Surinder Kumar vs Jaswant Singh And Others

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
107 FAO-1397-2001 (O&M)
Date of decision :19.11.2026
SURINDER KUMAR …APPELLANT
VERSUS
JASWANT SINGH AND OTHERS ...RESPONDENTS
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PARMOD GOYAL
Present: Mr. Utsav Sharma, Advocate and
Mr. Lakshya Saini, Advocate for
Mr. Sandeep K. Sharma, Advocate
for appellant.
Mr. Anoop Kumar Yadav, Advocate
for respondent No.6-Insurance Company.
*
PARMOD GOYAL, J. (ORAL)
As per office report, original lower Court record was received
by this Court in the year 2004, however, same got burnt in a fire incident
which took place in the year 2011. No record has been furnished by any of
the parties as same is not available.
2. Notice issued to respondent No.3 received back with report
‘served through Sh. Harbans Singh, Senior Assistant’, however no
representation has been made on behalf of respondent No.3. Accordingly,
respondent No.3 is proceeded ex parte .
3. Present appeal has been preferred by appellant-claimant
seeking enhancement in compensation awarded vide award dated
07.08.2000 passed by learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Mukatsar
(hereinafter referred to as ‘ Tribunal ’), whereby appellant-claimant was
awarded total compensation of Rs.1,64,000/- on account of injuries
sustained by him in motor vehicular accident dated 31.05.1993 allegedly
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.20 15:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-1397-2001
-2-
caused due to rash and negligent driving of respondent-driver while driving
truck bearing registration No.PB-10-E-9189 (hereinafter referred to as
‘ ’).
offending vehicle
4. Since in the present appeal the only issue raised by the
appellants-claimants is with regard to the quantum of compensation and no
appeal or cross-objection has been preferred by any of the respondents to
challenge findings of learned Tribunal as regards to rash and negligent
driving of offending vehicle driven by respondent-driver, therefore, the
detailed facts regarding the manner of accident are not being noticed herein
for the sake of brevity.
5. In the present case, learned Tribunal had awarded the
following compensation to appellant-claimant:
Income Rs.1,800/-
per month
40 % Disability Rs.9,000/-
(rounded off)
Multiplier 16
Loss of earning capacity Rs.1,44,000/-
(Rs.9,000 X 16)
Medical expenses Rs.10,000/-
Pain and sufferings Rs.10,000/-
Total compensation Rs.1,64,000/-
awarded
6. Learned counsel for the appellant-claimant has sought
enhancement of compensation on the following grounds:
●
Future prospects were not added while determining
loss of earning capacity. Future prospects to the extent
40 % of monthly income needs to be added as
appellant-claimant 32 years of age at the time of
accident.
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.20 15:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-1397-2001
-3-
●
Correct multiplier was not applied by learned Tribunal;
●
Compensation for loss of future prospects and future
amenities and for future medical expenses has not been
granted to which appellant-claimant is entitled to; and
●
Enhancement of compensation for pain and sufferings,
medical expenses, special diet, transportation and
attendant charges etc. and for loss of income during
treatment, is warranted being insufficient in view of
nature of injuries, nature of treatment and period of
hospitalisation.
7. In order to prove loss suffered by appellant-claimant, he
himself appeared as PW-1 and had asserted that on account of accident
both his legs were fractured. It was stated that he suffered other multiple
injuries also. To corroborate his testimony, appellant-claimant examined
Dr. Kailash Goyal as PW2, who had deposed that appellant-claimant was
admitted in his hospital on 31.05.1993 as a case of accidental injuries. PW2
further deposed that appellant-claimant was given first aid at Civil
Hospital, Gidderbaha and splintage of fractures along with I.V. fluids four
units of blood and antibiotics and analgesics were administered to
appellant-claimant and he was referred to Government Medical College,
Patiala on 07.06.1993. Certificate relating to admission of appellant-
claimant and intimation sent by doctor in-charge regarding admission of
appellant-claimant were duly placed on record as Ex.PW2/A and
Ex.PW3/2 respectively.
8. Appellant-claimant had also claimed that on account of
injuries suffered in accident, he had suffered 40% disability and in order to
prove permanent disability, appellant-claimant had relied upon disability
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.20 15:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-1397-2001
-4-
certificate (Ex.PW5/A) issued by office of Civil Surgeon, Moga whereby it
was stated that the appellant-claimant had suffered 40% disability on
account of fractures of the bones of his left leg as well as right femur.
9. The evidence regarding accidental injuries, nature of
treatment, extent of permanent disability led by appellant-claimant was
duly accepted by learned Tribunal and it was concluded that he had
suffered multiple fractures along with other injuries and had suffered 40%
permanent disability on account of said injuries.
10. Finding of learned Tribunal is based upon evidence placed on
record and is therefore affirmed. The only question which requires
consideration is as to what extent appellant-claimant had suffered loss and
to what amount, appellant-claimant shall be entitled.
11. From the nature of treatment, period of hospitalization and
extent of permanent disability, it is clearly made out that appellant-
claimant must have spent some amount on hospital bills, medicines, special
diet, transportation and attendant expenses etc. Accordingly, compensation
of Rs.15,000/- is awarded towards medical expenses, special diet,
transportation and attendant expenses etc . to appellant-claimant.
Similarly, appellant-claimant must have also undergone immense pain
and sufferings due to multiple fractures along with other injuries,
therefore, amount of Rs.10,000/- granted by learned Tribunal is totally
insufficient and same is enhanced to Rs.50,000/- .
12. Appellant-claimant claimed that he was working as
commission agent in a pesticides company and earning Rs.2,600/- per
month by way of commission. However, except for self-serving oral
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.20 15:10
assertions, no material to justify pleaded income and vocation was placed
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-1397-2001
-5-
on record. Learned Tribunal, after taking in consideration minimum wages
payable to worker in the year 1993, had concluded income of appellant-
claimant to be Rs.1,800/- per month. In view of evidence available on
record, no other conclusion other than as drawn by learned Tribunal can be
drawn by this Court. Accordingly, income of appellant-claimant as
Rs.1,800/- per month as assessed by learned Tribunal is upheld.
13. Appellant-claimant must have also remained out of job for at
least 06 months on account of injuries sustained by him, therefore he is
entitled to compensation for loss of income for six months for the period of
treatment, keeping in view extent and nature of injuries as well as time
taken by him in recovery. Therefore, appellant-claimant shall be entitled to
Rs.10,800/- (Rs.1,800/-X6) for loss of income during treatment .
14. Appellant-claimant in present case had also succeeded in
proving that on account of accidental injuries, he had suffered permanent
disability to the extent of 40% which is duly proved by disability certificate
(Ex.PW5/A). Keeping in view nature of job of appellant-claimant, where
mobility was key aspect, it is clearly made that on account of injuries
suffered by appellant-claimant, he must have suffered functional disability
resulting into loss of earning capacity. Therefore, functional disability is
taken as 40% equivalent to permanent disability for determining loss of
earning capacity.
15. In present case, appellant-claimant was stated to be 32 years
old at the time of accident, therefore, for the purposes of calculating loss of
earning capacity, future prospects to the extent of 40% are required to be
added in view of mandate of Hon’ble Supreme Court in National
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.20 15:10
Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors. , 2017 (16) SCC
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-1397-2001
-6-
680. Multiplier of ‘16’ shall be applicable as per judgment passed by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Smt. Sarla Verma & Ors. Vs. Delhi
, 2009(6) SCC 121. Appellant-claimant
Transport Corporation & Anr.
definitely would have suffered loss of future prospects and future amenities
of life on account of permanent disability to the extent of 40%.
Accordingly, appellant-claimant is granted Rs.75,000/- towards loss of
future prospects and future amenities of life .
16. Accordingly, loss of earning capacity payable to injured-
appellant-claimant has to be determined by taking functional disability
equivalent to 4 0% after taking monthly income of the injured to be
Rs.1,800/- , by adding future prospects to the extent of 40 % and by
applying multiplier of ‘ 16 ’. No future medical expenses are payable in
absence of any evidence in this regard.
17. Re-worked compensation payable to appellant-claimant is as
under:-
Income Rs.1,800/- Rs.1,800/-
per month per month
Future prospects 40% Rs.2,520/-
(1,800+720)
40% Permanent 40% of Rs.2,520/- Rs.1,008/-
disability
Multiplier 16 16
Total loss of earning Rs.1,008/-X16X12 Rs.1,93,536/-
capacity
Loss of income (Rs.1,800/-X6) Rs.10,800/-
during treatment
Compensation for
medical expenses,
transportation,
special diet and
attendant charges
Rs.15,000/
Compensation for Rs.50,000/-
pain and sufferings
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.20 15:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

FAO-1397-2001
-7-
Rs.75,000/-
Compensation for
loss of future
prospects and future
amenities of life
Rs.1,64,000/-
Total compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
Total compensation Rs.3,44,336/-
awarded in appeal
Rs.1,80,336/-
Enhanced Rs.3,44,336 /-
compensation (awarded in appeal)
-
Rs.1,64,000 /-
(awarded by Tribunal)
18. Appellant-claimant shall also be entitled to interest over en-
hanced amount to the extent of 7.5% from the date of filing of claim peti-
tion till its realization. The liability of respondents to pay compensation
shall be as per award.
19. Present a ppeal is allowed in above terms.
20. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand(s)
disposed of accordingly .
(PARMOD GOYAL)
JUDGE
19.11.2026
Sunil Chander
Whether speaking/reasoned : Yes/No
Whether reportable : Yes/No
SUNIL CHANDER
2026.11.20 15:10
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document