Lokai @ Loknath vs State of U.P.
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
LUCKNOW
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. - 890 of 2012
Lokai @ Loknath
.....Appellant(s)
Versus
State of U.P.
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Appellant(s) : Ambrish Kumar Pandey, Manoj
Kumar Tripathi
Counsel for Respondent(s) : Govt. Advocate
Court No. - 13
HON'BLE SUBHASH VIDYARTHI, J.
1. Heard Sri Ambrish Kumar Pandey, the learned counsel for the
appellant, Sri Ravi Srivastava, the learned A.G.A. appearing on
behalf of the State and perused the records.
2. By means of the instant appeal filed under Section 374(2) Cr.P.C.
the appellant has challenged the validity of the judgment and order
dated 01.05.2012, passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge
Ex Cadre, Shravasti in Session Trial No. 44 of 2010, arising out of
Case Crime no. 166 of 2008 under Sections 323/34, 308/34, 504, 506
IPC Police Station Ikauna, District Shravasti, whereby the appellant
was convicted for the offences under Sections 323 read with 34, 308
read with 34, 504, 506 IPC and he was sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for 4 years and to pay Rs. 2000/- fine for the
offence under Section 308/34 IPC, simple imprisonment for 1 year for
the offence under Section 323 IPC, simple imprisonment for 6 months
for the offence under section 504 IPC and simple imprisonment for 1
year for the offence under Section 506 IPC.
3. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that he does not
want to challenge the validity of the order of conviction and sentence
and he confined his submission for granting benefit of Section 4 of
the Probation of Offenders Act to the appellant and an application
dated 08.04.2026 has been filed with this prayer.
4. The District Probation Officer, Shravasti has sent a report as per
CRLA No. 890 of 2012
2
which the appellant is not involved in any other criminal case, his
financial and social status is normal, he does manual labour work, his
neighbours did not complain about his behavior and conduct and he
is not involved in any other criminal case. As per the report submitted
by the Superintendent District Jail Shravasti the appellant has
remained incarcerated for 2 months 15 days.
5. When the court examined the facts of the case with the object of
deciding the application for grant of benefit under Section 4 of the
Probation of Offenders Act and it transpired that the prosecution case
is that the complainant's husband Ram Chhabile was raising a wall,
the appellant started abusing him and when the complainant
objected, the appellant assaulted the complainant's husband by
hitting on his head with a spade. The complainant had suffered a
lacerated wound on her head besides a contusion on the little finger
of the left hand, an abrasion on the outer aspect of the right knee, an
abrasion on the outer aspect of the left knee and complaint of pain in
the entire body.
6. Althought, the FIR alleges that the accused persons had assaulted
on the head of the complainant's husband, but there is no evidence in
support of this contention. None of the injuries caused in the incident
have been proved to be grievous in nature.
7. Section 4 of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 provides as
under:
"4. Power of Court to release certain offenders on probation
of good conduct.-
(1) When any person is found guilty of having committed an
offence not punishable with death or imprisonment for life
and the Court by which the person is found guilty is of
opinion that, having regard to the circumstances of the
case including the nature of the offence and the character
of the offender, it is expedient to release him on probation
of good conduct, then, notwithstanding anything contained
in any other law for the time being in force, the Court may,
instead of sentencing him at once to any punishment direct
that he be released on his entering into a bond, with or
CRLA No. 890 of 2012
3
without sureties, to appear and receive sentence when
called upon during such period not exceeding three years,
as the Court may direct, and in the meantime to keep the
peace and be of good behaviour:
Provided that the Court shall not direct such release of an
offender unless it is satisfied that the offender or his surety,
if any, has a fixed place of abode or regular occupation in
the place over which the Court exercises jurisdiction or in
which the offender is likely to live during the period for
which he enters into the bond.
(2)Before making any order under sub-section (1), the
Court shall take into consideration the report, if any, of the
probation officer concerned in relation to the case.
(3)When an order under sub-section (1) is made, the Court
may, if it is of opinion that in the interests of the offender
and of the public it is expedient so to do, in addition pass a
supervision order directing that the offender shall remain
under the supervision of a probation officer named in the
order during such period, not being less than one year, as
may be specified therein, and may in such supervision
order impose such conditions as it deems necessary for the
due supervision of the offender.
(4)The Court making a supervision order under sub-section
(3) shall require the offender, before he is released, to enter
into a bond, with or without sureties, to observe the
conditions specified in such order and such additional
conditions with respect to residence, abstention from
intoxicants or any other matter as the Court may, having
regard to the particular circumstances, consider fit to
impose for preventing a repetition of the same offence or a
commission of other offences by the offender.
(5)The Court making a supervision order under sub-section
(3) shall explain to the offender the terms and conditions of
the order and shall forthwith furnish one copy of the
supervision order to each of the offenders, the sureties, if
CRLA No. 890 of 2012
4
any, and the probation officer concerned."
8. In Sunita Devi v. State of Bihar; 2024 SCC OnLine SC 984 , the
Hon'ble Supreme Court held that: -
"28. Before passing the sentence on a convict, after
rendering conviction, the Judge shall consider the feasibility
of proceeding in accordance with the provisions of Section
360 of the CrPC, 1973 which speaks of releasing a convict
on probation of good conduct or after admonition. Being a
beneficial provision dealing with a reformative aspect, it is
the bounden duty of the Judge to consider the application
of this provision before proceeding to hear the accused on
sentence. While doing so, the Judge has to hear the
accused and the prosecution. Similarly, the Court has to
apply the salient provisions contained under Sections 3, 4
and 6 of the Probation of Offenders Act, 1958 (hereinafter
referred to as "Act, 1958"). If an offence is considered as
an act against the society, the resultant action cannot be
retributive alone, as equal importance is required, if not
more, to be given to the reformative part. The ultimate goal
is to bring the accused back on the rails, to once again be a
part of society. Any attempt to ignore either Section 360 of
the CrPC, 1973 or the provisions as mandated in the Act,
1958 would make their purpose redundant. It looks as if
these laudable provisions have been lost sight of while
rendering a sentence. The ultimate objective is to prevent
the commission of such offences in future. It can never be
done by a retributive measure alone, as a change of heart
at the behest of the accused is the best way to prevent an
act of crime. Therefore, we have absolute clarity in our
mind, that a trial court is duty bound to comply with the
mandate of Section 360 of the CrPC, 1973 read with
Sections 3, 4 and 6 of the Act, 1958 before embarking into
the question of sentence. In this connection, we may note
that sub-section (10) of Section 360 of the CrPC, 1973
makes a conscious effort to remind the Judge of the rigour
of the beneficial provisions contained in the Act, 1958.
CRLA No. 890 of 2012
5
29. Hearing the accused on sentence is a valuable right
conferred on the accused. The real importance lies only
with the sentence, as against the conviction. Unfortunately,
we do not have a clear policy or legislation when it comes
to sentencing. Over the years, it has become judge-centric
and there are admitted disparities in awarding a sentence.
30. In a country like ours, sentencing accused persons
pursuant to a conviction, on a uniform pattern, would also
be prejudicial. When it comes to sentencing, there are
various factors such as age, sex, education, home life,
social background, emotional and mental conditions, caste,
religion and community that constitute aggravating and
mitigating circumstances.
31. There is a distinction between knowledge and
character. Knowledge is acquired, while character is
formed. The formation of a person's character depends
upon various factors. More often than not, a convict does
not have control over the formation of his character. This
leads to certain groups of people inheriting crime. In this
connection, we can draw an analogy from nature itself.
Before falling on the ground, rainwater remains the same. It
is the soil which changes the character of the water.
Rainwater partakes in the character of the soil, over which
it does not have any control. The issues are extremely
complex.
32. A decision of a Judge in sentencing, would vary from
person to person. This will also vary from stage to stage. It
is controlled by the mind. The environment and the
upbringing of a Judge would become the ultimate arbiter in
deciding the sentence. A Judge from an affluent
background might have a different mindset as against a
Judge from a humble one. A female Judge might look at it
differently, when compared to her male counterpart. An
Appellate Court might tinker with the sentence due to its
experience, and the external factors like institutional
constraints might come into play. Certainly, there is a crying
CRLA No. 890 of 2012
6
need for a clear sentencing policy, which should never be
judge-centric as the society has to know the basis of a
sentence.
33. Sentencing shall not be a mere lottery. It shall also not
be an outcome of a knee-jerk reaction. This is a very
important part of the Fundamental Rights conferred under
Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India. Any
unwarranted disparity would be against the very concept of
a fair trial and, therefore, against justice.
34. Various elements such as deterrence, incapacitation
and reformation should form part of sentencing. There is a
compelling need for a studied scrutiny of sentencing, to
address in particular the reformative aspect, while
maintaining equality between different groups. Perhaps,
much study is also required on the occurrence of repeat
offences, which could be attributable to certain groups. The
nexus between particular types of offences and the
offenders forming their own groups has to be taken note of
and addressed.
35. The concept of intuitive sentencing is against the rule of
law. A Judge can never have unrestrictive and unbridled
discretion, based upon his conscience formed through his
understanding of the society, without there being any
guidelines in awarding a sentence. The need for adequate
guidelines for exercising sentencing discretion, avoiding
unwanted disparity, is of utmost importance."
9. In Chellammal v. State, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 870 , it has been
held that: -
"28. Summing up the legal position, it can be said that while
an offender cannot seek an order for grant of probation as
a matter of right but having noticed the object that the
statutory provisions seek to achieve by grant of probation
and the several decisions of this Court on the point of
applicability of Section 4 of the Probation Act, we hold that,
unless applicability is excluded, in a case where the
CRLA No. 890 of 2012
7
circumstances stated in sub-section (1) of Section 4 of the
Probation Act are attracted, the court has no discretion to
omit from its consideration release of the offender on
probation; on the contrary, a mandatory duty is cast upon
the court to consider whether the case before it warrants
releasing the offender upon fulfilment of the stated
circumstances. The question of grant of probation could be
decided either way. In the event, the court in its discretion
decides to extend the benefit of probation, it may upon
considering the report of the probation officer impose such
conditions as deemed just and proper. However, if the
answer be in the negative, it would only be just and proper
for the court to record the reasons therefore.
29. For the foregoing reasons and in the light of the factual
matrix, we are unhesitatingly of the opinion that the
Sessions Judge and the High Court by omitting to consider
whether the appellants were entitled to the benefit of
probation, occasioned a failure of justice. Consequently,
there was no worthy consideration as to whether the
appellants could be extended the benefit of probation."
10. Section 11 of the Probation of Offenders Act provides that the
High Court may also order release of a convict on probation when the
case come before it in appeal.
11. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the applicant
is first offender, which fact is not disputed by the learned AGA and
the learned AGA has not pointed out involvement of the appellant in
any other criminal case.
12. The nature of allegations and the maximum sentence carried by
the offences is such as admits of granting benefit under Section 4 of
the Probation of Offenders Act.
13. As a period of more than one decade stands elapsed since the
appellant was sentenced, during which period the appellant is not
said to have committed any other offence, which period far exceeds
the maximum period of probation of three years provided in Section 4
of the Probation of Offenders Act, there is no need to keep the
CRLA No. 890 of 2012
8
appellant under probation for any further period.
14. Accordingly, the present appeal is disposed off while upholding
the conviction of the appellant and granting him the benefit of
Probation of Offenders Act, 1958. The appellant is directed to deposit
the amount of fine within a period of two weeks from today.
November 13, 2026
Ram.
(Subhash Vidyarthi,J.)
Whether the judgment is speaking: Yes
Whether the judgment is reportable: No
(Subhash Vidyarthi,J.)
Digitally signed by :-
RAM SINGH
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad,
Lucknow Bench