Riddhi Zutshi Minor Through Her Natural Guardian vs State Of Punjab And Others
- Court
- Punjab and Haryana High Court
CWP-25413-2026 - 1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
(101-1) CWP-25413-2026
Riddhi Zutshi (minor through her natural guardian) ... Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and others ... Respondents
Judgment Judgment Judgment Whether only
Reserved on Pronounced on Uploaded on the operative
part of the
judgment is
pronounced
Whether the full
judgment is
pronounced
18.09.2026 23.09.2026 24.09.2026 No Yes
CORAM:- HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUVIR SEHGAL
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH GAUR
Present:- Mr. Shashank Shekhar Sharma, Advocate, for the petitioner.
Mr. A.S.Khara, Senior DAG, Punjab, for respondents No.1 and 2.
Mr. Nitin Kaushal, Advocate and
Mr. Sahil, Advocate, for respondent No.3-University.
SUVIR SEHGAL, J.
1) Petitioner, a minor student, has approached this Court, inter-alia , for
quashing communication dated 04.08.2026, Annexure P-18, sent by
respondent No.3-Baba Farid University of Health Sciences (BFUHS), Faridkot
and for a direction to the respondents to grant preference to candidates, who
fulfill eligibility conditions of Clause 11 of Prospectus, Annexure P-6,
governing admission to MBBS & BDS course for the academic session 2026
under 1% quota earmarked for migrants from Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) due
to terrorist violence.
KAMAL SHARMA
2026.09.24 15:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25413-2026 - 2-
2) Brief background of the case leading to the filing of the petition is
that petitioner qualified NEET-UG 2026 examination conducted on
21.06.2026. She possesses a Migrant Certificate, Annexure P-3, issued by the
Relief and Rehabilitation Commissioner (Migrants), Jammu. Additionally, she
also possesses a Punjab Resident Certificate, Annexure P-4, certifying that she
was born in Ludhiana. Her claim is that being a resident of the State of
Punjab, she is entitled to priority in admission under 1% quota for J&K
migrants.
3) Mr. Shashank Shekhar Sharma, counsel for the petitioner submits
that admissions for MBBS and BDS course with BFUHS for the academic
session 2026 are governed vide Prospectus, Annexure P-6, and Clause 11
thereof, prescribes the eligibility for the State quota. He urges that Clause 16
(x) of the Prospectus, Annexure P-6, governs 1% quota in private institutions
for migrants from J&K due to terrorist violence and it has to be read conjointly
with Clause 11. It is his contention that as Clause 11 does not use the word
“domicile” and consequently, the waiver of domicile contemplated under
Clause 16 (x) does not dispense with the requirement that a candidate must be
a resident of the State of Punjab. Reliance has been placed by him upon
judgment passed by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in CWP- 23071-2025
titled as “ Doyel Koul V ersus The S tate of Punjab and others ”, decided on
11.08.2025, Annexure P-14, to urge that candidates fulfilling the dual
condition of being J&K migrants as well as State quota have to be given
preference in admission. Reference has also been made by him to clarification
dated 18.09.2025, Annexure P-15, issued by BFUHS providing for first
KAMAL SHARMA
2026.09.24 15:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25413-2026 - 3-
preference to migrants, who fulfill Clause 11 and second preference to other
eligible migrants.
4) Per contra , Mr. A.S.Khara, Senior DAG, Punjab as well as Mr. Nitin
Kaushal, counsel for the respondents have opposed the petition and urge that
admission process is governed by a fresh Prospectus, Annexure P-6, which
supersedes the previous admission notifications. It has been contended that
Clause 16 of the new Prospectus expressly incorporates instructions dated
15.10.2019, Annexure P-9, issued by the Government of India and grants
eligible J&K migrants a waiver from domicile requirement. It has been
asserted that earlier decision in Doyel Koul’s case ( supra ) was based on a
concession and instructions, Annexure P-15, were circulated on the basis of
the statement made before the Court. A stand has been taken that once a
notification for the current academic session has been issued and candidates
have participated in the admission process with the knowledge of the
eligibility conditions, any change in the category of reservations would amount
to change in the rules of the game after the games have begun, which is
impermissible and would affect thousands of candidates, who did not
participate in the admission process. While making a reference to the reply
filed on behalf of the State, it has been submitted that petitioner had secured
371 marks in NEET-UG 2026 and her name figures at Sr. No.31 in the
combined merit list, Annexure R-1 for J&K migrants quota. It has been
submitted that seven seats have been earmarked in private medical colleges for
J&K migrants and by filing the present petition, petitioner is attempting get
ahead of meritorious candidates.
KAMAL SHARMA
2026.09.24 15:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25413-2026 - 4-
5) We have heard counsel for the parties and we have given a
thoughtful consideration to the rival submissions addressed by them. We have
also examined the record and the documents relied upon by the counsel.
6) Prospectus, Annexure P-6, which governs admission to MBBS and
BDS courses has been circulated by BFUHS for the session 2026. This
Prospectus forms the basis of admission to the current academic session.
Clause 11 thereof, lays the eligibility of a candidate for admission under the
State quota. The relevant extract of the Clause is reproduced hereunder:-
“11. The eligibility of the candidate for state quota is as under :
a) The candidate should be Citizen of India.
b) The candidate must have passed 10+1 & 10+2 from
the state of Punjab or
c) The candidate should have born in the state of Punjab
or
d) The candidate must be permanent resident of the state
of Punjab
Note:-Permanent resident of State of Punjab means : -
i) Candidates who have studied for a period of 5 years in Punjab
or have studied in Punjab for 2 years just preceding the qualifying
examination for the admission.
or
ii) Children wards of
XXXXXXXX XXXXXXX XXXXXXXX”
7) Clause 16 (x) provides for 1% reservation in private institutions for
migrants from J&K due to terrorist violence. This clause reads as under:-
(x) Migrants from Jammu & Kashmir due to terrorist violence 1%
Note:
a. A candidate seeking admission under this category
shall submit a valid certificate issued by the Relief and
Rehabilitation Commissioner (Migrants), Jammu,
certifying that the candidate belongs to a family of Jammu
& Kashmir Migrants displaced due to terrorist violence.
b. In terms of the instructions issued by the Government of
India, Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Department of Higher Education vide letter no. 3-4/2017-
KAMAL SHARMA
2026.09.24 15:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25413-2026 - 5-
NER dated 15.10.2019 the concession of waiver of
domicile requirement shall be available to eligible Jammu
& Kashmir Migrants. Further Kashmiri Pandits/Kashmiri
Hindu Families (Non-Migrants) residing in the Kashmir
Valley shall be required to produce a valid Domicile
Certificate issued by the competent authority.
c. The benefit under the aforesaid Government of India
letter shall be restricted only to the extent of
relaxation/waiver of domicile requirements as applicable.
The provisions relating to relaxation in minimum
eligibility criteria/cut-off percentile, enhancement of
reservation quota, or reservation of additional seats shall
not be applicable unless specifically provided under the
applicable regulations, Government policy, or admission
notification.”
8) A perusal of the above reproduced clauses show that Clause 16 (x)
creates a special category for migrants displaced from J&K due to terrorist
violence. Eligibility under this category depends upon the production of the
requisite certificate and provides for a concession of waiver of domicile
requirement, as has been laid down by the Government of India in its letter,
Annexure P-9. Sub Clause (c) to Clause 16 (x) clarifies that the benefit of the
Government of India instructions would remain confined only to the
relaxation/waiver of domicile requirements. Clause 11, on the other hand,
prescribes the eligibility, which requires a candidate to be a citizen of India
and requires that he should have passed the qualifying examination from the
State of Punjab. The additional requirement under this clause is that the
candidate must have been born in the State of Punjab or must be a permanent
resident of the State. Clause 11 lays down the eligibility criteria applicable to
the State quota. Apart from Indian citizenship, it refers to the schooling in
Punjab, birth in Punjab and permanent residence in the State of Punjab.
KAMAL SHARMA
2026.09.24 15:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25413-2026 - 6-
9) When both the clauses are read together, their implication is explicit.
The admission authority was aware of the condition of State quota eligibility
prescribed under Clause 11 and expressly provided for relaxation from the
prescribed territorial or residential connection with State of Punjab. Merely
because Clause 11 does not use the expression “domicile”, the requirement of
being a resident of Punjab cannot be held to be mandatory. The words used in
the Prospectus, Annexure P-6, have to be understood in the manner in which
they have been used. There is no separate requirement of the expression “state
domicile” in the notification by which the “waiver of domicile requirement”
has been done away with. The provision regarding residence is laid down in
Clause 11 and the requirement of waiver of residence has to be read as the
requirement of residence in the State of Punjab.
10) The background in which the requirement of waiver has been laid
down is also to be kept in mind. This provision has been incorporated
primarily with the intention of rehabilitating a special category of migrants
from J&K, who have been involuntarily forced to leave their native State due
to the atmosphere created due to terrorist action. This classification has a
rational nexus with the object sought to be achieved, namely, facilitating
access to professional education for families subjected to forced displacement
due to terrorism. It is, therefore, distinguishable from ordinary State quota
preference based upon residence. The only requirement being that such a
migrant has to produce the certificate as specified in the prospectus to the
effect that family was displaced from J&K due to terrorist violence. No other
relaxation in minimum eligibility criteria, NEET cut off, enhancement of quota
KAMAL SHARMA
2026.09.24 15:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25413-2026 - 7-
or additional seats has been provided. This relaxation is based on government
instructions, Annexure P-9, which provide for a concession from the domicile
requirement to eligible J&K migrants. In case the J&K migrants are required to
establish their residence or connection with the State of Punjab, it would defeat
the very objective of reservation and preference given to them.
11) Reliance placed by counsel for the petitioner upon the decision in
Doyel Koul’s case ( supra ) is misplaced. Said judgment was founded on a
specific stand taken by the State under the notification applicable to the
previous academic session. That notification did not expressly incorporate the
government instructions, Annexure P-9, nor provided for waiver of domicile
requirement. It was in this backdrop that a statement was made before this
Court that the candidates would be required to fulfill the twin conditions, that
is, the candidate must belong to the State of Punjab and must have a J&K
migrant status. On the basis of the statement made before the Court, the
Government issued a clarificatory letter dated 09.08.2025, Annexure P-13.
Moreover, Clause 25 of the present Prospectus, Annexure P-6, specifically
provides that all the earlier notifications pertaining to admission to MBBS and
BDS course in this State shall stand superseded. Therefore, no benefit can be
drawn by petitioner on the basis of the previous admission notification or upon
the judgment rendered by this Court.
12) In Dr. Tanvi Bahl Versus Shrey Goel and others, 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 180, Hon’ble the Supreme Court explained the manner in which
expressions “domicile”, “permanent residence” and “residence” have been
employed in admission policies. Hon’ble the Supreme Court noticed that the
KAMAL SHARMA
2026.09.24 15:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.
CWP-25413-2026 - 8-
term “domicile” is frequently used by the State Governments and educational
institutions, although, the actual intention is to “permanent residence” or
“residence”. Apex Court observed that in the strict sense, there is no provincial
or State domicile in India and an Indian citizen has only an Indian domicile.
Hon’ble Supreme Court was dealing with the constitutional validity of a state
based reservation in Postgraduate Medical courses. The Court held that such a
reservation at the postgraduate level to be impermissible under Article 14,
while expressly recognizing that the residence based preference may be
permissible at the MBBS/undergraduate level, keeping in view the local needs
and other relevant considerations. Petitioner, therefore, cannot derive any
benefit from the observations made by the Apex Court.
13) For the foregoing reasons, this Court does not find any merit in the
submissions made by the counsel for the petitioner. Ergo , writ petition is
dismissed, though with no order as to costs.
14) Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand disposed of.
(SUVIR SEHGAL)
JUDGE
(RAJESH GAUR)
23.09.2026 JUDGE
Kamal
Whether Speaking/Reasoned Yes/No
Whether Reportable Yes/No
KAMAL SHARMA
2026.09.24 15:55
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
High Court, Sector-1, Chandigarh.