case of Neera Tiwary vs. Union of India
and Anr. , O.A. No. 3354/2025, decided by this Tribunal vide
order dated 30.09.2026, her service was directed to be regularised.
He submits that the advertisement which was the subject matter of
the said O.A. was dated 05.03.2014. He has drawn our attention to
the said advertisement, wherein the post applied for by Neera
Tiwary was mentioned at Sl. No. 53, i.e., Senior Hindi Officer. He
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

10
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

submits that after considering the submissions made by the parties,
this Tribunal held that the applicant therein was entitled to
regularisation. Since the facts of Neera Tiwary (supra) and the
present O.As. are identical, the applicants are also entitled to
regularisation of their services.
10. Mr. D.S. Shukla, learned counsel for the respondents,
vehemently submits that the present O.As. are not maintainable, as
the applicants admittedly did not submit any representation before
the competent authority seeking regularisation of their services. He
draws our attention to Para 6 of the O.A. to buttress his arguments
that no such representation was made by the applicants. He
submits that in view of Section 20 of the Administrative Tribunals
Act, 1985, the applicants cannot approach this Tribunal without
first making a representation to the competent authority. He
further submits that the judgment in Neera Tiwary (supra) is not
applicable to the facts of the present cases. He also draws our
attention to the appointment orders, which stipulate that the
applicants shall have no right to claim regularisation, as their
appointments are contractual in nature. He submits that having
accepted their appointments subject to the said condition, the
applicants cannot now seek regularisation of their services. He,
therefore, prays for dismissal of the present O.As.
11. Mr. D.S. Shukla, learned counsel for the respondents, further
submits that the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare has issued
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

11
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

an O.M. dated 03.11.2023, clarifying that regularisation cannot be
treated as a mode of recruitment by any department, in view of the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Secretary, State of
Karnataka and Ors. vs. Uma Devi , (2006) 4 SCC 1. He also
relies upon the O.M. dated 07.10.2020 in support of his contention
opposing regularisation. Learned counsel for the respondents
further submits that the notifications issued by AIIMS, Delhi, and
AIIMS, Raipur, cannot be relied upon, as each AIIMS is a separate
entity.
12. We have given thoughtful consideration to the submissions
made by learned counsel for the respective parties.
13. The only question that arises for our consideration is
whether, in the facts and circumstances of the present cases, the
applicants are entitled to regularisation of their services.
14. The applicants have furnished, in tabular form in Para 4.4 of
O.A. No. 600/2024, the details of their dates of joining at AIIMS as
contractual employees, their subsequent engagement through
outsourcing, and their reinstatement in contractual service. The
said table is reproduced below for the facility of reference:
Sl. No. Name of Applicants Date of Joining at
AIIMs Contract
(M/D/Y)
Date of Joining at
AIIMS Outsourcing
(M/D/Y)
Contractual Service
reinstated w.e.f
(M/D/Y)
1. CHAMPAL RANA 2/2/2015 --- 7/2/2022
2. RAJESH BHATT 1/24/2015 8/5/2020 6/1/2023
3. LOKENDRA SINGH
BISHT
2/11/2015 10/20/2018 6/1/2023
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

12
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

4. PAWAN KUMAR 2/12/2015 1/1/2019 6/1/2023
5. RANBIR SINGH
RAWAT
2/2/2015 1/3/2019 6/1/2023
6. MANBIR SINGH
RAWAT
1/23/2015 1/1/2019 6/1/2023
7. DIGAMBER
PRASAD
2/5/2015 1/1/2019 6/1/2023
8. DANISH MANSOOR 2/14/2015 1/1/2019 6/1/2023
9. MAHENDAR SINGH 2/2/2015 12/1/2018 6/1/2023
10 AWADHESH
SHARMA
2/2/2015 12/15/2018 6/1/2023
15. It is pertinent to note that, when the applicants were engaged
through outsourcing, they approached the Hon’ble High Court of
Uttarakhand at Nainital, which directed the respondents to decide
their representations. Pursuant to the decisions taken on those
representations, the applicants were once again reinstated as
contractual employees.
16. It is not in dispute that the applicants have been working as
contractual employees against various posts, such as Technical
Assistant, Technical Officer, Driver Grade-II, Manifold Room
Attendant, Dark Room Assistant, Junior Engineer, Assistant
Engineer, Store Keeper-cum-Clerk and Upper Division Clerk, on
the basis of their selection pursuant to the advertisement dated
05.03.2014. They have continued to work against the respective
posts on a contractual basis since then. It is also not in dispute that
their appointments were made after following due procedure. By
the year 2025, the applicants had completed ten years of service.
On the basis of similar facts, AIIMS, Delhi, and AIIMS, Raipur,
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

13
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

issued notifications for regularisation of the services of employees
working on contractual basis. However, the respondents declined
to regularise the services of the present applicants, as reflected in
the recommendation of the Committee dated 03.05.2013. We
would like to reproduce the same for facility of reference:
“In compliance to Hon'ble High Court of Uttarakhand Orders
dated 27/02/2023 & 28/02/2023 in various writ Petitions,
representations of 34 ex-contractual employees (as per Annexure
attached) of AIIMS Rishikesh, who have been working through
outsourced Agency, were considered by the Committee constituted vide
Office Order No. AIIMS/RISHI/AO/203/2023/259 dated 21/03/2023
and on the recommendations of the Committee, the Competent
Authority, AIIMS Rishikesh has decided to re-instate their services on
contractual basis to their corresponding posts w.e.f. 01st June 2023
subject to following conditions:-
1. The terms & conditions mentioned from point 1 to 13 of their
respective original offer of contractual appointment shall remain
binding.
2. Any claim for work experience, back wages or arrears for the
period w.e.f. discontinuation date of previous contractual service and
date of re-engagement will not be enforceable. Work experience
through outsourced agency will not be counted as contractual service.
3. Consolidated remuneration will be effective as per current pay
structure norms applicable to contractual employees.
4. Re-instatement of their services as contractual does not confer
any right for regularization on the corresponding posts and in case of
regular appointment to the posts, their services will end automatically.
5. Re-instatement in contractual services of above mentioned ex-
contractual employees will be effective only prior to submission of
acceptance of above mentioned conditions in hand written letter to
undersigned within 07 days from issue to this order
This office order is without prejudice to any rights that Institute
has under. the governing laws and same shall not create any unintended
right in favour of above mentioned persons or any ex-contractual staff /
third person.
This issues with approval of Competent Authority, AIIMS
Rishikesh.”
17. From the aforesaid Office Order dated 30.05.2023, it is
evident that the respondents rejected the applicants’ claim for
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

14
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

regularisation. The said Office Order does not disclose any reason
for rejecting their claim. It merely states that reinstatement of the
applicants on contractual basis would not confer upon them any
right to regularisation against the corresponding posts and that,
upon regular appointment to those posts, their services would
automatically come to an end.
18. It is pertinent to mention that the applicants have been
working against the aforesaid posts continuously since 2015. It is
not the case of the respondents that the work being performed by
the applicants is not perennial in nature. The respondents have,
instead, placed reliance upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka vs. Uma Devi ,
(2006) 4 SCC 1, to contend that regularisation was intended to be a
one-time exercise and cannot be undertaken subsequently.
19. We are unable to accept the submissions made by learned
counsel for the respondents, for the reason that the Hon’ble
Supreme Court, in Jaggo vs. Union of India , SLP (C) No.
5580/2024, has held that the long and uninterrupted service of
employees cannot be disregarded merely because their initial
appointments were described as part-time, temporary or
contractual. The relevant paragraphs of the judgment rendered by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Jaggo (supra) are reproduced
below for ready reference:
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

15
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

“10. Having given careful consideration to the submissions advanced
and the material on record, we find that the appellants’ long and
uninterrupted service, for periods extending well beyond ten years,
cannot be brushed aside merely by labelling their initial appointments
as part-time or contractual. The essence of their employment must be
considered in the light of their sustained contribution, the integral
nature of their work, and the fact that no evidence suggests their entry
was through any illegal or surreptitious route.
*
12. Despite being labelled as “part-time workers,” the appellants
performed these essential tasks on a daily and continuous basis over
extensive periods, ranging from over a decade to nearly two decades.
Their engagement was not sporadic or temporary in nature; instead, it
was recurrent, regular, and akin to the responsibilities typically
associated with sanctioned posts. Moreover, the respondents did not
engage any other personnel for these tasks during the appellants’
tenure, underscoring the indispensable nature of their work.
13. The claim by the respondents that these were not regular posts lacks
merit, as the nature of the work performed by the appellants was
perennial and fundamental to the functioning of the offices. The
recurring nature of these duties necessitates their classification as
regular posts, irrespective of how their initial engagements were
labelled. It is also noteworthy that subsequent outsourcing of these
same tasks to private agencies after the appellants’ termination
demonstrates the inherent need for these services. This act of
outsourcing, which effectively replaced one set of workers with another,
further underscores that the work in question was neither temporary
nor occasional.
*
19. It is evident from the foregoing that the appellants’ roles were not
only essential but also indistinguishable from those of regular
employees. Their sustained contributions over extended periods,
coupled with absence of any adverse record, warrant equitable
treatment and regularization of their services. Denial of this benefit,
followed by their arbitrary termination, amounts to manifest injustice
and must be rectified.
20. It is well established that the decision in Uma Devi (supra) does
not intend to penalize employees who have rendered long years of
service fulfilling ongoing and necessary functions of the State or its
instrumentalities. The said judgment sought to prevent backdoor
entries and illegal appointments that circumvent constitutional
requirements. However, where appointments were not illegal but
possibly “irregular,” and where employees had served continuously
against the backdrop of sanctioned functions for a considerable period,
the need for a fair and humane resolution becomes paramount.
Prolonged, continuous, and unblemished service performing tasks
inherently required on a regular basis can, over the time, transform
what was initially ad-hoc or temporary into a scenario demanding fair
regularization. In a recent judgement of this Court in Vinod Kumar
and Ors. Etc. Vs. Union of India & Ors .5, it was held that held that
procedural formalities cannot be used to deny regularization of service
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

16
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

to an employee whose appointment was termed "temporary" but has
performed the same duties as performed by the regular employee over a
considerable period in the capacity of the regular employee. The
relevant paras of this judgement have been reproduced below:
“6. The application of the judgment in Uma Devi (supra) by the
High Court does not fit squarely with the facts at hand, given the
specific circumstances under which the appellants were
employed and have continued their service. The reliance on
procedural formalities at the outset cannot be used to perpetually
deny substantive rights that have accrued over a considerable
period through continuous service. Their promotion was based
on a specific notification for vacancies and a subsequent circular,
followed by a selection process involving written tests and
interviews, which distinguishes their case from the appointments
through back door entry as discussed in the case of Uma Devi
(supra).
7. The judgement in the case Uma Devi (supra) also
distinguished between “irregular” and “illegal” appointments
underscoring the importance of considering certain
appointments even if were not made strictly in accordance with
the prescribed Rules and Procedure, cannot be said to have been
made illegally if they had followed the procedures of regular
appointments such as conduct of written examinations or
interviews as in the present case…”

21. The High Court placed undue emphasis on the initial label of the
appellants’ engagements and the outsourcing decision taken after their
dismissal. Courts must look beyond the surface labels and consider the
realities of employment:
continuous, long-term service, indispensable duties, and absence of any
mala fide or illegalities in their appointments. In that light, refusing
regularization simply because their original terms did not explicitly
state so, or because an outsourcing policy was belatedly introduced,
would be contrary to principles of fairness and equity.

26. While the judgment in Uma Devi (supra) sought to curtail the
practice of backdoor entries and ensure appointments adhered to
constitutional principles, it is regrettable that its principles are often
misinterpreted or misapplied to deny legitimate claims of long-serving
employees. This judgment aimed to distinguish between “illegal” and
“irregular” appointments. It categorically held that employees in
irregular appointments, who were engaged in duly sanctioned posts and
had served continuously for more than ten years, should be considered
for regularization as a one-time measure. However, the laudable intent
of the judgment is being subverted when institutions rely on its dicta to
indiscriminately reject the claims of employees, even in cases where
their appointments are not illegal, but merely lack adherence to
procedural formalities. Government departments often cite the
judgment in Uma Devi (supra) to argue that no vested right to
regularization exists for temporary employees, overlooking the
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

17
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

judgment's explicit acknowledgment of cases where regularization is
appropriate. This selective application distorts the judgment's spirit and
purpose, effectively weaponizing it against employees who have
rendered indispensable services over decades.
*
28. In view of the above discussion and findings, the appeals are
allowed. The impugned orders passed by the High Court and the
Tribunal are set aside and the original application is allowed to the
following extent:
i. The termination orders dated 27.10.2018 are quashed;
ii. The appellants shall be taken back on duty forthwith and their
services regularised forthwith. However, the appellants shall not be
entitled to any pecuniary benefits/back wages for the period they have
not worked for but would be entitled to continuity of services for the
said period and the same would be counted for their post-retiral
benefits.
29. There shall be no order as to costs.”

20. From the judgment in Jaggo (supra), it is evident that even
part-time employees may be entitled to regularisation where they
have rendered continuous service for the requisite period and the
work performed by them is perennial in nature. In the present cases,
the perennial nature of the work is evident from the fact that the
respondents have issued an advertisement for filling up the posts in
question on a regular basis. It is also not in dispute that the applicants
were appointed against sanctioned posts. In view of the above, we find
no justification for denying regularisation of the applicants’ services.
21. A similar issue arose for consideration before this Tribunal in
Neera Tiwary (supra). Learned counsel for the respondents has
vehemently contended that the facts of Neera Tiwary (supra) are
different from those of the present O.As. However, we are unable to
agree with the submission made by Mr. D.S. Shukla, learned counsel
for the respondents. The post in question in Neera Tiwary (supra)
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

18
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

was also advertised pursuant to the advertisement dated 05.03.2014.
In that case, this Tribunal, relying upon the judgments of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Uma Devi (supra), Jaggo (supra), etc., held that
the applicants had been appointed against sanctioned posts on
contractual basis and had completed ten years of uninterrupted
service. In these circumstances, this Tribunal directed the
respondents to regularise the services of the applicant therein from
the date of her initial appointment, i.e., 11.02.2015.
22. Even assuming, for the sake of argument, that the judgment in
Neera Tiwary (supra) is not applicable to the facts and
circumstances of the present cases, the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Jaggo (supra) makes it clear that the applicants
are entitled to consideration for regularisation. In terms of the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Uma Devi (supra), the
relevant criteria for regularisation are: (i) the existence of a
sanctioned post; (ii) the employee having worked against such post
for more than ten years; (iii) the appointment being irregular and not
illegal; and (iv) the employee not having continued in service under
the protection of any interim or other order passed by a court of law.
We find that the applicants fulfil the aforesaid requirements and,
therefore, their services deserve to be regularised. The submission of
learned counsel Shri. D S Shukla that the applicant did not make any
representation is stated to be rejected for the reason that in the Office
Order dated 30.05.2023 it is stated that the representation made by
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT

19
Item No. 13/ C-1 O.A. No. 600/2024 & Batch

the applicants were rejected. Accordingly, we pass the following
order:
a. O.A. No. 600/2024, along with O.A. No. 3406/2025 and O.A.
No. 3672/2025, is allowed.
b. The respondents are directed to regularise the services of the
applicants from the dates of their respective initial appointments,
subject to their otherwise being eligible under the relevant
Recruitment Rules.
c. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of
twelve weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
d. All pending M.As., if any, shall also stand disposed of.
e. No order as to costs.


(
Rajinder Kashyap) (Justice M. G. Sewlikar)
Member (A) Member (J)


/ sb /
RA
SU
RA
J
BIS
J
BIS
HT