Quality Services And Solution Private Limited A Company Incorporated Under The Companies Act 1956 vs Northern Coalfiels Ltd. A Miniratna Company

Court
Madhya Pradesh High Court

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91856
1 WP-46126-2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR

BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VISHAL MISHRA
th
ON THE 16 OF NOVEMBER, 2026
WRIT PETITION No. 46126 of 2026
CNR No.: MPHC010820012026
QUALITY SERVICES AND SOLUTION PRIVATE LIMITED A COMPANY
INCORPORATED UNDER THE COMPANIES ACT 1956 AND ANR
Versus
NORTHERN COALFIELS LTD. A MINIRATNA COMPANY
Appearance:
Shri Akshay Spare - Advocate for the petitioner.
Shri Greeshm Jain - Advocate for the respondent No.1.
ORDER
The present petition has been filed assailing the order dated 05.08.2026 and
23.10.2026 whereby the penalty of termination of agreement and blacklisting for a
period of 5 years has been inflicted upon the petitioner including recovery.
2. It is the case of the petitioner that the petitioner No.1 is a Private Limited
Company engaged inter-alia in third party inspection, sampling, testing and coal
quality assessment services. The petitioner No.2 is a duly authorised
representatives of the petitioner No.1 and has been authorised by the resolution of
the Board of Directors of petitioner No.1 to take all necessary legal steps and
represent the Company in relation to the present proceedings challenging the
impugned order dated 23.10.2026 passed by the respondent. Northern Coalfields
Limited is a subsidiary company of Coal India Limited. Therefore, being an
instrumentality of State is amenable to the writ jurisdiction of this Court. A show
cause notice was issued to the petitioner No.1 which subsequently culminated into
the impugned order dated 23.10.2026 was passed whereby it is directed to
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANINDYA
SUNDAR MUKHOPADHYAY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
19:00:25

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91856
2 WP-46126-2026
terminate all Tripartite Agreement (TPA) executed with the petitioner No.1;

debarment of petitioner No.1 from participating in future bidding for a minimum
period of five years and directed recovery of Rs.59,52,266/- along with applicable
penal interest. The petitioner has submitted a detailed reply to the show cause
notice on 13.08.2026. Without considering the reply and without granting any
opportunity of personal hearing, the impugned order has been passed. During the
course of business, the petitioner No.1 have been providing coal sampling and
related services to the respondent under the Tripartite Agreement. The show cause
notice dated 04.08.2026 was issued being handwritten as 05.08.2026 alleging
suspected forgery and manipulation of referee analysis results across six referee
laboratories. The allegations related to 1,280 referee samples for the period from
April, 2024 to April, 2026 of which discrepancies were alleged in 631 samples.
On the basis of the alleged breaches of TPAs and the Integrity Pact, the proposed
action including termination of TPAs debarment/blacklisting and recovery of
alleged financial loss is alleged in the show cause. It is argued before this Court
that by communication dated 05.08.2026, the respondents have directed stoppage
of all activities undertaken by the petitioner No.1 across NCL projects, including
coal sampling, testing, supervision, certification and reporting and directed that no
operations be carried out through petitioner No.1. The petitioner No.1 filed a
detailed reply explaining the contractual and operational safegaurds governing the
sampling and referee analysis process under the TPAs. He further placed on
record the operational data relating to services rendered to the respondents, also
the proceedings of the Apex Committee constituted by the Central Electricity
Authority concerning the issue of discrepancies in referee analysis results. Vide
reply dated 13.08.2026, the petitioner has requested the respondent to provide the
complete particulars and supporting material underlying the proposed recovery,
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANINDYA
SUNDAR MUKHOPADHYAY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
19:00:25

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91856
3 WP-46126-2026
including the sample wise and consumer wise details and other related documents.

However, without mentioning the same the order impugned is passed in violation
of the principles of natural justice and fair play. Counsel appearing for the
petitioner has submitted that the impugned order passed by the
authorities/respondents is contrary to the guidelines and office memorandum dated
02.11.2021 issued by the Ministry of Finance, Government of India. It is argued
that the debarment of the petitioner cannot exceed two years in terms of the said
office memorandum. Even otherwise, the impugned order dated 23.10.2026 does
not reflect any reason assigned by the authorities nor the consideration of the
detailed reply submitted by the petitioner. It only speaks that after careful
consideration of the explanation and submissions furnished by the petitioner, the
same has not been found to be satisfactory as they do not adequately address the
gravity, extent and contractual implications of the irregularities brought out in the
show cause notice. It is argued that by impugned order the serious civil
consequences are faced by the petitioner. Any order having a serious civil
consequences, the authorities are required to pass a reasoned order which has not
been done in the present case. He has relied upon the judgment passed by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Aurobindo Realty and Infrastructure Private
Limited Vs. NHAI reported in 2024 SCC Online Del 8266, Raghunath Thakur
Vs. State of Bihar reported in (1989) 1 SCC 229 and Erusian Equipment &
Chemicals Ltd Vs. State of West Bengal reported in (1975) 1 SCC 70. Therefore,
this petition.
3. On notice being issued reply to the interim relief has been filed by the
respondents denying the petitioner's averments. It is contended that the interim
relief claimed by the petitioner virtually amounting to final relief, therefore, the
same should not be granted. The petitioner is having an efficacious remedy as per
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANINDYA
SUNDAR MUKHOPADHYAY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
19:00:25

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91856
4 WP-46126-2026
the terms and conditions of the Tripartite Agreement. The petitioner may approach

the competent authority against the same. It is contended that the petitioner was
empanelled by Power Finance Corporation Ltd. (PFC) for NCL along with other
similar agencies. The Tripartite Agreement was entered among NCL, Coal
consumer and M/s Quality Services and Solution Pvt. Ltd. i.e. the petitioner.
Therefore, the petitioner was wholly responsible for collection, preparation,
storage, transportation and analysis of coal samples in a transparent manner. The
TPSA was required to conduct the sampling of coal because the value of coal
depends on the grade of coal which is sampled and analysis/identified by the
TPSA. The coal producer and coal consumer is empowered to dispute of the
submission of results by TPSA. Party challenging the TPSA result will raise a
referee challenge. The referee sample will be sent to National Accreditation Board
for Testing and Calibration Laboratories which is normally known as referees labs.
In the present case, there are large number of Tripartite Agreement. General
complaints received in WCL with respect to manipulation or malpractices carried
out by the petitioner which was enquired by the WCL and ultimately the police
complaint on 30.04.2026 was lodged before Gitti Khadan Police Station. It is
contended that during April, 2024 to April, 2026, a lotwise/lab wise detailed
report were verified which were in number 1280 and it was found that there were
manipulation in 631 reports. Accordingly, a show cause notice was issued to the
petitioner granting 14 days time to file reply. The petitioner filed a reply to the
show cause notice and after due consideration of the same, the impugned order has
been passed. It is argued that there is a condition mentioned in the Tripartite
agreement regarding blacklisting for a period of 5 years that is condition
No.4.1(VII), therefore, no illegality was committed by the authorities, full
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANINDYA
SUNDAR MUKHOPADHYAY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
19:00:25

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91856
5 WP-46126-2026
opportunity was granted to the petitioner. Therefore, principles of natural justice

has been followed by the authorities. He has prayed for dismissal of the petition.
4. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
5. The admitted facts being petitioner entered into Tripartite agreement with
the respondents. Prior to passing of the impugned order a detailed show cause
notice was issued to the petitioner on 04/05.08/2026. The reply to the show cause
notice was submitted by the petitioner and thereafter, the impugned order was
passed. From the perusal of the impugned order it is reflected that the authorities
have mentioned "after careful consideration of the explanation and submissions
furnished by M/s Quality Services and Solutions Pvt. Ltd., the same have not been
found to be satisfactory, as they do not adequately address the gravity, extent and
contractual implications of the irregularities brought out in the show cause notice,
which amounts to serious violation of the obligations cast upon the agency under
the relevant Tripartite Agreement and constitute a clear and material breach of
Integrity Pact thereof" and thereafter the directions were issued directing for
termination of all Tripartite agreement with the petitioner, debarment of petitioner
for a period of 5 years and recovery of total penalty of Rs.59,52,266/-. It is the
specific case of the petitioner that by a detailed reply to the show cause notice, the
petitioner has given explanation to all the allegations made against him. They were
never taken note of by the authorities. It is argued that by impugned order, the
petitioner's Tripartite agreement has been cancelled. He has been debarred for a
period of five years and subsequent recovery is ordered against him. The
impugned order is having serious civil consequences upon the working of the
petitioner. The authorities were required to consider the reply submitted by the
petitioner and thereafter should have passed an order. It is the trite law that the
quasi judicial authorities are also required to pass a reasoned order as the reasons
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANINDYA
SUNDAR MUKHOPADHYAY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
19:00:25

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91856
6 WP-46126-2026
are the heartbeat of the orders and judgments. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the

case of M/s Kranti Associates (P) Ltd. vs Masood Ahmed Khan reported in (2010)
9 SCC 496 had an occasion to deal with the similar issue wherein it is held as
under:-
"47. Summarizing the above discussion, this Court holds:-
(a) In India the judicial trend has always been to record reasons, even in
administrative decisions, if such decisions affect anyone prejudicially.
(b) A quasi-judicial authority must record reasons in support of its conclusions.
(c) Insistence on recording of reasons is meant to serve the wider principle of justice
that justice must not only be done it must also appear to be done as well.
(d) Recording of reasons also operates as a valid restraint on any possible
arbitrary exercise of judicial and quasi-judicial or even administrative power.
(e) Reasons reassure that discretion has been exercised by the decision maker
on relevant grounds and by disregarding extraneous considerations.
(f) Reasons have virtually become as indispensable a component of a decision
making process as observing principles of natural justice by judicial, quasi-
judicial and even by administrative bodies.
(g) Reasons facilitate the process of judicial review by superior Courts.
(h) The ongoing judicial trend in all countries committed to rule of law and
constitutional governance is in favour of reasoned decisions based on relevant facts.
This is virtually the life blood of judicial decision making justifying the principle
that reason is the soul of justice.
(i) Judicial or even quasi-judicial opinions these days can be as different as the
judges and authorities who deliver them. All these decisions serve one common
purpose which is to demonstrate by reason that the relevant factors have been
objectively considered. This is important for sustaining the litigants' faith in the
justice delivery system.
(j) Insistence on reason is a requirement for both judicial accountability and
transparency.
(k) If a Judge or a quasi-judicial authority is not candid enough about his/her
decision making process then it is impossible to know whether the person deciding is
faithful to the doctrine of precedent or to principles of incrementalism.
(l) Reasons in support of decisions must be cogent, clear and succinct. A pretence of
reasons or `rubber-stamp reasons' is not to be equated with a valid decision making
process.
(m) It cannot be doubted that transparency is the sine qua non of restraint on abuse
of judicial powers. Transparency in decision making not only makes the judges and
decision makers less prone to errors but also makes them subject to broader scrutiny.
(See David Shapiro in Defence of Judicial Candor (1987) 100 Harward Law Review
731-737).
(n) Since the requirement to record reasons emanates from the broad doctrine of
fairness in decision making, the said requirement is now virtually a component of
human rights and was considered part of Strasbourg Jurisprudence. See (1994) 19
EHRR 553, at 562 para 29 and Anya vs. University of Oxford, 2001 EWCA Civ
405, wherein the Court referred to Article 6 of European Convention of Human
Rights which requires, "adequate and intelligent reasons must be given for judicial
decisions".
(o) In all common law jurisdictions judgments play a vital role in setting up
precedents for the future. Therefore, for development of law, requirement of giving
reasons for the decision is of the essence and is virtually a part of "Due Process."
6. Even in the case of Aurobindo Realty (supra), the High Court of Delhi has
held that a show cause notice which merely lists possible penalties without clearly
specifying the proposed punitive action cannot be sustained and the reserving
rights to take action or enumerating multiple possibilities does not constitute valid
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANINDYA
SUNDAR MUKHOPADHYAY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
19:00:25

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91856
7 WP-46126-2026
show cause notice. In the case of Raghunath Thakur (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme

Court has held that the order of blacklisting cannot be sustained where no
opportunity of hearing has been afforded to the affected parties. In the case of
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. Vs. SPS Engineering Ltd, LPA No.916/2004, the
High Court of Delhi has held that an authority proposing blacklisting is duty
bound to meaningfully consider the contractor's explanation and record reasons for
finding the same to be unsatisfactory.
7. If the aforesaid principles are applied to the facts and circumstances of the
present case, it is clear that the impugned order does not reflect the consideration
of the detailed explanation given by the petitioner. Counsel appearing for the
respondents was put to a specific question to demonstrate from the impugned
order the consideration of the reply to the show cause notice as well as the
explanation given by the petitioner to the allegations made against him. He could
only point out that the authorities have observed that after careful consideration of
the explanation, it was found to be unsatisfactory. The said does not amount to
assigning reasons for rejection of the explanation tendered by the petitioner. Under
these circumstances, the impugned orders do not sustain judicial scrutiny and is
unsustainable. They are hereby quashed. The matter is remanded back to the
authorities for reconsideration from the stage of furnishing of reply by the
petitioner. The authorities are expected to grant an opportunity of hearing to the
petitioner prior to passing any fresh order.
8. With the aforesaid observations, the petition is disposed off.
(VISHAL MISHRA)
JUDGE
AM
Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANINDYA
SUNDAR MUKHOPADHYAY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
19:00:25

NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2026:MPHC-JBP:91856
8 WP-46126-2026


Signature Not Verified
Signed by: ANINDYA
SUNDAR MUKHOPADHYAY
Signing time: 20-11-2026
19:00:25