M.B. PATIL CONSTRUCTIONS LIMITED vs THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
- Court
- Karnataka High Court
- 1 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
KALABURAGI BENCH
TH
DATED THIS THE 27 DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO
COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 200010 OF 2026
C/W
COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 200024 OF 2026
IN COMAP No. 200010/2026
BETWEEN:
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PWP AND
IWTD DIVISION,
KALABURAGI,
SRI. RAHUL S/O DIGAMBAR,
GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. NARENDRA M. REDDY, HCGP)
AND:
1. M. B. PATIL CONSTRUCTIONS LIMITED,
ND
CORPORATE OFFICE AT 2 FLOOR,
COMMERCIAL BUILDING NO.1,
OPP. INCOME TAX BUILDING, SHANKARSHETH
ROAD, SWARAGATE,PUNE-411042,
(MAHARASHTRA STATE),
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN
SRI. MALLIKARJUN S/O BASWANTRAO PATIL,
Digitally signed
by B NAGAVENI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
- 2 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
THROUGH HIS POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER
SRI DHANAJI S/O VENKATRAO PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS,
R/O. UDGIR, TQ. UDGIR,
DIST. LATUR. 413517.
2. SRI. ARUN CHOWDAPURKAR,
RETD. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS, JUDGE
SOLE ARBITRATOR, KALABURAGI.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ASHOK MULAGE, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
V/O DTD.01.04.2026 NOTICE TO R2 DISPENSED WITH)
THIS COMMERCIAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 13
(1A) OF COMMERCIAL COURTS ACT 2015, PRAYING TO, A)
CALL FOR RECORDS. B) ALLOW THE PRESENT COMMERCIAL
APPEAL AND SET ASIDE THE ORDER OF THE LEARNED PRL.
DISTRICT JUDGE, AT KALABURAGI DATED 02-05-2025 PASSED
IN COMMERCIAL ARBITRATION SUIT NO.05/2019 VIDE
ANNEXURE-N, IN SO FAR IT RELATED TO NON CALCULATION
OF THE LIQUIDATED DAMAGES IN THE AMOUNT AWARDED
UNDER DIFFERENT CATEGORIES IS CONCERNED AND GRANT
SUCH OR FURTHER RELIEF OF RELIEFS AS THIS HON’BLE
COURT MAY DEEMS FIT.
IN COMAP NO. 200024/2026
BETWEEN:
1. M.B. PATIL CONSTRUCTIONS LIMITED
ND
CORPORATE OFFICE AT 2 FLOOR,
COMMERCIAL BUILDING NO.1
OPP. INCOME TAX BUILDING,
SHANKARSHETH ROAD, SWARAGATE,
PUNE-411 042, MAHARASHTRA
REPRESENTED BY ITS CHAIRMAN,
SRI. MALLIKARJUN,
S/O BASWANTRAO PATIL,
THROUGH HIS POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER,
- 3 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
SRI. DHANAJI S/O VENKATRAO PATIL,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS,
R/O UDGIR TALUK,
LATUR DISTRICT,
MAHARASHTRA STATE.
...APPELLANT
(BY SRI. ASHOK MULAGE, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
PWP AND IWTD DIVISION,
KALABURAGI DISTRICT,
KARNATAKA-585104.
2. SRI. ARUN CHOWDAPURKAR,
RETD. DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE,
SOLE ARBITRATOR,
KALABURAGI-585104.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. NARENDRA M. REDDY, HCGP)
THIS COMMERCIAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
37 OF THE ARBITRATION AND CONCILIATION ACT, WITH
SECTION 13(1)(A) OF THE COMMERCIAL COURTS ACT,
R/W CHAPTER VI OF THE KARNATAKA HIGH COURT RULES
1959, PRAYING TO:
A) CALL FOR THE RECORDS IN COM.A.S.NO.5/2019 ON
THE FILE OF THE PRL. DISTRICT JUDGE, KALABURAGI.
B) CALL FOR RECORDS IN C.M.P. NO.200006/2014
ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL OF SRI. ARUN CHOWDAPURKAR SOLE
ARBITRATOR.
C) SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT DATED 2-5-2025 PASSED BY
THE PRL. DISTRICT JUDGE, KALABURAGI IN COM.A.S.
NO.5/2019 - ANNEXURE-A.
- 4 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
D) CONFIRM THE AWARD DATED 30.10.2018 PASSED BY
THE ARBITRAL TRIBUNAL OF SRI. ARUN CHOWDAPURKAR
SOLE ARBITRATOR IN C.M.P.NO.200006/2014 -
ANNEXURE-B. E) PASS ANY SUCH OTHER ORDERS AS THIS
HON’BLE COURT DEEMS FIT IN THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF
THE CASE.
THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK S. KINAGI)
These commercial appeals arise out of a common
judgment passed in Commercial Arbitration Suit
No.5/2019 dated 02.05.2025 by the Principal District
Judge, Kalaburagi.
2. Brief facts leading rise to filing of these appeals
are as follows:
The Executive Engineer, PWP and IWTD Division,
Kalaburagi, filed Commercial Arbitration Suit No.5/2019,
challenging the award passed by the Arbitrator in
- 5 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
CMP.No.200006/2014 dated 30.10.2018 and the rectified
award dated 08.03.2019 with costs. The appellants in both
the cases filed an application for condonation of delay in
filing the respective commercial appeals. In Commercial
Appeal No.200010/2026, an application was filed in
I.A.No.3/2026 seeking for the condonation of delay of 240
days in filing appeal. In support of an application, the
Executive Engineer, Department of Public Works filed an
affidavit stating that the judgment was passed on
02.05.2025 and it was noticed that the first portion of the
judgment was in favour of the appellant. However, the
second portion was ambiguous. Hence, after receiving the
judgment, the officials discussed with the higher
authorities the question of preferring an appeal against the
impugned judgment. Thereafter, M.B.Patil Constructions
Limited/Contractor, filed a review petition in
R.P.No.1/2025. The Executive Engineer, PWP and IWTD
contested the said review petition, which was dismissed by
an order dated 27.01.2026.
- 6 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
3. The Contractor filed an execution petition in
E.P.No.6/2026, which was contested by the Executive
Engineer, PWP and IWTD. However, the question of
maintainability raised by the Executive Engineer, PWP and
IWTD was not considered. Meanwhile, the Executive
Engineer, PWP and IWTD, filed a writ petition in
W.P.No.200864/2026, which was disposed of on
23.02.2026. The officials collected the entire records again
to obtain the Government orders for preferring the appeal.
Consequently, there was some delay in obtaining the
copies. The reasons for delay is caused due to official
communication and frequent transfer of the officials and
the aforesaid reasons. However, delay was not intentional.
If the delay is not condoned, the appellant-the Executive
Engineer, PWP and IWTD would sustain an irreparable loss
as huge monetary loss will cause to the appellant. Hence,
on these grounds, he prays to allow the application.
- 7 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
4. The contractor filed an appeal in Commercial
Appeal No.200024/2026, challenging the judgment passed
in Commercial Arbitration Suit No.5/2019 and filed an
application in I.A.No.1/2026 seeking condonation of a
delay of 422 days in filing the appeal. In support of the
application Sri Dhanaji, S/o Venkatrao Patil, filed an
affidavit stating that, after the judgment and decree were
passed by the learned Prl. District Judge and Commercial
Court at Kalaburagi, the Contractor noticed certain
ambiguity in the judgment. Therefore, on 02.06.2025, the
contractor filed a review petition seeking to set aside the
impugned judgment dated 02.05.2025 passed by the Prl.
District Judge in Commercial Arbitration Suit No.5/2019 to
the extent that the impugned award has been set aside on
the ground of non-consideration of the liquidated damages
as claimed by the respondent in Review Petition
No.1/2025. The Executive Engineer, PWP and IWTD, filed
objections to the review petition. On 27.01.2026, the Prl.
District Judge, Kalaburagi, dismissed the review petition
- 8 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
filed by the Contractor as not maintainable in law with
liberty to the appellant to approach before the Competent
Court. It is stated that the deponent has instructed his
counsel to collect the papers with the intention to
preferring an appeal before the Hon'ble Court. In the
meanwhile, the deponent was also unwell. Consequently,
immediately after collecting the papers, the counsel did
not approach him. In the first week of August, the
deponent instructed the counsel to file an appeal before
this Hon'ble Court. Thus, there was a delay in filing
appeal. Hence, on these grounds, he prays to allow the
application.
5. Learned counsel for the parties submits that the
Commercial Arbitration Suit was disposed of by a
judgment dated 02.05.2025. Thereafter, the Contractor
filed a review petition before the learned District Judge in
R.P.No.1/2025. The said review petition was dismissed as
not maintainable, with liberty to the Contractor to
- 9 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
approach before the Competent Court. It is contended that
there was a delay in approaching this Court and that the
delay was not an intentional. Hence, learned counsel
appearing for the Contractor as well as the Government
prays to allow the applications.
6. Learned High Court Government Pleader – Sri
Narendra M. Reddy has submitted that due to
administrative exigencies, the Executive Engineer, PWP
and IWTD could not file the appeal before this Court within
the prescribed time. He further submits that, in view of
the review petition pending before the learned District
Judge, the appeal could not be filed within time. He
submits that the Executive Engineer, PWP and IWTD has
shown sufficient cause for condoning the delay in
preferring the appeals.
7. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and
perused the records.
- 10 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
8. Admittedly, the appeals have been filed beyond
the period of limitation. The only reason assigned for the
delay is that the review petition was pending and
therefore, the appeals could not be preferred within the
prescribed time.
9. The delay in filing the appeals cannot be
condoned merely as a matter of course, as the Arbitration
Act has been enacted to ensure speedy redressal of
disputes. Delay can be condoned only where sufficient
cause is established and supported by a satisfactory
explanation. Before considering the causes shown by the
appellants in both the cases for seeking condonation of
delay of 422 days by the Contractor and 240 days by the
Executive Engineer, PWP and IWTD, it would be useful to
refer to the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case
of S HEO R AJ S INGH (D) T R .L RS . V S . U NION O F I NDIA
reported IN (2023) 10 SCC 531, particularly paragraph
Nos. 30, 31, 32, 39 and 40, which read as follows:
- 11 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
30. Considering the aforementioned decisions,
there cannot be any quarrel that this Court has
stepped in to ensure that substantive rights of
private parties and the State are not defeated at the
threshold simply due to technical considerations of
delay. However, these decisions notwithstanding, we
reiterate that condonation of delay being a
discretionary power available to courts, exercise of
discretion must necessarily depend upon the
sufficiency of the cause shown and the degree of
acceptability of the explanation, the length of delay
being immaterial.
31. Sometimes, due to want of sufficient
cause being shown or an acceptable explanation
being proffered, delay of the shortest range may not
be condoned whereas, in certain other cases, delay
of long periods can be condoned if the explanation is
satisfactory and acceptable. Of course, the courts
must distinguish between an ‘explanation’ and an
‘excuse’. An ‘explanation’ is designed to give
someone all of the facts and lay out the cause for
something. It helps clarify the circumstances of a
particular event and allows the person to point out
that something that has happened is not his fault, if
it is really not his fault. Care must however be taken
to distinguish an ‘explanation’ from an ‘excuse’.
Although people tend to see ‘explanation’ and
‘excuse’ as the same thing and struggle to find out
the difference between the two, there is a distinction
which, though fine, is real.
32. An ‘excuse’ is often offered by a person to
deny responsibility and consequences when under
attack. It is sort of a defensive action. Calling
something as just an ‘excuse’ would imply that the
explanation proffered is believed not to be true. Thus
said, there is no formula that caters to all situations
and, therefore, each case for condonation of delay
based on existence or absence of sufficient cause has
to be decided on its own facts. At this stage, we
- 12 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
cannot but lament that it is only excuses, and not
explanations, that are more often accepted for
condonation of long delays to safeguard public
interest from those hidden forces whose sole agenda
is to ensure that a meritorious claim does not reach
the higher courts for adjudication.
39. University Of Delhi vs Prateek Sharma is a
decision by a larger Bench and, therefore, binding on
us. This Court, while deciding University of Delhi
(supra), was seized of a situation where even if the
delay were to be condoned, it would cause grave
prejudice to the respondent Delhi Metro Rail
Corporation at the instance of the casual approach of
the appellant University. This Court, on the argument
of non- availability of the Vice Chancellor for granting
approval to file the appeal, and other reasons put
forth in the matter, could not conclude that there
was fulfilment of sufficient cause for condonation of
delay; hence, the refusal to condone the delay. The
decision really turns on the facts before this Court
because of the prejudice factor involved.
40. We can also profitably refer to State Of
Manipur & 2 Ors vs Koting Lamkang (supra), cited by
Mr. Sen, where the same Bench of three Hon’ble
Judges of this Court which decided University of Delhi
(supra) was of the view that the impersonal nature
of the State’s functioning should be given due
regard, while ensuring that individual defaults are
not nit-picked at the cost of collective interest. The
relevant paragraphs read as follows:
“7. But while concluding as above, it
was necessary for the Court to also be
conscious of the bureaucratic delay and
the slow pace in reaching a government
decision and the routine way of deciding
whether the State should prefer an
appeal against a judgment adverse to it.
Even while observing that the law of
- 13 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
limitation would harshly affect the
party, the Court felt that the delay in the
appeal filed by the State, should not be
condoned.
8. Regard should be had in similar such
circumstances to the impersonal nature of
the Government's functioning where
individual officers may fail to act responsibly.
This in turn, would result in injustice to the
institutional interest of the State. If the
appeal filed by the State are lost for
individual default, those who are at fault, will
not usually be individually affected.”
(emphasis supplied)
10. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
HARKHAND RJA TPADAN IGAM TD VS HARAT
J U U N L M/S B
H EAVY E LECTRICALS L IMITED reported in 2025 INSC 533,
particularly paragraph Nos.20 and 21, held as follows:
20. The High Court, thereafter, proceeded to
answer the aforesaid question as under:
“19. In order to answer this question, we cannot
lose sight of the whole purpose of enactment of the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 i.e., to provide for
speedy disposal of high value commercial dispute.
20. No doubt there was a similar provision in
Haryana Consumer Protection Rules, 1988 framed
under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 which was
considered by the Supreme Court in the case of
Housing Board, Haryana.
The said provision in the Haryana Consumer
Protection Rules, 1988 also provided for
- 14 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
communication of the order of the District forum to
the parties free of charge in order to avoid the delay
as well as to save the parties from the burden of
expenses that may he incurred for obtaining the
certified copy.
The Supreme Court held that the scheme of the
Consumer Protection Act was to provide for better
protection of the interest of the consumers as a
measure for economical and speedy remedy for the
settlement of the dispute and the matters connected
therewith and therefore, the said rule should be
understood in a manner so that it would protect the
interest of the parties before the District forum by
making it obligatory on the District forum to provide
a copy of the order duly signed and dated by the
members of the Bench; and the period of limitation
prescribed with regard to filing of an appeal under
Section 15 of the said Act therefore, has to be
computed as commencing from the date of
communication of the order in the manner laid down
in the rules.
It was in that context that it was Held that mere
pronouncement of an order in the open Court would
not be enough, but under the scheme of the rules
copy of the said judgment has to be communicated
to the parties affected by the said order so that the
parties adversely affected therefrom may have a fair
and reasonable opportunity of knowing the text,
reasons and contents thereof so as to formulate
grounds of attack before the appellate or before the
higher forums.
In absence of such communication of signed and
dated order, it was held that the parties adversely
affected by it will have no means of knowing the
contents of the order so to challenge the same and
get it set aside by the appellate authority or by the
higher forums.
- 15 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
21. Normally petitioners before the District
forums under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 are
individuals and not corporate entities like the
appellant/instrumentality of the State. So, there is
justification for taking the view as regards petitioners
in District forums that the provisions in the Haryana
Consumer Protection Rules, 1988 which mandated
communication of the order of the said forums to the
parties free of charge was to save the parties from
the burden of expenses that may be incurred for
obtaining the certified copy.
The Supreme Court in Para 19 of it's judgment in
Government of Maharashtra (2 supra) discussed the
statement of objects and reasons behind enacting of
the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 and held that
period of limitation must always to some extent be
arbitrary and may result in some hardship, but this is
no reason as to why they should not be strictly
followed.
In para 32, it held that the condonation of delay
under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 has to be
seen in the context of the object of speedy resolution
of the dispute.
In para 58, the Supreme Court held that given
the object sought to be achieved under the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015 i.e., the speedy
resolution of the disputes, expression "sufficient
cause" in Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 is not
elastic enough to cover long delays beyond the
period provided by the appeal provision itself; and
that the expression "sufficient cause" is not itself a
loose panacea for the ill of pressing negligent and
stale claims.
In other words, the Supreme Court indicated
that in exercise of power under Section 5 of the
Limitation Act, 1963 a delay beyond the period
- 16 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
of 60 days from the date on which the appeal
could have been filed can be condoned (i.e.,
below 120 days from the date of
pronouncement of the judgment) by invoking
Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, but where
there is negligence, inaction or lack of bona
fides, such power ought not to be exercised.
It went further in para 59 by observing that
merely because the Government is involved, a
different yardstick for condonation of delay
cannot be laid down. (This rule would thus
apply equally to instrumentalities of
Government like the applicants herein).
It held in para 62 that merely because sufficient
cause has been made out in the facts of a given
case, there is no right in the applicants or the
appellants to have the delay condoned.
It concluded in para 63 as under:
“63. Given the aforesaid and the object of speedy
disposal sought to be achieved both under the
Arbitration An and the Commercial Courts Act, for
appeals pled under section 37 of the Arbitration Act
that are governed by Articles 116 and 117 of the
Limitation Act or Section 13(l-A)of the Commercial
Courts Act, a delay beyond 90 days, 30 days or 60
days. respectively, is to be condoned by way of
exception and not by way of rule. In a fit case in
which a party has otherwise acted bona fide and not
in a negligent manner, a short delay beyond such
period can, in the discretion of the court, he
condoned, always bearing in mind that the other side
of the picture is that the opposite party may have
acquired both in equity and justice, what may now
be lost by the first party’s inaction, negligence or
laches.”
(emphasis supplied)
- 17 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
11. In commercial matters, condonation of delay
should not be granted in a routine manner. The appellant
must establish sufficient cause to justify the delay. In the
present case, the appellants have not shown sufficient
cause for condoning the inordinate delay in preferring the
commercial appeals. The applicable provisions of Section
13(l-A) of the Commercial Courts Act 2015, must be
considered while determining whether the delay can be
condoned. The Court must be satisfied that the delay is
supported by sufficient cause and is not attributable
merely to a lack of diligence.
12. Admittedly, in the instant case, apart from
contending that the review petition was pending, the
appellants have not shown sufficient cause for the delay. It
is also admitted there was no interim order in the review
petition. Further, the review petition was filed by the
- 18 -
HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC-K:11563-DB
COMAP No. 200010 of 2026
C/W COMAP No. 200024 of 2026
CNR: KAHC030027802026
Contractor and not by the Executive Engineer, PWP and
IWTD.
13. In view of the above discussion, we do not find
any sufficient cause for condoning the delay in preferring
the appeals. Accordingly, the applications filed by the
appellants in both appeals deserve to be rejected.
14. Accordingly, we proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
i. The applications for condonation of delay in
filing the instant appeals are rejected.
ii. Consequently, the appeals are dismissed.
Sd/-
(ASHOK S. KINAGI)
JUDGE
Sd/-
(SUBRAMANYA RANGARAO)
JUDGE
SSB
CT:PK