DHRITI MOHON PAUL vs SRIMATI SUTAPA PAUL

Court
Calcutta High Court

16.11.2026
Court No.29
Item No. 25
tbsr
CRR 2837 of 2026

In the matter of: Dhriti Mohon Paul
….Petitioner.

Mr. Kartik Kumar Roy
Mr. Debashis Banerjee
Mr. Rakesh Jana
Mr. Apurba Kolya
….for the petitioner



Leave to add the State of West Bengal as opposite party No. 2 is
granted.
Petitioner/husband has assailed the proceeding being G. R. Case
No. 33 of 2014 under Section 468A/342/344/323/34 of the Indian
Penal Code read with Section 3/4 of the Dowry Prohibition Act
presently pending before the learned Additional Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Ghatal.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid proceeding, learned counsel for
the petitioner submits that the de facto complainant had lodged an
FIR against the present petitioner and all the family members. During
pendency of the proceeding, the mother-in-law died and the
remaining seven accused persons preferred a revisional application
before this High Court being CRR 2771 of 2014 and by an order dated
18.07.2017, this High Court was pleased to quash the impugned
proceeding qua the petitioners.
Being aggrieved by the same proceeding, learned counsel for the
petitioner submits that the allegation level against the present
petitioner is omnibus. At the relevant point of time, he was serving in

2
the Indian Air Force and was posted at Srinagar. From the very
inception of the marriage, the opposite party expressed her
unwillingness to reside with the petitioner’s aged parents and
repeatedly insisted upon staying separately with the petitioner. As no
official family accommodation was allotted to the petitioner at his
place of posting, he requested the opposite party to stay with his
parents until suitable residential accommodation became available.
After making temporary arrangements by securing a room, the
petitioner approximately 15 days after the marriage, took the opposite
party to Srinagar where they resided together for nearly 11 months.
He further submits that the present petitioner is almost on the same
footing with the other accused persons in respect of whom the
present proceeding has already been quashed . No specific overt act is
being attributed against the present petitioner. The allegations of
cruelty are wholly general in nature and are unsupported by any
contemporaneous evidence or independent witness and, therefore,
stand incapable of constituting the offence under Section 498A. The
allegations relating to wrongful restraints and wrongful confinement
are inherently improbable and fail to satisfy the statutory ingredients
of Section 341/342/344 of the IPC. However, the Investigating Officer
conducted the investigation in a mechanical way and submitted
charge sheet against the petitioner. The allegations regarding demand
and payment of a sum of Rs. 4 lakhs towards dowry are wholly
unsupported by any documentary evidence, bank records, receipts or
independent witnesses and, therefore are merely speculative and
incapable of sustaining criminal prosecution. The allegations relating
to entrustment and subsequent misappropriation of gold ornaments

3
and other articles are also not supported by any receipt, valuation
certificate, inventory or other documentary material and therefore are
wholly baseless. The FIR has been lodged after an inordinate and
unexplained delay of nearly four years. The instant case also suffers
from glaring inconsistencies and material contradictions in
connection with the pleadings of the domestic violence proceeding
and also with the written statement filed in the matrimonial
proceeding. The opposite party also failed to establish the allegations
of domestic violence against the accused persons. The present
criminal proceeding has been instituted only after the petitioner
initiated matrimonial proceeding seeking dissolution of marriage,
which establishes that the criminal case is a retaliatory measure
intended to pressurize the petitioner and to frustrate the matrimonial
litigation. Therefore, further continuance of the impugned proceeding
would be mere abuse of the process of the Court.
Having heard learned counsel for the petitioner, the application is
admitted.
The petitioner is directed to serve a copy of the application upon
the opposite party no. 2/State of West Bengal through the Office of
the Public Prosecutor and upon the opposite party no. 1 by speed
post intimating the next date of hearing and to file an affidavit of
service on the returnable date.
Let the matter be listed in the Monthly List of January, 2027.
Learned counsel for the petitioner also prays for interim relief.

4
Having heard learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner
has made out an arguable case which requires adjudication on
merits, let the impugned proceeding being G.R. Case No. 33 of 2014
presently pending before the learned Additional Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Ghatal is hereby stayed for a period of eight weeks or
until further orders, whichever is earlier qua the petitioner, Dhriti
Mohon Paul.
(Dr. Ajoy Kumar Mukherjee, J.)