Narinder Singh vs STATE OF HP
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
2026:HHC:50261
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA.
High Court of H.P.
CWPOA No.1767 of 2019
th
Decided on: 18 November, 2026
Narinder Singh ...Petitioner
versus
State of H.P. and others ...Respondents
Coram
Hon’ble Mr.Justice Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge.
1
Whether approved for reporting? Yes.
_______________________________________________
For the petitioner: Mr. Dheeraj K. Verma, Advocate.
For the respondents: Mr. Amandeep Sharma,
Additional Advocate General.
Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge (Oral)
The petitioner by way of present petition has prayed for
the following substantive reliefs:-
“i. That in view of the Provisions of Notification/letters dated 01-
09-1998 Annexure P-14, Annexure P-16 , dated 13-12-2000,
Annexure P-17 dated 9-01-2007 and Annexure P-18 dated
11-4-2007 the orders passed by the Respondents vide
impugned Annexure P-15 dated 21-09-2010 may kindly be
quashed and set aside and respondents may kindly be
directed to place the Petitioner in the higher Scale of Rs.
4550-7220 with the designation as Technician Gd-1 w.e.f. 01-
01-1996.
ii. That the office order dated 02-07-2002 Annexure P-23 issued
on the basis of combined seniority list of different trades
Annexure P-24 may kindly be quashed and set aside as this
seniority list has wrongly been drawn in contravention of the
Notification issued on 30-08-1997 Annexure P-12 , and
Notification dated 01-09-1998Annexure P-14 and 14A as
Annexure P-12 provides that the trade/Job specification of the
Mechanics were to be shown separately in the bracket and
Annexure P-14 and 14A provides that the ratio as mentioned
1
Whether the reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
2
in column 5 of the Notification was to be applied trade wise
separately for the placement in the higher scale.
iii. That the Respondents may kindly be directed to draw the
trade wise seniority separately as per the notification dated 01-
09-1998 Annexure P-14 and 14A and place the Petitioner in
the higher scale of Rs. 4550-7220 w.e.f. 01-01-1996 in
pursuance of the provisions of Annexure P-16,P-17 and P-18
as he was the senior most in the trade of Mechanic cum Fitter
of Machinery.
iv. That alternatively, if the joint Seniority of mechanic-cum-fitter
is to be taken into account, in that event the Petitioner humbly
prays that the respondents may kindly be directed to place the
Petitioner in the higher scale from the date his junior was
allowed the pay scale of Rs. 4550-7220 or at least from the
date Shri Nihal Chand Mechanic-cum-fitter was retired from
service w.e.f. 31-7-2004.Because as per combined seniority
list the Petitioner is at serial No.4 and first 3 persons above
him have already been granted the scale of Rs. 4550-7220.
Therefore, on the retirement of Sh. Nihal Chand he was the
senior most to be placed in the scale of Rs. 4550-7220.
v. That the Respondents may kindly be directed to grant all the
consequential benefit to the petitioner i.e. Pay and allowance
in accordance with law after fixing the Pay of the petitioner
w.e.f.1-1-1996 or from the date Shri Nihal chand has been
retired i.e. 31-07-2004.”
2. Shorn of unnecessary details, the key facts of the case
High Court of H.P.
are that the petitioner did his diploma in the trade of Turner in the
year 1974. Thereafter, he was appointed on daily wage basis as
Mechanic/Fitter in the Mechanical Sub-Division HPPWD Chamba, as
is evident from a perusal of Annexure P-2. The petitioner being
qualified for the post of Mechanic-cum-Fitter was recommended by
the Departmental Promotion Committee (in short ‘DPC’) in its
meeting held on 28.06.1978 for the post of Mechanic-cum-Fitter, as
is evident from a perusal of letter dated 30.06.1978 (Annexure P-4)
issued by respondent No.3 and appointment was offered to him vide
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
3
office order dated 12.07.1978 (Annexure P-5) on regular/work
High Court of H.P.
charge basis in the pay scale of Rs.100-160/- plus usual allowances.
The petitioner was asked to look after and repair the various
bulldozers, JCBs and air compressors vide office order dated
26.10.2006 (Annexure P-6).
3. The Government of Himachal Pradesh issued office
Memorandum dated 14.01.1981 (Annexure P-8), whereby the
Schedule earlier issued was amended and pay scale of the post of
General Mechanic/Mechanic/Fitter, was revised from Rs.100-160/- to
Rs.400-660/- and the nomenclature of the post was also changed as
‘Mechanic’. Thereafter, the pay scale was again revised as per
Notification dated 30.08.1997 (Annexure P-12) to Rs.950-1800/-
with initial start of Rs.1000/- with effect from 01.01.1986. As per
this Notification, various posts of skilled and semi-skilled categories
including the post of Mechanic were designated as Junior Technician
and further the irrespective trade/job specification were to be
indicated in bracket i.e. Junior Technician (Plumber), (Painter) and
so on.
4. The Government of Himachal Pradesh issued
Notification on 01.09.1998 (Annexure P-14), when the Himachal
Pradesh Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 1998 were amended and
the skilled and semi-skilled categories of Junior Technician,
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
4
Technician Grade-III and Technician Grade-II were granted the pay
High Court of H.P.
scale of Rs.3120-5160/-, Rs.4020-6200/- and Rs.4550-7220/- in the
ratio of 50:30:20 respectively. Further, as per the ratio given in the
second schedule mentioned in column No.5 against each category
was to be followed for having posts of different levels of Technicians
in each trade separately. If in a cadre, the existing posts of higher
level/levels fall short of the norms, upgradation shall be done, so as
to satisfy the general norms without exceeding the total strength.
5. The precise grievance of the petitioner is that he had
joined the services on 12.07.1978 and was initially appointed as
Mechanic-cum-Fitter in September, 1974 and deployed to lookafter
the machinery with job specifications of fittings of parts and repair
of machinery and since he was the senior most in his trade of
Mechanic-cum-Fitter of light and heavy machinery, he was entitled
to be placed in the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- instead of Rs.4020-
6200/- as on 01.01.1996.The respondents did not place him in the
pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- and the placement of Mechanic-cum-
Fitter with the trade of Motor Mechanic and Blacksmith in the scale
of Rs.4550-7220/- is wrong and further the persons, who had joined
after him such as S/Sh. Satish Kumar and Mahima Nand, Mechanic-
cum-Fitter, having trade of Motor Mechanic with job specification as
Motor Mechanic on 30.06.1987 and 26.10.1987 respectively were
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
5
placed in the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- on 01.08.2004 and
High Court of H.P.
01.01.1996 and one Shri Atma Ram, who was in the trade of
Blacksmith with job specification as Blacksmith and joined the
regular service on 21.02.1992 has also been placed in the higher
grade of Rs.4550-7220/- with effect from 01.01.1996. Since the
petitioner was not given the benefit as per his trade/job
specification, though he was senior most in the cadre of Mechanic-
cum-Fitter of light and motor machinery, he was deprived of his
placement in the higher pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- with effect
from 01.01.1996. Further, he has been discriminated by respondents
No.3 and 4 by wrongly applying the provisions of the Notifications
dated 30.08.1997 and 01.09.1998 (Annexures P-12 and P-14)
respectively.
6. The petitioner feeling aggrieved by the action on the
part of the respondents, had made a representation highlighting his
grievances. However, the representation made by him was rejected
by respondent No.3, vide letter dated 21.09.2010 (Annexure P-15),
on the ground that as per the seniority list of Mechanic-cum-Fitter
received from the Division, Shri Pritam Singh, Mechanic-cum-Fitter
had joined the service on 11.07.1978, whereas the petitioner joined
his service on 12.07.1978. Shri Pritam Singh was allowed the benefit
of pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- with effect from 01.01.1996 and the
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
6
petitioner was allowed the benefit of pay scale of Rs.4020-6200/- in
High Court of H.P.
the ratio of 20:30:50and there is no irregularity in the pay scale. It
has further been averred that the respondents have wrongly
rejected the representation and the placement in the pay scale of
Rs.4550-7220/- cannot be treated as promotion.
7. The petitioner has placed on record the combined
seniority list of Mechanic-cum-Fitters, wherein the employees have
been allowed the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- to first three persons
in the seniority and pay scale of Rs.4020-6200/- to next four
persons having the designation of Mechanic-cum-Fitter. The
respondents have drawn combined seniority list of Mechanic-cum-
Fitters with different trades, which is against the orders issued by
the respondents. Since the petitioner has not been granted the
higher pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- preferred the present petition.
8. The petitioner feeling aggrieved by non-grant of the pay
scale of Rs.4550-7220/- to him has approached this Court by way of
instant petition inter alia on the grounds that as per the Notification
dated 30.08.1997, each category shall be followed for having posts
of different levels of Technicians in each grade separately and the
respondents have not followed the said norms. The petitioner has
wrongly been paid the pay scale of Rs.4020-6200/- instead of
Rs.4550-7220/-. He has further averred that S/Sh.Satish Kumar and
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
7
Mahima Nand, Technicians with Motor Mechanic trade, who had
High Court of H.P.
joined the services on 30.06.1987 and 26.10.1987 respectively and
Shri Atma Ram Blacksmith, who had joined the service in the year
1992 were allowed the benefit of higher pay scale of Rs.4550-7220
with designation as Technician Grade-I, whereas, the petitioner,
who was appointed as Mechanic-cum-Fitter on 12.07.1978, has been
denied the said pay scale, which is illegal and as such prayed for the
abovesaid reliefs.
9. The respondents filed reply to the petition and in
preliminary submissions averred that the petitioner was engaged
with the respondent-Department during the year 1974 as daily
waged Mechanic-cum-Fitter having a diploma of Turner from
Industrial Training Institute, Chamba and continued as such till his
regularization on 30.06.1978 in the pay scale of Rs.100-160/- and
thereafter, in the revised corresponding pay scales revised by the
Government of Himachal Pradesh from time to time. After the
implementation of pay revision in 1996, several skilled and semi-
skilled categories were re-designated as Junior Technician,
Technician Grade-III and Technician Grade-II and 29 such
categories were given ascending pay scale in the ratio of 50:30:20
and 20% employees of the cadre in the pyramid receiving highest
pay scale. As per Notification of the Finance Department
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
8
No.Fin(PR)B(7)-1/98 dated 01.09.1998, the Junior Technicians, who
High Court of H.P.
were getting the pay scale of Rs.950-1800/- were granted the pay
scale of Rs.3120-5160/-, Technician Grade-III pay scale of Rs.4020-
6200/- and Technician Grade-II pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- in the
ratio of 50:30:20 respectively. Rules notified on 05.05.1995 with
respect to Mechanic-cum-Fitter Grade-I (Fitter Grade-IV, Diesel Auto
Motor Mechanic, Mechanic-cum-Fitter) were repealed and new Rules
were framed under category of Junior Technician, vide Notification
dated 02.08.2011 and the mode of promotion under the Rules has
been provided 40% by direct recruitment on regular basis or on
contract basis and 60% by promotion. Thus, with effect from
01.01.1996, the cadre of Junior Technician (Mechanic-cum-Fitter
Grade-I) has been bifurcated in the ratio of 20:30:50. According to
the Notification, 20% Technicians shall be placed in the pay scale of
Rs.4550-7220/- with designation as Technician Grade-I, 30% in the
higher scale of Rs.4020-6200/- with designation as Technician
Grade-II and remaining 50% in the pay scale of Rs.3120-5160/-
with designation as Junior Technician in the trade. The placement is
to be done strictly on the basis of seniority of the incumbent as
Junior Technician (Mechanic). As per the seniority list of Mechanic-
cum-Fitter drawn on 01.01.1996, the petitioner in fact is junior to
one Shri Pritam Singh Mechanic-cum-Fitter, because he has joined
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
9
the respondent-Department on 12.07.1978 and Shri Pritam Singh
High Court of H.P.
joined on 11.07.1978. As per the Notification of 01.01.1996, Shri
Pritam Singh has been allowed the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/-
being senior to the petitioner, whereas, the petitioner has been
placed in the pay scale of Rs.4020-6200 in the ratio of 20:30:50.
The petitioner is not entitled to the post of Mechanic-cum-Fitter
Grade-I, because as per the provisions of R&P Rules, he does not
possess the requisite qualification of Motor Mechanic, which fact has
already been explained in Annexure P-15 appended with the
petition. However, the petitioner has now been granted the pay
scale of Mechanic-cum-Fitter Grade-I now Technician Grade-I of
Rs.10300-34800/- with effect from 01.10.2012 by the Executive
Engineer, Chamba Division vide office order dated 12.04.2013
(Annexure R-1) and has been placed as Technician Grade-I in the
pre-revised scale of Rs.4550-7220 and placed in the pay scale of
Rs.10300-34800/- with effect from 01.10.2012.
10. On merits, the similar averments have been reiterated.
It has further been averred that though S/Sh. Satish Kumar and
Mahima Nand were junior to the petitioner, but they were having
diploma in Motor Mechanic at the relevant time, whereas the
petitioner is having diploma in Turner and since he does not possess
the requisite qualification as per the provisions of R&P Rules, he is
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
10
not entitled to higher pay scale of Technician Grade-II and as such
High Court of H.P.
dismissal of the writ petition has been prayed for by the
respondents.
11. The petitioner filed rejoinder to the reply filed by the
respondents and controverted the facts.
12. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and
also perused the record carefully.
13. As per the reply filed by the respondents, the petitioner
was engaged with the respondent-Department in the year 1974 as a
daily wage Mechanic-cum-Fitter having diploma of Turner and
continued as such till his regularization on 30.06.1978. Though, in
the rejection order dated 21.09.2010 (Annexure P-15), it has been
mentioned that the petitioner had joined on 12.07.1978 and Shri
Pritam Singh Mechanic-cum-Fitter had joined on 11.07.1978, but
once the respondents in the reply have admitted that the petitioner
was regularized on 30.06.1978, he cannot be said to be junior to
Shri Pritam Singh Mechanic-cum-Fitter, simply on the basis of his
joining. The petitioner was already serving with the respondent-
Department since 1974 which fact has not been denied. As per the
Notification dated 01.09.1998, the categories of skilled and semi-
skilled were classified as Junior Technicians, Technician Grade-III
and Technician Grade-II and were granted the pay scale of Rs.3120-
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
11
5160/-, Rs.4020-6200/- and Rs.4550-7220 in the ratio of 50:30:20
High Court of H.P.
and the ratio as given in the column No.5 against each category
shall be followed for having posts of different levels of Technicians
in each trade separately. The petitioner, who was appointed as
Mechanic as per the recommendations of the DPC convened on
28.06.1978 as Mechanic-cum-Fitter, could not have been denied the
pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- by not classifying his category as per
the ibid Notification even if his past service rendered w.e.f.
September, 1974 is ignored.
14. The respondents while filing reply to the petition have
not disputed the averments made in para 8 of the petition wherein
it has specifically been mentioned that S/Sh. Satish Kumar and
Mahima Nand, Mechanic-cum-Fitter having trade of Motor Mechanic
with job specification as Motor Mechanic, who joined the
Department on 30.06.1987 and 26.10.1987 respectively have been
granted the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- on 01.08.2004 and
01.01.1996 respectively and one Shri Atma Ram, who was in the
trade of Blacksmith with job specification as Blacksmith and joined
regular service on 21.02.1992 has also been placed in the higher
grade pay of Rs.4550-7220/- with effect from 01.01.1996. In reply
to paras 15 and 16 of the petition, the respondents have admitted
that as on 01.01.1996, though S/Sh. Satish Kumar and Mahima
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
12
Nand were junior to the petitioner, but they have the diploma in
High Court of H.P.
Motor Mechanic at the relevant time, whereas the petitioner was
having the diploma of Turner. Since the petitioner was not
possessing the requisite qualification as per the provision of the R&P
Rules, he was not entitled to higher pay scale of Technician Grade-I.
However, he became eligible to higher pay scale of Technician
Grade-I w.e.f. 01.10.2012, which stood granted to him as per office
order dated 12.04.2013.
15. As per the Notification dated 01.09.1998(Annexure P-
14), when the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules,
1998 were amended, the pay scale was not given on the basis of
the qualification of the Junior Technicians, but it was given on the
basis of the cadre strength of the Junior Technicians in the ratio of
50:30:20. Earlier the post of Junior Technician was classified as
Junior Technician, Technician Grade-III and Technician Grade-II in
the pay scale of Rs.3120-5160, 4020-6200 and 4550-7220 in the
ratio of 50:30:20. However, later on these posts were classified as
Junior Technician, Technician Grade-II and Technician Grade-I in
the pay scale of Rs.3120-5160, Rs.4020-6200 and Rs.4550-7220/- in
the same ratio of 50:30:20. Once the pay scale was based on the
cadre strength and not on the basis of the qualification, as now
projected by the respondents in the reply, the petitioner had joined
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
13
earlier to S/Sh. Satish Kumar and Mahima Nand, who are admittedly
High Court of H.P.
junior to him and, therefore, he could not have been denied the pay
scale of Rs.4550-7220/- as granted to S/Sh. Satish Kumar and
Mahima Nand.
16. The respondents have not even disputed the proforma
placed by the petitioner along with Annexure P-15 (at page 82),in
which Sh. Satish Kumar and Mahima Nand have been shown to have
joined the services on 30.06.1987 and 26.10.1987 respectively and
they have been granted the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- with effect
from 01.01.1996 and 01.08.2004respectively. Even Atma Ram, who
is at serial No.10 in this proforma, was appointed as Blacksmith on
01.02.1992 and he too, was granted the pay scale of Rs.4550-
7220/-. Since S/Sh. Satish Kumar and Mahima Nand, who were
appointed as Mechanic-cum-Fitter after the petitioner, having been
granted the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/-, the petitioner who
admittedly joined the respondent-Department prior to them could
not have been denied the said pay scale and thus, the action on the
part of the respondents to deny the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- to
the petitioner and further rejecting his representation is illegal,
arbitrary and discriminatory.
17. Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance
upon the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Gurcharan
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
14
Singh Grewal and another vs. Punjab State Electricity Board
High Court of H.P.
& others, (2009) 3 SCC 94 and Union of India and others vs.
C.R. Madhava Murthy and another, (2022) 6 SCC 183 and
contends that once the petitioner had joined the respondent-
Department earlier to S/Sh. Satish Kumar and Mahima Nand and is
senior to them, he could not have been granted the less pay scale.
18. As per the aforementioned judgments, it has been held
that a senior cannot be paid lesser salary than the junior and in the
present case, once the respondents have not disputed the factum of
appointments of S/Sh. Satish Kumar and Mahima Nand after the
petitioner and they are junior to him, he could not have been denied
the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- as was given to them and as such,
the petitioner is held entitled to the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/-
instead of Rs.4020-6200/-with effect from 01.01.1996, when this
pay scale was given to his junior.
19. Learned Additional Advocate General has vehemently
argued that since the petitioner was not having the requisite
qualification and S/Sh. Satish Kumar and Mahima Nand, though
were junior to him, but were having diploma in Motor Mechanic,
were granted the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/-. However, the said
contention cannot be accepted for the simple reason that as per the
Notification dated 01.09.1998, it is not stipulated that the pay scale
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
15
of Rs.4550-7220/- has to be given on the basis of the qualification
High Court of H.P.
as now portrayed in the reply as well as in the arguments advanced
by learned Additional Advocate General. The pay scales of Rs.3120-
5160/-, Rs.4020-6200/- and Rs.4550-7220/- are given to the Junior
Technician in the ratio of 50:30:20 on the basis of the seniority of
Junior Technicians. The senior most Junior Technicians, who are
designated as Technicians Grade-I, are given the pay scale of
Rs.4550-7220/-in the ratio of 20%, thereafter the Junior
Technicians, who are designated as Technicians Grade-II are given
the pay scale of Rs.4020-6200/- in the ratio of 30% and rest of the
Junior Technicians are given the pay scale of Rs.3120-5160/-. The
above pay scales are not given on the basis of the qualification and
as such, the contention raised by the learned Additional Advocate
General that the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- was to be given on the
basis of qualification as prescribed in the R&P Rules is ill founded
and thus rejected.
20. Learned Additional Advocate General has further
strenuously argued that since the petitioner was junior to Shri
Pritam Singh, he is not entitled to the pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/-.
However, the said contention cannot be accepted for the reason
that the respondents while filing reply to the petition have admitted
that other persons namely S/Sh. Satish Kumar, Mahima Nand,
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS
2026:HHC:50261
16
Mechanic-cum-Fitter and Atma Ram Blacksmith, who were
High Court of H.P.
appointed after the petitioner were granted the pay scale of
Rs.4550-7220. Once juniors to the petitioner have been granted
higher pay scale, the petitioner cannot be given less pay scale and
thus, the respondents have treated the petitioner arbitrarily and
discriminatorily. Therefore, rejection of his claim vide order dated
21.09.2019 is wrong and illegal and as such, the impugned order is
quashed and set aside.
21. Consequently, the present petition is partly allowed and
the order dated 21.09.2010 (Annexure P-15) is quashed and set
aside and the respondents are directed to grant the petitioner the
pay scale of Rs.4550-7220/- with effect from 01.01.1996 with all
consequential benefits, except the monetary benefits, which shall be
paid to him three years prior to the date of institution of the present
petition. In case, the arrears are not paid to the petitioner within a
period of three months from today, the respondents shall pay
interest thereon at the rate of 6% per annum from today till actual
payment. No order as to costs. Pending applications, if any, also
stand disposed of.
( Jiya Lal Bhardwaj )
th
18 November, 2026 Judge
(naveen)
::: Downloaded on - 20/11/2026 18:50:21 :::CIS