Reshma Rizvi And Anr vs State Of Maharashtra And Anr

Court
Bombay High Court

CNR No : HCBM010039262024

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
Ajay

IN IN THE THE HIGH HIGH COURT COURT OF OF JUDICATURE JUDICATURE AT AT BOMBAY BOMBAY
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 1489 OF 2024
Dr. Akhtar Hasan Rizvi .. Petitioner
Versus
State of Maharashtra and Anr. .. Respondents
WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 502 OF 2024
Reshma Rizvi and Anr. .. Petitioners
Versus
State of Maharashtra and Anr. .. Respondents
....................

Mr. Aabad Ponda, Senior Advocate a/w. Mr. Prashant Relekar,
Ms.Rubina Akhtar Rizvi, Mr. Prasad Arun Komthe and Mr. Sujit
Lahoti, Advocates for Petitioner in Writ Petition No.1489 of 2024.

Mr. Niranjan Mundargi a/w. Ms. Keral Mehta, Mr. Dinesh
Pednekar, Mr. C. Keswani, Mr. Tanmay Bhave, Mr. Rayan Badheka
and Ms. Chandrama Raje Advocates i/by Economic Laws Practice
for Petitioners in Writ Petition No.502 of 2024.

Mr. Yogesh M. Nakhwa, APP for Respondent – State.

Mr. Mandar Soman a/w. Mr. S.R. Page and Ms. Janhavi Kolge,
Advocate for Respondent No.2 in both Petitions.

PI – Ms. Anita Varade, EOW, Mumbai present.
......…...........
CORAM : MILIND N. JADHAV, J.
DATE : NOVEMBER 18, 2026.
JUDGEMENT:
1. Heard Mr. Ponda, learned Senior Advocate alongwith Mr.
Relekar, Advocate for Petitioner in Writ Petition No.1489 of 2024; Mr.
Mundargi along with Ms. Mehta, learned Advocates for Petitioners in
Writ Petition No.502 of 2024; Mr. Soman learned Advocate for
1
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
Respondent No.2 in both Petitions and Mr. Nakhwa, learned APP for
Respondent No.1– State.
2.
Writ Petition No. 1489 of 2024 is filed by Petitioner Dr.
Akhtar Hasan Rizvi under Article 226 of the Constitution of India read
with Section 482 of Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 seeking to quash
and set aside FIR being CR No.786 of 2022 subsequently transferred to
Economic Offences Wing (for short “EOW”) as CR No.121 of 2022 and
Criminal Case No.769/PW/2023 pending before the 47th Metropolitan
Magistrate Court, Esplanade, Mumbai pending against the Petitioner.
Petitioner is charged for cheating and criminal breach of trust under
Section 409, 420, 34 of Indian Penal Code (for short "IPC") and under
Section 3,4,8 and 13 of Maharashtra Ownership of Flats Act (for short
“MOFA”).
3. Writ Petition No. 502 of 2024 is filed by Reshma Rizvi and
Meena Rizvi under Article 226 of the Constitution of India read with
Section 482 of Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 seeking to quash and
set aside FIR being CR No.0915 of 2022 subsequently transferred to
Economic Offences Wing as CR No.121 of 2022 and Criminal Case
No.769/PW/2023 pending before the 47th Metropolitan Magistrate
Court, Esplanade, Mumbai pending against the Petitioners. Petitioners
are charged under Section 409, 420 and 34 of IPC and under Section
3,4,8 and 13 of MOFA.
2
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
4. Briefly stated, there are 5 accused persons in the present
crime registered vide FIR No.786 of 2022 dated 28.07.2022 with
Vakola Police Station under Section 409 and 420 of IPC and Sections
3,4,8 and 13 of Maharashtra Ownership of Flats Act. This FIR is later
transferred to EOW and registered vide FIR No.121 of 2022. Accused
No.1 is Rizvi Land Development Pvt. Ltd, a company. Accused No.2 Is
Akhtar Hasan Rizvi, 85 years old, director of the Company who is
Petitioner in Writ Petition No.1489 of 2024. Accused No.3 is Meena
Akhtar Hasan Rizvi daughter of Accused No.2 and 4 and sister of
Accused No.5. Accused No.4 is the ex - wife of Accused No.2, she is 84
years old. Accused No.5 is Abis Rizvi son of Accused No.2 who expired
on 01.01.2017.
4.1.
According to prosecution’s case FIR is lodged by one Junaid
Ebrahim Khan alleging that he and his 3 brothers were introduced to
deceased Accused No.5 by one estate agent Mr. Suhas Vengulekar in
the year 2013 as they were looking for purchasing commercial
premises. According to prosecution’s case, the 4 brothers executed
MOU rather 4 separate MOU all dated 22.04.2013 with Accused No.1 –
Company which was executed by decased Accused No.5 on behalf of
Accused No.1. Under the said MOUs all 4 brothers paid 50% (Rs.70
lakhs each) of the total sale consideration for purchase of 4
commercial premises in a prospective development undertaken by
Accused No.1 – Company. Record show that all dealings were done by
3
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
the First Informant and his 3 brothers with deceased Accused No.5
Abis Akhtar Rizvi on behalf of Accused No.1 – Company. In fact, MOU
of First Informant is appended to page No.87 of the Petition and
according to prosecution case, all 4 MOUs were signed and executed
by Accused No.5 on behalf of Accused No.1 – Company. There are
certain facts emanating from the record namely that Accused No.5 was
not authorised by any resolution of the company to execute the said
MOU on behalf of the Company and that Accused No.5 was the sole
person who executed and signed the 4 MOUs which was not to the
knowledge of the other directors since Accused No.5 was looking after
the Company in 2013.
4.2. On 01.01.2017 Accused No.5 met an unfortunate and
untimely demise. Record clearly shows that First Informant and his 3
brothers entered into further negotiations with the Petitioner namely
Accused No.2 i.e. father of Accused No.5 thereafter for allotment of 4
residential premises in lieu of the originally contemplated 4
commercial premises under the 4 MOUs. Insofar as Accused No.3 is
concerned, though she was a director, she was a director, she was
living in the US for the past 20 years and similarly Accused No.4 was a
home maker and not concerned with running of the Company. Record
clearly shows that on request made by First Informant - Complainant
and his 3 brothers, four 3 BHK flats in one of the properties developed
by Accused No.2 were reserved and allotted to them pursuant to
4
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
negotiations between the parties. Reliance is placed on a letter dated
29.03.2018 copy of which is placed at page No.370 of the Petition
issued by Petitioner namely Accused No.2 which specifically states that
the amounts paid by Complainant and his 3 brothers would stand
forfeited in the event of failure to pay the balance consideration.
Substantial correspondence between the parties was exchanged during
this time. Respondent No.2 being aggrieved filed a complaint against
the Petitioner – Accused No.2 in MahaRERA on 15.11.2017 however
the authority was about to dismiss the said Complaint and hence on
11.01.2018 the Complaint was withdrawn by Respondent No.2
unconditionally.
4.3. Record shows that Respondent No.2 First Informant lodged
written Complaint on 25.10.2017 against Petitioner (Accused No.2)
with Bandra Police Station. He filed the same Complaint on
08.11.2017 against Petitioner (Accused No.2) in Vakola Police Station
in Santacruz East. He also filed the same complaint dated 05.04.2018
with DCP Zone VIII, BKC Bandra East. These 3 complaints were filed
for cheating against the Petitioner (Accused No.2). Record shows that
after conducting enquiry and scrutiny of all relevant documents the
Senior Police Inspector of Vakola Police Station addressed letter dated
31.05.2018 to Respondent No.2 First Informant informing that since
he was not remaining present for pursuing the said complaint, no
cognizable offence was detected and therefore the complaint was
5
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
consigned to record.
4.4. Record shows that on 05.07.2022, the First Informant
Complainant filed Commercial Suit in this Court against Petitioner and
others including the Company (Accused No.1) alleging that fraud was
committed and terms and conditions of MOU dated 22.04.2013 were
breached. In the said Suit proceedings by order dated 22.012.2022, ad-
interim relief was rejected. Record shows that Respondent No.2’s
brother Mr. Faizal Ebrahim Khan separately filed another Commercial
Suit No.279 of 2022 in this Court against Accused Nos. 1 to 4 claiming
Rs.5.57 crores together with profit at the rate of 24% per annum as a
money claim on the basis of his MOU under which Rs.70 lakhs was
paid by him. By order dated 22.12.2022 ad-interim relief was rejected.
The said suit is transferred to City Civil Court, Mumbai and is pending.
The other two brothers namely Afzal and Imran did not file any Suit
for recovery or even any complaint against the Company or the
Petitioners’ herein. Petitioner i.e. Accused No.2 has been protected by
this Court in Anticipatory Bail Application filed by him and it is
directed that no coercive steps shall be taken against him and the said
ad-interim relief was continued and extended. Record shows that when
ABA No.309 of 2023 was finally heard by this Court on 28.03.2023,
order was passed on the request by the respective parties to keep the
matter for settlement. A further order was then passed on 05.04.2023
which is crucial and which records that Respondent No.2 Complainant
6
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
is not ready to accept the flat which according to him was not
according to the specification in the original agreement.
4.5.
Thereafter it is seen that learned APP was appointed by this
Court to help the parties arrive at a settlement in a further order dated
22.05.2023 in the Anticipatory Bail Application No.309 of 2024
wherein this Court observed that learned APP made his best efforts but
First Informant did not cooperate to finalise the Consent Terms and
therefore the matter was next adjourned to 19.06.2023. The said
Anticipatory Bail Application No.309 of 2023 was heard by this Court
on 08.08.2023 when this Court passed order directing Petitioner to
deposit Rs.6 crores in this Court while observing that the dispute
between the parties was over the quantum of sale consideration and
the fact that Civil Proceedings before this Court being Commercial
Suits for recovery of money along with Complaint in MahaRERA were
filed and pending, Accused No.2 deposited Rs.3 crores on 11.08.20233
and another Rs.3 crores on 13.08.2023 in this Court. Despite the
aforesaid, chargsheet was filed on 16.10.2023 in the present case.
Hence the present Petition.
5. Mr. Ponda, learned Senior Advocate for Petitioner in Writ
Petition No.1489 of 2024 would submit that offences of cheating and
criminal breach of trust are both distinct and cannot be applied
together qua the Petitioner (Accused No.2). He would submit that for
7
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
the offence of cheating to be fulfilled, dishonest intention has to subsist
from the inception whereas for the offence of criminal breach of trust
to be fulfilled, initial transaction has to be lawful and dishonest
intention has to develop subsequently. He would submit that Petitioner
– Dr. Akhtar Hasan Rizvi has neither executed any of the four MOUs
with the Complainant nor was there any resolution passed authorising
Petitioner's son, Late Mr. Abis Rizvi, to execute the four MOUs with
Respondent No.2. He would submit that the aforementioned
transactions were entered into between Late Mr. Abis Rizvi (Accused
No.5) on behalf of the Company and Respondent No.2 and his
brothers with Petitioner playing no role therein. He would submit that
this is an admitted fact as the FIR is completely silent on this aspect.
He would submit that there is no provision levying vicarious liability
upon the Directors of the Company under IPC therefore Petitioner
cannot be prosecuted merely because of his association as a Director of
the Company.
5.1.
He would submit that this Petitioner (Accused No.2) and
Respondent No.2 exchanged communications on numerous occasions
attempting to address the issues arising out of the aforementioned
MOUs and at the request of Respondent No.2, Petitioner reserved and
allotted four 3 BHK residential flats before 30.01.2019. He would
submit that on 01.07.2022, Respondent No.2 - Complainant and his
brothers filed Commercial Suits in this Court and subsequently within
8
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
27 days FIR came to be registered against this Petitioner on
28.07.2022, thus civil proceedings preceded the criminal proceedings.
He would submit that the MOUs were executed with buy - back option
and Respondent No.2 failed to excersise the buy - back option within
the stipulated period of time and instead decided to pursue and seek
refund of the monies paid by him and his brothers to Accused No.5 -
Late Mr. Abis Rizvi. He would submit that in the Suits filed by
Respondent No.2, this Court rejected ad - interim relief to Respondent
No.2 on the ground that his claim was a simpliciter money claim hence
this itself demonstrates the contractual and commercial nature of the
dispute between the parties.
5.2. He would submit that the 4 MOU's disclose a claim of
Rs.2.80 crores however the Complainant alleged loss of Rs.12 crores
without any documentary evidence filed in respect of the same. He
would submit that enhancement of the claim was done by Respondent
No.2 upto Rs.10 crores to deliberately bring the scope of the criminal
dispute under the purview of Economic Offences Wing. He would
submit that continuation of the present FIR and criminal proceedings
against Petitioner is therefore an abuse of the due process of law and
he would urge this Court to quash the present FIR and subsequent
criminal proceedings qua the Petitioners before the Court.
6. Mr. Mundargi, learned Advocate on behalf of Petitioners in
9
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
Writ Petition No.502 of 2024 would adopt the submissions of Mr.
Ponda which for brevity sake are not reiterated herein. He would
submit that present FIR is filed qua present Petitioners on the sole
ground that they were Directors in the Company along with Petitioner
in Writ Petition No.1489 of 2024. He would submit that there is no
case or ground made out to prosecute Petitioners since the FIR and
Chargsheet do not attribute any specific act or role to the Petitioners.
He would submit that Petitioner No.1 in his Petition was residing in
USA for over 20 years and Petitioner No.2 is eighty four years old
housewife and both have never been involved in the day - to day
management of the Company at any point of time. He would urge this
Court to therefore quash the impugned FIR and criminal proceedings
against these Petitioners.
7. Mr. Soman, learned Advocate for Respondent No.2 would
vehemently oppose both the Petitions. He has filed Written
Submissions of his oral arguments dated 17.11.2026 and would submit
that Petitioner’s son Late Mr. Abis Akhtar Rizvi was Director of Rizvi
Land Developments Pvt. Ltd and he executed 4 MOUs all dated
22.04.2013 on behalf of the Company with Respondent No.2 and his 3
brothers for sale of 4 commercial office units in the proposed Rizvi
Corporate Park. He would submit that Petitioner No.1 was the founder
of the Company and continues to be director of the Company. He
would submit that since Late Mr. Abis Akhtar Rizvi executed 4 MOUs
10
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
in his capacity of Director of the Company with Respondent No.2 and
his brothers, all the Directors falls into the definition of Promoter and
Respondent No.2 fall into the definition of Purchaser under MOFA. He
would submit that Respondent No.2 and his brothers, after paying
Rs.2,80,00,000/- to the Company, came to know that the land upon
which the proposed Rizvi Corporate Park was to be developed was
reserved for residential purpose and not for commercial expolitation.
He would submit that this fact was known to Petitioners but their
failure to disclose the same to Respondent No.2 constitutes the offence
of cheating.
7.1.
He would submit that since the construction of Rizvi
Corporate Park did not finish within the stipulated period of 24
months, Respondent No.2 and his 3 brother invoked the buy back
option however at that time refused Accused No.5 to comply on the
ground that the Company was to be intimated of the same within 21
months from the date of execution of the MOU and the purchases were
late in invoking the said option. He would submit that Respondent
No.2 therefore filed complaint before MahaRERA to seek reliefs against
the Company and Petitioners, however MahaRERA opined that the
dispute arose prior to MahaRERA coming into force and therefore,
Respondent No.2 withdrew his complaint unconditionally.
7.2. He would submit that on 18.11.2017 Respondent No.2 filed
11
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
complaint with Vakola Police Station against Petitioner however on
25.03.2018, Petitioner - Dr. Akhtar Hasan Rizvi as Director of the
Company and as Power Attorney holder of Reshma Akhtar Rizvi and
Meena Akhtar Rizvi addressed letter to Respondent No.2 demanding
payment of the balance amount with a specific threat to forfeit the
amounts paid by them in 2013. He would submit that Late Mr. Abis
Rizvi was Director of the Company and notwithstanding his demise, all
Directors of the Company are jointly and severally liable for the acts of
the Company and therefore it is not open for Petitioners to claim that
Late Mr. Abis Rizvi is personally liable and other Directors are not
liable and responsible for the same.
7.3. He would submit that Respondent No.2 received a letter
from Vakola Police Station dated 31.05.2018 stating that they have
received the orders from higher authorities to register F.I.R. against all
directors of the Company i.e. Accused Nos.2,3 and 4 and Respondent
No.2 addressed reply dated 20.06.2018 stating that as Petitioner being
Director of the company wished to settle the dispute amicably,
however if not done, only then he would proceed with the registration
of FIR.
7.4. He would submit that by letter dated 07.05.2019 issued by
Petitioner as a Director, he informed Respondent No.2 and his brothers
that he had reserved and allotted four 3 BHK flats situated on 4 floors
12
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
in the B Wing of Rizvi Utopia at Kalina, Mumbai and possession of the
flats would be given within 30 days of issuance of occupation by SRA.
He would submit that Petitioners addressed letter dated 04.06.2021,
calling upon Respondent No.2 and his brothers to pay Rs.70 Lakhs per
flat i.e. the balance amount for the 4 flats and this itself indicated the
dishonest intention on the part of Petitioners. He would submit that
Petitioners addressed another letter dated 09.08.2021, once again
calling on Respondent No.2 to pay Rs.70 lakhs per flat instead of Rs.35
lakhs per flat as earlier agreed and therefore on account of Petitioners
demands and failure to handover possession of the flats, Respondent
No.2 lodged a Complaint with the Respondent No. I Police Station.
7.5. He would submit that after the FIR was registered,
Respondent No.2 and his three brothers filed four Civil Suits before
this Court which are now pending in the City Civil Court at Mumbai.
He would submit that filing and pendency of the Civil Suits does not in
any manner create an embargo on the Respondent No.2 to pursue all
available remedies in law and merely because Civil Suits are filed and
pending, it cannot be a legal and valid ground for Petitioners to seek
quashing of the FIR. He would refer to and rely upon the decision of
the Supreme Court in the case of Shivkumar Jatia Versus State of NCT
1
of Delhi to contend that principle of corporate criminal liability and
"alter-ego" is widely recognized by the Supreme Court and is squarely
1 (2019) 17 SCC 193
13
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
applicable to the facts of the present case as the Accused persons were
in joint control of the affairs of the Company ,hence jointly and
severally committed offences under the provisions of MOFA Act.
7.6. He would submit that merely because Petitioners are now
senior citizens and that Petitioner – Dr. Akhtar Hasan Rizvi deposited
Rs.6 crores in this Court, it cannot be a legal and valid ground for
quashing of the impugned FIR. He would submit that it is trite law that
criminal prosecution is independent of remedies in civil law and the
rights and remedies available in law can be exercised by aggrieved
parties which admittedly has been done by Respondent No.2 in the
present case. He would submit that Petitioners’ contention that FIR
was registered after filing of Suit cannot be sustained in law since it is
clear that Petitioners have no intention to hand over the flats or even
repay the amounts. He would submit that intention of Petitioners since
inception was to cheat, while inducing the Complainant to invest in a
project which was non-est, refusing to accept the buyback offer, not
agreeing to hand over the flats which Complainants were ready to
accept, complete the offences under IPC and MOFA. He would refer to
and rely upon a decision of the Supreme Court in the case of The State
2
of Rajasthan Vs. Mst. Vidyawati & Anr. in support of his submissions
and persuade the Court to dismiss the Petition.
8. I have heard the submissions of the learned advocates at the
2 1962 AIR 933
14
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
bar and considered the material placed before me with their able
assistance. Submissions made the learned advocates have received due
consideration of the Court.
9. It is seen that Petitioner in Writ Petition No.1489 of 2024 is
arraigned as accused in FIR No.0786 of 2022 and both Petitioners in
Writ Petition No.502 of 2022 are arraigned as accused in FIR No.0915
of 2022. EOW filed Chargesheet being CR No.121 of 2022 and
Criminal Case No.769/PW/2023 presently pending before 47th
Magistrate Court, Esplanade, Mumbai in both FIRs indicting Petitioners
in both Petitions.
10. In the present case it is seen that, much prior to registration
of FIR, Respondent No.2 - Complainant along with his 3 brothers
instituted four commercial Suits on 01.07.2022 for seeking refund of
monies paid in pursuance to execution of MOUs with Late Mr. Abis
Rizvi with respect to agreement to purchase commercial spaces in Rizvi
Corporate Park. Copy of one of the MOU entered into with Respondent
No.2 is appended at page No.87 to 182 of the Petition. I have perused
the same. It is seen that Junaid Ebrahim Khan, Faizal Ebrahim Khan,
Afzal Ebrahim Khan and Imran Ebrahim Khan entered into 4 MOUs
dated 22.04.2013 separately with Late Mr. Abis Rizvi however only
Junaid Ebrahim Khan i.e. Respondent No.2 herein registered the
present FIR.
15
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
11. What is intriguing is that Respondent No.2 - Complainant
entered into the MOU with Late Mr. Abis Rizvi as Director of Rizvi
Land Development Pvt. Ltd. however present Petitioner – Dr. Akhtar
Hasan Rizvi who is father of Late Mr. Abis Rizvi is indicted in the
present offence despite him having no role and none even being
attributed to him with respect to the offences he is charged with and
more so in light of subsisting of Commercial Suit proceedings pending
before Civil Court for seeking refund of monies paid under the MOUs.
It is further seen that Clause Nos.8 and 9 of the MOU allowed
Respondent No.2 to avail contractual remedy of specific performance
in case of breach of terms of the MOU, further Respondent No.2 was
possessed with the option of excersising the buy back option contained
therein. It was therefore open for Respondent No.2 to exercise either of
these contractual remedies but Respondent No.2 and his 3 brothers
adopted civil proceedings by filing Commericial Suits before City Civil
Court to seek refund of their monies. These Suits are pending before
the City Civil Court. However soon after instituting the Suits on
01.07.2022, Respondent No.2 alone registered FIR dated 28.07.2022
against Petitioners i.e. after merely 27 days. This on its own accord
shows the malafides of Respondent No.2 since inspite of pursuing civil
remedy available in law by filing a Suit for refund of the monies paid,
he registered FIR against Petitioners and therefore this Court is of the
view that this was done to badger the Petitioners into settling the Suit
16
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
with a demand to handover four 3 BHK flats in Bandra. This action of
Respondent No.2 cannot be allowed primarily because in Anticipatory
Bail Application proceedings for the same cause of action the Petitioner
– Dr. Akhtar Hasan Rizvi has already deposited a sum of Rs.3 crores on
11.08.20233 and Rs.3 crores on 13.08.2023 in this Court.
12. Record prima facie shows that each of the four brothers paid
Rs.70 lakhs each but investigation and statement of only Respondent
No.2 - Complainant is recorded whereas no statement of remaining
three brothers were recorded at any stage. There is no material
evidence or evidence in the form of bank statements collected to show
that Petitioner (Accused No.2) or even Accused Nos.3 or 4 personally
received any part of the aforesaid amount of Rs.70 lakhs each from the
four brothers. It is equally shocking that EOW has sought to investigate
the present offence when according to the circular which is not
annexed to the chargsheet it is seen that EOW ordinarily investigates
offences in which the amount involved exceeds Rs.10 crores and in any
event the amount involved in the present case qua all the four brothers
or their claim or even by the standard of valuation obtained by the
Investigating Officer from the Sub Registrar’s office the claim stands
well below the threshold of Rs.10 crores. This fact itself shows the
malafides on the part of the Respondent No.2 – Complainant.
13. From the above it is seen that in respect of the same 4 MOUs
17
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
dated 22.04.2013 and the amounts paid by the four brothers, they
approached Bandra Police station on 25.10.2017 thereafter Vakola
Police Station 08.05.2017 thereafter MahaRERA on 15.11.2017
thereafter DCP Zone VIII on 05.04.2018 again by 4 complaints filed in
August 2022, thereafter by filing the Complaint with EOW on
31.10.2022 and thereafter by filing separate Commercial Suits and
thereafter filing perjury application in the City Civil Court on the basis
of a Counsel statement and finally the present FIR and chargsheet. In
all the aforesaid proceedings namely civil proceedings, Respondent
No.2 First Informant or his brothers have not been able to procure any
orders against Petitioners and therefore filing of the present FIR and
Chargsheet is nothing but a sheer abuse of the due process of law and
as seen as clear counterblast to push the Petitioners into submission.
This is a classic example of criminal law set into motion to resolve a
civil dispute of recovery after so many years and several civil
proceedings.
14.
It is seen from the FIR and Chargesheet that no role,
inducement or transaction is attributed to Petitioners in Writ Petition
No.502 of 2024 as well. Petitioner No.1 in Writ Petition No.502 of
2024 has been residing in the USA since the past 20 years and
Petitioner No.2 is an eighty four year old housewife with absolutely no
knowledge or involvement in the day to day operations of the
Company therefore no criminal prosecution or vicarious liability can
18
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
exist against them. Perusal of the record would show that there is no
role attributed to any of these Petitioners either in the Complaint of
they having deceived Respondent No.2 or possessed any dishonest
intention to commit the crime against Respondent No.2. It is seen that
present Petitioners have not made any representations or promises
either to Respondent No.2 neither to his 3 brothers rather they have
not entered into any communication whatsoever with Respondent No.2
save and except Petitioner in Writ Petition No.1489 of 2024 when he
attempted to intervene and settle the issues with Respondent No.2 and
his 3 brothers arising out of the MOU after 2017 i.e. after the demise
of his son and even those communications do not show any criminal
intent by Petitioner in Writ Petition No.1489 of 2024 to deceive
Respondent No.2. In fact those communications and some orders
passed by the Court prima facie show that the intention of the
Petitioners was always bonafide and to settle but Respondent No.2
kept protracting the issue for reasons best know to him.
15.
It is seen that if Respondent No.2 is aggrieved because he
entered into the MOU with Late Mr. Abis Rizvi who expired before
fructification of the MOU, he ought to have exercised his substantive
right in civil law and under the provisions of the MOU sought
appropriate remedies under MOFA, rather than filing a criminal
complaint after merely 27 days from the date of filing of the Suit
against Petitioners for recovery of monies. This is further reinforced by
19
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
Petitioner – Akhtar Hassan Rizvi in Writ Petition No.1489 of 2024
having deposited Rs.6 crores in this Court in the Anticipatory Bail
Application proceedings pursuant to order dated 08.08.2023 to show
his bonafides. It is in the above background of facts that I come to the
unequivocal conclusion that Respondent No.2 has made an
unsuccessful attempt to paint the present civil dispute between the
parties with the color of criminality for reasons best known to him only
since there are clear civil remedies available in law and under the
provisions of the MOU for Respondent No.2 to pursue in order to
protect and enforce his substantive rights which have already been
invoked. Therefore I cannot countenance the submission of Mr. Soman
that present Petitioners have prima facie committed the offences of
cheating and criminal breach of trust and that they are involved in any
criminal act inducing and deceiving Respondent No.2 – Complainant.
16.
There is no dishonest inducement to deliver any property to
complainant by any of the Petitioners before me. Rather there is no
nexus between the parties except through the Accused No.1 –
Company which was being dealt with by deceased Accused No.5,
neither is there any dishonest misappropriation or conversion of the
monies by the Petitioners for their for own use or disposal of the
property entrusted to them for their own use. Plain and simple the
aforesaid facts show that Respondent No.2 has reconciled himself to
recovery of a money claim. The aforesaid incidents show that criminal
20
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
breach of trust for entrustment of money which was given to Accused
No.5 cannot be applied to the present Petitioners. In fact allegations in
the FIR and the material placed before me do not disclose a cognizable
offence against the 3 Petitioners before me. It is settled law that a
Director can be prosecuted only when incriminating material shows his
own active role coupled with criminal intent.
17.
There is none insofar as the 3 Petitioners before me are
concerned. The chargsesheet merely describes Accused No.2 as
Director but does not identify any act done by him or the other 2
Petitioners personally in relation to the MOU transactions. There is no
fraudulent or dishonest inducement at the very inception of the MOU
transactions which are attributable to Accused No.2,3,4 neither is there
entrustment of money to Accused Nos.2, 3 and 4. Common intention
under Section 34 require a prior meeting of minds and participation in
the criminal act and from the above facts no such common intention to
commit a criminal act qua the Petitioners is seen. It is seen that
Respondent No.2 and his brothers have approached at least 8 forums
for complaining about breach of the same MOUs and criminal process
is set into motion by them in a clearly disputed civil action only after
failing to get any orders. Petitioner's bonafides of offering to refund the
entire amount of Rs.2.8 crores as recorded by the Court in one of its
orders alluded to hereinabove and his conduct of depositing Rs.6
crores in this Court clearly belies any dishonest intention.
21
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
18. Respondent No.2 cannot be allowed to set the wheels of
criminal law into motion against Petitioners in order to browbeat them
into settling his and his brother’s monetary claim over the years and
meet their demands in the Suit pending before the City Civil Court. An
unsuccessful attempt is made even before this Court when at the
inception this Court called upon the Respondent No.2 to consider
settlement since the monies were deposited in the Suit proceedings in
this Court. I need not go into those details since it was without
prejudice to the rights and contentions of both the parties and an
attempt made to put an end to the entire lis. It is seen from a
combined reading of the material placed on record that there is not a
hint of criminality in the present dispute qua the 3 Petitioners before
me and that the lis is purely civil in nature.
19. Merely because Respondent No.2 has failed to obtain interim
relief from this Court or may foresee an unfavorable ending to the civil
litigation pending before this Court, he cannot force the Petitioners to
settle his claims by filing a criminal case for cheating and breach of
trust. Suit filed by Respondent No. 2 is purely for a money claim.
Respondent No.2's intention is therefore clear about receiving his
monies back. Deposit is made by Petitioner No.1 in this Court in the
Anticipatory Bail Application. Respondent No.2 and his brothers can
undoubtedly excersice their rights to seeking withdrawal of the same in
accordance with law if so entitled to do so. The Suits shall be decided
22
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
at trial after parties lead evidence in that respect. Respondent No. 2
should have no fear to go to trial if he is right and positive about his
own case in which he seeks a money claim. Filing a criminal case for
cheating and breach of trust when no offence is made out from the
material placed before Court qua the 3 Petitioners before me cannot be
sustained. Petitioner No.1 is a person with deep roots in Society. I am
therefore not in agreement with the submissions advanced by Mr.
Soman at all that there is criminal intent on the part of Petitioners to
deceive the Complainant. The facts in the present case are squarely
covered by Guideline Nos.(1), (3) and (7) of the guidelines /
parameters stipulated by the Supreme Court in paragraph No.102 of
3
the decision in the case of State of Haryana Vs. Bhajan Lal , which
apply to the present case enabling the Court to quash the present
criminal proceedings. The relevant paragraph No.102 is reproduced
below for ease of reference:-
“102. In the backdrop of the interpretation of the various
relevant provisions of the Code under Chapter XIV and of the
principles of law enunciated by this Court in a series of
decisions relating to the exercise of the extraordinary power
under Article 226 or the inherent powers under Section 482 of
the Code which we have extracted and reproduced above, we
have given the following categories of cases by way of
illustration wherein such power could be exercised either to
prevent abuse of the process of any court or otherwise to secure
the ends of justice, though it may not be possible to lay down
any precise, clearly defined and sufficiently channelised and
inflexible guidelines or rigid formulae and to give an exhaustive
list of myriad kinds of cases wherein such power should be
exercised.
(1) Where the allegations made in the first information report
3 1992 SCC (Cri) 4226
23
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face value and
accepted in their entirety do not prima facie constitute any
offence or make out a case against the accused.
(2) Where the allegations in the first information report and
other materials, if any, accompanying the FIR do not disclose a
cognizable offence, justifying an investigation by police officers
under Section 156(1) of the Code except under an order of a
Magistrate within the purview of Section 155(2) of the Code.
(3) Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the FIR or
complaint and the evidence collected in support of the same do
not disclose the commission of any offence and make out a case
against the accused.
(4) Where, the allegations in the FIR do not constitute a
cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable
offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer without
an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under Section 155(2)
of the Code.
(5) Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint are so
absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of which no
prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion that there is
sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused.
(6) Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of the
provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which a
criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and
continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is a specific
provision in the Code or the concerned Act, providing
efficacious redress for the grievance of the aggrieved party.
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended with
mala fide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously instituted
with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on the accused
and with a view to spite him due to private and personal
grudge.”
20. In view of the above observations and findings, continuation
of criminal proceedings against the 3 Petitioners in the light of pending
Civil Suits would be a sheer travesty of justice and unnecessary
harassment of the Petitioners in a lis which is primarily civil in nature
and which is infact pending in the Commercial Suit proceedings
instituted in the Court.
24
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09

WP.1489.2024 +1.doc
21.
Writ Petition No.1489 of 2024 therefore stands allowed in
terms of prayer clause (a) and Writ Petition No.502 of 2024 stands
allowed in terms of prayer clause (b) which read thus:-
Writ Petition No.1489 of 2024
a) quash and set aside F.I.R. being No.786/2022, dated 28/07/2022 Vakola -dated
8/7/2022, registered with Wakola Police Station against the petitioner, for the
offence punishable under Sections 409 and 420 read with Section 34 of the Indian
Penal Code and under Sections 3, 4, 8 and 13 of the Maharashtra Ownership of
Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and
Transfer) Act, 1963 and subsequently transferred and renumbered as F.I.R.
No.121/2022 with the Economic Offences Wing, Unit 5, Bombay and to quash and
set aside Chargesheet and further all the consequential proceedings bearing CC No.
769/PW/2023 on the file of the 47th Metropolitan Magistrate's Esplanade Court
against petitioner in the interest of justice.
Writ Petition No.502 of 2024
b. That this Hon'ble Court be pleased to quash and set aside the Impugned FIR
Beating CR No. 915 of 2022 dated 30 July 2022 registered with Vakola Police
Station and the consequential proceedings bearing CC NO. 769/PW/2023 on the
file of the 47th Metropolitan Magistrate's Esplanade Court in the interest of justice.
22. Both Writ Petitions are allowed and disposed.
[ MILIND N. JADHAV, J. ]
Ajay
25
of 25
Uploaded on - 18/11/2026 Downloaded on - 18/11/2026 15:13:09
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)