SANTOSH KUMAR MAHAWAR S/O. SH. BALKISHAN vs STATE OF RAJASTHAN

Court
Rajasthan High Court

[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB]
REPORTABLE
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
(1) D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 18459/2026
CNR: RJHC020889922026 | URN: CW / 38286U / 2026
Murari Lal Verma S/o Radheyshyam Verma, Aged 59 Years 11
Months, R/o Ward No. 34, Pilani, District-Jhunjhunu, (Raj.).
----Petitioner
Versus
1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Principal Secretary,
Department Of Personnel, Main Building, Secretariat,
Jaipur.
2. Additional Chief Secretary, Department Of Home,
Government Of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur.
3. Director, Directorate Of Prosecution Department,
Secretariat Jaipur.
4. Anil Mewara S/o Shri Gopal Lal, Presently Working On The
Post Of Administrative Officer, Through Director,
Directorate Of Prosecution Department, Secretariat Jaipur.
5. Bhanu Kumar Thawani S/o Shri Ramesh Chand, Presently
Working On The Post Of Administrative Officer, Through
Director, Directorate Of Prosecution Department,
Secretariat Jaipur
----Respondents
Connected With
(2) D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 13218/2024
CNR: RJHC020683192024 | URN: CW / 26487U / 2024
1. Santosh Kumar Mahawar S/o. Sh. Balkishan, Aged About
36 Years, R/o. Kawai Saalpura, Police Station Kawai,
District Baran, Presently Working As Head Constable No.
1044, District Baran
2. Ajay Potar S/o. Sh. Purshottam Potar, Aged About 35
Years, R/o. Police Line, District Baran, Presently Working
As Constable No. 227, District Baran
3. Vijendra Singh S/o. Sh. Brajraj Singh, Aged About 37
Years, R/o. Baran District, Presently Working As Head
Constable No. 311, Sc/st Cell Baran, District Baran
4. Brij Sunder Sharma S/o. Sh. Hari Prasad Sharma, Aged
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(2 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
About 42 Years, R/o. Oil Factory, Baran, District Baran,
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 61, District
Baran
5. Ashish Pankaj S/o. Sh. Bharat Bhushan, Aged About 38
Years, R/o. Police Line Baran, District Baran, Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 54, Police Line Baran
6. Surendra Singh Hada S/o. Sh. Man Singh Hada, Aged
About 38 Years, R/o. Adarsh Colony, Baran, Presently
Head Constable No. 509, Circle Office Baran, District
Baran
7. Ghanshyam Yogi S/o. Sh. Mannalal Yogi, Aged About 43
Years, R/o. Brij Nagar, Tehsil Kishanganj, District Baran,
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 261, District
Baran.
8. Mohan Singh S/o. Sh. Roop Singh, Aged About 47 Years,
R/o. Khoh Tehsil And District Deeg, Presently Working As
Head Constable No. 972, District Baran
9. Rajendra Singh Hada S/o. Sh. Laxman Singh Hada, Aged
About 40 Years, R/o. Bakrawada, Police Station
Nahargarh, District Baran, Presently Working As Head
Constable No. 28, District Baran
10. Arjunram S/o. Sh. Narayan Ram, Aged About 36 Years,
R/o. Parbatsar, Police Station Parbatsar, District
Deedwana, Kuchaman, Presently Working As Constable
No. 994, District Sadar, Baran, District Baran
11. Virendra Singh S/o. Sh. Dashrath Singh, Aged About 40
Years, R/o. Baran, Presently Working As Head Constable
No. 458, Police Station Atru, District Baran
12. Harish Kumar S/o. Sh. Shivnathram, Aged About 37
Years, R/o. Khetolai, District Jaisalmer, Presently Working
As Constable No. 214, Police Line, District Baran
13. Rakesh Singh S/o. Sh. Gajendra Singh, Aged About 39
Years, R/o. Kawai Saalpura, District Baran, Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 511, Spo District Baran
14. Kaushal Kishore Nagar S/o. Sh. Latur Lal Nagar, Aged
About 35 Years, R/o. Rijhiya, Tehsil Maangrol, District
Baran, Presently Working As Constable No. 712, District
Baran.
15. Aamir S/o. Sh. Saabir Khan, Aged About 38 Years, R/o.
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(3 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
Harnawadashahji, District Baran, Presently Working As
Head Constable No. 180, District Baran.
16. Vikram Singh S/o. Sh. Vijay Singh, Aged About 32 Years,
R/o. Maharana, District Jhunjhunu, Presently Working As
Constable No. 1084, Police Station Pali, District Baran.
17. Ravi Kumar S/o. Sh. Mannulal, Aged About 38 Years, R/o.
Beelkhedramaal, Tehsil Shahabad, District Baran,
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 57, Office Of
Additional Superintendent Of Police, District Baran.
18. Bhanupratap Singh S/o. Sh. Ummaid Singh, Aged About
39 Years, R/o. Singhani, Police Station Kawai, District
Baran, Presently Working As Head Constable No. 144,
Police Station Bhawargarh, District Baran
19. Manish Sharma S/o. Sh. Om Prakash Sharma, Aged
About 37 Years, R/o. Village Bhoyal, Tehsil Shahabad,
District Baran Presently Working As Head Constable No.
66, District Baran
20. Hariom Nagar S/o. Sh. Balram Nagar, Aged About 37
Years, R/o. Jalwada, Police Station Nahargarh, District
Baran, Presently Working As Head Constable No. 76,
District Baran
21. Sukendra Singh S/o. Sh. Kan Singh, Aged About 41
Years, R/o. Rahlai, Police Station Atru, District Baran,
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 356, Cyber
Police Station, Baran
22. Aakash Shinde S/o. Sh. Pratapraoshinde, Aged About 39
Years, R/o. Vamangaon, Police Station, Kasbathana, Tehsil
Shahabad, District Baran, Presently Working As Head
Constable No. 193, District Baran.
23. Mahendra Singh S/o. Sh. Hazarilal, Aged About 45 Years,
R/o. Gurgachka, Police Station, Kotkasim, District Alwar,
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 680, District
Baran.
24. Digvijay Singh S/o. Sh. Jai Singh, Aged About 39 Years,
R/o. Village Bhorajedi, Tehsil Anta, District Baran,
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 22, District
Baran.
25. Brijraj Singh S/o. Sh. Tej Singh, Aged About 41 Years,
R/o. Village Bakravada, Tehsil Atru, District Baran,
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(4 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 515, District
Baran
26. Chetna Swami D/o. Sh. Vimal Prakash Swami, Aged
About 43 Years, R/o. Dadupanthi bagichi Road, Baran,
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 132, District
Baran.
27. Vinod S/o. Sh. Mahaveer Singh, Aged About 48 Years,
R/o. Maaligaon, District Jhunjhunu, Presently Working As
Head Constable No. 226, Police Station Kotwali, District
Baran.
28. Mahendra Pratap S/o. Sh. Padam Singh, Aged About 35
Years, R/o. Bhakrawada, Police Station Kawai, Tehsil Atru,
District Baran, Presently Working As Constable No. 949,
District Baran
29. Harinarayan S/o. Sh. Jagdish Prasad, Aged About 43
Years, R/o. Jalwada, District Baran, Presently Working As
Head Constable No. 120, District Baran.
30. Dashrath Singh S/o. Sh. Suresh Singh, Aged About 34
Years, R/o. Pandeka Tehsil Pahadi, District Deeg,
Presently Working As Constable No. 65, Police Station
Chabra, District Baran.
31. Mahesh Pal Singh S/o. Sh. Mahaveer Singh, Aged About
35 Years, R/o. Loroli, Tehsil Makrana, District Deedwana,
Kuchaman, Presently Working As Constable No. 55, Police
Station Chabra, District Baran.
32. Meenakshi Rajawat D/o. Sh. Bheem Singh Rajawat, Aged
About 38 Years, R/o. Kakarda, Police Station Kishanganj,
District Baran, Presently Working As Head Constable No.
674, District Baran.
33. Fariduddin S/o. Sh. Abdul Hameed, Aged About 44 Years,
R/o. Devri, District Baran, Presently Working As Head
Constable No. 16, District Baran
34. Kiran Saxena D/o. Late Sh. Sushil Kumar Saxena, Aged
About 38 Years, R/o. Kelwada, Police Station Kelwada,
District Baran, Presently Working As Head Constable No.
653, Police Station Sadar, District Baran.
35. Kishan Singh S/o. Sh. Girwar Singh, Aged About 37
Years, R/o. New Nanka Colony, Baran, Presently Working
As Head Constable No. 307, Police Station Atru, District
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(5 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
Baran.
36. Gyanchand Sharma S/o. Sh. Krishanchand Sharma, Aged
About 41 Years, R/o. Village Khankhra, Tehsil Kishanganj,
District Baran, Head Constable 495, Presently Working As
Assistant Sub-Inspector, Acb, District Baran.
37. Abid Hussain S/o. Sh. Noor Mohammad, Aged About 40
Years, R/o. Baran, Presently Working As Head Constable
No. 477, Traffic Branch, District Baran.
38. Lakki Galav S/o. Sh. Madanlalgalav, Aged About 37 Years,
R/o. Kesholi Presently Working As Head Constable No.
539, Police Station Chabra, District Baran.
39. Bheem Singh S/o. Sh. Narpat Singh, Aged About 46
Years, R/o. Bakrawada, Tehsil Atru, District Baran,
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 250, Traffic
Branch, District Baran.
40. Vikramditya Shinde S/o. Sh. Gopalraoshinde, Aged About
37 Years, R/o. Bamangaon, Police Station Kasbathana,
District Baran, Presently Working As Constable No. 668,
Mahila Thana, District Baran.
41. Virendra Poonia S/o. Sh. Mahaveer Singh, Aged About 47
Years, R/o. Keharpurakhurd, Thala, Bagad, District
Jhunjhunu, Presently Working As Head Constable No. 62,
Police Line, Baran, Districtbaran.
42. Diwan Singh S/o. Sh. Lakkhi Ram, Aged About 46 Years,
R/o. Soopa, Tehsil Bayana, District Bharatpur, Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 93, District Baran.
43. Kulvendra Singh S/o. Sh. Vikram Singh Hada, Aged About
33 Years, R/o. Doongarpur, Tehsil Khanpur, District
Jhalawar, Presently Working As Constable No. 822,
District Baran.
----Petitioners
Versus
1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Principal Secretary,
Department Of Personnel, Main Building, Secretariat,
Jaipur.
2. Principal Secretary, Law Department, Main Building,
Secretariat, Jaipur.
3. Additional Chief Secretary, Department Of Home,
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(6 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
Government Of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur - 302005.
4. Director General Of Police, Rajasthan, Police
Headquarters, Lal Kothi, Jaipur - 3020015.
5. Inspector General Of Police, Kota Range, Kota, Dadabari,
Kota-324009.
6. Superintendent Of Police, Baran, Bamboliya, Baran-
325222.
7. Sh. Nemichand S/o Sh. Kishan Lal, Presently Working As
Head Constable, Belt No. 518, Traffic Branch, Baran,
District Baran.
8. Anup Singh Choudhary S/o Sathen Singh Choudhary,
Aged About 52 Years, R/o N-59, Bharat Path, Hanuman
Vatika-2, Tagore Nagar, Ajmer Road, Jaipur.
9. Durga Ram S/o Bheekha Ram, Aged About 47 Years, R/o
Sayn Ka Tall Lunara, Loonara, Barmer, Rajasthan.
10. Kamlesh Kumar Sharma S/o Shri Ram Kalyan Sharma,
Aged About 52 Years, R/o New Nakoda Colony, Baran, At
Present Posted As Asi, Police Line, Kota.
11.
Lal Bahadur Singh S/o Shri Laxman Singh, Aged About 51
Years, R/o Jharniya, Chhipa Badod, District Baran, At
Present Posted As Asi, Mahila Thana, Baran.
12. Prem Shankar S/o Shri Ganga Ram, Aged About 47 Years,
R/o Village Bawadi Kheda, Tehsil And District Baran, At
Present Posted As Hwead Constable-884, Police Line
Baran.
13.
Mohan Lal Verma S/o Shri Chaturbhuj, Aged About 51
Years, R/o Agresen Nagar, Near Manihar Talab, Baran, At
Present Posted As Constable, Mahila Thana, Baran
14.
Harsha Ram S/o Gumna Ram, Aged About 46 Years, R/o
Malaniya Ki Dhani, Tehsil And District Barmer, At Present
Posted As Head Constable No. 712 St/sc Cell, Barmer.
15.
Durga Ram S/o Karna Ram, Aged About 44 Years, R/o
Village Gunga, Tehsil Sheo, District Barmer. Presently
Posted As Head Constble No. 1001, In The Oice Of
Additional Superintendent Of Police, Barmer.
----Respondents
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(7 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
(3) D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 13648/2024
CNR: RJHC020691772024 | URN: CW / 27466U / 2024
1. Jaideep Hada S/o. Sh. Tejraj Singh, Aged About 39 Years,
R/o. Lodha Gudha, Police Station Khanpur, Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 464, District Sunel,
District Jhalawar.
2. Hemraj Soni S/o. Sh. Durgashankar Soni, Aged About 39
Years, R/o. Harishchandra Colony, Jhalrapatan, Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 603, S.p. Office,
Jhalawar.
3. Irshaad Mohammad S/o. Sh. Gafoor Khan, Aged About 40
Years, R/o. Sehatkhedi, Police Station Jhawar, District
Jhalawar Presently Working As Head Constable No. 795,
Police Line, Jhalawar.
4. Sandeep Somra S/o. Sh. Satyaveer Singh, Aged About 37
Years, R/o. Moi Bharu, District Jhujhunu, Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 69, Police Station Sadar,
District Jhalawar.
5. Poonam Chand Nagar S/o. Sh. Janki Lal, Aged About 45
Years, R/o. Noorpoora, Police Station Sunel, District
Jhalawar, Presently Working As Head Constable No. 676,
Police Line, Jhalawar.
6. Shailendra Singh S/o. Sh. Man Singh, Aged About 44
Years, R/o. Karni Nagar-B, Jhotwara, Jaipur Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 200, S.p. Office,
Jhalawar.
7. Subhash Gadwal S/o. Sh. Richpal Singh, Aged About 41
Years, R/o. Nimeda Police Station Jajodh, District Sikar,
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 1596, Police
Station Mishroli, District Jhalawar.
8. Babulal Swami S/o. Sh. Banwari Lal Swami, Aged About
36 Years, R/o. Village Pitalpur, Tehsil Ajeetgarh, District
Neem Ka Thana, Presently Working As Constable No. 539,
Police Station Jhalrapatan, District Jhalawar.
9. Gautam Chand Vishnoi S/o. Sh. Paboo Ram, Aged About
42 Years, R/o. Patel Nagar, Bikaner, Presently Working As
Head Constable No. 1053, Police Station Jhalrapatan,
District Jhalawar.
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(8 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
10. Dashrath Sharma S/o. Sh. Sukhdev Sharma, Aged About
42 Years, R/o. Housing Board Colony, Jhalawar Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 1054, Police Station
Aklera, District Jhalawar.
11. Prem Singh Jodhana S/o. Sh. Nand Singh, Aged About 37
Years, R/o. Molkya Kalan, Police Station Bakani, District
Jhalawar, Presently Working As Head Constable No. 792,
Police Line, Jhalawar.
12. Nathu Lal Gurjar S/o. Sh. Ramchandra Gurjar, Aged About
43 Years, R/o. Bhawani Mandi, District Jhalawar, Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 269, Office Of
Superintendent Of Police, Jhalawar.
13. Sitaram Samota S/o. Sh. Baksa Ram, Aged About 42
Years, R/o. Ratanpura, District Neem Ka Thana, Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 144, Police Station
Jhalrapatan, District Jhalawar.
14. Nitin Sharma S/o. Sh. Omprakash Sharma, Aged About
44 Years, R/o. Hanumangarh Town, District
Hanumangarh, Presently Working As Head Constable No.
98, Police Line Jhalawar.
15. Ranjeeta Dilawar D/o. Sh. Prabhulaldilawar, Aged About
45 Years, R/o. Jalwada, District Baran, Presently Working
As Head Constable No. 1093, Office Of Superintendent Of
Police, Jhalawar.
16. Niranjana Sharma D/o. Sh. Mohan Lal Sharma, Aged
About 39 Years, R/o. Bakani, Presently Working As Head
Constable No. 606, Office Of Superintendent Of Police,
Jhalawar.
17. Preetam Singh S/o. Sh. Pratap Singh, Aged About 43
Years, R/o. Dakamandi, Tehsil Buhana, District
Jhunjhunu, Presently Working As Head Constable No.
441, Police Station Bhalta, District Jhalawar.
18. Satyanarayan Sharma S/o. Sh. Biramchand Sharma,
Aged About 38 Years, R/o. Chandipur, Tehsil
Manoharthana, Presently Working As Head Constable No.
909, Police Station Ratlai, District Jhalawar.
19. Devendra Singh S/o. Sh. Shivraj Singh, Aged About 40
Years, R/o. Tilak Nagar, Jhalawar, Presently Working As
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(9 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
Head Constable No. 185, Police Station Jhawar, District
Jhalawar.
20. Girdhari Singh Shekhawat S/o. Sh. Samandar Singh,
Aged About 44 Years, R/o. Balacan, Tehsil Chomu, District
Jaipur, Presently Working As Head Constable No. 471,
Office Of Superintendent Of Police, Jhalawar.
21. Sangeeta Sharma D/o. Sh. Mohan Lal Sharma, Aged
About 47 Years, R/o. Bakani, Presently Working As Head
Constable No. 1045, Police Line, Jhalawar.
22. Yashpal Singh S/o. Sh. Shyam Sunder Singh, Aged About
43 Years, R/o. Roopnagar Colony, Jhalawar, Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 679, Office Of
Superintendent Of Police, Jhalawar.
23. Ashish Sharma S/o. Sh. Chandresh Sharma, Aged About
44 Years, R/o. Tagar Mohalla, Bhawani Mandi, Presently
Working As Constable No. 177, Police Line, Jhalawar.
24. Pushpendra Singh S/o. Sh. Raghuraj Singh, Aged About
35 Years, R/o. Jawahar Colony, Jhalawar, Presently
Working As Constable No. 1112, Police Line, Jhalawar.
25. Vinod Gurjar S/o. Sh. Devlal Gurjar, Aged About 35 Years,
R/o. Village Maloni, Police Station Sarola, Presently
Working As Constable No. 805, Police Line, Jhalawar.
26. Surendra Singh Nathawat S/o. Sh. Prem Singh, Aged
About 36 Years, R/o. Beniya Ka Baas, Police Station
Jobner, District Jaipur Gramin, Presently Working As Head
Constable No. 192, Police Station Bhawanimandi, District
Jhalawar.
27. Kanwar Lal Lodha S/o. Sh. Radhakishan Lodha, Aged
About 41 Years, R/o. Village Chandipur, Tehsil
Manoharthana, Presently Working As Head Constable No.
26, District Jhalawar.
28. Deependra Singh S/o. Sh. Jhujhar Singh, Aged About 39
Years, R/o. Lunera, District Ratlam, Madhya Pradesh
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 40, Police Line,
Jhalawar.
29. Shaikh Javed S/o. Sh. Jameel Mohammad, Aged About 38
Years, R/o. Purani Jail Road, Jhalawar, Presently Working
As Head Constable No. 102, Office Of Superintendent Of
Police, Jhalawar.
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(10 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
30. Hemendra Pal Singh S/o. Sh. Hari Singh, Aged About 39
Years, R/o. Asanawar, District Jhalawar, Presently Working
As Head Constable No. 153, Police Station Sadar,
Jhalawar.
31. Virendra Singh S/o. Sh. Jagdish Singh, Aged About 38
Years, R/o. Jawahar Colony, Jhalawar, Police Station
Kotwali, Jhalawar, Presently Working As Head Constable
No. 42, Police Line, Jhalawar.
32. Hemant Sharma S/o. Sh. Bharat Lal Sharma, Aged About
39 Years, R/o. Gautam Nagar, Bhawani Mandi, Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 13, Office Of
Superintendent Of Police, Jhalawar.
33. Sandeep Kumar S/o. Sh. Mool Chand, Aged About 43
Years, R/o. Sikar, Presently Working As Head Constable
No. 165/34, Ats, Jaipur.
34. Harvirendra Singh S/o. Sh. Rambhajan Singh, Aged About
44 Years, R/o. Dharsoni, Tehsil Vair, District Bharatpur,
Presently Working As Head Constable No. 440, Police
Station Bhawanimandi, District Jhalawar.
35. Kundanlal Rathore S/o. Sh. Madanlal, Aged About 45
Years, R/o. Jhalrapatan, District Jhalawar, Presently
Working As Head Constable No. 18, Police Training
School, Jhalawar.
36. Mahendra Kumar S/o Chotelal, Aged About 40 Years, R/o.
Brij Nagar, Khanpur Road, Jhalawar, Presently Working As
Head Constable No. 265, Office Of Superintendent Of
Police, Jhalawar.
37. Kamaruddin S/o Mobin Khan, Aged About 45 Years, R/o
Mirjapur, Tehsil-Aklera, District-Jhalawar, Presently
Working As Head Constable No 120 , Cyber Police Station,
Jhalawar.
----Petitioners
Versus
1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Principal Secretary,
Department Of Personnel, Main Building, Secretariat,
Jaipur.
2. Principal Secretary, Law Department, Main Building,
Secretariat, Jaipur.
3. Additional Chief Secretary, Department Of Home,
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(11 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
Government Of Rajasthan, Secretariat, Jaipur - 302005.
4. Director General Of Police, Rajasthan, Police
Headquarters, Lal Kothi, Jaipur - 3020015.
5. Inspector General Of Police, Kota Range, Kota, Dadabari,
Kota-324009.
6. Superintendent Of Police, H5V3-Chm, Mini Secretariat
Campus, Jhalawar, Rajasthan 326001.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s) : Mr. Sudhir Yadav through VC assisted
by Mr. Piyush Bhardwaj
Mr. Shobit Tiwari
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Vigyan Shah, AAG assisted by
Mr. Yash Joshi
Mr. Samee Khan on behalf of
Mr. Bhuwnesh Sharma, AAG
Mr. Punit Singhvi
Mr. R.K. Gouttam with
Mr. G.S. Gouttam,
Ms. Saakshi Meena &
Ms. Arati Bai Meena
Ms. Ruchika Nuwal with
Ms. Khushboo Rathore on behalf of
Mr. Namo Narayan Sharma
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SANJAY K. AGRAWAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SAMEER JAIN
Order
(28/09/2026)
Sanjay K. Agrawal, CJ:
1. This batch of writ petitions has been filed challenging the
validity of notification dated 16.03.2023, issued by the
respondent-herein, whereby amendments were brought in the
respective Rules mentioned in the Schedule, appended to the said
notification dated 16.03.2023.
2. The main challenge of the petitioners is against the
substitution made in the existing provision under respective
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(12 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
service rules regarding embargo on promotions of the employees
for three recruitment years from the date on which, his/her
promotions become due, if he/she has more than two children on
or after 01.06.2002.
3. The impugned notification dated 16.03.2023, by way of
substitution, provides for consideration of all such persons for
promotion upto the year 2019-20, who were previously deprived
on account of the embargo, as referred to hereinabove. However,
it was also clarified that persons already promoted shall not be
reverted due to implementation of the substitution made vide
notification dated 16.03.2023.
4. The constitutional validity of the notification dated
16.03.2023 had been the subject matter of challenge before this
Court at the Principal Seat at Jodhpur in D.B. Civil Writ Petition
No.9429/2024-Pradeep Kumar & Anr. Vs. State of
Rajasthan & Ors. , which after due consideration, came to be
rejected by the Division Bench vide order dated 06.04.2026.
Paragraph 1 and 15 of the said order state as under:
“1. By way of this petition, petitioners challenge the
notification dated 16.03.2023 issued by the Department of
Personnel, whereby, while making several amendments in
the service rules, the Rajasthan Various Service
(Amendment) Rules, 2023 were notified. The impugned
notification is reproduced as under:
“ GOVERNMENT OF RAJASTHAN
DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL
(A-Gr. II)
No.F.7(1)DOP/A-II/95/Pt. Jaipur, dated: 16.3.2023
NOTIFICATION
In exercise of the powers conferred by the
proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India, the
Governor of Rajasthan hereby makes the following
rules further to amend the Various Service Rules as
mentioned in the Schedule appended hereto, namely:-
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(13 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
1. Short title and commencement. - (1) These rules
may be called the Rajasthan Various Service
(Amendment) Rules, 2023.
(2) They shall come into force from the date of their
publication in the Official Gazette.
2. Amendment. - (1) The existing provisos to sub-rule
(3), (4) or (5), as the case may be, relating to
Disqualification for appointment of person having more
than two children of rule as mentioned in column
number 3 against each of the service rules as
mentioned in column number 2 of the Schedule
appended hereto shall be substituted by the following,
namely:-
"Provided that,-
(i) the candidate having more than two children shall not
be deemed to be disqualified for appointment so long
as the number of children he/she has on 1st June,
2002, does not increase.
(ii) where a candidate has only one child from earlier
delivery but more than one child are born out of a
single subsequent delivery, the children so born shall
be deemed to be one entity while counting the total
number of children.
(iii) while counting the total number of children of a
candidate, the child born from earlier delivery and
having disability shall not be counted.
(iv) any candidate who performed remarriage which is not
against any law and before such the remarriage he is
not disqualified for appointment under this sub-rule, he
shall not be disqualified if any child is born out of single
delivery from such remarriage.
(v) the provisions of this sub-rule shall not be applicable to
the appointment of a widow and divorcee women."
(2) The existing provision of rule as mentioned in column number
4 against each of the service rules as mentioned in column
number 2 of the Schedule appended hereto:-
"No person shall be considered for promotion for three
recruitment years from the date on which his/her promotion
becomes due, if he/she has more than two children on or after
1st June, 2002.”
shall be substituted by the following, namely:-
"The person who had not been considered for
promotion upto the year 2019-2020 because he/she
had more than two children on or after 1st June 2002
shall be considered for promotion from the date on
which his/her promotion was due and on such
promotion his/her pay shall be refixed at the pay which
he/she would have drawn but no arrear shall be paid
and if any person who has more than two children on
or after 1st June,2002 and his promotion becomes due
in the year 2020-2021 or thereafter shall be considered
for promotion from the date on which his/her
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(14 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
promotion becomes due and his/her pay shall be fixed
for the promotional post, but he /she shall be entitled
for annual increment notionally for three subsequent
years and after such three years he/she shall be
allowed actual benefits of such increments, however no
arrears shall be paid for such notional increments.
There shall be no consequential effect on subsequent
promotions of the person promoted as per provisions of
this sub-rule. The person already promoted shall not be
reverted due to implementation of this sub-rule:"
SCHEDULE
S.
No.
Name of Service Rules Number
Number of existing
of
Existing
rules
rules
1 2 3 4
1. The Rajasthan Administrative Service Rules, 1954 25B sub-rule (4) of rule 28B
2. The Rajasthan Police Service Rules, 1954 25C sub-rule (4) of rule 28A
3. The Rajasthan Accounts Service Rules, 1954 25B sub-rule (4) of rule 28A
4. The Rajasthan Inspectors of Registration and Stamps
Service Rules, 1954
21A sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
5. The Rajasthan Service of Engineers (Electrical and
Mechanical Branch) Rules, 1954
21A sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
6. The Rajasthan Service of Engineers and Research
Officers (Irrigation Branch) Rules, 1954
21A sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
7. The Rajasthan Service of Engineers (B&R Branch)
Rules, 1954
21A sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
8. The Rajasthan Cooperative Service Rules, 1954 21A sub-rule (4) of rule 24B
9. The Rajasthan Secretariat Service Rules, 1954 - sub-rule (4) of rule 11B
10. The Rajasthan Motor Garage Service Rules, 1958 20A sub-rule (4) of rule
21AA
11. The Rajasthan Labour and Welfare Service Rules, 1958 20A sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
12. The Rajasthan Economics and Statistical Service
Rules, 1958
15B sub-rule (4) of rule 25A
13. The Rajasthan Service of Inspectors of Factories and
Boilers and Inspector of Factories (Chemical) Rules,
1958
21A sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
14. The Rajasthan Jails Service Rules, 1959 20A sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
15. The Rajasthan State Insurance and Provident Fund
Service Rules, 1959
21A sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
16. The Rajasthan Government Presses Service Rules,
1960
21A sub-rule (4) of rule 25A
17. The Rajasthan Employment Exchanges ervice Rules,
1960
20A sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
18. The Rajasthan Mines and Geological Service Rules,
1960
20 sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
19. The Rajasthan Agriculture Service Rules, 1960 22A sub-rule (4) of rule 25A
20. The Rajasthan Industries Service Rules, 1960 20A sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
21. The Rajasthan Archaeology & Museums Service Rules,
1960
21A sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
22. The Rajasthan Horticulture Service Rules, 1962 20 sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(15 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
23. The Rajasthan Medical Service (Collegiate Branch)
Rules, 1962
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
24. The Rajasthan Forest Service Rules, 1962 25A sub-rule (4) of rule 31A
25. The Rajasthan Animal Husbandry Service Rules, 1963 21 sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
26. The Rajasthan Social Welfare Service Rules, 1963 21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
27. The Rajasthan Medical and Health Service Rules, 1963 21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
28. The Rajasthan Public Relations Service Rules, 1966 21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
29. The Rajasthan Town Planning Service Rules, 1966 21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
30. The Rajasthan Oriental Research Institute Service
Rules, 1967
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
31. The Rajasthan Excise (Preventive Officers) Service
Rules, 1967
- sub-rule (4) of rule 17
32. The Rajasthan Service of Engineers and Allied Post
(Public Health Branch) Rules, 1968
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
33. The Rajasthan Ground Water Service Rules, 1969 21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
34. The Rajasthan Commercial Taxes Service Rules, 1971 15A sub-rule (4) of rule 18
35. The Rajasthan Architectural Service (P.W.D. & B & R)
Rules, 1973
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
36. The Rajasthan Ayurvedic, Unani, Homeopathy and
Naturopathy Service Rules, 1973
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
37. The Rajasthan Excise Service (General Branch) Rules,
1974
- sub-rule (4) of rule 11A
38. The Rajasthan Technical Training Service Rule, 1975 21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
39. The Rajasthan Archives Service Rules, 1975 21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
40. The Rajasthan Engineering Service (Electrical
Inspectorate Branch) Rules, 1975
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
41. The Rajasthan Food and Civil Supplies Service Rules,
1976
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
42. The Rajasthan Tourism Service Rules, 1976 21 sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
43. The Rajasthan Home Guards and Civil Defence
Service Rules, 1976
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
44. The Rajasthan Prosecution Service Rules, 1978 - sub-rule (4) of rule 9
45. The Rajasthan Evaluation Service Rules, 1979 22 sub-rule (4) of rule 24
46. The Rajasthan Forensic Science Service Rules, 1979 22 sub-rule (4) of rule 24
47. The Rajasthan State Enterprises Service Rules, 1979 22 sub-rule (4) of rule 24
48. The Rajasthan Transport Service Rules, 1979 22 sub-rule (4) of rule 24
49. The Rajasthan Librarians and Physical Training
Instructors Service (Collegiate Branch) Rules, 1980
22 sub-rule (4) of rule 24
50. The Rajasthan District Gazatteers Service Rules, 1980 22 sub-rule (4) of rule 24
51. The Rajasthan State Agricultural Marketing Service
Rules, 1986
22 sub-rule (4) of rule 24
52. The Rajasthan Educational Service (Collegiate
Branch) Rules, 1986
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 26
53. The Rajasthan State Institute of Public Administration
Service Rules, 1990
- sub-rule (4) of rule 9
54. The Rajasthan Rural Development State Service Rules,
2007
24 sub-rule (4) of rule 27
55. The Rajasthan Rural Ayurvedic, Unani, Homeopathy
and Naturopathy Service Rules, 2008
19 -
56. The Rajasthan Technical Education (Engineering) 26 sub-rule (4) of rule 29
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(16 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
Service Rules, 2010
57. The Rajasthan Technical Education (Non-Engineering)
Service Rules, 2010
25 sub-rule (4) of rule 28
58. The Rajasthan Civil Aviation State Service Rules, 2013 26 sub-rule (4) of rule 28
59. The Rajasthan Sanskrit (Collegiate Branch) Service
Rules, 2022
27 sub-rule (4) of rule 33
60. The Rajasthan Legal State and Subordinate Service
Rules, 1981
26 sub-rule (4) of rule 28
61. The Rajasthan idhi Rachna State and Subordinate
Service Rules, 1981
26 sub-rule (4) of rule 28
62. The Rajasthan Computer State and Subordinate
Service Rules, 1992
27 sub-rule (4) of rule 30
63. The Rajasthan Secretariat Librarian State and
Subrodinate Service Rules, 1997
23 sub-rule (4) of rule 26
64. The Rajasthan Rural Developmetn and Panchayati Raj
State and Subordinate Service Rules, 1998
25 sub-rule (4) of rule 28
65. The Rajasthan Integrated Child Development State and
Subordinate Service Rules, 1998
25 sub-rule (4) of rule 28
66. The Rajasthan Devasthan State and Subrodinate
Service Rules, 2000
25 sub-rule (4) of rule 28
67. The Rajasthan Tribal Area Development State and
Subrodinate Service Rules, 2001
25 sub-rule (3)(II) of rule
28
68. The Rajasthan Petroleum State and Subordinate
Service Rules, 2012
27 sub-rule (4) of rule 30
69. The Rajasthan Fisheries State and Subordinate Service
Rules, 2012
27 sub-rule (4) of rule 30
70. The Rajasthan Language and Library (State and
Subordinate) Service Rules, 2013
27 sub-rule (4) of rule 30
71. The Rajasthan Sanskrit Education State and
Subordinate Service (School Branch) Rules, 2015
28 sub-rule (4) of rule 31
72. The Rajasthan Excise Laboratory (State and
Subordinate) Service Rules, 2015
27 sub-rule (4) of rule 30
73. The Rajasthan Women Empowerment (State and
Subordinate) Service Rules, 2017
29 sub-rule (4) of rule 32
74. The Rajasthan Minority Affairs (State and
Subordinate) Service Rules, 2017
30 sub-rule (4) of rule 33
75. The Rajasthan Bio-fuel (State and Subordinate) Service
Rules, 2019
28 sub-rule (4) of rule 31
76. The Rajasthan Circuit Houses (State and Subordinate)
Service Rules, 2019
29 sub-rule (4) of rule 32
77. The Rajasthan Science and Technology (State and
Subordinate) Service Rules, 2021
29 sub-rule (4) of rule 32
78. The Rajasthan Educational (State and Subordinate)
Service Rules, 2021
29 sub-rule (4) of rule 32
79. The Rajasthan Subordinate Cooperative Service
(Class-I) Rules, 1955
24A sub-rule (4) of rule 27A
80. The Rajasthan Subordinate Cooperative Service
(Class-II) Rules, 1955
23A -
81. The Rajasthan Tehsildars Service Rules, 1956 24D sub-rule (4) of rule 28A
82. The Rajasthan Mines and Geological Subordinate
Service Rules, 1960
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
83. The Rajasthan Subordinate Accounts Service Rules,
1963
25 sub-rule (4) of rule 28A
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(17 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
84. The Rajasthan Social Welfare Subordinate Service
Rules, 1963
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
85. The Rajasthan Transport Subordinate Service Rules,
1963
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
86. The Rajasthan Horticulture Subordinate Service Rules,
1965
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
87. The Rajasthan Medical and Health Subordinate
Service Rules, 1965
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
88. The Rajasthan Ayurvedic, Unani, Homoeopathy and
Naturopathy Subordinate Service Rules, 1966
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
89. The Rajasthan Industries Subordinate Service Rules, 1966 21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
90. The Rajasthan Engineering Subordinate Service
(Public Health Branch) Rules, 1967
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
91. The Rajasthan Engineering Subordinate Service
(Irrigation Branch) Rules, 1967
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
92. The Rajasthan Archives Subordinate Service Rules,
1968
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
93. The Rajasthan Statistical Subordinate Service Rules,
1971
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 25
94. The Rajasthan Governm,ent Presses Subordinate
Service Rules, 1973
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
95. The Rajasthan Technical Education Subordinate
Service Rules, 1973
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
96. The Rajasthan Subordinate Engineering (B & R
Branch) Service Rules, 1973
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
97. The Rajasthan Ground Water Subordinate Service
Rules, 1973
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
98. The Rajasthan Town Planning Subordinate Service
Rules, 1974
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
99. The Rajasthan Food and Civil Supplies Subordinate
Service Rules, 1974
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
100. The Rajasthan Excise Subordinate Service (General
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
Branch) Rules, 1974
101. The Rajasthan Technical Training Subordinate Service
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
Rules, 1975
102. The Rajasthan Commercial Taxes Subordinate Service
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
(General Branch) Rules, 1975
103. The Rajasthan Public Relations Subordinate Service
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 24A
Rules, 1975
104. The Rajasthan Revenue Accounts Subordinate Service
25 sub-rule (4) of rule 28A
Rules, 1975
105. The Rajasthan Excise3 Subordinate Service
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
(Preventive Branch) Rules, 1976
106. The Rajasthan State Enterprises Subordinate Service
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
Rules, 1976
107. The Rajasthan Animal Husbandry Subordinate Service
21 sub-rule (4) of rule 23A
Rules, 1977
108. The Rajasthan Agriculture Subordinate Service Rules,
22 sub-rule (4) of rule 24
1978
109. The Rajasthan Prosecution Subordinate Service Rules,
17 -
1978
110. The Rajasthan Motor Garage Subordinate Service
22 sub-rule (4) of rule 24
Rules, 1979
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(18 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
111. The Rajasthan Education Subordinate Service
22 sub-rule (4) of rule 24
(Collegiate Branch) Rules, 1979
112. The Rajasthan Forensic Science Subordinate Service
22 sub-rule (4) of rule 24
Rules, 1980
113. The Rajasthan Police Subordinate Service Rules, 1989 24 sub-rule (4) of rule 26
114. The Rajasthan Jails Subordinate Service Rules, 1998 33 sub-rule (4) of rule 35
115. The Rajasthan Subordinate Service (Recruitment and
32 sub-rule (4) of rule 35
other Service Conditions) Rules, 2001
116. The Rajasthan Rural Ayurvedic, Unani, Homeopathy &
19 sub-rule (4) of rule 29
Naturopathy Subordinate Serivce Rules, 2008
117. The Rajasthan Madarsa Education Assistant
27 -
Subordinate Service Rules, 2013
118. The Rajasthan Scheduled Area Subordinate Ministerial
26 sub-rule (4) of rule 29
and Class IV (Recruitment and other Service
Conditions) Rules, 2014
119. The Rajasthan Vidhyalay Sahayak Subordinate Service
27 -
Rules, 2015
120. The Rajasthan Engineering Subordinate Service
29 -
(Electrical Inspectorate Branch) Rules, 2020
121. The Rajasthan Forest Subordinate Service Rules, 2015 33 sub-rule (4) of rule 37
122. The Rajasthan Home Guards Subordinate Service
31 sub-rule (4) of rule 33
Rules, 2021
123. The Rajasthan Secretariat Ministerial Service Rules,
15 sub-rule (4) of rule 26
1970
124. The Rajasthan Subordinate Offices Ministerial Service
31 sub-rule (4) of rule 33
Rules, 1999
125. The Rajasthan Class IV Service (Recruitment and other
19 sub-rule (4) of rule 26
service Conditions) Rules, 1999
By order and in the name of the Governor,
sd/-
(Ram Niwas Mehta)
Joint Secretary to the Government” ”
15. In the facts of present case, private
respondents were initially reverted on account
of qualification arising from having more than
two children as on or after the cut-off date.
However, once the State, in its wisdom, has
removed said disqualification and restored
promotional benefits for all, the very
foundation of their reversion ceases to exist
and promotion originally awarded to them
become legally justified.
Accordingly, the action of respondents in
setting aside reversion orders and restoring
promotions of private respondents is found to
be legally justified. No sustainable objection
can be raised against such restoration once
the disqualifying condition itself has been
deleted across the board.”
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(19 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
5. Almost similar grounds, as were raised in the matter of
Pradeep Kumar (supra), have been raised in this batch of writ
petitions. The grounds of challenge in Pradeep Kumar (supra), in
brief, can be summarized as under:
“i. The retrospective amendment of the rules could not
have been done as it seeks to create right for
promotion from back date.
ii. The notification should be declared ultra-virus having
been introduced in excess of legal power of the State.
iii. That the vested rights of consideration for promotion
of the petitioners have been duly affected due to
retrospective amendment dated 16.03.2023 as the
earlier order of revision of the private respondents on
account of having more than two children have been
withdrawn giving effect to the notification dated
16.03.2023.
6. As such, a Co-ordinate Division Bench of this Court, in its
order dated 06.04.2026, considered all the aspects and rejected
the challenge, so made to the notification dated 16.03.2023. The
petitioners did not make any attempt to get these petitions listed
along with the petition filed by Pradeep Kumar (supra).
7. It is trite law that the judgment of the Co-ordinate Division
Bench is binding upon the subsequent Co-ordinate Benches and
even if the Co-ordinate Bench is of the view that some aspects of
the matter were not considered or not raised before the Court or
some additional aspects should have been gone into by the Court
in deciding the matter earlier, still the subsequent Co-ordinate
Bench must follow the earlier precedent.
8. In this regard, the decision of the Supreme Court in the
matter of Mahadeolal Kanodia Vs. The Administrator General
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(20 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
1
of West Bengal may be noticed herein. It has been held in this
case that if the Division Bench is disagreed with the view of
previous Division Bench, question should be referred to the Larger
Bench, observing in para 19 as under:
“(19) Before we part with this appeal, however, it is our
duty to refer to one incidental matter. We have noticed
with some regret that when the earlier decision of two
judges of the same High Court in Deorajin's Case, 58
Cal WN 64 : (AIR 1954 Cal 119), was cited before the
learned judges who heard the present appeal they took
on themselves to say that the previous decision was
wrong, instead of following the usual procedure in case
of difference of opinion with an earlier decision, of
referring the question to a larger Bench. Judicial
decorum no less than legal propriety forms the basis of
judicial procedure. If one thing is more necessary in law
than any other thing, it is the quality of certainty. That
quality would totally disappear if judges of co-ordinate
jurisdiction in a High Court start overruling one
another's decisions. If one Division Bench of a High
Court is unable to distinguish a previous decision of
another Division Bench, and holding the view that the
earlier decision is wrong, itself gives effect to that view
the result would be utter confusion. The positions would
be equally bad where a Judge sitting singly in the High
Court is of opinion that the previous decision of another
single Judge on a question of law is wrong and gives
effect to that view instead of referring the matter to a
larger Bench. In such a case lawyers would not know
how to advise their clients and all courts subordinate to
the High Court would find themselves in an
embarrassing position of having to choose between
dissentient judgments of their own High Court.”
9. Similarly, in the matter of Jaisri Sahu Vs. Rajdewan
2
Dubey and Others , it has been held by their Lordships of the
Supreme Court that when a Bench of the High Court gives a
decision on a question of law, it should in general be followed by
other Benches unless they have reasons to defer from it, in which
case the proper course to adopt would be to refer the question for
1 AIR 1960 SC 936
2 AIR 1962 SC 83
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(21 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
the decision of a Full Bench. The relevant paragraphs 9 and 10 of
the aforesaid judgment read as under:
“(9) Then there is the question of the practice to be
followed when there is a conflict among decisions
of Benches of the same High Court. When a Bench
of the High Court gives a decision on a question of
law, it should in general be followed by other
Benches unless they have reasons to ditter trom it,
in i which case the proper course to adopt would be
to refer the question for the decision of a Full
Bench……..…….
(10)………...Law will be bereft of all its utility if it
should be thrown into a state of uncertainty by
reason of conflicting decisions, and it is therefore
desirable that in case of difference of opinion, the
question should be authoritatively settled. It
sometimes happens that an earlier decision given
by a Bench is not brought to the notice of a Bench
hearing the same question and a contrary decision
is given without reference to the earlier
decision…………...”
10. Similarly, in the matter of Rajasthan Public Service
Commission and Another Vs. Harish Kumar Purohit and
3
Others , it has been held by the Supreme Court that the earlier
decision of the Division Bench is binding on a Bench of Co-ordinate
strength and if Bench hearing matters subsequently entertains
any doubt about correctness of the earlier decision, the only
course open to it is to refer the matter to a Larger Bench.
11. Further the Supreme Court in the matter of Official
4
Liquidator Vs. Dayanand and Others , considering the binding
effect of ruling of the Co-ordinate Bench of the High Court, held in
paragraph 90 and 91 as under:
“90. We are distressed to note that despite several
pronouncements on the subject, there is substantial
increase in the number of cases involving violation of
3 (2003) 5 SCC 480
4 (2008) 10 SCC 1
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(22 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
the basics of judicial discipline. The learned Single
Judges and Benches of the High Courts refuse to follow
and accept the verdict and law laid down by coordinate
and even larger Benches by citing minor difference in
the facts as the ground for doing so. Therefore, it has
become necessary to reiterate that disrespect to the
constitutional ethos and breach of discipline
have grave impact on the credibility of judicial
institution and encourages chance litigation. It must be
remembered that predictability and certainty is an
important hallmark on judicial jurisprudence developed
in this country in the last six decades and increase in
the frequency of conflicting judgments of the superior
judiciary will do incalculable harm to the system
inasmuch as the courts at the grass roots will not be
able to decide as to which of the judgments lay down
the correct law and which one should be followed.
91. We may add that in our constitutional set-up every
citizen is under a duty to abide by the Constitution and
respect its ideals and institutions. Those who have been
entrusted with the task of administering the system
and operating various constituents of the State and
who take oath to act in accordance with the
Constitution and uphold the same, have to set an
example by exhibiting total commitment to the
constitutional ideals. This principle is required to be
observed with greater rigour by the members of judicial
fraternity who have been bestowed with the power to
adjudicate upon important constitutional and legal
issues and protect and preserve rights of the individuals
and society as a whole. Discipline is sine qua non for
effective and efficient functioning of the judicial system.
If the courts command others to act in accordance with
the provisions of the Constitution and rule of law, it is
not possible to countenance violation of the
constitutional principle by those who are required to lay
down the law.”
12. After hearing learned counsel for the parties, we are not
persuaded to take the other view with regard to the notification
dated 16.03.2023 as the decision rendered by this Court in
Pradeep Kumar (supra), has adjudicated the issue, qua the
notification dated 16.03.2023.
13. In view of the above, this batch of writ petitions deserves to
be dismissed and is, accordingly, dismissed. Pending application, if
any, also dismissed.
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)

(23 of 23)
[2026:RJ-JP:39755-DB] [CW-18459/2026]
14. A copy of this order be placed in each connected file.
(SAMEER JAIN),J (SANJAY K. AGRAWAL),CJ
77-79/KAMLESH KUMAR
(Uploaded on 05/10/2026 at 11:59:56 AM)
(Downloaded on 05/10/2026 at 12:46:23 PM)
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)