Rakesh Kumar vs Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal, Jalandhar And Ors.

Court
Punjab and Haryana High Court

1
LPA-1100 of 2024 (O&M)

IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH

103
LPA-1100-2024 (O&M)

Reserved on: 28.10.2026
Pronounced on: 16.11.2026
Uploaded on 16.11.2026

Whether only operative part of the judgment is
pronounced or the full judgment is pronouned: Full judgment

RAKESH KUMAR
…..Appellant

V/S

PRESIDING OFFICER, INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNAL, JALANDHAR AND
OTHERS.

… Respondents

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUVIR SEHGAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH GAUR

Present: Mr. Ram Kumar Chauhan, Advocate for the appellant.

Mr. Amit Kumar Goyal, Addl. Advocate General, Punjab
for respondent no.1.

None for respondents no. 2 and 3.



RAJESH GAUR, J.

1. Present intra-Court Appeal has been filed under clause X of the
Letters Patent assailing the judgment dated 05.01.2024 passed by the learned
Single Judge in CWP-9320 of 2017, whereby, instead of ordering reinstatement
in service and consequential benefits to the appellant-workman, he has been
awarded lump-sum compensation of Rs.1,00,000/-.

2. The brief facts of the case are that the appellant-workman was
appointed as a Salesman with the respondent-management on 01.07.2008 and
continuously worked from 01.07.2008 to 09.08.2010, completing more than 240
days of service in each year. He was drawing a monthly salary of Rs.3200/-,
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.16 17:40
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

2
LPA-1100 of 2024 (O&M)

which was paid against vouchers upto 31.07.2010. It is alleged that his services
were terminated in violation of the provisions of Section 25F of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Act of 1947'), without
following the prescribed procedure. It is further alleged that the management, in
collusion with its erstwhile Secretary, illegally appointed Amit Jhariyan as a
Salesman, who was junior to the appellant-workman. By retaining Amit
Jhariyan while terminating the services of the appellant-workman, the
respondent-management also violated the provisions of Section 25G of the Act
of 1947. No settlement could be arrived at between the parties, the matter was
referred to the Industrial Tribunal, Jalandhar.

3. The appellant-workman duly filed his claim statement, to which
the respondent-management filed its reply. The stand taken by the respondent-
management was that the appellant-workman had been engaged on a contractual
basis under a leave-gap arrangement and was not appointed against any
permanent post of Salesman. It was further pleaded that no employee junior to
the appellant-workman had been retained at the time of termination of his
services.

4. The appellant-workman, on the other hand, averred that the
termination of his services was in violation of the provisions of the Act of 1947.
After considering the mandatory provisions of the Act of 1947, the nature of
employment and the length of service rendered by the appellant-workman, the
learned Presiding Officer, Industrial Tribunal, Jalandhar, awarded lump-sum
compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- in lieu of reinstatement.

5. Aggrieved by the Award dated 17.11.2016 passed by the Presiding
Officer, Industrial Tribunal, Jalandhar, the appellant-workman approached this
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.16 17:40
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

3
LPA-1100 of 2024 (O&M)

Court by way of a writ petition. The learned Single Judge observed that the
appellant-workman had been inducted into service pursuant to a resolution,
without issuance of appointment letter or following any prescribed procedure.
It was further observed that the appellant-workman had worked for only about
two years. Finding no perversity in the award passed by the Presiding Officer,
Industrial Tribunal, Jalandhar, the learned Single Judge upheld the same and
dismissed the writ petition.

6. Dissatisfied with the judgment dated 05.01.2024 passed by the
learned Single Judge, the appellant-workman has filed the present Letters Patent
Appeal.

7. Learned counsel for the appellant-workman submits that
reinstatement with full back wages and consequential benefits is an automatic
relief and further submits that Amit Jhariyan, who was junior to the appellant-
workman, was appointed as a Salesman on 06.08.2000 in his place, which
clearly amounts to a violation of Section 25G of the Act of 1947.

8. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondent-management
submits that the appellant-workman was engaged on a contractual basis under a
leave-gap arrangement against the leave vacancy of Ravi Nandan Singh. It is
further submitted that upon the joining of the regular incumbent, namely Ravi
Nandan Singh, the services of the appellant-workman were dispensed with,
thereby attracting the exception contained in Section 2(oo)(bb) of the Act of
1947.

9. It is further submitted that no employee junior to the appellant-
workman was appointed in his place. Accordingly, the provisions of Sections
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.16 17:40
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

4
LPA-1100 of 2024 (O&M)

25F and 25G of the Act of 1947 were not attracted and the appellant-workman
was not entitled to reinstatement with consequential benefits.

10. We have heard learned counsel for the rival parties and have
perused the record with their able assistance.

11. Upon examination of the record, it emerges that the appellant-
workman was not appointed on a regular basis but was merely engaged pursuant
to a resolution. No formal appointment letter nor any convincing evidence has
been produced to establish that any other post of Salesman is available with the
respondent-management. Further, appellant-workman had worked for only
about two years.

12. In view of the relevant facts and circumstances, we find it apposite
to refer to the judgment passed by this Court in ‘ Ram Sarup v. State of Punjab
and others’, Law Finder Doc ID # 2971026 , the relevant paragraphs of which
are reproduced here-in-below:-
“12 Reliance is made to the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in Ranbir Singh Vs. Executive Eng. P.W.D. (Law
Finder Doc ID #1875252) decided on 02.09.2021 . In the
abovesaid case, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has granted
compensation of Rs.3.25 lakhs to the workman who had worked for
08 years in lieu of reinstatement in service. Relevant extract of the
judgment is reproduced below:-
“2. The case of the appellant was that he was working with the
respondent for a period of nearly eight years and service
was terminated without complying with Section 25F of the
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter referred to as,
`the Act'). The Labour Court rejected the contention of the
respondent that the appellant had not worked for 240 days
and found that appellant had indeed worked for 240 days. It
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.16 17:40
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

5
LPA-1100 of 2024 (O&M)

is found that there is noncompliance of Section 25F of the
Act and the Labour Court awarded reinstatement of the
appellant with 25 per cent back wages. As already noticed,
it is this award which is set aside by the High Court.
3. Shri Manjeet Singh, learned Senior Counsel for the
appellant would seek to rely upon the judgment of this Court
in Ajaypal Singh v. Haryana Warehousing Corporation,
(2015) 6 SCC 321 . He would further submit that some of
persons juniors to him were also dealt with in a different
fashion, and in their case, they are working and they have,
in fact, been regularised also. Learned counsel submits that
the appellant should be reinstated in terms of the order of
the Labour Court. Per Contra, Shri Samar Vijay Singh,
learned AAG for the respondent pointed out that the
acceptance of the contention of the appellant involved
violation of the law laid down by this court in Secretary,
State of Karnataka and others v. Umadevi (3) and others,
(2006) 4 SCC 1 . He still further drew out attention to the
decision of this Court in State of Uttarakhand and another
v. Raj Kumar, (2019) 14 SCC 353 and points out that, in
such circumstances, an order of reinstatement may not be
justified.
4. It is true that in the Ajay Pal Singh (supra), the Bench of this
Court, by judgment rendered in the year 2015, took the view
that, when the termination is effected of service of a daily
wager, there must be compliance of Section 25F. This Court,
in fact, went on also to note that unlike a private body, in the
case of a public body, while it may be open to resort to
retrenchment of the workmen on the score that there is non-
compliance of Articles 14 and 16 in the appointment, in
which case, in the order terminating the services, this must
be alluded to, it would still not absolve the public authority
from complying with the provisions of Section 25F of the Act
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.16 17:40
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

6
LPA-1100 of 2024 (O&M)

and, should it contravene Section 25F, it would amount to
an unfair trade practice. We do notice, this judgment has
been reiterated in a subsequent judgment also in Durgapur
Casual Workers Union and others v. Food Corporation of
India and others, (2015) 5 SCC 786.
5. However, we notice that there is another line of decisions,
and the latest of the same, which is brought to our notice by
Shri Samar Vijay Singh, learned AAG, is Raj Kumar (supra).
We may refer only to paragraphs-9 and 10:
"9. In our opinion, the case at hand is covered by the
two decisions of this Court rendered in BSNL v.
Bhurumal [BSNL v. Bhurumal, (2014) 7 SCC 177:
(2014) 2 SCC (L&S) 373] and Distt. Development
Officer v. Satish Kantilal Amrelia [Distt.
Development Officer v. Satish Kantilal Amrelia,
(2018) 12 SCC 298 : (2018) 2 SCC (L&S) 276].
10. It is apposite to reproduce what this Court has
held in BSNL [BSNL v. Bhurumal, (2014) 7 SCC
177 : (2014) 2 SCC (L&S) 373] : (SCC p. 189, paras
33-35)
"33. It is clear from the reading of the aforesaid
judgments that the ordinary principle of grant of
reinstatement with full back wages, when the
termination is found to be illegal is not applied
mechanically in all cases. While that may be a
position where services of a regular/permanent
workman are terminated illegally and/or mala fide
and/or by way of victimisation, unfair labour practice,
etc. However, when it comes to the case of termination
of a daily-wage worker and where the termination is
found illegal because of a procedural defect, namely,
in violation of Section 25F of the Industrial Disputes
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.16 17:40
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

7
LPA-1100 of 2024 (O&M)

Act, this Court is consistent in taking the view that in
such cases reinstatement with back wages is not
automatic and instead the workman should be given
monetary compensation which will meet the ends of
justice. Rationale for shifting in this direction is
obvious.
34. The reasons for denying the relief of reinstatement
in such cases are obvious. It is trite law that when the
termination is found to be illegal because of non-
payment of retrenchment compensation and notice
pay as mandatorily required under Section 25F of the
Industrial Disputes Act, even after reinstatement, it is
always open to the management to terminate the
services of that employee by paying him the
retrenchment compensation. Since such a workman
was working on daily-wage basis and even after he is
reinstated, he has no right to seek regularisation [see
State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) [State of
Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1 : 2006
SCC (L&S) 753] . Thus when he cannot claim
regularisation and he has no right to continue even
as a daily-wage worker, no useful purpose is going to
be served in reinstating such a workman and he can
be given monetary compensation by the Court itself
inasmuch as if he is terminated again after
reinstatement, he would receive monetary
compensation only in the form of retrenchment
compensation and notice pay. In such a situation,
giving the relief of reinstatement, that too after a long
gap, would not serve any purpose.
35. We would, however, like to add a caveat here.
There may be cases where termination of a daily-
wage worker is found to be illegal on the ground that
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.16 17:40
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

8
LPA-1100 of 2024 (O&M)

it was resorted to as unfair labour practice or in
violation of the principle of last come first go viz.
while retrenching such a worker daily wage juniors to
him were retained. There may also be a situation that
persons junior to him were regularised under some
policy but the workman concerned terminated. In such
circumstances, the terminated worker should not be
denied reinstatement unless there are some other
weighty reasons for adopting the course of grant of
compensation instead of reinstatement. In such cases,
reinstatement should be the rule and only in
exceptional cases for the reasons stated to be in
writing, such a relief can be denied."
6. In the light of the state of the law, which we take note of, we
notice certain facts which are not in dispute. This is a case
where it is found that, though the appellant had worked for
240 days, appellant's service was terminated, violating the
mandatory provisions of Section 25F of the Act. The
authority involved in this case, apparently, is a public
authority. At the same time, it is common case that the
appellant was a daily wager and the appellant was not a
permanent employee. It is relevant to note that, in the award
answering Issue No.1, which was, whether the termination
of the appellant's service was justified and in order, and if
not, what was the amount of back wages he was entitled to,
it was found, inter alia, that the appellant could not adduce
convincing evidence to establish retention of junior workers.
There is no finding of unfair trade practice, as such. In such
circumstances, we think that the principle, which is
enunciated by this Court, in the decision, which is referred
to in Raj Kumar (supra), which we have referred to, would
be more appropriate to follow. In other words, we find that
reinstatement cannot be automatic, and the transgression of
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.16 17:40
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document

9
LPA-1100 of 2024 (O&M)

Section 25F being established, suitable compensation would
be the appropriate remedy.
7. In such circumstance, noticing that, though the appellant
was reinstated after the award of the Labour Court in 2006,
the appellant has not been working since 2009 following the
impugned order, and also taking note of the fact that the
appellant was, in all likelihood, employed otherwise, also
the interest of justice would be best subserved with
modifying the impugned order and directing that in place of
Rs. 25000/- (Rupees Twenty Five Thousand), as lumpsum
compensation, appellant be paid Rs.3.25 lakhs (Rupees
Three Lakhs and Twenty Five Thousand), as compensation,
taking into consideration also the fact that the appellant had
already been paid Rs. 25000/- (Rupees Twenty Five
Thousand) as compensation.”
13. In view of the aforesaid factum and the established laws, this Court
does not find any illegality, infirmity or perversity in the order dated 05.01.2024
passed by the learned Single Judge. Accordingly, present appeal is dismissed
with no order as to costs.
14. All pending civil miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also
stand disposed of.

(SUVIR SEHGAL) (RAJESH GAUR)
JUDGE JUDGE


16.11.2026
Kamal Gandhi


Whether speaking Yes
Whether reportable Yes
KAMAL GANDHI
2026.11.16 17:40
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document