Reliance General Insurance Co Ltd vs Supinder Kaur & Ors

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

FAO-5505-2014 (O&M) &
XOBJC-210-CII-2015
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH



i) FAO-5505-2014 (O&M)


Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. ...Appellant
Versus
Supinder Kaur and others ...Respondents
ii) XOBJC-210-CII-2015


Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. ...Appellant
Versus
Supinder Kaur and others ...Respondents

Reserved on: 17.11.2026

Pronounced on: 18.11.2026
Pronounced fully/operative part: Fully

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK GUPTA

Argued by: Mr. Sanjeev Kodan, Advocate for the appellant.

Mr. Neeraj Khanna, Advocate and
Mr. Inderjit Sharma, Advocate
for respondents No.1 to 4 – Cross objector.


DEEPAK GUPTA, J.
This order shall dispose of the appeal filed by Insurer - Reliance
General Insurance Company Limited seeking reduction of compensation
awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Rupnagar (hereinafter
referred to as 'the Tribunal'), vide award dated 01.05.2014, as well as the cross-
objections filed by the claimants seeking enhancement thereof. The cross-
objections are accompanied by an application under Section 5 of the Limitation
Act seeking condonation of delay of 298 days.
2. Briefly, on 19.06.2013, Luvpreet Singh, aged about 19 years, was
travelling on Activa scooter bearing registration No.CH-49-T-2354, along with
pillion rider Amritpal Singh. When they reached near Theme Park, Chamkaur
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 15:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 1 of Total 8 Pages

FAO-5505-2014 (O&M) &
XOBJC-210-CII-2015
Sahib, container truck bearing registration No.HP-12-D-9758, driven by
respondent Ayub Khan, struck against the scooter, resulting in fatal injuries to
Luvpreet Singh. FIR No.102 dated 19.06.2013 was registered at Police Station
Chamkaur Sahib, under Sections 279, 334 & 304-A IPC.
3. The parents and two sisters of the deceased filed a claim petition
under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, pleading that the deceased
was pursuing a Diploma in Civil Engineering and was also running a utensils
shop, earning ₹15,000 per month. It was further pleaded that his prospective
income after completion of the diploma would have been ₹30,000 per month.
4. The Tribunal, after appreciating the evidence, held that the
accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the offending truck.
However, the alleged income from the utensils shop was not found proved.
Considering that the deceased was pursuing a Diploma in Civil Engineering, his
notional monthly income was assessed at ₹6,000. After deducting 50%
towards personal expenses and applying multiplier 18, compensation of
₹6,48,000 towards loss of dependency was assessed. A further sum of ₹10,000
towards transportation and last rites was awarded, making a total of
₹6,58,000, along with interest at 9% per annum from the date of filing of the
claim petition till its realization. The compensation was apportioned equally
between the parents, whereas the claim of the two sisters was declined.
5. Learned counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company submits
that the Tribunal has assessed the income of the deceased on the higher side.
It is contended that Ex.P2 establishes that the deceased had secured
admission to the first year of Diploma in Civil Engineering only on 06.06.2013,
merely 13 days before the accident. There was no evidence of his actual
earnings or any assured employment after completion of the course.
6. Conversely, learned counsel for the claimants submits that the
Tribunal failed to adequately appreciate the future earning potential of the
deceased and awarded inadequate compensation. Reliance is placed upon
Gurmit Kaur and others v. Daljit Singh and another, 2026 Law Finder (P&H)
966 .
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 15:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 2 of Total 8 Pages

FAO-5505-2014 (O&M) &
XOBJC-210-CII-2015
7. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
Application for condonation of delay
8. Before examining the merits, the application seeking condonation
of delay of 298 days in filing the cross-objections requires consideration.
9. It is pleaded in the application that the insurer's appeal was listed
before this Court on 14.08.2014, whereafter notice was issued to the
claimants. Upon receipt of notice in October 2014, the claimants approached
their counsel. However, the complete record, including the award, remained
with their counsel before the Tribunal, and only the grounds of appeal were
initially supplied. Subsequently, upon obtaining the complete file on
25.08.2015, the claimants were advised to file cross-objections, resulting in the
aforesaid delay. It is pleaded that the delay was neither intentional nor wilful.
10. It is well settled that the expression 'sufficient cause' occurring in
Section 5 of the Limitation Act must receive a justice-oriented interpretation.
However, the applicant must establish a bona fide explanation, and mere
negligence or inaction cannot constitute sufficient cause. Reference may be
made to Collector, Land Acquisition, Anantnag and another v. Mst. Katiji and
and
others, (1987) 2 SCC 107, Esha Bhattacharjee v. Managing Committee of
Raghunathpur Nafar Academy and others, (2013) 12 SCC 649 .
11. In the present case, the explanation furnished by the claimants is
not entirely satisfactory, particularly regarding the time taken to obtain the
complete record and seek appropriate legal advice. Nevertheless, the
claimants had entered appearance in the insurer's appeal, and the controversy
regarding assessment of compensation was already pending before this Court.
The cross-objections arise from the same award and involve substantially the
same material. Considering the nature of the proceedings, the explanation
furnished and the fact that the controversy can be finally adjudicated without
causing any substantial prejudice to the insurer, this Court considers it
appropriate to adopt a liberal approach.
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 15:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 3 of Total 8 Pages

FAO-5505-2014 (O&M) &
XOBJC-210-CII-2015
12. Accordingly, the application is allowed and the delay of 298 days
in filing the cross-objections is condoned. However, to balance the equities,
the claimants shall not be entitled to any interest on the enhanced
compensation for the aforesaid period of 298 days attributable to the delayed
filing of cross-objections.
Merits of the appeal and cross-objections
13. The finding of the Tribunal regarding rash and negligent driving of
the offending truck is based upon the testimony of Kuldeep Singh (PW1), who
witnessed the accident. His testimony remained unrebutted, as the driver of
the offending truck did not enter the witness box. The insurer has also failed to
establish any violation of the terms and conditions of the insurance policy.
Consequently, the findings regarding negligence and liability call for no
interference.
14. The main controversy concerns the assessment of notional
income of the deceased. Admittedly, he was 19 years old and had secured
admission to the first year of Diploma in Civil Engineering at Baba Banda
Bahadur Polytechnic College, Fatehgarh Sahib, on 06.06.2013, as established
by Ex.P2. The accident occurred on 19.06.2013. Thus, the deceased had barely
commenced his technical education.
15. In Arjun Kumar Aggarwal v. New India Assurance Company
Limited and others, 2023 Law Finder (SC) 1042; and Kandasami and others v.
Lindabriyal and another, 2023 ACJ 1653 , the Hon'ble Supreme Court
recognized the relevance of professional qualifications and prospective
earning capacity while determining just compensation. Similarly, in S.
Mohammed Hakim v. National Insurance Company Limited and others, 2025
AIR SC 3495, the earning prospects of an engineering student were considered
in the context of permanent disability. However, the assessment of income in
such cases necessarily depends upon the educational qualifications, stage of
studies, academic record and other circumstances established on record.
16. In
Deepak Singh @ Deepak Chauhan v. Mukesh Kumar and
others , AIR 2025 SC 1094 , the Hon'ble Supreme Court reiterated that the
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 15:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 4 of Total 8 Pages

FAO-5505-2014 (O&M) &
XOBJC-210-CII-2015
notional income of an engineering student should not be mechanically
equated with minimum wages payable to an unskilled worker. Nevertheless,
the assessment must remain realistic and cannot be founded upon
conjectures.
17. Learned counsel for the claimants has particularly relied upon
Gurmit Kaur and others v. Daljit Singh and another (supr) wherein this Court
assessed the monthly income of a deceased student pursuing a Diploma in
Civil Engineering at ₹12,000. However, the facts of the said case are materially
distinguishable. The deceased therein was in the last semester of the diploma
course and had established academic merit by securing positions in earlier
semesters. His prospective earning capacity was, therefore, assessed in the
light of his advanced stage of technical education and established academic
performance.
18. In contrast, the deceased in the present case had secured
admission merely 13 days before the accident. There is no evidence regarding
his academic performance in the diploma course, nor any material establishing
an assured prospect of employment. The claimants also failed to substantiate
the alleged income from the utensils shop. Consequently, the income assessed
in cannot be mechanically adopted in the present case.
Gurmit Kaur (supra)
19. At the same time, the Tribunal has already assessed the monthly
income at ₹6,000, considering the deceased's age and admission to a technical
course. Having regard to the year of accident, namely 2013, and the
circumstances established on record, the said assessment cannot be regarded
as excessive. Equally, no sufficient basis has been made out for enhancing the
monthly income beyond ₹6,000. Accordingly, the assessment made by the
Tribunal is affirmed.
20. However, the Tribunal did not make any addition towards future
prospects. In view of the principles laid down in National Insurance Company
Limited v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680, read with Kirti and another v.
, addition of 40%
Oriental Insurance Company Limited, (2021) 2 SCC 166
towards future prospects is warranted. The deduction of 50% towards
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 15:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 5 of Total 8 Pages

FAO-5505-2014 (O&M) &
XOBJC-210-CII-2015
personal expenses, the deceased being a bachelor, and application of
multiplier 18 are in accordance with Sarla Verma and others v. Delhi
Transport Corporation and another, (2009) 6 SCC 121 .
21. The Tribunal has also failed to award adequate compensation
under the conventional heads. The deceased was an unmarried young man
aged about 19 years. Apart from his parents, he left behind two sisters, namely
Gurpreet Kaur and Manpreet Kaur, who were claimants before the Tribunal.
Merely because the sisters were not financially dependent upon their younger
brother, they cannot be denied consideration of their independent claim
towards loss of consortium. Financial dependency is relevant for assessing loss
of dependency, whereas consortium compensates the deprivation of
companionship, care, affection and familial relationship resulting from the
untimely death of a loved one.
22. In Magma General Insurance Company Limited v. Nanu Ram,
(2018) 18 SCC 130, the Hon'ble Supreme Court awarded compensation
towards consortium to the father as well as the sister of the deceased. The
principles relating to consortium were subsequently considered in United
India Insurance Company Limited v. Satinder Kaur alias Satwinder Kaur,
wherein it was clarified that loss of love and affection is
(2021) 11 SCC 780,
comprehended within loss of consortium and cannot be awarded separately.
23. In the present case, both sisters have suffered the permanent loss
of the companionship and affection of their young brother. Having regard to
their relationship with the deceased and the fact that they were claimants in
the original proceedings, this Court considers it appropriate to award ₹40,000
each to them towards loss of consortium.
24. Considering that the accident occurred in 2013, ₹40,000 each to
all the claimants towards filial consortium, ₹15,000 towards loss of estate and
₹15,000 towards funeral expenses are accordingly awarded. The consolidated
amount of ₹10,000 earlier awarded towards transportation and last rites shall
stand subsumed in the reassessed conventional heads, to avoid duplication.
25. Accordingly, compensation is reassessed as under:
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 15:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 6 of Total 8 Pages

FAO-5505-2014 (O&M) &
XOBJC-210-CII-2015
Head of compensation Amount

Monthly income ₹6,000

Future prospects (40%) ₹2,400

Monthly income after addition ₹8,400

Deduction towards personal expenses (50%) ₹4,200

Monthly dependency ₹4,200

Multiplier 18

Loss of dependency ₹9,07,200

Filial consortium — mother ₹40,000

Filial consortium — father ₹40,000

Consortium — Gurpreet Kaur (sister) ₹40,000

Consortium — Manpreet Kaur (sister) ₹40,000

Loss of estate ₹15,000

Funeral expenses ₹15,000
Total compensation ₹10,97,200

Less: Compensation awarded by Tribunal ₹6,58,000
Enhanced compensation ₹4,39,200
Apportionment
26. The Tribunal apportioned the compensation equally between the
parents. However, the distinction between a legal representative and a
dependant must be borne in mind. In Sarla Verma (supra), the Hon'ble
Supreme Court observed that ordinarily the mother alone is considered a
dependant of an unmarried deceased son, whereas the father is not presumed
to be financially dependent unless evidence to the contrary is produced. In the
present case, no specific evidence establishing the financial dependence of the
father upon the deceased has been brought on record. The two sisters, being
elder to the deceased, were also not shown to be financially dependent upon
him.
27. Consequently, the compensation towards loss of dependency is
attributable to the mother, whereas both parents are independently entitled
to filial consortium. However, since the original award apportioned the
compensation equally between the parents and the insurer has not specifically
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 15:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 7 of Total 8 Pages

FAO-5505-2014 (O&M) &
XOBJC-210-CII-2015
challenged the apportionment, it would not be appropriate, in proceedings
seeking reassessment of compensation, to direct recovery of any amount
already disbursed to the father.
28. Accordingly, the enhanced compensation of ₹4,39,200 shall be
payable to the mother, appellant No.1 in the cross-objections. The father shall
retain the amount, if any, already received under the original award. The
entitlement of both parents towards filial consortium shall stand recognized in
the reassessed compensation. The Tribunal shall effect disbursement in a
manner consistent with these directions, without ordering recovery of any
amount already released pursuant to the original award.
Conclusion
29. For the reasons recorded hereinabove, the appeal filed by
Reliance General Insurance Company Limited seeking reduction of
compensation is dismissed. The cross-objections filed by the claimants are
partly allowed. The compensation awarded by the Tribunal is enhanced from
₹6,58,000 to ₹10,97,200, resulting in enhancement of ₹4,39,200.
30. The enhanced amount shall carry interest at the rate of 7.5% per
annum from the date of filing of the claim petition till realization, excluding the
period of 298 days attributable to the delay in filing the cross-objections.
31. The Insurance Company shall deposit the enhanced compensation
along with accrued interest before the Tribunal within eight weeks from the
date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment. The Tribunal shall disburse
the same in accordance with the directions contained hereinabove. All other
terms and conditions of the award shall remain unchanged.
32. Both the appeal and the cross-objections stand disposed of
accordingly. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall also stand
disposed of.

18.11.2026 (DEEPAK GUPTA)
Yogesh JUDGE

Whether speaking/reasoned: Yes/No
Whether reportable: Yes/No

Uploaded on: 18.11.2026
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.11.18 15:41
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 8 of Total 8 Pages