IN REF. ASHOK vs STATE OF RAJASTHAN
- Court
- Rajasthan High Court
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB]
REPORTABLE
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
Judgment Reserved on : 04.11.2026
Judgment Delivered on : 21.11.2026
Judgment (Full) Uploaded on : 21.11.2026
D.B. Civil Reference No. 4/2026
CNR: RJHC021080542026 | URN: CREF / 7U / 2026
In
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No.12101/2026
In Ref. Ashok son of Nibhori Lal, resident of Village Kharagpura,
Police Station Basedi, District Dholpur (Rajasthan) presently
confined in Open Air Camp, Karauli through his elder brother
Hari Babu so of Nibhori Lal, aged about 42 years, resident of
village Kharagpura, Police Station Basedi, District Dholpur
(Rajasthan)
----Petitioner
Versus
1. State Of Rajasthan through Secretary, Department of Home,
Government of Rajasthan, Jaipur.
2. The Prisoners Parole Advisory Committee (State Committee)
through its Chairman, Director General of Prisons, Rajasthan.
3. Deputy Inspector General of Prisons, Jaipur, Rajasthan.
4. Deputy Superintendent, District Jail, Dholpur
----Respondent
Connected with
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No.12102/2026
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No.12103/2026
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No.12104/2026
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No.12106/2026
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No.12107/2026
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No.12108/2026
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No.12109/2026
D.B. Civil Writ Petition No.12111/2026
For Petitioner(s) : Mr. Anshuman Saxena with
Mr. Dharamsheel Sharma,
Ms. Manisha Agarwal &
Mr. Divyansh Saini
Mr. Shiv Charan Gupta with
Mr. Harsh Saraswat &
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:54 PM)
(2 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
Mr. Tarun Singhal
Mr. Kapil Gupta with
Mr. Ajay Ghadwal,
Mr. R.S. Sinsinwar,
Mr. Dharmendra Kumar Bairwa,
Mr. Chitransh Saxena,
Ms. Anisha Yadav,
Mr. Abhay Singh Rathore,
Mr. Tanay Choudhary,
Mr. Aval Yadav &
Mr. Sunil Yadav
Mr. Ramsharan Singh
Mr. Dheeraj Singhal
Mr. Jai Lodha with
Mr. Ankit Rathore, Adv. Saral Sharma
Mr. Katyani Singh
Mr. Vishram Prajapati
Mr. T.C. Swami
Mr. Abhishek B. Sharma with
Mr. Deependra Yadav
Mr. Rajesh Kala with
Mr. Avi Airun,
Mr. Jitendra Mitruka &
Mr. Harshit Sharma
Mr. Siddharth Jain Mutha
Mr. Anubhav Agarwal with
Mr. Hemang Kumawat
Mr. Chain Singh Rathore with
Mr. Vikas Meena &
Mr. Banwari Lal Sharma
Mr. Achin Singhal
Mr. Prem Chand Dewanda with
Ms. Riya Choudhary,
Mr. Kapil Choudhary,
Mr. Himanshu Dholia,
Mr. Abhishek Singh Devanda &
Ms. Muskaan Jalu
Mr. P.L. Saini with
Mr. Pawan Kumar
Mr. Ramveer Saini
Mr. Govind Rawat
Mr. Kalu Rram Bhati through VC
Mr. Amit Sharma through VC
Mr. Rahul Soni through VC
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Rajendra Prasad, Advocate
General assisted by Mr. Rajesh
Choudhary, GA-cum-AAG, Ms.
Harshita Thakral & Ms. Neha Goyal
Mr. Shobhit Tiwari with
Mr. Pushpendra Singh Tanwar &
Mr. Rohit Tiwari
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:54 PM)
(3 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
FULL BENCH
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. SANJAY K. AGRAWAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANOOP KUMAR DHAND
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SAMEER JAIN
C.A.V. JUDGMENT
Sanjay K. Agr a wal, CJ
For the sake of exposition, this judgment is divided in
following parts:
Part Particulars Page Nos.
Part-I Preface 3
Part-II
Questions of law referred to the Larger
Bench
4
Part-III The object of grant of parole 4
Part-IV The difference between parole and
remission
6
Part-V The Prisons Act, 1894 and the Prisons
(Rajasthan Amendment) Act, 2015
10
Part-VI Answer to question of law No.B 11
Part-VII Answer to question of law No.C 13
Part-VIII Answer to the referred questions of law 18
Part-I Preface
1. The Division Bench of this Court on 29.10.2026 finding
divergence of the judicial view for the purpose of grant of parole
as to whether the rules prevailing on date of conviction of the
prisoners, i.e., the Rajasthan Prisoners (Release on Parole) Rules,
1958 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Rules of 1958'), would apply
or whether the rules in force at the time of consideration of parole
application i.e. the Rajasthan Prisoners (Release on Parole) Rules,
2021) (hereinafter referred to as 'the Rules of 2021') would apply.
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:54 PM)
(4 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
Referred the matter to Hon'ble The Chief Justice for constitution of
Larger Bench for determination of questions of law.
Part- II : Questions of law referred to the Larger Bench
2. The said Bench referred the matter to the Chief Justice for
determination of the following three questions of law by order
dated 29.10.2026, which reads as under,
“(a) Whether, for the purpose of grant of parole, the
Rules prevailing on the date of conviction (the
Rajasthan Prisoners (Release on Parole) Rules,
1958) would apply, or the Rules in force at the time
of consideration of the parole application (the
Rajasthan Prisoners (Release on Parole) Rules,
2021).
(b) Whether the grant of parole amounts to a
temporary suspension of sentence, as contemplated
under Section 386 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 (Section 427 of the BNSS).
(c) What would be the effect of the repeal of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and its
replacement by the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023, on the applicability and operation of
the Rajasthan Prisoners (Release on Parole) Rules,
1958.”
3. Pursuant to order dated 29.10.2026, the Full Bench has been
constituted to determine the aforesaid questions for adjudication.
This is how this reference is before us for determination.
Part -III: The object of grant of parole
4. The object of granting parole is to make necessary efforts to
rehabilitate a convict in the main stream of society based on
“Karuna” (compassion), as well as on human consideration. His
Lordship A.P. Sen, J. speaking for the Supreme Court, while
highlighting the object of parole in the matter of Poonam Lata v .
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:54 PM)
(5 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
1
M.L. Wadhawan and others , observed in no uncertain terms
that “release on parole is a wing of the reformative process and is
expected to provide opportunity to the prisoner to transform
himself into a useful citizen. Parole is thus a grant of partial liberty
or lessening of restrictions to a convict prisoner.
5. The concept of "Karuna" with reference to right of a prisoner
who stands convicted for a criminal offence has been highlighted
by His Lordship V.R. Knahina lyer, J. speaking for the Supreme
Court, in the matter of Inder Singh and another v. State
2
(Delhi Administration) as under:
“….Parole will be allowed to them so that their family
ties may be maintained and inner tensions may not
further build up. ….”
6. Not only this, His Lordship further emphasized the object of
parole and quoted a passage from Lewis Moore with approval. The
said passage reads as under:
"You cannot rehabilitate a man through brutality and
disrespect. Regardless of the crime a man may
commit, he still is a human being and has feelings.
And the main reason most inmates in prison today
disrespect their keepers, is because they themselves
(the inmates) are disrespected and are not treated
like human beings. Does this type of treatment bring
about respect and rehabilitation? No! It only instills
hostility and causes alienation toward the prison
officials from the inmate or inmates involved.
If you treat a man like an animal, then you must
expect him to act like one. For every action, there is a
reaction. This is only human nature. And in order for
an inmate to act like a human being, you must treat
him as such. Treating him like an animal will only get
negative results from him. Lewis Moore (71 pg. 72)"
1 (1987) 3 SCC 347
2 AIR 1978 SC 1091
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:54 PM)
(6 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
7. Thus, parole has been considered as a part of human dignity
which is included in Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
8. In the matter of State of Haryana v. Nauratta Singh &
3
Ors. , the Supreme Court has held that the line in Black’s Law
Dictionary as “a conditional release of a prisoner, generally under
supervision of a parole officer, who has served part of terms for
which he was sentenced to prison”. It is further held by His
Lordship that the parole relates to executive action taken after the
door has been closed on a convict. During parole period there is
no suspension of sentence but the sentence is actually continuing
to run during that period also.
Part -IV: The difference between parole and remission:
9. In case of parole, the sentence is not at all interfered with,
but the prisoner is allowed to come out of the prison wall while
continuing under custody and supervision of prison authorities. On
the other hand, prison even though does not alter the sentence
judicially imposed however, it results in reduction in the terms for
which a sentence is to be carried out in prison. Thus, in some way,
it affects the effective sentence itself.
10. A constitution Bench judgment in the matter of Maru Ram
4
V s. Union of India & Ors. , relying upon Sarat Chandra
5
Rabha & Ors. Vs. Khagendranath & Ors. , the Supreme Court
has held that an order of remission does not wipe off the offence;
it also does not wipe out the conviction. All that it does is to have
an effect on the execution of the sentence; though ordinarily, a
3 (2000) 3 SCC 514
4 (1981) 1 SCC 107
5 (1961) 2 SCR 133
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:54 PM)
(7 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
convicted person would have to serve out the full sentence
imposed by the court as observed in para 24 is under:
“24. We are loathe to loading this judgment with citations
but limit it to two leading authorities in this part of the
case. Two fundamental principles in sentencing
jurisprudence have to be grasped in the context of the
Indian corpus juris. The first is that sentencing is a judicial
function and whatever may be done in the matter of
executing that sentence in the shape of remitting,
commuting or otherwise abbreviating, the Executive cannot
alter the sentence itself. In Rabha's case, a Constitution
Bench of this Court illumined this branch of law. What is
the jural consequence of a remission of sentence ?
In the first place, an order of remission does not wipe out
the offence, it also does not wipe out the conviction. All
that it does is to have an effect on the execution of the
sentence; though ordinarily a convicted person would have
to serve out the full sentence imposed by a court, he need
not do so with respect to that part of the sentence which
has been ordered to be remitted. An order of remission
thus does not in any way interfere with the order of the
court; it affects only the execution of the sentence passed
by the court and frees the convicted person from his
liability to undergo the full term of imprisonment inflicted
by the court, though the order of conviction and sentence
passed by the court still stands as it was. The power to
grant remission is executive power and cannot have the
effect which the order of an appellate or revisional court
would have of reducing the sentence passed by the trial
court and substituting in its place the reduced sentence
adjudged by the appellate or revisional court. This
distinction is well brought out in the following passage from
Weater's "Constitutional Law" on the effect of reprieves and
pardons vis a vis the judgment passed by the court
imposing punishment, at p. 176, para 134:-
"A reprieve is a temporary suspension of the
punishment fixed by law. A pardon is the remission
of such punishment. Both are the exercise of
executive functions and should be distinguished from
the exercise of judicial power over sentences. 'The
judicial power and the executive power over
sentences are readily distinguishable', observed
Justice Sutherland, 'To render a judgment is a
judicial function. To carry the judgment into effect is
an executive function. To cut short a sentence by an
act of clemency is an exercise of executive power
which abridges the enforcement of the judgment but
does not alter it qua judgment."
Though, therefore, the effect of an order of
remission is to wipe out that part of the sentence of
imprisonment which has not been served out and
thus in practice to reduce the sentence to the period
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:54 PM)
(8 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
already undergone, in law the order of remission
merely means that the rest of the sentence need not
be undergone, leaving the order of conviction by the
court and the sentence passed by it untouched.
The relevance of this juristic distinction is that remission
cannot detract from the quantum or quality of sentence or
its direct and side-effects except to the extent of entitling
the prisoner to premature freedom if the deduction
following upon the remission has that arithmetic effect."
11. Similarly, in the matter of State of Haryana & Ors. v.
6
Jagdish , it has been held as under:
“39. The Constitution Bench of this Court in Maru Ram
(supra) clarified that not only the provisions of Section
433-A Cr. P.C. would apply prospectively but any
scheme for short sentencing framed by the State would
also apply prospectively. Such a view is in conformity
with the provisions of Articles 20 (1) and 21 of the
Constitution. The expectancy of period of incarceration
is determined soon after the conviction on the basis of
the applicable laws and the established practices of the
State. When a short sentencing scheme is referable to
Article 161 of the Constitution, it cannot be held that
the said scheme cannot be pressed in service. Even if, a
life convict does not satisfy the requirement of
remission rules/short sentencing schemes, there can be
no prohibition for the President or the Governor of the
State, as the case may be, to exercise the power of
clemency under the provisions of Article 72 and 161 of
the Constitution. Right of the convict is limited to the
extent that his case be considered in accordance with
the relevant rules etc., he cannot claim pre-mature
release as a matter of right. ”
12. In the matter of Hitesh @ Bavko Shivshankar Dave Vs.
7
State of Gujarat , it has been held that for entitlement of a
convict for premature release, the policy of the State Government
on date of conviction would have to be the determinative factor.
13. As such, from the decisions rendered in Maru Ram (supra),
Jagdish (supra) & Hitesh @ Bavko Shivshankar Dave (supra),
it is evidently clear that remission in its effects ultimately results
6 (2010) 4 SCC 216
7 (2024) 5 SCC 623
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:54 PM)
(9 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
in reduction of sentence in the sense of early release from prison.
Therefore, the law on the date of conviction becomes relevant.
14. As such, the concept and consideration for remission are
completely different. The Rules for shortening of sentence have
separately been framed under the provisions of Prisons Act, 1894
(hereinafter referred to as 'the Act of 1894') i.e. the Rajasthan
Prisoners (Shortening of Sentence) Rules, 1958, which have been
repealed and reenacted as Rajasthan Prisoners (Shortening of
Sentence) Rules, 2006 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Rules of
2006').
15. In exercise of powers conferred by Sub-Section (6) of
Section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (equivalent
to Section 432 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973), the
Government of Rajasthan enacted the Rules of 1958 which came
into force w.e.f 20.12.1958. Rule 13 of the Rules of 1958 provides
that the grant of parole should be regarded as concession to
encourage good conduct and it shall not be claimed by prisoners
as a matter or right. This rule has been enacted under Sub-
Section (6) of Section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1898 which sates as under:
"(6) The Government may, by general rules or special
orders give directions as to the suspension of
sentences and the conditions on which petitions
should be presented and dealt with. "
16. The Code of Criminal Procedure 1898 has been repealed by
the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 has now been repealed by the Bharatiya Nagrik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (hereinafter referred to as 'BNSS').
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:54 PM)
(10 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
Part-V: The Prisons Act, 1894 and the Prisons (Rajasthan
Amendment) Act, 2015
17. The Act of 1894 is law relating to prisons in India and to
provide rules for regulation of such prison. Section 58A of the Act
of 1894 was introduced in the Act of 1894 by the State of
Rajasthan w.e.f 08.10.2015, which states as under:
" 58-A. Release of prisoners on parole '- The State
Government or any authority empowered by it may
release a prisoner on parole in accordance with such
rules as may be made in this behalf."
18. Section 58A of the Act of 1894 provides that the State
Government or any authority empowered by it, may release a
prisoner on parole in accordance with such rules as may be made
in this behalf and Section 58B provides for surrender of prisoners
on the expiry of the period on temporary release.
19. Similarly, Section 59 of the Act of 1894 provides for the
power to the State Government may, by notification in the Official
Gazette, make rules consistent with the Act of 1894. Clause (27-
a) in sub-section (1) of Section 59 of the Act of 1894 was inserted
vide the Prisons (Rajasthan Amendment) Act, 2015 (hereinafter
referred to as 'the Act of 2015') by publication in Official Gazette
dated 08.10.2015, to be effective from w.e.f. 20.08.2015 and
after the enactment of the Act of 2015, the Prisons (Rajasthan
Amendment) Ordinance, 2015 was repealed.
20. The State Government (Rajasthan) in exercise of powers
conferred by Clause (27-a) of Section 59 of the Act of 1894
enacted the Rules namely; Rajasthan Prisoners (Release on
Parole) Rules, 2021 w.e.f. 30.06.2021 after publication in the
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:54 PM)
(11 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
Official Gazette. Rules make detailed provision for grant of parole
to the prisoners and parole defined in Clause 2(g) means
conditional enlargement of a prisoner from the jail under these
rules. Clause 15 of the Rules of 2021 provides that the grant of
parole should be regarded as concession to encourage good
conduct and it shall not be claimed by prisoners as a matter of
right.
21. As such, Rule 25 of the Rules of 2021 repeals the Rules of
1958. Sub-Rule 2 of Rule 25 of the Rules of 2021 provides that
repeal under Sub-rule (1) shall not affect the previous operation of
the rules, so repealed, and anything done or action taken or
deemed to have been done.
22. Now on the aforesaid consideration of questions of law in this
background, we will proceed to consider the questions of law so
formulated and referred to us.
23. In order to appropriately answer the questions so
formulated, it would be apt to answer the question Nos.B & C
together first and then to answer question No.A.
Part-VI: Answer to question of law No.B
24. We have already held that the parole is not the suspension of
sentence and their Lordships of the Supreme Court in the matter
8
of Dadu Alias Tulsidas v. State of Maharashtra , in categorical
terms, have held that the grant of parole is not a suspension of
the sentence. The convict continues to serve the sentence despite
granting of parole under the statute, rules, jail manual or the
Government Orders. “Parole” means the release of the prisoner
8 (2000) 8 SCC 437
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:54 PM)
(12 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
temporarily for a special purpose before the expiry of a sentence
and has observed in Para Nos. 6 & 11 as under:
"6. Parole is not a suspension of the sentence. The
convict continues to be serving the sentence despite
granting of parole under the statute, jail manual or the
Government Orders. “Parole” means the release of the
prisoner temporarily for a special purpose before the
expiry of a sentence, on the promise of good behaviour
and return to jail. It is a release from jail, prison or
other internment after actually being in jail serving part
of sentence...........
11. It is thus clear that parole did not amount to the
suspension, remission or commutation of sentences
which could be withheld under the garb of Section 32A
of the Act. Notwithstanding the provisions of the
offending section, a convict is entitled to parole, subject
however, to the conditions governing the grant of it
under the statute, if any, or the jail manual or the
government instructions. The writ Petition No.169 of
1999 apparently appears to be misconceived and filed
in a hurry without approaching the appropriate
authority for the grant of relief in accordance with the
jail manual applicable in the matter. "
25. In the matter of Sunil Fulchand Shah v. Union of India &
9
Ors. , a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court has clearly held
that 'parole' is a form of "temporary release" from custody, which
does not suspend the sentence or the period of detention, but
provides conditional release from custody and changes the mode
of undergoing the sentence, as observed in paragraph 13 as
under:
"13. Thus, it is seen that 'parole' is a form of "temporary
release" from custody, which does not suspend the
sentence or the period of detention, but provides
conditional release from custody and changes the mode
of undergoing the sentence."
9 AIR (2000) SC 1023
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:55 PM)
(13 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
26. As such, the grant of parole does not amount to suspension
of sentence, as parole being a benefit granted for good behavior
or in case of emergencies and earned by serving the sentence, but
by good behavior post imposition of sentence and during its
execution, the rules as applicable on the date of accrual of right
for conferment of such benefit would be relevant.
Part-VII: Answer to question of law No.C
27. As noticed hereinabove, the Rules of 1958 were enacted with
reference to the Section 401(6) of the old Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1898 (for short 'the old Cr.PC, 1898'). The code of
Criminal Procedure, 1898 has been repealed by the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 and the Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973 has now been repealed by BNSS w.e.f. 01.07.2024. Though
the Rules of 1958 are said to have been enacted under Section
401(6) of the old Cr.PC, 1898 but the Cr.P.C. contains no such
provision for grant of parole.
28. This aspect has been considered by the Constitution Bench of
the Supreme Court in the matter of Sunil Fulchand Shah
(supra) , wherein it has been held that there are no statutory
provision dealing with the question of grant of parole. The Code of
Criminal Procedure does not contain any provision for grant of
parole, as observed in paragraph 12 as under:
"12. In this country, there are no statutory
provisions dealing with the question of grant
of parole. The Code of Criminal Procedure
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:55 PM)
(14 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
does not contain any provision for grant of
parole.
By administrative instructions, however,
rules have been framed in various States,
regulating the grant of parole. Thus, the
action for grant of parole is generally
speaking an administrative action. The
distinction between grant of bail and
parole has been clearly brought out in the
judgment of this Court in State of
Haryana v. Mohinder Singh (2000 1 JT
(SC) 629 : (2000 AIR SCW 478) to which
one of us (Wadhwa, J.) was a party. That
distinction is explicit and I respectfully
agree with that distinction."
29 . As noticed hereinabove, the Prisons Act, 1894 has been
amended by the State Government vide Gazette Notification dated
08.10.2015 and made effective w.e.f. 20.08.2015, by which
Clause (27-a) in sub-section (1) of Section 59 of the Act of 1894
was inserted. Thereafter, the State Government, in exercise of
power conferred by above Clause (27-a) of Section 59, enacted
the Rules of 2021 vide Gazette Notification dated 30.06.2021, to
be made effective from the date of their publication in the Official
Gazette.
30. Effect of repeal/complete obliteration of the enactment is as
if it had never been enacted. The effect is to destroy all inchoate
rights and all causes of action that may have arisen under the
repealed statute. However, the saving clause in the repealing
statute and the provisions of General Clauses Act, which apply to
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:55 PM)
(15 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
all enacted statutes, may have bearing upon continuance of
certain rules.
31. The Supreme Court in the matter of Qudrat Ullah vs.
10
Municipal Board, Barelly , provides the consequence of repeal
of statute, as held in paragraph 18 as under:
"18. Certain propositions are clear regarding
the consequence of repeal of a statute. The
general principle is that an enactment which is
repealed is to be treated, except as to
transactions passed and closed as if it had
never existed. However, the operation of this
principle is subject to any savings which may
be made expressly or by implication, by the
repealing enactment (vide Halsbury's Laws of
England Vol. 36 Paragraph 714)."
32. Similarly in the matter of State of Rajasthan vs. Mangilal
11
Pindwal , the Supreme Court has held as under:
"9. As pointed out by this Court, the process
of a substitution of statutory provision consists
of two Steps; first, the old rule is made to
cease to exist and, next, the new rule is
brought into existence in its place. [see
Koteshwar Vittal Kamath v, K. Rangappa , 1969
(3) SCR 40, at p. 48]. In other words, the
Substitution of a provision results in repeal of
the earlier provision and its replacement by the
new provision. As regards repeal of a statute
the law is thus stated in Sutherland on
Statutory Construction.........
10 AIR 1974 SC 396
11 AIR 1996 SC 2181
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:55 PM)
(16 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
"The effect of the repeal of a statute where
neither a saving clause nor a general saving
statute exists to prescribed the governing rule
for the effect of the repeal, is to destroy the
effectiveness of the repealed act in future and
to divest the right to proceed under the statute,
which, except as to proceedings past and
closed, is considered as if it had never existed."
[Vol. I, para 2042, pp.522-523]
10. Similarly in Crawford's Interpretation of Laws it
has been said :
"Effect of Repeal, Generally. - In the first
place, an outright repeal will destroy the
effectiveness of the repealed act in futuro
and operate to destroy inchoate rights
dependent on it, as a general rule. In many
cases, however, where statutes are repealed,
they continue to be the law of the period
during which they were in force with
reference to numerous matters." [pp.640-
641]
11. The Observations of Lord Tenterden and
Tindal C.J. referred in the abovementioned
passages in Craies on Statute Law also indicate
that the principle that on repeal a statute is
obliterated is subject to the exception that it
exists in respect of transactions past and closed.
To the same effect is the Jaw laid down by this
Court. [See : Qudrat Ullah v. Municipal Board .
Bareilly. 1974 (2) SCR 530, at p. 539]
12. This means that as a result of repeal of a
statute as repealed ceases to exist with effect
from the date of such repeal but the repeal does
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:55 PM)
(17 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
not affect the previous operation of the law
which has been repealed during the period it was
operative prior to the date of such repeal.
Section 24 on the other hand provides for
continuance of rule etc. with the rider that the
rules enacted under repealed act should not be
inconsistent to the provisions re-enacted and
further that such existing rules should not have
been superseded by Rules issued under
provisions of enacted law."
33. As such, the Rules of 1958 being merely executive
instructions, on being replaced by the Rules of 2021 w.e.f.
30.06.2021 and having been specifically repealed through Rule 25
of the Rules of 2021, and only the previous operation of the Rules
of 1958 having been saved and as such there will be complete
obliteration of the Rules of 1958 as if they have never been
enacted except to the extent of saving under Rule 25(2) of the
Rules of 2021. Since the Rules of 1958 stood repealed, question of
consideration of parole of any convict under the Rules of 1958, in
no circumstance, arises for consideration.
34. Consequently, it is held that by virtue of repeal having
become effective w.e.f. 30.06.2021, the Rules of 1958 not being in
force, will not otherwise be revived or repealed by Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1898, or by Code of Criminal Procedure,
1973, or by BNSS, 2023, and BNSS, 2023 does not specifically
provide for revival of any such rules.
35. Consequently, as on date and w.e.f. 30.06.2021 for the
purpose of grant of parole, the Rules enforced at the time of
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:55 PM)
(18 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
consideration, the parole application, i.e., the Rules of 2021
(w.e.f., 30.06.2021) would govern the grant of parole.
36. We answer the aforesaid questions of law as under:
Part-VIII: Answer to the referred questions of law
36.(i) The Rules of 2021, having come into force on 30.6.2021
and having expressly repealed the Rules of 1958, would govern
the consideration of every application for release on parole,
temporary or permanent, made after their commencement,
irrespective of the date of conviction. The mere fact that prisoner
was convicted while the 1958 Rules were in force does not give
him a vested right to have later applications considered under the
repealed rules of 1958. The principle laid down in Jagdish (supra)
& Hitesh @ Bavko Shivshankar Dave (supra), concerning the
remission policy at conviction in cases of permanent release, does
not extend to parole/permanent parole.
36.(ii) The grant of parole does not, in its legal character, amount
to suspension, remission, or commutation of sentence. It is a
conditional release that changes only the mode of undergoing the
sentence, as held by the Supreme Court in Sunil Fulchand Shah
(supra), Dadu Alias Tulsidas (supra) and Nauratta Singh
(supra), as the period spent on parole as per Rule 10 of the Rules
of 2021 including permanent parole is to be treated as
imprisonment served.
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:55 PM)
(19 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
36.(iii) The Rules of 1958 framed under Section 401(6) of Cr.P.C.
1898, continued after coming into force of CrPC 1973 by virtue of
Section 484 (2)(b) of Cr.P.C. They were expressly repealed by Rule
25(1) of the Rules of 2021 with effect from 30.06.2021 and the
Rules of 2021 have been made independently under Section 59 of
the Act of 1894 read with Rule 27-a of the Act of 1894. Section
531(2)(b) of BNSS, 2023 preserves only rules in force
immediately before 01.07.2024, so the repeal of the Cr.P.C. 1973
and the commencement of BNSS neither affect the Rules of 2021
nor revive the Rules of 1958.
37. The aforesaid questions of law are answered accordingly.
Now the matter be placed before the appropriate Bench having
the roster to consider the writ petitions accordingly.
38. The reference is disposed off accordingly.
39. We place on record our appreciation for the assistance
rendered by Mr. Rajendra Prasad, learned Advocate General, Mr.
Anshuman Saxena with Mr. Dharamsheel Sharma, Ms. Manisha
Agarwal & Mr. Divyansh Saini, Mr. Shiv Charan Gupta with Mr.
Harsh Saraswat & Mr. Tarun Singhal, Mr. Kapil Gupta with Mr. Ajay
Ghadwal, Mr. R.S. Sinsinwar, Mr. Dharmendra Kumar Bairwa, Mr.
Chitransh Saxena, Ms. Anisha Yadav, Mr. Abhay Singh Rathore, Mr.
Tanay Choudhary, Mr. Aval Yadav & Mr.Sunil Yadav, Mr. Ramsharan
Singh, Mr. Dheeraj Singhal, Mr. Jai Lodha with Mr. Ankit Rathore,
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:55 PM)
(20 of 20)
[2026:RJ-JP:46271-DB] [CREF-4/2026]
Adv. Saral Sharma, Mr. Katyani Singh, Mr. Vishram Prajapati, Mr.
T.C. Swami, Mr. Abhishek B. Sharma with Mr. Deependra Yadav,
Mr. Rajesh Kala with Mr. Avi Airun, Mr. Jitendra Mitruka & Mr.
Harshit Sharma, Mr. Siddharth Jain Mutha, Mr. Anubhav Agarwal
with Mr. Hemang Kumawat, Mr. Chain Singh Rathore with Mr. Vikas
Meena & Mr. Banwari Lal Sharma, Mr. Achin Singhal, Mr. Prem
Chand Dewanda with Ms. Riya Choudhary, Mr. Kapil Choudhary,
Mr. Himanshu Dholia, Mr. Abhishek Singh Devanda & Ms. Muskaan
Jalu, Mr. P.L. Saini with Mr. Pawan Kumar, Mr. Ramveer Saini, Mr.
Govind Rawat, Mr. Kalu Rram Bhati through VC, Mr. Amit Sharma
through VC, Mr. Rahul Soni through VC, who appeared on behalf of
the petitioners and Mr. Rajesh Choudhary, GA-cum-AAG, Ms.
Harshita Thakral & Mr. Rohit Tiwari learned counsels who appeared
and made submissions in arriving at the aforesaid conclusion.
(SAMEER JAIN), J (ANOOP KUMAR DHAND),J (SANJAY K. AGRAWAL),CJ
SANJAY KUMAWAT (RESERVED)
(Uploaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:20:45 PM)
(Downloaded on 21/11/2026 at 04:34:55 PM)
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)