SMT UJWALA VETALKAR W/O SHAHU NANGNURKAR vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT DHARWAD
TH
DATED THIS THE 12 DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF
WRIT PETITION NO.103501 OF 2023 (S-RES)
BETWEEN:
SMT. UJWALA VETALKAR W/O. SHAHU NANGNURKAR,
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS, OCC. TEACHER,
TH
R/O. 5 LINE, H.NO.17, SHIVAJI NAGAR, BELAGAVI.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. B. SHARANABASAWA, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION (HIGH SCHOOL),
M.S. BUILDING, BENGALURU-01,
REPT. BY ITS SECRETARY.
2. THE UNDER SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION (HIGH SCHOOL),
M.S. BUILDING, BENGALURU-01.
3. THE ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER,
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS,
DHARWAD-580001.
4. THE ASST. DIRECTOR (ADMINISTRATION),
OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER,
DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION,
DHARWAD-580001.
5. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTIONS,
BELAGAVI, DIST. BELAGAVI-590002.
Digitally signed by
THEJAS KUMAR N
Location: High
Court of Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
6. THE BLOCK EDUCATION OFFICER,
RURAL DIVISION, BELAGAVI,
TQ. AND DIST. BELAGAVI-590002.
7. THE MARATHA MANDAL,
(LINGUISTIC MINORITY GROUP OF
EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS)
1907, MALAMATTI EXTENSION,
BELAGAVI-590016, REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT.
8. THE HEAD MASTER,
MARATHA MANDAL'S HONAGA,
HIGH SCHOOL, HONAGA-591113,
TQ AND DIST. BELAGAVI.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. SHARAD V.MAGADUM, AGA FOR R1 TO R6;
NOTICE TO R7 AND R8 ARE SERVED)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO A)
ISSUE A WRIT IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARI, BY QUASHING
THE ORDER/COMMUNICATION PASSED/ISSUED DATED
16.03.2023 BEARING NO.EP03SOH2022, BY THE RESPONDENT
NO.2, VIDE ANNEXURE-Q. B) ISSUE A WRIT IN THE NATURE
OF CERTIORARI, BY QUASHING THE IMPUGNED
ENDORSEMENT DATED 12.05.2023 BEARING
NO. f5/±Á²C/ªÉÃ.C£ÀÄ/«ªÀ-154/2008-09/275 ISSUED BY THE
RESPONDENT NO.4, VIDE ANNEXURE-Q1. C) ISSUE A WRIT IN
THE NATURE OF MANDAMUS DIRECTING THE RESPONDENTS
NO.1 TO 4 TO APPROVE THE APPOINTMENT OF PETITIONER AS
TH
ASSISTANT TEACHER (SCIENCE) IN 8 RESPONDENT’S
TH
SCHOOL RUN BY THE 7 RESPONDENT INSTITUTION AND TO
INCLUDE THE NAME OF THE PETITIONER FOR GRANT-IN-AID,
BY PROVIDING ALL CONSEQUENTIAL SERVICE BENEFITS FROM
TH
THE DATE OF HER APPOINTMENT IN THE 8 RESPONDENT’S
SCHOOL AS SCIENCE TEACHER FROM DATE OF HER
APPOINTMENT. D) ISSUE, SUCH OTHER WRIT, ORDER OR
DIRECTION AS THIS HON’BLE COURT DEEMS FIT IN THE
CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE.
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
IN 'B' GROUP, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS
UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.M.NADAF
ORAL ORDER
This petition is filed seeking following reliefs:
“a) Issue a Writ in the nature of certiorari, by quashing
the order/communication passed/issued dated:
16.03.2023 bearing No.EP03SOH2022, by the
respondent No.2, vide Annexure-Q.
b) Issue a Writ in the nature of certiorari, by quashing the
impugned endorsement dated 12.05.2023 bearing
f5/±Á²C/ªÉÃ.C£ÀÄ/«ªÀ-154/2008-09/275
No. issued by the
respondent No.4, vide Annexure-Q1.
c) Issue a writ in the nature of Mandamus directing the
respondents No.1 to 4 to approve the appointment of
th
petitioner as Assistant Teacher (Science) in 8
th
respondent’s School run by the 7 respondent
Institution and to include the name of the petitioner
for Grant-in-Aid, by providing all consequential service
th
benefits from the date of her appointment in the 8
respondent’s School as Science Teacher from date of
her appointment.
d) Issue, such other writ, order or direction as this
Hon’ble Court deems fit in the circumstances of the
case.”
2. Heard Sri B. Sharanabasawa, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Sri Sharad V. Magadum, learned AGA for
respondents No.1 to 6/State.
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
3. Facts in brief to file the present Writ Petition are as
under:
3.1. It is the case of the petitioner that she has passed
her SSLC examination with Marathi medium as first language
and thereafter secured her B.Sc. Decree and B.Ed. from the
Karnataka University, Dharwad and also obtained B.Sc.
Degree from the Eastern Institute for Integrated Learning in
Management, Sikkim University.
3.2. The appointment of the petitioner came to be
rejected on the premise that the degree certificate issued by
the Sikkim University cannot be considered as a qualification
for the appointment to the post of Assistant Teacher
(Science) by means of endorsement dated 3/13.02.2017.
Aggrieved by the said communication/endorsement, the
petitioner was before this Court in W.P.No.102652 of 2018
(S-RES). This Court by order dated 08.11.2021 disposed of
the said petition stating that though the Degree certificate
issued from the Sikkim University were to be excluded from
consideration. She would nevertheless be entitled to grant-
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
in-aid because she did possess educational qualification
prescribed for the said post in terms of the Degree certificate
issued by the Karnataka University, Dharwad and further
observed that the University has not properly considered the
certificates of B.Sc. and B.Ed. both issued by KUD and
directed the authorities to reconsider the case of the
petitioner with reference to the degrees that she has
obtained from KUD in the light of the relevant circulars
prevailing as on the date of appointment.
3.3. Subsequent to the order passed by the
coordinated Bench of this Court supra , the Principal
Secretary, School Education and Public Instructions
Department, Bengaluru issued a communication dated
16.03.2023 as per Annexure-Q to the Additional
Commissioner, Department of Public Instructions, Dharwad
stating that in view of the Karnataka Education Department's
Services (Department of Public Instructions) (Recruitment)
(Amendment) Rules, 2016 notified on 29.09.2016, the case
of the petitioner cannot be considered as qualified for the
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
post of Assistant Teacher (Science) (CBZ). In terms of the
communication/order dated 16.03.2023, the Additional
Commissioner, Department of Public Instructions, Dharwad
issued an endorsement dated 12.05.2023 as per Annexure-
Q1 to the petitioner turning down the request of the
petitioner for considering her case for approval and to admit
her to grant-in-aid. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner is
before this Court.
4. Sri B. Sharanabasawa, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner submits that in an identical matter, wherein in
respect of Shiksha Sanathak qualification this Court held that
Rules 2016 operate only prospectively from the date of its
publication in the official Gazette and shall not affect the
admissions made to the courses, re-examinations conducted
for selections or appointments made or eligibility accrued to
the candidates and institutions, under the un-amended
recruitment Rules, 2003. The Judgment of the Coordinate
Bench in W.P.No.106596 of 2017 (EDN-RES) and connected
matter, disposed of on 29.01.2026 read as under:
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
“ORAL ORDER
Both the writ petitions are filed by Dakshina Bharata
Hindi Prachara Sabha.
2. WP.No.106596/2017 is filed calling in
question the Government order dated 18.04.2017
(Annexure-W), whereby the State relying upon the
Karnataka Education Department's Services (Department
of Public Instructions) (Recruitment) (Amendment) Rules,
2016 (‘Amendment Rules, 2016’ for short) notified on
29.09.2016 (Annexure-Q) has withdrawn the
recognition/equivalence earlier granted to Hindi Shiksha
Sanathak qualification and has sought to give effect to
such withdrawal retrospectively affecting appointments
and eligibility for the post of language assistant (Hindi).
3. WP.No.108852/2016 is filed assailing the
gazette notification dated 29.09.2016 (Annexure-J), by
which, 2000 Amendment Rules were brought into force
retrospective effect from 23.03.2015, deleting Hindi
Shiksha Sanathak as recognized qualification under the
recruitment rules and mandating B.A as the sole
professional qualification for appointment as language
assistant (Hindi).
4. Since the challenge in both writ petitions
arise out of the same amendment and its retrospective
application, they are heard together and disposed of by
this common order.
Brief facts:
5. The petitioner- Dakshina Bharata Hindi
Prachara Sabha, a statutory body established under the
Dakshina Bharata Hindi Prachara Sabha Act, 1964, having
the object of promotion and propagation of Hindi and
imparting teacher-training qualification such as Hindi
Praveen/Shiksha Sanathak, which were, for several
decades recognized by the State of Karnataka for the
purpose of appointment as teachers, including language
assistants (Hindi).
6. Under the Recruitment Rules, 1967 as
amended by the Gazette Notification dated 24.06.2003
(Annexure-E), Shiksha Sanathak was expressly
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
recognized as a valid professional qualification for
appointment as language assistant (Hindi). Acting on the
said statutory recognition, institutions were permitted to
function, students were admitted, examinations were
conducted and appointments were made.
7. In the earlier round of litigation, issue of
competence of the State Government, to withdraw
equivalence after coming into force of the National
Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) in 1993 came to be
considered and by the judgment in W.P.No.44785/2001,
preferred by the Dakshina Bharata Hindi Prachara Sabha
disposed on 19.12.2002 (Annexure-H) and the earlier
Division Bench Judgment in T Shrilaxmi and Others Vs.
1
State of Karnataka and Others (T Shrilaxmi) relating
to another institution, it has held that the State lacked
jurisdiction to unilaterally withdraw equivalence and the
said judgments have attained finality.
8. Subsequently, the State issued Amendment
Rules, 2016 (Annexure-J in WP No.108852/2016),
deleting Shiksha Sanathak as qualification and giving the
amendment retrospective operation from 23.03.2015,
which is a subject matter of challenge in the present writ
petition.
9. Learned counsel for the petitioners contends
that the impugned notification seeks to give a
retrospective effect to the deletion of the recognized
qualification. It is submitted that the statutory
requirement rules may be amended prospectively, but
accrued and vested interest of institutions, students and
candidates cannot be taken away retrospectively,
particularly when the earlier recognition flawed from a
statutory rule. It is contended that issue of equivalence of
Hindi qualification imparted by petitioner-Sabha has
already been adjudicated in the earlier round of litigation,
the T Shrilaxmi’s case held that the State Government
has no jurisdiction to withdraw the equivalence once
NCTE regime applies and Annexure-J though relating to
another institution, lays down the same principle of law
1
WP.Nos.20275-294/2002 D.D 29.11.2002
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
and these judgments have attained finality and bind the
same.
10. It is contended that the petitioner's Sabha is
not a private body but a statutory Sabha engaged in Hindi
Prachara, and its qualification has historically been
treated as equivalent to B.A-B.ED for teaching purpose, a
position recognized for decades and affirmed judicially. It
is contended that the deletion of qualification by
Amendment Rules, 2016, if applied retrospectively would
adversely affect;
i) institution lawfully conducting courses,
ii) students, who enrolled earlier on statutory
recognition,
iii) candidates already selected are eligible for
selection. Such civil consequences cannot be imposed
retrospectively unless expressly authorized by law which
is absent here.
11. It is submitted that even assuming that the
State has power to align recruitment rules with NCTE
regulations, Amendment Rules, 2016 can operate only
prospectively. The recognition under Annexure-E cannot
be nullified for the past period.
12. Per contra, learned AGA contends that 2016
amendment Rules was issued in conformity with NCTE
Regulation 2014 after inviting objections. Once the
amendment occupies the field, earlier Rules, inconsistent
therewith, stand superseded. The deletion of Shiksha
Sanathak is only a policy decision to maintain uniform
standards in teacher education.
13. Learned counsel for respondent Nos.2 and 3-
NCTE in W.P.No.106596/2017, places the reliance on the
judgment of the Apex Court in Unnikrishnan CV and
2
Others Vs. Union of India and Others
(Unnikrishnan
CV) to contend that Courts cannot prescribe qualification
or declare equivalence of causes, and the determination
of equivalence lies exclusively within the domain of the
2
2023 Live law (SC) 256
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
expert bodies unless the rule itself recognizes a
equivalence, the Court cannot substitute its own view.
14. This Court has carefully considered the
contentions urged and perused the material on record.
15. There can be no quarrel with the proposition
of law laid down by the Apex Court in Unnikrishnan CV,
that Courts should not substitute their views for that of
expert bodies in prescribing qualification or determining
equivalence. However, the present case stands on a
distinct and narrow footing.
16. What falls for consideration here is not
whether this Court should newly declare equivalence, but
whether the State can retrospectively withdraw a
qualification that was statutory recognized and judicially
upheld. In the earlier round of proceedings as evidenced
initially in WP.No.44785/2001 and in the case of T
Shrilaxmi stated supra, it has been conclusively held
that;
i) the State Government lacked jurisdiction to
unilaterally withdraw equivalence after the NCTE Act,
ii) the recognition then prevailing was
protected,
iii) such determination has attained finality.
17. Annexure-E in W.P.no.108852/2016, being a
statutory amendment of Recruitment Rules, 2003,
expressly recognized Shiksha Sanathak as a valid
qualification. Acting on the said rules, rights accrued in
favour of institutions, students and candidates.
Amendment Rules, 2016 delete Hindi Shiksha Sanathak
as qualification and prescribe B.Ed. as mandatory. The
State is competent to amend recruitment rules
retrospectively so as to align them with the NCTE
regulations. However, the clause giving amendment
retrospective from 23.03.2015, directly affects;
i) institutional lawfully imparting the cause,
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
ii) students admitted on the strength of
statutory Rules,
iii) candidates whose eligibility has already been
accrued.
Such retrospective deprivation of rights is impermissible
in law.
18. Annexure-W in W.P.No.106596/2017 is only
an executive Government order issued to implement the
retrospective operation of the Amendment Rules, 2016.
An executive order cannot override the statutory rules nor
nullify the binding judicial pronouncement, nor can it
retrospectively extinguish vested rights. However, the
present case does not involve this Court declaring
equivalent suffrage, this Court is only examining the
legality of the retrospective withdrawal of an already
recognized qualification, which had statutory backing and
judicial affirmation. Deletion of a recognized qualification
is not a procedural change but a substantial one with
serious civil consequences. In the absence of express
legislative mandate, such deletion cannot operate
retrospectively.
19. The accrued and vested rights protected
under Annexure-E and the earlier judgments cannot be
taken away by 2016 Amendment Rules or by Annexure-
W. The amendment brought about by Amendment Rules
2016 (Annexure-J) to the extended deletes in the Shiksha
Sanathak as a qualification, cannot operate
retrospectively so as to nullify rights flowing from 2003
Rules (Annexure-E) and protected by earlier binding
judgments at Annexures-H and J. The amendments can
only have prospective effect and any contrary
interpretation would amount to arbitrary deprivation of
vested rights of institutions, students, and candidates.
20. For the foregoing reasons, the following:
ORDER
i. The writ petitions are allowed .
ii. It is declared that the Karnataka Education
Department Services (Department of Public
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
Instructions) (Recruitment) (Amendment)
Rules, 2016 notified vide Gazette Notification
dated 29.09.2016 (Annexure-J in
WP.No.108552/2016), insofar as they gave
retrospective effect from 23.03.2015 to the
deletion of Hindi 2003 Rules Shiksha Sanathak
as a recognized qualification for appointment to
the post of language assistant (Hindi) are
illegal, arbitrary and unenforceable.
iii. It is further declared that the said Amendment
Rules, 2016 shall operate only prospectively
from the date of their publication in the official
gazette and shall not affect;
-
a. admissions made to the courses,
b. examination conducted,
c. selections or appointment made or,
d. eligibility accrued to candidates and institutions
under the unamended recruitment Rules of
2003 (Annexure-E in W.P.No.108852/2016).
iv. The respondents are directed to consider and
protect all accrued and vested rights of the
petitioners-institution, students and candidates
arising prior to 29.09.2016, in light of the
statutory recognition contained in Annexure-E
and binding judgments of this Court produced at
Annexures-H and J.
v. It is made clear that nothing in this order shall
prevent the State or the competent authority
from enforcing Amendment Rules, 2016
prospectively in accordance with law and
subject to the regulations framed by the
National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE).
vi. All consequential actions taken solely on the
basis of retrospective operation of the impugned
notifications shall stand set aside .
vii. No order as to costs.”
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
5. From the Judgment of the co-ordinate bench stated
supra , it is imperative that the effect of Rules 2016 shall be
considered as prospective and not retrospective. In the case
on hand, the petitioner admittedly appointed on 09.10.2015
in terms of the resolution. In that view of the matter, the
order/communication at Annexure-Q dated 16.03.2023 and
the endorsement dated 12.05.2023 in terms of Rule 2016
vide notification dated 29.09.2016 are not sustainable in law.
Accordingly, this Court proceeds to pass the following :
ORDER
(i) Writ Petition is allowed in terms of the
order passed by the coordinate Bench in
WP No.106596 of 2017 (EDN-RES)
disposed of on 29.01.2026 directing the
respondents to consider the case of the
petitioner for admitting her to grant-in-aid
in terms of the rules prevailing as on the
date of her appointment i.e. on
09.10.2015 and pass appropriate orders
in that regard.
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-D:18612
WP No. 103501 of 2023
CNR: KAHC020085652023
(ii) The entire exercise shall be concluded as
expeditiously as possible. However within
an outer limit of 6 weeks from today and
file compliance report immediately after
th
the 6 week with the registry of this
Court.
Sd/-
(T.M.NADAF)
JUDGE
CKK
CT: UMD
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 9