MOHD YAMIN ALI vs STATE OF UTTARAKHAND THROUGH DISTRICT MAGISTRATE,
- Court
- Uttarakhand High Court
UKHC010030372021
2026:UHC:10573-DB
Office Notes,
reports, orders
or proceedings
or directions
and Registrar’s
order with
Signatures
SL.
Date
No.
COURT’S OR JUDGE’S ORDERS
SPA/112/2021
Mohd Yamin Ali … Petitioner
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand Through District
Magistrate, … Respondent
Hon’ble Manoj Kumar Tiwari, ACJ
Hon’ble Subhash Upadhyay, J.
1. None present for the appellant.
2. Mr. Ranjan Ghildiyal, learned
Standing Counsel for the State of
Uttarakhand.
3. This intra-court appeal is directed
against judgment and order dated
22.02.2021 rendered by learned Single
Judge in WPMS No. 344 of 2021. By the
said judgment, challenge thrown by
appellant to an order dated 05.02.2021
rd
passed by 3 Additional District Judge,
Dehradun in Land Acquisition
Miscellaneous Case No. 786 of 2019, was
rejected. Operative portion of the
impugned judgment is reproduced
below:-
“ 4. There had been a subsequent rival
contention, which had been raised by the
petitioner by approaching this Court, by filing a
writ petition, being Writ Petition No.605 of 2011
(M/S), Mohd. Yamin Ali vs. State of Uttarakhand,
who claimed himself to be the President of
respondent no.2, herein, wherein the said writ
petition was decided by the Coordinate Bench of
this Court by the judgment dated 20.05.2019,
whereby the controversial issue, about the
petitioner’s entitlement to receive the
compensation, as a consequence of the conclusion
of the Land Acquisition, in the capacity of being
the President and as to whether the alleged
Secretary of the Society, Mrs. Leela Negi, would
be entitled to receive the compensation, since was
UKHC010030372021
2026:UHC:10573-DB
a disputed question of fact, the Coordinate Bench
of this Court by a judgment of 20.05.2019, had
directed the petitioner to file a regular civil suit to
get the matter decided. The Coordinate Bench by
the judgment of 20.05.2019, had granted liberty
to the petitioner to file a suit within two months
from the said date failing which the amount was
directed to be released in favour of the Society in
terms of the impugned order, which was
challenged therein dated 03.03.2011, the
following observation was made by the learned
Single Judge:-
“On failure on the part of the petitioner to file
the suit within two months, the amount, as
aforesaid, shall be released in favour of the
society in terms of the impugned order dated
03.03.2011.”
5. As against this judgment, the petitioner had
preferred a review petition, which was too
dismissed on 12.10.2020. Against the aforesaid,
two judgments, which were rendered in Writ
Petition No.605 of 2011 (M/S), admittedly a
special appeal, being Special Appeal No.312 of
2020 filed by the petitioner, is pending
consideration, without there being any interim
order passed by the Division Bench in favour of
the petitioner. Consequent thereto and further in
the spirit of the judgment of 20.05.2019, which
was rendered by the Coordinate Bench, that on
there being a failure on part of the petitioner to
file a suit to determine an inter-se rights between
the Secretary, Leela Negi and the present
petitioner as its President, as to who would be
entitled to receive the compensation, since no suit
was instituted within the aforesaid period of two
months, as directed therein by the judgment of
20.05.2019. The award was put to execution and
the awarded amount has yet again been directed
to be released in pursuance to the impugned order
dated 05.02.2021, which was rendered by the
court of IIIrd A.D.J. in Misc. Case No.786 of 2019,
Audyogik Avam Shaikshik Sansthan vs. State of
Uttarakhand and others. It is this order, which has
been put to challenge by the petitioner and quite
obviously, since it is an order, which was passed
by the Subordinate Court, the writ petition has
been preferred by the petitioner under Article 227
of the Constitution of India, for the purposes of
exercising its supervisory jurisdiction, over the
order impugned passed by the subordinate courts
in a proceedings, which are contemplated under
the special statute. The impugned order under
challenge dated 05.02.2021, would automatically
UKHC010030372021
2026:UHC:10573-DB
fall to be, a decision taken, as a consequence of
the compliance of the judgment of this Court
dated 20.05.2019, which was passed by the
Coordinate Bench directing the disbursement of
the money.
6. The recourse to filing of a writ petition, by
giving a challenge to the said order would be
nothing, but a cumulative and a successive
invoking the forum of the writ courts without
getting the factual aspect being determined in the
regular proceedings of the suit as was directed by
the judgment of 20.05.2019 and it cannot be ruled
out that institution of the present writ petition is
nothing, but a reagitation of an issue of
entitlement of the compensation, which otherwise
has already been directed to be adjudicated at the
behest of the petitioner, by filing a regular suit,
which has not been done till date. Consequently,
the impugned order, which has been passed by
the court of IIIrd Additional District Judge,
Dehradun dated 05.02.2021 is in league with the
judgment of 20.05.2019.”
4. By order dated 05.02.2021, learned
rd
3 , Additional District Judge, Dehradun
allowed the prayer for withdrawal of the
amount of compensation in favour of
Secretary of the Society, named as,
‘Audyogik Avam Shaikshik Sansthan’
(respondent no. 3), with the condition
that she will have to give an undertaking
and affidavit, that in case, any contrary
order is passed by the High Court, then
she will be liable to refund the amount of
₹54,50,775/-.
5. Since appellant challenged an order
rd
passed by learned 3 Additional District
Judge in a land acquisition case,
therefore, special appeal would not be
maintainable against a judgment
rendered by learned Single Judge while
exercising power of superintendence
under Article 227 of the Constitution.
Thus, we find force in the submission of
learned State Counsel that intra-court
appeal would not be maintainable in view
of express provision contained in Chapter
UKHC010030372021
2026:UHC:10573-DB
VIII Rule 5 of the Rules of the Court. For
ready reference, CHAPTER VIII Rule 5 of
the Rules, 1952, is extracted below:-
Chapter VIII
“
5. Special appeal.—An appeal shall lie to the Court
from a judgment (not being a judgment passed in
the exercise of appellate jurisdiction) in respect of
a decree or order made by a Court subject to the
superintendence of the Court and not being an
order made in the exercise of revisional
jurisdiction or in the exercise of its power of
superintendence or in the exercise of criminal
jurisdiction [or in the exercise of the jurisdiction
conferred by Article 226 or Article 227 of the
Constitution in respect of any judgment, order or
award - (a) of a tribunal, Court or statutory
arbitrator made or purported to be made in the
exercise or purported exercise of jurisdiction under
any Uttarakhand Act or under any Central Act,
with respect to any of the matters enumerated in
the State List or the Concurrent List in the
Seventh Schedule to the Constitution, or (b) of the
Government or any officer or authority, made or
purported to be made in the exercise or purported
exercise of appellate or revisional jurisdiction
under any such Act of one Judge.”
6. Learned Single Judge was dealing
with a writ petition, in which an order
passed by a judicial forum was
challenged, thus it can be safely inferred
that it was a petition under Article 227 of
the Constitution. Thus, in the view of the
express provision contained in CHAPTER
VIII Rule 5 of Rules of the Court, 1952,
the special appeal would not be
maintainable.
7. Accordingly, the special appeal is
dismissed, as not maintainable.
(Subhash Upadhyay, J.) (Manoj Kumar Tiwari, ACJ)
19.11.2026
Aswal
NITI RAJ SINGH ASWAL
Digitally signed by NITI RAJ SINGH ASWAL DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, 2.5.4.20=eacc6757ee7881e933ff8934f07477005aa85f9802a3a08b08d1369512ea30f3, postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND, serialNumber=44EB54CBF00B7698CB6F10C2CE3D26F5C22DACF4F4610C1FE58A58531726FBB0, cn=NITI RAJ SINGH ASWAL Date: 2026.11.19 20:47:10 -08'00'